The text
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods 1 Ms Yeo Wan Ling asked the Acting Minister for Transport what considerations have been put in place to ensure that Singaporean taxi and private hire drivers' livelihoods are safeguarded even if more licences are made available to Malaysian cross-border services upon review of the Cross Border Taxi Scheme.
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods 2 Mr Ang Wei Neng asked the Acting Minister for Transport (a) whether the Ministry is looking into facilitating more point-to-point (P2P) transfers between Singapore and Johor Bahru given the setting up of Johor-Singapore Economic Zone; and (b) if so, how will the Ministry safeguard the livelihood of Singapore P2P drivers given the large cost disparity of driving Malaysian-registered and Singapore-registered vehicles.
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods Mr Speaker, may I have your permission to take Question Nos 1 to 2 in today’s Order Paper together, please?
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods Go ahead.
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods The Land Transport Authority (LTA) has been conducting enforcement operations against illegal point-to-point (P2P) services. Since July this year, the LTA has impounded 107 vehicles whose drivers were caught providing illegal services.
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods We recognise that there is demand from commuters for more convenient cross-border P2P services. The Ministry of Transport (MOT) and LTA have been exploring options to enhance the existing arrangements. For instance, under the Cross Border Taxi Scheme, we are discussing with Malaysia possible options to liberalise the scheme, including to allow Malaysian cross-border taxis to drop off passengers anywhere in Singapore, and Singaporean taxis to do likewise in Johor Bahru. This will provide greater convenience to commuters from both countries.
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods To minimise foreign taxis cruising around empty and potentially carrying out illegal trips, these foreign taxis would only be allowed to pick up passengers at designated points so that they do not infringe into the local P2P market. However, for the convenience of commuters, we will identify more pick-up points in both Johor Bahru and Singapore. We will discuss options with the Malaysian authorities on a reciprocal basis.
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods We will continue to engage the National Taxi Association (NTA) and the National Private Hire Vehicles Association (NPHVA) to take in their suggestions.
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods We are also exploring using location tracking, including ERP 2.0, and other measures to prevent illegal trips by cross-border taxis within Singapore.
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods LTA will continue its enforcement efforts even after enhancements to the existing arrangements are rolled out.
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods Ms Yeo Wan Ling.
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods Thank you, Speaker. I declare I am the adviser to NTA and NPHVA. Given the deep social and economic ties between Singapore and Malaysia, our drivers have expressed through the associations that they are excited that the calls to review and update the current Cross Border Taxi Scheme are being looked into. Ensuring that the scheme remains relevant as consumption patterns change is critical, as this is a livelihood stream for 200 of our Singapore cross-border drivers.
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods With the programme being updated, and I have taken note of the Senior Minister of State's response, with the increasing demands for P2P drop-offs, how will the Ministry use technology such as online booking platforms and in-vehicle tracking units to ensure that there is fair competition between Singapore-licensed and Malaysian-licensed vehicles, noting that there are fare and exchange rate differences? Also, more importantly, how will the Ministry look to expanding the scheme to allow our drivers broader earning opportunities?
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods I thank the Member for her supplementary questions. Indeed, there is a lot of unmet demand from commuters who would like to travel more frequently across the border. We have families with children, families with the elderly, families who want to visit relatives in Johor Bahru. They want to do shopping trips. They want to go on short holidays. So, it is under these conditions that we are looking at how to enhance the current Cross Border Taxi Scheme.
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods The Member had some questions with regard to the use of technology. We see that some of our taxi operators have already rolled out online booking forms, phone calls as well, to facilitate doorstep pick-up in Singapore. At the same time, I have shared that we can make use of the installation of the on-board unit (OBU), especially on foreign taxis, in order to enhance location tracking. And not to forget our platform operators, the ride-hail platform operators, also have technology platforms that they can use to enhance location tracking.
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods So, these are ways in which we can ensure that foreign vehicles are not conducting illegal P2P trips in Singapore.
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods The second question she had was with regard to fares. When it comes to fares, we will have discussions with the NTA as well as the NPHVA to understand what are the reasonable fares we should be looking at to enhance cross-border trips. We know that there are cost disparities between the cost of operating as well as driving in Singapore versus Johor Bahru, so, we will take this into consideration when setting fares.
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods Mr Ang Wei Neng.
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods Thank you, Speaker. Thank you, Senior Minister of State Sun for the comprehensive reply. Before I go on, let me declare I am the CEO of Strides Premier, a company that provides cross-border taxi service as well.
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods I have a few supplementary questions. First of all, what is the plan that LTA has to expand the fleet of 200 cross-border taxis to more, and whether it will allow the application by a taxi driver on a monthly basis, rather than restrict it to once a year?
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods Secondly, what is the plan to expand this cross-border taxi service to private hire cars? Because private hire cars' pricings are quite dynamic and as pointed out by the Senior Minister of State, the operating cost of driving a P2P vehicle in Johor Bahru is a small fraction of what is the cost in Singapore. So, how would MOT consider measures to prevent the undercutting of fares in this matter? And thirdly, when the Senior Minister of State says that LTA wants to increase the number of drop-off points in Malaysia and Singapore – currently, there is only one drop-off point in Johor Bahru and it is in Larkin; and in Singapore, there is one drop-off point – how many drop-off points is MOT thinking of having? Is it five? Is it 10 or is it 20?
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods I thank the Member for his supplementary questions. There have been several discussions between Singapore's MOT as well as Malaysia's Ministry of Transport and Agensi Pengangkutan Awam Darat (APAD). Amongst the discussion points that we have include a higher quota of taxis for each country, the introduction of larger multi-purpose vehicle taxi models and the use of ride-hailing apps to make bookings.
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods The Member had a second question with regard to private hire vehicles. This, I would approach cautiously because we have been having discussions with our local NPHVA. They are conscious that if we should liberalise the Cross Border Taxi Scheme too widely and not have a separate scheme for private hire vehicles, there could be a situation where private hire vehicles could end up providing illegal P2P services in Singapore.
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods I think what is important to note is that any vehicle, especially those which are foreign that operate in Singapore, they need to have the necessary decals, the necessary livery, so that is very clear that they are part of a licence scheme that has been negotiated between both countries, and not individuals owning private hire vehicles conducting illegal P2P trips.
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods Sorry, the Member had a third question. Yes, could I ask him to repeat that?
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods Yes, thank you to the Senior Minister of State. My third question is that we know the cost of operating a taxi in Malaysia is a small fraction of the cost of operating a taxi in Singapore. So, when we increase the fleet size and also liberalise the cross-border taxi services, how could we ensure that the parties will not undercut the fare?
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods Thank you. I had shared in my main reply that part of the discussions that we are having with the Malaysian authorities is to allow Singapore as well as Malaysian vehicles to drop off at any point in Singapore and in Johor Bahru, because there is demand, this is a need that has been expressed by commuters.
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods But that said, it is very important that we enforce effectively. And that is why I have emphasised the need for us to have the installation of the OBU, for instance, for the purposes of location tracking and also discussing with platform operators to use their technology platforms to track where the vehicles are going.
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods Ms Yeo, keep it short.
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods Thank you, Speaker. I note that Senior Minister of State had in her reply talked about working with ride-hail platforms, and I also have reports of ride-hail platforms from across the border being set up, introducing cross-border taxi services. How will LTA or MOT be working with these overseas registered apps to ensure that there is parity and fairness when it comes to offering such rides in Singapore as well as in Malaysia?
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods I thank the Member for her supplementary question. Such apps have to be recognised by both Singapore and Malaysia. So, where we are aware that there are apps that are being used to provide cross-border services, but have actually not been endorsed by our local authorities before-hand, we will investigate. We cannot allow the proliferation of apps that have not been discussed between both authorities before. This is to ensure that there will not be illegal P2P trips being conducted via such apps.
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods Mr Ang. Keep it short as well.
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods Thank you, Speaker. I have asked a question on how could we prevent the undercutting of fares, because the cost of operating a taxi in Malaysia is only a fraction of the cost of operating a taxi in Singapore.
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods I thank the Member for his question. As part of the review of the Cross Border Taxi Scheme, we will be consulting our associations to ensure that fares are reasonable to our passengers, while providing assurance to Singaporean drivers that cross-border trips are viable, given their operational cost.
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods I think what the Member is concerned about is rides that are illegal, and the fares of these illegal rides are undercutting the fares and the services that are being provided by legal provision of such services. So, for such illegal provision of services where fares are undercutting the fares that are pre-negotiated between both countries' authorities, we will enforce in a strict manner against such illegal providers of services.
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods Last supplementary question. Assoc Prof Jamus Lim. Keep it short.
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods Thank you, Speaker. If I may build on the question by Ms Yeo earlier on, I have also received feedback from residents engaged in private hire vehicle services that these illegal ride-hailing services are offered not just via unauthorised apps, but also via chat groups.
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods My first question is I am wondering whether the Ministry has a sense of the pervasiveness of such illegal services being offered via chat groups as well as apps. And secondly, if the Ministry has a plan to crack down on such means of securing services, for example, using "secret shopper" or methodologies of this nature?
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods I thank the Member for his question. Under Singapore's laws, the Government can order the take down of content linked to illegal activities and non-compliance can lead to further enforcement actions like blocking access or app removal. So, this is with regards to illegal chat groups that promote the provision of illegal P2P services.
Facilitating Cross-border Taxi Transfers between Singapore and Johor While Safeguarding Singapore P2P Drives' Livelihoods MOT and LTA are also looking to obtain further legal powers to ensure that online platforms comply with LTA's removal request for illegal P2P services should the platforms remain unresponsive. At the same time, the LTA has also been conducting operations to infiltrate into these chat groups and to take action against providers of such illegal services. Unfortunately, for operational reasons, I cannot share more details. But rest assured that LTA is aware of the situation.
Data on MDWs Seeking Treatment for Mental Health Conditions 3 Dr Hamid Razak asked the Minister for Manpower (a) from 2021 to 2025, whether there is data on the number of migrant domestic workers in Singapore who have (i) sought treatment for mental health conditions or (ii) encountered legal issues when seeking treatment for mental illnesses; and (b) if so, what is the data.
Data on MDWs Seeking Treatment for Mental Health Conditions Mr Speaker, each year, between 2022 and 2024, less than 20 migrant domestic workers (MDWs) sought medical assistance at public healthcare institutions, polyclinics and general practitioners (GPs) for mental health reasons. The Ministry of Manpower (MOM) has not come across any cases of MDWs encountering legal issues when seeking such assistance.
Data on MDWs Seeking Treatment for Mental Health Conditions MDWs' legal rights to access medical treatment, including for mental health conditions, are protected under the Employment of Foreign Manpower Act which requires employers to cover their MDW's medical expenses, including for mental health treatments. Employers who deny their MDWs of necessary medical treatment could be fined up to $10,000 and/or imprisoned for up to 12 months. The employer may also be barred from employing migrant workers in the future.
Data on MDWs Seeking Treatment for Mental Health Conditions Dr Razak.
Data on MDWs Seeking Treatment for Mental Health Conditions I thank the Senior Parliamentary Secretary for the answer. The reason I am asking this supplementary question is that we have feedback on the ground that some MDWs have cited mental health issues to seek secondary employment as well as breaking down soon after seeking employment following a medical assessment prior to getting employment. I think the question has been raised in the House before, on whether the Ministry would consider, at some point in time, when the burden of mental health illness, which is a certain threshold, if mental health assessment be part of the pre-employment assessment for MDWs in future.
Data on MDWs Seeking Treatment for Mental Health Conditions I thank the Member for the question. Today, MDWs are required to declare whether they have mental health conditions, as part of their pre-employment medical examination. So, where there is a positive declaration or any suspicion that they have mental health conditions, the attending doctor, at that time, may recommend further assessments, but with additional costs.
Data on MDWs Seeking Treatment for Mental Health Conditions This approach helps to keep medical tests and costs manageable for the employers in general, whilst ensuring that the individuals with healthcare conditions can be identified for further necessary follow-up. So, employers with concerns about their MDWs' mental health well-being, are also advised to seek medical advice, which may also be referred to a mental health facility or care professional.
Funding and Viewership Ratings for Public Service Broadcasting Programmes 4 Mr Foo Cexiang asked the Minister for Digital Development and Information (a) in each of the past five years, how much Government funding has been provided for public service broadcasting (PSB); (b) which PSB programmes has received such Government funding; and (c) whether the Ministry has assessed a need to recalibrate the amount of Government funding provided in order to boost the popularity of locally created content.
Funding and Viewership Ratings for Public Service Broadcasting Programmes 5 Mr Foo Cexiang asked the Minister for Digital Development and Information (a) whether the Ministry tracks data and statistics on viewership ratings of public service broadcasting (PSB) programmes; and (b) if so, how do the viewership ratings of PSB programmes in the past five years compare with those in the earlier preceding five years.
Funding and Viewership Ratings for Public Service Broadcasting Programmes Mr Speaker, may I have your permission to answer Question Nos 4 and 5 together?
Funding and Viewership Ratings for Public Service Broadcasting Programmes Go ahead.
Funding and Viewership Ratings for Public Service Broadcasting Programmes Sir, our Public Service Media (PSM) play an important role to inform, educate and connect Singaporeans. They provide trusted and timely sources of information to form a common basis for social discourse. They also reflect our multicultural fabric and way of life.
Funding and Viewership Ratings for Public Service Broadcasting Programmes To enable our PSM entities to effectively adapt and innovate in the fast-changing media landscape, the Government provides funding for their overall operations, rather than individual programmes.
Funding and Viewership Ratings for Public Service Broadcasting Programmes Over the past five financial years, the Government has allocated about $380 million annually to support Mediacorp to reach domestic audiences across four languages. This is lower than the annual funding of approximately $750 million allocated to the national broadcasters of Finland and Denmark, which have similar population sizes to Singapore. Mediacorp reached more than 90% of the local population through its owned and operated platforms as well as social media platforms. More than 75% of its audiences were satisfied with its services.
Funding and Viewership Ratings for Public Service Broadcasting Programmes We do not have comparable reach data in the earlier years as we have moved from tracking solely television (TV) reach to a broader reach metric across all Mediacorp's platforms and social media platforms. This is in keeping with the domestic audiences' changing consumption habits and Mediacorp's broader network strategy. For example, Mediacorp's TV reach dropped by about 10% over the last decade or so, but unique video viewers on meWATCH have increased by about 80% in the same period. Meanwhile, public satisfaction with Mediacorp has held steady, at more than 75% across this time period.
Funding and Viewership Ratings for Public Service Broadcasting Programmes The Government is committed to continue supporting our PSM to deliver high-quality and trusted news and entertainment content to Singaporeans. We will continue to ensure that Government funding can adequately and effectively support our PSM in achieving their national mission.
Funding and Viewership Ratings for Public Service Broadcasting Programmes Mr Foo.
Funding and Viewership Ratings for Public Service Broadcasting Programmes Speaker, Sir, I grew up watching Channel 8 and Channel 5, as did many of my classmates. These were hot discussion topics during lunch, but most importantly, these were core common memories grounded in the local culture and community. I think it is absolutely critical that we continue to have this for future generations.
Funding and Viewership Ratings for Public Service Broadcasting Programmes I understand the challenges of growing demands and competition, such as Netflix, but in particular, there were three developments recently that left me very encouraged.
Funding and Viewership Ratings for Public Service Broadcasting Programmes Mediacorp's Emerald Hill, the Little Nyonya story, I note, was Singapore's most watched series on Netflix, even overtaking hot K-dramas starring starring IU when it first debuted. It had more than 1.67 million views on meWATCH and Channel 8, and it is going to premiere on Chinese streaming platform Tencent at the end of this year. We have had many actors, local actors, nominated for Best Actor/Actresses at the Golden Horse Awards, and I am also looking forward to the return of Xie Shaoguang to the silver screen later.
Funding and Viewership Ratings for Public Service Broadcasting Programmes So, contrary to what naysayers say, I think the future is bright and we have to give this a further boost. Therefore, my question for the Minister is: is the Government prepared to support Mediacorp, our local broadcaster, in more collaborations with international platforms, such as Netflix and Tencent, so that our local produced dramas and shows will have a reach both local and overseas?
Funding and Viewership Ratings for Public Service Broadcasting Programmes Mr Speaker, I am very heartened by the Member's enthusiastic support for creators of local drama content, local entertainment content. I realise that he and I share something in common now. Growing up on local TV productions, we probably can hum several tunes together, given the right opportunity.
Funding and Viewership Ratings for Public Service Broadcasting Programmes He is right that there is a need to support such local production initiatives and he mentioned a few examples that are now available on streaming services, such as Netflix, and soon to come, Tencent. These are very important to widening the reach of not just Mediacorp's productions, but also the productions of independent media content creators in Singapore. They both contribute to the vibrancy of our local ecosystem.
Funding and Viewership Ratings for Public Service Broadcasting Programmes In that regard, I am happy to share with him that it is not just the negotiations that are commercial in nature that take place between the production houses, including Mediacorp, and streaming services. These will, obviously, have to be carried forward with a view towards making sure that there is actually demand for the productions.
Funding and Viewership Ratings for Public Service Broadcasting Programmes Another very important way in which we are supporting this effort is through the International Co-Production Fund that the Infocomm Media Development Authority launched about two years ago. What this programme does is to provide funding support to the producers of local drama series to collaborate with their international counterparts, and their international counterparts will include scriptwriters, directors, producers. The reason we want to do so is to enable a reach into the wider pool of talents that are available but, more importantly, to create content that has potentially an audience beyond Singapore, even though the themes are very much anchored on Singapore.
Funding and Viewership Ratings for Public Service Broadcasting Programmes In this way, we also help the local production houses, including Mediacorp, reach an international audience and tell Singapore stories better. And I am pleased to share with him that since this fund was launched, in fact, there have been productions that have been provided with the support, and we will assess to what extent this kind of support can be sustained as well as expanded in the future.
Singapore's Assessment of 20-Point Peace Plan for Gaza 6 Mr Ang Wei Neng asked the Minister for Foreign Affairs (a) how will Singapore support the 20-point peace plan for Gaza proposed by the United States; and (b) whether Singapore will consider playing a role in the peace plan if it is accepted by both Israel and Hamas.
Singapore's Assessment of 20-Point Peace Plan for Gaza 7 Mr Zhulkarnain Abdul Rahim asked the Minister for Foreign Affairs (a) how does the Government assess the viability of the Gaza peace plan in advancing a two-state solution; and (b) what role can Singapore play to contribute constructively, including the possible recognition of a Palestinian state under suitable conditions.
Singapore's Assessment of 20-Point Peace Plan for Gaza Mr Speaker, with your permission, can I address Question Nos 6 and 7 together?
Singapore's Assessment of 20-Point Peace Plan for Gaza Please proceed.
Singapore's Assessment of 20-Point Peace Plan for Gaza I believe Mr Gerald Giam1 has also filed a question, similar topic, for a subsequent Sitting. I will try to address the issue in this reply and also be happy to take supplementary questions. And if that is adequate, the Member can withdraw his Parliamentary Question that was filed for a later session.
Singapore's Assessment of 20-Point Peace Plan for Gaza Singapore welcomed the agreement that was reached on 9 October 2025 by Israel and Hamas on the first phase of the Trump peace plan. I need to commend the incredible achievement of President Trump, his negotiating team, which includes Mr Steve Witkoff, Marco Rubio, Jared Kushner and also, the invaluable part played by Egypt, Qatar and Turkey.
Singapore's Assessment of 20-Point Peace Plan for Gaza This is a critical plan and it is not just the details of the plan or how many points there are. But the fact is that America remains the indispensable superpower with real leverage and is willing to apply that leverage on the warring parties to arrive at where we are today. So, the first phase is now being implemented and in particular, that means a ceasefire and the release of the hostages, at least, those who are alive. And this is crucial, this is important, this is the first step of what will, in fact, be a long and arduous journey to peace. And we should have no illusions. Many things can still go wrong.
Singapore's Assessment of 20-Point Peace Plan for Gaza The next few essential steps are a surge in humanitarian assistance – and I will explain later what Singapore will do on that front – and then, the establishment of some kind of Transitional Authority. I would also expect and hope that there will be some United Nations (UN) Security Council resolution to provide an international legal framework for these arrangements. And then, the Palestinian Authority, which as part of that plan, has committed to reform. And I will also explain what we will do to assist the Palestinian Authority on its journey and, on its journey, which I would like to add, ultimately, to a two-state solution, which Singapore supports.
Singapore's Assessment of 20-Point Peace Plan for Gaza So, now let me turn to what we are doing and are hoping to do more of on the humanitarian front.
Singapore's Assessment of 20-Point Peace Plan for Gaza In the past two years, we have been working very closely with the Egyptian Red Crescent, with the Jordanian Hashemite Charity Organisation. We are also working with the World Food Programme; and we are also working with a few Egyptian hospitals, in fact, the medical team from the National University Hospital was just there a few weeks ago. We have also deployed as and when there has been hospital ships in the area to provide medical treatment to people who need help.
Singapore's Assessment of 20-Point Peace Plan for Gaza I think the immediate acceleration of humanitarian assistance now, is the fact that I hope the over land routes will open. That is crucial if humanitarian assistance is going to be delivered at the scale necessary. So, we will certainly look forward to doing more with our partners in the region and I would add, we also expect the Israelis to do their part to facilitate the delivery of humanitarian assistance over land through the crossings into Gaza.
Singapore's Assessment of 20-Point Peace Plan for Gaza It is premature to discuss what we will do with the Transitional Authority, because that is still inchoate at this point in time. But what I would say, is that, in the short term, in the immediate term, we certainly want to do more with the Palestinian Authority.
Singapore's Assessment of 20-Point Peace Plan for Gaza We have already been working with them for years – capacity-building programmes, technical assistance, more recently, scholarships. And all this with a view to enhancing the capacity, to exercise effective administrative oversight and to exercise the levers of government in their eventual statehood. And I would expect to increase the tempo of our interaction with the Palestinian Authority so that they can fulfil this ambition. Again, we will need time and we will stand ready to respond to the Palestinian Authority's assessment of its own needs and particularly, I hope its ability to exercise governance in Gaza as well, an area in which it has not been able to exercise governance for two decades.
Singapore's Assessment of 20-Point Peace Plan for Gaza So, I just want to give this House the assurance that we are watching developments very closely and we will do our best within the limits and constraints of distance and the fact that we are very small, but we happen to have a multiracial, multi-religious united society who is open-hearted, generous and willing to do, in a sense, more than our fair share to help people in need in this very dire set of circumstances.
Singapore's Assessment of 20-Point Peace Plan for Gaza Mr Ang.
Singapore's Assessment of 20-Point Peace Plan for Gaza Thank you, Sir. And thank you to the Minister for the comprehensive reply. When I submitted this Parliamentary Question, the 20-point peace plan was yet to be accepted by Hamas and Israel. We are glad that the plan has now been accepted and the hostages have been released.
Singapore's Assessment of 20-Point Peace Plan for Gaza I would like to ask the Minister if Singapore would consider helping to rebuild Gaza by setting up a clinic to offer treatments to the residents of Gaza and send a medical team to Gaza right now, in the interim. And two, will the Minister also consider setting up a school, for example, in Gaza, to educate the young that have very little opportunity to access quality education? And thirdly, will Singapore consider sending a small peacekeeping team to provide logistic support to the bigger efforts led by the US? Of course, I am suggesting this when the situation is more stable.
Singapore's Assessment of 20-Point Peace Plan for Gaza Mr Speaker, I have explained that we have, in fact, already been contributing on the medical front in the last two years. We look forward to doing more with our partners. But it depends very much on access, on security and on the needs.
Singapore's Assessment of 20-Point Peace Plan for Gaza I would make this point from a medical perspective. At this stage, you are not dealing with the immediate acute trauma. In fact, you are dealing with difficult sequelae like amputations, the need for prosthesis, the need for rehabilitation, the need to deal with psychological and emotional trauma. So, it is a different set of of specialties that are necessary. And my point again is depending on the needs and depending on our resources, we will do our part. That is on the medical side.
Singapore's Assessment of 20-Point Peace Plan for Gaza The exact locations of deployment are again dictated by exigencies on the ground. Where are the facilities in which our medical staff can make a contribution? And to that end, I am sure this House will agree, we also want to pay attention to the safety of our staff on the ground.
Singapore's Assessment of 20-Point Peace Plan for Gaza On schools, well, I think we should be cognisant that there are very few Arab fluent speakers in Singapore. But to the extent that we can work with "train the trainer" programmes, and in the long run, there is going to be a need for education, and vocational education and training, which will help enhance their ability to acquire the skills which are necessary for the long-term economy.
Singapore's Assessment of 20-Point Peace Plan for Gaza So, these are things again and I see where the Member is coming from, but let us be realistic and approach this in a step wise fashion.
Singapore's Assessment of 20-Point Peace Plan for Gaza It is premature to talk about peacekeeping troops. As I said, I would wait first for a UN Security Council resolution. I hope there will be one and we will assess very carefully what role we can contribute. It would be premature for me to make any commitments at this stage.
Singapore's Assessment of 20-Point Peace Plan for Gaza Mr Zhulkarnain Abdul Rahim.
Singapore's Assessment of 20-Point Peace Plan for Gaza Thank you, Mr Speaker. And I thank the Minister. I had a supplementary question on humanitarian aid assistance and I am heartened to hear that Singapore will continue to work with the international bodies, and at the same time maintain the safety of our humanitarian workers there.
Singapore's Assessment of 20-Point Peace Plan for Gaza My question is on the President Trump brokered peace deal. While it covers the phased withdrawal and also ceasefire, it leaves the questions of Palestinian statehood and the governance in Gaza unresolved. Does the Government view this as a credible step towards a genuine two-state solution? And then, as a follow-up question to that, I agree with the Minister that it may be too early or premature to tell whether this peace plan would be enduring and effective. But if it does lead to peace and stability for both the Israelis and the Palestinian people, we have to give credit where credit is due. Would Singapore nominate or support President Trump for the Nobel Peace Prize?
Singapore's Assessment of 20-Point Peace Plan for Gaza The 20-point plan, as the Member has said, is a great achievement. It is a first and essential step – but not sufficient to achieving peace, security, development, hope and even ultimately a two-state solution.
Singapore's Assessment of 20-Point Peace Plan for Gaza Let me come back to the basics of where Singapore stands. Singapore believes the Palestinians have a right to self determination. Singapore believes there should be a negotiated two-state solution. I think I just delivered a Ministerial Statement and we spent two or more than two hours on this subject a month ago. So, our position on that remains unchanged.