Family Division of the High Court · Decided 21 October 2022
WCX v WC W
Feedback & support[2022] SGHCF 26 · Case no. District Court Appeal No 14 of 2022 · 11 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
- [2]
[2] Both parties filed summonses for leave to adduce further affidavits in respect of the appeal. HCF/SUM 208/2022 (“SUM 208”) is the Father’s application to file a further affidavit to adduce evidence that was not before the DJ. The Father says that there have been changes in his living arrangements as well as his employment situation which he believes are relevant towards the issues of care and control and access. In particular, he says that he has now purchased a property near the child’s primary school and that he has also resigned from his position as a part-time lecturer in a polytechnic.
- [3]
[3] In respect of the Father’s application in SUM 208, I am of the view that the evidence is neither relevant nor material to my decision in this appeal. The DJ below had asked counsel about the Father’s future living arrangements, and was already apprised of the Father’s plans to purchase a property near the child’s primary school when he determined the issues of care and control, and access. In any case, if the Father is of the view that his living arrangements would have a material impact on the child, he should have ensured that the necessary arrangements were made before the AM matters were heard. It is also of little relevance that the Father has resigned from his position as a polytechnic lecturer as this was only a part-time position, whereas his full-time role is with his digital marketing business.
- [4]
[4] HCF/SUM 273/2022 (“SUM 273”) is the Mother’s application to file a further affidavit to adduce evidence. She says that since the AM hearing, there were several incidents that have taken place which endangered the child’s life, including one incident where the Father shot the child’s face with a toy nerf gun. She wishes to adduce, inter alia, photographic evidence of an alleged injury caused by that nerf gun.
- [5]
[5] In respect of the Mother’s application in SUM 273, I am similarly of the view that the new evidence is neither relevant nor material. The Father’s counsel pointed out during the hearing that the toy nerf gun was purchased by both parents for the child. The child’s cheek had a reddish blotch from the nerf gun in the course of playing with the Father, but it would be an exaggeration to say that the Father endangered the life of the child in that way. The nerf gun is a toy found in many toy shops and red blotches can be expected where the skin has been ‘shot’.
- [6]
[6] Both SUM 208 and SUM 273 are therefore dismissed. Although the court has a discretion to admit new evidence that is available only after the date of the decision, parties are reminded that this should be evidence which may have an impact on the decision: see TSF v TSE [2018] 2 SLR 833 at [43]. If further evidence were to be admitted without restraint, it serves only to distract and be of no help to the determination of the actual issues on appeal.
- [7]
[7] I now address the issues in DCA 14. In respect of care and control, the Father prays that the parties have shared care and control of the child. He proposes that the child shall be under the Father’s care from Wednesday after school (or 5.00pm when there is no school) to Saturday 9.00pm, and under the Mother’s care for the rest of the week. The Mother says that the DJ’s decision on care and control should be upheld.
- [10]
[10] In my view, there is no reason to depart from the DJ’s decision on care and control. The support and stability provided by the child’s maternal grandmother was an important factor which the DJ had rightly taken into consideration. It was not disputed that even before the breakdown of the marriage, both parties were working full time and relied on the maternal grandmother to care for the child. The Mother is also able to play with and care for the child in the evening. Although the Father may be capable of and keen to care for the child, giving sole care and control to the Mother will allow the child to have a stable home environment and would be in the best interests of the child. As I have not disturbed the DJ’s decision on care and control, the orders made in respect of the handover location at the Wife’s residence and the Wife’s safekeeping of the child’s documents are to remain.
- [11]
[11] In the alternative, the Father seeks more access time with the child. Under the AM orders, the Father has regular access from Saturday 9.00pm to Monday 9.00am, as well as Thursday after school (or 5.00pm when there is no school) to 8.00pm. He asks that he have increased access to the child from Wednesday after school (or 5.00pm when there is no school) to Saturday at 9.00pm.
- [12]
[12] The Father’s proposal on increased access would have the same effect as ordering shared care and control and is not workable. In my view, the DJ’s orders on access are pragmatic and reasonable. The Father has two nights of overnight access for part of the weekend (from Saturday to Monday) and one dinner access on Thursday after school. This affords the Father sufficient opportunities to spend meaningful time with the child. I further add that the access arrangements may be adjusted by the parties’ mutual agreement since both are working parents, and some give and take is inevitable.
- [14]
[14] The Father says that the present orders are unclear as to who has care or access of the child from 9.00pm on CNY eve to 10.00am on CNY Day 1; as well as from 9.00pm on CNY Day 2 to 10.00am on CNY Day 3 (if that is a designated public holiday). In respect of CNY access, the Father seeks increased access as follows:
- [15]
[15] I accept that the Father wishes to have increased access over the duration of the CNY holiday, which is a special family occasion, and since there are three nights to the CNY holiday, the Father should have at least one of them. I thus allow the Father to have increased access to the child during CNY as follows: