Family Division of the High Court · Decided 10 March 2022
VLI v VLJ
Feedback & support[2022] SGHCF 8 · Case no. District Court Appeal (Family Division) No 141 of 2021 · 18 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [1]
[1] In this appeal, the appellant is referred to as the Mother and the respondent is referred to as the Father.
- [2]
[2] The Mother raises the following issues in her appeal:
(a) whether the Court had erred in law in dismissing the Mother’s application for sole custody, care and control of the Child with restricted and supervised access to the Father;
(c) accordingly, whether the Court erred in law and in fact by not making the orders for relief sought for by the Mother.
Did the court err in dismissing the Mother’s application for sole custody, care and control of the Child and supervised access to the Father?
The Mother’s submissions
- [4]
[4] In relation to custody, the Mother submits on appeal that the Child’s right to apply for Singapore citizenship falls within the ambit of the welfare principle. Moreover, a real dispute has arisen between the parties sufficient to invoke the Court’s intervention to make orders on custody as “the Father does not agree with the Mother that the Child should apply for Singapore citizenship”. She submits that it was agreed between the parties during the marriage, before it broke down, that they would apply for Singapore citizenship for the Child, but the Father later changed his mind.
- [5]
[5] On the issue of care and control, the Mother submits “that the Court ought to have at the very least made care and control orders for the Child”. The Mother argues that the Court’s intervention to make orders for care and control arises from the breakdown of the marriage, and the question of whether or not there is a dispute between the parties is not a relevant factor to be considered. She submits that as the marriage has broken down, there is a need for the court to intervene to make care and control orders.
- [6]
[6] The Mother’s position on access is that the Father’s access ought to be on a restricted and supervised basis. She proposes that any access be conducted for 2 hours once a week under the supervision of the Plaintiff or through the DSSA”. She submits that since August 2020, “the Father has only made half-hearted and insincere attempts to see the Child for the Child’s 1st birthday. No other attempts were made by the Father to see the Child.” As “the Father is practically a stranger to the Child”, the Mother argues that it is not in the best interest of the Child to be “thrust into access arrangements with the Father without supervision or restriction”.
The Father’s submissions
- [7]
[7] The Father provides maintenance and leaves the Mother to care for the child. The Father’s position is that the Child’s citizenship application is a personal decision to be made by parents. As he is the Singapore citizen who does not wish to apply for citizenship for the Child, the Mother should not insist on this. He is of the view that it would be in the best interests of the Child to return to Israel to study, as the Israeli system provides good education and comparatively more education and healthcare benefits. He submits that “currently the main interest of the plaintiff is … to obtain the child citizenship status that allows her to ride on and live in Singapore”.
- [9]
[9] The Father disagrees that access should be supervised and restricted. He wishes to bring his son to visit his family and highlights that it “is for the best interest of the child and his welfare to spend time bonding with [the Father’s] grandparents, family, relatives and [the Father].” He also wishes that access will be unsupervised, with no third parties around. Previously, the Father had tried to organise a gathering at his uncle’s place in celebration of the Child’s birthday in 2020, but the Mother was not agreeable as she wished for the gathering to be at a Jewish restaurant which served kosher food. As parties were unable to reach an agreement, the gathering did not materialize.
My decision
- [10]
[10] The DJ held that (OSG 112 GD at [18]):
- [11]
[11] He explained (OSG 112 GD at [15]-[16]):
- [12]
[12] There appears to be some confusion with respect to the concepts of custody and care and control. The DJ relies on the Father’s concession that there are no disagreements (or actual disputes) between the parties over matters relating to the Child’s upbringing in OSG 102. This appears to be a reference to matters relevant to “custody”. The DJ found in OSG 112 that there were no fresh events that gave rise to a genuine or actual dispute in respect of the Child’s citizenship. However, in applying CX v CY, the DJ made no orders for care and control as well, not just in respect of custody.
- [17]
[17] From the evidence and submissions before the court below in both OSG 102 and OSG 112, it is apparent that there were disputes over the care and control and access arrangements. While the Father accepts that the Mother is the “primary care-taker of the child”, he clarified at the hearing that he prefers to have shared care and control of the Child. He also wishes to have unsupervised access to the Child, while the Mother maintains that access should be supervised and restricted. Evidence on how the parties faced conflicts over the Child’s access on the Child’s birthday was before the court below. The Father clarified at the hearing that he would like access to the Child but has not recently nor presently pursued it due to serious concerns that doing so will cause more difficult issues and conflict, which he described as “trouble”.
- [18]
[18] Presently, the Father accepts that the Mother is the “primary care-taker of the child” and does not wish to disrupt the status quo. He expressed his desire at the hearing that he may pursue shared care and control, or more access when he is able to afford a lawyer in future. Given that the Mother has been the main caregiver of the Child since the parties separated in June 2020, I accept that the Mother should be given sole care and control of the Child.
Did the court err by refusing to direct that the Father be ordered to apply for the Child’s Singapore citizenship?
- [22]
[22] It is also noteworthy that the father of the child in UKM v AG (who was a Singapore citizen) desired to apply for Singapore citizenship for the child, whereas in the present case, the Singapore citizen parent does not wish to do so.
- [23]
[23] In the Mother’s long submissions totalling 56 pages, she also raised at various points, the issue of whether it was in the best interests of this child to be a Singapore citizen. She submits that:
- [24]
[24] One of the Mother’s justifications for compelling an unwilling party to apply for citizenship for the Child is that prior to the breakdown of the marriage, this was promised to the Child. However, this argument fails to take into account the reality of family relationships after the marriage has broken down. The intentions and plans of an intact family before the marriage breaks down may no longer be the same after the breakdown. The relationships have changed. Many personal decisions will have to be made to cope with life after breakdown.
- [25]
[25] Another argument advanced by the Mother is that Singapore is the best place to raise the Child, and it is in the Child’s welfare to be a Singapore citizen and be raised in Singapore. Whether a child should be raised in country x or country y are personal decisions. The court is not in the position to, and should not, assess and compare the sufficiency of systems and quality of life of the various countries this family appears connected to – Israel, Thailand and Singapore (see UYK v UYJ [2020] 5 SLR 772 at [71]). Some parents of children with Singapore citizenship relocate and give up Singapore citizenship for personal reasons, which could, for example, be a belief that the education system in Singapore is too stressful for their children. Other parents think Singapore is a safe country with an excellent education system and choose to make Singapore their home. These are personal decisions.
Conclusion
- [27]
[27] The parties shall have joint custody of the Child. The Mother shall have sole care and control of the Child and the Father shall have reasonable access which is to be arranged by the parties.
- [28]
[28] As the parties have joint custody of the Child, the Mother cannot unilaterally decide on the matter of the Child’s citizenship. Her appeal to compel the Father to make an application for Singapore citizenship for the child is dismissed.