Family Division of the High Court · Decided 4 January 2021
VNW v VNX
Feedback & support[2021] SGHCF 1 · Case no. Divorce (Transferred) No 5670 of 2018 · 111 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [1]
[1] The plaintiff (“the Wife”) and the defendant (“the Husband”) appeared before me in relation to ancillary matters following their divorce. Part of their dispute with respect to these matters was settled by consent while I made orders relating to the maintenance of the child and the plaintiff and the division of matrimonial assets. I set out below the grounds for my decision.
Background
- [2]
[2] The Husband and the Wife, who are citizens of the United Kingdom and permanent residents of Singapore and Australia, registered their marriage in Singapore in December 2006. The parties have two children, a son, aged 17, and a daughter, aged 13.
- [3]
[3] The marriage lasted 12 years and 2 months. During this period, the parties lived in Singapore from March 2006 to November 2011, Australia from November 2011 to September 2014 and Japan from September 2014 to November 2016. They returned to Singapore in November 2016.
- [4]
[4] The Wife, who accused the Husband of being unfaithful to her, filed for divorce in December 2018. The Husband did not file a Defence or Counterclaim. Interim judgment was granted on 20 February 2019 on the basis of the Wife’s claim that the marriage had irretrievably broken down as the Husband had behaved in such a way that she cannot reasonably be expected to live with him.
- [5]
[5] After the interim judgment, the parties attended the Child Focused Resolution Centre (“CFRC”) programme for divorcing parents as the law requires such parents with at least one child below the age of 21 years to participate in the said programme of counselling and mediation as part of the divorce proceedings. After participating in the programme, the parties resolved the issues of custody, care and control and access in relation to the children by themselves.
The hearing of the ancillary matters.
- [7]
[7] For the purpose of the ancillary hearing, the parties filed a number of affidavits. The Wife filed her first Affidavit of Assets and Means (“WA1”) on 5 August 2019 and her second Affidavit of Assets and Means (“WA2”) on 26 June 2020. As for the Husband, he filed his first Affidavit of Assets and Means (“HA1”) on 26 July 2019 and his second Affidavit of Assets and Means (“HA2”) on 19 June 2020.
- [8]
[8] The issues that were before the court in relation to ancillary matters were as follows:
(a) the operative date for determining the pool of matrimonial assets;
(b) the operative date for valuing the pool of matrimonial assets;
(c) the just and equitable division of the matrimonial assets;
(d) maintenance for the Wife; and
(e) maintenance for the children.
- [9]
[9] At the hearing of the ancillary matters on 21 September 2020, the parties agreed that their matrimonial assets should be divided equally and that the date for ascertaining what is in the pool of matrimonial assets should be the date of interim judgment.
- [10]
[10] It was further agreed between the parties that the date for determining the amount in the bank accounts forming part of the matrimonial assets will be the date of interim judgment, namely, 20 February 2019, and that the date for determining the value of other matrimonial assets will be the date of the hearing of the ancillary matters, which is 21 September 2020.
- [11]
[11] Finally, it was common ground that in relation to matrimonial assets with values expressed in foreign currency, the exchange rate for conversion of the foreign currency to Singapore dollars will be the rate on 21 September 2020.
- [12]
[12] As the parties reached agreement on the above-mentioned matters, the only matters left to be determined concerned what is to be included in or excluded from the pool of matrimonial assets, the monthly maintenance for the Wife and the monthly maintenance for the two children.
The pool of matrimonial assets
- [13]
[13] As for what is to be included in or excluded from the pool of matrimonial assets, section 112(10) of the Women’s Charter (Cap 353, 2009 Rev Ed) (“Women’s Charter”) defines a “matrimonial asset” as follows:
(b) any other asset of any nature acquired during the marriage by one party or both parties to the marriage,
- [14]
[14] In relation to the burden of proof as to whether a property is or is not a matrimonial asset, in USB v USA and another appeal [2020] SGCA 57, the Court of Appeal stated (at [31]-[32]):
- [15]
[15] In the present case, the Wife lambasted the Husband for failing to fully and frankly disclose his assets in his affidavits. She also complained that instead of stating his position in his affidavits, the Husband had, in the Joint Summary of the respective positions of the parties as at 6 August 2020 (the “Joint Summary”), attempted to adduce new evidence and raise issues and allegations for the first time without supporting documentary evidence. She contended that this attempt to raise new issues and allegations after all affidavits in relation to ancillary matters had been filed cannot be countenanced as the Joint Summary contains the lawyers’ submissions on the parties’ respective positions as at 6 August 2020 and not the evidence of the parties. Furthermore, the Wife has not had the opportunity to respond to the allegations in the Joint Summary.
- [16]
[16] The Husband retorted that he had tried to be co-operative with respect to the ancillary matters but he suffered from depression during the divorce proceedings and found it difficult to look at his solicitors’ e-mails or reply to them in a timely manner.
- [17]
[17] For convenience, what was included in or excluded from the parties’ pool of matrimonial assets will be considered in the sequence in which the parties’ assets were listed in the Joint Summary.
Items 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 of Joint Summary - Joint Bank accounts
- [18]
[18] Items 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 of the Joint Summary concern a number of bank accounts held in the parties’ joint names. These are as follows:
(a) a joint savings account with DBS with a balance of S$527.98;
(b) a joint savings account with POSB with a balance of S$8,163.62;
(c) a joint account with Commonwealth Bank with a balance of AUD10,119.26; and
(d) two joint foreign currency accounts with Commonwealth Bank with no money in the accounts.
- [19]
[19] As it was accepted by the parties that the funds in the above-mentioned bank accounts are matrimonial assets, the said funds were included in the pool of matrimonial assets.
Item 6 of Joint Summary –Husband’s Australian property
- [20]
[20] Item 6 of the Joint Summary concerns a property at Harbour Road, Queensland, Australia, (the “Queensland property”), which is in the Husband’s sole name.
- [21]
[21] The gross value of the Queensland property, which was purchased in 2012 for AUD840,000, was estimated at AUD765,000 as at 15 January 2018. There is an outstanding mortgage on the said property, which the Husband estimates to be more than AUD605,000.
- [22]
[22] Initially, the Husband was willing to have this property sold and the net sale proceeds divided equally with the Wife. However, he subsequently decided to keep this property in Queensland for himself.
Item 7 of Joint Summary – Husband’s property in Liverpool
- [24]
[24] Item 7 of the Joint Summary concerns an apartment in Henry Street, Liverpool, United Kingdom, an apartment which is in the Husband’s sole name (the “Liverpool apartment”). The Husband claimed that the Liverpool apartment was purchased by him in 2005 for GBP160,000.
- [25]
[25] In HA1, the Husband proposed (at para 21) that the Liverpool apartment be sold and that the net sales proceeds after paying the outstanding mortgage and expenses of the sale be shared equally between the parties.
- [26]
[26] At the hearing of the ancillary matters, the Husband changed his position and his counsel claimed that the Liverpool property is not a matrimonial asset as it was purchased before the marriage. The Wife contended that this assertion, which was not made in HA1 or HA2, was not supported by any documentary evidence and was first made in the Joint Summary, which is not the parties’ evidence. To be fair to the Husband, he did assert in HA1 (at para 18) that the property was purchased in 2005, which was before the parties’ marriage in 2006. However, there was no documentary evidence to support this assertion.
- [27]
[27] As it turned out, there was no need to consider whether or not this property was acquired before the marriage for the simple reason that after taking into account the outstanding mortgage on the property, there was nothing left to be divided between the parties. As such, the parties accepted that this property need not be considered any further for the purpose of division of matrimonial assets.
Item 8 of Joint Summary – Husband’s property in Cheshire
- [28]
[28] Item 8 of the Joint Summary relates to a property owned by the Husband in Warrington, Cheshire, United Kingdom (the “Cheshire property”).
- [29]
[29] The Husband stated in HA1 (at para 21) that he was prepared to have the Cheshire property sold and the net proceeds of sale after payment of the outstanding mortgage and expenses of the sale divided equally between the parties. He subsequently claimed at the hearing that the Cheshire property was acquired before the marriage and should not be included in the pool of matrimonial assets. The Wife contended that this assertion was not made in HA1 or HA2 and it first surfaced in the Joint Summary, which is not evidence of his claim that this asset was acquired before the marriage. Again, to be fair to the Husband, he did assert in HA1 (at para 18) that the property was purchased for GBP135,000 in 2005 before the parties’ marriage although no documentary evidence was adduced to back up this assertion.
- [30]
[30] As with the case of the Liverpool property, it was clear that after taking into account the outstanding mortgage on the property, there was nothing left to be divided between the parties if the property is sold. As such, the parties accepted that there was no need to consider the Cheshire property any further for the purpose of division of matrimonial property.
Item 9 of Joint Summary - Husband’s Volkswagen car
- [31]
[31] Item 9 in the Joint Summary concerns a Volkswagen Scirocco bearing number SLE 4130M (“the Volkswagen”), which was purchased for S$30,000 on 4 June 2018, while the parties were still married. According to the Husband, the money for the car was withdrawn from the parties’ joint POSB savings account.
- [32]
[32] Less than two months after the date of the interim judgment, the Volkswagen was sold on 12 April 2019 for S$15,900. The Wife alleged that the Husband has not accounted for the sale proceeds. The Husband claimed that he has used the proceeds of sale for his living expenses, the children’s living expenses and put some of the money in his business (“Source Bulk Food”).
Item 10 of Joint Summary – Husband’s BMW Coupe
- [34]
[34] Item 10 of the Joint Summary concerns the second vehicle owned by the Husband, a BMW coupe M3 series Coupe (“the BMW”) bearing number SMC 108D.
- [35]
[35] The Wife complained that the Husband had lied that the BMW was his friend’s car. As the Husband did not disclose that he owned this car in HA1, the Wife asked the Husband to provide information on the purchase price of the car, the source of funds for the purchase and the current value of the car. In his reply, the Husband merely said that the car was purchased after the grant of the Interim Judgment on 20 February 2019 and was thus not a matrimonial asset. When pressed further in the Wife’s Second Request for Interrogatories, the Husband responded by saying that he was in the process of obtaining the documents in question. However, he failed to provide the said documents.
- [37]
[37] Regrettably, despite the direction of the Assistant Registrar, the Husband did not provide any documentary evidence relating to the source of funds for the purchase of the BMW. Although he claimed to have taken a loan for the purchase of the BMW and to have repaid the loan, he furnished no evidence of the alleged loan. As there was nothing to indicate that the Husband had in fact obtained a loan for the purchase of the BMW on 12 April 2019, a question arises as to where the funds for the purchase of this car came from.
Item 11 of Joint Summary - Husband’s Australian insurance policy
- [39]
[39] Item 11 of the Joint Summary concerns the Husband’s Australian Super Income Protection Insurance.
- [40]
[40] Both parties agreed that this policy, which has a value of AUD121,046.66 is a matrimonial asset. As such, this amount was added to the pool of matrimonial assets.
Item 12 of Joint Summary – Husband’s Microsoft Corporation Employment Stock Purchase Plan
- [41]
[41] The Husband, who worked for Microsoft Operations Pte Ltd from 12 November 2016 to December 2018, accumulated a large number of stocks in the Microsoft Corporation Employment Stock Purchase Plan (“ESPP”).
Item 13 of Joint Summary – Annual Microsoft Stock Awards
- [43]
[43] Item 13 of the Joint Summary relates to the Husband’s Annual Microsoft Stock and Leadership Awards (“Annual Microsoft Stocks”). Whether there are such stocks in the Husband’s hands is a bone of contention in these proceedings.
- [44]
[44] The Annual Microsoft Stocks were not disclosed by the Husband in HA1. According to him, he did not disclose these stocks because he does not own any such stocks. However, the Wife contended that when the Husband started work at Microsoft, he was granted stock awards, as indicated at paragraph 6 of his employment contract dated 1 October 2016, which was disclosed in HA1. The Wife also discovered documents indicating that the Husband was eligible for stock awards estimated at USD177,000 per year from Financial Year 2018. She pointed out that as the Husband was employed by Microsoft until March 2019, he would have been granted the said stock awards for Financial Year 2018. This was highlighted by the Wife in WA2 (at para 18]). Notably, the Husband did not file an affidavit to reply to this assertion. Instead, he claimed for the first time in the Joint Summary that the existence of these stocks is based on the Wife’s conjectures.
- [45]
[45] The Wife pointed out that the Husband could have written to Microsoft to confirm whether he held the stocks in question and he had more than a year to do this. However, he chose not to write to Microsoft and he remained silent in the face of her allegations and the documents produced by her. She thus invited the court to draw an adverse inference that the stocks exist and to add USD177,000 to the pool of matrimonial assets.
Item 14 of Joint Summary – Husband’s shares in Salesforce
- [47]
[47] Item 14 of the Joint Summary relates to the Husband’s Salesforce stocks. Whether or not the Husband holds any of these stocks was a hotly contested issue.
- [48]
[48] The Husband was employed by Salesforce Japan before he left this company for a position at Microsoft. While at Salesforce, he was eligible for the award of Salesforce stocks. The Salesforce stocks were not disclosed in HA1 and the exact type of the Husband’s stocks in Salesforce is not known.
- [49]
[49] In WA1, the Wife exhibited a note in the Husband’s handwriting that showed that the assets held by him in 2012-2014 included Salesforce stocks that were already vested in him. Notably, she also produced email correspondence between the Husband and Microsoft when he was negotiating his pay with his new employers that indicated that he was eligible for more Salesforce stocks.
- [50]
[50] In an email dated 1 September 2016, Microsoft asked the Husband to clarify the vesting schedule for his Salesforce Stocks and explain how USD1.1m worth of such stocks will vest in him over the next few years. In his reply in an email on 2 September 2016, the Husband provided Microsoft with a vesting schedule which showed that by February 2020, the full value of USD1,116,255 worth of Salesforce stocks would have been vested in him. The Husband also stated in the said email to Microsoft that he was still working on the “bonus amounts” and that “it may take a day or so to find the details”.
- [51]
[51] As the Husband did not disclose the Salesforce stocks in HA1, the Wife asked him in her first Request for Discovery dated 15 August 2019 to provide stock statements showing the balance and transactions for the Salesforce stocks from January 2014 to date.
- [52]
[52] The Husband responded that he would not provide the requested statements because these stocks were the same as those listed in the E*Trade Financial Employee Stock Plan 69456002 (“E*Trade stocks”), which were sold in April 2017 for USD1,094,539.18. He added that the proceeds of the sale of these stocks were deposited into the parties’ joint Commonwealth Bank Foreign Currency Account and that the Wife had already benefited from the sale of the Salesforce stocks.
- [53]
[53] The Wife submitted that the Husband’s contention that the Salesforce stocks are the same as the E*Trade stocks sold in 2017 that were sold for USD1,094,539.18 in 2017 is untrue for a number of reasons. To begin with, she pointed out that in 2017, the cumulative value of the Salesforce stocks already vested in the Husband was only around USD177,485 – USD321,640. According to the Husband’s own email dated 2 September 2016 to Microsoft, the Salesforce stocks were to be vested over four years from 2016 to 2020 and in 2017, the sale of the Salesforce stocks would not have yielded the amount received for the sale of the E*Trade stocks. This shows that the E*Trade Stocks, which were sold for more than USD1m in April 2017, were separate stocks and could not have been the Salesforce stocks which she was referring to.
- [54]
[54] The Husband undermined his position further by asserting in the Joint Summary that he had asked his former employers, Salesforce, to honour his right to the Salesforce stocks but this was not done. This assertion was not referred to in either of the Husband’s affidavits on the ancillary matters and the Joint Summary is not evidence as it merely contains a summary of the parties’ positions by their counsel. More importantly, the Husband’s claim that Salesforce did not honour their obligations in relation to the Salesforce stocks that should have been awarded to him contradicts his earlier assertion that these stocks are the same stocks as the E’trade Financial Employee Stock Plan 69456602, which were allegedly sold in April 2017 for more than USD1m. The Wife rightly pointed out that the Husband cannot argue that Salesforce had not honoured their commitment to him in relation to his Salesforce stocks and also contend that Salesforce stocks claimed by her as being part of the matrimonial assets were the same E*Trade stocks sold in 2017 for more than USD1m. She said that the Husband was in fact asserting that in 2017, he had sold Salesforce stocks that he now claimed that he did not own.
Item 15 of Joint Summary – Husband’s IBM shares
- [56]
[56] Item 15 of the Joint Summary concerns the Husband’s shares in the IBM Computershare Investors Service Programme (the “ISP shares”). In the context of other assets to be divided, the value of these shares is not significant.
- [57]
[57] The Wife placed the value of the ISP shares at around USD3,714.25 as at 19 February 2019. She contended that the Husband must have sold the ISP shares and has failed to account for the sale proceeds. According to the Husband, the shares were not sold and were transferred to the New York State Comptroller of Unclaimed Funds Account. He placed the value of the shares at USD3,287.12 as at 30 July 2020.
Item 16 of Joint Summary – Husband’s other IBM stocks
- [59]
[59] Item 16 of the Joint Summary relates to other IBM stocks in the Husband’s name (“other IBM stocks”), which were valued at USD15,540.41 as at June 2014.
- [60]
[60] The Husband’s position was that the other IBM stocks were sold in 2014 and the proceeds of sale were deposited into the parties’ joint bank account with the Wife’s knowledge. However, the Wife, who denies any knowledge of the depositing of the cheque into their joint account, exhibited documents from the New York State Office of the State Comptroller which showed that a small quantity of the shares was sold for USD72.25 in 2001 and a larger quantity of the same was sold in 2014 for USD15,468.16. The net sale proceeds for the two sales totalled USD15,540.41 and she wanted the Husband to account for the sale proceeds.
- [61]
[61] The sale of the shares took place many years ago and the money would have been spent rather than stashed away to avoid being added to the pool of matrimonial assets as the question of divorce did not arise in 2011 and 2014. I thus held that the sale proceeds of the other IBM stocks should not be added to the pool of matrimonial assets.
Item 17 of Joint Summary – Husband’s Commonwealth Bank account
- [62]
[62] Item 17 of the Joint Summary relates to the Husband’s Commonwealth Bank Smart Access account, which was disclosed in HA1. There is a large sum of AUD691,502.82 in this account as at 28 February 2019.
Item 18 of Joint Summary – Husband’s DBS Multiplier account
- [64]
[64] Item 18 of the Joint Summary deals with a DBS Multiplier account in the Husband’s sole name, which was disclosed in HA1. It was accepted that this account, which has a balance of S$120,740.01, is a matrimonial asset. In view of this, the balance in this account is to be added to the pool of matrimonial assets.
Item 19 of Joint Summary – Husband’s National Westminster account
- [65]
[65] Item 19 of the Joint Summary concerns the Husband’s National Westminster Bank. A bank statement disclosed by the Husband in HA1 showed that there was a sum of GPB3,405.34 in this account on 30 March 2019.
- [66]
[66] As the parties accepted that this account with the National Westminster Bank is a matrimonial asset, the balance in this account is to be added to the pool of matrimonial assets.
Item 20 of Joint Summary – Husband’s Japanese bank account
- [67]
[67] Item 20 of the Joint Summary deals with a comparatively smaller amount of money in SMBC (Prestia) Trust Bank, previously referred to as Citibank Japan. A transaction advice from the said bank, showed that there was a balance of JPY404,076 or around S$5,271.95 on 19 November 2016 in the account, which was, according to the Wife, used as their “daily joint account” while they were living in Japan.
- [68]
[68] In her first Request for Discovery dated 15 August 2019, the Wife asked the Husband to provide statements in relation to this Japanese account. He did not respond to this request or to a second Request for Discovery dated 13 January 2020 for the said statements.
Item 21 of Joint Summary – The Husband’s ING bank account
- [72]
[72] Item 21 of the Joint Summary concerns the Husband’s ING bank account, which has a balance of only AUD6.75 on 31 March 2019. The parties accepted that this small amount is be added to the pool of matrimonial assets.
Item 22 of Joint Summary – The Husband’s CPF account
- [73]
[73] Item 22 of the Joint Summary relates to the Husband’s Central Provident Fund account, which has a balance of S$328,672.12 on 23 July 2019. This sum comprises S$177,756.97 in the Ordinary account, S$55,042.76 in the Medisave account and S$95,872.39 in the Special account.
- [74]
[74] The parties accepted that the amount in the Husband’s CPF account should be included in the pool of matrimonial assets.
Item 23 of Joint Summary – The Husband’s Cap Gemini (UK) pension plan
- [75]
[75] Item 23 of the Joint Summary deals with the Husband’s Cap Gemini (UK) Pension Plan, which is worth GBP7,711.42 (“the Cap Gemini Plan”). The Husband did not disclose in HA1 that he had such a pension plan. As such, in her first Request for Interrogatories dated 15 August 2019, the Wife asked the Husband to provide the pension plan statements.
- [76]
[76] The Husband’s lawyers responded in a letter dated 18 November 2019 that the Cap Gemini Plan had been cashed out for GPB1,500 and that their client does not recall the whereabouts of the proceeds received. However, he did not furnish any documentary evidence of the cashing out or make any attempt to acquire such evidence by writing to the Pension Fund.
- [77]
[77] When the Assistant Registrar dealt with the Husband’s non-disclosures at a Case Conference on 14 February 2020, the latter belatedly agreed to make a formal request for documents relating to the pension plan, including those concerning the closure of the account. The documents produced by the Husband were not documents relating to the closing of the account. In fact, they showed that there were still funds in the said account. The cash values indicated were GBP3,374.88 with Equitable Life and GBP2,836.54 under a protected rights fund.
- [78]
[78] Although the Husband did not raise in earlier proceedings or in HA1 or HA2 that the Cap Gemini Plan was a pre-marital asset that should not be added to the pool of matrimonial assets, the Husband’s counsel raised this matter for the first time in the Joint Summary, which, as stated before, is not the parties’ evidence on affidavit.
Item 24 of Joint Summary– Husband’s Allied Dunbar (Zurich Assurance) pension plan
- [80]
[80] Item 24 of the Joint Summary concerns the Husband’s Allied Dunbar (Zurich Assurance) pension plan bearing the number P31322-01J-PB-PO1 (“the Allied pension plan”), which was not disclosed by him in HA1. In WA1, the Wife exhibited documents which showed that this pension plan has a transfer value of around GBP111,000 in January 2020.
- [81]
[81] In her first Request for Discovery stated 15 August 2019, the Wife requested the Husband to provide the Allied pension plan statements. The Husband’s lawyers replied on 18 November 2019 that the pension plan had been cashed out and that their client could not recall the whereabouts of the proceeds of the pension plan received by him.
- [82]
[82] When the Assistant Registrar dealt with the Husband’s non-disclosures during a Case Conference on 14 February 2020, the Husband finally agreed to make a formal request for documents relating to the Allied pension plan. However, the correspondence between the Husband and Allied Dunbar (Zurich Insurance) provided information regarding another policy that had nothing to do with the Allied pension plan. Instead, the documents concerned another policy - an Allied Dunbar/Zurich Assurance Lifestyle Plan (bearing registration number 000654-11S-DHF) in the joint names of both parties and without any cash value.
- [84]
[84] In the Joint Statement, the Husband’s counsel pointed out that this pension plan is a pre-marital asset and is, as such, not a matrimonial property. However, the Wife pointed out that this assertion was not made by the Husband in HA1 or HA2. In view of this, the Wife contended that the assertion in the Joint Statement that this is a pre-marital asset should be disregarded. She urged the court to draw an adverse inference against the Husband for his failure to make full and frank disclosure of the said pension plan. The Husband has himself to blame for not failing to make full and frank disclosure of the Allied pension plan and raising the issue of a pre-marital asset without any affidavit evidence. In any case, the Husband had also claimed that the Allied pension plan is actually a life policy in respect of which he has continued to pay premiums every month. If this is so, then the fact that premiums were paid during the marriage must be noted. As such, I included this pension plan in the matrimonial pool of assets.
Item 25 of Joint Summary – Husband’s SAP (UK) Ltd Group pension plan
- [85]
[85] Item 25 of the Joint Summary deals with the Husband’s SAP(UK) Ltd Group Personal Pension Plan (“the SAP Pension”), which was not disclosed by him in HA1 or HA2. It was only upon the Wife’s first Request for Discovery dated 15 August 2019 that he provided a copy of this pension plan which has a value of GBP60,078.22.
- [86]
[86] At the hearing of the ancillary matters, the Husband’s counsel asserted that the SAP Pension was purchased before the marriage and should not be included in the pool of matrimonial assets. However, this assertion was not made in either HA1 or HA2 and was made for the first time in the Joint Summary without any documentary evidence. The Wife’s counsel pointed out that this submission should be disregarded.
Item 26 of Joint Summary - Luminor watch
- [88]
[88] The subject matter of item 26 of the Joint Summary is a Luminor watch. The Wife contended that the Husband owns a Luminor watch that should be included in the pool of matrimonial assets. She exhibited a photograph of a Luminor watch and claimed that the Husband had said that he purchased the watch in November 2017. She also exhibited an online price quote of S$30,900 for the watch.
- [89]
[89] The Husband denies owning the said watch and said that the Wife’s assertion that he owns such a watch is based on her own conjectures. He pointed out that there is no evidence that he owns such a watch and that he does not appear in the photograph of the watch submitted by the Wife.
- [90]
[90] I held that it was not established that the Husband owns the watch in question and the value of the watch is not to be included in the pool of matrimonial assets.
Items 27-30 of Joint Summary – Husband’s art collection
- [91]
[91] Items 27, 28, 29 and 30 of the Joint Summary dealt with a few art works in the Husband’s possession.
- [92]
[92] The Wife alleged that the art works included two works by Anya Brock, four works by David Bromley and an art work by Ewa Bathelier. According to her, the Anya Brock’s art works are worth AUD7,600 while David Bromley’s works are worth AUD45,000 and the work by Ewa Bathelier is worth S$15,000. There were also other artwork which the Wife claims is worth at least S$550. In contrast, the Husband believes that the Anya Brock works have no value. He also said that the David Bromley artworks are imitations purchased for S$280 in December 2016. As for the Ewa Bathelier work, he said that this was also an imitation piece purchased from a painting wholesaler for only S$150. The Husband claims that all these pieces are of “no value any longer”.
- [93]
[93] The Wife complained that the Husband’s claim that the art works in question are of no value is not supported by any documentary evidence but she also did not furnish adequate evidence of the value of the said works.
- [94]
[94] As there was no proper evidence of the value of the art works by either party, it was not possible for the court to assess the value of these works for the purpose of determining the amount to be put into the matrimonial pool of assets.
Items 31, 32 and 33 of Joint Summary – Sums allegedly dissipated by the Husband in 2017 and 2018
- [95]
[95] Items 31, 32 and 33 of the Joint Summary relate to sums allegedly dissipated by the Husband. The Wife alleged that the Husband dissipated their matrimonial assets by withdrawing the following sums of money from their joint POSB account on the following dates:
(a) S$4,717.31 on 22 February 2017;
(b) S$15,000 on 2 November 2017;
(c) S$5,000 on 7 September 2018; and
(d) S$47,000 from March 2017 to October 2017.
- [96]
[96] The Wife also complained that the Husband dissipated their matrimonial assets when he made the following withdrawals from their Commonwealth Joint USD foreign currency account:
(a) USD35,000 on 20 November 2017;
(b) USD35,000 on 21 November 2017;
(c) USD24,500 on 22 November 2017.
(d) USD39,250 on 5 March 2018.
- [97]
[97] The Husband insisted that he had spent the money allegedly dissipated by him solely on the family and himself. He claims that the sums listed in (a), (b) and (c) of the above paragraph were withdrawn for payment of Australian income tax while the parties were living in Japan and that the Wife knew about the withdrawals. As for the sum in item (d) of the above paragraph, he claimed that the money was withdrawn to pay for income tax in Singapore while the parties were living in Japan.
- [98]
[98] The Husband also alleged that while the Wife complained about his expenditure, she also did what she accused him of doing when she withdrew S$90,000.00 from their joint POSB savings account on 2 October 2018 without consulting him.
- [99]
[99] Often enough, parties complain about withdrawals of funds by the other party during the marriage when the division of their matrimonial assets is being considered. It ought to be borne in mind that as a general rule, during a marriage, parties have no expectation that they will have to explain precise items of their expenditure and must produce balance sheets in relation to their expenditure.
- [102]
[102] I accept that it will not be just and equitable for the Husband to be required to return the allegedly dissipated sums to the matrimonial pool of assets. As such, the amounts in question were not added to the pool of matrimonial assets.
Item 34 of Joint Summary –Husband’s investment in Source Food franchise
- [103]
[103] Item 34 of the Joint Summary concerns the Husband’s investment in his business as a franchisee of Source Bulk Foods, Australia’s largest specialised bulk food retailers, which prides itself as a zero-waste health food company and specialises in organic food.
- [104]
[104] In HA1, the Husband claimed to be unemployed and did not disclose that he was running a business as a franchisee. Source Bulk Foods supplies its franchisees with bulk food pantry products, including nuts, grains, seeds, dried fruit, chocolates, flours, pasta, cereals, raw honey, muesli, rice and oils.
- [105]
[105] The National Franchise Agreement with Source Bulk Foods in relation to business in Singapore was made with Honey Jean Pte Ltd (“Honey Jean”), which was incorporated on 9 November 2018 while the parties were still married. The Husband is the sole director and the sole shareholder of Honey Jean, He is also the guarantor in relation to Honey Jean’s franchise agreement with Source Foods, which was dated 2 March 2018. The Husband paid S$100,000 for the National Master Franchise Fee.
- [106]
[106] Schedule 11 of the National Franchise Agreement requires the franchisee to maintain a minimum of two stores at the end of the first year of operation, three stores at the end of the second year of operation, 4 stores at the end of the third year of operation, and a minimum of 9 stores by the end of the fourth year of operations. To date, three stores have opened at Cluny Court in Bukit Timah Road, Great World City in Kim Seng Promenade and Change Alley Mall in Raffles Place.
- [107]
[107] The Straits Times reported that the Husband is also the master franchisee for South East Asia and based on this report, the Wife asked that he produce the South East Asia Master Franchise Agreement. To date, the Agreement has not been produced.
- [110]
[110] The Husband accepted that Honey Jean is a matrimonial asset but he contended that it should not be included in the pool of matrimonial assets even though it was incorporated in November 2018 before the interim judgment because the value of the company increased only because of work done by him after the date of the interim judgment.
Item 35 of Joint Summary – Husband’s road bikes
Item 36 of Joint Summary - 40 feet container in Australia
- [113]
[113] Item 36 of the Joint Summary relates to the value of the contents of a 40- ft container which is presently being stored in Australia. This dispute about the container, which contains, among other things, household items, shows the degree of acrimony in these divorce proceedings.
- [114]
[114] The Wife asked the Husband to provide the full list and details of the items in the container that have been sold and an account of the sale proceeds, if any. She claimed that the contents of the container are worth AUD87,315 and that as the Husband has not given an account of what has been sold, it should be assumed that none of the items in the container have been sold. As such, she contended that the sum AUD87,315 should be added to the list of matrimonial assets.
- [115]
[115] The Husband retorted that the Wife kept the packing list and that he has no access to the said list. He wanted to have the container, for which storage charges continue to be incurred at the rate of AUD1,140 for three months, to be returned to Singapore. According to the Husband, no action has been taken on this because the Wife had not given him a reply in relation to this proposal. He also contended that the contents of the container should not be included in the pool of matrimonial assets as it is questionable how the Wife obtained the values of the items allegedly inside the container.
- [116]
[116] Without sufficient evidence on the value of the contents of the container in Australia, it was not possible to decide whether the contents are part of the pool of matrimonial assets and if so, their value.
Item 37 - British Club membership
- [118]
[118] The Husband is a member of the British Club. Apparently, the value of the membership ranges from S$7,000 to S$10,000.
- [119]
[119] The Wife submitted that this membership benefited the family and must be regarded as an unquantifiable matrimonial asset, which should be sold and the proceeds of sale divided. The Husband agreed to the proposed sale of his club membership and to the division of the sale proceeds.
Item 38 - The Wife’s car
- [121]
[121] Item 38 of the Joint Summary relates to a Toyota Harrier vehicle bearing number SLX9402X, which was purchased with money from their joint account. The estimated value of the motor vehicle in June 2019 was S$110,000. This sum was added to the pool of matrimonial properties.
Items 39, 40, 41, 42 and 43 – Wife’s bank accounts
- [122]
[122] Items 39, 40, 41, 42 and 43 of the Joint Statement concern a number of bank accounts in the Wife’s name. The accounts are as follows:
(a) DBS eMulti Currency Autosave Account with a balance of S$16,908.94 as at 8 July 2019;
(b) Commonwealth Bank Netbank Saver, which has no funds in it;
(c) Commonwealth Bank Foreign Currency Account with a balance of AUD 35,788.40 as at 30 April 2019;
(d) Commonwealth Bank Foreign Currency Account with a balance of USD 480,367.53 as at 30 May 2019; and
(e) Barclays Bank account with a balance of GPB 589.78 as at 5 August 2019.
- [123]
[123] The parties agreed that the balances in the above-mentioned accounts in the Wife’s name should be added to the pool of matrimonial assets.
Item 44 – Wife’s watch
- [124]
[124] Item 44 of the Joint Summary deals with a watch owned by the Wife, which is valued at S$7,600. The value of this watch was added to the pool of matrimonial assets
Maintenance for the Wife
- [125]
[125] Section 114(1) of the Women’s Charter, which concerns the payment of maintenance for a wife or former wife, provides as follows:
- [126]
[126] Section 114(2) of the Women’s Charter further provides that in exercising its powers under this section, the court shall endeavour to place the parties, so far as is practicable and, having regard to their conduct, just to do so, in the financial position in which they would have been if the marriage had not broken down and each had properly discharged his or her financial obligations and responsibilities towards the other.
- [128]
[128] In TNL v TNK, the Court of Appeal stated (at [62]) that ultimately, the award of maintenance is a multi-factorial inquiry which, pursuant to s 114(1) of the Women’s Charter, requires the court to have regard to all the circumstances of the case including the matters listed in ss 114(1)(a) to 114(1)(g) of the said statute.
- [129]
[129] In the present case, the Wife’s case is that the Husband should pay her S$7,740 per month as maintenance. She also wanted back-dated maintenance of S$9,500 per month between April 2019 to January 2020 and S$7,740 per month between February 2020 to September 2020. In contrast, the Husband contended that no maintenance should be paid to the Wife as their matrimonial assets have been divided equally.
Maintenance for the children
- [131]
[131] Section 68 of the Women’s Charter, which makes it clear that it is the duty of parents to maintain their children, provides:
- [132]
[132] Two matters will be considered. The first concerns the determination of the monthly expenses of the two children. The second concerns the proportion of the said expenses that is to be borne by each parent.
- [133]
[133] The parties had different views on the children’s monthly expenses. The Wife claimed that almost S$22,000 per month is required for the maintenance of the two children. She claimed that the elder child required S$11,164 per month while the younger child required S$10,722 per month. She also wanted the maintenance for the children to be back-dated to April 2019, when the Husband stopped paying for their maintenance.
- [134]
[134] The Husband thought that the Wife’s estimate of the children’s monthly expenses was too high. He submitted that the monthly expenses for the elder and younger child should only be S$8,049 and S$7,373 respectively.
- [135]
[135] The parties’ positions on the elder child’s share of household expenses and his own expenditure are listed below:
- [136]
[136] The expenses of the younger child are broadly similar to that of the elder child, with big items of expenditure such as school fees (around S$3,500), rental (S$2,100), groceries (S$833.33), maid’s salary (S$700) and medical insurance and consultations similar to the amounts claimed for the elder child.
- [140]
[140] That said, I find that the Wife’s claim for certain items to be unsupportable. For example, the Wife claims S$150 a month for gluten-free food for the elder child when he is not gluten intolerant. She has also claimed S$400 for taxi fares for the children, which is on the high side and could be halved. Another questionable expense relates to wine and spirits, for which the Wife has claimed S$80 for the younger child, who is only 13 years old. Furthermore, as the British Club membership is to be sold, the children’s share of the expenses in connection with this club need not be taken into account.
Costs
Senior Judge