Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 29 Jul 2022
Contents

Family Division of the High Court

WAA v VZZ

Feedback & support

[2022] SGHCF 20Case no. District Court Appeal (Family Division) No 139 of 20213 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. [2] The Father prays that care and control of both children be granted to him with access to the Mother and in the alternative, that the parties have split care and control, or shared care and control of the children. The Father says that he is the better parent for care and control as, inter alia, the children will be cared for after school by his parents and himself, as compared to being in the childcare centre for the whole day as proposed by the Mother. The Mother says that the current AM Orders should be upheld.

  2. [3] Subject to the warning I gave to her, I agree that the Mother should have care and control of the children. I emphasise that this is not because the Mother is the “superior caregiver”, but because the children seem comfortably adjusted to living with her. At this point, the children have been living with the Mother for almost ten months. It is in the interests of the children to have continuity and not disruption in their care arrangements. Although the Mother relies on the assistance of a childcare centre for the children, I agree with the DJ that there is nothing wrong with that. The children can better learn and socialize at the childcare centre. Having interviewed the children on 5 May 2022, I am of the view that split care and control is also not a feasible option. The children clearly share a close bond with each other, and it will not be in their interests to separate them. The Father’s proposal of shared care and control is also not feasible as the parties are unlikely to give each other the co-operation that shared care and control requires.

  3. [12] In my view, the Mother, as the parent with care and control of the children, is entitled to keep the jewellery that belongs to the children. I note that the Father had adduced receipts of jewellery purchased from Ishtara Jewellery Pte Ltd, showing that he has purchased a diamond earring, diamond necklace and a “bracelet baby”. Without more, it appears that they were purchased for the Mother or children. While the Father seeks the return of his jewellery, he has not adequately proved that the Mother currently has jewellery in her possession that belongs to him (and not herself or the children).