Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 17 Jan 2022

Family Division of the High Court

URN v URM and another appeal

Feedback & support

[2022] SGHCF 2Case no. District Court Appeal (Family Division) No 129 of 20209 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Background facts

  2. [1] The Father, a Swedish citizen, and the Mother, a Singapore citizen, were married in Singapore in August 2014. Their two daughters were born in 2015 and 2016.

  3. [2] On 4 August 2017, the Mother filed FC/OSG 168/2017 under the Guardianship of Infants Act (Cap 122, 1985 Rev Ed) (“GIA”) for custody and care and control, with supervised access to the Father and reasonable maintenance for herself and the children (“OSG 168”). On 11 August 2017, the Father commenced divorce proceedings in Sweden. On 25 August 2017, the Father filed FC/OSG 183/2017 in Singapore for, inter alia, the parties to be granted joint custody and the Mother to be granted care and control (“OSG 183”). On 28 September 2017, the Mother commenced divorce proceedings in Singapore in FC/D 4545/2017 (“D 4545”).

  4. [3] On 10 July 2018, in D 4545, the Mother filed FC/SUM 2420/2018 in Singapore for maintenance for herself from the Father (“SUM 2420”). On 31 August 2018, the Mother filed an application for spousal maintenance in the divorce proceedings before the District Court of Stockholm.

  5. [4] On 7 September 2018, the District Court of Stockholm granted a “part judgement” of divorce. In its “Grounds for Decision” dated 7 September 2018, it noted that the Father had submitted a request to complete the divorce and for the court to appoint an “estate distribution executor” to distribute the parties’ property. The Mother continued to oppose the petition for divorce and maintained that the only court to hear the matter was the court in Singapore as that is where the family resides. However, she was agreeable to the Father’s request for the Stockholm court to appoint an estate distribution executor. The Stockholm court said it could hear matters about an estate distribution executor “if the matter is connected with divorce proceedings in Sweden”. The court also said that “it remains the matter about custody, residence and visitation regarding the common children as well as maintenance to spouse”; it did not mention maintenance for the children as an outstanding issue in the divorce.

  6. [10] The Father appealed on 22 December 2020 in HCF/DCA 129/2020 (“DCA 129”), and the Mother appealed on 28 December 2020 in HCF/DCA 131/2020 (“DCA 131”).

  7. District Judge’s decision

  8. Parties’ arguments in DCA 129

  9. Father’s submissions

  10. Mother’s submissions

  11. My decision on DCA 129

  12. Parties’ arguments in DCA 131 on maintenance

  13. Mother’s submissions

  14. [20] The Mother submitted that the DJ erred in reducing the maintenance payable by the Father. First, the DJ pointed out that the Father’s assertions that he had no work ability from December 2018 to December 2020 contradict his submissions for OSG 168 and OSG 183. She submitted that the Father’s financial affairs were “shrouded in mystery”. The Father also did not disclose his income from various entities. Second, she argued that the DJ failed to take into account the fact that the Mother’s increase in income was because she was forced to work extra hard to look after the children, since the Father had failed to make the child maintenance payments and she was receiving no spousal maintenance. Third, the increase in the Mother’s income was only interim and temporary; compelling her to hold down full-time employment while being the sole caregiver of the children was too onerous on her.

  15. Father’s submissions

  16. [21] The Father submitted that he ended up earning much less than projected because he was significantly impeded by the Mother’s own actions. He also submitted that the Mother “does not deny” her employment and “hefty salary”. It was always expected that she would take on employment to foot her fair share of the children’s expenses. Finally, he argued that the Mother had provided no evidence that the increase in her income was only interim and temporary.

  17. My decision on DCA 131

  18. [23] Second, as the Mother stated that the increase in her income was only “interim and temporary”, she seemed to expect that she need not work full-time. However, whatever the situation was when the parties were married, the reality now is that both the Father and Mother are expected to work to provide for their children. In this regard, I noted that expenses for a domestic helper were already taken into consideration in the DJ’s decision on maintenance on 12 September 2018, to enable the Mother to be supported when she works.

  19. [24] In summary, I did not think the DJ erred in reducing the maintenance payable by the Father.

  20. Conclusion