Skip to content
Official report

Hansard

Hansard, Monday, 10 March 2025

Feedback & support

The text

(1)

Requirement for Stallholders to Personally Operate Their Hawker Stalls 1 Mr Edward Chia Bing Hui asked the Minister for Sustainability and the Environment (a) why does NEA require stallholders to personally operate their hawker stalls; (b) how is this aligned with the objectives of hawker centres; and (c) whether there are any circumstances where NEA exercises flexibility when hawker stallholders are temporarily unable to operate their stalls due to personal reasons.

(2)

Requirement for Stallholders to Personally Operate Their Hawker Stalls Sir, stalls in our hawker centres provide an opportunity for Singaporeans to personally operate their own small food businesses at lower costs and provide affordable hawker food options. By personal operations, the National Environment Agency (NEA) requires hawkers to physically operate their stalls.

(3)

Requirement for Stallholders to Personally Operate Their Hawker Stalls The requirement for a hawker to personally operate the stall is important as it prevents subletting. If this requirement is not imposed, the tenant who has successfully bid for the stall could potentially sublet the stall and collect the difference in rent. It may encourage persons to bid for a stall without an intention to run a stall but only to sublet it. If the tenant is unable to operate the stall, he is expected to return the stall to NEA which will then release the stall for other interested hawkers to bid for the stall. This will give new hawkers a fair chance to enter the trade.

(4)

Requirement for Stallholders to Personally Operate Their Hawker Stalls The Member asks whether there are any circumstances where NEA exercises flexibility when hawker stallholders are temporarily unable to operate their stalls. Indeed, in situations where a hawker is temporarily unable to operate the stall for good reasons, for example, for medical reasons, he or she can appoint a joint operator or a nominee to operate the stall during that period. In the event that the stall has to close temporarily, NEA may also extend support through rental waivers.

(5)

Requirement for Stallholders to Personally Operate Their Hawker Stalls NEA supports hawkers who wish to expand their businesses by allowing individuals to hold up to two cooked food stalls in our hawker centres, provided they are able to divide their time and operate the stalls personally. Hawkers have also made use of other arrangements to grow their businesses. Some take on more stalls at hawker centres with their family members as stallholders or sell their recipes to other hawkers who in turn successfully bid for those stalls. Others continue to operate their stalls personally even as they expand their businesses to other establishments, such as coffee shops and food courts.

(6)

Requirement for Stallholders to Personally Operate Their Hawker Stalls For those who are unable to personally operate their hawker stalls, they may relinquish their stalls or hand them over to a family member. There are also hawkers who enter into franchise arrangements, where they can leverage established brands to start or grow their businesses. This is a good way for them to learn the ropes and enter the food and beverage (F&B) space. It is in this context that we sometimes see stalls carrying the same brand across different hawker centres. NEA does not restrict such arrangements, as long as registered stallholders in hawker centres are still able to fulfil the tenancy requirements by personally operating their stalls.

(7)

Requirement for Stallholders to Personally Operate Their Hawker Stalls NEA generally does not allow corporates to bid directly for and operate hawker stalls as this could crowd out aspiring hawkers, and run counter to our intent of providing opportunities for Singaporeans to run small food businesses. We have made some exceptions based on social considerations. For example, operators of Socially-conscious Enterprise Hawker Centres are allowed to run a small number of stalls as part of their operations. But these operators are required to plough back at least 50% of any surpluses to benefit the centre and stallholders, such as by providing shuttle services from transport nodes.

(8)

Requirement for Stallholders to Personally Operate Their Hawker Stalls Our hawker centres have played an integral role in nation building and hawker culture has been an important part of the Singapore identity. We want our hawker centres to continue providing opportunities for Singaporeans to directly operate their own small food businesses. We will continue to support them as best as we can.

(9)

Requirement for Stallholders to Personally Operate Their Hawker Stalls Mr Chia.

(10)

Requirement for Stallholders to Personally Operate Their Hawker Stalls Thank you, Mr Speaker. Sir, I would like to ask two follow-up clarifications to the Senior Minister of State. First of all, does the current rule of requiring hawkers to personally operate the stall have actually been effective in preventing unintended subletting and has it also unintentionally discouraged genuine hawkers? In the case of hawkers who are intending to expand, can they re-assign their stall leases to business partner without the need to re-bid or to re-apply for their stalls?

(11)

Requirement for Stallholders to Personally Operate Their Hawker Stalls The second clarification is that, today, for new hawkers to grow their business, they actually have to invest in branding, work on social media marketing and some might also set up their central kitchen or choose shared services. And many of these business activities require them to be physically present elsewhere than physically present at their stalls. My understanding is that today, for a stallholder, they must actually operate minimally eight hours physically. Or in the case where they have two stalls, they have to be physically present at the stall for four hours. Can the Ministry exercise some flexibilities for hawkers who may need to be outside of the stall because there are many other business activities that they have to operate?

(12)

Requirement for Stallholders to Personally Operate Their Hawker Stalls Sir, I thank the Member for his questions. On his first question about personally operating the stall, we believe that physical presence is actually the most practical and fair way of ensuring that the stall is not sublet and the person is operating it personally. Because through these inspections, NEA is able to directly monitor whether stallholders physically operate their stalls during the stall's operating hours.

(13)

Requirement for Stallholders to Personally Operate Their Hawker Stalls The truth is, to catch subletting is not so easy, because it is a private arrangement that can take place between the person who has bid for the place but has no intention to run it and under the table, could be collecting subletting income from someone else and profiting from rent.

(14)

Requirement for Stallholders to Personally Operate Their Hawker Stalls As I have said, we have let out our stalls for sometimes even below market rates in terms of rent. And there are stalls that successfully bid as low as $1. What we do not want is for a subletter to then profit from the huge margin by extracting rent from the person who is interested to run the stall and pass the cost subsequently to consumers.

(15)

Requirement for Stallholders to Personally Operate Their Hawker Stalls And if there is a way for us to catch it better, we would want that. So, if there are suspicions of subletting, NEA would follow up on feedback where possible. Nonetheless, NEA also understands that there are some stallholders who may need to be away from their stalls for a short period of time, to run quick errands for example. In such cases, we will exercise flexibility and give these stallholders the ability to do so without taking any penalty actions on them.

(16)

Requirement for Stallholders to Personally Operate Their Hawker Stalls On Mr Chia's question about stallholders who have expanded their businesses to say, central kitchens and have many other food establishments elsewhere, I think if the persons have already expanded their business beyond hawker centres and are very successful, and they have no time to run the stalls themselves, I think it is only right that they actually relinquish the stalls to someone else who needs the space better and focus on their business instead.

(17)

Requirement for Stallholders to Personally Operate Their Hawker Stalls One option they could do this is to nominate their own family member to take over the stall. This is something allowed under our policies. But to nominate the stall to an unrelated person opens up the risk of someone then profiteering and buying whatever has been given to this person through a business transaction. That is something that we will not allow.

(18)

Requirement for Stallholders to Personally Operate Their Hawker Stalls Assoc Prof Jamus Lim.

(19)

Requirement for Stallholders to Personally Operate Their Hawker Stalls Thank you. Could I just quickly clarify? The Senior Minister of State said that you will exercise flexibility – I had a resident, for instance, who had sought that flexibility by asking for a window by which he had to physically be present at the stall for the inspections. I understand again, of course, that you want there to be some kind of spot checks to prevent instances of subletting. But nevertheless, it seems like giving a window is a reasonable accommodation. Is that not something that is considered part of that flexibility?

(20)

Requirement for Stallholders to Personally Operate Their Hawker Stalls Sir, I do not know the case that the Member is talking about. There could be constraints on the ground. There could be individual circumstances. But there are place managers at each and every one of our hawker centres. So, I do hope that there is communication between the place manager and the hawker who may need some flexibility on the ground to do so.

(21)

Requirement for Stallholders to Personally Operate Their Hawker Stalls I believe our principle is to make sure that we allow flexibility where it is needed. But if it is time and again when the things are flouted and it is too much of a repeat ask, then I think it calls into question whether that is a genuine need or whether there are some actions to try and circumvent our rules. So, we have to take things on a case-by-case basis.

(22)

Requirement for Stallholders to Personally Operate Their Hawker Stalls But I would say that, in the end, it really is about what we want to see our hawker culture thrive. There are many successful hawkers who have done well and expanded their business outside of hawker centres, but yet they try their very best to run those one or two stalls that they started their business with personally. But there are also those who have successfully branched out to other F&B establishments where there are no restrictions like what we have, and they have chosen to give up their hawker stalls as well.

(23)

Requirement for Stallholders to Personally Operate Their Hawker Stalls So, I think to be fair to all players, we have to respect the rules. Our aim is to encourage more small businesses to enter the hawker trade because of our low barrier to entry, but not allow chain players to start to dominate our hawker scene and change the texture and authenticity of our hawker culture.

(24)

Requirement for Stallholders to Personally Operate Their Hawker Stalls Last supplementary question. Mr Chia.

(25)

Requirement for Stallholders to Personally Operate Their Hawker Stalls Thank you, Speaker for your indulgence. I think the Senior Minister of State answered my first clarification. On my second clarification, where I shared that today, many of the new hawkers are also investing in time on social media marketing, they could be at the central kitchen preparing some of the ingredients, they could be doing deliveries to their customers – and they cannot be physically at the stall. But today, some of the place managers are actively enforcing, based on strict hours, for example, eight hours if they have one stall; four hours, they have two stalls. Will there be flexibility accorded in terms of the actual hours they are physically present? And how will this flexibility be consistent and fair throughout all NEA hawker centres?

(26)

Requirement for Stallholders to Personally Operate Their Hawker Stalls Sir, I think this is something that I think we have to look at with some sensitivity. Because as I said in my earlier reply to the Member Jamus Lim, if a hawker's business has grown to a size where they are unable to split the time properly and they have to focus their time more on the businesses outside the hawker centres, then I think it is time for them to really take a hard look and see where their main revenue source is coming from. I think if they have grown to such a scale, they ought to focus on that and they may have to give up that stall in which we are giving them, to some extent, a lower rent and a lower barrier to entry, to someone else who may need the space more.

(27)

Requirement for Stallholders to Personally Operate Their Hawker Stalls I know there are members of the public who have seen this particular case that has surfaced on the Internet recently, on social media. I think the Member Mr Chia has engaged this particular hawker before, Mr Noorman Mubarak.

(28)

Requirement for Stallholders to Personally Operate Their Hawker Stalls He put up a social media post about his wife who's pregnant and is unable to run the stall personally. But that is a very one-sided story. Actually, NEA has offered his wife to nominate another person to take over the stall while she is undergoing pregnancy. But instead of accepting that as a legitimate option to do so, they decided to put it on social media to try and say that we have been unhelpful.

(29)

Requirement for Stallholders to Personally Operate Their Hawker Stalls I would say that for individuals like Mr Mubarak, who's running, I think about 20 stalls outside of the NEA system – he has two to three stalls in NEA hawker centres, but up to I think 21 registered stalls in other F&B establishments.

(30)

Requirement for Stallholders to Personally Operate Their Hawker Stalls We are quite happy that hawkers like him have succeeded, but it is understandable that as a business owner he wants to focus on his other business and try not to focus as much attention on the hawker stalls. But that is not something that we would want, because we cannot allow our NEA hawker system to be catering to the interest of such private chain owners. We need to make sure that there are opportunities for others to enter the trade as well.

(31)

Requirement for Stallholders to Personally Operate Their Hawker Stalls Let us remember that hawker centres are not just commercial spaces, but they are also community dining spaces with a social role. We have invested in our hawker centres to provide affordable cooked food for Singaporeans, while wanting to enable small food businesses to earn a reasonable living. So, we have deliberately kept the barrier to entry low to allow many hawkers, including like Mr Mubarak himself, to build a successful business and expand to other F&B establishment.

(32)

Requirement for Stallholders to Personally Operate Their Hawker Stalls So, we have to maintain fairness, because this is the important role that our hawker centres play. We are happy to see our hawkers succeed, but we must also prevent individuals from gaming the system by profiteering from subletting.

(33)

Requirement for Stallholders to Personally Operate Their Hawker Stalls So, if we did not enforce these rules, what would the alternative be? Should we allow stalls to be fully run by hired workers as businesses expand and they cannot run the stalls themselves? If so, hawker centres would become rather indistinguishable from coffee shops and food courts, eroding the authenticity. And over time, our hawker culture will be diluted, shifting from passionate hawkers serving their own dishes to our customers, to businesses just prioritising efficiency and scale over heritage and quality.

(34)

Requirement for Stallholders to Personally Operate Their Hawker Stalls We support technology adoption, be it central kitchen, be it marketing technology through social media to improve. But what we want is to make sure that as they do so, they do not compromise and erode the culture that we are trying to protect and grow.

(35)

Requirement for Stallholders to Personally Operate Their Hawker Stalls So, while we support technology to improve stall level efficiency, we should not do so at the expense of our hawkers stepping away from running the stalls themselves and letting the workers just take over the day-to-day running and cooking of the food. Because if hawkers wish to extend to a chain model and become bigger, they have the option to move out of the hawker centres and do it at other F&B establishments, where we do not impose the restrictions.

(36)

Requirement for Stallholders to Personally Operate Their Hawker Stalls The reality, therefore, is that we need to balance between protecting our heritage, keeping the food affordable and ensuring fair opportunities for new hawkers. So, these are quite difficult to maintain if we do not have rules to manage. It would have been far easier for NEA to let the hawker centres just operate like any other commercial outfits, such as food courts or coffee shops, without any restrictions on subletting or any business model that the operators wish to do. But that would mean losing what makes them really special today.

(37)

Requirement for Stallholders to Personally Operate Their Hawker Stalls So, if Singaporeans are prepared to accept hawker food at price points, quality and the business model just like any other coffee shops or food courts, then we could remove these restrictions and let the free market take its course. But for now, we believe these regulations will help ensure that hawker centres remain a place for authentic, accessible and culturally significant food experiences for Singaporeans.

(38)

Ensuring Real Wage Growth for Security Officers following PWM Implementation 2 Mr Gerald Giam Yean Song asked the Minister for Manpower (a) whether the Ministry has data on security agencies which incorporate security officers’ allowances into their basic pay following the implementation of the Progressive Wage Model (PWM); (b) if so, whether this has resulted in any reduction of total wages for security officers; and (c) what measures are in place to ensure that salary adjustments under PWM result in genuine income growth rather than reclassification of existing wage components.

(39)

Ensuring Real Wage Growth for Security Officers following PWM Implementation Sir, we do not have data on security agencies which incorporate allowances into basic wages following the implementation of the Progressive Wage Model (PWM). However, we observe that gross wages for security officers, which include allowances, have increased since the implementation of PWM for security officers in 2016. From 2016, when we started PWM, to 2023, the median gross wage of Singapore Citizens and Permanent Residents working as full-time security officers increased 19.2% cumulatively.

(40)

Ensuring Real Wage Growth for Security Officers following PWM Implementation Employers have the prerogative to decide how to structure workers’ overall compensation, provided they comply with PWM requirements. While it is possible for employers to incorporate allowances into the basic wage to offset PWM-mandated wage increases, such practices are unsustainable. PWM requirements increase year on year and there is a limit to how much wage components can be shifted.

(41)

Ensuring Real Wage Growth for Security Officers following PWM Implementation Let me explain. In 2016, the PWM wage requirements for a security officer employed by a security agency was $1,300. [Please refer to "Clarification by Senior Minister of State for Manpower", Official Report, 10 March 2025, Vol 95, Issue 161, Correction By Written Statement section.] From 1 January 2025, this year, this has increased to $2,870 and by 2028, this would increase to $3,530. So, this translates to PWM raising the salaries of security officers to around 220% more than the wage requirement in 2016.

(42)

Ensuring Real Wage Growth for Security Officers following PWM Implementation This means that security officers will likely see that total take-home pay, which includes both basic wages and variable components, such as allowances, increase over the coming years. Security officers who wish to report contractual breaches or employers not adhering to PWM requirements can approach their union or contact the Ministry of Manpower (MOM) for assistance.

(43)

Ensuring Real Wage Growth for Security Officers following PWM Implementation Mr Gerald Giam.

(44)

Ensuring Real Wage Growth for Security Officers following PWM Implementation I thank the Senior Minister of State for his reply. Sir, given that security officers earning above $2,600 now a month are no longer covered under Part 4 of the Employment Act, has the Ministry assessed whether security agencies are increasing reliance on overtime instead of hiring additional officers following the PWM implementation and what measures will be taken if excessive overtime becomes the norm?

(45)

Ensuring Real Wage Growth for Security Officers following PWM Implementation And related to that, how is MOM ensuring that security officers are not subjected to arbitrarily low overtime pay, now that they rely on employer-determined overtime rates?

(46)

Ensuring Real Wage Growth for Security Officers following PWM Implementation Lastly, will the Ministry consider increasing the salary threshold for Part 4 protections so that security officers can retain essential protections under the Act, even as wages rise?

(47)

Ensuring Real Wage Growth for Security Officers following PWM Implementation I thank the Member for his question. In fact, it is a good thing actually that our security officers now earn above what is covered in the Employment Act, Part 4, because, ultimately, this means that their wages now are growing beyond the bottom 20% mark.

(48)

Ensuring Real Wage Growth for Security Officers following PWM Implementation Technically, if you want to go by strict definitions, they are exceeding past what we used to think as low-wage workers. So, that is good progress from the unions and the tripartite partners in terms of how we have managed to increase the low wages of security officers such that by 2028, they will even get up to $3,500, which is much higher than what many of our low-wage workers earn today. [Please refer to "Clarification by Senior Minister of State for Manpower", Official Report, 10 March 2025, Vol 95, Issue 161, Correction By Written Statement section.] So, to a large extent, that shows progress.

(49)

Ensuring Real Wage Growth for Security Officers following PWM Implementation However, I take the Member's point. In short, the Minister for Manpower announced during the Committee of Supply debate that we are reviewing the Employment Act as well and that will include things like this, whether the thresholds have to be increased to keep up with the current pace, for example. These are areas we will look at.

(50)

Ensuring Real Wage Growth for Security Officers following PWM Implementation But I just want to assure the Member that security officers are not worse off in terms of the maximum number of overtime hours or paid leave entitlements because, ultimately, security officers continue to be licensed by the Singapore Police Force's (SPF's) Police Licensing and Regulatory Department. So, this is a licensed area. Today, the relevant provisions of the Employment Act still apply to them. For example, the licensing conditions provide that the total number of extra hours above the 44-hour work week is kept at a maximum of 72 hours per month. So, this ensures that there is no gaming, hopefully. But if there was any gaming, please surface it to us and we will take them to task with the Police. These are aspects in which there is still protection available because this is a licensed sector.

(51)

Ensuring Real Wage Growth for Security Officers following PWM Implementation Nonetheless, having said that, one of the key reasons why we moved towards a gross wage structure for PWM is to make sure that they do not game the system, such that everything is all-in or all-encompassing, and as long as you meet the PWM requirements for gross wage, I think that is sufficient to ensure that there is a minimum amount that security officers can benefit from PWM. [Please refer to "Clarification by Senior Minister of State for Manpower", Official Report, 10 March 2025, Vol 95, Issue 161, Correction By Written Statement section.]

(52)

Impact of SAF’s Overseas Training Detachments on Skills of Servicemen and Singapore's Defence Ties 3 Mr Neil Parekh Nimil Rajnikant asked the Minister for Defence (a) in what ways have the various overseas training detachments abroad helped to sharpen the training and warfare skills of the men and women of the Singapore Armed Forces in land-scarce Singapore; and (b) in what ways have these overseas training detachments boosted bilateral defence ties between Singapore and the host country providing the training facilities.

(53)

Impact of SAF’s Overseas Training Detachments on Skills of Servicemen and Singapore's Defence Ties Mr Speaker, the primary purpose of overseas training detachments is to enable the Singapore Armed Forces (SAF) to train realistically and remain operationally ready. Singapore’s limited land, air and sea space constrains the scale and complexity of military training that the SAF can conduct locally. The Ministry of Defence and the SAF are grateful to our foreign partners and their people who have extended valuable overseas training opportunities to us.

(54)

Impact of SAF’s Overseas Training Detachments on Skills of Servicemen and Singapore's Defence Ties With access to overseas training spaces, the SAF is able to hone its warfighting skills in complex scenarios, realistic conditions and varied terrain. For example, the Shoalwater Bay Training Area in Australia, which is the location for Exercise Wallaby, is about five times the size of Singapore. It allows the SAF to exercise the full range of capabilities and cross-service integrated training. Its varied terrain, ranging from beaches to light forests and open fields, allows our commanders to hone their military training and leadership, and our soldiers to polish their execution and capabilities.

(55)

Impact of SAF’s Overseas Training Detachments on Skills of Servicemen and Singapore's Defence Ties Long-term overseas training detachments also offer the added benefit of learning and benchmarking with our foreign counterparts. Our Air Force’s overseas training detachments in the United States (US), for example, do not just provide our F-16 fighter aircraft and Apache attack helicopter pilots and crew access to large airspaces and live-firing ranges to sharpen their skills. They also provide our people valuable opportunities to participate in exercises and competitions to learn from and benchmark against their US counterparts.

(56)

Impact of SAF’s Overseas Training Detachments on Skills of Servicemen and Singapore's Defence Ties In addition to conducting regular exchanges with their professional counterparts, SAF personnel in our overseas training detachments participate actively in local community life and contribute back to the local communities, thus contributing to the strengthening of bilateral ties. For example, the RSAF’s 150 Squadron based in Cazaux Air Base in France joins the French in Bastille Day flypast ceremonies and celebrations. Our personnel also stand ready to render assistance in times of need, just as an example, our CH-47 Chinooks in Queensland had done so last month, in supporting Australia’s flood relief efforts.

(57)

Impact of SAF’s Overseas Training Detachments on Skills of Servicemen and Singapore's Defence Ties We thank our foreign partner countries and their people who have welcomed us warmly into their countries and communities and extended valuable training opportunities to the SAF.

(58)

Impact of SAF’s Overseas Training Detachments on Skills of Servicemen and Singapore's Defence Ties Mr Neil Parekh.

(59)

Impact of SAF’s Overseas Training Detachments on Skills of Servicemen and Singapore's Defence Ties I thank the Senior Minister of State for his response. Could I ask the Senior Minister of State to share the various safety protocols that are upheld when training is done overseas? And to date, how has the safety record for the SAF been in its overseas training exercises in the last few years?

(60)

Impact of SAF’s Overseas Training Detachments on Skills of Servicemen and Singapore's Defence Ties Mr Speaker, I thank Mr Neil Parekh for the supplementary question. To begin with, I want to take this opportunity to also stress this point that, while we seek realistic training in order to hone our warfighting skills, we do so with utmost priority also accorded to the safety of our soldiers across different terrains and different scenarios, both locally as well as overseas.

(61)

Impact of SAF’s Overseas Training Detachments on Skills of Servicemen and Singapore's Defence Ties The SAF trains realistically in challenging terrain and tempo of drills locally and especially in overseas exercises. Safe training can only be achieved with a strong safety culture and robust safety management system which emphasises both leadership accountability as well as personal responsibility of soldiers. To achieve safety outcomes and zero fatalities in these exercises, detailed assessments of risks in each part of each exercise are required, together with concrete plans to avoid injuries. Commanders lead in these measures and the safe conduct of exercises is a key deliverable. Safety standards and protocol procedures are specified for a range of training activities. Soldier training is conducted progressively to ensure that they master the basics before moving on to more demanding tasks and complex situations, and pre-activity safety briefs and drills are also conducted as reminders.

(62)

Impact of SAF’s Overseas Training Detachments on Skills of Servicemen and Singapore's Defence Ties On top of the pre-planning to make sure that we lower any possible risk to the minimum, obviously, in the protocols, there would also be safety provisions on site in the event that, despite the planning, there could be certain injuries, in which case, then the response and the responsiveness will be very key. And in the case of overseas training, then there will be specific link-ups into the systems of our overseas partners, for example, if there is a need to further send the injured NSman to the local hospitals for more specialised treatment, that, too, was all planned in as well in terms of the protocols.

(63)

Impact of SAF’s Overseas Training Detachments on Skills of Servicemen and Singapore's Defence Ties As I have said earlier, we take the safety of every NSmen very, very seriously, locally and certainly overseas as well. In this context, if there ever was going to be any injury or worse, the necessary inquiries would also be opened up in order to inquire into what happened in each case, so that we could then learn from it and put in the necessary measures to the extent possible to prevent recurrences.

(64)

Impact of SAF’s Overseas Training Detachments on Skills of Servicemen and Singapore's Defence Ties On top of that, and as I have shared each year, for several years at the Ministry of Defence’s Committee of Supply debates, we also have external expert panels to help evaluate our protocols and so on to ensure that we remain robust in safeguarding the safety of our NSmen, even as we train robustly to ensure mission success.

(65)

11.32 am 4 Mr Yip Hon Weng asked the Prime Minister and Minister for Finance in light of the current talent shortage in Singapore's financial sector (a) how does the Ministry ensure that efforts to attract foreign talent are balanced with the development and progression of the local workforce in the financial sector; (b) what measures are in place to maintain such balance in this sector; and (c) how does the Ministry monitor their effectiveness.

(66)

11.32 am Sir, the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) is committed to developing our financial sector’s local workforce while being open to complementary foreign manpower. Working closely with industry, we invest heavily in building skills and capabilities in our local workforce to enable our locals to take up good jobs in our financial sector. As a leading regional and global financial centre, Singapore must continue to attract high-quality talent, both locally and from abroad, in order to stay competitive.

(67)

11.32 am This balanced approach has been key to Singapore’s success as a global financial centre. We are now a leading financial centre in Asia and the third most competitive globally. We are home to over 2,500 licensed financial institutions and employ close to over 200,000 people. Over 80% of our financial sector workforce is local and the sector offers the highest median gross incomes amongst employed locals. Over 2018 to 2023, the financial sector workforce grew by more than 25,000, of which more than nine out of 10 of the net jobs created went to locals.

(68)

11.32 am To help locals acquire skills and capabilities to take on the good jobs in our financial sector, MAS has committed $400 million from 2021 to 2025 to support the training of local finance professionals at each stage of their careers.

(69)

11.32 am At pre-entry and entry levels, MAS provides funding for internships, apprenticeships and job rotation programmes to equip our polytechnic and university students and fresh graduates with the skills to take on the jobs that we have created in the financial sector. At the mid-career level, MAS provides opportunities for finance professionals to both upskill and reskill. We work with training providers to develop relevant courses, subsidise these course fees and develop career conversion programmes with financial institutions for our mid-careers. At the senior-level, MAS supports the development of senior leaders through overseas postings, leadership programmes and by building leadership networks.

(70)

11.32 am Financial institutions also recognise the importance of growing and developing local talent to meet their manpower needs. For instance, in 2024, I had the opportunity to work with OCBC to launch “OCBC Ignite”, an accelerated career programme that comprises an internship and apprenticeship on full-time employment with the bank. OCBC Ignite aims to benefit 500 polytechnic students and graduates over three years. UBS also partnered the Government to develop the UBS-SUPER programme in 2020 and has trained over 400 fresh graduates and mid-career professionals. UBS has also doubled the number of Singaporeans sent on overseas postings, compared to pre-COVID-19 levels.

(71)

11.32 am Minister of State, would you like to round up your answer?

(72)

11.32 am Yes, Sir, rounding up.

This is the start of the text. The rest is on the official site. Open the official text