Singapore International Commercial Court · Decided 2 July 2021
Judah Value Activist Fund v Open Faith Investment Ltd
Feedback & support[2021] SGHC(I) 7 · Case no. Suit No 6 of 2020
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Laws this judgment relies on
Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [1]
[1] The plaintiff, Judah Value Activist Fund, is an exempted company incorporated in the Cayman Islands. It is an activist hedge fund which targets mainly Singapore and Hong Kong listed companies. Activist hedge funds typically seek to make a large investment in a company so as to be able to participate in or influence the management and decision-making of the company invested in. Activist hedge funds are also different from traditional funds in that they usually have a less diversified portfolio.
- [2]
[2] The plaintiff’s Chief Investment Officer (“CIO”) is Mr Roland Jude Thng Qida (“Mr Thng”). His role was to monitor the plaintiff’s portfolio of assets and liaise with investors. He was the individual in charge of making decisions on behalf of the plaintiff. Mr Thng is also a shareholder of the plaintiff (through Judah Group Limited) together with a number of other corporate and individual investors. The plaintiff is also managed by Swiss-Asia Financial Services Pte Ltd (“Swiss Asia”) under an investment management agreement. The fund administrator is the Apex Group (“Apex”).
- [3]
[3] At the relevant time, i.e. end-December 2019, the plaintiff’s portfolio of shares comprised 157,995,000 shares in Agritrade Resources Limited (“Agritrade”), a company listed on the Hong Kong Stock Exchange. Agritrade International Pte Limited (“APIL”) was the controlling shareholder of Agritrade, holding approximately 55.7% of the issued shares of Agritrade. In turn, APIL was owned in proportions of 40.1% by Mr Ng Say Pek, chairman of the Board and the executive director of APIL, and 59.9% by his son, Mr Ng Xinwei, (sometimes referred to as “Xman”), the executive director and Chief Executive Officer of Agritrade.
- [4]
[4] The plaintiff had a margin loan facility (“MLF”) with Maybank Kim Eng Securities Pte Ltd (“Maybank”) under which, according to the plaintiff, the plaintiff was required to maintain a Loan-to-Value Ratio (“LTV Ratio”) below 70%. The terms of the MLF were contained in a letter dated 22 November 2018 (the “MLF Letter”) which provided in material part as follows:
- [5]
[5] During the trial, there was a dispute between the parties concerning what were, in fact, the relevant and applicable “Margin Facility Terms” stated to be “available on [Maybank’s] website” as referred to in the letter extracted above. I was told by the plaintiff’s Counsel that the plaintiff did not have a copy of those terms. Certainly, none had been disclosed by the plaintiff. However, the defendant’s expert, Mr Kon Yin Tong (“Mr Kon”), had sourced a copy of what he considered to be the relevant terms from Maybank’s website (as referred to in the MLF Letter). He appended those terms to his report and referred to them extensively in the body of his report. I shall refer to these as Maybank’s T&Cs. In the course of Mr Kon’s cross-examination, it was suggested by the plaintiff’s Counsel, for the first time, that these terms were not, or at least might not be, the relevant terms applicable to the MLF; such suggestion subsequently developed into a forceful submission by Counsel on behalf of the plaintiff in the course of closing arguments at the end of the trial that these terms were inapplicable. Given that Mr Kon’s report had been served some four weeks before the trial, and further that the parties’ experts had been in communication and produced a Joint Statement (“JS”) without any suggestion that these terms were or might be inapplicable, that belated suggestion and subsequent submission by Counsel on behalf of the plaintiff were, to say the least, somewhat surprising. If those terms were neither relevant nor applicable, this could and should have been raised much earlier: trial by ambush is inappropriate in modern commercial litigation.
- [6]
[6] By way of riposte, it was the defendant’s submission that the Court should draw an adverse inference against the plaintiff that the plaintiff had failed, refused, or neglected to disclose the Maybank T&Cs because its contractual provisions are applicable to how the Margin Ratio was to be computed and would show that Mr Kon’s approach is correct. In support of that submission, I was referred to illustration (g) of s 116 of the Evidence Act (Cap 97, 1997 Rev Ed.), Evidence and the Litigation Process (Jeffrey Pinsler, 7th ed) (LexisNexis, 2020), and several guiding principles set out by the Court of Appeal in Sudha Natrajan v The Bank of East Asia Ltd [2017] 1 SLR 141 (“Sudha Natrajan”).
- [7]
[7] In my view, Maybank’s T&Cs were plainly highly material to this case. As appears below, the issue of causation (which is important in this case) turns on how the Margin Ratio is computed, and the Maybank T&Cs are potentially critical to that issue because they contain the relevant provisions to compute the Margin Ratio. I find it surprising that the plaintiff did not have a copy of the Maybank T&Cs. But, even if that is correct, it seems to me that it would have been entitled to request a copy from Maybank and, as such, the Maybank T&Cs would have been within the plaintiff’s “control” and therefore discoverable in these proceedings. At the very least, it seems to me that it would have been very easy indeed for the plaintiff to ask Maybank for a copy of the Maybank T&Cs, and there is no reason to suppose that Maybank would not have complied with such a request. In my view, it is no answer that the defendant might itself have requested Maybank to provide a copy of the Maybank T&Cs, particularly since I was told that they were, in any event, publicly available on the Maybank website and, as I understand, no objection had been raised by the plaintiff to the fact that Mr Kon had exhibited a copy of the Maybank T&Cs to his report and made extensive reference to them in the body of his report.
- [8]
[8] Be all this as it may, the plaintiff has not pointed to a different set of terms as it could easily have done if different terms were applicable. In these circumstances, I accept Mr Kon’s evidence that he had sourced Maybank’s T&Cs from Maybank’s website as referred to in the MLF Letter and proceed on the basis that these were the applicable terms.
- [9]
[9] As to the relevant terms of the contractual relationship between the plaintiff and Maybank, I note the following:
(a) The MLF Letter itself provided on its face that (i) the Margin Ratio must at all times be maintained at a ratio of at least 140%; (ii) a Margin Call occurs if and when the Margin Ratio falls below 140% or the Margin Limit is exceeded; and (iii) Maybank had the right to sell all or any part of the Securities without prior notice if and when, inter alia, the Margin Ratio fell below 130%.
(b) Maybank’s T&Cs (as referenced in Mr Kon’s report) provided in material part as follows:
(i) In Clause 1 (Definitions):
- “Collateral” means “all the Approved Securities and other Securities that are or will be provided by way of security to [Maybank] pursuant to the Security Document”
- “Collateral’s Security Value” means “the sum of the Security Value of each Collateral”
- “Loan-to-Value” means “… the percentage of the Market Value that [Maybank is] prepared to finance; the percentage determined by [Maybank] from time to time may vary depending on the type of Approved Securities.”
- “Security Value” means “… an amount determined using [an Approved Security’s] Loan-to-Value; and for any other Collateral, an amount as may be determined by [Maybank]”
- “Margin Ratio” means “the percentage determined by [Maybank] based on the following formula:
Collateral’s Security Value
______________________
(Outstanding Amount – cash in Account, if any)”
(ii) In Clause 14.1 (Margin Calls): “A Margin Call occurs if we determine at any time and on any day that the Margin Raito [sic] has fallen below a certain ratio prescribed by us.” The remainder of Clause 14 set out what Maybank may request its counterparty to do in the event of a Margin Call and the consequences of non-compliance with such a request.
(iii) In Clause 17 (Event of Default), a list of events of default and the consequences of an event of default, including a right by Maybank to sell property subject to the security interest, is set out.
(iv) In Clause 27 (Rights and Waivers): “[Maybank has] absolute discretion as to what we do or do not do under or for the purposes of any Finance Document. We do not have to give any reasons for doing or not doing something under or for the purposes of any Finance Document.”
As appears below, the plaintiff’s pleaded case is that Maybank was entitled to make a margin call when the LTV Ratio exceeded 70%. The LTV Ratio is, of course, different from the Margin Ratio although the two are related. So far as relevant, I consider this further below.
- [10]
[10] The defendant is a company incorporated in the British Virgin Islands. It is in the business of consultancy and investment holdings. The defendant’s sole director and shareholder is Mr Tay Jing Yi Joseph (“Mr Tay”).
- [11]
[11] Before this dispute, Mr Thng and Mr Tay had known each other for about 3 years. They were friends. They share the same Christian faith, went to the same church, and had common interests in investment and fund management. They also periodically met up for coffee. As appears below, they frequently communicated by WhatsApp.
- [12]
[12] At the relevant time, i.e. at the end of 2019, the defendant had a portfolio of approximately 160 million Agritrade shares made up of:
(a) 100,005,000 Agritrade shares in its brokerage account with Bluemount Securities Limited, out of which approximately 80 million Agritrade Shares were encumbered pursuant to a loan agreement with a company known as Wealthy Hero Holdings Limited (“Wealthy Hero”);
(b) 50,063,016 Agritrade shares in its brokerage account with Hong Kong Stock Link Securities Limited (“HKSLS”); and
(c) An anticipated further transfer of 14,705,000 Agritrade shares into its brokerage account with HKSLS.
- [13]
[13] The present case concerns disputes arising out of a contract consisting of a Subscription Application Form (“SAF”) and a Private Placement Memorandum (“PPM”) signed on 11 December 2019 between the plaintiff and the defendant (hereinafter referred to collectively as the “subscription agreement” or “SA”) whereby (as is common ground) the defendant agreed to subscribe for a number of Class B shares in the plaintiff by way of a transfer in specie by the defendant to the plaintiff of 60 million Agritrade shares (the “Agritrade Shares”).
- [14]
[14] In essence, it is the plaintiff’s case that (a) pursuant to the SA, the defendant was obliged to transfer the Agritrade Shares to the plaintiff by latest 31 December 2019; (b) in breach of that obligation, the defendant failed to effect such transfer by that date or at all; and (c) as a result, the plaintiff’s LTV Ratio exceeded 70%, causing a margin trigger event under the MLF and thereby entitling Maybank to issue a margin call to the plaintiff, which Maybank did on 20 January 2020 (the “margin call”). Shortly thereafter, between 20 and 23 January 2020, Maybank force sold the plaintiff’s entire holding of Agritrade shares in three tranches to clear off the margin loan at an average price of HK$ 0.1957 per share. It is uncontested that Maybank was entitled to force sell the said Agritrade shares.
- [16]
[16] The defendant does not dispute that it entered into the SA. However, it is the defendant’s case that the SA did not specify a date when the share transfer was to be made and, in particular, did not impose any obligation on the defendant to transfer the Agritrade Shares by 31 December 2019. In further support of the foregoing, the defendant says that in the weeks leading up to 31 December 2019, there were no reminders sent by the plaintiff that the defendant had to transfer the Agritrade Shares by 31 December 2019, and, following that date and with knowledge that the Agritrade Shares had not been transferred, the plaintiff also did not highlight that the defendant had been remiss, nor did it seek to enforce the transfer of the Agritrade Shares without delay.
- [17]
[17] Further, the defendant has raised a number of specific defences which are, in summary, as follows:
(a) It was an implied term of the SA that the share transfer need not be effected before the due diligence and subscription application process were completed, and such process had not yet been completed by 31 December 2019.
(b) The plaintiff was entitled to, and did in fact, exercise its discretion to change the day upon which the obligation to transfer the Agritrade Shares to the plaintiff fell due to a date after 31 December 2019.
(c) If (contrary to the defendant’s case) the SA obliged the defendant to transfer the Agritrade Shares by 31 December 2019, the plaintiff, by its words and conduct after 31 December 2019, had waived its right to insist on strict compliance with such deadline; alternatively, the plaintiff is estopped from insisting on strict compliance with that date.
- [18]
[18] In any event, it is the defendant’s case that any breach of contract on its part did not cause the loss now claimed by the plaintiff and/or the plaintiff’s alleged loss was not reasonably foreseeable and too remote. In very broad summary, the defendant says that the stock market is unpredictable; that funds (like the plaintiff’s fund) seek to capitalise on such unpredictability; that they can make a lot of money if they get it right; but they can also face serious losses if they get it wrong. Here, the defendant says that the present case is a cautionary tale of the latter scenario, where the plaintiff essentially “backed the wrong horse” by concentrating its entire portfolio in Agritrade; that the price of Agritrade shares was on a steady and inexorable decline between December 2019 and January 2020; that the plaintiff, with a concentrated portfolio in this single company, was going to bear the brunt of this decline; that the plaintiff was eventually confronted with a margin call by its financier, Maybank, when the share price of Agritrade tanked in early January 2020; that the plaintiff is wrong to pin the blame of its losses on the defendant; that even if the defendant had transferred its 60 million Agritrade Shares to the plaintiff before 20 January 2020, the plaintiff would still have been faced with a margin call from Maybank; that this would in all likelihood have precipitated the same events that unfolded on 20 to 23 January 2020; and that, in other words, the plaintiff’s loss was inevitable irrespective of any breach by the defendant.
The Evidence
- [19]
[19] In addition to the documentary material put in evidence, the parties relied on the evidence contained in the affidavits of evidence-in-chief of the following individuals, all of whom gave evidence and submitted themselves for cross-examination:
(a) On behalf of the plaintiff:
(i) Mr Thng. As stated above, he was the plaintiff’s CIO. His role was to monitor the plaintiff’s portfolio of assets and liaise with investors. He was an experienced investor.
(ii) Mr Ee Swee Yee (“Mr Ee”, also referred to in the evidence as “Andy”). He was the plaintiff’s Portfolio Manager from June 2019 to March 2020, which included the relevant period. He was also Mr Thng’s assistant and worked closely with him. He was responsible for facilitating investors’ subscriptions with the plaintiff, including conducting analysis on companies, working closely with the investors to obtain the required information, and ensuring that the investors executed the required documentation.
(iii) Ms Ho Seok Hua (“Ms Ho”). She is the General Counsel of Swiss-Asia. Her duties included Swiss-Asia’s compliance matters, including conducting client due diligence and know-your-client checks (“CDD”) on the plaintiff’s investors. Ms Ho was called as a witness and confirmed under oath the contents of her affidavit of evidence in chief. However, the defendant’s Counsel elected to forego any cross-examination. Accordingly, Ms Ho’s evidence stands unchallenged.
(b) On behalf of the defendant: Mr Tay. As stated above, he is the director and sole shareholder of the defendant. He is also an experienced investor with numerous business interests and travels frequently between Singapore and Hong Kong.
- [20]
[20] In addition, the parties adduced in evidence the following expert reports:
(a) On behalf of the plaintiff, the report of Mr Tan Kah Leong (“Mr Tan”), currently the Head of Business Development & Education at IG Asia Pte Ltd.
(b) On behalf of the defendant, the report of Mr Kon, Managing Partner at Foo Kon Tan LLP.
- [21]
[21] The main issues addressed by these experts were as follows:
(a) Whether prior to the defendant’s intended subscription, the plaintiff’s MLF with Maybank already had a high LTV Ratio;
(b) Whether it was the defendant’s failure to transfer the Agritrade Shares by 31 December 2019 or the plaintiff’s own trading activities that caused the margin call on the plaintiff’s account;
(c) Whether the continuous share price drop from 2019 to January 2020 was the cause of the plaintiff’s margin call;
(d) Whether the plaintiff’s losses that arose as a result of the margin call were the type of loss which would ordinarily have been in the contemplation of the plaintiff and defendant at the time when the SA was entered into;
(e) What was the quantum of the plaintiff’s loss as of 31 December 2019, being the date that (as asserted by the plaintiff) the defendant was obliged to transfer the Agritrade Shares;
(f) What was the quantum of the plaintiff’s loss as of 20 January 2020, being the date of the margin call; and
(g) What was the market practice for a subscriber to transfer its shares to the Fund pursuant to the subscriber’s execution of a subscription application form, where payment is to be made wholly in specie.
The Relevant Facts
- [22]
[22] Before turning to consider the main issues, I set out below a summary of the relevant facts.
- [23]
[23] As stated above, the plaintiff had an MLF with Maybank under which, according to the plaintiff, the plaintiff was required to maintain an LTV Ratio below 70%. It was originally part of the defendant’s case that the plaintiff had a “high” LTV Ratio in the latter part of 2019 and that the margin calls made by Maybank were simply due to the plaintiff’s own trading activities.
- [24]
[24] As appears from the chart below, there is no doubt that the market value of Agritrade shares fell in the course of 2019 from a high of approximately HK$ 1.70 per share in February 2019 to a low of approximately HK$ 0.55 per share in early December 2019 before a moderate pick up in the course of December 2019 and early January 2020, followed by a very steep fall thereafter.
- [25]
[25] However, both the expert witnesses, Mr Tan and Mr Kon, agreed that the plaintiff’s MLF with Maybank did not have a high LTV Ratio prior to 11 December 2019, and that the plaintiff’s own trading activities did not cause the margin calls. In passing, I should note that there was some dispute between the experts as to the precise figure for the plaintiff’s Margin Ratio and LTV Ratio during the relevant period. According to Mr Kon, the plaintiff’s Margin Ratio ranged from approximately 274 to 204% and its LTV Ratio from 36% to 48% between 30 September 2019 and 11 December 2019, whereas Mr Tan calculated slightly lower figures ranging from approximately 393% to 296% and 25% to 33% respectively during that same period. This difference between the experts was due primarily to a difference of methodology. in particular with regard to the method of calculating what was referred to as “collateral value”. However, the difference is of little, if any, relevance in the present context because, as stated above, both experts agreed that the plaintiff’s MLF with Maybank did not have a high LTV Ratio prior to 11 December 2019. However, the difference in methodology and in the method of calculating the appropriate “collateral value” is important (and potentially crucial) when considering later events in January 2020, which I consider further below.
- [26]
[26] Although (as is now common ground between the parties) the plaintiff’s LTV Ratio was not high in the latter part of 2019, it was the evidence of Mr Thng (which I accept) that, out of prudence, he began exploring two possible options concerning the plaintiff’s margin loan with Maybank viz. (a) the plaintiff could sell off a sufficient amount of its Agritrade shares so that it had sufficient funds to clear the margin loan and have some cash left over as a buffer (the “First Option”); or (b) the plaintiff could strengthen its buffer against a potential margin call by acquiring even more Agritrade shares (the “Second Option”). In the event, Mr Thng decided (at least initially) to pursue the First Option by selling 75 million out of the plaintiff’s holding of Agritrade shares so as to raise approximately S$ 7 million.
- [27]
[27] Sometime in or around October 2019, Mr Thng found a willing buyer to acquire the plaintiff’s 75 million Agritrade shares. The buyer, known as “Saurav”, is Mr Thng’s friend and a fund manager in New York. Saurav was going to acquire the plaintiff’s 75 million Agritrade shares through Power One Limited, a company that he (Saurav) controlled.
- [28]
[28] At about the same time, it was Mr Thng’s evidence that he had discussions with Mr Tay concerning what he referred to as the plaintiff’s margin issues. That this was indeed the case appears, for example, from a WhatsApp exchange between Mr Thng and Mr Tay on 11 October 2019.
- [29]
[29] Before Mr Thng finalised the proposed trade with Saurav, sometime in or around October 2019, Mr Thng shared with Mr Tay during one of their meetings his plan for the plaintiff to pursue the First Option by selling 75 million Agritrade Shares to Saurav. According to Mr Thng, when Mr Tay learnt of this, he (i.e. Mr Tay) asked whether Mr Thng would be willing to forego the First Option and give the defendant and Alliance East Asia Limited (i.e. a company that Mr Tay allegedly had control and/or influence over) the opportunity to collectively sell 75 million Agritrade shares to Saurav. Mr Tay explained that, as the defendant and Alliance East Asia Limited were facing some financial difficulties, they needed this opportunity to raise funds. Mr Tay indicated that he could raise funds by having the defendant and Alliance East Asia Limited sell off 13 million and 62 million Agritrade shares (a total of 75 million Agritrade shares) to Saurav respectively.
- [30]
[30] According to Mr Thng, in exchange for Mr Thng and the plaintiff forgoing the First Option, Mr Tay proposed the following:
(a) The defendant would subscribe to the plaintiff and transfer 60 million Agritrade shares before the end of the year, using the Net Asset Value (“NAV”) as of 31 December 2019; and
(b) Mr Tay would arrange for his friend, one “William”, who controlled Eagle Eye Group Limited, to subscribe to the plaintiff and transfer 40 million Agritrade shares to the plaintiff sometime in early 2020.
- [31]
[31] According to Mr Thng:
(a) The net effect of Mr Tay’s proposal was that the plaintiff would essentially be foregoing the First Option for the Second Option. Mr Thng explained that the reason why he agreed to take the Second Option instead was that the plaintiff would receive 100 million Agritrade shares in total, thus increasing its buffer against a potential margin call.
(b) Mr Thng thus agreed to Mr Tay’s proposal on the basis that, after the defendant and Alliance East Asia Limited had sold their shares to Saurav:
(i) The defendant would subscribe to the plaintiff and transfer 60 million Agritrade shares before the end of December 2019 so the defendant’s 60 million Agritrade shares would be valued using the NAV as of 31 December 2019; and
(ii) Eagle Eye Group Limited would subscribe to the plaintiff and transfer 40 million Agritrade shares sometime in January or February 2020.
In support of the foregoing, Mr Thng referred to various exchanges including a WhatsApp exchange on 10 December 2019.
- [32]
[32] Mr Tay’s evidence presented a different picture. In summary, his evidence was as follows:
(a) In or around October 2019, Mr Thng learnt that the defendant held shares in Agritrade.
(b) Thus, Mr Thng and Mr Tay started discussing the possibility of the defendant investing in the plaintiff’s fund. Mr Tay understood from his discussions with Mr Thng that the plaintiff was looking to build up its portfolio of Agritrade shares with an aim of eventually making an en-bloc sale of the Agritrade shares at a high value as part of its investment strategy. In particular, Mr Thng informed Mr Tay that the plaintiff was hoping to eventually structure a sale or placement with or through an acquaintance of his – an individual named “Saurav”.
(c) Mr Thng’s pitch was attractive to the defendant since the defendant was seeking to raise funds to pay down a HK$ 20 million loan from Wealthy Hero. The loan from Wealthy Hero was secured by the defendant pledging 80 million of its Agritrade shares.
(d) The defendant was thus motivated to subscribe to the plaintiff as it hoped to benefit from the plaintiff’s intended strategy of making an en-bloc sale of Agritrade shares.
(f) In or around end-November 2019, Mr Thng and Mr Tay began discussing the defendant’s potential investment into the plaintiff’s fund. Through these discussions:
(i) Mr Thng offered Mr Tay a seat on the plaintiff’s board, and the terms of this were being negotiated.
(ii) While Mr Thng did mention that the defendant’s Agritrade shares could help the plaintiff with its margin issues, this was only mentioned in passing and was not elaborated on. In the light of Mr Tay’s discussions with Mr Thng and matters stated in certain presentation slides which, according to Mr Tay, were given to him by Mr Thng during one of their meetings at the end of November 2019, Mr Tay believed that the plaintiff had little or no leverage.
(iii) Mr Thng was aware that a good number of the defendant’s Agritrade Shares were pledged to Wealthy Hero. Importantly, the defendant needed to maintain a suitable buffer of Agritrade shares against a potential call for more security, or as a pledge to secure an extension of time for repayment. The timing and ease with which the defendant could transfer its Agritrade shares would depend on the defendant’s ability to deal with Wealthy Hero.
- [33]
[33] So far as relevant, I address the differences between the evidence of Mr Thng and Mr Tay further below.
- [34]
[34] In any event, it is common ground that, in or around end-November 2019, Mr Thng handed the SAF, PPM and the plaintiff’s Articles of Association to Mr Tay.
- [35]
[35] It is the plaintiff’s case that on 29 November 2019, Mr Thng handed Mr Tay the relevant contracts for the defendant and Alliance East Asia Limited to sell a total of 75 million Agritrade shares to Saurav, through Power One Limited. The sale went through a few days later on or around 4 December 2019. On 6 December 2019, the defendant and Alliance East Asia Limited collectively received approximately S$ 7 million as consideration for the sale of their Agritrade shares. I note for completeness that Mr Tay denies having control and/or influence over Alliance East Asia Limited.
- [36]
[36] In final submissions, Counsel on behalf of the defendant made forceful submissions with regard to the foregoing and, in particular, the “unenviable task” facing the Court of having to decide between what were said to be the “competing accounts” of how the SAF and PPM came to be signed viz. whether, on the defendant’s case, the SAF and PPM were signed because the defendant was persuaded to subscribe on the prospect of an eventual sale and “cash out” of Agritrade shares or, as the plaintiff claims, the defendant’s subscription was a quid pro quo for the plaintiff giving up an arrangement with Saurav, by which the plaintiff would have been able to sell 75 million Agritrade shares for S$ 7 million. On behalf of the defendant, it was said that deciding the correct account is important because it informs the factual context in which the parties entered into the SAF and PPM, and, consequently, addresses the question of whether the defendant was obliged to transfer its shares by 31 December 2019. As formulated, I do not accept that submission. Whilst I readily accept that the factual matrix and the parties’ conduct may be relevant, the question whether the defendant undertook a contractual obligation to transfer its shares by 31 December 2019 depends primarily on the proper construction of the SAF and PPM – or at least that is the starting point.
- [37]
[37] Be all this as it may, it is common ground that on 11 December 2019, the plaintiff and the defendant signed the SAF and PPM (together, the “contract documents”). As stated above, it is the plaintiff’s case that it was an express term of these contract documents that the defendant was obliged to transfer the Agritrade Shares to the plaintiff by 31 December 2019. In support of that submission, the plaintiff relies upon the following express provisions:
(a) The recital on page 2 of the SAF, which stipulated that the defendant was to transfer the consideration for subscription (i.e. the defendant’s Agritrade Shares) by the “Subscription Day”, which was defined as the first business day of each month at page 15 of the PPM.
(b) Page 35 of the PPM, where it was stipulated that that the subscription consideration must be received by the plaintiff by the “Subscription Dealing Deadline”, which was defined as two business days before the proposed Subscription Day.
(c) Page 36 of the PPM, where it was further stipulated that the directors of the plaintiff had the absolute discretion to accept the subscription consideration (i.e. the defendant’s Agritrade Shares) after the “Subscription Dealing Deadline”.
- [38]
[38] It was on the basis of these provisions that the plaintiff submitted that, (a) under the SAF and PPM, the defendant was obliged to subscribe to the plaintiff and transfer the Agritrade Shares to the plaintiff by the “Subscription Day”, which was the first business day of each month – i.e. in this case, 2 January 2020 since the SAF and the PPM were executed after 1 December 2019; and that (b) since the defendant’s Agritrade Shares would have to be transferred in accordance with the “Subscription Dealing Deadline” – i.e. 2 business days before the “Subscription Day”, the said transfer had to be made by 30 December 2019. However, the plaintiff says that it exercised its contractual discretion to allow the defendant to transfer its lion Agritrade Shares a day later, i.e. on 31 December 2019. Alternatively, the plaintiff submits that on a true construction of the SAF and PPM, the defendant was contractually required to transfer the Agritrade Shares to the plaintiff by 31 December 2019.
- [39]
[39] For present purposes, it is sufficient to note that the defendant disputes that these provisions have the effect contended by the plaintiff. In particular, as stated above, although the defendant accepts that it was obliged to transfer the Agritrade Shares to the plaintiff, it denies that there was any obligation to transfer those shares by 31 December 2019. As to this dispute, I deal with the parties’ respective submissions below.
- [41]
[41] Another main issue between the parties concerns the purpose for which the defendant agreed to subscribe to the plaintiff’s fund by transferring the Agritrade Shares in specie and the state of Mr Tay’s knowledge with regard to such purpose in the period up to and as at the date of the SA i.e. 11 December 2019. This topic is important – indeed crucial - with regard to the issue of remoteness which I consider further below.
- [42]
[42] In essence, it was Mr Thng’s evidence that, as Mr Tay well knew, the purpose of the SA was both to increase the plaintiff’s buffer against a potential margin call and, in line with the plaintiff’s investment strategy as an activist fund, for the plaintiff to have a larger stake in Agritrade which would allow the plaintiff to have a larger say in management with a view to structuring a 250 million share placement with Saurav in the future.
- [43]
[43] The evidence of Mr Tay with regard to this topic and, in particular, whether he (Mr Tay) was aware of the plaintiff’s margin issues and that at least one of the purposes for the agreement to transfer the Agritrade Shares was to provide the plaintiff with an increased buffer against a potential margin call was, at least in part, both contradictory and confusing. In particular:
(a) In paragraph 10 of his affidavit of evidence-in-chief (“AEIC”), Mr Tay accepted that in or around early October 2019, he learnt from Mr Thng that the plaintiff was looking to raise approximately US$ 1.3 million and that he understood that this was because the plaintiff had some margin issues with Maybank.
(b) In cross-examination, Mr Tay also accepted that he initially offered to assist the plaintiff by acquiring some Agritrade shares from the plaintiff to help with the plaintiff’s margin issue because Mr Thng was a friend.
(c) However, in paragraph 14 of his AEIC, Mr Tay stated that he learned that the plaintiff eventually raised certain funds by selling some of its Agritrade shares to other buyers and that he “surmised” that the plaintiff had sorted out its issues with Maybank. In cross-examination, Mr Tay explained that the basis of this statement in his AEIC was an exchange of WhatsApp messages between himself and Mr Ee on 16 October 2019 when Mr Ee told him of a sale of 2.5m shares at HK$ 0.74; and, in further cross-examination, Mr Tay maintained his position that as of late October 2019, his personal knowledge was that the plaintiff had “cleared” its margin issue with Maybank. I do not accept that evidence. The sale referred to by Mr Ee on 16 October 2019 would only have generated about US$ 250,000 i.e. only a small portion of the US$ 1.3 million which Mr Thng was looking to raise as Mr Tay acknowledged. Thus, in my view, the evidence of Mr Tay that he “surmised” on the basis of this sale that the plaintiff had sorted out its margin issues with Maybank is without any proper justification.
(d) In reaching this conclusion, I also bear in mind that the market price of Agritrade shares continued its downward trend during the remainder of October and November as appears from the above table. If anything, that downward trend would have exacerbated the risk of a margin call by Maybank at some stage in the future.
(e) In passing, it is fair to say that in the middle of his cross-examination, Mr Tay suggested out of the blue for the first time that his “surmise” that the plaintiff had cleared its margin issues was based not only on his WhatsApp exchange with Mr Ee but also on a conversation with Mr Thng. I do not accept that suggestion. If Mr Thng had indeed told Mr Tay at any stage that the plaintiff’s margin issues had been cleared, that would have been very important evidence. As such, it is impossible or at least difficult to understand why this was not mentioned by Mr Tay in his AEIC. Indeed, any such suggestion would seem to be inconsistent with what Mr Tay does say in his AEIC i.e. that he simply “surmised” that the plaintiff’s margin issues had been cleared. Moreover, it was never suggested to Mr Thng in cross-examination that he (Mr Thng) had told Mr Tay that the plaintiff’s margin issues had been cleared.
(f) In paragraphs 27(b) and (c) of Mr Tay’s AEIC, I note that he states that Mr Thng shared with him some marketing presentation slides touting the plaintiff’s track record and that he (Mr Tay) noted that these reflected the plaintiff’s investment risk management as “Zero leverage”. At trial, he said these slides were shared with him around end-November 2019. On this basis, it was submitted on the defendant’s behalf that these would have led the defendant to understand and believe that the plaintiff was not facing any margin issues in end-November 2019. However, as submitted on behalf of the plaintiff, it seems that the particular slide referred to by Mr Tay was not up to date and, if that is right, it cannot (at least by itself) refer to the position as it was in the last quarter of 2019.
(g) In any event, Mr Tay’s evidence that his personal knowledge was that the plaintiff’s margin issues had been cleared by late October 2019 also seems difficult to square with the evidence in paragraph 27(d) of his AEIC where he refers to discussions between Mr Thng and himself around a month later in or around end-November 2019 and states that Mr Thng did mention in the course of such discussions that the defendant’s Agritrade Shares could help the plaintiff with its margin issues although, according to Mr Tay, this was only “mentioned in passing and was not elaborated.” In particular:
(i) As stated above, it was (at least initially) Mr Tay’s evidence as stated in his AEIC that as of late-October 2019, he “surmised” that the plaintiff had “cleared its margin issue with Maybank”.
(ii) When cross-examined with regard to what he had stated in paragraph 27(d) of his AEIC, Mr Tay’s initial evidence was that by end-November 2019, he “knew [the plaintiff] had margin. Not margin issues”.
(iii) However, under further cross-examination, Mr Tay initially accepted that (contrary to the evidence he had just given) he did know that the plaintiff had margin issues as of end-November 2019 and that the defendant’s shares could help with such margin issues. However, when it was then put to Mr Tay that the defendant had knowledge of the plaintiff’s margin issues all along up to the execution of the SA on 11 December 2019, he said: “I do not agree.”
(iv) In my view, if, as Mr Tay accepted, he knew as of end-November 2019 that the plaintiff had margin issues and that the defendant’s shares could help with such margin issues, there is no basis for suggesting otherwise only 11 days later when the SA was signed. Nothing of significance appears to have happened during that very short period to change the position other than perhaps the further decline in the market price of Agritrade shares from HK$ 0.620 on 29 November 2019 to HK$ 0.570 on 11 December 2019 which, at least if that downward trend continued, would only have exacerbated the risk of a potential margin call by Maybank.
(v) That both parties understood that the intention behind the agreement to transfer the Agritrade Shares was, at least in part, to help the plaintiff “protect against the margin call” also appears from an audio recording recorded during a meeting between Mr Thng and Mr Tay at a coffee shop on 23 January 2020.
- [44]
[44] It is equally fair to say that the evidence of Mr Thng with regard to the plaintiff’s supposed margin issues towards the end of 2019 and what he supposedly told Mr Tay with regard thereto prior to 11 December 2019 is also somewhat limited. There is no contemporaneous documentary evidence to indicate that Mr Thng told Mr Tay that the plaintiff had margin issues either in a general sense or, more specifically, exactly what those margin issues were. Even putting Mr Thng’s evidence at its highest, he does not suggest that such supposed margin issues were specified or explained in any detail to Mr Tay. To that extent, this would seem to tally with the evidence of Mr Tay that any margin issues were only mentioned in passing but not elaborated upon by Mr Thng.
- [45]
[45] Further, it is important to note that although the defendant had initially pleaded (in paragraph 12(a) of the Defence) that prior to the defendant’s intended subscription, the plaintiff’s MLF already had a high LTV Ratio, this was subsequently deleted by way of Amendment No. 1. I have already touched on this point earlier in this Judgment. Although there were differences between the experts (essentially depending on the amount attributed to the “collateral value”) as to the correct figure for the LTV Ratio in the last quarter of 2019 ranging from, according to Mr Tan, approximately 25% in September 2019 to 33% in December 2019 and, according to Mr Kon, approximately 36% to 48% during that same period, both experts agreed in the Joint Statement that these figures did not amount to a high LTV Ratio.
- [46]
[46] In light of the foregoing, I find it impossible to reach a conclusion on the evidence as to exactly what Mr Thng said to Mr Tay with regard to the plaintiff’s margin issues in the period immediately before Mr Tay signed the SA and Mr Tay’s state of knowledge with regard thereto. For present purposes, it is sufficient to say that it is my conclusion that (a) Mr Tay was well aware that at least one of the purposes for the defendant agreeing to transfer the Agritrade Shares was to help the plaintiff with its margin issues so that the plaintiff would have an appropriate buffer to prevent a margin call; and (b) as an experienced trader Mr Tay would also have been well aware that (i) if the market price of Agritrade shares continued to fall, the plaintiff’s LTV Ratio would obviously rise and the Margin Ratio would obviously fall; (ii) in that scenario, the potential for a margin call by Maybank would increase; and (iii) if the defendant did not transfer the Agritrade Shares into the plaintiff’s fund and the share price fell, it was at the very least not unlikely that Maybank would make a margin call which the defendant could not meet and then effect a forced sale of the plaintiff’s existing portfolio of Agritrade shares (whether in whole or in part) causing the plaintiff potential substantial losses. This conclusion is important in the context of the defendant’s case that the losses now claimed by the plaintiff are too remote in law, which I consider further below.
- [47]
[47] On 11 December 2019, following signing of the contract documents, Mr Thng immediately sent an email to Swiss-Asia (copying Mr Tay) to provide the team with a copy of the contract documents to get the defendant’s onboarding process started. He also informed the team at Swiss-Asia to liaise directly with Mr Tay if additional documents were required. Shortly thereafter, Mr Thng also introduced Mr Tay to Mr Daniel Kwek (“Mr Kwek”) from Maybank by email to coordinate the transfer of the defendant’s Agritrade Shares.
- [48]
[48] Also on 11 December 2019, after Mr Tay was introduced to Swiss-Asia and Maybank, Ms Marilyn Chao (“Ms Chao”), a staff member of Swiss-Asia, emailed Apex to inform them that the expected Subscription Day would be 2 January 2020. According to Mr Thng, Ms Chao did this because the parties involved in facilitating the transaction knew and operated on the basis that the Subscription Dealing Deadline under the contract documents was 30 December 2019 (i.e. 2 business days before 2 January 2020) although, according to Mr Thng, the deadline was shifted back one day by the plaintiff to 31 December 2019.
- [50]
[50] On behalf of the plaintiff, it was submitted that the fact that Mr Tay and Mr Thng “rushed” to get the BS Note signed supports the conclusion that the transfer of shares was required to be done by 31 December 2019 and that Mr Tay well understood that this was the case. This was disputed by the defendant. In particular, it was submitted on behalf of the defendant that the fact that steps were taken by Mr Tay to sign the BS Note and pay the stamp duty on 17 December 2019 was done “purely as a matter of convenience” because he (Mr Tay) was going away for his year-end vacation and it was convenient to arrange for the BS Note at the time. Indeed, as Mr Tay explained in evidence, if the transfer deadline were imminent, he would not have then dropped everything after 17 December 2019 and gone on holiday. Insofar as may be relevant, I consider this further below.
- [51]
[51] Meanwhile, on 16 December 2019, Mr Thing sent an email to Mr Tay stating: “Can u chase swissasia n ask when u can transfer the shares? U have investor power now. Haha.”
- [52]
[52] To further expedite the onboarding process, Mr Thng followed up with an email (copying Mr Tay) to the Swiss-Asia team and Mr Kwek from Maybank instructing them to receive the defendant’s transfer of the Agritrade Shares after CDD had been cleared:
- [53]
[53] On 17 December 2019, there were further WhatsApp communications between Mr Tay, Mr Ee and Mr Kwek regarding what Mr Tay described as the “incoming transfer”.
- [54]
[54] Meanwhile, immediately after the contract documents were signed, both Swiss-Asia and Apex also commenced CDD on the defendant. That process was described and explained in detail by Ms Ho in her AEIC. As there stated, Ms Ho confirmed that:
(a) Swiss-Asia’s CDD clearance is the only requirement for the transfer of the shares. Apex’s CDD clearance is not a pre-requisite for the transfer of the shares.
(b) Mr Tay was forthcoming and expeditious in responding to Swiss-Asia’s requests for documents and information. He was also responsive and would provide the required documents or information within very short timeframes.
(c) By 18 December 2019:
(i) Swiss-Asia's due diligence process had been completed.
(ii) The defendant had cleared Swiss-Asia's CDD process for the transfer of the Agritrade Shares by the defendant to the plaintiff.
(iii) Apex had also completed a sufficient portion of the CDD process to enable the transfer to be effected.
(d) From 18 December 2019, the defendant was able to transfer the Agritrade Shares by 31 December 2019.
So far as relevant, Mr Thng and Mr Ee both gave evidence to similar effect.
- [55]
[55] In contrast, it was submitted on behalf of the defendant that from 17 December 2019 to 31 December 2019, Swiss-Asia and Apex were still conducting due diligence checks on the defendant and processing the defendant’s subscription application. Mr Tay’s evidence was that even after the BS Note was signed and Swiss-Asia had cleared its CDD on 18 December 2019, it was still not possible to immediately transfer the Agritrade Shares to the plaintiff. However, Mr Tay could not give any satisfactory explanation as to why there was any difficulty or other impediment in so doing after 18 December 2019. In its pleaded case, the defendant suggested that the transfer could not be completed until Apex had performed its own checks. In particular, the defendant had specifically amended its pleaded Defence to assert that it was obliged to transfer the Agritrade Shares only after the necessary due diligence was completed by the plaintiff, Swiss-Asia “and/or Apex” and the necessary approvals obtained. It was thus only after the commencement of proceedings that the defendant even suggested that completion of checks by Apex, as opposed to just the plaintiff and Swiss-Asia, was necessary. However, Mr Tay could not give a satisfactory explanation as to why this was so: indeed, I found Mr Tay’s evidence in this context both evasive and not credible. As referred to above, Ms Ho’s unchallenged evidence (which I accept) was that as long as Swiss-Asia's CDD is cleared, an investor in the plaintiff can proceed to provide the relevant consideration to the plaintiff as stated in the contract; and that this is so even if the fund administrator, such as Apex had not cleared CDD. In light of the foregoing, I reject Mr Tay’s evidence to the contrary. I note for the avoidance of doubt that my analysis here relates to whether the shares could have been transferred following the clearance of Swiss-Asia’s CDD, and does not touch on the precise state of Mr Tay’s knowledge of what was possible at the material point in time.
- [56]
[56] Thus, it is my conclusion that from 18 December 2019, the defendant was able to transfer the Agritrade Shares to the plaintiff and that there was no difficulty or impediment in so doing.
- [57]
[57] After the defendant had cleared Swiss-Asia’s CDD process, Mr Ee immediately informed Mr Tay by WhatsApp message dated 18 December 2019 at 10.29am that the defendant’s know-your-client requirements had been approved “on our side”. The result was that the plaintiff was permitted under the Monetary Authority of Singapore’s Notice SFA04-N02 (the “MAS Notice”) to onboard the defendant and accept the defendant’s Agritrade Shares.
- [58]
[58] Thereafter, Mr Thng sent a number of WhatsApp messages chasing or reminding Mr Tay to effect the transfer, including the following:
- [59]
[59] Notwithstanding the above messages, it is important to note that the defendant relies heavily on the fact that there were no reminders sent by the plaintiff stating expressly and specifically that the defendant had to transfer its Agritrade Shares by 31 December 2019. In cross-examination, Mr Thng suggested somewhat tentatively for the first time that he had in fact called Mr Tay to remind him “verbally” of the 31 December 2019 deadline. However, if this had been the case, it is surprising that it was not mentioned previously in Mr Thng’s AEIC; in these circumstances, I do not consider that there is sufficient evidence to conclude that Mr Thng did in fact speak to Mr Tay to tell him specifically of the deadline.
- [60]
[60] It is common ground that the defendant did not transfer the Agritrade Shares to the plaintiff on 31 December 2019, or at any time thereafter.
- [61]
[61] At the beginning of 2020, the closing share price of Agritrade shares was HK$ 0.570. Thereafter, the share price hovered at around that level for the first few days of January 2020 and then, from about 9 January 2020, declined quite rapidly, as appears from the following table:
- [62]
[62] This decline in the share price of Agritrade shares, in particular from 13 January 2020, also appears from the following chart which formed part of Mr Kon’s expert report:
- [63]
[63] Meanwhile, it is important to note that it is the defendant’s case that even after the alleged “deadline” of 31 December 2019 and with knowledge that the Agritrade Shares had not been transferred, the plaintiff did not highlight that the defendant had been remiss, nor did it seek to enforce the transfer of the Agritrade Shares without delay; and that such silence or inaction by the plaintiff is significant because the plaintiff was under a “duty to speak”. This is disputed by the plaintiff. The plaintiff says that it did chase the defendant for the shares after 31 December 2019. In that context, the plaintiff relies, in particular, on the following communications between the parties:
- [64]
[64] By this stage, i.e. 16 January 2020, it can be seen from the table above at [61] that the Agritrade share price had fallen to HK$ 0.375 per share.
- [65]
[65] At 8.37pm on 16 January 2020, Mr Ee sent a message to Mr Tay stating: “Bro. Swiss asia side will be using end jan Nav. They said it will be too late as Dec Nav already out. Subscription will be done in Feb.” According to Mr Thng and Mr Ee, this was a mistake which Mr Thng clarified in the course of a further WhatsApp exchange with Mr Tay the following day i.e. 17 January 2020:
On behalf of the defendant, it was submitted that the assertions by Mr Thng and Mr Ee that the message at 8.37pm on 16 January 2020 was sent mistakenly by Mr Ee were untrue. So far as relevant, I deal with this further below.
- [66]
[66] That evening, i.e. Friday 17 January 2020, the closing price for Agritrade shares was HK$ 0.375 per share. Following that weekend, on the market opening on Monday 20 January 2020, the price had fallen to HK$ 0.370 per share. Thereafter, during the day, it continued a further steep decline, closing at 4.00pm at HK$ 0.250 per share. I set out at Annex 1 to this Judgment a table showing the opening prices and trading volumes of Agritrade shares at 15 minute intervals from 16 January 2020 to 23 January 2020.
- [68]
[68] In that context, it is certainly interesting to note that before 16 January 2020, the volume of shares traded daily on the market was relatively low; but on that day i.e. Thursday 16 January 2020, the number of shares traded then spiked to some 34,350,000 shares, falling back on Friday 17 January 2020 to 14,080,000 before spiking hugely after the weekend during Monday 20 January 2020 to a much higher figure of 129,640,000 shares. It is important to note that these trades occurred before the release of the public notice of the Moratorium Application (and accompanying automatic moratorium) at 7.34pm on 20 January 2020 (the “Moratorium Announcement”), after the market had closed that day. The timing is important for reasons which I address later in this Judgment. It is also important to note that Mr Tay’s evidence was that he was not aware of the Moratorium Application until sometime after the issuance of the public notice, and probably not until the following day i.e. 21 January 2020.
- [69]
[69] Meanwhile, at 8.11am on Monday 20 January 2020 i.e. before the opening of the market, Maybank’s representative, Morris Teo, told Mr Thng of a margin call for S$ 235,000 over WhatsApp. Shortly thereafter, the opening price at 9.30am was HK$ 0.370. By 10.30am, the share price had fallen approximately 20% to HK$ 0.300 per share. A few minutes later, at 10.35am, Morris Teo sent Mr Thng a further WhatsApp message stating: “… immediate margin call now as price tanked today. S$1.3m” .
- [70]
[70] The plaintiff’s pleaded case is that on 20 January 2020, its LTV Ratio reached 70.87%, crossing the margin trigger threshold. However, it is important to note that the plaintiff did not adduce evidence in these proceedings from Morris Teo (or anyone else from Maybank) to explain (a) how Maybank had calculated the initial margin call of S$ 235,000, or the later margin call of S$ 1.3 million, or even the figure of 70.87% just mentioned; or (b) what Maybank would have done in the counter-factual situation i.e. if the defendant had transferred the Agritrade Shares to the plaintiff at any time prior to 20 January 2020. The failure by the plaintiff to call any evidence from Morris Teo or anyone else from Maybank relating to these matters was the subject of robust criticism by Counsel of behalf of the defendant. So far as relevant, I address such criticism below.
- [71]
[71] For present purposes, it is sufficient to note that although both experts agreed that the margin trigger threshold had been triggered on 20 January 2020 so as to entitle Maybank to make a margin call and to force sell at least some of the plaintiff’s Agritrade shares, there was a significant difference between them as to the extent to which the LTV Ratio had been exceeded and the Margin Ratio breached on that day. Further, and perhaps more important, there was also a significant difference between them as to what the counter-factual position would have been i.e. on the assumption that the defendant had transferred the Agritrade Shares to the plaintiff.
- [72]
[72] In paragraph 4.9 of his original report, the defendant’s expert, Mr Kon, summarised his calculations with regard to what he called Scenario A (i.e. the actual position) and Scenario B (i.e. the counter-factual position assuming that the defendant had transferred the Agritrade Shares to the plaintiff) as at 3.15pm on 20 January 2020 in Table 3, which I set out below:
As appears from this table, in the case of Scenario B (Column F), the Margin Ratio was, on the basis of Mr Kon’s calculations, above 140%. On this basis, Mr Kon stated in paragraph 4.11 of his original expert report, that in Scenario B (i.e. the counter-factual situation), a margin call would not have been triggered on 20 January 2020. This was the same conclusion (albeit on different figures) as that reached by the plaintiff’s expert, Mr Tan, and in line with the plaintiff’s case. However, in the course of the trial shortly before Mr Kon was due to give evidence, he (Mr Kon) explained in a further AEIC that he had made a mistake i.e. whereas he had originally used a share price of HK$ 0.285 per share to calculate the Margin Ratio as set out in the original Table 3, he had inadvertently failed to notice that the share price had in fact fallen below that figure to HK$ 0.280 per share at 2.15pm on 20 January 2020; that recomputing the figures using that lower figure, his conclusion was that the Margin Ratio would have fallen below 140% in the counter-factual situation at that time; and that, on this basis and contrary to his original conclusion, Maybank would in any event have been entitled to make a margin call even if the defendant had transferred the Agritrade Shares to the plaintiff. If correct, that conclusion is of considerable importance when considering the plaintiff’s claim for damages. I consider this further below. For present purposes, I would simply note that this volte face by Mr Kon was hotly disputed by the plaintiff’s expert, Mr Tan, and by Counsel on behalf of the plaintiff.
- [73]
[73] Be all this as it may, it was, as I have said, common ground that (a) Maybank was entitled to make the margin calls which it made on 20 January 2020; (b) the plaintiff was unable to meet those margin calls; and (c) accordingly, from about 3.15pm onwards, Maybank force sold (as it was entitled to do) some 30 million of the plaintiff’s Agritrade shares at an average price of HK$ 0.1957 per share, which was slightly above the closing price of HK$ 0.250 per share at 4.00pm on that day.
- [74]
[74] Meanwhile, during that day, there were various increasingly frenetic WhatsApp exchanges between Mr Thng and Mr Tay both before and after the sale of these Agritrade shares by Maybank:
- [75]
[75] As also stated above, later that evening after trading closed on 20 January 2020, notice of the Moratorium Application was released and made public by a formal notice.
- [76]
[76] At 8.56am on the next day, 21 January 2020, Maybank issued a further immediate margin call for S$ 1.27 million. Again, I note that there is no evidence from Maybank as to how this figure was calculated. Shortly thereafter, the opening price at 9.30am fell further to HK$ 0.240. As appears from Annex 1, the price then continued to decline during that day, closing at 4.00pm at HK$ 0.180 per share. In the course of that day, Maybank force sold a further 127,745,000 shares in two tranches, viz 20,000,000 shares at HK$ 0.170 and a further 107,745,000 shares at HK$ 0.18344, equivalent to an average price of HK$ 0.1813 per share. The precise timings of these sales are uncertain, but the prices achieved would seem to indicate that such sales must have occurred at least some time after opening, when the market price was still HK$ 0.240.
- [77]
[77] During that day i.e. 21 January 2020, there were further WhatsApp messages exchanged between Mr Thng and Mr Tay:
- [78]
[78] On 22 January 2020, there were yet further exchanges between Mr Thng and Mr Tay via WhatsApp:
- [79]
[79] On 23 January 2020, Maybank sold the last relatively small tranche of the plaintiff’s Agritrade shares i.e. 250,000 shares at an average price of HK$ 0.2211 per share.
- [80]
[80] On that same day i.e. 23 January 2020, there was also an important face-to-face meeting in a coffee shop between Mr Thng and Mr Tay. The meeting was partially recorded by Mr Thng, and included the following exchange:
- [81]
[81] On 28 January 2020, Mr Tay and Mr Thng had a heated exchange over WhatsApp culminating in Mr Tay observing that it seemed that he was “losing at the start” and that he should be “calling the investigation and querying”. Mr Thng replied to point out that it could be proved that, had Mr Tay’s shares “c[o]me in, there will be no margin call”. Mr Thng asked what Mr Tay intended to do, emphasising that he (i.e. Mr Thng) was “really trying to settle cordially”. With no response from Mr Tay, Mr Thng pointed out that he believed Mr Tay’s conscience still spoke to him, and that Mr Tay knew that he “screwed everyone in the fund” on 21 January 2020. Mr Thng suggested that they cordially mediate the matter with Swiss-Asia thereafter, but Mr Tay did not reply.
- [82]
[82] On 29 January 2020, the plaintiff sent a letter of demand to the defendant demanding payment for the loss it had suffered from the forced sale of its Agritrade shares.
- [83]
[83] On 3 February 2020, this Suit was commenced.
The Issues
- [84]
[84] Against that background, I turn to consider the main issues. There was some dispute between the parties as to the precise formulation of these main issues. However, I would summarise them as follow:
(a) Issue 1: Was there an agreement between the parties that the defendant was obliged to transfer the Agritrade Shares to the plaintiff by 31 December 2019?
(b) Issue 2: Was there an implied term that the defendant’s obligation to transfer the Agritrade Shares only arose after the due diligence and subscription application process had been completed?
(c) Issue 3: Did the plaintiff waive the requirement for the defendant to transfer the Agritrade Shares by 31 December 2019 and/or is the plaintiff estopped from so contending?
(d) Issue 4: Did the defendant’s breach (if any) cause any, and if so what, loss to the plaintiff, and is any such loss irrecoverable because it is too remote?
Issue 1: Was there an agreement between the parties that the defendant would transfer the Agritrade Shares to the plaintiff by 31 December 2019?
- [85]
[85] I have already summarised the plaintiff’s case with regard to this central issue and the particular provisions of the SAF and PPM relied upon.
- [86]
[86] Before considering the defendant’s case, it is necessary to deal briefly with one minor issue viz. whether the relevant date was 30 December 2019 or 31 December 2019. At the end of the day, this does not seem to me to be crucial because it was common ground that the plaintiff was entitled to exercise its discretion to change the subscription date so that if, on the plaintiff’s case, the original date was 30 December 2019, it was open to the plaintiff to exercise that discretion and change the date to 31 December 2019. The evidence of Mr Thng was that as the plaintiff and defendant had agreed that the Agritrade Shares were to be transferred using the NAV on 31 December 2019, the plaintiff therefore exercised its contractual discretion under the contract documents to allow the defendant to transfer its Agritrade Shares by 31 December 2019 as it was the plaintiff’s usual practice to allow investors to transfer the shares on the last business day of the month, corresponding to the date of the NAV that would be used for the valuation of the Agritrade Shares. I accept that evidence.
- [87]
[87] However, there was, at least initially, a dispute between the parties as to whether the defendant had been informed that the plaintiff had exercised its contractual discretion. The evidence in relation to that issue was somewhat confusing although, again, I do not think that this issue is crucial. In cross-examination, Mr Tay admitted that he understood that the subscription date was in fact changed to 31 December 2019. However, it is not easy to fit that evidence in with the rest of the defendant’s case. Be that as it may and subject to the defendant’s other submissions, I proceed on the basis that, at least on the plaintiff’s case, the subscription date had been extended from 30 December to 31 December 2019.
- [88]
[88] In summary, it was the defendant’s case that with the proper appreciation of the factual context leading up to the signing of the SAF and PPM, 31 December 2019 was not the agreed deadline for the defendant to transfer the Agritrade Shares.
- [89]
[89] As to the applicable legal principles, the defendant relied upon the following:
(a) The Court may consider the factual context when interpreting a contract: see CIFG Special Assets Capital I Ltd (formerly known as Diamond Kendall Ltd) v Ong Puay Koon and others and another appeal [2018] 1 SLR 170, in particular at [19]:
(b) Singapore law has consistently affirmed the relevance of the context when interpreting the terms of a contract: Y.E.S. F&B Group Pte Ltd v Soup Restaurant Singapore Pte Ltd (formerly known as Soup Restaurant (Causeway Point) Pte Ltd) [2015] 5 SLR 1187 at [34], which states that when the text of a contract is ambiguous “… it is clear that the relevant context will generally be of the first importance …” (emphasis original).
(c) The Singapore Courts are open to relying on prior negotiations and subsequent conduct to interpret a contract. In Zurich Insurance (Singapore) Pte Ltd v B-Gold Interior Design & Construction Pte Ltd [2008] 3 SLR(R) 1029, the Court of Appeal stated at [132(d)] that “there should be no absolute or rigid prohibition against evidence of previous negotiations or subsequent conduct, although, in the normal case, such evidence is likely to be inadmissible for non-compliance with the requirements [of relevancy, clarity, and availability to the parties]”.
- [90]
[90] I accept the foregoing as a brief summary of the relevant applicable principles at least with regard to matters existing prior to the contract. Turning to the position under Singapore law with regard to subsequent conduct, I was referred by Counsel on behalf of the plaintiff to MCH International Pte Ltd and others v YG Group Pte Ltd and others and other appeals [2019] 2 SLR 837 (“MCH International”) at [20] and Hewlett-Packard Singapore (Sales) Pte Ltd v Chin Shu Hwa Corinna [2016] 2 SLR 1083 (“Hewlett-Packard Singapore”) at [56], where the Court of Appeal refused to express a definitive view on the admissibility of subsequent conduct for the purposes of contractual interpretation. In Hewlett-Packard Singapore, the Court of Appeal noted at [55]–[56] that in the event that subsequent conduct was to be admitted, the court also had to bear the following criteria in mind viz (i) the evidence of the subsequent conduct must be relevant, reasonably available to all the contracting parties, and relate to a clear and obvious context; (ii) the principle of objectively ascertaining contractual intention(s) remains paramount; and accordingly, (iii) the subsequent conduct must always go toward proof of what the parties, from an objective viewpoint, ultimately agreed upon.
The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.