Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 6 Jan 2022

Family Division of the High Court

VVB v VVA

Feedback & support

[2022] SGHCF 1Case no. Registrar’s Appeal from the Family Justice Courts No 17 of 202119 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Laws this judgment relies on

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Background

  2. [1] The appellant in this appeal was the defendant in FC/OSM 270/2020 (“the OSM”). The respondent was the plaintiff in the OSM who sought, amongst other prayers, that “the Court revokes the appointment of [the appellant] as donee of [the donor (“P”)] under Lasting Power of Attorney No. LPA 30097NU20 dated 26 June 2020”.

  3. [2] The District Judge (“DJ”) provided the following snapshot of the background in his Grounds of Decision (“GD”) at [1]–[4]:

  4. Appellant’s submissions

  5. [5] The appellant appealed on the following grounds:

  6. (a) The DJ erred in finding that the appellant ought to bear costs because she “threw in the towel” and “disclaimed her appointment” prior to the hearing;

  7. (b) The DJ erred in finding that the appellant ought to bear costs because she had “aggressively contested” the application;

  8. (c) The DJ erred in finding that the parties’ in-principle agreement regarding costs “cut both ways”; and

  9. (d) Costs, if any, should be borne by the estate.

  10. The appellant clarified at the hearing that in the alternative, if costs were awarded, that costs be fixed instead of taxed.

  11. Relevant provisions on costs

  12. [7] Rule 852(2) of the Family Justice Rules 2014 (“FJR”) provides:

  13. [8] Rule 854 of the FJR provides that:

  14. Decision

  15. Issue involving the finding that appellant threw in the towel

  16. [11] The appellant submitted:

  17. [12] The High Court in UTOC Engineering Pte Ltd v ASK Singapore Pte Ltd [2016] 5 SLR 83 (“UTOC Engineering”) has observed (at [10]):

  18. [14] Had the matter been adjudicated, and the respondent successful in the litigation, this outcome would be the “event” referred to in r 852 of the FJR. However, if the same outcome is reached not by full adjudication but by the appellant’s voluntary act, is such an outcome the “event” intended in r 852?

  19. [18] It was understandable why the DJ described the present case as one where the appellant threw in the towel at the doorstep of the hearing (GD at [9(d)]).

  20. Issue involving the finding that the appellant had “aggressively contested” the application

  21. [19] The appellant submitted that she could not be faulted for merely taking all necessary steps to defend the action, particularly when all the appellant was seeking to do was to protect P’s wishes as set forth in the LPA, and not for any personal gain. She asserted that she and her counsel were also simultaneously trying hard to settle the matter amicably in negotiations and that her decision to resign was primarily motivated by a genuine desire to deal with the respondent’s aggressive litigation tactics in a way that de-escalated the acrimony.

  22. [20] The appellant further submitted that:

  23. The appellant’s counsel submitted at the hearing that the adoption of “Therapeutic Justice” in family proceedings supported this submission.

  24. [21] The DJ found that the appellant had aggressively contested the application and “was certainly not trying hard to settle the matter amicably” (GD at [21]–[22]). He provided his reasons by setting out the chronology of proceedings and appellant’s actions as follows (GD at [21]):

  25. [23] One could imagine that, from the subjective point of view of the parties in Chan, defending one’s position in itself is not unreasonable. Indeed, it is common in family proceedings for parties to feel that it is the other party who is being unreasonable and increasing acrimony. Yet, Chan’s case shows that more is expected from the parties. Each step or act taken by one party in court proceedings has an effect on how the other party reacts. The Court of Appeal has said in VDZ v VEA [2020] 2 SLR 858 that “a kind act begets a kind response while a nasty act inflames the other” (at [77]).

  26. [24] Therapeutic justice seeks to support parties in their journey of healing and moving forward by adopting a problem-solving approach instead of an adversarial one. The appellant submitted that:

  27. [25] It appears that in those months before the hearing was fixed in January 2021, numerous affidavits and applications were filed in this period of “contest” (see [21] above). I did not think that the DJ could be faulted in reaching the view that he did after considering the objective facts such as the filing of many affidavits and other applications, as well as an eleventh-hour adjournment of the hearing of the OSM on 11 January 2021. There may have been an early invitation to have a discussion, but without more clarity from both sides on what transpired, it was hard to see this early invitation as constituting best efforts at an amicable resolution, in light of the litigious actions from September 2020 onwards.

  28. [27] I add a few more general remarks on the notion of therapeutic justice. Therapeutic justice is not about parties feeling happy and satisfied that they got whatever they sought in their present dispute. In fact, for both parties to obtain what each wanted in the first place is not practically possible without some compromise – the parties had, after all, a dispute that they simply could not resolve on their own. It would be a grave misperception of the therapeutic justice system if parties feel entitled to be “pandered to” during the court proceedings. Instead, a therapeutic justice system involves parties making what they may perceive to be “sacrifices” – letting go of what has hurt them deeply, refraining from doing “inflammatory” acts against the other party, compromising by giving in and cooperating with the other party in some issues, taking responsibility where required and finding the will to recast the future. Going through this part of the journey is not easy. In the Family Justice Courts Workplan 2018, In The Next Phase, I had said (Debbie Ong J, “Family Justice Courts: In The Next Phase”, speech at the Family Justice Courts Workplan 2018 (28 February 2018)):

  29. Just as the surgical removal of a diseased organ is painful and a loss, the problem-solving process takes effort and some sacrifices. But healing will come after the pain. It is that new positive future in the long term that is of great gain to the parties in this therapeutic justice system.

  30. [28] The notion of therapeutic justice operates within the framework of the law and does not prevail over the law. Judges apply the law and legal principles, in a system that is non-adversarial and conducive to problem-solving. Our family law is rich in legal principles and jurisprudence that promote therapeutic outcomes, and all legal actors in the family justice system would do well to apply the law to achieve therapeutic justice for our families.

  31. Issue involving the finding that the agreement regarding costs “cut both ways”

  32. [30] I did not see how this submission would assist her case. The DJ had said that (GD at [9(a)]):

  33. Issue on whether costs should be borne by estate

  34. [33] The appellant submitted that the DJ was in error because:

  35. Conclusion