High Court · Decided 16 February 2024
Mitsui E&S Power Systems Inc v Neptun International Pte Ltd and another (DBS Bank Ltd, non-party)
Feedback & support[2024] SGHCR 3 · Case no. Originating Claim No 5 of 2023 (Summons No 2489 of 2023) · 32 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [4]
[4] I now set out the full grounds of my decision.
Background
- [5]
[5] The facts in this Application were not in dispute.
- [6]
[6] On 6 January 2023, Mitsui commenced a suit against inter alia, Neptun. When Neptun and its co-defendant (together, the “Defendants”), failed to file a Notice of Intention to Contest or Not Contest within the prescribed time period, Mitsui sought and obtained a Judgment in Default of a Notice of Intention to Contest or Not Contest on 27 April 2023 ordering that the Defendants pay Mitsui a sum of money (“Judgment Debt”).
The Parties’ Positions
The Issues
- [13]
[13] This turned on:
(a) whether there was a debt due to Neptun from DBS ‘immediately or at some future date’ (which is the language used in O 22 r 2(2)(c) of the ROC 2021); and
(b) whether the monies in Neptun’s Account were a ‘contingent debt’.
The Law on Attachment of Debts
- [15]
[15] I begin with the law.
- [16]
[16] Enforcement orders for the attachment of debts are governed by O 22 r 2(2)(c) of the ROC 2021, which provides:
- [17]
[17] The corresponding provision in the Rules of Court (Cap 322, 2014 Rev Ed) (“ROC 2014”) is O 49 r 1 and provides:
- [18]
[18] The language used in both provisions is different. For a debt to be attachable under O 22 of the ROC 2021, the debt must be due “immediately or at some future date or at certain intervals in the future”. On the other hand, a debt is attachable under O 49 of the ROC 2014 if the debt is “due or accruing due”. Notwithstanding the difference in language, it was not disputed that the law on attachment of debts under the ROC 2021 is in substance the same as the law on garnishee proceedings under ROC 2014. I agreed. In my view, O 22 is merely a simplification of O 49. It seeks to explain what “due or accruing due” has come to mean as case law has developed: Art Ask Agency SL v Person(s) Unknown (“LXS-WL STORE”) [2023] SGHCR 14 at [55]. It follows that common law principles concerning O 49 r 1(1) of the ROC 2014 continue to be relevant to the interpretation of O 22 r 2(2)(c) of the ROC 2021.
- [19]
[19] With that, I turned to consider the key concepts in relation to the attachment of debts.
Debts due immediately or at some future date
- [20]
[20] I first considered what it means for a debt to be due “immediately or at some future date”, guided by the cases decided under O 49 of the ROC 2014.
- [21]
[21] A debt that is due “immediately”, as the plain wording suggests, is a sum of money which is payable now: see Webb v Stenton [1883] 11 QBD 518 (“Webb”) at p 527 cited in O’Laughlin Industries Co Ltd v Tan Thiam Hock [2020] SGHCR 6 (“O’Laughlin”) at [14]. A debt that is due “at some future date” is a debt that is not yet actually payable, but will become payable in the future by reason of a present obligation: see Webb at p 527; O’Laughlin at [14].
- [22]
[22] At the end of the day, the key for a debt to be attachable is that there must be a present and existing obligation to pay a sum of money whether now or at some point in the future: see Webb at pp 524, 527; O’Laughlin at [14]-[15]. Put another way, for a debt to be attachable, it is essential that the relationship of creditor and debtor should exist between the enforcement respondent and the non-party: Cavinder Bull S.C. (ed), Singapore Civil Procedure 2021 (Sweet & Maxwell: 2021) (“Singapore Civil Procedure”) at para 49/1/10. Following from the above, a useful but not infallible test to determine if a debt is attachable is to consider whether the debt is actionable: O’Laughlin at [20] citing Taurus Petroleum Ltd v State Oil Marketing Co of the Ministry of Oil, Republic of Iraq [2018] AC 690; see also Singapore Civil Procedure at para 49/1/10.
Contingent debts
- [23]
[23] A slightly different but closely-related concept is that of contingent debts. Contingent debts are debts that do not exist until and unless the contingency or event that triggers their creation occurs: O’Laughlin at [16]; see also Vintage Bullion DMCC (in its own capacity and as representative of the customers of MF Global Singapore Pte Ltd (in creditors’ voluntary liquidation)) v Chay Fook Yuen (in his capacity as joint and several liquidator of MF Global Singapore Pte Ltd (in creditors’ voluntary liquidation) [2016] 4 SLR 1248 (“Vintage Bullion”) at [45]. Until and unless the contingency occurs, there is no obligation between the enforcement respondent and the non-party that can be attached. It is for that reason that contingent debts cannot be garnished under O 49 of the ROC 2014.
- [24]
[24] As I mentioned at [21] above, the key for a debt to be attachable under O 22 of the ROC 2021 is that there must be a present and existing obligation to pay a sum of money, without which, there is simply nothing to be attached. Accordingly, contingent debts are similarly not attachable under O 22 of the ROC 2021.
- [25]
[25] With these principles in mind, I returned to the present case.
A Present Obligation Exists
- [26]
[26] DBS’s position was that the monies in the Account could not be attached because:
- [27]
[27] I disagreed and dealt with each of them in turn.
Effect of the CAD Order
- [29]
[29] However, I did not think that was the case.
- [33]
[33] On this note, I found it helpful to refer to the astute observations made by the late Professor Tan Yock Lin, citing s 35 of the CPC and the corresponding provision governing the procedure relating to seizure of property (s 370 of the CPC) in his footnotes, that:
(Tan Yock Lin, Personal Property Law (SAL Academy Publishing: 2014) at [03.061])
- [36]
[36] I disagreed.
- [37]
[37] In Vintage Bullion at [23] above, a company had entered into certain leveraged foreign exchange and leveraged commodity transactions (“Transactions”) with its customers. The Transactions were all speculative contracts that traded on differences. During the initial stage of the Transactions, the customer would take a position in the market known as the “open position”. As long as the customer’s position remained open, the customer would still be speculating and exposed to movements in the market. If the movement of the underlying currency or reference bullion favoured the customer, the customer would have “Unrealised Profits” corresponding to the value of the open position for that particular day. If the movement of the market was against the customer’s bet, the customer would have “Unrealised Losses”. The customer could choose to close his position, and when he did so, he would no longer be speculating. At that point, his profits or losses from the Transactions would be realised or crystallised. If the position was closed at a profit to the customer, this would give rise to a sum reflected as the “Forward Value” in the customer’s statement. When the position is closed, the company would also issue a trade confirmation stating a “Value Date”. On the “Value Date”, the sum reflected as the “Forward Value” would be credited to the customer’s ledger balance. The customer would then be able to request a withdrawal of a sum amounting to the value of the ledger balance which includes the “Forward Value”. One of the issues that arose was whether the “Forward Value” were sums that were “accruing” to the customers under the Commodity Trading Regulations 2001 (“CTR”).
- [38]
[38] The Court of Appeal, having considered the various other legal contexts in which the words “accrue” or “accruing due” were used, including the term “debt due or accruing due" used in O 49 of the ROC 2014, held that the sums representing the “Forward Value” did accrue to the customers: at [41] and [46]. In doing so, the Court held that sums could be said to be “accruing to” a customer within the meaning of reg 21(1)(a) of the CTR when the customer concerned was legally entitled to the sum in question: at [37]. In this regard, the Court was of the view that for the customer to be legally entitled to the sum concerned, there must be no ‘legal impediments’ which may put the customer’s legal right to the sum in question (e.g. the sum representing the “Forward Value” had not been eroded by crystallised losses, or the customer had not occasioned some breach of contract): at [46]. The Court was of the view that the customers were legally entitled to the sums representing the “Forward Value” as the underlying transaction had already been closed or concluded. This was notwithstanding the fact that the customers could not withdraw the sums until the “Value Date” had arrived. The Court drew a distinction between the customer’s legal entitlement and the concept of payment and stated at [46] as follows:
- [41]
[41] Accordingly, I did not accept DBS’s argument that there was no property belonging to Neptun with DBS that was available for attachment.
No contingent debt
- [43]
[43] I disagreed and explain by discussing the cases that have considered the concept of a contingent debt.
- [44]
[44] I first discuss Vintage Bullion, the facts of which have been set out at [37] above. In that case, another issue that the Court had to consider was whether the “Unrealised Profits” were sums that were “accruing” to the customers under the CTR.
- [45]
[45] The Court held that the “Unrealised Profits” were not sums “accruing to” the customers but were contingent debt obligations: Vintage Bullion at [45]. In arriving at its decision, the Court noted that the Transactions were structured such that, until the customer closes his or her position, any profits that were recorded in the form of “Unrealised Profits” were nothing more than a hypothetical position of what would be the profit if the position had been closed out: Vintage Bullion at [45]. As long as the customer’s position remained open, the customer was still speculating and it was impossible to tell if he or she would eventually make a profit or a loss: Vintage Bullion at [45]. Accordingly, until and unless the customer closes out his position, his or her profits would remain uncrystallised (i.e. a contingent debt) and could not be said to have “accrued to” him or her: Vintage Bullion at [45].
- [49]
[49] However, the present case is different and presents a reverse scenario. Here, a debt is already in existence. While the outcome of any disposal inquiry or other separate proceedings may lead to the monies eventually being paid to someone else, the fact is that an obligation exists now and unlike the case of Vintage Bullion, the monies standing in Neptun’s Account are not merely hypothetical.
- [50]
[50] A contingent debt is one where the contingency must happen for there to be a debt. It is not one where the contingency happens for there not to be a debt. Until and unless it is determined that the debt is not owed to Neptun, the obligation continues to exist, which remains available for attachment.
Attachment vs Release
- [53]
[53] Generally, garnishee or attachment orders are viewed as a single enforcement process. The purpose is to have monies that are owed by third parties to the judgment debtor paid to the judgment creditor instead. However, at a conceptual level, it may be broken down into two stages:
(a) Stage 1: Attachment. This refers to the capture of the obligation that is owed to the judgment debtor. At this stage, the Court considers whether there is a “debt due or accruing due” (under O 49 of the ROC 2014) / debts due “immediately or at some future date or at certain intervals in the future” (under O 22 of the ROC 2021) or if the debt is a “contingent debt”. In other words, at this stage, the Court is concerned with determining whether there is an existing obligation owed to the judgment debtor. If there is, the debt or obligation will be attached.
(b) Stage 2: Release. After the debt has been attached, the monies need to be released. At this stage, the judgment creditor is able to realise the obligation that has been captured or attached into actual monies by having the monies that were attached being paid or released to him.
(see Société Eram Shipping Co Ltd v Cie Internationale de Navigation [2004] 1 AC 260 at [62] (cited in O’Laughlin Industries at [18]))
- [55]
[55] Clearly, it is possible for an attachment of a debt to be maintained while not being released.
Fair and Practical Outcome
Conclusion
- [64]
[64] For the foregoing reasons, I dismissed DBS’s application.
(collectively, the “Conditions”)
(a) Within 3 working days of the Conditions being satisfied, Mitsui is to inform DBS in writing that the Conditions are satisfied, with the relevant supporting documents;
(b) Where DBS is informed that the Conditions are satisfied (before Mitsui informs DBS), DBS shall inform Mitsui of the same;
(i) the Sheriff for any commission due;
(ii) Mitsui the balance amount due from DBS to Neptun;
save that DBS shall not be required to transfer any sums to the Sheriff or Mitsui if:
(A) there is disagreement between DBS and Mitsui on whether the Conditions have been satisfied;
(B) there are pending Disposal Inquiry Proceedings; or
(d) In the event that Mitsui or DBS is notified in the final determination of the Disposal Inquiry Proceedings that DBS is to pay the monies in the Account to any party other than the Sheriff, Neptun or Mitsui, Mitsui shall apply for the monies in the Account to be released from attachment as soon as practicable but in any case within 21 days from the date Mitsui or DBS is so notified.
(e) Either Mitsui or DBS shall have liberty to apply for the necessary directions or orders.
- [67]
[67] Finally, it leaves me to thank both counsel for Mitsui and DBS for their able assistance and helpful submissions.