The text
12.00 pm Order. Oaths and Affirmations of Allegiance. Pursuant to the Constitution of the Republic of Singapore, the Special Select Committee nominated the following nine persons to the President for appointment as Nominated Members of Parliament:
12.00 pm Mr Azhar Bin Othman
12.00 pm Assoc Prof Goh Toh Chuan, Kenneth
12.00 pm Dr Haresh s/o Singaraju
12.00 pm Assoc Prof Terence Ho Wai Luen
12.00 pm Ms Kuah Boon Theng
12.00 pm Mr Mark Lee Kean Phi
12.00 pm Dr Neo Kok Beng
12.00 pm Prof Kenneth Poon Kin Loong
12.00 pm Mr Sanjeev Kumar Tiwari
12.00 pm President Tharman Shanmugaratnam, by Instruments of Appointment dated on the same day, appointed the nine Members as Nominated Members of Parliament for a term of two and a half years, with effect from 8 January 2026.
12.00 pm The Nominated Members are present today to take their seats. They will now take their oaths and affirmations of allegiance, and will proceed to the Table to do so, when their names are called.
12.06 pm [(proc text) The following Members took and subscribed the Oath of Allegiance, or made Affirmation of Allegiance, in the order below: (proc text)]
12.06 pm [(proc text) Mr Azhar Bin Othman (proc text)]
12.06 pm [(proc text) Assoc Prof Goh Toh Chuan, Kenneth (proc text)]
12.06 pm [(proc text) Dr Haresh s/o Singaraju (proc text)]
12.06 pm [(proc text) Assoc Prof Terence Ho Wai Luen (proc text)]
12.06 pm [(proc text) Ms Kuah Boon Theng (proc text)]
12.06 pm [(proc text) Mr Mark Lee Kean Phi (proc text)]
12.06 pm [(proc text) Dr Neo Kok Beng (proc text)]
12.06 pm [(proc text) Prof Kenneth Poon Kin Loong (proc text)]
12.06 pm [(proc text) Mr Sanjeev Kumar Tiwari (proc text)]
12.06 pm I welcome the Nominated Members and look forward to their participation in the proceedings of this House. [Applause.]
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums 1 Mr Yip Hon Weng asked the Coordinating Minister for Social Policies and Minister for Health regarding the new Integrated Shield Plan rider requirements (a) whether there will be an absolute cap on patients' out-of-pocket costs; (b) whether insurers can retain older policies with higher coverage; and (c) what measures will be implemented to prevent insurers from unilaterally reducing coverage for ageing policyholders on existing plans.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums 2 Ms Poh Li San asked the Coordinating Minister for Social Policies and Minister for Health in view of the Ministry’s move to curb rising healthcare insurance premiums by April 2026, how will families facing hefty medical bills be supported if their out-of-pocket expenses for co-payments become unaffordable.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums 3 Dr Hamid Razak asked the Coordinating Minister for Social Policies and Minister for Health regarding the new Integrated Shield Plan rider (a) whether the policy design anticipates that policyholders will continue to access private healthcare despite higher cost-sharing; (b) if so, what is the policy basis; and (c) what contingency measures have been developed to support restructured hospitals should there be increased patient volume due to shifts from private to public healthcare.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums 4 Mr Kenneth Tiong Boon Kiat asked the Coordinating Minister for Social Policies and Minister for Health given that the Monetary Authority of Singapore primarily regulates solvency, whether the Ministry intends to establish a dual-regulation framework to oversee the (i) healthcare outcomes (ii) panel selection criteria and (iii) loss-ratio efficiency of private insurers to ensure they align with national health goals.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums Mr Speaker, may I have your permission to answer Question Nos 1 to 4 together?
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums Please proceed.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums My response will also address written Parliamentary Questions raised by Dr Hamid Razak in today's Order Paper, and a similar question raised by Ms Mariam Jaafar scheduled for a subsequent Sitting. If the Members are satisfied with the response, they may wish to withdraw their questions after this session.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums Let me first try to put everyone on the same page. Over the past few years, patient load has been shifting from private hospitals to public hospitals. In 2010, the split between private and public was 15:85. In 2020, it became 12:88. Now, it is 10:90.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums The issue of insurance and insurance riders is not the reason why patient load is shifting from private to public. This has been happening for the last 15 years and there are many reasons. Part of it is that as people get older, some of them prefer public hospitals, where there are more disciplines and more holistic care.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums Another key reason is the escalating cost of private healthcare. That is in turn fuelled by Integrated Shield Plan (IP) riders, which provide overly generous health insurance coverage, and that leads to a greater tendency for over-servicing and over-consumption of healthcare services. Higher private healthcare cost is translated into higher private hospital IP rider premiums. IP premiums for private hospital have been growing at an average rate of 17% annually for the past three years – it is double that of IP premiums and even higher compared to MediShield Life premiums.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums Hence, every year, about 100,000 policyholders cancel or downgrade their IP rider policies. And I suspect amongst them, many switched from using private to public hospitals.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums To Dr Hamid’s question on the indicators that we used as a basis to decide policies, the data and signs have been clear and the situation is not ideal and not sustainable.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums We have been actively expanding healthcare infrastructure and expanding manpower in order to cope with rising workload and manage wait times. Our plans are significant, I have made them public before and I will not repeat here.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums To Mr Yip’s question, the new requirements for IP riders will only affect policyholders who purchased riders on or after 27 November 2025. Individual IP insurers will decide on their approach for rider policyholders who purchased their plans before 27 November 2025.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums As for affected IP riders, and these are the new ones, we should expect the following changes.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums First, IP rider premiums under the new design should be lower, on average 30% lower, compared to existing policies with maximum coverage. This is a significant recurrent saving.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums Second, the new IP rider policies will not cover the minimum IP deductibles and also require higher co-payment. We share Members’ concerns about patients’ out-of-pocket costs, especially for large medical bills. But this is precisely the main aim of the rider changes: preserve the protection against very large, unexpected medical bills, but disallow coverage of the minimum deductible, which is a fixed sum, which users of private hospitals tend to be able to afford. This would help restore health insurance to its original objective, which is to provide assurance against large, infrequent, often unexpected healthcare bills, rather than the small bills.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums For a rider plan designed with the new requirements, there will still be a cap of 5% co-payment up to $6,000 a year, in addition to the deductibles. In reality, these need not be out-of-pocket cash payments because patients can tap on their MediSave. We project that six in 10 rider claimants should not have to pay cash out-of-pocket after MediSave. For the remaining four in 10, majority of those with cash out-of-pocket would pay $1,000 or less, and practically all will pay $3,000 or less.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums We should bear in mind that most of the affected claimants that I am talking about pertain to private hospital patients. Their IP rider premiums have been driven up so high that under the new design, many can expect significant premium savings which can more or less offset the higher co-payments.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums In short, the current design of IP riders may no longer make financial sense for many policyholders and this change will help redress the situation.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums Let me give you an example. A 60-year-old on a private hospital IP and rider with maximum coverage, can now save about $1,600 a year in premiums by switching to the new rider. Over three years, he would have saved $4,800 in cash, which would be more than sufficient to offset the increase in co-payment for a typical procedure – for instance, $3,300 for a knee joint replacement surgery in a private hospital.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums Ms Poh asked about support measures for families facing unaffordable out-of-pocket expenses. Patients should consider their financial and healthcare needs when choosing where to seek care, including seeking subsidised care in public hospitals should affordability become an issue.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums Third impact, there should be, in the medium to long term, changes in the respective utilisation of private and public care and wait times. As I explained earlier, this change is part of our efforts to mitigate the shift of patients from private to public healthcare that has happened over the last 10 to 15 years, by putting the private healthcare sector and health insurance on a more sustainable path and ensuring private care remains accessible to Singaporeans in the long term.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums However, in the short term, as a few Members have expressed concern about, some individuals on the new riders may choose to seek care at public hospitals to reduce their co-payment. We will monitor this closely. Efforts to expand public health capacity – both in terms of hospital beds and outpatient capacity – are already ongoing to support the demands of an ageing population. If need be, we may need to implement surge capacity for selected treatments.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums On Mr Kenneth Tiong’s question relating to the regulation of IP insurers, the Ministry of Health (MOH) and the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) work closely together in exercising regulatory oversight of IP insurers, to ensure that policyholders’ interests are protected and the products are sustainable.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums MOH’s key role is to oversee the development and operation of the public healthcare system and ensure universal access to healthcare. For individuals who prefer private healthcare and purchase private insurance, we should not micro-manage or prescribe the market practices. Instead, we set requirements pertaining to the key parameters of IPs and riders, such as co-payment and deductible requirements, to ensure that the schemes are sustainable. We only step in when we see a serious market failure emerging, which is why we have intervened in this case, to tighten the design of IP riders.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums Doctor panels are an example of cost-management measures put in place by the market, by insurers in response to rising private healthcare bills and claims. MOH has been and will continue working with key stakeholders including insurers, healthcare providers, hospitals, medical professionals and consumer representatives through the Multilateral Healthcare Insurance Committee on these matters, to strike a balance between the interests of all stakeholders.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums To sum up, we must take a long-term and balanced view of this issue so that we can put private healthcare and insurance on a more sustainable path.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums Mr Yip Hon Weng.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums Thank you, Mr Speaker. I thank the Minister for his response. Minister, I filed this Parliamentary Question (PQ) because I have received much feedback from many seniors in my constituency who have concerns about the new rider requirements.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums I just have one supplementary question. I understand that policyholders may keep existing riders, but insurers may respond by re-pricing or adjusting the benefits that amount to the de facto coverage reduction. What specific safeguards will MOH impose to prevent such indirect erosion of benefits, especially for ageing policyholders with limited options?
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums The most important safeguard is to make sure that IP rider policies are sustainable. So, while at the point of being sold the policies, the agent probably told them, "Buy all these for peace of mind – not just peace of mind, but absolute peace of mind, you do not have to worry".
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums But that went down a path of unsustainability. So, while you enjoy it for a while, it is obvious, through my answer, that I have explained, it is becoming unsustainable. Because when there is over-coverage, in a private hospital, the bill just goes up. You cannot blame anybody; it is just the way human nature is. Somebody else is paying for most of the bill, so between doctor and patient, somehow, you will oversupply and I will overconsume. And the bill just keeps on going up at an unsustainable pace. And it still comes back to the consumer, to the patient, in terms of higher premiums – which is why, now, the same residents that gave the Member the feedback, is also screaming, "Why is my IP rider premium going up at 20% a year?" It is because cost is going up.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums We need to tackle the issue at the root and our strong hypothesis is – in fact, there is a lot of literature on this – over-coverage just leads to wastage and cost increases. To redress this, for new riders, we are making the design different, a bit more co-payment, instil discipline in both the supply and demand for healthcare; then, I think we are much more likely to have a more sustainable position.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums So, explain to your residents: choose this new rider; tell them they are paying very high premiums, rising premiums now for a tail risk, and it may not be worth it. Do their calculations, talk to their financial advisors. If they choose the new rider design, they save, on average, 30% on premiums every year. For someone in their 70s, that is a lot. That is $3,000 a year! Someone in their 60s saves about $2,000 a year.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums That money saved – it differs from case to case – often is more than enough to pay the deductibles and co-payment.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums Ms Poh Li San.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums Thank you, Speaker and Minister. I have one supplementary question. How would MOH prevent adverse selection, that is, those who have existing riders continue to over-consume medical services; or those who actually do not have the means to finance the co-payments and deductibles, then, decide to give up their existing riders and may, possibly, end up delaying their treatment?
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums There are a few questions in that question, I think. But if I were to suss out what are the key questions, one is, you want to have continuity of care. So, be assured, even if they find that, today, they cannot afford their IP rider anymore, because it is getting expensive and they give it up, there is always public subsidised healthcare. That is our assurance to all Singaporeans. You can always come back to public healthcare. And we are expanding the system; we are recruiting manpower. While we are very busy, this is our commitment to all Singaporeans.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums So, on the healthcare front, be assured that it is always universal healthcare through the public health system.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums As for others, who continue to stay on their riders, I think they are also feeling the pinch. As I mentioned to Mr Yip just now, IP rider premiums are going up at a very fast rate because cost is going up at a very fast rate. And why is cost going up? Because there is over-generous coverage, leading to overconsumption, unnecessary treatment. So, many existing rider policyholders are also rethinking. I hope more would do so.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums Increasingly, over dinner tables, amongst friends and colleagues, more people are thinking about their rider policies, that they may not be worth it. And more and more people do their calculations and find that it is not worth it. And as it is, 100,000 every year are changing. With these changes, with this signalling, I think more may do so. At some point, insurance companies have to do their calculations. Year to year, they do change their terms and conditions, and we have to see what they intend to do with existing rider policyholders.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums Dr Hamid Razak.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums Mr Speaker, I thank the Minister for the reply. The reason I asked the PQ is that there has been lots of sentiments from my colleagues in the restructured hospitals that waiting times for subsidised patients have been increasing. They are worried that with this new rider that is coming up from April that those who are on private riders will then switch to public healthcare because of the higher cost-sharing that is in place.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums Will the Ministry and the Minister be able to reassure that there is data in place to say that this new rider principles will, in fact, continue to encourage those with private riders to remain in private healthcare? And also reassure that insurance companies will not make unilateral decisions on premium hikes, for example, which, again, will deter our residents from staying in the private healthcare and this will give rise to a surge capacity in our public institutions as well?
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums Let me briefly address the comment that Dr Hamid made towards the end of his question, which is to hope that insurers do not unilaterally make premium hikes. But these are private contracts. The Government does not regulate their premiums. And when insurance companies find that cost is going up and they are barely making – most of them are actually making losses on their private hospital insurance portfolio – they will end up raising premiums. This is something we are watching, but this is a commercial arrangement, something that they may do.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums I thank the Member for raising the concerns of his colleagues in the public healthcare system. I am totally with them. I am equally concerned as them, which is why we are making this move. Because, as I mentioned earlier, over 10, 15 years, the shift is very discernible, away from private into public and as I mentioned, a key reason is the rising cost in private hospitals.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums And why is cost rising? It is because IP riders are fuelling that cost increase, shifting people from private to public. It makes a lot more sense when someone who has the ability to buy private healthcare insurance, including a rider, wants to use private insurance. But half of them, today, switch to public subsidised care, for whatever reasons.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums It will help the entire system and in particular, the public healthcare system, if more of them who can afford it, stay with private hospital care. And so, private hospital care has to become more accessible, more affordable. But we cannot do that without this adjustment in IP rider policy.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums So, please tell your colleagues that my and my colleagues in MOH's assurance is that we are watching this closely. Wait times are very important to us, capacity adequacy is very important to us and their well-being is very important to us.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums Mr Kenneth Tiong.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums Thank you, Speaker. MOH itself notes a trend of escalating cost and premiums alongside tightening claims practices. MAS can act on unfair claims handling, but MAS is primarily a financial regulator. MOH's direct levers seem strongest when policies are MediSave-linked.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums So, my question is, what enforceable levers does MOH have to ensure that insurer conduct advances healthcare affordability and access? And where does MOH remain dependent on MAS?
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums Also, it appears to me that no one is cleanly accountable for insurer behaviour as a health system actor. Does the Minister believe that this is a gap that requires filling?
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums The IP rider has become a problem and we are taking action. And I think that shows accountability that when something is not sustainable, not working in the best interest of the patients and people, we will take action.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums Between MAS and MOH, I think we have plenty of levers and we will work together to make sure that insurers are operating in a way that is ethical, that is viable but at the same time in the interest of patients and the people we serve. And I think we have more than enough levers to do so.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums There is a part of Mr Tiong's question that talks about panel doctors. What we want to make sure is that Government's main responsibility is actually to run the public healthcare system to ensure universal accessibility. But when it comes to private healthcare, we let the market operate. But if the market cannot operate in a laissez-faire manner, we will regulate. Where we regulate is clinical effectiveness, safety, and key parameters that are sensible and make the system sustainable, and there is no market failure.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums But we should not be tempted to become micro-managing, because it is the worst thing to do to say that we leave it to the market, but we micro-manage all their actions and behaviour. I think that is the worst of both worlds. Then, you might as well nationalise it. But we already have a huge nationalised system in public healthcare. So, for private healthcare, control the important levers, control the key parameters, but let the market operate.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums Last supplementary question. Mr Fadli Fawzi.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums Thank you, Speaker, Minister. Is there sufficient surge capacity in our healthcare system to deal with more private patients coming in after this policy change, especially for smaller procedures that are under the deductible limit?
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums Again, I will want to remind the Member that because of the ageing population, demand has been going up. There has also been a trend, a secular trend of private hospital patients moving to public. So, whatever problem that the Member is painting now, it has been happening for the last 15, 20 years.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums And it is an issue we are most concerned about. We have spoken in this Chamber, many times how we are expanding capacity, ensuring people are healthy, moderating the demand by controlling chronic diseases. But IP riders are an additional fuel to the fire that we are facing, which is, mainly, an ageing population pushing up healthcare demand.
Managing Healthcare Insurance Premiums So, we will continue to expand the system and take a multi-prong approach to both increase supply and moderating the demand for healthcare, especially unnecessary treatment and wastage.
Lower Investment Returns Reported by Temasek Holdings and GIC 5 Mr Saktiandi Supaat asked the Prime Minister and Minister for Finance (a) whether the Government assesses that Temasek’s and GIC’s risk-adjusted returns relative to appropriate global benchmarks remain competitive; and (b) how their mandates should evolve to balance capital preservation with the need for higher real returns ahead.
Lower Investment Returns Reported by Temasek Holdings and GIC 6 Mr Shawn Loh asked the Prime Minister and Minister for Finance (a) whether the investment returns of GIC and Temasek Holdings have underperformed the Government's expectation; (b) if so, whether there is an impact on the Government's Net Investment Returns Contribution to the Budget; and (c) what steps have been taken to ensure that the investment entities have incentives that are aligned to achieve better performance.
Lower Investment Returns Reported by Temasek Holdings and GIC 7 Mr Shawn Loh asked the Prime Minister and Minister for Finance (a) whether the Government has assessed the merits of a low-cost passive index-tracking investment approach for its investments; (b) whether the Government has compared this to GIC and Temasek Holdings’ active and more costly investment management approaches; and (c) if so, what are the considerations in deciding to give GIC and Temasek Holdings the investment mandates to choose the latter approach.
Lower Investment Returns Reported by Temasek Holdings and GIC 8 Mr Liang Eng Hwa asked the Prime Minister and Minister for Finance (a) whether the Government is satisfied with the long-term investment performances of GIC, Temasek and MAS when measured against the relevant risk-adjusted global benchmarks; and (b) whether the Government sees the need to review the capital allocation and investment risks framework of GIC, Temasek and MAS.
Lower Investment Returns Reported by Temasek Holdings and GIC 9 Mr Fadli Fawzi asked the Prime Minister and Minister for Finance (a) whether the difference between GIC's investment returns and the interest payments made by the Government to the CPF Board on Special Singapore Government Securities has narrowed in tandem with the underperformance of GIC relative to other major sovereign wealth funds; and (b) if so, how will this impact the Government's fiscal position or rate of reserves accumulation.
Lower Investment Returns Reported by Temasek Holdings and GIC 10 Assoc Prof Jamus Jerome Lim asked the Prime Minister and Minister for Finance (a) whether the Government is aware if GIC uses risk-adjusted performance metrics such as the Sharpe ratio in assessing portfolio performance relative to its reference portfolio; and (b) if so, whether a description of such metrics can be provided at a high level.
Lower Investment Returns Reported by Temasek Holdings and GIC 11 Mr Liang Eng Hwa asked the Prime Minister and Minister for Finance (a) in view of the fragmenting global geopolitical environment and its associated investment risks, whether the Government sees the need to review the current investment mandates of both GIC and Temasek; and (b) whether the emerging investment landscape is assessed to be conducive to sustaining a steady Net Investment Returns Contribution in the next decade.
Lower Investment Returns Reported by Temasek Holdings and GIC Mr Speaker, may I have your permission to answer Question Nos 5 to 11 in today's Order Paper together?
Lower Investment Returns Reported by Temasek Holdings and GIC Please proceed.
Lower Investment Returns Reported by Temasek Holdings and GIC Thank you. My reply will also cover Question No 4 for written answer filed by Mr Ng Shi Xuan for today's Sitting.
Lower Investment Returns Reported by Temasek Holdings and GIC Mr Speaker, recent media reports have compared the performance of GIC and Temasek with that of other funds, including other sovereign wealth funds. Such comparisons are often done, but they should be interpreted in their proper context because different funds operate under different mandates and risk profiles.
Lower Investment Returns Reported by Temasek Holdings and GIC The Government assesses GIC and Temasek's performance primarily against their respective mandates and risk profiles, and not with other funds. Our focus has always been on long-term performance, rather than on short-term or year-to-year fluctuations.
Lower Investment Returns Reported by Temasek Holdings and GIC GIC is the Government's fund manager, and its mandate is to preserve and enhance the international purchasing power of the assets under its management. In recent years, GIC took pre-emptive measures to moderate its risk exposure, in anticipation of increased market volatility and heightened valuations. These measures were intended to keep portfolio risks within acceptable limits and to guard against the possibility of significant asset impairment in the event of a sharp market correction. But as equity markets have continued to remain elevated, these prudent de-risking measures resulted in some foregone returns.
Lower Investment Returns Reported by Temasek Holdings and GIC Any assessment of returns must, therefore, be considered alongside the risks that are taken to achieve them – a point that Assoc Prof Jamus Lim made, where he referred to the Sharpe ratio in his Parliamentary Question (PQ). GIC monitors a wide range of risk indicators, including and beyond the Sharpe ratio. In fact, GIC publishes both the returns and volatility or the risks associated with its portfolio in its annual report to provide a more complete picture.
Lower Investment Returns Reported by Temasek Holdings and GIC Ultimately, what is more important is the longer-term performance that is achieved within acceptable risk limits. On that basis, GIC has achieved a real return of 3.8% per annum over the past 20 years. This outcome reflects, in part, GIC’s active management, which enabled it to consistently add value to portfolio returns, preserve the international purchasing power of the assets under its management and deliver returns above global inflation.
Lower Investment Returns Reported by Temasek Holdings and GIC Temasek began as a holding company for the Government’s local assets. While Singapore-based Temasek Portfolio Companies (TPCs) continue to form a core part of its total portfolio, Temasek has progressively expanded its direct equity investments overseas – initially in Asia, and more recently, across global markets.
Lower Investment Returns Reported by Temasek Holdings and GIC Temasek operates mainly as an active, bottom-up investor. It does not operate against a conventional reference portfolio. Instead, it invests directly in companies in the geographies and domains where it has built deep capabilities, and where it sees long-term growth potential. Relative to GIC, Temasek therefore operates at the higher end of the risk spectrum.
Lower Investment Returns Reported by Temasek Holdings and GIC In recent years, Temasek’s performance was affected by the performance of the Chinese market, though this was mitigated by higher returns from its growing investments in Europe and the United States (US). Nonetheless, over the last 20-year period, Temasek has reported a Total Shareholder Return of 8% per annum in US dollar terms.
Lower Investment Returns Reported by Temasek Holdings and GIC Taken as a whole, the Government’s assessment is that the returns generated by GIC and Temasek are reasonable and within expectations, given their mandates and risk profiles. We will continue to review their mandates and performance regularly, in line with changes in the global economic investment landscape.
Lower Investment Returns Reported by Temasek Holdings and GIC Some Members asked about the implications of our investment entities’ recent performance on the sustainability of the Net Investment Returns Contribution (NIRC) and the Government’s ability to meet our Central Provident Fund (CPF) liabilities. As explained in this House previously, the Net Investment Return framework was designed to ensure a steady and sustainable stream of income for the annual Budget. The NIRC is thus derived from the expected long-term real rate of return which the Reserves can sustain, and not short-term market returns.
Lower Investment Returns Reported by Temasek Holdings and GIC The Government is able to meet all debt servicing costs and obligations, including the committed CPF rates through the Special Singapore Government Securities (SSGS). GIC does not just manage the SSGS or CPF monies on their own, but a combined pool of Government funds, including a significant sum of unencumbered assets. This approach allows GIC to invest for the long term and to secure good long-term returns.
Lower Investment Returns Reported by Temasek Holdings and GIC As investment markets are uncertain and volatile, GIC’s returns over shorter periods could be low or even negative. But the Government is able to absorb these short-term market risks, because it has a strong balance sheet. This substantial buffer of net assets enables the Government to meet the obligations on its liabilities and continues to underpin the Government’s strong fiscal position.
Lower Investment Returns Reported by Temasek Holdings and GIC Mr Saktiandi Supaat.
Lower Investment Returns Reported by Temasek Holdings and GIC Thank you, Mr Speaker. I have two supplementary questions. First of all, I would like to declare that I am an employee of a financial institution.
Lower Investment Returns Reported by Temasek Holdings and GIC Mr Speaker, the income from the Reserves play an important role in the Government's revenue, but as the Senior Minister of State has mentioned, the environment has become more volatile. Global markets have become more volatile. In the previous PQ, we have actually discussed about expenditure on healthcare and others being more demanding.
Lower Investment Returns Reported by Temasek Holdings and GIC So, my two supplementary questions, Mr Speaker: first, how will the Ministry model the impact of a prolonged global resolve cycle on sovereign investment returns and the resulting implications for the Budget stability and social spending sustainability?