Family Division of the High Court · Decided 21 January 2022
CLB v CLC
Feedback & support[2022] SGHCF 3 · Case no. Divorce (Transferred) No 1639 of 2019 · 18 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [1]
[1] The plaintiff (the “Father”) and the defendant (the “Mother”) were married on 15 September 2003. There are two children of the marriage – [B] and [C], who will respectively turn 17 and 15 years old in 2022. The Interim Judgment of Divorce (“IJ”) was granted on 26 July 2019.
- [2]
[2] The ancillary matters (the “AM”) have been bifurcated. These are the grounds of my decision pertaining to the issues of custody, care and control, access, and maintenance; the decision in respect of the division of matrimonial assets has earlier been delivered. I heard parties on the issues of custody, care and control, access, and maintenance on 1 December 2021. Pursuant to my directions at the hearing, the parties submitted a letter to court with their table of positions on custody, care and control and access, as well as maintenance for the children, on 17 December 2021 (the “Table”). This Table was useful, especially as the parties sought rather detailed orders in respect of the sharing of time with the children.
Custody
Care and control
Father’s submissions
- [4]
[4] The Father sought shared care and control (with residence predominantly with the Mother), because the children “ought to know that he shares an equal status with the [Mother]”. He submitted that this is “analogous to the rationale for joint custody orders”.
Mother’s submissions
- [6]
[6] The Mother sought sole care and control of the children. She submitted that the Father still had difficulties communicating and interacting with the children, and on the Father’s own account, a third party agency would be required to facilitate the Father’s time with the children. She submitted that given these challenges in his relationship with the children, it would not be feasible for them to be cared for by the Father for half the week.
Decision on care and control
Access
Weekly and overnight access
- [12]
[12] The Father said that he saw the children about once every two weeks, for no more than three hours each time. The Father proposed that he should have time with the children twice a week, whether together or separately, with one day on a weekend for longer hours. He proposed that a weekday meeting should be three hours long while a weekend meeting should be eight hours long. Once overnight access was in place, access could take place once a week. He submitted that access should be arranged through a facilitator, at least for six months following the adjudication, such that a person from the Divorce Support Specialist Agencies (“DSSA”) or CAPS could ensure compliance. He submitted that the weekday routine meetings ought to be fixed so that the children could plan their other activities around their meetings with him.
- [13]
[13] The Mother proposed that, until the Father’s overnight access commenced, he should have dinner with the children from 5.30pm to 7.30pm, or any timings as mutually agreed between him and the children, during the following time periods:
(a) once every fortnight during the children’s school terms;
(b) on a weekly basis during the children’s school holidays in June and December while travelling is restricted by the Singapore Government; and
(c) when the Singapore Government allows overseas travelling, the Father shall have weekly dinners with the children in the first half of their school holidays in June and December of even years from the year of 2022, and in the second half of the children’s school holidays in June and December of odd years, from the year of 2021.
- [14]
[14] As for overnight access, I noted that both parties agreed that the Father shall have overnight access from Friday 6pm to Saturday 6pm or from Saturday 6pm to Sunday 6pm – however, the Mother wanted this to commence from December 2022 while the Father wanted it to start immediately. According to the Mother, overnight access should only commence from December 2022 to give the Father and children more time to rebuild their relationship – if, however, their relationship did improve before December 2022, the Mother was open to the children staying overnight at the Father’s home from an earlier period as long as the children and Father were agreeable. The Mother also said that she did not wish to be involved in the Father’s access to the children as the parties had a painful history with each other. She was agreeable, however, to a neutral third party facilitating the access with the Father for at least the next six months.
- [15]
[15] Based on the Father’s affidavit, his relationship with the children had improved since November 2020, and they had begun visiting his home as well as meeting at restaurants in their fortnightly sessions with him. The Father said, however, that his primary concern was the absence of some support structure to ensure continuity of time with the children to improve their relationship.
School holiday access
- [17]
[17] I noted that both parents agreed that the Father shall have the following school holiday access:
(a) March/September holidays: four consecutive overnight access from the weekend at the beginning of these holidays during even years and at the end of the said holidays during odd years.
(b) June/December holidays: Uninterrupted access to the children during the first half of the said holidays during even years and at the second half of the said holidays during odd years.
(c) The Father’s access shall be based on half of the total number of days of the said school holiday as stipulated by the Ministry of Education (“MOE”). The first day of access shall commence at 9am and access shall conclude on the last day at 9pm.
(d) The Mother shall provide the Father with the children’s Singapore passports at the commencement of the Father’s school holiday access. Upon the conclusion of the Father’s school holiday access, the Father will return the children’s Singapore passports to the Mother.
Chinese New Year
- [19]
[19] For Chinese New Year (“CNY”), the Mother proposed that:
(a) the children shall spend every CNY Eve and the first day of CNY with the Mother.
(b) the Father shall have access to the children on the second day of CNY, from 11am to 8pm or such time as the children may mutually agree with the Father.
- [20]
[20] The Father agreed with this proposal, but he also sought overnight access on the second day of CNY.
Special days access
- [22]
[22] The Father proposed that the children spend time with each parent on their respective birthdays. For the children’s birthdays, if the Father’s routine meeting with the child was fixed for that day, then the Mother should have time to share a meal with the child. Conversely, if their birthdays fell on a non-meeting day for the Father, he should be provided with three hours to have a meal with the child. The Mother did not state her position on this in the Table.
Public holidays (other than Chinese New Year)
- [24]
[24] The Father proposed that public holidays were to be split between the parties on an alternate basis unless expressly agreed (ie CNY was expressly excluded), and that access should be from 6pm on the eve of the public holiday to 6pm on the day of the public holiday. The Mother did not state her position on this in the Table.
Overseas access
- [27]
[27] The Mother did not state her position on overseas travel in the Table. In my view, the Father’s proposal that the parties be allowed to bring the children for overseas travel, as well as his proposal that the non-travelling parent be provided with telephone/video access during the travel period and one-month notice of the trip, was reasonable. However, I clarified that, by default, the Mother would hold the passports of the children as she was the parent with sole care and control. Thus, the children’s passports would remain with the Mother, unless there was a trip scheduled with the Father for which the children would need to bring along their passports, in which case the Mother should provide the children’s passports to the Father. It was not entirely clear what the Father meant by “ad-hoc trips” – in my view, there still had to be notice given to the Mother as long as the Father intended to bring the children out of Singapore (even if it was to Batam or Malaysia). With these considerations in mind, my orders on overseas access were as follows:
(a) Each parent is at liberty to bring the children out of Singapore during the school holidays, with appropriate precautions and insurance arrangements in view of the pandemic.
(b) The non-travelling parent should be provided with telephone and video access during the travel period and the travel and hotel itinerary at least one month prior to the travel.
(c) The travelling parent is to bear all the expenses of the trip without any claim from the non-travelling parent.
Mother’s general access terms
Liaising with and meeting the children
- [31]
[31] Fourth, the Mother proposed that the Father shall not pick up or fetch the children from their home before and after the Father’s access to the children – instead, the Mother shall provide the children with monies to enable them to take a private car or taxi. The Father did not agree. He proposed that he may pick up or return the children from where they live, though he agreed that there was to be no interaction between the parents on such occasions. In my view, the Father’s proposal was more reasonable – while the Mother had indicated her desire not to interact with the Father, this did not mean he should be prohibited from picking up or dropping off the children at their address. The Father may pick up or return the children from where they live.
Counselling
No negative influence
Children’s involvement in proceedings
Other orders sought by the Father
- [42]
[42] The Father also sought several other orders.
Maintenance for the children
- [48]
[48] In the Table, the Father proposed the following:
(a) The Father will provide a weekly allowance of $80 per child, ie an allowance of $320 per month, and pocket money of $10 per school day (which, assuming 5 school days in a week, is $200 per month for pocket money). In total, that would be an allowance/pocket money of $520 per month for each child. The Father will make payment directly to the children’s respective bank accounts on a weekly basis.
(b) The Father will make full payment for school expenses upon the Mother providing receipts/invoices. These comprise:
(i) all school fees, private school bus fees, purchase of school uniforms, school shoes and any other required clothing for school;
(ii) purchase of books and stationery up to a maximum of $300 annually;
(iii) all expenses incurred by the children on overseas school trips;
(iv) all expenses for the children’s mathematics and science tuition; and
(v) all sports related expenses, including equipment and required clothes.
(c) The Father will make full payment for the children’s handphone, computer and IT accessories.
(i) The Father will liaise directly with the children on their respective needs and purchase the items with the children.
(ii) If the items are needed urgently, the Mother is to buy the item and the Father will reimburse her upon provision of the relevant receipts. A cloud sharing system should be set up between the parties for the Mother to deposit these receipts. Alternatively, the Mother should give the children the receipts to pass to the Father during their access session.
(iii) The purchase of new handphones and laptops for each child shall be limited to one item within a two-year period.
(d) The Father will equally split the costs of tertiary education with the Mother. The Father will pay for [B]’s health insurance (including hospitalisation insurance) while the Mother will pay for [C]’s health insurance (including hospitalisation insurance). If either child is hospitalised, the parents are to make equal contributions following the deductions from the child’s respective medical insurance. As the Mother receives $2,000/child per year for the child’s medical bill, and upon the Mother’s production of the relevant receipt, the Father will pay half of each child’s medical bill not covered by the Mother’s employment benefit.
(e) Maintenance for the children is to be backdated to 6 October 2020 and will include the rental proceeds from the Niven Road Property.
- [50]
[50] As for the remainder of the Father’s proposal on maintenance, I noted that the Father did not deal with some of the other expenses listed in the Mother’s submissions and her affidavit, eg tuition for non-mathematics and science subjects like General Paper and Chinese, music lessons, and the children’s share of the household expenses. Thus, while the Father had offered to solely pay for some items, such as the children’s mathematics and science tuition and the children’s handphone/computer/IT accessories, this would still leave the Mother to bear most of the expenses for the children. For example, for [B], the Mother would still have to pay for music lessons, tuition for General Paper and Chinese, public transport, spectacles, musical instruments, [B]’s share of the household expenses, etc.
Costs