Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 3 May 2021
Contents

Family Division of the High Court

VOU v VOT

Feedback & support

[2021] SGHCF 6Case no. District Court Appeal No 108 of 20209 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. [2] The parties were married on 25 December 2016, after cohabiting for four years in a “tumultuous” on-again, off-again relationship. It is not disputed that the husband gave the wife monthly sums of $5,000 from March 2014 to February 2017. In March 2017, the husband opened a joint bank account with the wife (the “Joint Account”) from which the wife withdrew a sum of $5,000 every month between March to June 2017.

  2. [3] Their marital bliss was short-lived. The husband left the wife abruptly around 14 June 2017, after withdrawing $50,000 from the Joint Account. He left about $25,000 behind, which the wife says she withdrew on 20 June 2017 and used for her own expenses until it ran out in December 2017.

  3. [5] The husband disputes the wife’s claim that she had sold her business because of his assurance to take care of her. He says that the decision to sell the business was entirely the wife’s since the marriage had broken down by then. Her reason for selling the business was to free her time so that she could look after him. With both marriage and husband gone, it was not reasonable for her to sell her business in expectation of his return. This is not an unreasonable argument, and one might have thought that in the circumstances, the wife might have delayed the sale. In any event, I do not think that decision has such a great impact in her favour. She could, if she would, return to it, even if, as she says, that she cannot make kueh in the same quantities as before due to her medical condition. It was, after all, a business based entirely on her skill and effort alone.

  4. [7] On appeal before me, the wife seeks a lump sum of $420,000 on the basis of $5,000 per month for 7 years. She says this is reasonable because the husband had given her $5,000 per month from 2014 until June 2017, when he left her. She submits that a multiplier of 7 years is fair and reasonable because she will not be able to earn much income moving forward due to her age and medical conditions, and the husband did not maintain her for almost three years during the marriage.

  5. [8] In the alternative, the wife seeks a lump sum of $180,000 on the basis of $5,000 per month for three years. She says this is fair and reasonable, given that the husband refused to maintain her for almost the entire duration of the marriage from the time he left her around 14 June 2017 till the time Interim Judgment was granted on 26 May 2020.

  6. [11] I am also unpersuaded by the wife’s submission that the DJ had erred in failing to consider the parties’ high standard of living during the marriage, and by the wife’s reliance on the principle of financial preservation (Section 114(2) of the Women’s Charter). First, the parties had lived together as man and wife only from December 2016 till the husband left her in June 2017. Subjective as it might be, I agree with the husband’s counsel that there was therefore not much “lifestyle during the marriage” to speak of. It will take a high standard of living during the marriage, of which there is only scant and unconvincing evidence (such as a passing reference to their two-week honeymoon in Europe), to justify the wife’s claim.

  7. [12] I also agree with the DJ’s view that both parties were “mature adults who were financially independent when they remarried each other” (GD at [27]) and the wife “was of a certain means and was financially secure on her own” (GD at [32]). Although the wife no longer has her kueh business, she is significantly younger than the husband, who is 78 and retired, and she is capable of being self-sufficient and providing for herself.

  8. [13] In any event, from the start of the marriage till its sudden end, the wife had received a total sum of about $50,000 (based on the $5,000 monthly sum she had received from December 2016 till June 2017, and the sum she withdrew from the Joint Account after the husband’s departure). In my view, this was sufficient for her needs after they stopped living together.

  9. [15] For completeness, I do not agree with the wife’s argument that the DJ was “holding it against [her]” for not entering into a pre-marital agreement. The point the DJ was making was that the husband’s generosity towards the wife in giving her $5,000 every month during their cohabitation could not be relied on upon the breakdown of the marriage, although that arrangement might have been given some weight had it been recorded in a pre-marital agreement or a deed of separation (GD at [26]). The DJ was not saying that the wife was at fault for omitting to do so.