Court of Appeal · Decided 19 May 2004
Man B and W Diesel S E Asia Pte Ltd and Another v PT Bumi International Tankers and Another Appeal
Feedback & support[2004] SGCA 22 · Case no. CA 75/2003, 79/2003 · 6 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Chao Hick Tin JA (delivering the judgment of the court):
- [1]
[1] On 9 March 2004 we delivered a judgment (reported at [2004] 2 SLR 300) allowing an appeal by the appellants-defendants against a decision of the High Court granting damages to the respondent-plaintiff in an action in tort, on account of the fact that an engine supplied by the appellants for use on a vessel of the respondent was defective, thus resulting in the respondent suffering economic losses. We ruled that, in the circumstances of the case, the respondent was not entitled to claim in tort for the economic losses against the appellants.
- [2]
[2] There was also a related appeal which was filed by the respondent who was dissatisfied with the quantum of damages awarded by the judge. In view of our ruling on the defendants’ appeal, it followed that the respondent’s appeal had to be dismissed. The full facts of the case were set out in our earlier judgment and we do not propose to repeat them here.
- [3]
[3] Following our judgment, the appellants’ solicitors wrote to inform this court that on the third day of the trial, 24 April 2002, the appellants made an offer in the prescribed form to pay the respondent the sum of US$1.5m in settlement of its claim. The offer, which was open for acceptance within 14 days, was not accepted.
- [5]
[5] The governing provision for our present purposes is O 22A r 9(3), and it reads:
(a) The offer was not serious and genuine, being substantially less than what the trial judge held to be the damages which the respondent was entitled to.
(b) The offer was made very late, after the trial had commenced. The respondent failed in the claim because this court held that the appellants did not owe the respondent a duty of care, a point which was only raised at the start of the trial when leave to amend the defence was obtained. This court has a wide discretion in the matter and should consider all the circumstances before awarding indemnity costs.
(c) The issue of law in question was a highly controversial one and the court only came to its conclusion after much deliberation. It was a novel point.
(d) Much of the time at trial was spent on establishing the fact that the engine supplied by the appellants was defective and the cause of it.
and in O 22A r 12 which reads:
- [9]
[9] However, we would add one rider to this. Where there is no defence of any substance to a liquidated claim, then compromise is not a necessary element in an offer to settle: see The Endurance 1 at [43]. The reason for this was explained by Morden ACJO in Data General (Canada) Ltd v Molnar Systems Group Inc (1991) 85 DLR (4th) 392 (“Data General”) at 399 as follows:
- [14]
[14] It would be noted that one common feature in all these four cases discussed above is the fact that in each instance the offeror effectively expected the other party to capitulate.