Skip to content
Official report

Hansard

Hansard, Friday, 28 February 2025

Feedback & support

The text

(1)

Rise in Use of "Buy Now, Pay Later" Schemes among Young Consumers and Its Impact on Risk of Over-spending and Credit Assessments 1 Mr Yip Hon Weng asked the Prime Minister and Minister for Finance with regard to the rising use of Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL) schemes among young consumers (a) what regulations govern BNPL schemes to address the potential risks associated with easy access to large purchases; (b) how is appropriate credit assessment of young users ensured before approving their use of such platforms; (c) whether their outstanding BNPL payments are factored into total debt servicing ratio calculations; and (d) how are youths educated on responsible BNPL usage and financial prudence.

(2)

Rise in Use of "Buy Now, Pay Later" Schemes among Young Consumers and Its Impact on Risk of Over-spending and Credit Assessments Sir, "Buy Now, Pay Later" (BNPL) transactions remain small, compared to other means of consumer payment, accounting for about 1% of the value of total credit card and debit card payments in the first half of 2024.

(3)

Rise in Use of "Buy Now, Pay Later" Schemes among Young Consumers and Its Impact on Risk of Over-spending and Credit Assessments While the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) does not currently regulate BNPL firms, those operating in Singapore have committed to the BNPL Code of Conduct that was developed under MAS' guidance to mitigate the risk of debt accumulation and to protect the user interests. MAS provided details on the safeguards in the BNPL Code in our past replies to Parliamentary Questions in November 2022 and more recently, in February this year.

(4)

Rise in Use of "Buy Now, Pay Later" Schemes among Young Consumers and Its Impact on Risk of Over-spending and Credit Assessments Under the BNPL Code, accredited firms can only offer BNPL services to customers aged 18 years and above, and are not allowed to extend more than $2,000 in credit to a customer unless they conduct an additional credit assessment. The credit assessment includes conducting income checks and credit checks against the BNPL credit bureau, which includes information on BNPL users' outstanding balances, missed payments and delinquencies amongst accredited firms.

(5)

Rise in Use of "Buy Now, Pay Later" Schemes among Young Consumers and Its Impact on Risk of Over-spending and Credit Assessments The Total Debt Servicing Ratio (TDSR) includes monthly debt obligations from all credit facilities granted by financial institutions regulated by MAS. These account for 98% of all credit granted to Singapore households by commercial entities. MAS does not require financial institutions to include outstanding BNPL amounts when computing the TDSR requirements, recognising that BNPL outstanding amounts tend to be relatively small with safeguards to prevent snowballing.

(6)

Rise in Use of "Buy Now, Pay Later" Schemes among Young Consumers and Its Impact on Risk of Over-spending and Credit Assessments MoneySense, our national financial education programme, shares content on the importance of money management and financial budgeting on its website and social media channels. These include advising consumers to beware of spending beyond their means while using BNPL schemes and other instalment plans. The national school curriculum from primary up to the tertiary level has incorporated key financial concepts, such as the effects of compound interest and the responsible use of credit. The efforts are complemented by talks and exhibitions organised for youths by MoneySense.

(7)

Rise in Use of "Buy Now, Pay Later" Schemes among Young Consumers and Its Impact on Risk of Over-spending and Credit Assessments MAS continues to monitor developments in the BNPL sector and will review its regulatory framework as appropriate.

(8)

Rise in Use of "Buy Now, Pay Later" Schemes among Young Consumers and Its Impact on Risk of Over-spending and Credit Assessments Mr Yip.

(9)

Rise in Use of "Buy Now, Pay Later" Schemes among Young Consumers and Its Impact on Risk of Over-spending and Credit Assessments Thank you, Mr Speaker. I thank the Minister of State for his response. I understand it is only 1% but considering the take-up of such services, and I am more concerned about youths and young adults, and the growing popularity of BNPL schemes, does MAS foresee the necessity for stricter regulatory frameworks beyond the existing Code of Conduct? And what proactive steps are being considered to adapt to potential future challenges posed by BNPL schemes?

(10)

Rise in Use of "Buy Now, Pay Later" Schemes among Young Consumers and Its Impact on Risk of Over-spending and Credit Assessments Sir, I thank Mr Yip for his supplementary questions. I think we need to look at it in three parts. First, the responsibility of the regulator, in this case MAS, the responsibility of the industry and the responsibility of the individual borrower. On MAS' part, as the regulator, as I mentioned, MAS has provided guidance on the development of the BNPL Code. It has also worked with MoneySense, the financial education programme, to encourage users to spend within their means. MAS will continue to monitor the BNPL sector and its development, and review the regulatory framework, as appropriate.

(11)

Rise in Use of "Buy Now, Pay Later" Schemes among Young Consumers and Its Impact on Risk of Over-spending and Credit Assessments On the industry's part, the code has already been in place since 2023. I have mentioned that in previous Parliamentary replies, but I also wanted to highlight that there is also a BNPL credit bureau which shares information on customers' outstanding amounts and delinquency status. I also wanted to let the Member know that all four BNPL firms are now accredited to the BNPL Code and they must ensure customers that fail to pay on time are not able to use their BNPL services to make additional purchases.

(12)

Rise in Use of "Buy Now, Pay Later" Schemes among Young Consumers and Its Impact on Risk of Over-spending and Credit Assessments That is what the regulator can do. That is what industry can do. I think it is also important that borrowers and individuals also bear responsibility for their own individual purchases. There is a good CNA article about the BNPL issue and it spoke about the different purchases, particularly made by youths and young people in spending what they want and what they need. One big takeaway was this - many of the youths there who had BNPL purchases spoke of cost of living, but they also mentioned their choices of living in terms of expenditure and also living beyond their means.

(13)

Rise in Use of "Buy Now, Pay Later" Schemes among Young Consumers and Its Impact on Risk of Over-spending and Credit Assessments So, in short: regulator must play their part; industry must play their part; but so too borrowers must play their part.

(14)

Subsidies for School Bus Attendants for Phone and Mobile Data Plan Purchases if Their Work Requires Use of Apps The following question stood in the name of Dr Tan Wu Meng –

(15)

Subsidies for School Bus Attendants for Phone and Mobile Data Plan Purchases if Their Work Requires Use of Apps 2 To ask the Minister for Education (a) whether the Ministry has received reports about school bus attendants being required to install and use mobile apps for their duties, such as a school transport app, and not having been reimbursed for (i) mobile phone purchases or (ii) mobile data used for such duties; (b) if so, how many reports have been received; and (c) whether the Ministry will consider providing support to affected school bus attendants.

(16)

Subsidies for School Bus Attendants for Phone and Mobile Data Plan Purchases if Their Work Requires Use of Apps Question No 2.

(17)

Subsidies for School Bus Attendants for Phone and Mobile Data Plan Purchases if Their Work Requires Use of Apps Mr Speaker, no school bus attendant has been required by the Ministry of Education (MOE) to install and use mobile applications for their duties.

(18)

Subsidies for School Bus Attendants for Phone and Mobile Data Plan Purchases if Their Work Requires Use of Apps As part of its efforts to improve work efficiencies and support the school bus sector, MOE had invited willing school bus drivers and attendants to trial a mobile web-based application to take attendance of the students taking their school buses. This trial is voluntary as we understand that school bus operators may have their preferred means to take attendance or would have other considerations such as cost of purchasing mobile phones.

(19)

Encouraging SMEs to Protect Their Intellectual Property Business Interests 3 Mr Neil Parekh Nimil Rajnikant asked the Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Trade and Industry (a) what steps has the Government taken to encourage small and medium enterprises (SMEs) to protect their intellectual property (IP) business interests for the Singapore and global markets; (b) what issues have the SMEs faced in their efforts to protect their IP business interests; and (c) what roles can trade associations and chambers of commerce play in assisting SMEs in this area.

(20)

Encouraging SMEs to Protect Their Intellectual Property Business Interests Mr Speaker, the Singapore IP Strategy 2030 (SIPS 2030) was launched by the Ministry of Law, Ministry of Finance and Ministry of Trade and Industry in 2021 to grow Singapore as a global hub for Intangible Assets and Intellectual Property (IA/IP) activities and transactions, as well as to maintain Singapore's highly regarded IA/IP regime.

(21)

Encouraging SMEs to Protect Their Intellectual Property Business Interests As part of SIPS 2030, the Government launched the GoBusiness IP Grow platform in 2023 to better support the enterprises' IP needs and to help them grow and expand globally. The platform connects enterprises with third-party IP service providers for assistance in areas like IP search and registration. Enterprises can also get help from IP Business Clinics through the platform. First-timers can receive a complimentary 45-minute consultation session with participating service providers to receive advice on IP strategy and matters concerning expanding into overseas markets.

(22)

Encouraging SMEs to Protect Their Intellectual Property Business Interests To help enterprises leverage IP to drive business growth, the Government has set up more than 15 enterprise touchpoints island-wide at Startup Accelerators and Incubators, as well as SME Centres that are run by trade associations and chambers (TACs). The Intellectual Property Office of Singapore (IPOS) works with these touchpoints to support the IP needs of our SMEs. IPOS help enterprises with their IP needs and supports the TACs by training their SME Centre Business Advisors on IP-related topics and by integrating IP support into the TACs' programmes.

(23)

Encouraging SMEs to Protect Their Intellectual Property Business Interests To address companies' feedback on the costs of IP protection, Enterprise Singapore's Enterprise Development Grant offsets the IP fees that the companies incur when developing innovative and new products, and the Market Readiness Assistance Grant covers IP registration costs in overseas markets.

(24)

Encouraging SMEs to Protect Their Intellectual Property Business Interests The Government will continue to support our SMEs in leveraging IP for growth locally and internationally and to strengthen Singapore's position as a Global-Asia node for technology, innovation and enterprise.

(25)

Percentage of Financial Crime Cases with Confiscated Assets Returned to Victims and Forfeited by Government 4 Mr Gerald Giam Yean Song asked the Minister for Home Affairs (a) what percentage of financial crime cases that involve confiscated assets result in full or partial restitution to victims; (b) what proportion of seized scam proceeds in the past five years have been forfeited to the state rather than returned to victims; and (c) what measures are in place to ensure that all reasonably identifiable scam victims receive restitution before funds are transferred to the Government's consolidated fund.

(26)

Percentage of Financial Crime Cases with Confiscated Assets Returned to Victims and Forfeited by Government When investigating financial crime cases, the Police would freeze bank accounts and seize any assets suspected to be proceeds of crime or which constitute evidence. The Police do their best to ascertain the ownership of the seized property by examining bank transaction records. The seized property may often be needed for continuing investigations or subsequent court proceedings. If they are not so needed, the Police would apply to the Court for the property to be returned to the rightful owners.

(27)

Percentage of Financial Crime Cases with Confiscated Assets Returned to Victims and Forfeited by Government Where the persons entitled to the seized property cannot be ascertained or found, the Police would publish a notice in the Government Gazette to request for persons to establish their claim to the property within six months. The seized property would only be forfeited to the state if no one establishes a claim after the six-month notice period.

(28)

Percentage of Financial Crime Cases with Confiscated Assets Returned to Victims and Forfeited by Government It is operationally challenging to apportion and thus track the amount of scam proceeds returned to victims or forfeited to the state. This is because seized proceeds could be co-mingled with other non-scam-related activities, such as cases involving unlicensed moneylending proceeds. Seized proceeds may also not be directly correlated to crime committed in that same year. It would also be resource-intensive, given the high volume of scam cases. The Ministry of Home Affairs will explore the feasibility of tracking these amounts in the longer term.

(29)

Percentage of Financial Crime Cases with Confiscated Assets Returned to Victims and Forfeited by Government Mr Giam.

(30)

Percentage of Financial Crime Cases with Confiscated Assets Returned to Victims and Forfeited by Government I thank the Minister of State for her reply. In the case of the $3 billion money laundering case that was reported recently, has the Government Gazette been published to invite potential victims to submit their claims, and if not, when would that be?

(31)

Percentage of Financial Crime Cases with Confiscated Assets Returned to Victims and Forfeited by Government Secondly, has the Government considered establishing a scam victim restitution fund which is financed by the proceeds of these confiscated money laundering proceeds so that local scam victims can also be able to make claims and get some restitution for, in many cases, the thousands of dollars that they have lost in scams?

(32)

Percentage of Financial Crime Cases with Confiscated Assets Returned to Victims and Forfeited by Government I thank the Member for his follow-up questions. Specifically, on the $3 billion case, as it is specific to that case, could I invite the Member to file a separate Parliamentary Question, because it is quite case-specific?

(33)

Percentage of Financial Crime Cases with Confiscated Assets Returned to Victims and Forfeited by Government On his other proposal regarding whether or not there could be a consolidated fund of some sorts where victims could perhaps through the fund, be able to recover some of their lost amounts, I would like to say that various proposals are being considered to see how best to be able to compensate victims. But what I would like to add is the operational challenges that I had shared earlier in my main reply, which is that often times, the monies that are recovered by the Anti-Scam Centre, through the course of investigations, we are not able to ascertain specifically that all the monies recovered actually all pertain to scams. Because often times, the syndicates that run these scams operate a lot of various other crime business lines as well. I had mentioned illegal moneylending, for instance. So, the proceeds which are recovered by the Anti-Scam Centre are not just scam proceeds. There could be other proceeds that pertain to other forms of crime and therefore, there are other victims who may also similarly feel that they have a claim to those proceeds. So, that is the first point I would like to make.

(34)

Percentage of Financial Crime Cases with Confiscated Assets Returned to Victims and Forfeited by Government The second point I would like to make is that it is often very difficult to be able to track whether this dollar that is part of the proceeds and monies recovered actually is that dollar which was lost to one particular victim. And that is because of the co-mingling of funds. I think people who understand the scam landscape know that this co-mingling and in the cases where cryptocurrency is involved because of the use of cryptocurrency tumblers and mixers, it is often very, very difficult to ascertain for that dollar recovered, from which victim that dollar has actually been scammed from.

(35)

Percentage of Financial Crime Cases with Confiscated Assets Returned to Victims and Forfeited by Government As a result of that, it is thus going to be very difficult for us to be able to say, when you have a consolidated fund, which victim actually has a right to the monies that have been recovered.

(36)

Percentage of Financial Crime Cases with Confiscated Assets Returned to Victims and Forfeited by Government The next point I would like to add is that, as you can tell from the latest numbers, total losses are $1.1 billion this year; monies recovered this year are $182 million. It is a fraction of the total amounts of monies lost. So, there are going to be far more claimants for the monies than there are actually proceeds in the monies that are recovered. So, at the end of the day, victims if they ever are to be able to recover some portion of their monies, it is going to be a tiny fraction of what they lost in the first place.

(37)

Percentage of Financial Crime Cases with Confiscated Assets Returned to Victims and Forfeited by Government The very last point I would like to add is that we should also be concerned about how scammers, if they know that we have such a consolidated fund, how they may try to pivot and see how they could potentially entice other types of mules to participate in scam activities and potentially then, try to "recover" the monies from this scam recovery fund.

(38)

Percentage of Financial Crime Cases with Confiscated Assets Returned to Victims and Forfeited by Government So, I am just trying to share with you that there are various, various difficulties and concerns that we have. But at the end of the day, principle-wise, I agree with you that we should do our very best to be able to find some way of recovering proceeds and of course, compensating victims. [Please refer to "Clarification by Minister of State for Home Affairs", Official Report, 28 February 2025, Vol 95, Issue 155, Correction By Written Statement section.]

(39)

Supply Chain Resiliency for Replacement Parts of Motorised Mobility Devices Covered Under Government Subsidy Schemes The following question stood in the name of Dr Tan Wu Meng –

(40)

Supply Chain Resiliency for Replacement Parts of Motorised Mobility Devices Covered Under Government Subsidy Schemes 5 To ask the Minister for Health (a) whether vendors providing motorised mobility devices eligible for subsidy schemes such as the Seniors' Mobility and Enabling Fund or the Assistive Technology Fund are required to maintain adequate supply chains for replacement parts such as device batteries; and (b) whether such vendors are subject to responsiveness standards for device repairs including parts replacements.

(41)

Supply Chain Resiliency for Replacement Parts of Motorised Mobility Devices Covered Under Government Subsidy Schemes Question No 5.

(42)

Supply Chain Resiliency for Replacement Parts of Motorised Mobility Devices Covered Under Government Subsidy Schemes Mr Speaker, the Seniors' Mobility and Enabling Fund (SMF) and Assistive Technology Fund (ATF) provide eligible seniors and persons with disabilities with means-tested subsidies of up to 90% for assistive devices, including motorised mobility devices, its replacement parts and repairs.

(43)

Supply Chain Resiliency for Replacement Parts of Motorised Mobility Devices Covered Under Government Subsidy Schemes SMF and ATF beneficiaries can purchase their subsidised motorised devices from vendors via different touch points including the Agency for Integrated Care (AIC), public healthcare institutions and social service agencies. We do not impose device repairs and replacements standards on every vendor working with these touch points today. Clients who need greater assurance can purchase devices from vendors who offer warranties that ensures repairs and replacements are completed within a stipulated time period. For example, all vendors appointed by AIC offer such warranties.

(44)

Spot Checks to Ensure Drivers of Commercial Vehicles Hold Valid Driving Licences 6 Mr Yip Hon Weng asked the Minister for Home Affairs (a) how frequently does the Traffic Police conduct spot checks at work sites or workplaces to verify that drivers of commercial vehicles, particularly foreigners, hold valid driving licences; and (b) how many of such drivers have been found to be working without a valid driving licence in the past five years.

(45)

Spot Checks to Ensure Drivers of Commercial Vehicles Hold Valid Driving Licences Mr Speaker, the Traffic Police (TP) does not conduct spot checks at work sites or workplaces to verify drivers' licences. Instead, checks of commercial vehicle drivers, including foreign drivers, are conducted on public roads during patrol operations.

(46)

Spot Checks to Ensure Drivers of Commercial Vehicles Hold Valid Driving Licences In the past five years, an average of 270 foreign motorists per year were found to have been driving a commercial vehicle without a valid driving licence. In 2024, there was a spike in the number of cases by 47%, to 292 cases. TP is concerned about this trend, and has been stepping up its enforcement and public education efforts.

(47)

Spot Checks to Ensure Drivers of Commercial Vehicles Hold Valid Driving Licences Mr Yip.

(48)

Spot Checks to Ensure Drivers of Commercial Vehicles Hold Valid Driving Licences Thank you, Mr Speaker. I thank the Minister of State of his reply. My concern is really about road safety, especially when many of these drivers do not have valid driving licences. What measures are in place to hold employers accountable for ensuring that their commercial vehicle drivers possess valid licences? And has the Ministry considered implementing stricter penalties for companies that fail to comply with these regulations?

(49)

Spot Checks to Ensure Drivers of Commercial Vehicles Hold Valid Driving Licences Sir, I thank the Member for the supplementary questions and also for the suggestions he made relating to how we can work with the employers. Indeed, TP has already been working with the Ministry of Manpower (MOM) on this issue and will continue to do so, such as through tapping on their outreach channels and also engaging industry stakeholders, such as those in the food delivery and goods delivery sectors.

(50)

Spot Checks to Ensure Drivers of Commercial Vehicles Hold Valid Driving Licences This is regardless of whether it is the driver or the employer of the driver who committed the offence, because the penalties that are upon the driver also apply to any person who employs or permits another person to drive a motor vehicle on the road without a valid licence.

(51)

Spot Checks to Ensure Drivers of Commercial Vehicles Hold Valid Driving Licences So, we continue to engage the employers and also would want to remind them that at the end of the day, it is about road safety as well. We are very concerned about this spike, so we will continue to engage the community, the stakeholders and at the same time, enhance our enforcement efforts and in reaching out to the people.

(52)

Singapore's Position on Proposals for Resolving Israeli-Palestinian Conflict that will Lead to Displacement of Palestinians in Gaza 7 Mr Gerald Giam Yean Song asked the Minister for Foreign Affairs (a) whether Singapore has taken a position on the unilateral proposals for resolving the Israeli-Palestinian conflict that involve the forced displacement of Palestinians in Gaza; and (b) if so, what are the key principles underpinning this position.

(53)

Singapore's Position on Proposals for Resolving Israeli-Palestinian Conflict that will Lead to Displacement of Palestinians in Gaza Mr Speaker, Singapore has consistently supported the right of the Palestinian people to a homeland of their own. We believe that this is the only viable path for achieving a comprehensive, just and durable solution to this long-standing and tragic Israeli-Palestinian conflict, and that the only path is a negotiated two-state solution, in particular, negotiations between Palestinians and the Isrealis. This principled position is consistent with the relevant United Nations Security Council resolutions.

(54)

Singapore's Position on Proposals for Resolving Israeli-Palestinian Conflict that will Lead to Displacement of Palestinians in Gaza Mr Giam.

(55)

Singapore's Position on Proposals for Resolving Israeli-Palestinian Conflict that will Lead to Displacement of Palestinians in Gaza Sir, can I ask the Minister if Singapore has sought the United States' (US') clarifications on what it intends to do to follow through with President Trump's proposal regarding Gaza? And would it seek to reflect the concerns of Singaporeans with the US as well, in this engagement with the US?

(56)

Singapore's Position on Proposals for Resolving Israeli-Palestinian Conflict that will Lead to Displacement of Palestinians in Gaza Mr Speaker, no, we have not been consulted by the US on this specific proposal that President Trump announced some time ago. But our position is clear. I have just stated it just now. In fact, I have stated it repeatedly, over the years, and it is an unchanged principled position. Everyone is aware of our position on this.

(57)

Efforts to Promote and Nurture Young Golfing Talent in Singapore 8 Ms Yeo Wan Ling asked the Minister for Culture, Community and Youth what programmes are available to help promote and nurture young golfing talent in Singapore considering that access to public golf facilities and courses is now limited due to the reallocation and closure of such public facilities.

(58)

Efforts to Promote and Nurture Young Golfing Talent in Singapore Sir, Sport Singapore provides the overarching framework to encourage an increasingly strong sporting culture and participation in Singapore, as well as the development and nurturing of high performance athletes at all levels. In the case of golf, Sport Singapore works closely with the Singapore Golf Association (SGA) to promote and develop the sport of golf in Singapore.

(59)

Efforts to Promote and Nurture Young Golfing Talent in Singapore SGA identifies and grooms talented junior golfers through programmes such as the SGA Future Squad which provides a structured pathway into SGA's High-Performance programmes. For golfers in SGA's Junior Development, Development, Junior National and National Squads, SGA conducts weekly training for them at the Sembawang Country Club, Keppel Club and Sentosa Golf Club. Depending on training requirements, the Squads also have access to other private clubs such as the Singapore Island Country Club, Tanah Merah Country Club and Seletar Country Club which support SGA's national programmes.

(60)

Efforts to Promote and Nurture Young Golfing Talent in Singapore SGA organises junior level tournaments such as the SGA Junior Inter-Club League and SGA-BFG Junior Golf Series which are held across various golf courses and clubs in Singapore throughout the year. These tournaments also provide young, aspiring golfers aged five to 14 years old a platform to showcase their skills and compete with peers.

(61)

Efforts to Promote and Nurture Young Golfing Talent in Singapore In addition, the Singapore Sports School (SSP) also provides a further pathway to high performance in golf. SSP nurtures student-athletes in the national youth team and supports them on their academic and sporting development. SSP provides athlete-friendly academic and holistic development programmes that enable the student-athletes to focus on their sports commitments. SSP currently has seven student-athletes in golf, among whom is Chen Xing Tong, the youngest female to have won the Singapore Open Amateur Championships in 2024 at the age of 16.

(62)

Efforts to Promote and Nurture Young Golfing Talent in Singapore For those looking to pick up golf, either recreationally or to develop high performance talents, there is a range of programmes offered at both public and private golf courses, including the programmes outlined above.

(63)

Efforts to Promote and Nurture Young Golfing Talent in Singapore Whilst space constraints and competing land use requirements have limited the space available for golf courses, the Government recognises that it is important for the public to have continued access to the sport and is looking at expanding options by which to do so. We had previously extended the tenancy of Mandai Executive Golf Course until December 2026 and worked with Keppel Club to set aside the majority of slots at the Sime Golf Course for use by members of the public at an affordable price range, comparable to other public courses. The Government will continue looking into the provision of public golf facilities for the longer term.

(64)

Efforts to Promote and Nurture Young Golfing Talent in Singapore Ms Yeo Wan Ling.

(65)

Efforts to Promote and Nurture Young Golfing Talent in Singapore Thank you, Speaker. Punggol Town is home to one of three full public golf ranges in Singapore. On evenings that I am there on community visits, they run at almost full capacity with both men and women, as well as children and family playing the sports, pointing to its growing popularity in young towns.

(66)

Efforts to Promote and Nurture Young Golfing Talent in Singapore Given that Singapore has seen some very good budding sports success with our golfing athletes qualifying for the Olympics and the US Open and Masters, how can the Ministry continue to keep the costs affordable for our budding sports talents, including those who have not turned pro golf, and to ensure that affordable access to golf practice facilities, even with the closure of the golf range?

(67)

Efforts to Promote and Nurture Young Golfing Talent in Singapore Sir, the example that I mentioned earlier, in response to the Member's supplementary question is that we have worked with Keppel Club to provide or set aside a majority of slots for the public and to also keep costs affordable for these members of the public. Rest assured, we will continue to work hard to ensure continued public access to golf.

(68)

Efforts to Promote and Nurture Young Golfing Talent in Singapore r: Incidentally, two of our young talents, Shannon Tan and Chen Xing Tong, are currently competing in the HSBC Women's Championship in Sentosa. I wish them all the best.

(69)

11.32 am 9 Ms Yeo Wan Ling asked the Minister for Law (a) over the past three years, what is the yearly number of Magistrate's Complaints filed; and (b) whether the Ministry will consider implementing a public awareness education programme or campaign on the use of Magistrate's Complaints which may be used to aid criminal investigations by the Singapore Police Force.

(70)

11.32 am Sir, around 1,300 Magistrate's Complaints were filed yearly from 2022 to 2024.

(71)

11.32 am The Courts have informed us that there are educational resources available on the Judiciary's website, which members of the public may refer to for information on, amongst other things, when and how they may file a Magistrate's Complaint.

(72)

11.32 am The hon Member also referred to the relationship between Magistrate's Complaints and Police investigations. I should clarify that the Magistrate's Complaint process provides a framework for private prosecutions by any person, subject to the assessment of the Magistrate of whether there is sufficient reason for the complaint to proceed. The process is distinct from criminal investigations conducted by the Police following the filing of a Police report, which do not require the filing of a Magistrate's Complaint.

(73)

11.32 am Ms Yeo.

(74)

11.32 am Thank you, Speaker. A number of constituents who believe that a criminal offence has been committed against them have approached me at various times, with some confusion on when they need to apply for a Magistrate's Complaint, or when a Police report will suffice for Police investigations to commence against the alleged perpetrator. These offences include being slapped in public, damages to property, being cheated of money and breaches to Protection Orders. Some constituents shared that the Singapore Police Force had advised them to lodge a Magistrate's Complaint, especially if they would like to commence private prosecution.

(75)

11.32 am While some have shared that the $20 fee for lodging a Magistrate's Complaint and the need to turn up in Court have dissuaded them on pushing for further redress. How can the Ministry assist to provide more clarity to the members of public on the use of the Magistrate's Complaint and the process of getting one? And are there resources available to public who are unable to pay for the fee or have difficulty representing themselves perhaps due to language or disabilities during this session with the Magistrate?

(76)

11.32 am Minister of State Murali.

(77)

11.32 am Sir, I know the guillotine time is up. May I seek your leave to just reply to her?

(78)

11.32 am Go ahead. I took up one minute just now.

(79)

11.32 am Thank you. Very well, Sir. Sir, I agree with the hon Member that members of the public should be clear on when a Magistrate's Complaint can be filed and how to go about filing a Magistrate's Complaint. There are resources on the Judiciary's website that cover these. These include guides and templates. There are also resources to support persons who may need assistance in filing a Magistrate's Complaint. If there is a difficulty in filing online, the person can call the State Courts' call centre to seek guidance or go to the State Court's Service Hub, or use the terminals in the business centre to file the complaint.

(80)

11.32 am If the person has difficulty understanding the filing process or instructions in English, he or she can seek help from the counter staff. A student under the University Court Friends programme may also be assigned and can also help the person navigate the filing process.

(81)

11.32 am I would also add, Sir, that in relation to translation issues, the Court website states that when filing a Magistrate's Complaint, the person may indicate their preferred language in the Magistrate's Complaint form and arrangements will be made to assign an interpreter if required.

(82)

11.32 am On the issue of the filing fee, we will convey the feedback to the Judiciary.

(83)

11.32 am Order. End of Question Time. The Clerk will now proceed to read the Order of the day.

(84)

11.32 am [Pursuant to Standing Order No 22(3), provided that Members had not asked for questions standing in their names to be postponed to a later Sitting day or withdrawn, written answers to questions not reached by the end of Question Time are reproduced in the Appendix.]

(85)

2.33 pm [(proc text) Order read for Resumption of Debate on Question [18 February 2025] [3rd Allotted Day] (proc text)]

(86)

2.33 pm [(proc text) "That Parliament approves the financial policy of the Government for the financial year 1 April 2025 to 31 March 2026." – [Prime Minister and Minister for Finance]. (proc text)]

(87)

2.33 pm [(proc text) Question again proposed. (proc text)]

(88)

2.33 pm Ms Usha Chandradas.

(89)

2.33 pm Thank you, Mr Speaker, for allowing me to join the Budget debate. I thank the Prime Minister and the Minister for Finance for his announcement of a very generous Budget. It is one that is inclusive and diverse and I support it fully.

(90)

2.33 pm My speech today will cover two key topics. First, the Culture Pass and second, a proposal to support Singapore's visual arts sector. This proposal takes inspiration from the strong financial backing that we have seen in this Budget for businesses that are seeking a listing on the Singapore Exchange (SGX). In this speech, I would like to suggest similar financial mechanisms to strengthen our local visual arts scene.

(91)

2.33 pm But first, the Culture Pass. It is a very commendable initiative that makes arts and cultural experiences more accessible to Singaporeans. Last year, I filed a Parliamentary Question after hearing from arts businesses about their challenges. I heard that even if they were located in the heartlands, not all arts businesses were eligible for the Community Development Council (CDC) Voucher redemption scheme. They would have to be considered on a case-by-case basis. This raised concerns that the arts were not being recognised as an essential part of everyday life. With the Culture Pass now being issued broadly to every Singaporean aged 18 and above, the Government has sent a clear signal: the arts are essential to our society, just like any other basic necessity.

This is the start of the text. The rest is on the official site. Open the official text