Family Division of the High Court · Decided 27 May 2019
UHA v UHB and another appeal
Feedback & support[2019] SGHCF 12 · Case no. District Court Appeal No 37 of 2018 · 55 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Background
- [2]
[2] The parties were in a relationship for eighteen years but were never married. They have a 13-year-old child together (“the child”). The appellant in DCA 37/2018 and the respondent in DCA 38/2018 is the mother of the child (“the Mother”). The appellant in DCA 38/2018 and the respondent in DCA 37/2018 is the father of the child (“the Father”).
- [3]
[3] The Father is an Australian citizen and a Singapore Permanent Resident. The Mother is a Japanese citizen. The child has dual Australian and Japanese citizenship.
- [4]
[4] The parties and the child lived in Singapore as a family from 2007 to December 2014. During that time, the Father was responsible for all household expenses, including the expenses of the Mother and the child. The Mother was a full-time caregiver for the child.
- [5]
[5] In December 2014, the Mother and the child moved to Japan where the child enrolled in an international school. The Father remained in Singapore. The reasons for the move were in dispute. The relationship between the parties began to fracture in 2015 and there were issues over financial matters. On 28 December 2015, when the Mother and the child were still in Japan, the Mother filed the first maintenance application, MSS 5536/2015, for maintenance on behalf of the child. On 8 March 2016, the Father filed OSG 40/2016 for the return of the child to Singapore.
- [6]
[6] The Mother withdrew MSS 5536/2015 on 14 February 2017 on the first scheduled hearing day of the maintenance proceedings. The reasons for the withdrawal were in dispute. However, there is no dispute that the Father transferred a total sum of $36,766.03 to the Mother on 6, 7 and 8 January 2017, after he was served with the first maintenance application.
- [8]
[8] The Mother filed the present maintenance application, MSS 801386/2017, on 14 October 2017.
The parties’ cases
- [9]
[9] The Mother was represented by counsel at the trial below while the Father appeared in person. Both parties tendered written submissions in these appeals and both appeared in person at the hearing before me.
The Mother’s case
- [10]
[10] In MSS 801386/2017, the Mother claimed that the Father neglected or refused to provide reasonable maintenance for the child. Although her initial claim was for maintenance from January 2017 onwards, she confirmed at the hearing before the DJ that her claim related to maintenance for the child from 1 July 2017 onwards, after their return to Singapore.
- [11]
[11] The Mother alleged that the Father had stopped all payment for the child’s maintenance after December 2016 and that he only made a one-time payment of $7,500 in August 2017 after the court encouraged him to do so.
- [13]
[13] The Mother submitted that she could not afford to maintain the child as her inheritance moneys should not be taken into consideration in calculating her income, which was negligible.
- [14]
[14] The Mother also submitted that the child’s expenses should include an additional insurance policy. However, at the hearing, she conceded that she was not challenging the DJ’s calculation of expenses. I will not consider this issue in reaching my decision.
The Father’s case
- [16]
[16] Specifically, the Father pointed to payments he made to the Mother totalling $174,180.07 from November 2014 to November 2017. He submitted that the DJ erred in finding that these were used to pay for “extraordinary expenses” as the Mother failed to provide any evidence of the said expenses. He alleged that since the disputes arose in 2015, the Mother has not provided him with any details of the child’s expenses.
Decision below
- [19]
[19] The DJ first assessed the quantum of reasonable maintenance for the child that the Father should bear from 1 July 2017 onwards because it was necessary to determine whether there was any neglect to provide maintenance. The DJ considered two distinct periods – the first from 1 July 2017 to November 2017, when the child was not enrolled in school, and the second from December 2017 onwards, when the child was enrolled in school.
- [20]
[20] In respect of the first period from 1 July 2017 to November 2017, the DJ found that the child’s reasonable monthly expenses were $2,842. In respect of the period from December 2017 onwards, the DJ held that the child’s reasonable monthly expenses were $6,857 including school fees.
- [21]
[21] In light of the parties’ incomes, the DJ held that the Father should bear 85% of the child’s reasonable expenses. This was $2,450 per month from July to November 2017 and $2,200 per month from December 2017 onwards. The latter figure was obtained by taking 85% of the child’s reasonable monthly expenses of $6,857 and deducting the school fees and school-related expenses that the Father paid directly to the service provider. The DJ also held that the Father should pay for 85% of the one-off expenses that the Mother incurred when returning to Singapore with the child.
- [22]
[22] With these figures, the DJ then considered the preliminary question of whether the Father had neglected to provide reasonable maintenance. He accepted the Mother’s submission that the money that the Father transferred to her before 2017 was not meant merely for the child’s expenses, and the Mother had spent it on “extraordinary expenses.” He reached this conclusion on the basis that any payments made when the Mother and child were still in Japan would have been meant for the Mother as well, as the Father used to provide for her when they were in a relationship. Some expenses would also have been incurred when the Mother and child moved to Japan to set up home there. The DJ also found that the Father had not adduced any credible evidence to support his claim that the payments were meant for the child only, and concluded that it was an afterthought. Having excluded the earlier sums, the DJ found that the Father only paid a sum of $7,500 in 2017 and 2018 and had also stopped topping up the child’s school lunch card. He concluded that the Father had neglected or failed to provide reasonable maintenance for the child.
Summons to adduce fresh evidence
- [25]
[25] Since the decision below, parties have initiated separate custody and committal proceedings in the lower courts. Both parties filed summonses for leave to adduce fresh evidence in this appeal.
- [27]
[27] On 11 April 2019, the Mother wrote to the court with further submissions and requests. As no leave was granted by the court for any further submissions or evidence, I did not consider them in reaching my decision.
The issue in the present case
- [28]
[28] Section 69(2) and (4) of the WC provides:
…
- [29]
[29] The Mother argued that the Father ought to bear 100% of the child’s reasonable expenses as well as the Mother’s share of accommodation expenses. The Father argued that he had not neglected or refused to provide reasonable maintenance for the child. The burden of proof is on the party claiming maintenance to provide proof that the other party has neglected or refused to provide reasonable maintenance. To determine whether that burden has been met, it is first necessary to determine what “reasonable maintenance for his child” is on the facts of the case. After determining what the quantum of reasonable maintenance is, the next step is to determine whether the Father had indeed provided, or had neglected or refused to provide, such reasonable maintenance. I will discuss the issues below in two main sections: first, what is reasonable maintenance in the present case and second, whether there was neglect or refusal to provide reasonable maintenance.
What is reasonable maintenance in the present case
- [30]
[30] The DJ first calculated the child’s reasonable monthly expenses, then assessed the proportion that the Father ought to bear as reasonable monthly maintenance. He concluded that the Father ought to bear 85% of the child’s expenses.
- [32]
[32] The Mother repeatedly stated that at the hearing of OSG 40/2016, the Father assured the court that he would provide for all of the child’s expenses when the child returned to Singapore. According to her, the court was therefore misled or induced into ordering the return of the child to Singapore.
- [35]
[35] I add that I do not think any of the statements that the Mother points to can be taken as assurances that the Father agreed to bear all of the child’s expenses. The Mother’s submissions that the Father had given an undertaking or should be estopped from refusing to pay all of the child’s expenses has no basis.
- [36]
[36] As to the reasonable maintenance that parents must provide, the law is clear – both parents are equally responsible for providing for their children, but their precise obligations may differ depending on their means and capabilities (see AUA v ATZ [2016] 4 SLR 674 at [41]). I do not find that the DJ erred in calculating the proportions of both parties’ income on the evidence that was before him and relying on that to calculate their share of expenses. In the present circumstances, there is no basis for ordering the Father to bear all of the child’s expenses.
- [37]
[37] It is undisputed that when the parties were living together, the Father supported the Mother and the child. During the hearing and in her affidavits, the Mother made several references to the length of their relationship, which she submitted would qualify as a common law marriage in other jurisdictions. However, as the Mother herself admitted, these relationships are not recognised as marriages in Singapore. There is no basis for the Father to provide maintenance for the Mother as she is not a wife under s 69(1) of the WC or an ex-wife under s 113 of the WC. The Mother accepted this legal position, and did not seek maintenance on this basis.
- [38]
[38] Instead, the Mother relied on alleged assurances or undertakings that the Father made to the court in OSG 40/2016 that he would take care of the Mother’s accommodation. She therefore submitted that the Father should cover her share of rental, which is $1,950 by the DJ’s calculations.
- [39]
[39] As stated above, these alleged assurances had no impact on the court’s decision in OSG 40/2016. Further, I do not accept that the Father made any assurances that he would provide for the Mother’s expenses. The only evidence that the Mother pointed to indicated that he was at most willing to discuss some assistance for the sake of the child.
- [41]
[41] I do not think the DJ had erred in his finding on the quantum of reasonable maintenance that the Father ought to provide. I now consider the Father’s submission that he never refused or neglected to provide this sum.
Whether there was neglect or refusal to provide reasonable maintenance
Legal principles
- [44]
[44] Where one party takes out maintenance proceedings against another, it is easy to assume that there has been a neglect or refusal as the matter has escalated to the court. However, the burden is on the complainant to satisfy the court that the respondent has “neglected or refused to provide reasonable maintenance for his child”. This is a legal requirement in s 69(2).
- [45]
[45] In determining whether the legal threshold is satisfied, the court will assess what is “reasonable maintenance” as a monetary sum on the facts of the case, and will take a practical approach to assess whether the parties have reasonably provided such maintenance. Cooperating reasonably as parents is part of parental responsibility whether or not the parents are married or divorced, or were never married.
Reasonableness of the expenses
- [46]
[46] The court can consider “reasonableness” in several ways. First, the court can consider the reasonableness of the expenses in question. This goes towards the quantum of maintenance that the court considers reasonable on the specific facts of the case. Not all expenses are reasonable and the non-payment of such expenses is not conduct envisaged in s 69(2).
Reasonableness in communication of child’s expenses
- [48]
[48] Second, the court can also consider whether one party reasonably communicated the child’s needs or expenses to the other party. To find neglect or refusal to provide maintenance, the alleged non-paying party must be aware or ought to have been aware of the child’s needs or expenses. A parent ought to be aware that provision for basic needs would be required, whether or not a specific request for basic needs has been made. But where expenses are incurred for items beyond the usual necessities, it may not be reasonable to expect the parent to pay an undefined and unlimited amount at any time when no or little information is provided, for the purposes of finding neglect or refusal in s 69(2). The precise facts and circumstances of the case must be considered in assessing the matter.
Reasonableness of mode of provision
- [49]
[49] Third, the court can consider whether the paying party used a reasonable mode of provision of maintenance. An example of a reasonable mode of provision is giving direct access to funds in a bank account or a credit card.
- [50]
[50] Where the mode of provision is less than reasonable, the court may find that there is neglect or refusal to provide. For example, a paying party who insists on providing maintenance only on a reimbursement basis, requiring copies of every receipt, even for mundane recurring expenses, may not be providing maintenance in a reasonable way. A paying party who only provides reimbursement one year after the expenses are incurred may also be said to have failed to provide in a reasonable way. The court will consider all the facts and circumstances in making such assessments.
Application of legal principles to the present facts
- [51]
[51] In the present case, the relevant time period for assessing a refusal or neglect to pay is from 1 July 2017 onwards, as that is the Mother’s claim. While the exact time period may not be an issue in most maintenance cases, it is relevant here because the Father alleged that he had overpaid the Mother in previous months due to the Mother’s failure to inform him of the child’s exact expenses.
- [52]
[52] The question before me was whether there was any refusal or neglect by the Father to provide reasonable maintenance for the child at the time the Mother filed MSS 801386/2017 on 14 October 2017.
Reasonableness of the expenses in present case
- [53]
[53] I have dealt with the question of the reasonableness of the expenses in the present case in [30] to [41] above.
Reasonableness in communication to the Father in present case
- [54]
[54] The DJ found that the Mother made repeated requests for money for the child, but this occurred in 2015, when the Mother was still in Japan. While that may have been the parties’ approach to finances at the time, this was prior to the Father’s transfer of large sums in January 2016. The Mother should not be able to rely on those requests.
- [55]
[55] Instead, it is clear that subsequent to those requests, the Father transferred large sums of money to the Mother at irregular intervals. There is no evidence that the Mother made any further reasonable attempt to seek maintenance from the Father on behalf of the child. The Father’s complaint was that the Mother never communicated any specific needs to him and he had to estimate the child’s reasonable expenses, which was difficult as they were in separate countries and their relationship had deteriorated.
- [56]
[56] After their return, the Father alleged that the Mother still failed to inform him of the child’s expenses. On 21 September 2017, the Father wrote to the Mother’s counsel stating the following:
- [57]
[57] The Mother’s counsel responded later that same day stating, “We will take our client’s instructions on the same, and revert shortly.” The Father submitted that there was no response after this, and indeed there is no evidence that the Mother’s solicitors “reverted”. Instead, on 14 October 2017, the Mother filed the present maintenance application.
- [58]
[58] When asked, the Mother did not tender evidence of any requests for payment. She pointed to a text message conversation on 15 June 2017 where the Father refused to pay the $10,000 administrative fee required to enrol the child in school. The Father explained that he had paid the $10,000 fee, but it had been forfeited because of alleged delay on the Mother’s part. As discussed, the touchstone for the conduct of the parties is reasonableness. In these circumstances, I do not think that this incident constituted unreasonable conduct sufficient to demonstrate a neglect or refusal to provide reasonable maintenance.
- [59]
[59] The Mother also relied on affidavits filed in the course of the other proceedings between the parties to argue that the Father was aware of the child’s expenses. I do not think these affidavits, whether in the present proceedings or related ones, demonstrate neglect. The Mother has to communicate the child’s needs and expenses reasonably. The Father has to have an opportunity to provide reasonable maintenance before the matter is escalated to court. Regardless of how extensive court proceedings are, I do not think the request should be found only in an affidavit.
- [60]
[60] I find that despite the Father’s requests, the Mother did not provide any information on the child’s expenses before commencing the maintenance application. The Father had tried to discuss child support but the Mother was not cooperative in that respect. This occurred after he had transferred a substantial sum of money to her in 2015 and 2016, and his evidence is that he had overpaid in those months because he had not been informed of and had no way of knowing the child’s reasonable expenses.
Reasonableness of mode of provision in the present case
- [62]
[62] It is not disputed that the Father only made a single transfer of $7,500 from January 2017 to April 2018. As the Father asserts that he had provided reasonable maintenance for the child because he had “overpaid” in earlier months, his earlier payments will now be considered.
- [63]
[63] The Father made the following payments to the Mother from November 2014 to August 2017:
- [64]
[64] The DJ found that it was more likely than not that payments made to the Mother up to 2016 were made for both the Mother and the child’s expenses and other “extraordinary expenses”. He made this finding based on the fact that the Father used to support both the Mother and the child, and the Father and Mother only ended their relationship sometime in end-2015. He also found that the Mother and child likely incurred extra expenses setting up a new home in Japan.
- [65]
[65] I do not see a reason to disturb the DJ’s finding on when the parties ended their relationship, and that any payments made in 2015 should be disregarded as it would have been used to support both the Mother and child. I also agree that the Mother and child would have incurred larger expenses in 2015 when setting up a new home in Japan. However, I do not think that the 2016 payments should be disregarded. The Mother admitted that the payments made in January 2016 were a direct result of the first maintenance application filed in December 2015, which had been served on the Father the day before. By then, the relationship between the parties had deteriorated and I find that it is more likely than not that the January 2016 payments and subsequent payments were meant solely for the child, perhaps to stave off further maintenance applications.
- [66]
[66] The Father paid a total of $99,728.31 to the Mother from January 2016 to August 2017. Considering the period up to 14 October 2017 (the date of filing of MSS 801386/2017), which was a period of around 22 months, the sum paid works out to a provision of $4,533 a month. This would work out to $15,865 in total for the period of 1 July 2017 to 14 October 2017. On the basis of the DJ’s findings on reasonable maintenance, including his findings on rental and one-off expenses, the Father would have had to pay $11,187.11 during that same period. The Father had provided at least that sum as at 14 October 2017.
- [67]
[67] The DJ held that the Father failed to adduce credible evidence, such as contemporaneous messages, to support his claim that the payments were meant solely for the child. However, the burden of proof is on the Mother, as the complainant, to prove that the Father had refused or neglected to provide reasonable maintenance. As it is undisputed that the Father did pay these amounts, if the Mother asserts that there was an agreement that the money was also for her expenses or valid extraordinary expenses, the burden is on her to bring the evidence before the court.
- [68]
[68] The DJ found that the Father unilaterally stopped certain payments such as topping up the child’s school lunch card. This occurred after the maintenance application was filed on 14 October 2017, and is not helpful in determining whether the father had neglected or refused to provide maintenance at the time the suit was filed.
Decision
- [69]
[69] The present case presents unique circumstances. The parties were not married and lived in separate countries for over two years before the total breakdown of their relationship. By 1 July 2017, the parties were deeply entrenched in litigation. I accept that it may have been challenging by then for the Mother to request payment, and it is possible that the Father would have refused to pay. However, by refusing to communicate with the Father or make any request for payment, the Mother did not act reasonably. The Father cannot be faulted when the Mother did not reasonably communicate the child’s needs to him under the circumstances. During the relevant period, the Father paid for all accommodation, utilities, and expenses during the three days a week that the child stayed with him. It is possible that, absent a specific request for payment, he had assumed the earlier payments and these provisions were sufficient maintenance.
- [70]
[70] As such, the Mother has failed to show due proof that the Father had neglected or refused to provide reasonable maintenance for the child, and the threshold requirement in s 69(2) has not been met.
Best interests of the child
Conclusion
- [74]
[74] I allow the Father’s appeal in DCA 38/2018 and I dismiss the Mother’s appeal in DCA 37/2018.
- [76]
[76] I urge the Mother to act reasonably in seeking provision for the child, by making reasonable requests to the Father and providing details of the child’s expenses where appropriate. The parties, as parents, should cooperate to provide the best for the child.
Costs