Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 9 Jun 2022
Contents

Family Division of the High Court

WAY v WAZ and another appeal

Feedback & support

[2022] SGHCF 14Case no. District Court Appeal No 96 of 20216 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. [1] The parties married in December 2012 and have a child (“the Child”), born in 2014, presently 8 years old. The Mother commenced divorce proceedings in March 2016 and Interim Judgment was granted on 8 May 2017. District Judge (“DJ”) Azmin Jailani heard the parties on ancillary matters and made the following access orders (“the Access Orders”) in November 2018:

  2. (a) the Father to have weekend overnight access either on Friday, Saturday, or Sunday night — it is not disputed that the Father elected to have his overnight access from Sunday 10.15am to Monday morning;

  3. (b) the Father to have weekday access on Tuesday and Thursday from 5.00pm to 7.30pm and one school run, to pick the Child up from school on Monday and drop the Child at the Mother’s residence;

  4. (c) the Father to have specific access on specific occasions, such as Father’s Day, the Father’s birthday, the Child’s birthday, Chinese New Year, Christmas and other public holidays; and

  5. (d) the parties and the Child to enrol in any family therapy or counselling programme to incrementally extend the periods of access to the Father, which includes increased access in Singapore and overseas travel with the Child.

  6. [2] After the DJ gave the Access Orders, the parties attended family therapy and had their first session with their counsellor (“the Counsellor”) sometime in late January 2019. However, due to the lack of cooperation between the parties, the family therapy programme had no positive outcome, and the Counsellor terminated it in December 2019, before it was completed.

  7. [3] The Father commenced Summons 71 of 2021 in January 2021 to vary the Access Orders. He sought significant variations, which included an increase of overnight access from one night to three nights, the inclusion of school holiday access, and overseas travel access.

  8. [4] The learned DJ accepted that it is in the Child’s best interest for the Father to have more time with the Child since it had been more than three years after the Access Orders were made, but was not minded to grant the entirety of the variations sought by the Father. Therefore, the learned DJ partially allowed the Father’s variation application and granted him:

  9. (a) one additional weekday overnight access, from Tuesday 4.30pm to Wednesday morning from October 2021 onwards;

  10. (b) a 30-minute earlier pickup time for weekday access;

  11. (c) make-up access if a public holiday allocated to the Mother falls on the same day as the Father’s access; and

  12. (d) one additional weekday access and two days of back-to-back overnight access during the school holidays in June 2022 and November to December 2022, and school holidays thereafter.

  13. [9] Turning to Father’s appeal, I agree that the Child may be distressed under the current handover arrangements because of the hostility between his parents. This is also supported by the views of the Child’s psychologist who stated in his report that when the parents knowingly or unknowingly show hostility during the handover, the Child will perceive the hostility and have a psychological fear reaction, and over time, repeated experiences of failures during the handover can become a trigger for negative reactions in the Child. In my view, to reduce the Child’s stress at handovers, it is the duty of both parents to be cordial during the handover process. However, this may sometimes be difficult or impossible due to the unresolved animosity from their separation. In such cases, the court may need to intervene to ensure that the hostility between the parents does not harm the welfare of the Child. The Father’s proposal for handover is as follows:

  14. [13] In a happy marriage, the custody of the children is aligned with the right to care and control, for the interests of both parents are themselves aligned. When the parents are divorced, this alignment is torn asunder, and the parents may be given joint custody of the children as that is an obvious right, save in exceptional cases where one party is found to be unsuitable to have custody rights. But when the parents are separated by divorce, it is impossible to have joint care and control. That is why one parent is given care and control, and the other, access to the children.