Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 23 Aug 2021
Contents

Family Division of the High Court

VMG v V MH and another appeal

Feedback & support

[2021] SGHCF 31Case no. District Court Appeals No 78 of 20203 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. [6] The DJ has previously dismissed the Father’s application under SUM 1524 of 2020, which is his application to send the Mother for a second mental health assessment. By way of SUM 362 of 2020, the Father is effectively seeking to appeal against the DJ’s decision below. The DJ found that there was a lack of evidence to prove a prima facie case that the Mother had mental health issues that required another examination. The Mother was admitted to IMH for the first and only time between 21 to 29 March 2018, after the Father called an ambulance to send her to IMH. She was referred to the early psychosis team for assessment, following which it was concluded that the Mother had “no mental illness with marital problems [sic] and interpersonal relationship problems”. The Medical Report from IMH dated 10 May 2018 for the Mother’s first outpatient appointment states that the Mother has no mental illness. She was again examined by IMH two other occasions thereafter, and no contrary diagnosis was found. Looking at the facts, even if I am minded to review the merits of SUM 362, there is no evidence to suggest that the Mother had mental health issues. I therefore dismiss the Father’s application.

  2. [7] I turn to the issue of the custody, care and control of the son. In deciding all matters relating to the Child, the court’s paramount consideration is always the welfare of the Child, as per s 125(1) of the Women’s Charter (Cap 353, 2009 Rev Ed). The court’s role is to determine what is in the best interests of the child. Joint custody is generally preferred as both parents are expected to be involved in the child’s life. In this case, both parents acknowledge that the son would benefit from the presence of both parents in his life. Both parents have been taking care of the son, although to varying extent. I find that joint custody is appropriate, and both parents are expected to cooperate with each other to make decisions on significant matters such as the child’s education and healthcare.

  3. [10] The Father will be given reasonable weekend access. Although he currently spends time with the son daily, the access takes place in the evening when the son is weary from a day in school. To help improve the quality of their time, I grant the father unsupervised access on Saturdays and Sundays for four hours a day, and parties are to agree on the timing. If parties cannot agree, the access time would be from 11am to 3pm.