Family Division of the High Court · Decided 5 June 2023
WNE v Public Prosecutor
Feedback & support[2023] SGHCF 27 · Case no. Youth Court Appeal No 1 of 2023/01 · 5 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Laws this judgment relies on
Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
- [1]
[1] In July and August 2022, the appellant, together with his elder brother (“P”), stole over 225 stored-value cards containing an aggregate value of at least $2,134 from unattended motorcycles parked at multiple carparks across Singapore (“the theft offences”). They were, however, charged separately as the Public Prosecutor brought additional charges against P for offences he committed separately.
- [6]
[6] The DJ took into account P’s sentence of 21 months’ probation including a residential stay at the Boys’ Town Hostel for 12 months. Applying the principle of parity, the DJ adjusted the duration of residence in the JRC from 18 months (recommended by the probation officer) to 12 months.
- [7]
[7] The appellant’s case on appeal, in essence, is that the probation report which the DJ referred to was unsatisfactory and should not have been followed. Mr Rajandran drew my attention to the striking similarities in the “Assessment” section of the probation reports between the appellant’s report and P’s report. Mr Choo confirmed that these similarities included the risk factors regarding the appellant’s family environment. On this basis, Mr Rajandran argued that home probation ought to have been recommended for the appellant, noting that the family circumstances, household environment and offences committed were identical as between the appellant and P. If anything, Mr Rajandran says that the law ought to be more lenient toward the appellant because of his “cognitive disabilities” and his relative lack of culpability in comparison to P’s aggravated offences.
- [8]
[8] I agree with Mr Rajandran. The DJ correctly took into account P’s punishment in sentencing the appellant. But he had already considered probation to be inappropriate. Thus, P’s punishment only mitigated the length of detention at the JRC. It may be, as Mr Rajandran says, that the DJ only knew of the orders made against P but did not have sight of P’s probation report along with their striking similarity of circumstances to the appellant’s. Having the benefit of reading P’s probation report, I am satisfied that the orders made in respect of the appellant ought not to be harsher than those made against P. This was probably why the learned DPP too accepts that the principle of parity would be more accurately applied in this way.
- [9]
[9] A term of home probation in itself may be inadequate to address the severity of the appellant’s offence. Thus a 12-month stay at a Boys’ Hostel instead of 12 months in the JRC should suffice. Both the JRC and the Hostel are structured and institutional environments for the rehabilitation of young offenders. The differences lie in the level of regimentation and supervision, the ability to return home daily and the ability to continue schooling in public schools. The Boys’ Hostel would provide the appellant a structured environment for his rehabilitation, while not completely isolating him from the outside community. This is in my view vital, for it is easier for rehabilitation to run its course when the young offender remains connected with society so that the lessons learnt in the structured environment can be applied practically. This is, of course, subject to the level of delinquency of the offender, which in this case, is not an issue. For a young offender being sentenced for the first time, the prospects of a second chance must be open to him without crushing him at first blow.