Family Division of the High Court · Decided 13 February 2020
VGI v VGJ
Feedback & support[2020] SGHCF 5 · Case no. Registrar’s Appeal No 53 of 2019 · 4 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
- [2]
[2] The Plaintiff had lodged a caveat against any grant of probate in respect of a deceased person’s estate on the basis that he is the said deceased’s brother. The Defendant, who is the brother of the deceased’s late wife, subsequently sought a grant of probate based on a will (“Will”) which named him as the executor. The Plaintiff thereafter issued a writ seeking, inter alia, a declaration that the Will is invalid and that the deceased had died intestate.
- [4]
[4] The Plaintiff argues that he is not in the position of a plaintiff as he is merely a caveator and not the party who wishes to propound the Will to obtain a grant of probate. He submits that the Defendant, by having the burden to prove that the Will is valid, is in the position of the plaintiff.
Analysis
- [8]
[8] The Defendant on the other hand submits that those two old English cases can be distinguished from the present case on the basis that the caveator there did not institute proceedings and was not the plaintiff or substantively the “mover” or “actor” in the proceedings. Further, he submits that the relevant probate rules have since changed. The later provisions expand the purpose of a caveat to include the showing of cause against the grant, while the rules prevailing at the time of the two cases were narrower.
- [10]
[10] The cited English cases of Re Emery and Rose v Epstein are not inconsistent with my views. The English cases interpret the effect of a caveat to be a notice to the Registrar rather than an act to commence proceedings, at least based on English law at that time. Even today, a caveator who only seeks to ensure that the applicant proves the will in solemn form or intends to cross-examine witnesses produced in support of the Will will not be similarly treated as a plaintiff for purposes of r 459 of the FJR. Thus not every caveator is treated as the plaintiff for the purposes of the aforementioned provision. A caveat is a notice to the court not to proceed with the grant of probate until the caveat is addressed. Whether a person who begins involvement as a caveator is in the position of the plaintiff depends on what the substantive effect of his acts are and not merely the fact that he had lodged a caveat earlier. The cases of Re Emery and Rose v Epstein should be understood in this light and on their own facts and the prevailing law then.
Decision