Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 7 Jan 2021

Family Division of the High Court

VDX v VDY and another appeal

Feedback & support

[2021] SGHCF 2Case no. District Court Appeal (Family Division) No 115 of 201921 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. Background

  3. (a) The parents shall have joint custody, care and control of the Children.

  4. (b) The Children shall reside in and attend school in Singapore unless otherwise agreed between the parents.

  5. (c) The Father is to have care and control of the Children for at least the following periods:-

  6. (i) From 6.00 pm on Friday to 8.00 pm on Sunday each week during school terms, regardless of whether Monday is a public holiday or a school holiday during the school term;

  7. (ii) In the event that Friday is a public holiday or a school holiday during a school term, from 10.00 pm on Thursday to 9.00 pm on Sunday;

  8. (iii) The Children’s school holidays at the end of the last term of each school year;

  9. (iv) Whenever the Mother is not in Singapore, subject to another provision providing for overseas travel with the Children.

  10. (d) The Mother is to have care and control of the Children for the rest of the time.

  11. [6] To summarise, during the school term the Mother had care and control of the Children on weekdays while the Father had care and control of the Children on weekends. During the school holidays, the Mother had care and control of the Children except for the December holidays, when the Father had care and control of them. These arrangements might be viewed as maintaining parity between the parents and they appeared to have worked relatively smoothly for a significant number of years after the divorce. Until as recently as 2018, the parents were still communicating directly with each other to sort out care arrangements for the Children with cooperation and flexibility.

  12. The proceedings below

  13. (a) While the Father shall continue to have care of the Children for the December holidays, the Children shall be returned to the Mother by no later than 9.00 pm on 31 December.

  14. (b) The Mother shall have care of the Children from 6pm on the eve of Chinese New Year to 10.00 am on the first day of Chinese New Year and the Father shall have care of the Children from 10am on the first day of Chinese New Year to 10.00 am on the second day of Chinese New Year on even-numbered years, while the Father shall have care of the Children from 6.00 pm on the eve of Chinese New Year to 10.00 am on the second day of Chinese New Year on odd-numbered years.

  15. (a) The Father shall have care of C for the December holidays, and C shall be returned to the Mother by 9.00 pm on 1 January.

  16. (b) The Father shall have care of the Children from 5.00 pm on the eve of Chinese New Year to 9.00 am on the 2nd day of Chinese New Year.

  17. [10] Both parents also sought various other orders, including orders related to the care of the Children on special occasions such as the Mother’s Day and Father’s Day weekends and on birthdays. They eventually reached an agreement on most of the prayers sought and as the only issues on appeal involved the care of C on Chinese New Year’s Eve and New Year’s Eve, the other orders are not set out here.

  18. [11] The Mother submitted that her position was intended to promote sharing and joint parenting. She claimed that there had been no fixed arrangements in relation to the Children’s care over Chinese New Year’s Eve; now that the Children were older and the daughters were studying overseas, she had less quality time with them and she believed it was important to spend quality time as a family on Chinese New Year’s Eve. She submitted that the handover after the December holidays was best done on 31 December so that C could spend the whole day on 1 January settling in for school, which usually started on 2 January, and he would be too tired if he returned late on 1 January.

  19. [12] On the other hand, the Father claimed that the status quo was that the Children always had dinner with their paternal relatives on Chinese New Year’s Eve. He submitted that the Children should be permitted to maintain their ties with their extended family, and the dinner the Mother planned did not involve any extended maternal relatives. He also submitted that the Mother could spend time with the Children during lunch on Chinese New Year’s Eve. The Father also claimed that the previous arrangement and status quo was that the Children usually spent New Year’s Eve with him. The Father explained that he made extravagant preparations for New Year’s Eve celebrations with the Children, and submitted that depriving them of these events was not in their welfare.

  20. [13] The DJ heard the parties on 3 September 2019 and varied the orders in the following manner:

  21. (a) The Father shall continue to have care of the Children during the December Holidays, with the Children to be returned to the Mother by no later than 10.00 am on 1 January; and

  22. (b) The Mother shall have care of the Children from 3.00 pm to 8.30 pm on the eve of Chinese New Year, while the Husband shall have care of the Children thereafter to 10.00 am on the second day of Chinese New Year, after which the Wife shall have care of the Children for the remainder of the day.

  23. [15] In relation to the handover after the December holidays, the DJ agreed with the Mother that a reasonable time was needed for C to settle down before the start of the school year, but also accepted that the Father had a genuine intent to celebrate New Year’s Eve with the Children as he had done for several years. The DJ was of the view that both objectives could be met with a measure of compromise where the Father handed C over to the Mother at 10.00 am on 1 January, so as to maximise C’s time with both parents over the New Year, and balance the objectives of work and play as he transited from the holidays to the start of the school term (GD at [30]).

  24. [16] As for dinner time on Chinese New Year’s Eve, the DJ acknowledged the cultural significance of the reunion dinner for the family and observed that the question was whether parity between the two families was best achieved by alternating or sharing access to the Children over the occasion (GD at [35]). The DJ took a pragmatic view and directed that the Children could have an earlier dinner with their Mother, before joining the dinner at their Father’s home at 8.30 pm (GD at [36]).

  25. The appeals

  26. [17] Both parents filed their appeals against the DJ’s decision on 17 September 2019.

  27. My decision

  28. [24] I first make a note that in matters such as which days and for how many hours a child should be with one or the other parent, the court may have to make a decision that involves a compromise between the parents if their preferences are not aligned. Where there is an appeal against decisions involving the welfare of children, an appellate court will be slow to intervene, as decisions in such cases often involve choices between imperfect solutions (TSF v TSE [2018] 2 SLR 833 at [49], citing CX v CY (minor: custody and access) [2005] 3 SLR(R) 690 (“CX v CY”) at [15] and BG v BF [2007] 3 SLR(R) 233 at [12]). In reaching my decision in respect of these appeals, I considered whether the DJ had made any errors in the exercise of his discretion (CX v CY at [17]). I examined the legal principles that he had applied and his reasoning underlying the orders made.

  29. [26] I understood the parents to be submitting that the court ought to apply the legal principle of deciding in accordance with what was in the welfare of the child. While both parents argued that the arrangements they proposed promoted C’s welfare, in the present case, it is doubtful whether any decision on specific arrangements made in these appeals would materially affect the welfare of C. The issues before the court in the present appeals were very narrow. They concerned, at most, a few days of care of C with either parent every year. In fact, prior to the introduction of the new evidence on the starting date of the school term, the appeals concerned a matter of hours – how and with whom C should spend the evenings of Chinese New Year’s Eve and New Year’s Eve.

  30. [28] These appeals were not about any fundamental difficulties or unworkability in finalising appropriate practical arrangements on Chinese New Year’s Eve and New Year’s Eve, for the parties had no difficulty making these arrangements in the past. These two issues were far more minor than what the parents had to deal with over the past seven years. They related to practical decisions that the parents, who knew C the best, were best placed to make. In functioning families, disagreements about how holidays are spent would be resolved by compromise, graciousness and flexibility. The High Court observed in UYT v UYU and another appeal [2020] SGHCF 8 at [5]:

  31. [29] These observations are highly pertinent. The present issues, whether resolved in the way the Mother proposed, or in the manner the Father sought, would not significantly affect the welfare of C. What would significantly affect C’s welfare is the parents’ conflicts and the spirit in which they carry out the orders. If the arrangements are carried out by each parent with the intent to ruin the time that the other parent has with C, then C’s welfare is being undermined. On the other hand, either of the arrangements proposed by the parents, if carried out with a supportive and cooperative spirit, could and would go well, and promote C’s welfare.

  32. Dinner on Chinese New Year’s Eve

  33. [30] The Father has care of the Children on the first day of Chinese New Year, while the Mother has care of the Children on the second day of Chinese New Year. The issue of which parent should have care of C at dinner time on Chinese New Year’s Eve was a practical parenting issue. Some families may enjoy two reunions dinners on that night, one with maternal relatives and another with paternal relatives; as the DJ pointed out (GD at [36]), in functioning families, it is neither uncommon nor unthinkable that families accommodate one another’s obligations and eat dinner twice on the same night. Other families might reach a different arrangement where a reunion dinner with one set of relatives may be held on the weekend before Chinese New Year’s Eve. The arrangement chosen will be specific to the comfort level of particular families.

  34. Handover after December holidays

  35. [34] The question of the handover date mainly involved how much time C should have in the Mother’s care before he started school in the new school year. The amount of time a child might need to prepare for the first day of school and how that time should be used is a decision best made by the parents, who know their child best. Unfortunately, the parents in the present case could not agree on this matter. Both parents were keen to help C prepare for the new school term, and I did not doubt that both parents desired to do their best to support C. I thought it reasonable for C to have at least a full day in the residence of the parent with care of control of him during the school term (here, the Mother), before the first day of the new school year.

  36. [35] Where C would start his new school year on a Monday, I held that he should return to the Mother’s care by 9.00 pm on the Saturday of the weekend just before the first day of the new school term. Where C would start his new school year on a different weekday, he should return to the Mother’s care by 9.00 pm on the day before the eve of his first day of school (as an example, he should return on 9.00 pm on Sunday if the first day of school was Tuesday). This largely conformed to the term that the Father should have time with C for the entire December holidays. C would have been in the Father’s care for many weeks during the entire December holidays. This arrangement allowed C a full day to settle back into the routine of the new school term after having had more than a month of school holidays.

  37. [36] As the handover date would occur after New Year’s Day, the Mother also separately raised the issue of C spending New Year’s Eve (31 December) with her. While C is to be in the care of the Father for the entire December holidays, which includes New Year’s Eve and New Year’s Day, I reminded the parents to be reasonable in making arrangements for C. C may express a wish to be with the Mother or his sisters for a New Year’s Eve celebration, or as he grows older as a teenager, may even wish to celebrate that evening with his friends. The parents should have regard to C’s wishes, but they should not place him in a position of choosing between parents which may cause him to suffer a conflict of loyalty.

  38. [37] The Mother sought further clarification on what it meant for the parents to be “reasonable” with each other. I would think that they had largely cooperated reasonably in the past seven years and that experience would be an indication of what it would take to be “reasonable” in co-parenting. For one thing, they should not use inflammatory language in their communications. If there are solicitors involved, counsel should be mindful of the language used in communications. It is unnecessary and unhelpful to say “our client is shocked” by certain alleged nasty conduct. These parents had co-parented successfully prior to the recent deterioration of the relationship and I commend them for having done so. They are at liberty now to agree to arrangements that might differ from the existing court orders, having regard to C’s wishes, but if no agreement is reached then the existing orders will apply.

  39. Conclusion

  40. [39] I highlighted above (at [26]) that these appeals concerned a matter of a few days and, at one time, only a few hours with C. Litigation over these issues spanned nearly one and a half years. There were many opportunities for the parties to mediate and reach an agreement on these narrow issues. The lower court had heard the parties and provided a sensible arrangement for the parties. While the appeals arose from both parties’ dissatisfaction with that decision, this was also an opportunity for counsel to take a more active role in advising their clients on the likely scope of appellate intervention in such matters (see [24] above). The Court of Appeal remarked in BOI v BOJ [2018] 2 SLR 1156 at [3]:

  41. [40] Family law practitioners must be aware of the ways, both overt and subtle, in which they can influence the parenting dispute – these include the language used in correspondence and the mindset they bring to the proceedings. If both parties’ counsel can work as a team in problem-solving their clients’ parenting matters, they would have played a critical role in the delivery of therapeutic justice in our family justice system.

  42. [41] I urge the parents to reflect on their communications with each other and the positions they have taken in litigation. The evidence before the court demonstrated that the parties’ post-divorce co-parenting journey was far more successful than many cases that have come before this court; they must love the Children very much to have overcome any initial anger and resentment that commonly ensue upon divorce. Yet this long co-parenting relationship recently fell apart in a matter of months. The parents have both witnessed how the ongoing conflict has affected the children – perhaps the recent conflict has tainted their children’s experiences of what ought to be joyful celebrations on Chinese New Year’s Eve and New Year’s Day.

  43. [42] Parental responsibility is a personal responsibility. The Court is the last resort for the resolution of parenting matters, for parents should intentionally endeavour to make these decisions for their children themselves. They should strive hard not to mire the family, including the children, in litigation, nor should their resources and the court’s resources be spent on litigation to deal with an emotionally-driven conflict. This will involve some measure of compromise; it may involve being bigger, wiser and kinder – which must be very difficult when relationships have broken down, yet this is the legal responsibility placed on all parents. Parenting is not perpetual, and such sacrifices, painful as they may be, are not demanded of parents indefinitely for children do grow up to be adults – their chance to have a normal childhood should not be lost due to their parents’ conflict.