Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 21 Jan 2022

Family Division of the High Court

VWQ v V WR

Feedback & support

[2022] SGHCF 5Case no. District Court Appeal No 67 of 20215 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. IN THE FAMILY JUSTICE COURTS OF THE REPUBLIC OF SINGAPORE

  2. [2] The Husband is a Singapore national who is 45 years old this year. He is working as a safe-entry ambassador. The Wife is a Singapore Permanent Resident and citizen of the People’s Republic of China. She is 39 years old this year and is working as a part-time assistant manager at a café. There is one child to the marriage who was born in 2011 and is a primary school student in Singapore.

  3. [7] The Husband also sought to rescind Clauses 3(f) and Clause 3(g) relating to the living arrangements in the Flat and the transfer of his shares in the Flat to the Child. The Husband says that the matrimonial flat is jointly owned by his mother and him and that the said clauses affect third party rights. The DJ rejected the Husband’s argument, distinguishing the case from UDA v UDB and another [2018] 1 SLR 1015 (“UDA v UDB”) and finding that the clauses only pertained to the Husband’s shares in the property. With the consent of the parties, the DJ deleted the first sentence of Clause 3(f) which allowed the Wife to stay in the Flat for as long as she desired since the Wife had already moved out of the matrimonial flat.

  4. [8] The Husband appealed against the DJ’s decision. The Husband has raised three main points on appeal:

  5. (a) Firstly, the Husband argues that the DJ erred in refusing to reverse care and control of the Child from the Wife to him. The Husband contends that there has been a material change in circumstances because the Wife has moved out of the flat with the Child, disrupting the Child’s living arrangements. The Husband further contends that there is a lack of evidence on the Child’s present caregiving arrangements, and it is in the welfare of the Child for care and control to be given to him.

  6. (b) Secondly, the Husband says that the DJ erred in refusing to vary Clauses 3(c) and 3(d) concerning the maintenance of the Child and the Wife. The Husband contends that there has been a material change in circumstances because he stopped working as a sales manager at a Chinese restaurant in 2019 because of his diabetes, high blood pressure and high cholesterol. The Husband further contends that in November 2019, he was diagnosed with a growth in his large intestine and would require lifelong medication which impedes his prospect of securing a job.

  7. (c) Thirdly, the Husband says that the DJ erred in allowing Clause 3(g) to stand. The Husband contends that Clause 3(g) should be rescinded on the ground of impracticality because, as a joint tenant of the flat he does not own any “divisible share” in the Flat and therefore cannot transfer “his shares” of the Flat to the Child.

  8. [11] Since the Husband’s prayer for the reversal of care and control is not granted, the Husband’s prayer that the Wife pay him $700.00 per month for child maintenance would necessarily fail. The Husband has not provided any other justifiable reason for the reversal of the $700 maintenance payment.

  9. [12] Turning to the issue of wife maintenance, I take the view that the Husband’s loss of employment did not amount to a material change in circumstances in the present case. I accept that the Husband’s medical conditions may have caused him inconvenience in finding jobs in the food and beverage industry, his conditions are not so severe as to render him incapable of working. As I mentioned, the Husband had since found a job as a safe-entry ambassador.