Family Division of the High Court · Decided 22 February 2024
VEG v VEF
Feedback & support[2024] SGHCF 14 · Case no. District Court Appeal No 68 of 2023 · 7 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
- [2]
[2] The appellant works as a consultant in Saudi Arabia, earning $16,690 a month. The respondent is a freelance consultant in the Food and Beverage industry. She does not have a fixed monthly income, but she says that she earns an average of $4,000 a month. The DJ accepted this, based on the respondent’s bank and CPF statements, and the Inland Revenue Authority of Singapore’s confirmation that there were no Notices of Assessments for the respondent in the past three years.
- [3]
[3] Counsel for the appellant, Mr Leonard Loh, submits that the respondent did not provide full and frank disclosure of her documents in relation to her monthly income. He says that as the respondent was a DBS Treasures customer, there is a service fee of $50 per month that is payable if the customer fails to keep an ending balance of at least $200,000 at the end of each month. However, the documents adduced before the DJ below show that no such service fee was deducted, despite the respondent’s low credit balance of a few thousand dollars.
- [4]
[4] At the hearing before me on 26 January 2024, I asked the respondent, who appeared in person, to produce her DBS Treasures statements for the past 12 months (“the Statements”) and allowed her to file an explanatory note. Although she agreed to do so, the respondent only produced those statements for the months of January 2023 to August 2023. Her explanation is that she closed her DBS Treasures accounts in August 2023, and, therefore, does not have the statements from August 2023 onwards.
- [5]
[5] The Statements reveal that the respondent maintained four DBS bank accounts. Three of which had been disclosed to the DJ. The last one, however, was a DBS Portfolio where she held investment assets worth about $200,000. This investment account and its relevant bank statements were not adduced before the DJ. Only the statements pertaining to the other three accounts were adduced.
- [6]
[6] The Statements also reveal that on 29 August 2023, she liquidated her investment assets and transferred the liquidation proceeds to one of the remaining three accounts, thereby losing her DBS Treasures customer status. As it stood, the respondent’s total credit balance as of 31 August 2023 was $197,650.92.
- [7]
[7] In her explanatory note, the respondent says that the moneys in the DBS accounts were an inheritance from her father (who died in 2016), for her and her daughter. It was given to her as a reserve fund in case the appellant did not provide for them. I am of the view that these statements and explanations were important information that should have been given to the DJ. Although I accept that the respondent is indeed earning $4,000 a month as a freelancer, the large amount of undisclosed investment funds, which she claims to be for her and her daughter, cannot be overlooked. These funds would have been relevant in the DJ’s assessment of whether there had been a material change in circumstances warranting a change in the agreed maintenance payments. The respondent liquidated the funds less than a month after this appeal was filed on 31 July 2023. Both the timing and the reason behind the liquidation were not explained by the respondent.
- [10]
[10] Regarding the daughter’s tuition expenses, the DJ varied the monthly sum payable by the appellant from $610 to $680. The respondent concedes that the daughter no longer goes to the tuition centre in question and accordingly, no longer requires the variation, which I would have disallowed in any event, for the same reasons above (at [9]).