Skip to content
Official report

Hansard

Hansard, Tuesday, 14 October 2025

Feedback & support

The text

(1)

11.30 am Order. I have to inform hon Members that I have on 29 September this year communicated to the President the Address of Thanks agreed to by resolution of this Parliament on 26 September 2025.

(2)

11.30 am Order. Questions for Oral Answer.

(3)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy 1 Dr Choo Pei Ling asked the Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Trade and Industry what is the expected impact of the new tariffs imposed by the United States particularly for (i) Singapore’s pharmaceutical sector and (ii) future investments in Singapore.

(4)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy 2 Mr Lee Hong Chuang asked the Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Trade and Industry in view of the US decision to impose 100% tariffs on pharmaceutical products, (a) what is the impact on Singapore’s pharmaceutical exports; (b) whether any Singapore-based pharmaceutical companies are eligible for exemptions and what are the criteria involved; and (c) what are the initiatives to support Singapore’s pharmaceutical sector in maintaining access to US market.

(5)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy 3 Ms Poh Li San asked the Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Trade and Industry how will the new pharmaceutical tariffs imposed on branded or patented drugs imported into the United States affect Singapore Government’s long term development plans and jobs for Singaporeans in the biotechnology industry.

(6)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy 4 Mr Yip Hon Weng asked the Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Trade and Industry given the new US tariffs especially the 100% tariff on pharmaceuticals products (a) what is the assessed short and long-term impact on Singapore's economy and key export sectors; and (b) what specific measures are being developed to help Singapore businesses cope with the immediate costs and navigate long-term uncertainty created by these policies.

(7)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy 5 Mr Chua Kheng Wee Louis asked the Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Trade and Industry (a) in each year over the last three years, what is the value of Singapore's pharmaceutical exports to the US with a breakdown by branded and non-branded pharmaceutical products; (b) what is the estimated impact of the latest US pharmaceutical tariffs on Singapore; and (c) whether negotiations are still underway on tariff concessions for Singapore’s pharmaceutical exports.

(8)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy 6 Mr Liang Eng Hwa asked the Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Trade and Industry (a) what is the impact of the 100% tariff imposed by the US government on pharmaceutical products on Singapore's pharmaceutical sector and to the economy; and (b) what supporting initiatives are available to help pharmaceutical companies in Singapore manage the impact.

(9)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy 7 Mr Ang Wei Neng asked the Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Trade and Industry (a) what is the impact on the Singapore economy arising from the 100% tariff on pharmaceutical imports to the United States; (b) whether EDB will consider implementing additional measures in order to attract global pharmaceutical companies to continue investing in Singapore; and (c) if so, what are these measures.

(10)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy Mr Speaker, may I have your permission to answer oral Question Nos 1 to 7 in today’s Order Paper together, as they are on the United States (US) pharmaceutical tariffs?

(11)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy Please go ahead.

(12)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy Mr Speaker, on 25 September 2025, the US announced a 100% tariff on any branded or patented pharmaceutical product with effect from 1 October 2025, unless companies are building manufacturing plants in the US. It is unclear whether they will be subject to the tariff, once their building works are completed. The implementation of this tariff has since been delayed to allow time for pharmaceutical companies to negotiate exemptions with the US administration.

(13)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy The pharmaceutical industry is a key contributor to Singapore’s economy, with eight of the top 10 global pharmaceutical companies having manufacturing, and research and development (R&D) activities here. Between 2022 and 2024, Singapore’s pharmaceutical exports to the US averaged S$3.7 billion per year. These are primarily active pharmaceutical ingredients instead of finished products like tablets and capsules. We do not have a breakdown by branded and non-branded pharmaceutical products.

(14)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy We have been engaging Singapore-based pharmaceutical companies on the impact of the US tariffs. Many already have plans to build new capacity or expand their existing facilities in the US and are awaiting further details from the US administration to confirm that their plans would qualify for the tariff exemption. We are also in discussion with the US administration on a preferential tariff arrangement for Singapore’s pharmaceutical exports to the US and will provide an update when ready.

(15)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy On the immediate support measures for Singapore businesses, including pharmaceutical companies, a written reply had been provided to a similar question raised by Mr Saktiandi Supaat at the Sitting on 22 September 2025. [Please refer to ​"Impact of US Tariffs on Singapore Companies and Economy, Update on Negotiations and Support for Key Sectors", Official Report, 22 September 2025, Vol 96, Issue 2, Written Answers to Questions for Oral Answer not Answered by End of Question Time section.]

(16)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy We are closely monitoring the situation and stand ready to provide further support as needed.

(17)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy Our economic agencies continue to attract new manufacturing and R&D investments from global companies, provide support to our local enterprises and create good jobs for Singaporeans. However, the US tariffs and related global developments do point towards a changed world with greater uncertainty. The five committees undertaking the Economic Strategy Review (ESR) are developing recommendations on the strategy to grow our economy for the longer term and will provide an update in due course.

(18)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy Dr Choo.

(19)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy Mr Speaker, Sir. I thank the Minister of State for her response. I have two supplementary questions. One, what proportion of Singapore's pharmaceutical exports to the US comprises active pharmaceutical ingredients or intermediates? And two, are these categories subject to the same 100% tariffs or eligible for any exemptions?

(20)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy I thank the Member for her supplementary questions. As of 2024, 13% of our domestic exports to the US were pharmaceutical products. And this makes up 19% of our pharmaceutical exports to the US. It is unclear at this point on the details of the tariffs, differentiating between the patented and the non-patented products.

(21)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy Ms Poh Li San.

(22)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy Thank you, Speaker. Thank you, Minister of State. I would like to ask, what the long-term knock-on effects are on the pharmaceutical industry, given that the Government has invested quite a lot of money in this area. Would there be any strategies to diversify our investments?

(23)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy It is actually really too early to tell if there would be a change in the manufacturing and R&D investments in Singapore arising from this set of new tariffs on the pharmaceutical products. But also, I think we have to understand that beyond tariffs, companies will consider a range of other factors in making their investment decisions in Singapore, including our political stability, rule of law and the pro-business environment that we have here, global and regional connectivity that we will continue to enhance, and best-in-class infrastructure and access to skilled workforce.

(24)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy We will continue to look at how we can diversify our sectors in our economy. As I said earlier on, the ESR is looking into this and will be providing an update on the strategy going forward.

(25)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy Mr Yip Hon Weng.

(26)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy Thank you, Mr Speaker. I thank the Minister of State for her answer. How would the new US pharmaceutical tariffs affect our healthcare system, particularly medicine availability and drug pricing? Are Singaporeans seeking care likely to face higher costs and will the Ministry of Trade and Industry (MTI), together with the Ministry of Health and Health Sciences Authority, conduct a formal assessment of near-term risks to common medicines and how tariff costs may pass through to consumers?

(27)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy The Singapore Government is still currently in discussion with the US on preferential tariffs arrangement for our pharmaceutical exports to the US. I think it is really too early for us to tell whether the prices of pharmaceutical products in Singapore will be affected. But we will certainly make sure that healthcare will continue to be accessible and affordable for Singaporeans.

(28)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy Mr Louis Chua.

(29)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy Thank you, Speaker. Just two supplementary questions for the Minister of State. First, I think, as early as in May, the Deputy Prime Minister has mentioned that Singapore is pursuing preferential tariffs to the extent of even zero tariffs on pharmaceutical exports. And so, from that perspective, now that we are already in October, is the idea of having zero tariffs still a possibility, given the current environment? And secondly, more from a longer-term perspective, while companies like AstraZeneca, Pfizer and some of these big pharmaceutical companies are able to negotiate their own deals with the US, but more broadly for Singapore as a whole, and given that the European Union (EU) and Japan do already have their own tariff deals with the US, from Singapore's perspective, if the Minister of State can share the latest updates and what are some of the impediments to a deal with the US administration?

(30)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy We are still having negotiations with the US administration. In particular, Deputy Prime Minister Gan just had a virtual meeting with US Secretary Lutnick last week on a broad framework and the details are being followed up. The negotiation details are confidential. I am sure Speaker and Members in this House will clearly understand this point.

(31)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy I think we also have to take note that the preferential tariff rates secured by countries like Japan and Korea for their pharmaceutical exports were part of broader negotiations with the US on reciprocal tariffs. We have to be realistic at this point, but at the same time, we are working our best to negotiate for the good of our Singapore economy and the companies here.

(32)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy Mr Liang Eng Hwa.

(33)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy Thank you, Sir. My concern is more about how we can continue to attract investments, especially pharmaceutical investments into Singapore with this announcement. So, can I ask the Minister of State whether MTI or the Economic Development Board (EDB) see that to have an impact on how we attract new investments, whether it is from existing companies or from new companies?

(34)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy And secondly, how would that also impact our aspiration to be the R&D centre for drugs and vaccines discovery, whether that that will impact that aspiration as well.

(35)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy I will answer both questions together. Indeed, it is in our interest to try to continue to be an attractive place for investments and R&D in the pharmaceutical sector under the Research, Innovation and Enterprise 2025 Plan.

(36)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy We have committed $28 billion for research and innovation with the intent to accelerate human health and potential as one of the key focus areas. This includes funding to drive research and translational efforts in the biotech and life science sectors. We will be announcing the research funding under RIE 2030 later this year. At the same time, we will continue to invest in talent development, both our local as well as drawing foreign talent, so that we can have a competitive sector to attract businesses and R&D to Singapore.

(37)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy Mr Lee Hong Chuang.

(38)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy I thank the Minister of State for the statement. I just want to clarify that if there are any companies right now that are looking to coming to Singapore, but because of these tariffs, they are deterred or still just considering?

(39)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy I seek Speaker and also Members' understanding that the negotiations are still ongoing. And I think it is sensitive for us to disclose information about companies that are considering coming to Singapore at this point.

(40)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy Assoc Prof Jamus Lim.

(41)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy Thank you, Speaker. Presumably, MTI has a plan for what it will do should negotiations end up being somewhat less fruitful than we will all hope. Would the Minister of State be willing to share if their plans expand to third markets that they hope to target with our pharmaceutical exports? And if that was the case, whether she would be willing to share more details about which ones these may be?

(42)

100% Tariff on Pharmaceutical Imports to the US and its Impact on Singapore Economy Regardless of the outcome of the tariffs negotiation, I think Singapore will continue to look at how we can go to more markets where we think it makes business sense for our pharmaceutical exports.

(43)

Data for Cases Directed to Community Mediation Centre and Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals 8 Mr Kenneth Tiong Boon Kiat asked the Minister for Law (a) for each of the last three years, how many compulsory Community Mediation Centre attendances are directed through (i) authorised officer mediation direction; (ii) Community Disputes Resolution Tribunal order; (iii) Magistrate's Complaint; (iv) police referral; (v) Community Relations Unit mediation direction; (b) whether residents may appeal to the Ministry to compel mediation; and (c) if so, the number of such appeals and successful outcomes.

(44)

Data for Cases Directed to Community Mediation Centre and Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals 9 Dr Choo Pei Ling asked the Minister for Law (a) in each of the past two years and nine months, how many cases of disputes between neighbours had escalated to violence resulting in (i) injuries and (ii) fatalities; and (b) how many of these disputes were due to be or were being processed by the (i) Community Mediation Centre and (ii) Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals; and (c) what preventive measures are being studied and considered.

(45)

Data for Cases Directed to Community Mediation Centre and Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals Mr Speaker, Sir, may I have your permission to answer Question Nos 8 and 9 in today's Order Paper together?

(46)

Data for Cases Directed to Community Mediation Centre and Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals Yes, please proceed.

(47)

Data for Cases Directed to Community Mediation Centre and Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals Thank you, Sir. Sir, my response will also address related questions by hon Members Mr Gabriel Lam1, Mr Yip Hon Weng2, Mr Xie Yao Quan3, 4, Mr Ng Chee Meng5, Ms Valerie Lee6, Ms Elysa Chen7, 8 and Ms Gho Sze Kee9, which are scheduled for subsequent Sittings. Thereafter, Minister of State Alvin Tan will, with your permission, Sir, address Question Nos 10 and 11 in today's Order Paper.

(48)

Data for Cases Directed to Community Mediation Centre and Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals Mr Speaker, may I request that we deliver our replies, which pertain to neighbours' disputes, and then, for us to take supplementary questions together thereafter, please,

(49)

Data for Cases Directed to Community Mediation Centre and Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals Alright. So, we will take any supplementary questions after we have addressed Question No 11.

(50)

Data for Cases Directed to Community Mediation Centre and Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals Obliged, Sir. First, I will briefly recap the Government’s overall approach for managing community disputes, before addressing Members’ questions on difficult neighbour disputes and how we intend to address these more effectively. My colleague, Minister of State Alvin Tan, will respond to questions on the Community Relations Unit (CRU).

(51)

Data for Cases Directed to Community Mediation Centre and Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals Last year, we enhanced our Community Disputes Management Framework (CDMF) when this House passed the Community Disputes Resolution (Amendment) Act 2024. As Minister Edwin Tong explained during the Second Reading of the Act, our aim is to strengthen our community so that neighbours can constructively engage with one another, even when disagreements arise. This starts by fostering positive neighbourly relations.

(52)

Data for Cases Directed to Community Mediation Centre and Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals Now and then, disputes between some neighbours do arise. It is best for these to be settled amicably. So, whenever community leaders or Housing and Development Board (HDB) officers become aware of a dispute, they attempt to mediate informally, particularly at an early stage, before relationships break down. They will also encourage residents to attempt formal mediation at the Community Mediation Centre (CMC). When both neighbours participate, mediation has proven effective in resolving community disputes. It is free and it preserves neighbourly relations in the longer term.

(53)

Data for Cases Directed to Community Mediation Centre and Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals Our experience shows that neighbour disputes become harder to resolve when they become personal, emotionally charged or if they are prolonged. For these cases, where suitable, the recent CDMF enhancements will empower public officers, such as HDB officers, to issue a Mediation Direction (MD). MDs are legally backed orders that require recipients to attend mediation at the CMC. Non-compliance without reasonable excuse, is an offence. This allows us to require disputing neighbours to attend a mandatory mediation, which Members have asked about.

(54)

Data for Cases Directed to Community Mediation Centre and Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals Next, we have established the CRU and empowered its officers to take decisive action in a neighbour dispute. CRU officers are empowered to investigate, collect evidence and if need be, intervene quickly through levers like advisories, warnings and abatement orders.

(55)

Data for Cases Directed to Community Mediation Centre and Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals Since 7 April 2025, the CRU and the MD framework have been piloted in the HDB estates of Tampines town. We have previously explained why we have chosen to start with a pilot.

(56)

Data for Cases Directed to Community Mediation Centre and Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals Generally, most cases should be addressed through mediation or by the CRU. For the remaining intransigent cases, affected residents can consider the Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals (CDRT) as a last resort. We have enhanced the CDRT’s processes under the amendments last year and are working to operationalise them as soon as practicable.

(57)

Data for Cases Directed to Community Mediation Centre and Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals Having set the context, let me now address the questions that hon Members have filed in relation to our community mediation framework and the CDRT.

(58)

Data for Cases Directed to Community Mediation Centre and Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals Hon Member Mr Yip Hon Weng asked about the number of neighbour disputes where parties refused mediation. As I mentioned earlier, it is best for neighbour disputes to be settled amicably between neighbours or via informal mediation by community leaders or HDB officers. And many are indeed resolved in this way. For disputes that proceed to formal mediation, from November 2024 to August 2025, about 1,300 neighbour disputes were registered with the CMC for voluntary mediation. In about 50% of these cases, one party did not respond. In another 20%, at least one party declined outright.

(59)

Data for Cases Directed to Community Mediation Centre and Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals Hon Members Mr Ng Chee Meng and Mr Gabriel Lam asked how we can refer more disputes to mediation. As mentioned, directed mediation is now being piloted in Tampines. In suitable cases, authorised officers, such as HDB or CRU officers, can issue an MD to direct disputing parties to attend mediation at the CMC. The Ministry of Law (MinLaw) will continue to work with the Ministry of National Development (MND) and HDB to ensure that more suitable disputes are directed to the CMC for mandatory mediation. An early intervention with mediation will give parties a better opportunity to resolve their disputes before it becomes entrenched.

(60)

Data for Cases Directed to Community Mediation Centre and Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals Ms Gho Sze Kee asked whether we will consider empowering the CMC to issue MDs. This is already the case for what we call “re-mediation cases”. These are cases where residents previously attempted voluntary mediation and arrived at a settlement, but the same disputes resurfaced subsequently. So, there is value in directing re-mediation in such cases since both parties were willing to attempt voluntary mediation at the first instance.

(61)

Data for Cases Directed to Community Mediation Centre and Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals In a similar vein, hon Member Mr Kenneth Tiong asked whether residents may appeal to the Ministry to compel mediation. Beyond re-mediation cases, it will not be appropriate for the CMC to issue MDs to parties directly. The CMC cannot be seen as taking sides and compelling mediation because of an appeal by one party. The CMC cannot rely on the representation of one party to enforce mandatory mediation on the other. A proper assessment of the circumstances must be made. In this regard, the CMC has to rely on triage by ground agencies, such as HDB and CRU, to determine the situation on the ground. For example, cases involving physical threats will not be suitable for mediation. Residents who are unable to obtain their neighbour’s agreement to attend mediation, can approach the HDB or CRU for assistance. Also, if a CDRT claim is subsequently filed, it is possible for the judge to direct parties to attend mediation.

(62)

Data for Cases Directed to Community Mediation Centre and Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals Hon Member Mr Gabriel Lam asked about the expansion of the MD pilot, which started about six months ago on 7 April 2025. Agencies are actively reviewing the learnings from the pilot and will continually refine operational protocols. I will come back to this again in my concluding remarks.

(63)

Data for Cases Directed to Community Mediation Centre and Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals Minister of State Alvin Tan will also speak more on the CRU framework in his response.

(64)

Data for Cases Directed to Community Mediation Centre and Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals Hon Member Mr Xie Yao Quan asked whether stakeholders, such as grassroots advisers, can be empowered to issue MDs. We have scoped the legislative power to issue an MD to public officers and officers of Statutory Boards. Given the nature of MDs, and that non-compliance can result in a fine of up to $1,500, we have not expanded this power to include non-public officers. We will appoint more public officers as needed.

(65)

Data for Cases Directed to Community Mediation Centre and Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals Mr Kenneth Tiong asked about the number of compulsory mediations for neighbour disputes at the CMC for each of the last five years. [Please refer to clarification under ​"Criteria that Qualify for Intervention by Community Relations Unit and Unit's Effectiveness in Addressing Neighbourly Disputes", Official Report, 14 October 2025, Vol 96, Issue 7, Oral Answers to Questions section.]

(66)

Data for Cases Directed to Community Mediation Centre and Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals For court-mandated mediation, from 2022 to 2024, the CDRT and the Magistrates’ Court referred around 90 and 80 cases to the CMC respectively. Since 7 April 2025, the CRU has issued one MD; HDB has not issued any MDs; and the CMC has not issued any re-mediation directions under the MD framework. The Police do not direct any party to attend mediation.

(67)

Data for Cases Directed to Community Mediation Centre and Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals Next, hon Member Ms Valerie Lee asked about penalties for parties who fail to comply with an MD. First, apart from the fine mentioned earlier, once the CDRT enhancements are fully operationalised, complainants who fail to comply with an MD will not be allowed to file a CDRT claim against their neighbours. Next, where a respondent fails to comply, and a case is subsequently filed with the CDRT, the CDRT may make an adverse costs order against the respondent. This is because the respondent has failed to make reasonable efforts at amicable resolution.

(68)

Data for Cases Directed to Community Mediation Centre and Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals Mr Xie Yao Quan asked about the CMC’s plans to appoint more mediators and extend its services into the community. The CMC has increased accessibility to voluntary mediation by establishing 18 satellite mediation locations at various ServiceSG Centres, Community Clubs and Neighbourhood Police Posts. Where suitable, virtual mediation is also offered. The CMC continues to expand its pool of trained volunteer mediators, which has grown from about 140 at the start of 2022, to around 170 as of October 2025.

(69)

Data for Cases Directed to Community Mediation Centre and Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals Mr Yip Hon Weng asked about the immediate intervention measures when parties show aggression. In a similar vein, Dr Choo Pei Ling asked about preventive measures and statistics on disputes that escalate to aggression. To Dr Choo’s query, we have checked with the relevant agencies. Such statistics are not specifically tracked. Any resident who feels threatened by his neighbour should immediately call the Police. The Police will intervene when there are law and order concerns, taking proportionate action based on threat severity. More broadly, agencies will look at how we can strengthen our enforcement posture, particularly in cases that may involve threats of physical aggression.

(70)

Data for Cases Directed to Community Mediation Centre and Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals Ms Valerie Lee, Mr Gabriel Lam and Ms Gho Sze Kee asked about neighbour disputes where one or more parties may have underlying mental health conditions. The framework remains as Minister Edwin Tong and Senior Minister of State Sim Ann had explained during the Second Reading in November 2024. Our guiding principle is to persuade the resident to voluntarily go for assessment and treatment. Here, the assistance and involvement of the family and caregiver can be crucial. If frontline officers are unable to persuade the individual to seek treatment, then they will consider guiding the case towards a Mandatory Treatment Order, which we expect to operationalise by the end of this year.

(71)

Data for Cases Directed to Community Mediation Centre and Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals For some conditions, treatment may not be possible. In such cases, frontline officers partner with agencies, such as the Agency for Integrated Care, so that professionals can be brought in to assess how best to support the resident and manage the condition.

(72)

Data for Cases Directed to Community Mediation Centre and Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals Ms Elysa Chen asked for data on the CDRT’s caseload. She also asked about support for claimants in preparing evidence for CDRT hearings. The top three CDRT disputes for the last five years are claims for excessive noise, excessive vibration and littering. A party may include multiple types of disputes in a single claim. Between 2020 and 2024, a total of 1,031 CDRT claims were filed. About 65%, or two out of three claims, involved excessive noise. Of these CDRT claims, the CDRT issued 233 CDRT orders and dismissed or struck off 145 cases. Another 651 claims were withdrawn or discontinued.

(73)

Data for Cases Directed to Community Mediation Centre and Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals The CDRT made 26 enforcement orders, comprising 24 Special Directions and two Exclusion Orders.

(74)

Data for Cases Directed to Community Mediation Centre and Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals For cases that involve alleged breaches of CDRT orders to cease smoking, any evidence that points to the fact that the respondent was smoking in breach of the CDRT order, would be relevant. Some examples include letters or contemporaneous messages exchanged between neighbours; and written records with specific timestamps of the acts in question.

(75)

Data for Cases Directed to Community Mediation Centre and Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals Residents who require more information on the CDRT process can refer to the “Guide to Neighbour Dispute Claims”, which is available on the Judiciary’s website. Residents may also seek legal help from Pro Bono SG's Community Law Centres and Community Legal Clinics.

(76)

Data for Cases Directed to Community Mediation Centre and Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals Mr Speaker, Sir, let me say a few words in conclusion.

(77)

Data for Cases Directed to Community Mediation Centre and Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals Some Singaporeans are understandably concerned after the incident in Yishun last month. The Government will continue its existing efforts to strengthen the CDMF. This is a continuous ongoing process. For the more difficult cases, we are now piloting a directed mediation framework and the CRU in Tampines. Agencies are prepared to and will expand the application of the enhanced CDMF as soon as practicable, so that more cases can benefit from mediation and the direct intervention tools of the CRU.

(78)

Data for Cases Directed to Community Mediation Centre and Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals However, no framework will be able to address all manner of neighbour disputes or curb specific individual behaviour, especially violence. No one should resort to violence to deal with a neighbour dispute. That is a personal responsibility.

(79)

Data for Cases Directed to Community Mediation Centre and Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals It is therefore necessary for us all to press ahead with the important work of building up the community’s capacity to practise self-moderation and to engage with one another when disputes arise. It is a multi-pronged approach in building a harmonious community together.

(80)

Criteria that Qualify for Intervention by Community Relations Unit and Unit's Effectiveness in Addressing Neighbourly Disputes 10 Mr Kenneth Tiong Boon Kiat asked the Minister for National Development (a) what criteria distinguishes a severe noise dispute qualifying for Community Relations Unit intervention; and (b) given that the one-year pilot in Tampines handled only five severe cases while not deploying noise sensors, what is the Ministry’s assessment of (i) the unit’s efficacy and (ii) whether its enforcement powers are operationally useful.

(81)

Criteria that Qualify for Intervention by Community Relations Unit and Unit's Effectiveness in Addressing Neighbourly Disputes 11 Mr Abdul Muhaimin Abdul Malik asked the Minister for National Development since the pilot launch of the Community Relations Unit (CRU) in April 2025 (a) how many cases have been resolved or closed by the CRU; and (b) what is the Ministry’s assessment of the effectiveness of the CRU in addressing severe neighbour disputes involving noise and hoarding.

(82)

Criteria that Qualify for Intervention by Community Relations Unit and Unit's Effectiveness in Addressing Neighbourly Disputes Mr Speaker, may I have your permission to take Parliamentary Question Nos 10 and 11 on today’s Order Paper together please?

(83)

Criteria that Qualify for Intervention by Community Relations Unit and Unit's Effectiveness in Addressing Neighbourly Disputes Yes, go ahead.

(84)

Criteria that Qualify for Intervention by Community Relations Unit and Unit's Effectiveness in Addressing Neighbourly Disputes Sir, my answer will also address similar questions filed for oral answer by Members Ms Mariam Jaafar, Mr Xie Yao Quan, Mr Foo Cexiang, Dr Charlene Chen1, 2 and Ms Nadia Ahmad Samdin scheduled for the Sittings on 15, 16 and 17 October, and the questions filed for written answer by Members of Parliament Mr Gerald Giam, Mr Cai Yinzhou and Dr Charlene Chen3, 4 for the Sittings on 14, 15 and 16 October.

(85)

Criteria that Qualify for Intervention by Community Relations Unit and Unit's Effectiveness in Addressing Neighbourly Disputes Sir, when neighbours engage in a dispute, our priority is to bring them together to understand each other’s perspectives and needs, and then, also try to find a mutually acceptable solution. It is neither desirable for our community spirit nor sustainable for Government to step in as a first response for all disputes between neighbours.

(86)

Criteria that Qualify for Intervention by Community Relations Unit and Unit's Effectiveness in Addressing Neighbourly Disputes The Community Relations Unit (CRU) framework strikes a balance between Government stepping in to manage a dispute and leaving enough room for neighbours to settle disputes themselves. It is not a panacea for neighbour disputes and it is not a substitute for a strong foundation of positive community norms, good neighbourly relations and community dispute resolution options.

(87)

Criteria that Qualify for Intervention by Community Relations Unit and Unit's Effectiveness in Addressing Neighbourly Disputes CRU has a range of investigatory and enforcement powers, including the power to install noise sensors. These noise sensors are used as a confirmatory tool, after CRU's initial investigations narrow down from which unit the noise nuisance might be coming from. In the five cases in the pilot town of Tampines that CRU has investigated since April this year, noise sensors were not required because either the noisemakers gave formal statements that confirmed they were the source of noise, or the source of noise was clear and unambiguous.

(88)

Criteria that Qualify for Intervention by Community Relations Unit and Unit's Effectiveness in Addressing Neighbourly Disputes The CRU framework is a useful step forward but its implementation requires significant amounts of resources. Therefore, it is piloted in one town first, Tampines, focusing on severe neighbour noise and hoarding cases. We are reviewing this pilot carefully, to ensure our systems and processes are effective and we have resourced it correctly and sustainably before we extend the CRU services to other towns.

(89)

Criteria that Qualify for Intervention by Community Relations Unit and Unit's Effectiveness in Addressing Neighbourly Disputes As Minister Edwin Tong and the Senior Minister of State Sim Ann explained in their Second Reading speeches in November 2024, CRU focuses on severe cases that frontline agencies, like the Housing and Development Board (HDB) and the Police, triage and escalate to it. These cases represent a small proportion of all disputes between neighbours. They can include cases where one neighbour is deliberately making excessive noise at unreasonable hours and/or over prolonged periods to cause suffering to surrounding neighbours and where prior mediation has not been successful.

(90)

Criteria that Qualify for Intervention by Community Relations Unit and Unit's Effectiveness in Addressing Neighbourly Disputes Severe cases with a mental health nexus are another example. Of the three mental health-related cases CRU is dealing with, it has facilitated inpatient admission and treatment for one, and more consistent follow-up with the community for the other two.

This is the start of the text. The rest is on the official site. Open the official text