Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 31 May 2022

Family Division of the High Court

UBQ v UBR

Feedback & support

[2022] SGHCF 13Case no. Divorce (Transferred) No 1861 of 2015(Summonses Nos 326 and 370 of 2021)25 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. [1] The plaintiff is referred to as the “Husband”, and the defendant is referred to as the “Wife”. The parties have two children, [A] and [B], who are aged 14 and 12 respectively (the “Children”).

  3. Background

  4. [2] At the ancillary matters (“AM”) proceedings, the following orders, inter alia, were made (“AM Orders”):

  5. (a) Sole care and control of the Children is awarded to the Wife.

  6. (b) The Wife’s application for leave to relocate the Children to St Louis, Missouri, United States of America (the “US”) is denied.

  7. (c) The Husband shall have full and unsupervised access to the Children during the Spring Break and Fall Break. His access would begin after school on the last Friday of the school term and will end on 8.00pm of the Saturday before the school term resumes.

  8. (d) During the Summer Break, the Husband’s access will be as follows:

  9. (i) In the first week of the Summer Break, the Husband is to have access from after school on the last Friday of the school term until the next Saturday, at 8.00pm.

  10. (ii) In the two weeks before the end of the Summer Break, the Husband will have access from 2.00pm on the Friday two weeks before the end of the Summer Break, until 8.00pm of the Saturday before the school term resumes.

  11. Summons for injunction

  12. [4] In HCF/SUM 326/2021 (“SUM 326”), the Husband applied for the following orders to be made:

  13. (c) for all of the Wife’s overseas travels with the Children, the Wife shall furnish a banker’s guarantee of S$100,000 for each child as a safeguard to ensure that the Children are not abducted again and are returned to Singapore; and

  14. (d) such further orders as the court deems fit.

  15. Parties’ submissions

  16. Decision

  17. [8] In all matters where the custody or upbringing of the child is in issue, “the welfare of the child is paramount and this principle ought to override any other consideration” (BNS v BNT [2015] 3 SLR 973 at [19]). This welfare principle places the child’s interests at the forefront, ensuring that the child’s interests are not side-lined while his or her parents litigate over what they subjectively perceive to be their respective rights and entitlements (TAU v TAT [2018] 5 SLR 1089 at [10]).

  18. [9] I noted that certain aspects of the 2021 US trip were of concern. First, as the Husband pointed out, the Wife had left for the US over a period when the Husband was to have access with the Children, and this was a breach of the AM Orders. Further, while in the US, the Wife’s conduct of making placement enquiries at several American schools and arranging for school tours was suspicious, even if she had explained that the schooling arrangements in the US were meant to be temporary. I understood the alarm the Husband must have experienced then – as a loving parent who is concerned for the Children, I could see that he was worried for their well-being and concerned that he would be permanently separated from the Children in a different country.

  19. [10] However, I accepted that 2021 was an unprecedented year. Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, global travel was gravely affected – in particular, re-entry into Singapore for non-citizens and permanent residents required specific approvals. It was thus important that the 2021 US trip should be viewed against the backdrop of these unusual pandemic-related restrictions.

  20. [12] At the hearing, the Husband’s counsel argued that the fact that the Wife had mounted a defence under Article 13 of the Hague Convention in the Hague Convention proceedings also showed that she had no intention of returning to Singapore. However, I recognised that the Wife was not in a straightforward situation in 2021. [A] is no longer a young child that a parent could easily physically take along wherever she goes – he is a teenager who has opinions and can independently express his views. I accepted that she argued the Article 13 defence in the Hague Convention proceedings to allow [A] an opportunity to express his views during the proceedings.

  21. [14] Applying the welfare principle, I was of the view that it would be in the Children’s interests to be permitted to travel to the US twice a year, as provided in the AM Orders. Accordingly, the Wife and Children may take their next trip in the coming summer vacation in May/June 2022. There should be no need for the Wife to furnish a banker’s guarantee to travel. The passports should be held by the parent with care and control of the Children. The issue of care and control is addressed below.

  22. [15] I thus dismissed SUM 326.

  23. Summons for variation of judgment / order

  24. Care and control of [A] and [B]

  25. [19] In the alternative, the Husband prayed for only [B] to live with him for the next three months, while [A] continued being under the Wife’s sole care and control, but from the fourth month onwards, care and control of both be switched from the Wife to the Husband. He submitted that in this interim period, the current access arrangements for [A] should be maintained so that his relationship with [A] could first be repaired before care and control was switched.

  26. [20] The Husband submitted that the prayer to have uninterrupted sole care and control of the Children for the next six months without physical access to the Wife was to “repair [his] relationship with the Children and to reverse the harm and damage caused by [the Wife]”. He submitted that he would facilitate access and encourage the Children to speak with the Wife. He also had flexible working arrangements and would be able to spend time with the Children.

  27. [21] The Wife submitted that she had always been the Children’s primary caregiver. She pointed out that she did not have a “quest for relocation”, and even tried to return to Singapore when the Husband served the papers for the Hague Convention matter on her. She submitted that she had always spent the entire summer in the US. It was always her intention to return to Singapore within the normal timeframe, but was prevented from doing so due to the prevailing travel restrictions on individuals holding dependent and student passes, and the Husband’s request that the US Federal Court retain their passports until the Hague Convention application was concluded, as explained at [6] above. She submitted at the hearing that the Husband knew where the Children were and could even have flown over to the US to where they were. The Wife further pointed out that the Husband’s request was extreme, and that the impact on the Children would be great. She submitted that the Children were stable in her care and were well-loved and nurtured. On the alternative request, she submitted that the Children are close to each other and separating them for a period of six months would be “devastating” to the Children.

  28. [22] I understood that the Husband felt that after the orders in September 2020 were released, his relationship with [A] deteriorated greatly, with [A] blocking his calls and messages. I was of the view that the cumulative weight of litigation over the past seven years had affected the Children, who are no stranger to the proceedings. Each act, decision and step taken by the parties over the years had contributed to where this family is today. The Children had suffered under the burden of their parents’ litigation – even before the September 2020 orders were released, [B] was assessed to be at a high risk of suicide. Certainly, the COVID-19 situation (which was beyond the parties’ control) added further complications to the situation, including disrupting the Wife and Children’s travel to the US and back. However, the actions of both parties had also contributed to the emotional state that the Children are in. I was not prepared to find, in the present case, that only one party’s particular act caused a certain reaction and emotional state of a child. Given all that has happened, I had considered carefully what would be in the welfare of the Children.

  29. [25] I also did not think that the Husband’s alternative proposal for split care and control for six months served the Children’s welfare. It would not be in the Children’s best interests to separate the two Children who had grown up together where each is a vital source of support for the other. Losing the unity of both parents had been hard enough, and to lose the only sibling each has by separated living would be a devastating loss.

  30. Access orders

  31. [27] The Wife submitted that the Husband’s proposal would upset the Children’s entire routines and would be harmful to the Children’s emotional and mental welfare. She pointed out that the Children had been accustomed to long spans of being in the Wife’s sole care, even during the marriage, for the Husband travelled often and was not involved in the Children’s caregiving. [A] had detached himself from the Husband on his own accord. Furthermore, the Husband had sought to vary the holiday arrangements, which she argued would be detrimental to the Children who very much enjoy their winter and summer school breaks in the US.

  32. [28] The Wife asked that no make-up time be granted as she did not agree to the Husband’s calculation of his lost access time. She submitted that on an hour-by-hour calculation of the lost access time, she had provided the Husband with 40 days of make-up access, including consecutive periods, with the longest being a full month from 16 December 2021 to 16 January 2022. Furthermore, she submitted that the Children want orders that are predictable and reliable. It is a point of stress that the orders have been changing. She also submitted that the Husband contributed to their delay in returning to Singapore, as he prevented her from seeking the necessary assistance from his employer and also asked the US Federal Court to keep her in the US.

  33. [29] I found that the Husband’s request to have six months of uninterrupted access with the Children is not reasonable. I noted that the Husband had already been given consecutive periods of uninterrupted access time to [B], with the longest being a full month from 16 December 2021 to 16 January 2022, which was what he requested for in his fourth prayer in SUM 370. As the Husband and [A] had been estranged (such that the Husband also sought therapeutic support to repair their relationship), I found that it would not be in the best interests of [A] to be with the Husband for such long periods of time quite abruptly at this stage. While I understood that the Husband sought to have uninterrupted time with [A] to repair his relationship with [A], this repair had to be done in other ways.

  34. Appointment of therapist for counselling / family therapy / reunification treatment

  35. [30] The Husband further requested that a therapist (either [Therapist T of Company 1], [Therapist U of Company 2] or [Therapist V of Company 3]) be appointed to carry out the necessary counselling, family therapy and/or reunification treatment to restore the relationship between the Husband and [A]. The Husband submitted that his relationship with [A] was in “desperate need of help and intervention” as the Wife had alienated [A] from the Husband. He had originally proposed that [A] see [Therapist W], who previously attended to [B] between October 2020 and May 2021, but the Wife objected to this, proposing one [Therapist X] instead. [Therapist W] had since suggested two other therapists to sequester [A]’s issues from [B]’s issues. The Husband also believed that there is no urgency for [A] to see a psychiatrist, but it was important that a therapist be appointed to repair their relationship.

  36. [31] The Wife was of the view that [A] needed a therapist and psychiatrist. The Wife submitted that [A] was now seeing [Therapist Y of Company 4]. She submitted that it would make sense for [Therapist Y] to be appointed for therapy sessions for [A] and to clarify that sessions with the parents be limited to those necessary for [A]’s treatment and with his knowledge. She pointed out that the Husband did not consent to [A] seeing [B]’s new psychiatrist, and that the Husband had a tendency to discontinue services with a practitioner who disagrees with him. The Wife also asked that a child psychiatrist be appointed for the Children. She submitted that [A] was also in need of the supervision of a medical doctor. The Wife submitted that the Husband had objected to [A] seeing several psychiatrists, including [Therapist Z] and [Therapist X] (who had been apprised of the family’s history).

  37. Appointment of a Parenting Coordinator

  38. [33] The Husband submitted that the appointment of a Parenting Coordinator would assist him and the Wife in learning how to co-parent effectively and to communicate in a way that would benefit the Children. The Wife submitted that she was uncertain if this role would benefit their Children and was of the impression that this role would have been more helpful earlier in 2015, when the matters were just commencing.

  39. [34] A Parenting Coordinator assists largely with the carrying out of court orders, such as by assisting parties with smoothening out access handovers and assisting parties to implement flexibility in carrying out court orders practically. I did not see the need for such a Parenting Coordinator; a therapist would be more suitable in this case.

  40. Prayer that neither party shall disclose information relating to the proceedings to the Children or to speak ill of the other party in the presence of the Children

  41. Judicial interview with the Children

  42. [38] The Wife also requested that the Court speaks to the Children. The Wife asked that the Court interviews [A], to understand [A]’s independent views and feelings towards the Husband. She highlighted that [A] is 14 years old and should be involved in the processes of deciding his future. At the hearing, the Husband strongly resisted this, stating that the Children may be put under greater pressure as a result.

  43. [39] I decided not to speak to the Children. I heard the views of both parents in respect of this issue. I noted that when [A] was involved in the Hague Convention proceedings in the US, he had expressed his nervousness to the Wife about being involved in the proceedings. Having considered the materials before me, I did not think that it was necessary to further involve the Children this way.

  44. Conclusion and moving ahead

  45. [40] SUM 326 and SUM 370 were dismissed. The parties were well aware that the protracted litigation had taken a terrible toll on the Children. In general, children often suffer the “conflict of loyalty” when they try not to hurt either parent by appearing to take sides; they should not have to bear such burdens of their parents’ conflict. Children also have to spend time separately with each parent after divorce, which impacts their living arrangements and schedules greatly. This can already be demanding on children, even without the stress of parents who distrust each other and who continue litigating over them.

  46. [41] I further penned down some thoughts for both parties’ contemplation. They did not constitute my findings or reasons for the orders I have reached above. I had already earlier explained my reasons for my decisions. I offered these thoughts in the hope that they could be of use when the parties try to recast their future and work towards providing the Children a healthy and normal childhood. The Husband could reflect on how any of his acts may have played a part in his now-estranged relationship with [A]; whatever may have been the justification, how might the Children have perceived his applications to prohibit them from travelling to the US in December 2020 and again in May 2021? The Wife could reflect on how her response to the court’s decision in September 2020 might have been perceived by the Children, and if she had played a part in how events unfolded thereafter. If the parties are able to desist from finding fault with the other and instead extend grace and flexibility towards each other, the Children will sense the increasing harmony and be greatly uplifted by this. They will be able to heal.