Skip to content
Official report

Hansard

Hansard, Monday, 3 March 2025

Feedback & support

The text

(1)

Vaping Cases Referred to Health Sciences Authority and Those Referred by Parents 1 Dr Tan Wu Meng asked the Minister for Health (a) whether the Ministry tracks the number of vaping cases referred to the Health Sciences Authority (HSA) by the Police; (b) if so, what are the number such cases in 2023 and 2024 respectively; (c) how many of such cases arise from parents referring their own children to the Police; (d) what is the approach by HSA to such referrals; and (e) what help is available to parents who are worried that their children are vaping.

(2)

Vaping Cases Referred to Health Sciences Authority and Those Referred by Parents Mr Speaker, the Health Sciences Authority (HSA) received about 4,000 and 5,000 cases involving possession or usage of e-vaporisers from the Singapore Police Force over the past two years. In these two years, only one of these cases was a parent referring his child to the Police for vaping. For this case, the person was issued with a warning instead of a composition fine and referred to the Health Promotion Board (HPB) for counselling.

(3)

Vaping Cases Referred to Health Sciences Authority and Those Referred by Parents Parents who are concerned that their children are vaping can call the HPB QuitLine for a referral to HPB’s smoking and vaping cessation service. No enforcement action will be taken against the children.

(4)

Vaping Cases Referred to Health Sciences Authority and Those Referred by Parents Dr Tan.

(5)

Vaping Cases Referred to Health Sciences Authority and Those Referred by Parents Mr Speaker, I thank the Minister of State for her answer. My Clementi residents shared with me that they discovered their child was vaping. Because they did not know what to do, they brought their child to the nearest Police station. The Police referred the case to HSA and the child was issued with a $300 fine for vaping. The parents were distressed and concerned, and worried that this approach, however well-meant by the agencies, might discourage parents from getting their children help.

(6)

Vaping Cases Referred to Health Sciences Authority and Those Referred by Parents Can I ask the Minister of State two supplementary questions? Firstly, how closely does HSA work with the Police when a parent reports their child for vaping to a Police station? Because sometimes, parents may not be aware of what is the optimal channel. Secondly, do we know, for such cases, whether the Police when they update HSA, do they inform HSA that it was a parent who was concerned and thereby, highlighting the child's situation so that the agencies can take an appropriate approach, rather than levying a fine on a child because the parent was trying to get help for the child?

(7)

Vaping Cases Referred to Health Sciences Authority and Those Referred by Parents Mr Speaker, I thank the Member for his questions and for raising this issue. Indeed, for that particular case, because the Member had raised it to us, we managed to remediate the situation and addressed the situation accordingly. In general, we do take a very nuanced approach with regard to a voluntary situation where they want to stop vaping and the parents bring the child forward. Typically, for this kind of situations, it will be flagged to HSA and we will then issue vaping counselling to the child, issue a warning instead.

(8)

Vaping Cases Referred to Health Sciences Authority and Those Referred by Parents These are situations where we would need to continue addressing. What I would advise parents, if they are faced with a situation where they suspect their children of vaping, please use the HPB hotline to get them some help, and appropriate support will be given to the children. For those situations where there is an aberration and the matter is reported to the Police, please let us know if there are some difficulties. As mentioned in my earlier answer, it was only one case that we are aware of where the parents reported to the Police. In that case, a warning was issued instead.

(9)

Vaping Cases Referred to Health Sciences Authority and Those Referred by Parents If Members are aware of certain circumstances where the parents have approached the Police instead and some fines are issued, you could highlight that case to us. What we want to do is to have a nuanced approach where we are supportive of parents who want to help their children cease vaping.

(10)

Vaping Cases Referred to Health Sciences Authority and Those Referred by Parents Dr Lim Wee Kiak.

(11)

Vaping Cases Referred to Health Sciences Authority and Those Referred by Parents Can I ask, in light of the fact that we have a smoking cessation clinic, is there a vaping cessation clinic, whereby the public can surrender themselves and say, "I have been vaping. I wish to have some help"? And how does the Ministry of Health (MOH) handle this?

(12)

Vaping Cases Referred to Health Sciences Authority and Those Referred by Parents Like the smoking hotline, you can call HPB for their hotline and you can specify that it is an issue of vaping cessation, and the same support will be given to the individual who wishes to cease vaping.

(13)

Strength of Correlation between PSLE Scores and Socio-economic Status over the Years 2 Mr Louis Ng Kok Kwang asked the Minister for Education (a) whether the correlation between PSLE results and socio-economic status has strengthened or weakened in the past three years; and (b) what further plans does the Ministry have to reduce this correlation.

(14)

Strength of Correlation between PSLE Scores and Socio-economic Status over the Years The correlation between the Primary School Leaving Examination (PSLE) results and socio-economic status (SES) has remained stable over the past three years.

(15)

Strength of Correlation between PSLE Scores and Socio-economic Status over the Years The Ministry of Education (MOE) is committed to ensuring that our education system provides opportunities for all students to develop to their full potential, regardless of their backgrounds. Our lower-SES students have done well by international standards. Based on Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development's (OECD's) Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA) 2022, our students from the bottom-25% SES outperformed the average OECD student in all core domains of Reading, Mathematics and Science, and in Creative Thinking.

(16)

Strength of Correlation between PSLE Scores and Socio-economic Status over the Years We will continue with the following efforts to uplift our lower-SES students.

(17)

Strength of Correlation between PSLE Scores and Socio-economic Status over the Years First, we will continue to build a strong foundation in the early years, both in preschool and at home. We have significantly enhanced the accessibility, affordability and quality of preschools, particularly through government-supported operators. Targeted programmes, such as KidSTART, also support parents from eligible lower-income families with the skills and knowledge to support their child’s development.

(18)

Strength of Correlation between PSLE Scores and Socio-economic Status over the Years Second, MOE will continue to provide additional support to students with higher educational needs through programmes during or after school, both in academic and social-emotional development. For example, primary schools provide targeted academic intervention for students who need more support to strengthen foundational skills in literacy and numeracy. This includes the Learning Support Programme, Reading Remediation Programme and Learning Support for Mathematics. Schools also run programmes to strengthen students’ social and emotional skills, such as goal-orientation, growth mindset and motivation.

(19)

Strength of Correlation between PSLE Scores and Socio-economic Status over the Years Third, we will continue to enhance wraparound support for disadvantaged students. We work closely with community partners to provide targeted programmes such as interest-based activities to impart good values, life skills and habits.

(20)

Strength of Correlation between PSLE Scores and Socio-economic Status over the Years We also provide schools with additional manpower, guidance and teaching resources via UPLIFT Enhanced School Resourcing (UESR). Having observed improvements in students' attendance, behaviour and progression, we have doubled the number of primary schools receiving these additional resources over the past two years.

(21)

Strength of Correlation between PSLE Scores and Socio-economic Status over the Years Addressing social mobility requires a whole-of-society effort. While MOE will continue to work closely with the community and stakeholders in this endeavour, we call on all Singaporeans to share your resources and networks, recognise a diversity of skills and talents, and do your part to uplift those who are less endowed.

(22)

Strength of Correlation between PSLE Scores and Socio-economic Status over the Years Mr Louis Ng.

(23)

Strength of Correlation between PSLE Scores and Socio-economic Status over the Years Thank you, Sir. And I thank the Senior Parliamentary Secretary for the reply. I think in reply to my Parliamentary Question (PQ) quite a number of years back, MOE share that there is a positive correlation, which means that students from lower SES are doing not as well in their PSLE as compared to students from higher SES.

(24)

Strength of Correlation between PSLE Scores and Socio-economic Status over the Years So, I know the Senior Parliamentary Secretary has listed a whole range of programmes and outreach we have done to try and help these students from lower SES. But if the correlations still exist, I am just wondering what else is MOE going to do to address this to try and at least lower the correlation or make sure that it does not exist in the first place?

(25)

Strength of Correlation between PSLE Scores and Socio-economic Status over the Years I thank Mr Louis Ng for his supplementary question on that. I think, firstly, it is important to make sure that we are able to identify the disadvantaged students who would need more support, and continue to concentrate on them. Take for example, at the start of primary school, some students who have not demonstrated certain age-appropriate literacy and numeracy skills. In those cases, the students with weak foundations would then be supported by programmes, such as Learning Support for English and Mathematics.

(26)

Strength of Correlation between PSLE Scores and Socio-economic Status over the Years Schools themselves, teachers, school leaders will also have to proactively reach out to students with disadvantaged backgrounds. As the Member said, the correlation already exists, we know which are the target groups, we should focus our attention and resources in those areas. And some of them may not just need academic support in particular, but also non-academic support. For example, schools would proactively identify students would benefit most from, let us say, student care centres, where they will encourage and support families to enrol their children to be part of these student care centres.

(27)

Strength of Correlation between PSLE Scores and Socio-economic Status over the Years In addition, for families under ComLink, there are also dedicated family coaches under the Social Service Offices, where they provide targeted support in co-developing, certain customised action plans, with regard to the background of the family, restrictions and all, and that is where we can start some of our work. And hopefully with those collective efforts, we are able to uplift this group of students.

(28)

Strength of Correlation between PSLE Scores and Socio-economic Status over the Years Ms Hazel Poa.

(29)

Strength of Correlation between PSLE Scores and Socio-economic Status over the Years Does each and every school measure the correlation between academic results and SES? And if so, where can we find that information?

(30)

Strength of Correlation between PSLE Scores and Socio-economic Status over the Years Thank you to Ms Hazel Poa for the follow-up question. Mainly at the broad and the entire national cohort level, for students from lower-income households, as proxied from the MOE Financial Assistance Scheme, the range of results is large, but over the past few years, the median PSLE score has been very stable.

(31)

Number of Singaporeans and PRs Overseen by Each Social Service Office 3 Mr Pritam Singh asked the Minister for Social and Family Development in respect of each of the Social Service Offices (SSOs) (a) how many Singaporeans and Permanent Residents (PRs) who come under their geographical purviews respectively are recipients of ComCare Short-to-Medium Term Assistance and Long-Term Assistance, respectively, as of 31 December 2024; and (b) what is the total population of Singaporeans and PRs that each of the SSOs oversee for their respective geographical areas.

(32)

Number of Singaporeans and PRs Overseen by Each Social Service Office Sir, in 2024, each Social Service Office (SSO) town assisted an average of around 1,000 Singaporean and Permanent Resident (PR) households with either ComCare Short-to-Medium Term Assistance (SMTA) or Long Term Assistance (LTA). Each SSO town has an average of around 61,000 households.

(33)

Number of Singaporeans and PRs Overseen by Each Social Service Office Mr Pritam Singh.

(34)

Number of Singaporeans and PRs Overseen by Each Social Service Office Thank you to the Senior Parliamentary Secretary for the reply. Can I just enquire, for the geographical areas covered by these SSOs that showed the highest number of households requiring SMTA and LTA, does the Ministry of Social and Family Development (MSF) publish this SSO-specific information on its website, and is there any reason why it does not do so?

(35)

Number of Singaporeans and PRs Overseen by Each Social Service Office The second question is with regard to the assistance, I understand there is income guideline which is $800 per capita. And I understand even if the individual who comes to the SSO exceeds this guideline, SSO will still make an assessment. Can the Senior Parliamentary Secretary confirm what percentage of households, who have successfully applied for SMTA, what is that number even though they may have surpassed the $800 per capita income requirement?

(36)

Number of Singaporeans and PRs Overseen by Each Social Service Office Sir, I thank the Leader of the Opposition for his additional questions on SSO-town specific data. We do not publish that. We track the statistics at the national level. As to why we do not publish that, I think that there are some variabilities across towns, for instance, based on the demographic growth profiles of each town's population, there might be some differences in terms of those who qualify for LTA vis-a-vis those who qualify for SMTA for instance. But generally, we do not see a large standard deviation across towns with regard to those who qualify for SMTA and LTA.

(37)

Number of Singaporeans and PRs Overseen by Each Social Service Office As to the second supplementary question, I would encourage the Member to file another Parliamentary Question, because I do not have the statistics with me at this moment.

(38)

Number of Singaporeans and PRs Overseen by Each Social Service Office Mr Singh.

(39)

Number of Singaporeans and PRs Overseen by Each Social Service Office Just a quick follow-up to the Senior Parliamentary Secretary. MSF released a report just two-odd months ago, "Supporting Low-income Household Trends report", I think there is some data. But again, the data is, as the Senior Parliamentary Secretary said, at the national level.

(40)

Number of Singaporeans and PRs Overseen by Each Social Service Office There is some discrepancy between the data of SMTA and the amount of money that has been extended to Singaporeans who apply for that, the SMTA, through the years. So, for example, the annual report in 2022, reported that number that was disbursed comes up to $119 million. That is for SMTA. It is at page six of the report. But in the trends report, that number comes down to $112 million, and the number of households increases for 2022.

(41)

Number of Singaporeans and PRs Overseen by Each Social Service Office So, I hope the Senior Parliamentary Secretary can clarify that, perhaps if not at this session, but perhaps during the Committee of Supply.

(42)

Number of Singaporeans and PRs Overseen by Each Social Service Office Sir, I thank the Member for his additional questions. We will clarify during the Committee of Supply debates.

(43)

Restrictions for Use of DeepSeek by Public Officers 4 Mr Gerald Giam Yean Song asked the Minister for Digital Development and Information (a) whether the Government is considering restrictions on the use of DeepSeek by public officers, similar to bans imposed by some other countries on its use on Government devices; (b) if not, what factors justify a different approach in Singapore; and (c) how does the Government determine which AI models are deemed secure enough for public sector use.

(44)

Restrictions for Use of DeepSeek by Public Officers Sir, the Government has policies, frameworks and processes to guide the use of technology in the public sector, including emerging technologies like artificial intelligence (AI). This allows us to evaluate the suitability of technologies for different use cases, based on factors such as performance, security and resilience. This enables public sector agencies to use innovative technologies effectively while ensuring the security and reliability of government operations and functions.

(45)

Restrictions for Use of DeepSeek by Public Officers We regularly review and update our policies to address the evolving technological landscape and security considerations.

(46)

Restrictions for Use of DeepSeek by Public Officers Mr Giam.

(47)

Restrictions for Use of DeepSeek by Public Officers Sir, I thank the Senior Minister of State for his reply. I note that he did not address my question regarding DeepSeek. I would appreciate if he could address that more directly.

(48)

Restrictions for Use of DeepSeek by Public Officers Secondly, I some supplementary questions for him. I understand that the Government has developed Pair, which is a suite of AI tools that utilise large language models for internal use within the Public Service. Could the Senior Minister of State clarify if Pair is primarily using locally deployed open source models or does it connect to commercial AI platforms, like ChatGPT and DeepSeek that process data on foreign servers?

(49)

Restrictions for Use of DeepSeek by Public Officers Sir, I thank Mr Giam for his questions. The Government does not generally comment on specific commercial products. We advise companies to evaluate products on their own merits and the risks of use, including their compliance with relevant laws.

(50)

Restrictions for Use of DeepSeek by Public Officers Pair does indeed access large language models, but it does not access only one. The specific details of Pair, I do not have them on hand. If Mr Giam is interested in the technical details, I would be happy to follow up with him offline or he can file a subsequent Parliamentary Question.

(51)

Revitalising Singapore's Nightlife Offerings to Boost Tourism and Local Spending in the Sector 5 Mr Yip Hon Weng asked the Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Trade and Industry (a) whether the Ministry has any strategies to revitalise Singapore's nightlife offerings and businesses as part of the overall tourism product; and (b) how will these strategies also encourage local spendings in this sector.

(52)

Revitalising Singapore's Nightlife Offerings to Boost Tourism and Local Spending in the Sector Sir, the Singapore Tourism Board (STB) profiles local bars, bartenders, homegrown distilleries and breweries to showcase Singapore’s diverse and innovative beverage scene. STB also collaborates with nightlife businesses to leverage STB-supported events, such as iLight Singapore, Light to Night Festival, Grand Prix Season Singapore and others to create promotions or special experiences to attract both local consumers and visitors.

(53)

Revitalising Singapore's Nightlife Offerings to Boost Tourism and Local Spending in the Sector Mr Yip.

(54)

Revitalising Singapore's Nightlife Offerings to Boost Tourism and Local Spending in the Sector Thank you, Mr Speaker. I thank the Minister of State for his reply. The nightlife industry is heavily dependent on service staff. But rising wages and difficulties in hiring locals have increased the business costs. So, what measures are in place to help these businesses address manpower constraints, such as perhaps a flexible work schemes, training grants or adjustments to foreign manpower policies.

(55)

Revitalising Singapore's Nightlife Offerings to Boost Tourism and Local Spending in the Sector Sir, I thank Mr Yip for his supplementary questions. We have been working very closely with the Singapore Nightlife Business Association (SNBA) during COVID and during the period of recovery. So, for example, during COVID, we worked closely on providing support including financial support, grants and wage support as well. In the immediate post-COVID, there was a bump in nightlife businesses as restrictions were lifted and now, there are the challenges that Mr Yip had raised. And in fact, last night, I was speaking to the SNBA and we were discussing some of these challenges. They have raised what the Member had raised with regard to costs, wages, but as well as consumer behaviour trends that have been changed over the course of the COVID pandemic. That is not just confined to Singapore, but also in countries, such as the United States and Japan, where people are working from home more, they are a little bit more health conscious and they go online more for different entertainment options. So, these are some trends with regard to nightlife and also with regard to cost issues.

(56)

Revitalising Singapore's Nightlife Offerings to Boost Tourism and Local Spending in the Sector At the same time, the Government is supporting on a few different fronts. The first is on making sure that the nightlife scene is vibrant. Second is on transformation. And third, is on workers. STB and Enterprise Singapore, for example, work on continually having new products and services to liven up and make our nightlife scene more vibrant. For the transformation of the sector, Enterprise Singapore works closely with SNBA and other players. And for workers, they have been working together with Workforce Singapore.

(57)

Revitalising Singapore's Nightlife Offerings to Boost Tourism and Local Spending in the Sector Sir, I will discuss and share more about our tourism performance in the Ministry of Trade and Industry's Committee of Supply and how we continue to inject vibrancy into our tourism sector and our nightlife. But I wanted to assure the Member that we have indeed been working very closely with SNBA, through meetings. And we will be organising more later this month to factor in their feedback as well as their suggestions.

(58)

Unintended Release of Information Regarding Three-year Lock-in Period for New Vehicles Bought for Private-hire Purposes 6 Ms Hazel Poa asked the Minister for Transport (a) what are the circumstances that led to the unintended release of the information on the new mandatory three-year lock-in period for vehicles registered as business-owned private-hire cars, (b) whether an investigation will be conducted into this incident, and (c) whether any steps will be taken to prevent its recurrence.

(59)

Unintended Release of Information Regarding Three-year Lock-in Period for New Vehicles Bought for Private-hire Purposes Mr Speaker, the Land Transport Authority (LTA) had earlier explained why it brought forward the implementation of a mandatory three-year lock-in period for all newly registered or converted business-owned chauffeured private hire cars (PHCs) in its news release on 19 February 2025. Let me recap the key points.

(60)

Unintended Release of Information Regarding Three-year Lock-in Period for New Vehicles Bought for Private-hire Purposes LTA had originally planned to announce this policy change during the Ministry of Transport's (MOT’s) Committee of Supply (COS) debate in March 2025, as part of an update on our review of the point-to-point transport sector. However, LTA had to bring forward the implementation date due to an unintentional error by its system vendor NCS.

(61)

Unintended Release of Information Regarding Three-year Lock-in Period for New Vehicles Bought for Private-hire Purposes The team from NCS, who was working on the IT system changes, made a deployment error, resulting in the message regarding the lock-in period being prematurely revealed to some users before the planned announcement date. The mistake was due to human error. NCS has taken steps to prevent a recurrence.

(62)

Unintended Release of Information Regarding Three-year Lock-in Period for New Vehicles Bought for Private-hire Purposes When MOT and LTA found out on 18 February that the information was prematurely revealed to some users, we decided to make a public announcement on the policy change on 19 February morning. This was because there was an ongoing Certificate of Entitlement (COE) bidding exercise from 17 February to 19 February, and we wanted to ensure fairness and transparency to all parties and allow bidders sufficient time to decide whether to adjust their bids, before the bidding cycle closed at 4.00 pm on 19 February.

(63)

Unintended Release of Information Regarding Three-year Lock-in Period for New Vehicles Bought for Private-hire Purposes Mr Speaker, three other Members, namely Ms Mariam Jaafar, Mr Dennis Tan and Mr Yip Hon Weng, have filed questions on the lock-in period for business-owned chauffeured PHCs for subsequent Sittings. MOT will be sharing more details regarding the review of the point-to-point transport sector at the upcoming COS debate and we will address their questions then.

(64)

Unintended Release of Information Regarding Three-year Lock-in Period for New Vehicles Bought for Private-hire Purposes Ms Poa.

(65)

Unintended Release of Information Regarding Three-year Lock-in Period for New Vehicles Bought for Private-hire Purposes I think the Senior Minister of State for her reply. Is the Senior Minister of State able to share what steps NCS has taken to prevent a recurrence? And has there been any impact on the execution of this policy due to the implementation being earlier than planned?

(66)

Unintended Release of Information Regarding Three-year Lock-in Period for New Vehicles Bought for Private-hire Purposes I thank the Member for the supplementary question. As I noted earlier in my reply, this was a deployment error. NCS had acknowledged and taken responsibility for the error. The deployment error occurred when the system changes were being deployed to the production environment, that is the actual system. The lines of code for program to control when this lock-in period message will be displayed and to which users, were actually not deployed. So, it resulted in the premature display of this lock-in period message to users who were using the digital service for the relevant vehicle transactions.

(67)

Unintended Release of Information Regarding Three-year Lock-in Period for New Vehicles Bought for Private-hire Purposes When this error was discovered, NCS has taken various steps to prevent the recurrence of this error. Firstly, they have implemented additional checks both before and after the code merging deployment. They have also put in place a buddy system with a senior developer to check on the works or to review the works that were done.

(68)

Treatment of Essential Occupiers in HDB Flats as Similar to Owners for Fulfillment of Minimum Occupation Period 7 Assoc Prof Jamus Jerome Lim asked the Minister for National Development (a) what is the justification for treating essential occupiers of HDB flats similar to HDB owners with respect to having to fulfil the minimum occupation period for purchase of private property, while treating such essential occupiers as non-owners for liability for Additional Buyer’s Stamp Duty; and (b) whether the Ministry will consider harmonising the treatment of essential occupiers in both cases.

(69)

Treatment of Essential Occupiers in HDB Flats as Similar to Owners for Fulfillment of Minimum Occupation Period Mr Speaker, the Minimum Occupation Period (MOP) ensures that Housing and Development Board (HDB) flats are purchased for owner occupation. While essential occupiers are not flat owners, they form part of the core family nucleus that determines the household’s eligibility to own an HDB flat. For example, when a married couple buys an HDB flat, both of them must be listed in the flat application in order to form the core family nucleus. HDB allows both of them to be listed as co-owners, or one of them as owner and the other as an essential occupier. Hence, essential occupiers are required to fulfil the MOP before they can purchase a private residential property. However, essential occupiers are not allowed to use their Central Provident Fund (CPF) or any housing grant received to pay for the flat. They also cannot be a mortgagor of the housing loan for the flat.

(70)

Treatment of Essential Occupiers in HDB Flats as Similar to Owners for Fulfillment of Minimum Occupation Period The Additional Buyer’s Stamp Duty (ABSD) was introduced as a cooling measure to moderate investment demand in private residential property and promote a sustainable market. Broadly speaking, ABSD is applied based on the buyer’s profile and the number of residential properties the buyer owns. As essential occupiers do not own their HDB flat, it is not included in their residential property count. Hence, they do not incur ABSD if they are Singapore Citizens buying their first private residential property after MOP. Permanent Residents (PRs) and foreigners will incur ABSD.

(71)

Treatment of Essential Occupiers in HDB Flats as Similar to Owners for Fulfillment of Minimum Occupation Period As shared previously in this house, the vast majority of married couples buy HDB flats as co-owners. Only a small number list a spouse as an occupier, often for practical reasons with no intention to invest in a private residential property after fulfilling MOP. For example, a non-resident, married to a Singapore Citizen, cannot be an owner of an HDB flat, and will have to be listed as an essential occupier.

(72)

Treatment of Essential Occupiers in HDB Flats as Similar to Owners for Fulfillment of Minimum Occupation Period We will remain watchful of market trends and adjust our policies where needed, to ensure that the property market remains stable and sustainable.

(73)

Treatment of Essential Occupiers in HDB Flats as Similar to Owners for Fulfillment of Minimum Occupation Period Assoc Prof Lim.

(74)

Treatment of Essential Occupiers in HDB Flats as Similar to Owners for Fulfillment of Minimum Occupation Period I thank Minister Indranee for the explanation. The thrust of my question, the context is in part because of the increasing trend of couples that are getting older before they finally get married. As a result, some of these may end up being married with already substantial independent assets, which could include a private property. When they get married, if they do not have enough resources to purchase a larger private property, they hope to purchase an HDB, but instead, they are forced to sell off these independent assets that they would have acquired over the course of their professional careers.

(75)

Treatment of Essential Occupiers in HDB Flats as Similar to Owners for Fulfillment of Minimum Occupation Period So, I am wondering if there is some scope for these kinds of individuals who do get married later, entering the marriage already with significant independent assets, whether there could be some waiver for these kind of MOP requirements.

(76)

Treatment of Essential Occupiers in HDB Flats as Similar to Owners for Fulfillment of Minimum Occupation Period If there are instances of specific hardship, they can write in and appeal. The Ministry of National Development and HDB will consider on the merits. But the broad general policy principle which I have outlined does remain the principle underpinning the policy.

(77)

11.30 am 8 Mr Louis Ng Kok Kwang asked the Minister for Transport whether the Ministry will consider increasing the quantum of rebates provided under the Electric Vehicle Early Adoption Incentive scheme and extending the scheme to the end of 2026.

(78)

11.30 am Senior Minister of State Amy Khor, I hope it is a short answer.

(79)

11.30 am Today, it is really a short answer; just two paragraphs, Mr Speaker, Sir.

(80)

11.30 am The Electric Vehicle Early Adoption Incentive (EEAI) scheme was introduced in 2021 to encourage adoption of electric cars by narrowing the upfront cost gap between electric and internal combustion engine (ICE) cars. Adoption of electric cars has been increasing – last year, around one third of new car registrations were electric cars.

(81)

11.30 am We will review the EEAI later this year, taking into consideration factors such as EV adoption rates and upfront cost difference across powertrains.

(82)

11.30 am Order. End of Question Time. The Clerk will now proceed to read the Orders of the day.

(83)

11.30 am [Pursuant to Standing Order No 22(3), provided that Members had not asked for questions standing in their names to be postponed to a later Sitting day or withdrawn, written answers to questions not reached by the end of Question Time are reproduced in the Appendix.]

(84)

11.31 am [(proc text) Order read for consideration in Committee of Supply [Allotted Day]. (proc text)]

(85)

11.31 am [Mr Speaker in the Chair]

(86)

11.31 am Supplementary Estimates of Expenditure for the financial year 1 April 2024 to 31 March 2025, contained in Paper Cmd 33 of 2025. As there are no amendments, I propose to take the Heads of Expenditure en bloc. I will first take Heads E, J, M, P, Q, T, W and Z of the Supplementary Main Estimates.

(87)

11.31 am [(proc text) Question, "That the sums stated for the Heads of Expenditure as shown on page 6 of Paper Cmd 33 of 2025 stand part of the Supplementary Main Estimates," put and agreed to. (proc text)]

(88)

11.31 am I will now take the Supplementary Development Estimates. In respect of the Supplementary Development Estimates, they are Heads E, J, L, P, W and X.

(89)

11.31 am [(proc text) Question, "That the sums stated for the Heads of Expenditure as shown on page 9 of Paper Cmd 33 of 2025 stand part of the Supplementary Development Estimates," put and agreed to. (proc text)]

(90)

11.31 am [(proc text) Question, "That the sum of $3,883,986,000 shall be supplied to the Government under the Heads of Expenditure for the public services shown in the Supplementary Main Estimates of Expenditure for the financial year 1 April 2024 to 31 March 2025, contained in Paper Cmd 33 of 2025," put and agreed to. (proc text)]

(91)

11.31 am [(proc text) Question, "That the sum of $376,273,500 shall be supplied to the Government under the Head of Expenditure for the public services shown in the Supplementary Development Estimates of Expenditure for the financial year 1 April 2024 to 31 March 2025, contained in Paper Cmd 33 of 2025," put and agreed to. (proc text)]

(92)

11.31 am [(proc text) Resolutions to be reported. (proc text)]

(93)

11.31 am Second Minister for Finance.

(94)

11.31 am Mr Speaker, I report that the Committee of Supply has come to certain resolutions.

(95)

11.31 am [(proc text) First Resolution reported, (proc text)]

(96)

11.31 am [(proc text) "That the sum of $3,883,986,000 shall be supplied to the Government under the Heads of Expenditure for the public services shown in the Supplementary Main Estimates of Expenditure for the financial year 1 April 2024 to 31 March 2025, contained in Paper Cmd. 33 of 2025." (proc text)]

(97)

11.31 am [(proc text) Second Resolution reported, (proc text)]

(98)

11.31 am [(proc text) "That the sum of $376,273,500 shall be supplied to the Government under the Head of Expenditure for the public services shown in the Supplementary Development Estimates of Expenditure for the financial year 1 April 2024 to 31 March 2025, contained in Paper Cmd. 33 of 2025." (proc text)]

(99)

11.31 am Minister.

(100)

11.31 am Mr Speaker, I move, "That Parliament doth agree with the Committee on the said resolutions."

(101)

11.31 am [(proc text) Question put, and agreed to. (proc text)]

(102)

11.31 am [(proc text) Resolutions accordingly agreed to. (proc text)]

(103)

Estimates for the Financial Year 1 April 2025 to 31 March 2026 - Committee of Supply – Paper Cmd 33 of 2025 [(proc text) Order read for consideration in Committee of Supply [2nd Allotted Day]. (proc text)]

(104)

Estimates for the Financial Year 1 April 2025 to 31 March 2026 - Committee of Supply – Paper Cmd 33 of 2025 [Mr Speaker in the Chair]

(105)

12.02 pm Head F, Parliament. Ms Sylvia Lim.

(106)

12.02 pm Chairman, I seek to move, “That the total sum to be allocated for Head F of the Estimates be reduced by $100”.

(107)

12.02 pm Sir, law students learn early that the separation of powers between the Executive, Legislature and Judiciary is the foundation of the rule of law. As such, I hope the House will agree with me that Parliament, as the primary organ of the Legislative Branch, must not only be able to discharge its law-making responsibilities, but also to ensure that the Government remains faithful to its duty to all Singaporeans.

This is the start of the text. The rest is on the official site. Open the official text