Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 22 Oct 2021
Contents

Family Division of the High Court

VWW v VWX and another matter

Feedback & support

[2021] SGHCF 35Case no. Registrar’s Appeal from the Family Justice Courts No 18 of 20215 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Laws this judgment relies on

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. [1] The wife filed for divorce on 2 November 2020 and the interim judgment was made on 4 March 2021. The ancillary matters have not been disposed of, and the main contention appears to be the disagreement over the value of the husband’s motor-workshop. The valuers have not completed their assessment. The husband and wife were married on 18 March 2012. There are no children to the marriage.

  2. [2] On 8 June 2021 the husband applied under Rule 96(3)(a) of the Family Justice Rules to enter Final Judgment notwithstanding that the ancillary matters are outstanding. The grounds of his application are that the husband’s girlfriend had given birth to a child by him on 7 May 2020, and she is presently pregnant with their second child. The baby is due in a two months’ time.

  3. [5] At the hearing below, counsel for the wife submitted that the husband had not proved that he was the father of his girlfriend’s child, as well as the one she is currently carrying. He also submitted that there was no proof that he needed to legitimize the child for her and her mother to remain in Singapore. Hence, the husband applied to adduce further evidence by way of an affidavit by his girlfriend stating that he is the father of the child and that he would be marrying her upon his divorce. The husband says that he is not well-to-do as he earns only $1,400 a month.

  4. [6] Counsel for the husband also submitted that the immigration status of the girlfriend and her child depend on the husband marrying her and thus legitimizing the child as well as the child-to-be. Counsel relied on the website of the Immigration Authority for the proposition she advanced. Counsel must realise that the website of any person, company, or even government body, is not proof of any alleged fact other than the fact that the website carries the statement adduced. Not only might the website be out-of-date, the statements might be subject to a range of exceptions and internal guidelines. In any event, my decision does not depend on the veracity or truth of the husband’s claims. I will assume that the girlfriend’s child and child-to-be were fathered by the husband. I can also assume that as a foreigner the girlfriend’s immigration status is tenuous.

  5. [7] Nonetheless, those are not sufficient reasons to enter the final judgment in this case. There may be exceptional cases in which a court may exercise its discretion to enter final judgment even though the ancillaries have not been resolved, but this case is not one of them. His child with his girlfriend is almost a year and a half. Another child is due in a couple of months. Not only is this a case in which he and the wife had lived separate and apart for a long enough time that the husband might have been justified in starting his life anew in spite of the interim judgment not having been made final. The wife here contends that she had no knowledge of the girlfriend or of her having children with the husband.