Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 31 Jan 2008

High Court

Public Prosecutor v Mohammed Ali bin Johari

Feedback & support

[2008] SGHC 16Case no. CC 9/200775 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Laws this judgment relies on

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. [1] The events leading to this case attracted considerable public attention. A little girl, who had been reported missing and was the subject of a well-publicised search, was eventually found naked and dead in a recessed chamber under a flyover.

  2. [2] The deceased was Nur Asyura Binte Mohamed Fauzi, known as Nonoi to her family, and I shall also refer to her as Nonoi. She was 34 months old.

  3. [3] Nonoi’s mother is Mastura Binte Kamsir (“Mastura”). Mastura, a divorcee, was remarried to the accused Mohammed Ali bin Johari. Mastura has another child, a son named Daniel (who is also known as Didi), with the accused. The four of them, i.e. the accused, Mastura, Nonoi and Daniel formed a family unit with their home at Pipit Road (“the Pipit Road flat”).

  4. [4] The accused maintained strong links with his parents, as well as his unmarried siblings who resided at the family home at Circuit Road (“the Circuit Road flat”).

  5. [5] As Mastura worked as a masseuse and the accused was a free-lance despatch rider, they would bring the two children to the Circuit Road flat and bring them back to their Pipit Road flat after work.

  6. [6] They followed the routine on 1 March 2006. They walked with the children to the Circuit Road flat at around noon. They left the children at the flat and went on the accused’s motorcycle which was parked at the flat. They went window-shopping for furniture and had lunch, after which the accused sent Mastura to her workplace in Upper Serangoon at about 2.00 pm. The accused then returned to the Circuit Road flat at about 2.15 pm.

  7. [7] From that time on, the regularity in their lives was broken. An alarm was raised that Nonoi was missing from the Circuit Road flat. The police were alerted and the accused and Mastura, as well as the accused’s siblings went searching for her in vain over the following days.

  8. [8] On 4 March 2006, the accused confessed to Mastura and her mother Rozanah binte Salleh (“Rozanah”) that Nonoi was dead. The police were informed, and her body was subsequently recovered from a drain within a chamber under the Aljunied flyover along the Pan-Island Expressway.

  9. The initial admission

  10. [9] The accused made the revelations for the first time to Mastura and her mother Rozanah on 4 March 2006 at about 9.00 am in the Pipit Road flat.

  11. [10] Mastura’s evidence was:

  12. [11] Rozanah’s evidence was:

  13. [12] Their evidence was not disputed by the accused. He had also referred to this event in a statement to the police where he recounted that:[note: 3]

  14. The statements to the police

  15. [13] The accused went to the police on the same day and told them what had happened. Statements were recorded from him in the course of the police investigations touching on Nonoi’s death, and the statements were admitted in evidence in the trial without objections and without any suggestion put to the recording officers and the interpreters that they had misunderstood the accused, or had failed to record properly and completely what he told them.

  16. [14] On 4 March 2006, he made the first statement, which was recorded by Staff Sergeant Abdul Razak Said of the Bedok Police Division. In this statement[note: 4] the accused narrated:

  17. [15] On the same day, after Nonoi’s body was recovered, Station Inspector Noorma’at Sawab of the Criminal Investigation Department (“CID”) recorded another statement from the accused at the Geylang Serai Neighbourhood Police Post. In this second statement[note: 5], the accused revealed that:

  18. [16] The accused made a third statement during the early hours of 5 March 2006 to Senior Station Inspector Mazlan Shariff of the CID in the offices of the CID. In this statement[note: 6], the accused said:

  19. [17] Later on in the afternoon of the same day, the accused was charged with the murder of Nonoi, and Acting Inspector Roy Lim Eng Seng of the CID recorded a cautioned statement from him under s 122(6) of the Criminal Procedure Code (Cap 68, 1985 Rev Ed). In this fourth statement[note: 7], the accused stated:

  20. [18] On 8 March 2006, the investigation officer ASP Ang Bee Chin recorded a fifth statement from the accused. In this statement,[note: 8] he recounted in greater detail than he had done before the circumstances of Nonoi’s death thus:

  21. The account to the psychiatrist

  22. [19] The accused also described the events to Dr G Sathyadevan, Senior Consultant Psychiatrist, Institute of Mental Health while the doctor was making a psychiatric assessment of him. Dr Sathyadevan saw him on 14 and March, and 11 and 18 April 2006 and recorded in his report:[note: 9]

  23. The post-mortem examination

  24. [20] A post-mortem examination was carried out on Nonoi by consultant forensic pathologist Associate Professor Gilbert Lau (“A/Prof Lau”) of the Centre for Forensic Medicine. A/Prof Lau was present when Nonoi’s body was recovered on 4 March 2006. He examined the body in situ and found that she had been dead for two or three days, and he noticed some blood over the external genitalia and the perineum.

  25. [21] On 5 March 2006, A/Prof Lau conducted an autopsy of the body and put up an autopsy report.[note: 10] The relevant findings recorded in the autopsy report are:

  26. [22] Subsequently, A/Prof Lau put up a supplementary report[note: 11] after genetic analysis was carried out that:

  27. [23] On 17 August 2006, A/Prof Lau issued another report captioned Final Cause of Death:[note: 12]

  28. [24] This final certification that the cause of death was unascertained raised the question of causation, i.e. whether the accused’s actions had caused Nonoi’s death.

  29. [25] A/Prof Lau explained that he had been told of the immersions before he made his autopsy report and that he had received the accused’s statements before he gave evidence in court.

  30. [26] He added that his autopsy findings were consistent with death by drowning or secondary drowning i.e. delayed death from immersion, smothering or suffocation, and that from the accused’s accounts of the events, there were no other possible causes of death.

  31. [27] When A/Prof Lau’s reliance on the genetic studies and the medical records of Nonoi came under scrutiny, he conceded that he was not an expert on genetic examination, and that he was not able to explain fully the partial seizure and the secondary diagnosis of status epilepticus recorded in Nonoi’s clinical records.

  32. [28] After these issues came up, the prosecution applied to call two additional witnesses, namely Professor Edmund Lee of the Pharmacology Department, National University Hospital (“NUH”), who conducted the genetic screening, and Dr Foo Chong Wee, a member of the medical team at NUH which treated Nonoi and made the secondary diagnosis of status epilepticus.

  33. [29] I allowed the application. The possibility of Nonoi dying from a natural cause such as a seizure or cardiac failure must be examined against all the available and relevant information, and it would be wrong to keep out direct evidence from Prof Lee and Dr Foo.

  34. [30] Dr Foo, a House Officer (or houseman as is commonly known) when he saw Nonoi, is now a full Medical Officer in the NUH. When Nonoi was admitted to the Paediatric Ward of the NUH as an eight month-old baby on 26 January 2004, she was seen by Dr Ng Kar Hui, and the consultant in charge was Dr Kirk Charles Roland. Dr Foo was responsible for taking notes on the observations, diagnosis and prescriptions made. According to Dr Foo, Dr Kirk was an expatriate and has left Singapore, and Dr Ng was on training overseas at the time of the trial.

  35. [31] Dr Foo’s evidence was that a provisional diagnosis of status epilepticus with partial seizures was made on the day of admission when Nonoi was observed to have a partial tonic seizure. However, on 29 January 2004, when Nonoi’s case was reviewed by Dr Kirk, he diagnosed the seizures to be gastroenteritis-provoked, and that diagnosis was confirmed by Dr Ng and Dr Foo on 30 January 2004 when Nonoi was discharged. On her discharge, the principal diagnosis was gastroenteritis-provoked seizures, and the secondary diagnosis was status epilepticus.

  36. [32] A/Prof Lau had sought Prof Lee’s assistance to analyse the genetic makeup of Nonoi to investigate whether there were genetic factors that could have contributed to sudden cardiac death. Prof Lee put up a report on his screening[note: 13] with the conclusion that:

  37. He explained his findings further in his statement of evidence[note: 14] (or conditioned statement, as such a statement is also called):

  38. The call detail record

  39. [33] The investigation officer had obtained the call detail record of the accused’s mobile phone 8XXXXXXX. She obtained from the service provider MobileOne Ltd the record for the period 27 February 2006 to 4 March 2006[note: 15] which showed that there were three answered incoming calls received at that number on 3 March 2006, at 12.07 pm, 7.02 pm and 7.04 pm and three other calls made on the same day during 6.48 pm to the accused’s phone which were not answered but were forwarded.[note: 16] The effect of the evidence was that there were no calls answered on the accused’s mobile phone on 1 March 2006.

  40. The accused’s defence

  41. [34] On the basis of the accused’s statements and the autopsy findings, I found that the prosecution had presented a sufficient case for me to call on the accused to enter his defence. The accused gave evidence in his own defence, but did not call any witnesses.

  42. [35] His account of the events of 1 March 2006 leading to Nonoi’s death was broadly similar to the accounts that he had given to the police and the psychiatrist.

  43. [36] He recounted that after he sent his wife to work, he returned to his parent’s flat at Circuit Road. He took Nonoi with him as he felt that her presence would reduce the risk of drug enforcement officers stopping and checking him for drug consumption.

  44. [37] On the way back to his flat at Pipit Road, Nonoi was not her usual cheerful self, but was quiet and crying. When he brought her to a neighbourhood shop where she would usually buy something for herself, she did not want anything. They left the shop, and went to look for a friend, but the friend was not home, and they went back to the Pipit Road flat.

  45. [38] When they were at the flat, Nonoi was still crying and uncommunicative. He was annoyed at her, and scolded her, but she did not stop crying. He became angrier and slapped her face and punched her legs. Then he pulled her by her hand to the toilet and warned her that if she did not stop crying, he would immerse her in a pail. When she continued crying, he removed her clothes to frighten her.

  46. [39] He then recounted in his own words:

  47. [40] He put her clothes back on, and carried her out of the flat. He said:

  48. [41] When they were at his parents’ flat, he placed Nonoi on a bed, covered her with pillows and told the other persons in the flat that Nonoi was sleeping. Later in the day, when his mother and siblings left the flat, he took Nonoi from the bed and walked out of the flat.

  49. [42] He described what he did thereafter:

  50. [43] He returned to the Pipit Road flat alone, cleaned himself, and went back to his parents’ flat. By that time, Nonoi’s absence had been discovered. He was asked about her, but he lied that Nonoi was not with him. He went on his motorcycle to fetch his wife from her place of work, and told her that Nonoi was missing. They made a police report and he joined in the search for Nonoi.

  51. [44] He referred to the admissions he made on the morning of 4 March 2006. He said:

  52. [45] He explained that he had kept quiet for three days because:

  53. and he eventually broke his silence because:

  54. [46] I have stated that the accused’s account of the events given in his defence was broadly similar to the accounts given in his statements to the police and to the psychiatrist. There was, however, one significant difference. Whereas he had mentioned in the earlier statements that when Nonoi was immersed in the pail for the third time, his mobile phone rang, and he answered the call, that was noticeably absent from his evidence until he was cross-examined on it by the prosecutor.

  55. [47] The prosecutor took him through the parts of his statements where he had stated that his mobile phone rang and he had gone to answer it. He was first referred to [30] of his statement of 8 March 2006 set out in [18] hereof, and he said:

  56. [48] The prosecutor then referred to his first statement of 4 March 2006 set out in [14] hereof, and his response was:

  57. [49] With reference to his second statement of 4 March 2006, set out in [15] hereof, he said:

  58. [50] As for the mention of the phone call recorded in his statement of 5 March 2006 set out in [16] hereof, his explanation was:

  59. [51] He was also asked about his account of the events recorded by the psychiatrist and his reply was:

  60. [52] The prosecutor also brought the accused through his account of the events after the three immersions. The accused confirmed that after the immersions, Nonoi was weak and soft and was blinking her eyes. When he was asked why he did not seek help, he said he was in a state of panic:

  61. [53] The accused knew that Nonoi died eventually. There was some uncertainty as to the time when he realised that; it was either at the time he left the Pipit Road flat, or when he had returned to the Circuit Road flat.

  62. Evaluation of the evidence

  63. [54] There were two main issues, firstly, what did the accused do to Nonoi, and secondly, what caused Nonoi’s death.

  64. [55] What did the accused do to Nonoi? There were two parts to this question. The first was whether he had molested her and caused the genital injuries. The prosecutor argued that he must have done that and inflicted the injuries as he was the only person who was with Nonoi from the time they left the Circuit Road flat till the time she died, and that he immersed her into the pail of water to stop her crying following that.

  65. [56] There was no direct evidence on that, and the accused had not made any admissions to this in his statements when he admitted to the immersions. The prosecution did not charge him with molesting Nonoi. In any event, the alleged molestation had a limited bearing on the charge of murder that the accused faced as the genital injuries were not life-threatening. In the circumstances, it is not necessary for there to be a finding as to whether the accused had inflicted those injuries.

  66. [57] The second point was the intention and effect of the immersions. The accused admitted to immersing Nonoi head-first into a pail of water three times, and the post-mortem examination revealed conditions compatible with drowning or immersion. His evidence and his earlier accounts differ over the duration of immersion, particularly the third immersion.

  67. [58] He had, in the course of the police investigations and during the examination by the psychiatrist, said that he left Nonoi in the pail during the third immersion to answer a call on his mobile phone. The significance of this call was that it set the third immersion apart from the other two. From his description, Nonoi was immersed into the pail and withdrawn almost immediately in the first and second immersions. She did not appear to have suffered from those immersions, and continued to cry and he immersed her for the third time. The third immersion, however, ended in tragedy because he did not remove her immediately upon immersion, but left her in the pail when he answered his ringing mobile phone.

  68. [59] On the evidence, I had no doubt that he told the officers and the psychiatrist about the phone call. Defence counsel Mr Bajwa did not suggest to the recording officers and interpreters who he cross-examined or the psychiatrist, that the accounts recorded did not come from the accused, or did not reflect accurately what he had said about the immersions or the phone call. I found that he did not answer any call on his phone during the third immersion.

  69. [60] The conclusion that I came to was that the third immersion was not a quick immersion, and that he allowed Nonoi to remain immersed head-first in the pail, and that did not happen because he had to answer his phone.

  70. [61] It was clear that the accused wanted to stop Nonoi’s crying, whether because he had molested her or because she was having a tantrum. He was quite determined and did not stop after the first two immersions, and immersed her on the third occasion for a longer duration.

  71. [62] There was a secondary question - why did he not get help for her? I did not accept his explanation that he was in such a state of fear and panic that he could not speak. By his own evidence, he did not lose the ability to speak as he spoke to Nonoi and pleaded with her to wake up. Nor was he in such a state that he could not think, as he had attempted to revive her. Further, he described in [34] and [35] of his statement of 8 March 2006 set out in [18] hereof that “(a) lot of thoughts went on my mind, whether to call the police or not”, and that he carried Nonoi with her face to his neck, and he walked slowly when there were other persons, to avoid arousing their suspicions.

  72. [63] What caused Nonoi’s death? Although she had a medical history, she did not suffer from any life-threatening condition. Pathologist A/Prof Lau was unable to establish a specific cause of death because of the state of decomposition of the body when the autopsy was performed. To his credit, he arranged for genetic examination to be done to ascertain whether Nonoi could have died through natural causes.

  73. [64] Mr Bajwa argued in the closing submissions that the prosecution had not proved that the accused caused Nonoi’s death because:

  74. [65] However, A/Prof Lau’s evidence must be taken together with Prof Lee’s evidence, particularly [4] and [6] of his conditioned statement set out in [32] hereof. Prof Lee had explained that the possibility that the two genetic variants identified conferring a risk of causing cardiac arrhythmia in the presence of a trigger is speculative and not scientifically proven. Mr Bajwa did not present any material or call any witness to rebut Prof Lee’s evidence.

  75. [66] The references to seizures in the NUH records on Nonoi must be read in the context of the full records, as well as Dr Foo’s evidence. The diagnosis of status epilepticus with partial seizures was a provisional diagnosis made at the point of admission on the information that Nonoi had exhibited stiffening of the limbs and uprolling of the eyes for half an hour prior to her admission. Dr Foo’s explanation was that after further observation and treatment, the principal diagnosis was gastroenteritis-provoked seizures, with status epilepticus as the secondary diagnosis. Furthermore, the fact that the accused did not observe any stiffening limbs or uprolling eyes or other signs associated with seizures indicated that Nonoi did not have a seizure, whether from status epilepticus or other causes.

  76. [67] Mr Bajwa also submitted that the accused did not have the requisite intention to be guilty of murder in that:

  77. [68] For an offence of murder to be made out, an intention to cause death, or knowledge that the act carried out is likely to cause death does not have to be established in every case. Section 300 of the Penal Code (Cap 224, Rev Ed 1985) prescribes that murder is committed

  78. [69] The prosecution did not establish a case against the accused under limbs (a) and (b). The case against the accused fell to be considered under limb (c). The elements of s 300(c) were spelt out in the landmark decision of the Supreme Court of India in Virsa Singh v State of Punjab AIR 1958 SC 465 by V Bose J at [12]:

  79. This test has been referred to and adopted by our courts in numerous cases. In particular, the Court of Appeal in Public Prosecutor v Lim Poh Lye and Another [2005] 4 SLR 582 gave a careful explanation on the effect and application of this provision.

  80. [70] Injury is defined in s 44 of the Penal Code to include any bodily harm whatever illegally caused to a person. When the accused immersed Nonoi into the pail of water on the three occasions, he must have known that she would be unable to breathe, or she would inhale water. Her enlarged and waterlogged lungs were consistent with the latter. When water is inhaled into the lungs, that can cause death in the ordinary course of nature.

  81. [71] The pathologist found that the condition of Nonoi’s lungs was compatible with drowning or immersion, but he could not conclude that to be the cause of death on the basis of the autopsy examination because he could not exclude asphyxia and sudden cardiac failure as causes of death.

  82. [72] I was not constrained to look only at the autopsy findings, and I can and should consider all other relevant evidence. By the evidence of the accused who was with Nonoi at the time leading to her death, she was not smothered or suffocated, so death by asphyxia can be excluded.

  83. [73] Prof Lee’s findings and evidence were that there was no scientifically proven evidence that Nonoi’s genetic makeup put her at risk of sudden cardiac failure. Consequently sudden cardiac failure can also be excluded as a cause of death, and that left drowning or immersion as the cause of death.

  84. [74] On the totality of the evidence, I found that the accused knew and intended, when he immersed Nonoi head-first in the pail of water, that she would experience difficulty in breathing and might inhale water. If a person is immersed in water in that manner for a sufficient period, the person will die. In this respect, I found that the accused intentionally kept Nonoi immersed in the water for a longer duration on the third occasion and it was not accidental, and that he was not distracted by having to answer a phone call. It should also be remembered that at the trial the accused did not repeat the account about answering the phone. His evidence was that he was not sure if there was a phone call and he did not recall making the statements about answering the call. Lastly, I found, by the exclusion of other likely causes of death, that she died from the effects of the immersions.

  85. [75] The elements of s 300(c) of the Penal Code were therefore established. On that basis, I found the accused guilty and convicted him for the murder of Nonoi, and imposed the death sentence on him.

  86. [note: 1]PS17A para 13

  87. [note: 2]PS18A paras 10 and 11

  88. [note: 3]P238 para 53

  89. [note: 4]P229

  90. [note: 5]P230

  91. [note: 6]P231

  92. [note: 7]P233

  93. [note: 8]P237

  94. [note: 9]P226, para 28

  95. [note: 10]P212

  96. [note: 11]P213

  97. [note: 12]P214

  98. [note: 13]P278

  99. [note: 14]PS51

  100. [note: 15]P227

  101. [note: 16]D1, page 9

  102. [note: 17]Notes of Evidence pages 369-370

  103. [note: 18]Notes of Evidence page 370

  104. [note: 19]Notes of Evidence pages 371-372

  105. [note: 20]Notes of Evidence page 373

  106. [note: 21]Notes of Evidence page 373

  107. [note: 22]Notes of Evidence page 374

  108. [note: 23]Notes of Evidence page 404

  109. [note: 24]Notes of Evidence page 406

  110. [note: 25]Notes of Evidence page 407

  111. [note: 26]Notes of Evidence page 408

  112. [note: 27]Notes of Evidence page 436

  113. [note: 28]Notes of Evidence page 422

  114. [note: 29]Notes of Evidence page 427

  115. [note: 30]Defences’ Skeletal Submissions

  116. [note: 31]Defences’ Skeletal Submissions