Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 27 Mar 2024

Singapore International Commercial Court

Kiri Industries Ltd v Senda International Capital Ltd and another

Feedback & support

[2024] SGHC(I) 7Case no. Suit No 4 of 2017 (Summons No 59 of 2023)

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. Background

  3. [4] Kiri Industries Ltd (“Kiri”) and Senda International Capital Ltd (“Senda”) became joint venturers in DyStar Global Holdings (Singapore) Pte Ltd (“DyStar”). Kiri, a company incorporated and listed in India, held 37.57% of the shareholding in DyStar; Senda, a company incorporated in Hong Kong, held 62.43% of the shareholding. Senda is a wholly owned subsidiary of a company incorporated and listed in the People’s Republic of China (“China”, and the adjective “Chinese”), Zhejiang Longsheng Group Co, Ltd (“Longsheng”). One share was held by Well Prospering Ltd, another wholly owned subsidiary of Longsheng. DyStar carried on business in the dye industry, in which each of Kiri and Longsheng were already established players.

  4. [5] The relationship between Kiri and Longsheng broke down. In 2017, Kiri brought proceedings against Senda for oppression under s 216 of the Companies Act (Cap 50, 2006 Rev Ed). Senda counterclaimed against Kiri and officers of Kiri on a number of causes of action, and DyStar brought proceedings against Kiri and the officers mirroring those claims and with some additional claims.

  5. [11] Ms Fan and Mr Ruan are both Chinese nationals. At all material times Mr Ruan was and is resident in China. On the evidence before me, at all material times Ms Fan was and is resident in China; an issue is whether Kiri should have known that she was resident in China.

  6. [13] Service has not been effected on Mr Ruan. As later described, Kiri accepts that he must be served with the judicial assistance of the Chinese Courts pursuant to the Treaty on Judicial Assistance in Civil and Commercial Matters between the People’s Republic of China and the Republic of Singapore concluded in 1999 (“the Treaty”), and has set the necessary process in train, but service has not yet occurred.

  7. This Application

  8. An Adjournment Application

  9. [19] At the hearing, Mr Toh did not begin by applying for an adjournment. He was well into his substantive submissions when attention was drawn to the written submissions and he was asked whether the request for an adjournment was maintained. It was, and Mr Toh made his submissions in that respect. I declined to adjourn the application, and should give my reasons for doing so.

  10. [20] The application was filed in early December 2023. It was supported by a lengthy affidavit of Ms Fan and an affidavit of Mr Wang Lingqi (“Mr Wang”) providing an expert opinion on Chinese law. The hearing date was fixed. Pursuant to directions, responsive affidavits of Mr Manish Pravinchandra Kiri (“Mr Kiri”) and Dr Arthur Xiao Dong (“Dr Dong”) were filed, the latter also providing an expert opinion on Chinese law. Second affidavits of Ms Fan and Mr Wang were filed in reply, and then another affidavit of Mr Kiri. Nearly 3000 pages of materials were generated. Also pursuant to directions, written submissions were exchanged accompanied by numerous authorities. As earlier noted, the submission of an adjournment appeared in the Applicants’ written submissions.

  11. [25] I add that orders were made in SUM 24 shortly after the hearing of the application. They did not take up either of the proposals to which Mr Toh referred. The orders were for an en bloc sale of the shares in DyStar, with a procedure to determine a long-stop date for entry into a binding sale agreement; the timing was indeterminate. There was no reason to revisit the question of adjournment.

  12. Overview of the Applicants’ Contentions

  13. The EJD Order

  14. The making of the order

  15. Setting the scene: Burgundy Global

  16. [35] The Court’s examination of the English cases included the observation (at [86]):

  17. The Applicants’ contentions: discussion

  18. Conclusion as to the EJD Order

  19. The Service Out Order

  20. The making of the order

  21. [49] The application was supported by another affidavit of Mr Kiri. As to Ms Fan being found in Hong Kong, he referred to a Notice of Change of Company Director for Senda in the Hong Kong Integrated Companies Registry Information System (“ICRIS”) showing her “Correspondence Address” as the Hong Kong address, and a Director’s Particulars search showing the same, and said:

  22. The Applicants’ contentions: discussion

  23. [52] I return to Burgundy Global. As earlier explained, the Court held that the application for leave to serve out of the jurisdiction is the time when the court “may weigh the competing considerations”. When the Court turned to whether leave should be granted in that case, after accepting that the leave could be granted retrospectively, it was said:

  24. Ground (a): sufficiently close connection

  25. [56] In that respect, her position is similar to that of Mr Serafica, one of the directors in Burgundy Global. There was no evidence that the other directors had any knowledge of the company’s activities and assets, but it was argued from a phrase in his affidavit that he did. The Court considered that it was not open for Transocean to rely on the affidavit, but said (at [114]):

  26. [57] A close connection with the substantive claim, while described in Burgundy Global at [112] as fundamental, is also described as something which the court might wish to consider, and which might make it easier to justify invoking the court’s jurisdiction over the foreign officer. It can be the “something more” in addition to the foreign officer having relevant information, but there can be some other “something more”, and the ultimate question is whether the court is persuaded that it is a proper case to grant leave to serve out of the jurisdiction. Is there something more in the present case?

  27. Ground (b): contravention of Chinese law

  28. [61] Disentangled from ground (c), with which there was some overlap, the Applicants’ argument rested on Article 284 of the Civil Procedure Law of the People’s Republic of China (“the Civil Procedure Law”). It and the preceding Article 283 provided:

  29. [65] As to the collection of evidence, Mr Wang’s response in his second report was that the concept of evidence was relevant to civil procedure in general and was not confined to trial or pre-judgment stages, with reference to provisions said to illustrate the relevance of the concept in Chinese enforcement proceedings. One provision was concerned with evidence to support an application in enforcement proceedings, but there were some in which materials showing the judgment debtor’s means were referred to as evidence.

  30. [67] In interpreting the Articles, it must be remembered that they and the other provisions in Chinese law are before me in translation and nuances of words and expression may have been lost; with the best of assistance from Mr Wang and Dr Dong, it would be wrong to take definitive guidance from the words alone. I consider that I should seek to be guided also by considering the intent of the Articles. Their intent, it seems to me, is to have a wide operation whereby either through the use of treaty procedures or by necessary consent of Chinese administrative authorities, any activity constituting the collection of evidence in a wide sense is subject to Chinese oversight; a legalistic concept of evidence is not the answer. In this respect I prefer Mr Wang’s opinion: examination of a judgment debtor to ascertain their means, in my view, is a collection of evidence caught by the Articles.

  31. Ground (c): other ways to obtain the information

  32. [72] The ground rested on the Treaty. I have referred to its Article 2, providing for mutual judicial assistance in (amongst other things) the taking of evidence. By its Article 12:

  33. Full and frank disclosure

  34. [84] In his affidavit Mr Kiri asserted that “to the best of my knowledge, information and belief” Ms Fan was “located in Hong Kong”, with the basis for this conclusion being the “Correspondence Address” in the documents filed with the Hong Kong authorities, and said that Kiri had not been able to identify any other addresses for Ms Fan. The same affidavit included that a Directors’ Particulars search obtained from ICRIS stated Mr Ruan’s “Correspondence Address” as the Hong Kong address, but referred also to three other documents showing addresses for Mr Ruan in China; while the affidavit asserted that, based on these documents, to the best of Mr Kiri’s knowledge, information, and belief Mr Ruan was “located in China and/or in Hong Kong”. This and the known fact that the Hong Kong address was Senda’s registered office suggested that the “Correspondence Address” was not a true guide to the residence of Ms Fan. Ms Fan was known (and disclosed) to be a Chinese citizen, her possible residence in China was material, and little more could have brought the Assistant Registrar to the view that Ms Fan was resident in China and either not “located in Hong Kong” or, if “located in Hong Kong” in the sense of having a presence there, nonetheless resident in China.

  35. [85] There was more known to Kiri at the time. It disclosed Mr Ruan’s former directorship of Senda, and that Senda was a wholly owned subsidiary of Longsheng and Mr Ruan was the “Chairman and General Manager” of Longsheng. But it knew that Longsheng was a substantial Chinese-based company and that Senda was an investment vehicle for Longsheng, not an actively trading company, and from Mr Ruan’s involvement in the oppression proceedings Kiri could not reasonably have thought other than that his responsibilities as a senior officer of Longsheng meant that he was located in China and that either one or both (depending on timing) of the Chinese addresses was a residential address or he was elsewhere resident in China. In an affidavit dated 21 July 2023 filed in SUM 24, Mr Kiri had said that he believed that Ms Fan was Mr Ruan’s assistant. Those matters, if disclosed, would have significantly detracted from the already weak guide of the “Correspondence Address” to the “location” of Ms Fan: would not, or at least could not, Mr Ruan’s true “location” be China, probably resident at one of the Chinese addresses, and would or could not his assistant also be “located” in China where he was “located” and probably also resident in China? The reference to the “location” of Ms Fan in Hong Kong masked the question of where she was resident and whether she was resident in China. As well, if Ms Fan was Mr Ruan’s assistant, that could throw up whether she had a sufficiently close connection in accordance with Burgundy Global. These matters should have been disclosed.

  36. [86] There was material non-disclosure. It is no answer to say, as Mr Rajan submitted in answer, that by the “Correspondence Address” Ms Fan had represented, “If you want to give me notice, do so in Hong Kong”. It was not just a question of giving notice to Ms Fan.

  37. [88] The Applicants also submitted that there was material non-disclosure in that in the later attempts to serve Ms Fan in Hong Kong, Kiri was told, as described at [93] below, that Ms Fan was “not present“ at the Hong Kong address and “should be in China too”, and in late October 2023 was told by Senda’s lawyers that she was ordinarily resident in China; but, they said, it failed to file a supplementary affidavit to make voluntarily disclosure, referring to The Norglimpt [1988] QB 183 at 187–188. Mr Rajan did not respond to the submission. The occasion for supplementary disclosure in the present circumstances may be debateable – so far as I am aware the matter has not yet been considered in Singapore – and, it being unnecessary to go into it, in the absence of full submissions I will not do so.

  38. Conclusion as to the service out order

  39. The Substituted Service Order

  40. The making of the order

  41. [91] Senda was duly served at the Hong Kong address, its registered office, although the documents were returned. Attempts to serve Ms Fan at the Hong Kong address, unsurprisingly, were not successful.

  42. [93] Mr Lo had attended at the Hong Kong address, asked the man who answered the door if Ms Fan or Mr Ruan were present, and been told that the man recognised Mr Ruan’s name as someone from Senda, but had not heard of Ms Fan’s name before and had not seen her before. Mr Lo told the man that Ms Fan should be one of the bosses of Senda, to which the man replied that Senda’s bosses were in China, so if Ms Fan was one of the bosses, she should be in China too. Mr Lo attended at the Hong Kong address on a later occasion. He asked the woman who answered the door if Ms Fan was present, and was told that she was not.

  43. [94] Mr Suresh added that a woman who returned the documents left at the Hong Kong address for Senda told Kiri’s Hong Kong lawyers that Senda was at the address, but not Ms Fan or Mr Ruan; she said Senda could be contacted to receive the documents if there were documents for Senda and provided the phone number of one “Miki”. So far as appears, Kiri did not telephone “Miki”. Mr Suresh said that Kiri had not been able to identify any other addresses for Ms Fan in Hong Kong or elsewhere, and that even though the man who answered the door at the Hong Kong address claimed that the bosses of Senda should be in China “it appears that he was not a personnel of Senda, and it is also clear that he did not know who Fan was, or where Fan may be”. He said that based on the searches performed on ICRIS, meaning those which showed the Hong Kong address as Ms Fan’s “Correspondence Address”, to the best of Kiri’s knowledge, information, and belief Ms Fan was “in Hong Kong”.

  44. The Applicants’ contentions: discussion

The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.