Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 17 Apr 2019

Family Division of the High Court

UNE v UNF

Feedback & support

[2019] SGHCF 9Case no. Divorce (Transferred) No 1855 of 20169 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. [3] In PT Sandipala Arthaputra v STMicroelectronics Asia Pacific Pte Ltd [2018] 4 SLR 828, the High Court observed that:

  2. [4] In Mok Kah Hong v Zheng Zhuan Yao [2016] 3 SLR 1 (“Mok Kah Hong”), the Court of Appeal held that:

  3. Application to the present case

  4. What exactly does the Order require the Husband to do?

  5. Context of the Order in question

  6. Stipulated time frame

  7. [11] In the present case, the Wife had earlier sought in SUM 301/2018 a prayer, amongst other prayers, that:

  8. Mode of compliance

  9. [13] I note the letter dated 3 December 2018 from the Wife’s solicitors which records that when the Wife “visited the Toh Crescent property today to retrieve her photograph album, she was appalled to discover that the property was in complete shambles” and that the Wife “was unable to find the photograph album at the location which she recalled last having left it”. I must add my observation that I find this entire letter rather inflammatory. This letter confirms that there is no dispute that by 3 December 2018, the Wife had been given access to the Toh Crescent property to collect the Items.

  10. [14] Given that the Wife had been given access to the property by 3 December 2018, I asked the Wife’s counsel at the hearing what the alleged non-compliance was in the context of this committal action. I noted that in committal proceedings, a court may even allow the alleged contemnor more time to purge his contempt. I asked if her case was that the Husband had deliberately hidden or disposed of the Items before giving her access on 3 December 2018.

  11. [15] The Wife argues in written submissions filed after the hearing that:

  12. [17] The Husband deposed that he had given the Wife the keys to the Toh Crescent property and that she did enter the property on 3 December 2018. He stated that he had asked his daughter about the Items as she had helped to pack and collate the Wife’s items in the matrimonial home. He also stated that he understood that their daughter did come across some items she identified as belonging to the Wife, including a yellow photo album. However, as she was aware of neither the updated divorce proceedings nor the Wife’s specific wish to keep the photo album, she then disposed of some of the Wife’s belongings, including the album. In court, the Husband reiterated that he did not want to involve his children in the divorce proceedings, which have hurt them.

  13. Decision

  14. [21] I am aware that the divorce has deeply affected the Wife. I add for context that at the AM hearing, the Wife submitted that the marriage certificate is a matrimonial asset and sought to have the marriage certificate awarded to her, because she submitted that receiving it would assist her in recovering from the trauma of the failed marriage. I held that the marriage certificate is not a matrimonial asset and made no orders with respect to it. I added that the matter on the marriage certificate should not be a cause for further acrimony between the parties. I had also hoped that the matter of the Items would not be yet another matter causing further issues, and as the Husband had no objections to the Wife retrieving all her personal items including the Items, her request was included in the AM Orders.

  15. [23] SUM 391/2018 is dismissed.