Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 15 May 2023
Contents

Family Division of the High Court

WKN v W KM

Feedback & support

[2023] SGHCF 25Case no. HCF/DCA 2/20235 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. [1] The appellant (“the Mother”) and the respondent (“the Father”) were married on 12 February 2012. That year, they had a daughter — born on 12 July (“the Child”). She is presently 11 years old. The Father, aged 45, operates a business selling stationery and providing delivery services. The Mother, aged 41, is an admin executive. The Father filed for divorce on 26 September 2016, and the parties obtained the interim judgment of divorce on 13 December 2016. The ancillary orders were made by consent and the interim judgment of divorce was made final on 17 March 2017. Under the ancillary orders, both parents have joint custody of the Child, with care and control residing with the Father. The Mother was given liberal access (including overnight access) to the Child. The Child was 4 years old at the time of the orders. The Mother remarried on 25 May 2019; the Father has not remarried.

  2. [5] The essence of the Mother’s appeal was that the DJ erred in holding that the alleged sexual abuse and emotional abuse by the Father and his domestic helper were not material changes in circumstances because the Attorney-General’s Chambers (“AGC”) and relevant authorities did not take further action against the Father. Counsel for the Mother, Mr Michael Low, says that the lack of legal action taken by the AGC does not indicate a lack of change in material circumstances, because the standard of proof of beyond a reasonable doubt for criminal cases does not apply to family proceedings.

  3. [6] In response, Ms Sharma says that the DJ was aware of the civil standard of proof and all relevant circumstances when she dismissed the Mother’s application. Ms Sharma says that the Mother’s allegations are unfounded, citing the reports of the relevant authorities who have conducted investigations into those allegations. She emphasised that the Father remains an able caregiver to the Child, and there was thus no need to vary the care and control orders.

  4. [7] I was not persuaded by Mr Low’s arguments. From the DJ’s oral judgment delivered on 6 January 2023, it is clear that she had applied the civil standard of balance of probabilities when determining if there had been a material change in circumstances. I am of the view that the DJ was justified in dismissing the application of the Mother based on the arguments before her.

  5. [8] That, however, does not mean that there is no material change in circumstances based on other factors, that warrants a variation of the original orders for care and control. I am only concerned with the best interests of the Child. Where a child is young and unable to voice her preferences, the best interests of the child will depend on the ability and attitudes of the parents. But when a child is older, the child’s views can be significant. The Child, being 11 years old, is sufficiently mature to decide which parent she wishes to live with. At the interview, she was initially shy, but calmly answered my questions. She articulated her opinions with firmness and maturity. She made it clear that she prefers to live with the Mother. She seems clearly happier to be with her. The Child also said that she is comfortable living with the Mother’s current husband, and she “talks to [him] about many things”. Nonetheless, she was adamant that she would be happier if the care and control arrangements were reversed. She did not appear to be coached or under the influence of either parent. I am of the view that the Child’s best interests would be served by reversing the original orders. That will place her in a comfortable environment where she can be in the right state of mind to focus on her studies, especially with the crucial Primary School Leaving Examinations next year.

  6. (a) The Mother is to have care and control of the Child;

  7. (b) The Father is to have access to the child on Tuesday and Thursday nights from 5.30pm to 8.00pm, and on Friday, after school, to Saturday at 8.30pm;

  8. (c) The Child’s mobile phone is to be returned to her, so as to facilitate access to the Father;

  9. (d) The orders will take effect from Saturday, 6 May 2023;

  10. (e) Liberty to apply.