Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 8 May 2026

District Court

Public Prosecutor v Santos-Tumalip Maria Monalyn Bagaporo

Feedback & support

[2026] SGDC 159Case no. District Arrest Case No. DAC-916661-2023 & 6 Ors44 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Laws this judgment relies on

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. District Judge Shaiffudin Saruwan:

  2. Introduction

  3. [1] This is an appeal against sentence by the accused in relation to four charges to which she had pleaded guilty.

  4. [2] The prosecution was conducted by DPP Tan Jing Min. The Accused was represented by counsel, Ms Lim Lei Theng, who appeared under the EGPS scheme.

  5. The charges

  6. [3] The four proceeded charges were -

  7. (a) DAC-916661-2023: This charge concerned the offence of cheating under s 417 of the Penal Code 1871 (“PC”)(“the s 417 PC charge”). This was an amalgamated charge.

  8. (b) DAC-923562-2024: This charge concerned the offence of theft-in-dwelling under s 380 PC (“the s 380 PC charge”).

  9. (c) DAC-917857-2025: This concerned the offence of committing an act to obstruct the course of justice under s 204A PC (“the s 204A PC charge”).

  10. (d) DAC-917863-2025): This concerned the offence of cheating under s 420 PC (“the s 420 PC charge”). This was an amalgamated charge.

  11. [4] One count of cheating under s 420 PC (amalgamated), one count of cheating under s 420 PC and, one count of attempted cheating under s 420 PC read with s 511(1) PC were taken into consideration.

  12. The facts

  13. The facts relating to the s 417 PC charge (amalgamated)

  14. [5] Since May 2022, the accused had ordered food from the Home of Seafood, a restaurant. For each order, she made payment to the restaurant via “PayNow”. Subsequently, she hatched a scheme to avoid paying for the food she ordered. She did this by transferring the amounts for the food she ordered to herself via “PayNow”. She then took screenshots of the “Paynow” transaction slips on her mobile phone. She then used an application called “PhotoGrid” and edited these transfer slips by changing the recipient of the monies which was herself, to “Home of Seafood”. For some of the screenshots of the transfer slips, she had also edited the details of the senders’ accounts to make it appear that payments were made from different accounts. These edited screenshots were then sent to the restaurant via WhatsApp as proof of payment. The restaurant acknowledged these purported payments, processed the accused’s orders and then delivered the food accordingly. The restaurant did not check with its bank records to verify that the payments had been made.

  15. [6] By this method, the accused had dishonestly induced the restaurant to believe that she had made payment for her orders on 23 occasions between May 2022 and April 2023. In total, she had deceived the restaurant into delivering food amounting to S$3,241.62. The accused claimed that she had done this to order food for her friends to impress them. The deceptions were discovered on 2 September 2023 when the restaurant reviewed its bank account.

  16. [7] The accused had made full restitution to the restaurant.

  17. The facts relating to the s 380 charge

  18. [8] On 27 November 2024, at about 9.38 am, the accused entered the Giant Supermarket at Bedok Road. She was holding a trolley bag and an orange and black tote bag. Subsequently, at about 10.28 am, she exited the said supermarket after paying for four items at the self-service kiosk. She was stopped and her trolley bag and tote bag were checked. Many other items belonging to the supermarket were found in these bags. They had not been paid for. The accused had dishonestly taken them from the supermarket’s possession without consent. These items were –

  19. a. One packet of Shiitake Mushroom 150G valued at $2.55/- each

  20. b. One packet Cherry Tomatoes 250G valued at $1.95/- each

  21. c. One packet Fine Bean 150G valued at $1.95/- each

  22. d. Two cans of Enoki Mushroom 200G valued at $0.80/- each

  23. e. Five packets of Beef Ribeye 200G valued at $14.50/- each

  24. f. Three packets of “Merci” Brand Chocolate 400G valued at $19.00/- each

  25. g. Two packets of “Ferrero Rocher” Brand Chocolate 200G valued at $12.10/- each

  26. h. Six packets of “Soxbox” Brand Premium Cotton Socks valued at $1.90/- each

  27. i. One packet of “Kiddylicious” Brand Blueberry Biscuit 40G valued at $11.25/- each

  28. j. One packet of “Greenlife” Brand Immunity Booster 60S valued at $24.95/- each

  29. k. One “Aveeno” Brand Dermexa Moisturising Cream 2000ML valued at $23.80/- each

  30. l. One box of “Gerber” Brand Organic Cereal 227G valued at $11.45/- each

  31. m. Two packets of “Longkou” Brand Vermicelli 250G valued at $1.80/- each

  32. n. Four “Canesten” Brand 1% Clotrimazole Cream 10G valued at $13.75/- each

  33. o. Four “Canespro” Brand Anti-fungal Cream 15G valued at $26.00/- each

  34. p. Two packets of “Biogreen” Brand Spoons 20PC valued at $3.00/- each

  35. q. One “Aveemo” Brand Dermexa Daily Body Cream 500ML valued at $44.90/- each

  36. r. Two packets of “Ambi Pure” Brand Air Freshener valued at $7.90/- each

  37. s. One packet of “Bel” Brand Plastic Forks 50S valued at $1.80/- each

  38. t. One packet of “Kiddylicious” Brand Banana Wafers 10S 4G valued at $11.25/- each

  39. u. Eleven packets of “Tiger Balm” Brand Leg Plasters 3S valued at $5.70/- each

  40. v. Two packets of “Minnamame” Brand Frozen Edamame 400G valued at $3.05/- each

  41. w. Two packets of “Coke Zero” Brand Mini Cans 6S 180ML valued at $4.95/- each

  42. x. One carton of “Oatside” Brand Oat Milk Chocolate 1L valued at $6.00/- each

  43. y. One packet of “Pigeon” Brand Baby Wipes 240S valued at $10.10/- each

  44. z. One packet of “Meadows” Brand Unsalted Mixed Nuts 1KG valued at $30.00/- each

  45. aa. One packet of “Meadows” Brand Salted Mix Nuts 1KG valued at $30.00/- each

  46. bb. One Australia Pork Prime Ribs valued at $27.24/- each

  47. cc. One Australia Pork Prime Ribs valued at $15.14/- each

  48. dd. One Thawed Pork Belly Sliced valued at $20.66/- each

  49. ee. One Tiger Prawn XXL valued at $32.17/- each

  50. The facts relating to the s 420 PC charge

  51. [9] Between 15 June 2024 to 28 May 2025, the accused committed 24 cheating offences in relation to the ordering of food and falsifying the payments by employing the same modus operandi set out at [5] above. In these offences, her victim was Baci Baci, an Italian restaurant. Pursuant to the deception, the restaurant had delivered a total of S$6,167.52 worth of food to the accused over the relevant period. The deception was only discovered on 25 May 2025.

  52. [10] The accused made full restitution for the loss to the victim.

  53. The facts relating to the s 204A PC charge

  54. [11] The complainant was the director of a hair salon called Johwa. The accused posed as someone named “Tom” and communicated with the complainant through Johwa’s WhatsApp business account. She claimed that she wanted to buy a hair treatment voucher for her sister. She sent a fabricated screenshot of payment for the voucher to Johwa’s WhatsApp account. The complainant sent the voucher to the accused.

  55. [12] On 8 June 2025, the accused went to Johwa hair salon and used the voucher to obtain a hair treatment service valued at S$381.50. Subsequently, on the same day, she contacted the Johwa WhatsApp account again and purchased another gift voucher using the same method. This time the complainant checked on the payment and found out that the payments for the voucher and for the first voucher had not in fact been received. Over the next month, employees of Johwa kept reminding the accused to make the payments. As the accused kept on giving excuses, a police report was lodged against her.

  56. [13] The investigation officer contacted the accused on 30 July 2025 and asked her to report to the Police Cantonment Complex (“PCC”) the next day for her statement to be recorded. After receiving the call, the accused then deleted all the WhatsApp messages between herself and Johwa. At PCC, she was asked why these messages had been cleared. She admitted that she had deleted them out of fear. She knew that in doing so she was likely to obstruct the course of justice.

  57. Antecedents

  58. [14] The Accused was a first offender.

  59. The sentence

  60. Parties’ sentencing positions

  61. [15] The table below showed the respective sentencing positions of the parties -

  62. Charge

  63. Prosecution

  64. Defence

  65. s 417 PC (amalgamated)

  66. 2.5 to 3 months

  67. (consecutive)

  68. [4] weeks

  69. s 380 PC

  70. [2] to 3 months

  71. [1] week

  72. s 420 PC (amalgamated)

  73. [18] to 20 months

  74. (consecutive)

  75. [4] to 6 months

  76. s 204A PC

  77. [3] to 4 months

  78. [2] months

  79. The sentence by the Court

  80. [16] I sentenced the accused to the following –

  81. Charge

  82. Sentence

  83. s 417 PC (amalgamated)

  84. Ten weeks’ imprisonment

  85. s 380 PC

  86. Eight weeks’ imprisonment

  87. s 420 PC (amalgamated)

  88. [18] months’ imprisonment

  89. s 204A PC

  90. Three months’ imprisonment

  91. I ordered the sentences in the s 380 PC charge, the s 420 PC charge and the s 204A PC charge to run consecutively, making the total aggregate sentence 21 months’ and eight weeks’ imprisonment. The reasons for the sentences were set out below.

  92. The s 417 PC charge (amalgamated)

  93. [17] The prescribed punishment for an offence under s 417 PC was imprisonment not exceeding three years, or with fine, or with both. The maximum fine that could be imposed here was $30,000. However, given that the charge was an amalgamated charge, the maximum prescribed punishment was now doubled pursuant to s 124(8)(a)(ii) of the Criminal Procedure Code 2010.

  94. [18] The sentence approach for an amalgamated charge was set out in Prakash s/o Mathivanan v PP and other appeals [2025] SGHC 167 (“Prakash”). The framework comprised a three-stage approach –

  95. (a) At the first stage, the Court must identify the punishment prescribed for the base offence committed, and the sentencing factors for the base offence.

  96. (b) At the second stage, the Court will determine the appropriate starting point sentence, based on a holistic assessment of the offender’s culpability over the entire course of conduct, the aggregate harm caused, and the doubled punishment limit under s 124(8)(a)(ii) of the CPC.

  97. (c) At the third stage, the Court must then consider the relevant offender-specific aggravating and mitigating factors to determine whether adjustments are required to the starting point sentence.

  98. [19] In sentencing for financial and property offences, as a general principle, the greater the economic value involved in the offence, the heavier the sentence: per Gan Chai Bee Anne v PP [2019] 4 SLR 855 at [42] and [43] (“Gan Chai Bee Anne”). The amount involved was $3,241.62. I accepted both parties’ submissions that the amount was not a significantly high amount. I noted that the manner in which the offence was committed was not very sophisticated. However, there were two aggravating factors present which I found to be significant. First, the accused had persisted in the offending conduct for more than a year. By this she had exhibited a significant degree of brazenness and greed. Secondly, three other cheating offences were taken into consideration. All considered, I accepted that the harm-culpability level was low.

  99. [20] The court in Gan Chai Bee Anne also held that a custodial sentence was generally appropriate for an offence punishable under s 417 PC as long as the offence in question caused a victim to part with property that had more than negligible value: at [47] of the judgment. The court also made the observation that the cases cited in the Sentencing Practice in the Subordinate Courts (LexisNexis, 3rd Ed, 2013) (“Sentencing Practice”) indicated that custodial sentences for terms of between four to eight months’ imprisonment have been imposed for cheating offences that resulted in losses of between $1,000 and $15,000. For example, in Chew Im v PP, which was cited in the Sentencing Practice, the offender had pleaded guilty to two counts under s 417 PC involving S$5,000 and S$3,000 and the sentences imposed were eight months’ imprisonment on each charge with both sentences to run concurrently. Full restitution was made.

  100. [21] In another case, Idya Nurhazlyn bte Ahmad Khir v PP [2014] 1 SLR 756 (“Idya Nurhazlyn”), the offender had pleaded guilty to, inter alia, two charges under s 417 PC. She had also consented to have four charges taken into consideration; two of which comprised s 417 PC charges. In the first s 417 PC charge, the offender had deceived her aunt into believing that she could buy Apple products at a low price. Her aunt placed an order for several Apply products and transferred S$1,800 to the offender. Full restitution was made. For the first charge, she was sentenced to two months’ imprisonment. On appeal, it was reduced to one month’s imprisonment. In the second s 417 PC charge, the accused had placed an order with the victim’s company for Sony products worth S$10, 509. She issued a cheque which she knew would be dishonoured. She made restitution of S$7,586.58, while S$2,922.42 worth of Sony products were recovered. She was sentenced to three months’ imprisonment.

  101. [22] I was of the view that for the present case, the base sentence should rightly be about 10 weeks’ imprisonment. The accused’s culpability was only marginally higher than that of the offender in Idya Nurhazlyn (in relation to the first charge) This was because the modus operandi of the accused in the present case was more sophisticated as it involved the creation of fictitious payment slips. The level of harm in the present case was also higher given that the amount involved was twice the amount in Idya Nurhazlyn. These two factors moderated the abuse of trust factor in Idya Nurhazlyn which did not feature in the present case. I held the view that had the charge in the present case not been an amalgamated charge, a one-month imprisonment sentence would have been apt. As the charge was an amalgamated charge, an uplift was warranted to account for the accused’s culpability over the entire course of conduct. On this basis, I found the prosecution’s suggested sentencing range of two and a half months to three months’ imprisonment to be appropriate. All considered, I imposed a sentence of 10 weeks’ imprisonment. The sentence was also proportionally not inconsistent with the sentence meted out in PP v Jeremy Francis Cruez [2024] SGDC 293 (“Jeremy Francis Cruez”) cited by the prosecution. In that case, the offender had pleaded guilty to one amalgamated charge under s 417 PC. Four other similar charges were taken into consideration. The offender had deceived his company into paying him S$118,384 for fumigation supplies. He had submitted forged invoices to his company. These invoices contained a 5% mark-up from the actual amount spent to purchase the fumigation supplies. He pocketed the difference. He then purchased the supplies at a lower price. The offence carried on for three years. The actual loss caused to the company was S$12,953.73. He was sentenced to six months’ imprisonment.

  102. [23] I did not accept the defence’s proposal of four weeks’ imprisonment as it did not accurately reflect the accused’s culpability over the entire course of conduct. In arriving at the sentence above, I have also given the appropriate weight to the accused’s mental condition, which according to Dr Yap Hwa Ling of the Department of Psychological Medicine, Changi General Hospital, had contributed to the offence vide the medical report dated 5 November 2024. Of more significance was the fact that full restitution was made. This indicated remorse and substantially reduced the economic harm suffered by the victim.

  103. The s 420 PC charge (amalgamated)

  104. [24] I would deal first with the defence’s submissions that because the modus operandi used in this charge and in the s 417 PC charge were similar, it was unfair to impose vastly different sentences for the same conduct and the same mens rea, only because the offences charged with were under different provisions. It was important to understand why the prosecution had invoked s 417 for the first cheating offence and s 420 for the second cheating offence. The chronology of events was set out below.

  105. [25] On 16 October 2023, the charge preferred for the first cheating offence was under s 420 PC (amalgamated). The case was subsequently fixed for the accused to plead guilty on 18 August 2025. On 22 July 2025, as part of the on-going negotiation process, the charge was amended to s 417 PC (amalgamated). Then on 15 August 2025, the prosecution applied to have the case brought back to pre-trial conference because the accused was under investigations for fresh offences. These investigations culminated in other charges being preferred against the accused, including the second cheating offence under s 420 PC. Although the prosecution had the discretion to revert to the original s 420 PC charge for the first cheating offence, they decided not to do so.

  106. [26] Considering the context set out above, I did not find that there was inherent unfairness to sentence the first cheating offence under s 417 PC and the second cheating offence under s 420 PC even though the modus operandi was the same. On the contrary, I found that the net outcome was in favour of the accused. Notwithstanding the similar modus operandi in both charges, the court would have to consider the full spectrum of the penal sanctions prescribed for each of the two offences ie, for the s 417 PC charge, the maximum imprisonment term prescribed was three years imprisonment while for the s 420 PC charge, it was 10 years imprisonment.

  107. [27] The same frameworks at [18] and [19] above applied. The loss occasioned was S$6,167.52. Full restitution was made. The prosecution cited PP v Musadiq s/o Abbas [2019] SGDC 254 (“Musadiq”) was cited as a guide on account of the close similarity in the facts of the two cases. The offender in Musadiq had pleaded guilty to one count of cheating under s 420 PC. The charge was an amalgamated charge. One similar cheating charge was taken into consideration. The offender had cheated CapitaLand by creating 18 CapitaStar accounts through misusing the data of 18 individuals. He lied to sellers on Carousell that he wanted to buy their handphones. By doing this, he deceived them into sending him the original receipts of their handphones to him. When he faced difficulty in obtaining more of such receipts, he edited the receipts he had obtained to reflect different dates and times of purchase and receipt numbers. He then used these receipts to redeem a total of S$4,070 worth of Star$ and CapitaLand vouchers. The offender was sentenced to 15 months’ imprisonment.

  108. [28] Clearly the methodology and sophistication exhibited in Musadiq was closely similar to the present case. However, the presence of three other aggravating factors in the present case warranted a sentence that was higher than the one meted out in Musadiq - The amount involved in the present case was higher; the offence was committed whilst the accused was on court bail for the s 417 PC offence and, three other cheating offences were taken into consideration. For these reasons I accepted the prosecution’s submission that an uplift of three months was warranted, making the sentence 18 months’ imprisonment.

  109. [29] The defence’s proposed sentence of four to six months imprisonment was, in my mind, untenable. The premise was that for the s 417 PC charge, the prosecution had proposed a sentence ranging from two and a half months to three months. As the modus operandi in both these cheating offences was the same, therefore the sentence for the s 420 PC charge could not six times higher. I did not agree. As I had stated above, the court had to consider the full spectrum of the sentencing range prescribed for the offence. The sentence of 18 months’ imprisonment on the full spectrum of a maximum of 10 years was reasonable and did not breach the principle of fairness.

  110. The s 380 PC charge

  111. [30] The accused had stolen a total of 31 assorted food items from the Giant supermarket at Bedok Road. She committed the offence about a month after she was charged in court for the s 417 PC charge and was placed on court bail. Her modus operandi was to pay for only four food items at the self-service kiosk and not for the 31 other items, before she exited the supermarket. An alert loss prevention officer had discovered her ploy and she was detained. She had exhibited a high level of brazenness. Although all the items were recovered, and no actual loss was occasioned, no credit could be given to her. On the basis of the value involved ie, $738.76 alone, the defence’s submission of one week’s imprisonment was unsupportable. In PP v Praveen Nivash Velmurugan In [2025] SGDC 45 (“Praveen”), a case cited by the defence, the offender had stolen items valued at S$127.53. He pleaded guilty to the charge which was an amalgamated charge. The sentence imposed was one week’s imprisonment. Given that the value stolen in the present case was significantly higher, and the offence was committed whilst the accused was on court bail for another property-related offence, the appropriate sentence should be significantly higher than that imposed in Praveen. In that regard, I sentenced the accused to eight weeks’ imprisonment for this offence.

  112. The s 204A PC charge

  113. [31] In assessing the appropriate sentence for this offence, I needed to consider two things – (i) the effect of the attempt to pervert the course of justice and, (ii) the degree of persistence, premeditation and sophistication demonstrated.

  114. [32] The accused had deleted all WhatsApp messages between herself and the Johwa WhatsApp account. She did this after she had been contacted by the Police to go to the Police Cantonment Complex to furnish a statement concerning a cheating offence committed against Johwa. She was also on court bail when she committed this offence. The predicate offence was the serious offence of cheating under s 420 PC. It was noted that the accused had not persisted in the offence. She had confessed to the act the next day when she was asked by the Police. Also her action of deleting the messages did not significantly hinder the investigation as the Police had obtained the same messages from Johwa’s WhatsApp account.

  115. [33] I took guidance from three case precedents cited by the prosecution. These were all plead guilty cases –

  116. (a) PP v Joshua Tan Jun Liang [2023] SGDC 2 (“Joshua Tan”): The s 204A PC offence was one of seven charges that the offender had pleaded guilty to. He had thrown away his mobile phone intending to destroy evidence of his communications with the co-accused persons concerning a scheme to defraud the government vide the Skills Future Credit programme. Because of this act, the Police had to expend an additional six weeks gathering the evidence from other sources. He was sentenced to three months’ imprisonment.

  117. (b) PP v Chng Min Sheng [2024] SGDC 102 (“Chng”): The s 204A offence was one of 20 charges the offender had pleaded guilty to. He had smashed his mobile phone and disposed of the SIM card before he was arrested. He did this to conceal all communications relating to harassments done on behalf of unlicensed moneylenders. He has previous convictions for, inter alia, offences under the Moneylenders Act. He was sentenced to four months’ imprisonment.

  118. (c) PP v Ivan Goh Feng Jun [2024] SGDC 46 (“Ivan Goh”): The s 204A PC offence was one of five charges that he had pleaded guilty to. He had deleted his WhatsApp chat logs with his accomplice to conceal evidence of their scheme to commit chargeback fraud against banks. He had previous convictions for cheating. He was sentenced to six months’ imprisonment.

  119. [34] As the accused was a first offender, the sentence imposed should not be more than the sentence meted out in Joshua Tan. Although the accused had committed the offence whilst she was on court bail, this aggravating factor was moderated by the fact that unlike in Joshua Tan, her action had not hindered investigations. All considered, I sentenced the accused to three months’ imprisonment. In my view this sentence sufficiently addressed the principal of deterrence which was the primary sentencing consideration for a s 204A PC offence: Parthiban a/l Kanapathy v PP [2021] 2 SLR 847.

  120. Concurrent and/or consecutive sentences

  121. [35] I ordered the sentences in the s 420 PC charge, the s 380 PC charge and the s 204A PC charge to run consecutively. They were distinct offences and related to different legally protected interests. The total aggregate sentence was not, in my mind, crushing or disproportionate to the overall criminality exhibited by the accused, which was very high.

  122. Conclusion

  123. [36] The accused has lodged an appeal against sentence. She is presently serving her sentence.

  124. DPP Tan Jing Min (Attorney-General’s Chambers) for the Prosecution

  125. Ms Lim Lei Theng (Ms) (EGPS counsel) for the Accused