Skip to content
Official report

Hansard

Hansard, Thursday, 25 September 2025

Feedback & support

The text

(1)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme 1 Mr Patrick Tay Teck Guan asked the Minister for Education whether the Ministry tracks the career impact of SkillsFuture credits on Singaporeans who have utilised them in terms of (i) employment status (ii) hours worked and (iii) wage outcomes, since such data may increase take-up rates.

(2)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme 2 Mr Kwek Hian Chuan Henry asked the Minister for Education (a) what percentage of SkillsFuture Level-Up participants secured new employment within nine months of enrolment, with a breakdown by age groups 40–49 and 50–59; and (b) what were their median wages before and after completion of training.

(3)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme 3 Dr Hamid Razak asked the Minister for Education (a) whether the SkillsFuture Mid-Career Training Allowance for mid-career workers aged 40 and above can also cover Singaporeans in their 30s who need to pick up new skills for fast-growing industries; and (b) whether more flexibility can be given for its use for further studies such as to pursue postgraduate qualifications.

(4)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme 4 Mr Kenneth Tiong Boon Kiat asked the Minister for Education (a) what is the rationale for restricting the SkillsFuture Mid-Career Training Allowance to citizens aged 40 years and above since skills obsolescence affects all ages; (b) whether the Ministry will consider the reskilling needs of workers in their 30s; and (c) whether the Ministry will expand SkillsFuture to support postgraduate qualifications (i) in critical sectors or (ii) in general.

(5)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme 5 Mr Vikram Nair asked the Minister for Education (a) in 2025, how many Singaporeans have (i) used their SkillsFuture credits or (ii) received training allowances to pursue upskilling and reskilling under the SkillsFuture Mid-Career Training Allowance scheme; and (b) how do the numbers in 2025 compare with that of 2024.

(6)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme Mr Speaker, may I have your permission to take Question Nos 1 to 5 on today's Order Paper, please?

(7)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme Go ahead.

(8)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme Sir, to help Singaporeans develop to their full potential throughout life, SkillsFuture Singapore provides a range of broad-based training support that is kept affordable and accessible. Industry-relevant training programmes are subsidised at up to 70% of the course fees for all Singaporeans. At age 25, Singaporeans receive $500 in SkillsFuture Credit, which they can use to develop their skills and interests.

(9)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme For Singaporeans who are 40 and above, they can use the SkillsFuture Level-Up Programme (SFLP). This programme helps them to pursue a substantive skills reboot and helps them stay competitive in a rapidly changing economy. We are prioritising support for our mid-career Singaporeans, as they may face higher risk of skills obsolescence, having completed their original work-ready qualifications many years ago. At this stage in life, given their heavy family and work responsibilities, they also face higher opportunity costs in pursuing upskilling and reskilling, particularly when they take up substantive courses that require greater time and financial commitment.

(10)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme If they choose to pursue substantive training, the SkillsFuture Level-Up Programme helps them lower the opportunity cost in two ways.

(11)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme First, by providing further course fee support in the form of the SkillsFuture Credit (Mid-Career) top-up of $4,000. Introduced in May 2024, individuals can use the Credit to further offset out-of-pocket training costs. This is over and above course fee subsidies of up to 90%.

(12)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme Second, we provide financial support for those pursuing longer substantive training, such as full qualifications. The SkillsFuture Mid-Career Training Allowance helps to partially offset income loss during full-time training. From 1 May 2025, eligible individuals can receive a training allowance, sized at 50% of their average income over the last 12 months, up to a cap of $3,000 per month, for 24 months in their lifetime.

(13)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme Today, the SkillsFuture Credit (Mid-Career) top-up can be used for over 7,000 courses, of which, about 700 full-time training programmes qualify for training allowance.

(14)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme The SkillsFuture Level-Up courses are carefully curated to support substantive training, with the aim of improving a person's employability. They include full qualifications offered by the Institutes of Higher Learning (IHLs). These programmes provide good upgrading pathways that continue to enjoy good wage premium, as our studies have shown.

(15)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme Individuals looking to transition into another sector can consider SkillsFuture Career Transition Programmes that provide training for up to 12 months as well as employment facilitation. Between June 2022 when the Programme started and December 2024, about 55% of almost 4,300 SkillsFuture Career Transition Programme trainees who were previously unemployed found new jobs within six months after course completion.

(16)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme As of July 2025, there are about 330 SkillsFuture Career Transition Programmes offered in 21 sectors with good hiring opportunities such as Information and Communications, Professional Services and Food Services.

(17)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme The take-up of the Level-Up Programme has been positive. In the first year of implementation from 1 May 2024 to 30 April 2025, over 36,000 Singapore Citizens used their SkillsFuture Credit (Mid-Career) with claims amounting to over $24 million. From the claims data, the number of individuals taking SkillsFuture Career Transition Programmes increased by about six times from around 1,500 to around 8,500, compared to the same period in the preceding year, and those who used the SkillsFuture Credit for full qualifications increased by about 2.5 times from around 3,000 to around 7,000.

(18)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme Within the first three months of implementation, over 3,200 Singapore Citizens have been successful in their training allowance applications for full-time long-form training, with over $30 million in claims committed as at end-July 2025.

(19)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme To build on this momentum, we will expand the Level-Up Programme in the following ways for the immediate term.

(20)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme First, as announced at Budget 2025, we will expand the training allowance to part-time long-form training from early next year, to support mid-career Singaporeans who choose to pursue such training while continuing to work. This is estimated to benefit 10,000 Singaporeans annually.

(21)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme Second, we will continue to refresh and expand the number of IHL full qualifications and stackable micro-credentials, as well as SkillsFuture Career Transition Programmes to meet emerging skills needs. For example, over 100 SkillsFuture Career Transition Programmes were launched this year in high-demand areas such as Artificial Intelligence.

(22)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme Third, we will work with sector agencies and industry partners to include more courses offered by industry leaders and private training providers that are well-recognised by industry and confer credentials that lead to strong employment outcomes.

(23)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme We will continue to monitor the training needs of adult learners over their life stages as we expand the SkillsFuture Level-Up Programme. In particular, let me respond to two suggestions that Members have raised.

(24)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme First, on extending the Level-Up Programme to younger Singaporeans. For now, younger Singaporeans in their 30s can continue to benefit from the broad-based training support that I mentioned earlier. This includes subsidies at up to 70% of course fees for all Singaporeans. Additional support will be given to lower-wage workers in their 30s. Earlier this year, the Ministry of Manpower announced the Workfare Skills Support Level-Up Programme to better support these workers in upgrading to full qualifications that can uplift their wages. From early 2026, lower-wage workers in their 30s will receive monthly training allowance when they pursue eligible long-form training, similar to the SkillsFuture Level-Up Programme.

(25)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme The second suggestion is to extend the training allowance to postgraduate programmes. Today, the training allowance supports mid-career substantive training up to the undergraduate degree level. Mid-career Singaporeans can use their SkillsFuture Credit (Mid-Career) of $4,000 to offset the out-of-pocket training fees for postgraduate Masters’ programmes offered by the autonomous universities. We have not extended the training allowance to postgraduate programmes as most jobs in Singapore do not require such qualifications. We are also careful not to inadvertently perpetuate a paper chase at the Masters’ level. Individuals can decide whether it is worthwhile to invest in a Masters’ degree, given its high cost but also potentially high returns on investment, however, this applies to a small number of jobs in Singapore. We will continue to monitor the needs for postgraduate training in emerging sectors and adjust our level of support accordingly.

(26)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme We welcome feedback and will continue to monitor the employment outcomes from the increased training take-up.

(27)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme The success of the SkillsFuture Level-Up Programme ultimately must be measured by how confident mid-career Singaporeans are in using their newly acquired skills to navigate the disruptions in the economy ahead, and cannot just be measured by employment outcomes alone, since training alone cannot guarantee jobs and may not lead to immediate employment gains.

(28)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme To help our people succeed, we need to continue strengthening the whole-of-society partnerships between Government, individuals, unions, industry and training institutions to build a culture of lifelong learning so Singaporeans can stay resilient, employable and competitive.

(29)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme Mr Patrick Tay.

(30)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme Speaker, I just have one supplementary question. Thank you to the Senior Minister of State for the response. In Singapore, SkillsFuture is divided into two broad aspects: the employers-supported aspect as well as the individual-initiated aspect. And if you look at resident training participation, particularly last year, 2024, it has dropped to a nine-year-low of 40.7%, compared to about 49.9% in 2021.

(31)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme My question to the Senior Minister of State is, what can we do, or can employers do more? And how can we get them to better support both, from the employer-supported aspect as well as the individual-initiated training, as we embrace SkillsFuture in the next lap?

(32)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme Mr Speaker, I thank Mr Patrick Tay for his question. Indeed, we would ask for employers to do more to support our SkillsFuture movement. Overall, it has not been bad. If you look at the proportion of training places taken up under SkillsFuture, about 43% to 45% are employers-supported, which means that the learner, the worker, is not actually paying out of their SkillsFuture Credit.

(33)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme And overall, if you take a look at the last 10 years, the numbers have indeed increased. We have seen an increase in the number of employers that are involved and an increase in the number of training places supported by employers. But as the overall number of training places has increased, the proportion has remained relatively static. We think there is room for the proportion to increase and for employers to do more.

(34)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme There is also a benefit for the system and our movement, if employers can do more. Because if they are sending their workers for training, it means that they have recognised and are signalling the importance of such skills upgrading for their business and for their industry. It means that their workers and the learners under SkillsFuture have the assurance that these are industry relevant and are going to help them progress in their career. And it helps to, then embed this culture of lifelong learning as part of adult work.

(35)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme Some of it is about the business decisions and the sense of investment in their people. And some of it is also looking at the processes within their companies, in terms of reducing the frictions to allow people to go for training, have the work covered and think about the job transformation that will allow the embedding of lifelong learning as part of the career.

(36)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme So, I think there is room for the employers to do more. Some of it is about decisions in terms of the returns on investment that they will have and some of it is about reducing the frictions for their workers as learners in pursuing lifelong learning.

(37)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme Mr Henry Kwek.

(38)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme Speaker, I have a supplementary question for the Senior Minister of State about the learnings that we have, given the fact that this is new programme and it is attracting a different group of Singaporeans.

(39)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme I note in particular the statistics of around more than 50% of people who are able to get a job after this training. Is there any preliminary sense of what happens to the rest? I am asking because these groups are perfectly motivated people – they have a full-time job and then they transit, they retrain and, therefore, they should logically be able to get such skills because they highly motivated and are employable. Therefore, are there any lessons that we can learn or preliminary conclusions, especially with regard to matching the aspirations and qualifications of the trainees with the future industry needs?

(40)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme I thank Mr Kwek for the question. It is an important issue, but it is a little bit preliminary, it is a little bit premature. The programme is not very old and some of the types of gains that he is talking about will indeed take years to be realised. You transition into a new industry or even stay within the industry but now with the new set of qualifications. Although you have the qualifications, you now have to apply them to the job, develop your career prospects within this new role in this new task. And it can take some time for these to be realised in a metric that we can measure and present to the House.

(41)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme So, in the short term, some of the things that we have learned are about the need to have better matching and better integration between the curricula, the services of the training providers and the needs of the industry; and to look to see how we can bring the employers and in particular, large employers, those that we think of as SkillsFuture developers or Queen Bees, together with the trade associations, have them either participate in the training or inform the training providers about the curricula, the job roles and the particular skills and tasks that the learners are engaged in.

(42)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme The better we can do that, the more confidence the employers will have in the approach that we are taking and hence, the more confidence that workers and learners will have in dealing with the opportunity cost that is very real for someone undergoing training.

(43)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme So, those are some of the short-term lessons. I think the issues that the Member has highlighted are indeed important, but it is a little bit early to have a definitive comment on that.

(44)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme Dr Hamid Razak.

(45)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme Thank you, Mr Speaker. I would like to thank the Senior Minister of State for the detailed reply. I understand and appreciate the reasons why 40 was used as an age cut-off for the SkillsFuture Mid-Career Training Allowance. I am just wondering whether the Ministry has data on the appeals put to the Ministry for those aged 40 and below for the SkillsFuture Mid-Career Training Allowance – because studying those data may show us how better we can support the age group beyond just SkillsFuture itself.

(46)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme Sir, I thank Dr Hamid Razak for the question. Indeed, the decision to think of the age cut-off at 40 is informed by data, but not so much on the data that we have on appeals. I do not have the direct data for appeals received or granted. Perhaps the Member can return with a further question, if that is the focus.

(47)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme The data that informs us about the age cut-off is about the risks of a given individual becoming unemployed, and the length of time taken for that individual to then go back into the workforce and find a job. And we can see that those in their 40s have a higher risk of becoming unemployed, potentially because of skills obsolescence, and take longer to then go back into the workforce and to find employment, as compared to people in their 20s and 30s.

(48)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme And so for that reason, we have chosen the cut-off for that particular tier to be at 40. I just want to take the opportunity to emphasise that it does not mean that anybody under the age of 30 does not have assistance. There are the subsidies that are available to all Singaporeans at up to 70%, potentially rising to 90% if it is employer-driven; there is the SkillsFuture Credit that is available to everybody above the age of 25; and the moves that we are making to support lower-wage workers that are above the age of 30 that are coming and have already been announced.

(49)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme I would also point out that there are plenty of training opportunities available to Singaporeans of all ages that are not under SkillsFuture. Many organisations make training opportunities available. The public sector is one, for example, that provides training through the Civil Service College and so public sector officers do not have to use the SkillsFuture Credit in order to develop new opportunities through training. And there are many other employers that are doing something similar.

(50)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme Mr Kenneth Tiong.

(51)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme I thank the Senior Minister of State for his reply. I have two supplementary questions. The first is about the age cut-off. The Government's own data of the labour force survey findings of 2024 shows that there is a drop in training participation, falling fastest in the 30 to 39 age group, from 49.5% to 44.7%. My first supplementary question is this: does that not suggest that the 30 to 39 age group should be the subject of greater help, particularly for the SkillsFuture Level-Up Programme?

(52)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme And the second question is in regards to the clause restricting the Mid Career Training Allowance to undergraduate qualifications. On Monday, Deputy Prime Minister Gan said that there were five growth areas: precision medicine, AI, green economy, autonomous vehicles, space, and there is a strong research and development (R&D) and reskilling component for all of these industries. For those that have reliable data that I have managed to find, most of the R&D jobs – 90% to 100% of them – do require postgraduate degrees; and generally, in the industry, it appears that 30% to 40% of the jobs in the industry do require postgraduate degrees. So, I will just ask the Senior Minister of State, does he not agree that the clause restricting postgraduate qualifications does not really align with the spirit of the Ministry of Trade and Industry's future strategy?

(53)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme Mr Speaker, I thank Mr Tiong for the two questions. For his first question on the age cut-off and the training participation, I think that we should not take the view that what we must strive for is for everyone to use up their SkillsFuture Credit as soon as possible, and to engage in training as soon as possible. The idea is to make sure that there is an assurance that at any time of your career over the course of your life, you will have the opportunity to reskill should there be a need. And so, if there is no need – you are within a career, you are developing your professional skillsets, there is opportunity ahead of you – then, that may be the right thing for you to do, rather than using your SkillsFuture Credit and going for a course for a certification.

(54)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme We do want you to get into the culture of lifelong learning. And so perhaps, if there is an interest, a small course, please do so. But I think we should not necessarily see the data in a negative light. It may well be that that category of people does not need to utilise the SkillsFuture Credit in quite the same way and may need to do so at a future point in their career – which is its purpose.

(55)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme For the second point in terms of the postgraduate support, as I have explained, we are open to considering if there is a need. The issue is whether today, the supply of people with appropriate qualifications in order to drive the development of those areas is constrained by the type of training that is provided. It does not appear to be a direct indication at this point in time.

(56)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme We would also not want, as we are developing these programmes, to create a paper chase. Certainly, we do not want people to go and chase after postgraduate qualifications if they are not going to result in outcomes for that individual, which are useful to that individual.

(57)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme So, I think we have started this. We will learn from the lessons as we implement it. And should the need be there, we can always consider it again. But at the moment, as I have explained my original answer, it is not that there are no postgraduate qualifications that are supported. It is specifically the training allowance that is not applied, but the SkillsFuture Credit can be used for Masters programmes at our autonomous universities, and those Master's programmes indeed do support the various niche areas that that Mr Tiong highlighted in his supplementary question.

(58)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme Last supplementary question. Mr Vikram Nair.

(59)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme Thank you. I thank the Senior Minister of State, especially for the explanation of the Mid Career SkillsFuture Grant. The first part of my question actually was about the utilisation of SkillsFuture credits generally. Because I think in the middle of this year there was a report that said 70% of eligible households have not used the one-off $500 top-up for SkillsFuture, which is set to expire at the end of this year. So, taking the Senior Minister of State's point that SkillsFuture is meant for the long term, does the Senior Minister of State see this as a problem and is this something for which, say, the expiry should be extended, or something for which we should encourage people to utilise more quickly?

(60)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme Sir, I thank Mr Nair for highlighting the expiry of the $500 SkillsFuture Credit top-up that we have benefited from. I would encourage all Members of this House who I am sure are in the eligible age group, please do use up your expiring credits by the end of the year. Many courses are eligible for that subsidy.

(61)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme But that is not the end of the SkillsFuture Credit, and there is the additional $500 opening Credit and then the $4,000 that is available for the long term which does not expire.

(62)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme We do want to encourage people to take a few courses; and for some of the courses, you do not need to use very much of your SkillsFuture credits. Get into the habit of understanding what does lifelong learning look like and what does it mean to take a course while you are working if you have not done something like this before.

(63)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme In terms of the overall utilisation, we do see a spread of individuals of about 30% in their 40s, 30% in their 50s and 30% in their 60s, which then highlights that actually, this is about giving assurance that at any point during your career, if you should need a reboot, an opportunity to develop a new set of skills, there will be support and opportunity created through the SkillsFuture movement.

(64)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme So, in general, for most of the SkillsFuture Credit, there is no rush, and you can start to sample and set yourself up for the future. But for one particular tranche, I would encourage all Members and also, as you go and visit your constituents, to remind them that this $500 of SkillsFuture Credit is expiring by 31 December 2025. It is worth having your first taste of what it feels like to do lifelong learning and make use of those credits to do a course.

(65)

Career Impact of SkillsFuture Credits, Mid-Career Training Allowance and Level-Up Programme Indeed, thank you for the reminder. I must remind myself and my constituents this weekend.

(66)

Indicators of Success in AV Trials and Helping Public Transport Workers Transition to AV-related Roles 6 Ms Yeo Wan Ling asked the Acting Minister for Transport (a) how will Punggol residents' safety be prioritised when autonomous vehicles (AV) are trialed in the fourth quarter of 2025; (b) how does the Ministry ensure that rides offered by AVs are affordable and accessible to residents; and (c) how will the Ministry involve public transport workers and ensure they have a role to play when AVs are rolled out.

(67)

Indicators of Success in AV Trials and Helping Public Transport Workers Transition to AV-related Roles 7 Mr Edward Chia Bing Hui asked the Acting Minister for Transport (a) what key performance indicators will be used to measure the success of autonomous vehicle trials; (b) what safety benchmarks are in place; and (b) how legal liability and system security risks will be addressed.

(68)

Indicators of Success in AV Trials and Helping Public Transport Workers Transition to AV-related Roles 8 Mr Edward Chia Bing Hui asked the Acting Minister for Transport (a) what system-level benefits such as (i) improved accessibility (ii) reliability of public transport and (iii) congestion and emissions reductions, Singapore anticipates from autonomous vehicle (AV) deployment; and (b) whether such efficiencies may enable more affordable public transport in the future.

(69)

Indicators of Success in AV Trials and Helping Public Transport Workers Transition to AV-related Roles 9 Mr Edward Chia Bing Hui asked the Acting Minister for Transport (a) how will the Government’s autonomous vehicle (AV) strategy affect driving-related jobs; (b) what new job opportunities are expected; and (c) how the Ministry plans to support workers in transitioning to AV-related roles.

(70)

Indicators of Success in AV Trials and Helping Public Transport Workers Transition to AV-related Roles Mr Speaker, if I may have your permission to take Question Nos 6 to 9 in today’s Order Paper together?

(71)

Indicators of Success in AV Trials and Helping Public Transport Workers Transition to AV-related Roles Please proceed.

(72)

Indicators of Success in AV Trials and Helping Public Transport Workers Transition to AV-related Roles Autonomous vehicles (AVs) can enhance connectivity and create good jobs for Singaporeans.

(73)

Indicators of Success in AV Trials and Helping Public Transport Workers Transition to AV-related Roles AVs will add to our public transport network without running up against fundamental manpower constraints. We will start by deploying autonomous shuttles to operate scheduled, fixed-route services within our towns. These shuttle services can directly connect residents to key transport nodes and amenities such as the market and polyclinic.

(74)

Indicators of Success in AV Trials and Helping Public Transport Workers Transition to AV-related Roles There are three pilot routes in Punggol. If successful, we intend to expand the service to other towns that are further away from the city, such as Tengah. Besides AV shuttles, we will be piloting AV buses as public buses, starting with SBST bus services 400 and 191, which serve Marina Bay and one-north respectively.

(75)

Indicators of Success in AV Trials and Helping Public Transport Workers Transition to AV-related Roles The Ministry of Transport (MOT) and the Land Transport Authority (LTA) have put in place safeguards to ensure safe AV deployment in the regulatory sandbox as provided for in the Road Traffic Act. Every AV must pass a safety assessment before it is authorised to operate on public roads. The vehicle must be able to respond safely to the behaviour of other road users and adhere to traffic rules. For a start, a safety operator will be on board the AV at all times. All AVs deployed on roads must have third-party liability insurance, covering death, bodily injury and property damage. Third parties would be compensated in the event of accidents, similar to conventional vehicles.

(76)

Indicators of Success in AV Trials and Helping Public Transport Workers Transition to AV-related Roles The AV industry will bring new job opportunities for Singaporeans, including for our transport workers. There will be roles such as safety operators, remote operators, engineers and technicians.

(77)

Indicators of Success in AV Trials and Helping Public Transport Workers Transition to AV-related Roles As the supply of AV vehicles will be limited at the start, there will be no displacement effect for our taxi and private-hire vehicle drivers in the short term. That said, we recognise their anxiety. The Government and AV operators will roll out training and reskilling programmes to help drivers to take on opportunities in the AV sector, or to move into other sectors if they prefer. We will put these programmes in place early to provide drivers with options and time to go for reskilling.

(78)

Indicators of Success in AV Trials and Helping Public Transport Workers Transition to AV-related Roles Ms Yeo Wan Ling.

(79)

Indicators of Success in AV Trials and Helping Public Transport Workers Transition to AV-related Roles I declare I am the Executive Secretary of the National Transport Workers' Union. The announcement of the roll-out of the AV shuttle trials in Punggol has been met with both excitement and curiosity. I thank the Ministry for putting in a phased approach for the roll-out with safety mapping and terrain customisation of Punggol streets, before passengers services start. This will no doubt allow our Punggol residents to be familiarised with the technology and services, and to be more confident of the use of AVs in their daily commute.

(80)

Indicators of Success in AV Trials and Helping Public Transport Workers Transition to AV-related Roles What are the safety key performance indicators to be achieved during the non-passenger phase of the Punggol AV trials before graduating into passenger services? And will there be a town-wide consultation with Punggol residents during the various roll-out phases?

(81)

Indicators of Success in AV Trials and Helping Public Transport Workers Transition to AV-related Roles In addition, I note that there has been some identification of new jobs that would be created with AV trials, such as safety drivers and remote operators which the Senior Minister of State has talked about. How will the Ministry direct the appointed AV service providers to work with the transport unions and associations on prioritising these jobs for existing transport workers and to make more accessible the application for such jobs to a wider group of transport workers?

(82)

Indicators of Success in AV Trials and Helping Public Transport Workers Transition to AV-related Roles I thank the Member Ms Yeo Wan Ling for raising these questions. She has been a very, very active proponent for workers in the transport industry – in particular, after we have shared about our AV plans.

(83)

Indicators of Success in AV Trials and Helping Public Transport Workers Transition to AV-related Roles First and foremost, safety is a key priority for MOT and LTA. And that is why we are taking a phased approach to deploy the use of AV services. Firstly, before AVs are allowed on public roads in Singapore. They are subject to LTA's AV assessment framework, which requires them to pass a closed-circuit test at the Centre of Excellence for Testing and Research of Autonomous Vehicles (CETRAN).

(84)

Indicators of Success in AV Trials and Helping Public Transport Workers Transition to AV-related Roles Secondly, all AVs are required to undergo a preparatory phase with a safety operator on board at all times to map the routes to calibrate the sensors and fine-tune relevant artificial intelligence (AI) models. All shuttles are also monitored in real-time with performance data collected and analysed to ensure safe and reliable operations.

(85)

Indicators of Success in AV Trials and Helping Public Transport Workers Transition to AV-related Roles Apart from that, when we first identified the routes for trial in Punggol, we have taken care to identify what we call as "PUDOs", pick up and drop-off points, where there is adequate safety distance for onboarding as well as disembarking of commuters. At the same time, we are looking forward to having a bigger and engagement, a more widespread engagement with residents in Punggol, in particular those who go to the preschools, the schools as well as Active Ageing Centres to sensitise them to the use of the AVs on the roads.

This is the start of the text. The rest is on the official site. Open the official text