High Court · Decided 26 August 2025
Oro Negro Drilling Pte Ltd and others v Integradora de Servicios Petroleros Oro Negro SAPI de CV and others
Feedback & support[2025] SGHCR 28 · Case no. Originating Summons No 126 of 2018 (Summons No 1028 of 2025)
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
Background
- [4]
[4] In OS 126, the High Court had found in favour of the plaintiffs on liability against the third defendant (see Oro Negro Drilling Pte Ltd and others v Integradora de Servicios Petroleros Oro Negro SAPI de CV and others [2023] SGHC 297 (“Oro Negro (HC)”)). The High Court’s decision has been upheld by the Court of Appeal (see Gonzalo Gil White v Oro Negro Drilling Pte Ltd and others [2024] 1 SLR 307 (“Oro Negro (CA)”)). The proceedings in OS 126 are now concerned with the assessment of damages which the plaintiffs are entitled from the third defendant pursuant to the court’s earlier decision on liability. The background facts to OS 126 have been exhaustively set out in Oro Negro (HC) and Oro Negro (CA) and I only recite the salient facts where they are relevant for present purposes.
The parties
- [5]
[5] The first plaintiff is a holding company, and its only assets are shares in the second to sixth plaintiffs which are special purpose vehicles each owning a single offshore jack-up drilling rig operating in Mexico (Oro Negro (HC) at [20]). Until September 2017, the first plaintiff was a wholly owned subsidiary of the first defendant, Integradora de Servicios Petroleros Oro Negro, SAPI de CV (“Integradora”) (Oro Negro (HC) at [21]). The third defendant, Mr Gonzalo Gil White (“Mr Gonzalo”), was a director of the plaintiffs until September 2017 (Oro Negro (HC) at [26]). The second defendant, like Mr Gonzalo, was also a director of the plaintiffs until September 2017 (Oro Negro (HC) at [24]). The proceedings in OS 126 were and remain to be fought only between the plaintiffs and Mr Gonzalo only because (a) Integradora did not enter an appearance to oppose OS 126 and (b) the plaintiffs’ claims against the second defendant have been privately settled (Oro Negro (HC) at [23] and [25]).
- [6]
[6] Integradora is wholly owned by the Mexican state-owned oil and gas company, Petroleos Mexicanos (“Pemex”) (Oro Negro (HC) at [22]). Integradora also owns 99.25% of shares in another company, Perforadora Oro Negro S de RL de CV (“Perforadora”), and the remaining 0.75% shares in Perforadora are owned by another subsidiary of Pemex (Oro Negro (HC) at [28]). Perforadora chartered a drilling rig from each of the second to sixth plaintiffs under a bareboat charter, and then sub-chartered it further for offshore oil drilling operations in Mexico (Oro Negro (HC) at [28]).
The proceedings brought in Mexico and the US
- [7]
[7] Certain bonds (“the Bond”) issued by the first plaintiff to finance the purchase of a drilling rig by each of the second to sixth plaintiffs required the company constitutions of each of the plaintiffs to be amended to insert a new article (“Art 115A”), which, among other things, prohibited each plaintiff and its directors from carrying into effect any insolvency or restructuring proceeding anywhere in the world (an “Insolvency Matter”) unless two conditions were met: (a) each plaintiff’s shareholder voted in favour of doing so by passing an ordinary resolution to that effect; and (b) an independent director of each plaintiff, which was to be appointed by the trustee of the holders of the Bond (“the Bond Trustees”), voted in favour of doing so (Oro Negro (HC) at [32] and [37]). The Bond Trustees later appointed one Mr Noel Cochrane Jr (“Mr Cochrane”) as their independent director of each of the plaintiffs (Oro Negro (HC) at [34]).
- [8]
[8] On 11 September 2017, a Mexico law firm Guerra Gonzalez y Asociados (“the Guerra Lawyers”) filed a concurso petition in Mexico on behalf of Perforadora (Oro Negro (HC) at [44]). As the High Court explained in Oro Negro (HC) (at [8]–[10]), a concurso mercantile (or concurso) is a statutory, court-supervised restructuring procedure under Mexico law which is analogous to a creditors’ scheme of arrangement under Singapore law, and its effect is territorially confined to Mexico. After a concurso petition is filed, the court first determines if the debtor is indeed insolvent and therefore entitled to present a concurso petition and if so, the court then admits the concurso petition before proceeding to deal with its substance, including the appointment of a conciliator to build consensus between the company and its creditors on an acceptable reorganisation plan (Oro Negro (HC) at [11]–[13]). The concurso comes to an end after the implementation of the organisation plan, which is subject to final court approval (Oro Negro (HC) at [14]). Appeals against the decision of the court hearing a concurso petition (hereafter, the “concurso court”) are available on constitutional grounds to a separate court known as the amparo court which has the power to annul the concurso court’s decision and remit the issue for reconsideration by the concurso court (Oro Negro (HC) at [16]–[17]).
- [9]
[9] The Bond was supported by a guarantee from Integradora and a charterer’s undertaking from Perforadora (Oro Negro (HC) at [31]). As security, the first plaintiff also charged all of its shares in the second to sixth plaintiffs to the Bond Trustees, while Integradora also charged all of its shares in the first plaintiff to the Bond Trustees (Oro Negro (HC) at [33]). Perforadora’s concurso petition (“Perforadora’s Concurso”) constituted an event of default under the Bond (Oro Negro (HC) at [44]). The Bond Trustees accordingly declared such an event of default on 25 September 2017 and took steps for the plaintiffs’ directors (including Mr Gonzalo) to be replaced by directors whom they appointed (“the New Directors”) (Oro Negro (HC) at [46]).
- [10]
[10] On 29 September 2017, the Guerra Lawyers filed two further concurso petitions: (a) a concurso petition on behalf of Integradora (“Integradora’s Concurso”) and (b) six concurso petitions on behalf of each of the plaintiffs (“the Plaintiffs’ Concursos”) (Oro Negro (HC) at [47]). The Plaintiffs’ Concursos were filed pursuant to a shareholders’ resolutions of each of the plaintiffs (“the Shareholders’ Resolutions”) executed by Integradora (in its capacity as the sole shareholder of the first plaintiff) and the first plaintiff (in its capacity as the sole shareholder of the second to sixth plaintiffs) for the Guerra Lawyers to be engaged to file a concurso petition and for the Guerra Lawyers to be empowered by way of a power of attorney to seek or resist any proceedings on behalf of each of the plaintiffs (Oro Negro (HC) at [45]). Prior to the execution of the Shareholders’ Resolutions, Mr Gonzalo and the second defendant had, on 31 August 2017, in their capacities as directors of the plaintiffs, granted a power of attorney to the Guerra Lawyers to “file … all kinds of proceedings” on behalf of each plaintiff (see Oro Negro (HC) at [42]). It should be further noted that, for the purposes of Art 115A, an Insolvency Matter is defined as including without limitation a concurso (Oro Negro (HC) at [32(b)]). Contrary to the second of the two conditions in Art 115A, Mr Cochrane’s vote of approval was not obtained for the Shareholders’ Resolutions pursuant to which the Plaintiffs’ Concursos were filed (Oro Negro (HC) at [48]).
- [11]
[11] In the event, Perforadora’s Concurso was admitted on 5 October 2017 (Oro Negro (HC) at [51]). In the papers filed in SUM 1028, Perforadora’s Concurso was identified as Business Reorganisation Proceeding 345/2017-1 (“Concurso 345”), while Integradora’s Concurso and the Plaintiffs’ Concursos were identified as having been filed on a joint basis as Business Reorganisation Proceeding 395/2017-1 (“Concurso 395”). However, Integradora’s Concurso was subsequently joined to Perforadora’s Concurso in Concurso 345. As such, all that remains of Concurso 395 is the Plaintiffs’ Concurso, while Concurso 345 encompasses both Perforadora’s Concurso and Integradora’s Concurso.
- [12]
[12] On 9 October 2017, the New Directors, who had then learnt of the Plaintiffs’ Concursos, passed a directors’ resolution to revoke all authority granted to the Guerra Lawyers under the Guerra POA, and they also appointed a Mexican law firm Sainz Abogados SC (“Sainz Abogados”) to represent the plaintiffs in all legal proceedings in Mexico (Oro Negro (HC) at [52]). It may be observed that, while the Guerra Lawyers and Sainz Abogados both purport to act for the plaintiffs, quite clearly, they represented different sets of interests in the Mexico proceedings which are also in opposition in OS 126 – the Guerra Lawyers represented the defendants in OS 126 who had brought about the concursos, while Sainz Abogados represented the plaintiffs in OS 126 who oppose those proceedings. From this point onwards, a contest ensued in the Plaintiffs’ Concursos as to whether the Guerra Lawyers or Sainz Abogados were the lawful legal representatives of the plaintiffs (Oro Negro (HC) at [55]). This involved, among other things, applications in the concurso court as well as appeals to the amparo court against decisions of the concurso court brought by the Guerra Lawyers and Sainz Abogados (Oro Negro (HC) at [56]–[61]). On the other hand, the proceedings in Perforadora’s Concurso and Intergadora’s Concurso went ahead in parallel with the litigation in the Plaintiffs’ Concursos on issues specific to those proceedings (Oro Negro (HC) at [62]–[67]).
The proceedings in OS 126
- [14]
[14] The plaintiffs filed OS 126 in January 2018, seeking the following reliefs: (a) declarations that the Plaintiffs’ Concursos were invalidly filed for failure to comply with Art 115A and that the defendants had no authority to maintain the Plaintiffs’ Concursos; and (b) injunctions to prevent the defendants from maintaining the Plaintiffs’ Concursos or any other Insolvency Matter.
- [15]
[15] As mentioned above (at [5]), the proceedings in OS 126 were only contested by Mr Gonzalo because they were settled as against the second defendant, and Integradora did not enter an appearance to contest OS 126. The High Court found that plaintiffs are entitled to the reliefs sought against Mr Gonzalo as well as Integradora. In particular, the High Court found that the filing of the petitions for the Plaintiffs’ Concursos was a breach of Art 115A, which had prohibited the plaintiffs from doing so unless the independent director appointed by the Bond Trustees (ie, Mr Cochrane) had voted in favour of the Shareholders’ Resolutions (Oro Negro (HC) at [109]). The High Court further found that Art 115A formed the term of an implied contract between the plaintiffs and Mr Gonzalo (in his capacity as a director of the plaintiffs), and because Mr Gonzalo did cause the filing of the Plaintiffs’ Concursos in breach of Art 115A (see Oro Negro (HC) at [109]):
- [16]
[16] Mr Gonzalo appealed against the High Court’s decision. In the appeal, the main issue was whether there had been such an identity of issues between OS 126 and the Plaintiffs’ Concursos and whether that militated against the grant of the relief sought in OS 126. In the event, the Court of Appeal held that there was no such identity of issues for Mr Gonzalo’s appeal to be sustained (Oro Negro (CA) ([4] above) at [56]), and it upheld the High Court’s decision. With this, the proceedings in OS 126 are presently concerned with the assessment of damages which the High Court had found Mr Gonzalo to be liable to the plaintiffs for his breach of Art 115A (“the AD Proceedings”).
The interrogatories ordered in ORC 1753
- [17]
[17] Pursuant to the court’s directions, on 1 April 2024, the plaintiffs’ solicitors wrote to Mr Gonzalo’s solicitors, identifying three heads of damages which it is seeking to recover in the AD Proceedings:
- [18]
[18] I refer to these three heads of damages respectively as “the SA Legal Fees”, “the Dechert Legal Fees” and “the Unauthorised Transfer”.
- [19]
[19] In support of their claim for damages, on 3 June 2024, the plaintiffs disclosed 119 invoices issued by Sainz Abogados in relation to the SA Legal Fees (“SA Invoices”), and 41 invoices issued by Dechert LLP (“Dechert”) in relation to the Dechert Legal Fees (“Dechert Invoices”). While the SA Invoices were unredacted, all of the Dechert Invoices were wholly redacted save for the total fees and disbursements charged under each invoice. Subsequently, on 15 August 2024, the plaintiffs disclosed a further set of documents, including five more invoices issued by Sainz Abogados between March 2024 and July 2024 (“Further SA Invoices”). Like the Dechert Invoices, the Further SA Invoices were wholly redacted save for the total fees charged under each invoice.
- [20]
[20] On 6 September 2024, Mr Gonzalo served on the plaintiffs a set of interrogatories in connection with the three heads of damages. The plaintiffs then filed SUM 2725 for these interrogatories to be withdrawn pursuant to O 26 r 3(2) of the Rules of Court (2014 Rev Ed) (“ROC 2014”). The plaintiffs’ supporting affidavit for SUM 2725 refer to certain US proceedings which they say were brought in consequence of the Mexico proceedings (see [13] above). The plaintiffs say that they had appointed Dechert to act for them in those US proceedings, and the fees incurred are the subject of the Dechert Legal Fees. By the time SUM 2725 came up for hearing before me, only the interrogatories pertaining to the SA Legal Fees and the Dechert Legal Fees remained to be dealt with, because Mr Gonzalo accepted that the interrogatories pertaining to the Unauthorised Transfer had been sufficiently answered.
- [21]
[21] In resisting SUM 2725, Mr Gonzalo’s case was that the interrogatories are necessary for the plaintiffs to particularise and provide details of their claimed damages for the SA Legal Fees and the Dechert Legal Fees so that he can meaningfully respond and make his case in the AD Proceedings. Importantly, the documents disclosed by the plaintiffs did not assist him in understanding and responding to the plaintiffs’ case for damages. For example, each of the SA Invoices consisted of broad and generic descriptions without any indication of the legal proceeding for which work was undertaken and so they did not show how the plaintiffs’ legal fees had been incurred in relation to proceedings occasioned by his breach of Art 115A. As for the Dechert Invoices (and the same may be said of the Further SA Invoices), it was wholly unclear what the relevant legal fees had been incurred for because these invoices were completely redacted, and so the interrogatories requested were all the more necessary. The state of the plaintiffs’ documents also had to be viewed in the context of the court’s directions for the parties’ Affidavits of Evidence-in-Chief (“AEICs”) in the AD Proceedings to be filed concurrently, which meant that Mr Gonzalo had no opportunity to obtain further information about what the plaintiffs’ case on damages was, before his AEICs are to be prepared.
- [23]
[23] For ease of discussion, I refer to the interrogatories relating to the SA Legal Fees as “the SA Interrogatories”, and the interrogatories relating to the Dechert Legal Fees as “the Dechert Interrogatories”, and the sub-paragraphs respectively as parts (a), (b), (c) and (d) of the relevant interrogatories.
- [25]
[25] In support of its application in SUM 2725 for the interrogatories to be withdrawn, the plaintiffs relied on the following arguments, each of which I rejected for the reasons below (at [26]–[28]).
- [26]
[26] First, the plaintiffs argued that the interrogatories were unnecessary because their case is that none of the SA Legal Fees and the Dechert Legal Fees (as a whole) would have been incurred but for Mr Gonzalo’s breach of Art 115A. As such, if the interrogatories were allowed, the plaintiffs would effectively have to rewrite and narrow their case on damages. I rejected this. The plaintiffs were obviously entitled to run their case on damages in whatever manner they wished, but that does not detract from them having to provide necessary information about their case on damages which I considered Mr Gonzalo was entitled to.
- [27]
[27] Secondly, the plaintiffs argued that Mr Gonzalo would be fully aware as to what their claimed damages were because the legal fees were incurred in connection with proceedings that Mr Gonzalo had commenced through lawyers he engaged. I did not accept this submission. Although it is true that Mr Gonzalo would have an inkling of what the plaintiffs’ appointed lawyers had to do in response to the proceedings he had brought about, it remains the case that the SA Legal Fees and the Dechert Legal Fees were incurred in connection with the work which the plaintiffs had instructed Sainz Abogados and Dechert respectively to perform, and Mr Gonzalo would obviously not be privy to those instructions.
- [29]
[29] Pursuant to O 56 r 1(3) of the ROC 2014, the time for appeal against my decision in SUM 2725 expired on 7 November 2024. The plaintiffs did not appeal against my decision.
The plaintiffs’ attempts at compliance with ORC 1753 and the events leading to the filing of SUM 1028
- [30]
[30] ORC 1753 required the plaintiffs to provide their answers to the SA Interrogatories and the Dechert Interrogatories by 4 December 2024. The plaintiffs subsequently obtained an extension of time until 15 January 2025 for compliance.
- [31]
[31] On 15 January 2025, the plaintiffs filed an affidavit (“the 15 Jan Affidavit”) which purportedly contained their responses to the interrogatories. Paragraphs 6 and 7 of the 15 Jan Affidavit, respectively, identified Annex A of its exhibit as the plaintiffs’ response to the SA Interrogatories, and Annex B of its exhibit as the plaintiffs’ response to the Dechert Interrogatories. I will address the contents of these annexes in detail below (at [40]–[43]).
- [32]
[32] On 25 February 2025, Mr Gonzalo’s solicitors wrote to the plaintiffs’ solicitors (“the 25 Feb Letter”), identifying several deficiencies in the responses provided by the plaintiffs in the 15 Jan Affidavit (see [44] below). Mr Gonzalo’s solicitors invited the plaintiffs’ solicitors to file a further affidavit by 4 March 2025 to properly answer the interrogatories. At a pre-trial conference on 6 March 2025, the plaintiffs’ solicitors informed the court that they were still in the midst of taking their clients’ instructions on furnishing further answers to the interrogatories as requested in the 25 Feb Letter. The court directed that the plaintiffs provide a response to the 25 Feb Letter by 13 March 2025. On 13 March 2025, the plaintiffs’ solicitors wrote to court, citing the court’s earlier directions and informed the court that a response to the 25 Feb Letter would be provided by 21 March 2025 instead.
- [33]
[33] On 21 March 2025, the plaintiffs filed a further affidavit which they said contained responses which addressed the deficiencies identified in the 25 Feb Letter (“the 21 Mar Affidavit”). In the 21 Mar Affidavit, the plaintiffs exhibit a copy of a letter from the plaintiffs’ solicitors of even date which they confirmed contained their responses to the 25 Feb Letter. Similarly, I will address the contents of the 21 Mar Affidavit in detail below (at [45]).
- [34]
[34] Having reviewed the contents of the 21 Mar Affidavit, Mr Gonzalo maintained his view that the plaintiffs’ responses are deficient and on 28 March 2025, he filed SUM 1028.
The application in SUM 1028
(a) In relation to SA Interrogatories (see [22]–[23] above), part (c) of the interrogatories, which asked the plaintiffs to state “[t]he quantum of the professional fees, specific disbursements and identity of the invoices which correspond to” the work which the plaintiffs identified Sainz Abogados as having undertaken in each of the Mexico proceedings.
(b) In relation to the Dechert Interrogatories (see also [22]–[23] above), the entirety of those interrogatories except for part (d).
- [37]
[37] On 9 May 2025, the plaintiffs filed their reply affidavit in SUM 1028 (“the 9 May Affidavit”). It was in the 9 May Affidavit that the plaintiffs disclosed, for the first time, (a) unredacted copies of the Dechert Invoices; and (b) unredacted copies of the Further SA Invoices.
The issues
- [38]
[38] There were two key issues to be decided in SUM 1028:
(a) Whether the Identified Interrogatories have been sufficiently answered by the plaintiffs?
Whether the Identified Interrogatories have been sufficiently answered?
- [39]
[39] Before turning to the issue proper, let me set out the contents of the 15 Jan Affidavit and the 21 Mar Affidavit, which contain the plaintiffs’ responses to the SA Interrogatories and the Dechert Interrogatories.
The contents of the plaintiffs’ responses to the SA Interrogatories and the Dechert Interrogatories
- [40]
[40] The 15 Jan Affidavit consists of two annexes (Annex A and Annex B) which enclosed the plaintiffs’ responses to the SA Interrogatories and the Dechert Interrogatories, respectively.
- [41]
[41] Annex A of the 15 Jan Affidavit consists of the following:
(a) A table (“the Mexico Proceedings Timetable”) with three columns respectively titled “date”, “proceeding” and “action/motion”. There are several row entries in the Mexico Proceedings Timetable. The contents of each row entry consist of the following:
(i) A calendar month (eg, March 2019), which is stated in the “date” column.
(ii) The “proceeding” column identifies certain legal proceedings in the Mexico courts. Two examples are “Concurso Rig Owners 395/2017”, which appears to be a reference to Concurso 395 (ie, the Plaintiffs’ Concursos), and “Perforadora and Integradora Concurso Proceeding 345/2017”, which appears to be a reference to Concurso 345 (encompassing both Perforadora’s Concurso and Integradora’s Concurso) (see also [11] above).
(iii) The “action/motion” column contains a brief description of the work done by Sainz Abogados (with individuals from the team at Sainz Abogados specifically mentioned for most entries) in relation to the legal proceeding identified in the previous column.
(b) A table listing all the SA Invoices (“the Table of Invoices”), with details such as the date of the invoice, fees and disbursements charged, the period for which work was done and billed under that invoice (the second rightmost column), and the date on which each of the invoices were paid (the rightmost column).
- [42]
[42] Although not specifically stated, it appears that each calendar month entry in the Mexico Proceedings Timetable corresponds to each line entry in the Table of Invoices. In other words, each calendar month entry in the Mexico Proceedings Timetable relates to a distinct SA Invoice.
- [43]
[43] Annex B of the 15 Jan Affidavit consists of a document which sets out, in relation to each distinct proceeding in the US courts, a table of the key events which took place in each of those proceedings and the dates on which they occurred (“the US Proceedings Timetable”). These key events include the filing of certain applications, hearings, the filing of documents in court (such as letters and legal memoranda), the raising of objections by certain parties, and the making of certain orders. However, on the face of the US Proceedings Timetable, it is unclear whether each of these events were attributable to work done by Dechert or if they had even occasioned work on the part of Dechert. This is because, unlike the Mexico Proceedings Timetable, it is not stated in the US Proceedings Timetable as to who had brought about each of these events, for example, whether it had been the lawyers at Dechert or other parties, or how the lawyers at Dechert had been involved at all in connection with these events.
- [44]
[44] Mr Gonzalo’s solicitors considered the contents of the 15 Jan Affidavit inadequate. In the 25 Feb Letter, his solicitors wrote to the plaintiffs’ solicitors, identifying the following deficiencies in the plaintiffs’ responses:
(a) The plaintiffs had wholly failed to provide any answers in relation to the Further SA Invoices. At that time, the Further SA Invoices were completely redacted.
(b) The plaintiffs’ responses to the SA Interrogatories were inadequate because, among other things: (i) two of the row entries in the Mexico Proceedings Timetable (which correspond to the August 2017 and September 2017 SA Invoices respectively) did not identify the legal proceeding for which fees in those invoices had been incurred; and (ii) for several of the other row entries of the Mexico Proceedings Timetable, although there was some description of the work done and the proceeding in which such work was done was also identified, there was no indication as to the amount of fees in each invoice that was attributable to each of the identified proceeding(s). In other words, the breakdown of the quantum of fees in each invoice, which part (c) of the SA Interrogatories sought, remain unanswered.
(c) The US Proceedings Timetable was a “wholly meaningless document” that went nowhere towards answering the Dechert Interrogatories.
- [45]
[45] The plaintiffs provided their further response by way of the 21 Mar Affidavit. The 21 Mar Affidavit consisted of the following:
(a) A table similar to the Mexico Proceedings Timetable but consisting of row entries for the calendar months of February 2024 to June 2024 (“the Further Mexico Proceedings Timetable”). It appears that each calendar month entry relates to each distinct Further SA Invoice. At that time, all of the Further SA Invoices were completely redacted.
(b) A note setting out details of the various actions or proceedings which took place in the Mexico courts in relation to Concurso 345 and Concurso 395 (“the Mexico Proceedings Note”), such as the appeals brought to the amparo court and certain enforcement proceedings which were brought.
(c) A revised version of the US Proceedings Timetable (“the Revised US Proceedings Timetable”). Similar to the US Proceedings Timetable, the Revised US Proceedings Timetable also lists the various events in each of the US proceedings, but this time correlating each of them with a corresponding Dechert Invoice and also states the date on which each of these invoices were paid. At that time, all of the Dechert Invoices were completely redacted.
- [46]
[46] In the 9 May Affidavit, the plaintiffs disclosed unredacted versions of the Further SA Invoices as well as the Dechert Invoices. The plaintiffs also annexed a timetable which is identical in content to the Revised US Proceedings Timetable, but which includes additional information like docket and proceeding numbers and the title of each of the US proceedings involved. I will refer to this as “the Further Revised US Proceedings Timetable”.
The plaintiffs failed to provide any answer to part (c) of the SA Interrogatories
- [48]
[48] As mentioned above (at [42] and [45(a)]), each calendar month entry in the Mexico Proceedings Timetable as well the Further Mexico Proceedings Timetable relates to a distinct SA Invoice and Further SA Invoice, respectively. In connection with each SA Invoice, the Mexico Proceedings Timetable and the Further Mexico Proceedings Timetable identify the legal proceeding for which work was done (under the “proceeding” column) and contains a brief description of the work done by Sainz Abogados in each identified legal proceeding (under the “action/motion” column). The work which Sainz Abogados is said to have undertaken include the drafting of legal opinions and memoranda, the filing of motions and documents as well as appearance in court hearings. Most of these entries also identify the relevant individual from the team at Sainz Abogados that had carried out the work described, and the date on which such work was carried out.
- [49]
[49] Reading the Mexico Proceedings Timetable and the Further Mexico Proceedings Timetable, one can identify, for each SA Invoice or Further SA Invoice, the specific Mexico action or proceeding to which that invoice relates, and the work that was done within each proceeding. On this basis, I accept that the plaintiffs have provided a sufficient response to parts (a) and (b) of the SA Interrogatories which respectively seek: (a) a breakdown of the specific legal work performed by Sainz Abogados in the Mexico proceedings; and (b) the specific Mexico action or proceeding for which such work was undertaken.
- [50]
[50] Notwithstanding my view that the Mexico Proceedings Timetable and the Further Mexico Proceedings Timetable disclose a sufficient answer to parts (a) and (b) of the SA Interrogatories, I would observe that the manner in which the plaintiffs have prepared the Mexico Proceedings Timetable as a matter of compliance with ORC 1753 is far from satisfactory. I highlight three points.
(a) First, in the descriptions of work done in the “action/motion” column, various individuals are identified as having completed work which Sainz Abogados is said to have undertaken in the relevant Mexico proceeding, but there is no explanation in the Mexico Proceedings Timetable as to who these individuals were, though it appears that these individuals are lawyers at Sainz Abogados or legal professionals engaged by the plaintiffs.
(c) Finally, there are obvious typographical errors in the Mexico Proceedings Timetable, such as the third bullet point in the “action/motion” column for February 2018 and the third bullet point in the “action/motion” column for August 2019, both of which appear to be incomplete sentences. I do not think it is unreasonable to expect the Mexico Proceedings Timetable to be prepared with greater clarity and without such errors, given that it is intended to particularise the plaintiffs’ case and lay the requisite foundation for the AD Proceedings, and needless to say, comply with ORC 1753.
- [52]
[52] However, part (c) of the SA Interrogatories remain completely unanswered. To recap, part (c) sought:
- [53]
[53] Given the phrase “which correspond to the abovementioned work” [emphasis added], part (c) of the SA Interrogatories must be read together with parts (a) and (b). When so read together, part (c) essentially asks for the fees and disbursements charged in each SA Invoice (as well as Further SA Invoice) to be broken down with reference to the work for which those fees and disbursements were incurred (ie, answers furnished in response to part (a) of the SA Interrogatories) and the specific Mexico action or proceeding in respect of which that work was undertaken (ie, answers furnished in response to part (b) of the SA Interrogatories). In other words, to answer part (c) of the SA Interrogatories, the plaintiffs must break down the fees charged in each invoice with reference to the specific Mexico action or proceeding for which those fees were incurred, and additionally, they should also break down those fees with reference to the work which is said to have been undertaken in the identified Mexico action or proceeding, ie, the answers which they furnish in response to parts (a) and (b) of the SA Interrogatories.
- [54]
[54] None of the responses provided by the plaintiffs – whether in the 15 Jan Affidavit, the 21 Jan Affidavit, or the 9 May Affidavit filed in reply for SUM 1028 – provide any clue as to how the fees in each SA Invoice or Further SA Invoice are to be broken down, whether in terms of the specific Mexico action or proceeding for which fees were incurred or the work done in those proceedings. Let me illustrate this using the entry for March 2019 from the Mexico Proceedings Timetable (extracted at [47] above), which relates to SA Invoice no. 33076 issued on 3 April 2019, for which a sum of US$189,786.59 was charged. As the entry for March 2019 in the Mexico Proceedings Timetable identifies two sets of Mexico proceedings in respect of which work was done (namely, Concurso 395 (ie, the Plaintiffs’ Concursos) and Concurso 345 (encompassing both Perforadora’s Concurso and Integradora’s Concurso)), this means that the fees in invoice no. 33076 were charged in respect of two sets of Mexico proceedings. However, there is nothing in the Mexico Proceedings Timetable (or in any of the other responses provided by the plaintiffs) which purport to breakdown the total sum of fees in SA Invoice no. 33076 with reference to each of these proceedings.
- [56]
[56] With the exception of the entries for August and September 2017, all the other calendar month entries of the Mexico Proceedings Timetable and the Further Mexico Proceedings Timetable are of similar nature to the entry for March 2019, which I have described earlier. It is also undisputed that the structure of SA Invoice no. 33076 which I have described is similar to all of the other SA Invoices. Thus, the deficiency explained above (at [54]) apply equally to all these other entries of the Mexico Proceedings Timetable and the Further Mexico Proceedings Timetable, for the purposes of part (c) of the SA Interrogatories.
- [57]
[57] As for the entries for August and September 2017 in the Mexico Proceedings Timetable, they contain a brief description of work done in the “action/motion” column but the “proceeding” column is left blank. The work which is said to have been done in August and September 2017 consists of “[d]rafting legal opinions and memorandum regarding the legal framework of the concurso proceeding”. To recap, the concursos were only filed in September 2017 – the petition for Perforadora’s Concurso was filed on 11 September 2017, and petitions for Integradora’s Concurso and the Plaintiffs’ Concursos were filed on 29 September 2017 (see [8]–[10] above). By not specifying the relevant Mexico proceeding in respect of which such work was done, it would appear that the plaintiffs take the position that the same work was done in relation to all of the Mexico proceedings which Sainz Abogados had represented the plaintiffs for during the relevant period of time. To this extent, parts (a) and (b) of the SA Interrogatories have been answered in respect of the entries for August and September 2017 in the Mexico Proceedings Timetable, for reasons similar to those explained above (at [49]). However, the deficiency which I have identified above (at [54]) in relation to part (c) of the SA Interrogatories applies equally here because there is similarly no breakdown of the fees charged in the SA Invoices for August and September 2017 with reference to the specific Mexico action or proceeding for which work was done. The fact that the same work was done in all of the Mexico actions or proceedings does not excuse the plaintiffs from providing such a breakdown, since distinct fees for doing the same work would have been incurred in connection with each Mexico action or proceeding.
The plaintiffs provided insufficient answers to parts (a)–(b), and failed to provide any answer to part (c), of the Dechert Interrogatories
- [61]
[61] For ease of discussion, I set out an extract of the Revised US Proceedings Timetable below, which is similar to other sections of the Revised US Proceedings Timetable. I do not consider the Further Revised US Proceedings Timetable (see [46] above) separately as its contents appear to be identical to the Revised US Proceedings Timetable and do not contain any further information which the Revised US Proceedings Timetable does not already provide, for the purposes of responding to the Dechert Interrogatories.
- [62]
[62] The Revised US Proceedings Timetable identifies, in relation to each Dechert Invoice, the following: (a) the date of payment (as indicated by the final row in the extract above); (b) the different US proceedings for which work was done during the period of the invoice, as identified by the case numbers identified in the leftmost column; and (c) the “events” that took place in each of those proceedings.
- [63]
[63] In my view, the Revised US Proceedings Timetable does not disclose any sufficient answer to part (a) of the Dechert Interrogatories, which requires that the plaintiffs provide:
- [64]
[64] To be clear, while the descriptions of work contained in the Mexico Proceedings Timetable and the Further Mexico Proceedings Timetable are also somewhat generic (see [47]–[48] above), they are quite different in character from the descriptions listed in the “event” column of the Revised US Proceedings Timetable. In the Mexico Proceedings Timetable and the Further Mexico Proceedings Timetable, those descriptions relate to work which Sainz Abogados is said to have carried out. However, in the Revised US Proceedings Timetable, there is no indication of what work (if any) Dechert had undertaken in respect of each of those events. Without the latter piece of information, the entries in the “event” column are meaningless and abstract descriptions of the procedural timelines in the US proceedings that come nowhere close to providing a breakdown of what work Dechert had performed in the US proceedings, and whether (if at all) they related to the Plaintiffs’ Concursos.
- [66]
[66] As for part (b) of the Dechert Interrogatories, I accept that the plaintiffs have correlated the various descriptions in the “event” column with the corresponding US proceeding in which that event is said to have taken place. For example, in relation to the same fifth row entry from the extract above dated August 26, 2019, one can understand the event described as “Singapore Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss” as having taken place in the US proceeding involving case number 19-01294. However, for any such correlation to disclose a sufficient answer to part (b) of the Dechert Interrogatories, there must be some meaningful description of work done that qualifies as a sufficient answer to part (a) of the Dechert Interrogatories, in the first place. Given the conclusion I have arrived at in relation to part (a) of the Dechert Interrogatories, it follows that none of the correlations provided by the plaintiffs constitute a sufficient answer for the purposes of part (b) of the Dechert Interrogatories.
- [67]
[67] In the 9 May Affidavit, the plaintiffs finally disclosed unredacted versions of the Dechert Invoices. Even if the Revised US Proceedings Timetable is read together with the Dechert Invoices, they similarly do not disclose any sufficient answer to parts (a) and (b) of the Dechert Interrogatories. I illustrate this using Dechert Invoice no. 1433128, which is the subject of the extract from the Revised US Proceedings Timetable above. The line entries of Dechert Invoice no. 1433128 consist of brief descriptions of work done, such as working on briefs, review of materials and telephone calls with certain parties, and the time spent for each item of work done. Each Dechert Invoice also lists at its third page a “time and fee summary” which identifies the lawyers working on the matter and their respective hourly rates. As such, it is possible to calculate the fees charged for every item of work done that is listed in each Dechert Invoice. However:
(a) There is nothing in the invoice which indicates that all of the work done by Dechert and for which each Dechert Invoice was issued all relate to the Plaintiffs’ Concursos. It is a disputed issue as to whether the work for which the Dechert Invoices were issued exclusively relate to the Plaintiffs’ Concursos or also encompassed other proceedings which Mr Gonzalo says the plaintiffs ought not to be entitled to claim damages for. This also explains why part (a) of the Dechert Interrogatories require the plaintiffs to provide a breakdown of the work done and “which relate to the Plaintiff’s concurso”. As such, the descriptions in the invoice are similarly abstract and meaningless descriptions that came nowhere close to providing a breakdown of the work that Dechert had performed in a manner that answers part (a) of the Dechert Interrogatories.
(b) The invoice itself makes no reference to the various US case numbers that are referred to in the Revised US Proceedings Timetable. For each item of work listed in the invoice, there is also no indication of the relevant US proceeding in which that work was undertaken. As such, the contents of each Dechert Invoice similarly do not provide any answer to part (b) of the Dechert Interrogatories.
- [68]
[68] Similar to the SA Interrogatories (see [53] above), part (c) of the Dechert Interrogatories should be read together with parts (a) and (b) of the same because the breakdown of fees which part (c) of the Dechert Interrogatories sought is meant to be specific to the work relating to the Plaintiffs’ Concursos for which the fees in each Dechert Invoice were incurred (ie, answers furnished in response to part (a) of the Dechert Interrogatories) and the specific US proceeding in respect of which that work was undertaken (ie, answers furnished in response to part (b) of the Dechert Interrogatories). Quite clearly, the Revised US Proceedings Timetable does not provide any answer for part (c) of the Dechert Interrogatories. While the Revised US Proceedings Timetable does identify, for each Dechert Invoice, the specific US proceeding dealt with by that invoice, as well as events in the relevant US proceedings which come within the scope of that invoice, there is no breakdown of the fees whatsoever with reference to each specific US proceeding and the various events within each proceeding that are said to have occurred (putting aside the deficiencies in these descriptions which I have explained above at [64]–[67]). To use the extract above (at [61]) as an illustration, the sum of US$721,021.68 paid to Dechert in respect of invoices issued from July to September 2019 would encompass the various US proceedings and events listed in the corresponding parts of the Revised US Proceedings Timetable, but there is nothing in the Revised US Proceedings Timetable which breaks down this sum with reference to each of those listed US proceedings and events.
Summary
- [69]
[69] For the reasons above, having considered the contents of the 15 Jan Affidavit, the 21 Mar Affidavit as well as the 9 May Affidavit, I conclude that the plaintiffs’ answers to the Identified Interrogatories are plainly deficient and thus ORC 1753 has not been fully complied with. Specifically:
(a) The plaintiffs have failed to provide any answer to part (c) of the SA Interrogatories as well as part (c) of the Dechert Interrogatories.
(b) The answers which the plaintiffs purported to provide in response to parts (a) and (b) of the Dechert Interrogatories are plainly insufficient.
Whether an ‘unless’ order stipulating dismissal of the plaintiffs’ claim in the AD Proceedings as the consequence of breach is warranted to compel the plaintiffs’ full compliance with ORC 1753?
An ‘unless’ order is warranted given the plaintiffs’ conduct and the necessity of full compliance with ORC 1753 to secure a fair trial of the AD Proceedings
- [76]
[76] The 15 Jan Affidavit, being the plaintiffs’ first attempt at compliance with ORC 1753 after they were granted a six-week extension of time, ought to have contained all of the plaintiffs’ responses to the interrogatories. Notably, the plaintiffs had sought the six-week extension of time on the ground that they required more time to obtain information from Sainz Abogados to provide a “comprehensive response” to the interrogatories. Yet, the 15 Jan Affidavit is deficient, a fact which the plaintiffs were fully aware of when they filed that affidavit. The plaintiffs therefore intentionally breached ORC 1753 at first instance. When Mr Gonzalo’s solicitors wrote the 25 Feb Letter to the plaintiffs’ solicitors to highlight the deficiencies in the 15 Jan Affidavit, the plaintiffs were put on notice of these deficiencies and thus given an opportunity remedy their breach. Yet, the further responses in the 21 Mar Affidavit remained deficient, a fact which the plaintiffs also well knew when they filed that affidavit. The plaintiffs therefore intentionally maintained their breach of ORC 1753 despite being forewarned of the same.
The justifications provided by the plaintiffs for their failure to fully comply with ORC 1753 are without merit
Mr Gonzalo’s ability to make out for himself the plaintiffs’ case on damages
- [84]
[84] More fundamentally, however, I find that the plaintiffs are precluded by the doctrine of issue estoppel from relying on what they claim Mr Gonzalo knew of the Mexico and US Proceedings as a justification for providing insufficient answers to the Identified Interrogatories.
- [85]
[85] Where a court of competent jurisdiction has determined some question of fact or law, either in the course of the same litigation or in other litigation which raises the same point between the parties, the doctrine of issue estoppel operates to preclude a litigant from advancing that same point, except in the special circumstance where there has become available to that litigant further material relevant to the correct determination of the point involved in the earlier proceedings, provided that the further material in question could not by reasonable diligence have been adduced in those earlier proceedings (see The Royal Bank of Scotland NV (formerly known as ABN Amro Bank NV) and others v TT International Ltd (nTan Corporate Advisory Pte Ltd and others, other parties) and another appeal [2015] 5 SLR 1104 (“TT International Ltd”) at [100]; Beh Chew Boo v Public Prosecutor [2021] 2 SLR 180 at [39]). There are four distinct requirements that have to be met for an issue estoppel to be established: (a) there must be a final and conclusive judgment on the merits; (b) that judgment must be of a court of competent jurisdiction; (c) there must be identity between the parties to the two sets of litigation; and (d) there must be an identity of subject matter in the two proceedings (see Goh Nellie v Goh Lian Teck and others [2007] 1 SLR(R) 453 (“Goh Nellie”) at [26]).
The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.