The text
11.00 am Order. Pursuant to paragraph (7) of Standing Order 92, I have fixed the times for the conclusion of consideration of the heads of expenditure in the Estimates of Expenditure for FY2025/2026 in the Committee of Supply.
11.00 am In fixing these times, I have taken into account the reduction of Question Time to 30 minutes on the days allotted for the Committee of Supply debates and the extension of Sitting times of the Committee of Supply for each of the allotted days.
11.00 am Additionally, Members are notified that the Sittings on the allotted days of 3 March to 10 March will commence at 11.00 am.
11.00 am The "guillotine times" I have fixed have been notified to hon Members. I would also like to remind Members to use slides and videos sparingly to keep the spirit of our debating Chamber. Focusing on the delivery of speeches to be made will create a greater impact in a debate.
11.00 am Order. Questions for oral answer.
Reports of Fraudulent or Counterfeit Merchandise Sold on E-commerce Platforms - Whether these are deemed as commercial disputes or scams 1 Dr Tan Wu Meng asked the Minister for Home Affairs (a) how many Police reports have been made in 2023 and 2024 regarding fraudulent or counterfeit merchandise sold on e-commerce platforms where the seller and buyer were both in Singapore; (b) what were the considerations for such cases being deemed as commercial disputes rather than instances of cheating or scams; and (c) what recourse is available for affected buyers.
Reports of Fraudulent or Counterfeit Merchandise Sold on E-commerce Platforms - Whether these are deemed as commercial disputes or scams The Police assess whether any criminal offence is disclosed by looking at the full facts and circumstances of each case. For example, the import, sale, or distribution of goods with falsely applied trademarks for the purpose of trade is an offence under the Trade Marks Act 1998. Where deception is involved, the case may also be classified as "cheating" under section 420 of the Penal Code 1871.
Reports of Fraudulent or Counterfeit Merchandise Sold on E-commerce Platforms - Whether these are deemed as commercial disputes or scams Buyers who encounter allegedly counterfeit merchandise can file a Police report. Regardless of whether a criminal offence is disclosed, buyers can seek recourse by lodging a complaint with the Consumers Association of Singapore (CASE), filing a claim in the Small Claims Tribunal, or commencing civil proceedings in the Singapore Courts.
Reports of Fraudulent or Counterfeit Merchandise Sold on E-commerce Platforms - Whether these are deemed as commercial disputes or scams The Police do not track the data requested by the Member.
Reports of Fraudulent or Counterfeit Merchandise Sold on E-commerce Platforms - Whether these are deemed as commercial disputes or scams Dr Tan.
Reports of Fraudulent or Counterfeit Merchandise Sold on E-commerce Platforms - Whether these are deemed as commercial disputes or scams Mr Speaker, I thank the Minister of State for her answer. One of my Clementi residents contacted me. She said she filed a Police report, having purchased branded merchandise from a seller through the platform Carousell. She says the seller claimed the merchandise was genuine but it turned out the merchandise was counterfeit. My resident filed a Police report and was advised that the case was more of a contractual dispute and was referred to CASE. CASE told my resident it could not assist because the matter was between two private transactors. So, my resident is now wondering what redress might be possible in such situations, especially since she is of limited means and may find it hard to take up a case in the Courts?
Reports of Fraudulent or Counterfeit Merchandise Sold on E-commerce Platforms - Whether these are deemed as commercial disputes or scams I thank the Member for his supplementary question. Coming back to the example that he had shared where there was a merchandise that was advertised as genuine but was subsequently found to be counterfeit, there could be an instance whereby the seller either knew in the first place whether the merchandise was genuine or not. So, through Police investigations, if it was found that the seller did not know that the merchandise was actually counterfeit, then, a cheating offence may not be the means in which to charge the individual. If, however, the individual knew it was counterfeit – and this is found out through the course of Police investigations – but the seller still chooses to advertise the merchandise as a genuine product, then, this would be a case under both the Trade Marks Act as well as classified as cheating under section 420 of the Penal Code.
Reports of Fraudulent or Counterfeit Merchandise Sold on E-commerce Platforms - Whether these are deemed as commercial disputes or scams The Member had shared that his resident has faced difficulties seeking remedy through CASE. I would like to reiterate what I shared earlier: the victim can still file a law suit to recover damages under the civil remedies route. If the victim, his resident, find difficulties with the legal fees, she can approach Legal Aid to explore the options.
Government Spending on 2025 World Aquatics Championships Versus Benefits and Sponsorships Generated 2 Mr Gerald Giam Yean Song asked the Minister for Culture, Community and Youth (a) what is the full cost of constructing and dismantling the temporary competition venue at Carpark G near the Kallang Tennis and Football Hubs for the 2025 World Aquatics Championships; and (b) what are the outcomes of any feasibility studies looking into extending the use of the competition venue after these Championships instead of dismantling it.
Government Spending on 2025 World Aquatics Championships Versus Benefits and Sponsorships Generated 3 Mr Gerald Giam Yean Song asked the Minister for Culture, Community and Youth (a) what is the estimated number of international visitors expected to attend the 2025 World Aquatics Championships; (b) what methodology was used to arrive at this estimate; and (c) what is the projected total tourism revenue to be generated from these visitors.
Government Spending on 2025 World Aquatics Championships Versus Benefits and Sponsorships Generated (for the Minister for Culture, Community and Family Development): Mr Speaker, with your permission, may I answer Question Nos 2 and 3 in today’s Order Paper, as well as the Parliamentary Question for oral answer filed by Mr Giam that is scheduled for a later Sitting, together, please?
Government Spending on 2025 World Aquatics Championships Versus Benefits and Sponsorships Generated Please go ahead.
Government Spending on 2025 World Aquatics Championships Versus Benefits and Sponsorships Generated Thank you, Sir. The World Aquatics Championships (WCH) is the highest tier of world championships in aquatics. WCH 2025 will be the first time that an edition of the WCH is being held in Southeast Asia. Global sports events such as WCH help Singapore to gain sporting prominence and mindshare internationally. As of January this year, our social media content on WCH 2025 has made more than 5.8 million impressions, across various platforms such as Facebook, Instagram, Tiktok, Weibo and XiaoHongShu.
Government Spending on 2025 World Aquatics Championships Versus Benefits and Sponsorships Generated WCH strengthens Singapore’s reputation as a top-tier destination for international sporting events and reinforces our capabilities in hosting such large-scale events. Beyond sports, the event will also have a related impact on tourism, hospitality and other industries, further raising Singapore’s profile as a travel destination.
Government Spending on 2025 World Aquatics Championships Versus Benefits and Sponsorships Generated The WCH 2025 will inspire local athletes and further encourage our population at large to participate in sports. Our Team Singapore athletes can gain valuable experience from competing against the best athletes in the world and this in turn will bolster their chances of doing well at future tournaments. Such opportunities to compete with the world’s best are significantly enhanced when world class competitions are held right here in Singapore.
Government Spending on 2025 World Aquatics Championships Versus Benefits and Sponsorships Generated The WCH is not just for athletes but also for all Singaporeans. The event will rally Singaporeans together to cheer for Team Singapore in SG60, and we are confident that it will spark greater interest amongst Singaporeans for aquatic sports and inspire our next generation of sporting talents. Singaporeans can look forward to a variety of related community activities organised at the sidelines of the main event. We expect up to 350,000 Singaporeans will have the opportunity to participate in these activities. Some of these community activities will be commencing soon in the lead-up to the main event, such as the SG60 Swim Challenge that we will launch in April this year.
Government Spending on 2025 World Aquatics Championships Versus Benefits and Sponsorships Generated We expect to welcome about 40,000 international visitors to Singapore for the World Aquatics and World Aquatics Masters Championships 2025. This is a conservative estimate and comprises spectators and other visitors such as athletes, officials, production crew, media. Based on this, the estimated incremental tourism receipts generated by these international visitors is estimated to be some $60 million. The final tourism receipts generated will be clearer after the event.
Government Spending on 2025 World Aquatics Championships Versus Benefits and Sponsorships Generated For us to be able to host any large-scale sport competitions of the highest tier, we would have to put in place additional supporting infrastructure, as was the case for previous host cities of the WCH. For instance, the recent editions of WCH in Fukuoka and Doha required the construction of temporary pools to facilitate the hosting of the events at WCH, and coordination across the different aquatic events for officials, athletes and fans.
Government Spending on 2025 World Aquatics Championships Versus Benefits and Sponsorships Generated For WCH 2025, with the OCBC Aquatic Centre hosting water polo and diving competitions, a temporary facility will be needed to host the swimming and artistic swimming competitions. And this is being constructed at Kallang. Besides using the facility for the WCH, it will also be used for the World Aquatics Masters Championships that would be held from 26 July to 22 August this year. We are also studying the possible extension of the temporary facility to be used as a training and competition venue for other local and regional meets, as well as for athlete training and for public use, beyond the hosting of the WCH.
Government Spending on 2025 World Aquatics Championships Versus Benefits and Sponsorships Generated If possible, this would further amortise the cost of staging the WCH. More details will be shared later as these require additional feasibility studies.
Government Spending on 2025 World Aquatics Championships Versus Benefits and Sponsorships Generated The construction cost of the temporary facility is being finalised, but it is expected to be comparable to that of other host cities which built temporary facilities to host the WCH.
Government Spending on 2025 World Aquatics Championships Versus Benefits and Sponsorships Generated As host country, we aim to deliver a positive event experience for athletes and spectators alike, while being fiscally prudent and cost-effective. The organising committee has been careful to reduce costs where possible, while working hard to secure sponsorships for these events. These sponsorships will help us defray some costs associated with operations and logistics of the event. We have a sponsorship target and we are making good progress towards it. We are in active discussions with various sponsors and we will reveal them progressively. At this point of time, we are unable to disclose details of the sponsorships due to commercial sensitivity.
Government Spending on 2025 World Aquatics Championships Versus Benefits and Sponsorships Generated The success of this event will depend on Singaporeans’ support. So, let us cherish this opportunity to show the world what we can do as a nation united and deliver a championships that we can and will be proud of.
Government Spending on 2025 World Aquatics Championships Versus Benefits and Sponsorships Generated Mr Giam.
Government Spending on 2025 World Aquatics Championships Versus Benefits and Sponsorships Generated Sir, I thank the Senior Parliamentary Secretary for his response. Can I confirm that the temporary venue for this WCH event will remain up after the event, or will it be torn down? I am mainly concerned about ensuring that the public resources put into constructing the temporary sporting venue are put to good use.
Government Spending on 2025 World Aquatics Championships Versus Benefits and Sponsorships Generated My second question is, is the temporary sporting venue model expected to be a standard approach for hosting future large-scale sporting events in Singapore? How does the Ministry ensure that the resources spent on such temporary infrastructure deliver long-term benefits, beyond a single event, to contribute to Singapore's sporting ecosystem, rather than simply fulfilling international bodies' hosting needs?
Government Spending on 2025 World Aquatics Championships Versus Benefits and Sponsorships Generated Sir, I thank Mr Giam for his supplementary questions. With regard to the temporary venue, as I had mentioned earlier, we are already looking into the possible extension of the use of that facility for competitions, training and public use beyond WCH. The temporary venue actually sits on the footprint of the Kallang Alive masterplan. More fine grain details of the masterplan are currently being worked through. Various agencies like Sport Singapore, the Urban Redevelopment Authority for instance, will have to consider the various use cases of the plot for the mid to longer term. Definitely, we will be considering whether we can extend the use of the venue beyond its WCH utility.
Government Spending on 2025 World Aquatics Championships Versus Benefits and Sponsorships Generated On his second question about cost, I think a common stance amongst organisers of such international, global sporting events, us included, will be not to be more excessive than past editions of the same event. After considering sponsorships that we have garnered so far, I think it is reasonable for us to make a stand that we are more or less on track with this position.
Coordination between Government Agencies to Verify and Review Fire Risk of Hoarding Cases in HDB Flats 4 Ms Ng Ling Ling asked the Minister for National Development with regard to feedback received by HDB from residents on suspected excessive hoarding in a neighbour’s flat (a) what is the protocol for HDB officers to verify and ascertain if the excessive hoarding is true; (b) what is the existing coordination protocol between HDB and SCDF under the inter-agency Hoarding Management Core Group to mitigate fire risks associated with reported excessive hoarding in HDB flats; and (c) whether the Ministry will review and enhance both protocols.
Coordination between Government Agencies to Verify and Review Fire Risk of Hoarding Cases in HDB Flats Sir, generally, the Government does not interfere in how residents upkeep their homes, unless their actions pose health, safety or other risks to themselves or their neighbours. At the same time, we recognise that residents have legitimate expectations that their living environment is clean, safe and orderly. The need to balance these two considerations guide our whole-of-Government approach towards the management of in-unit hoarding.
Coordination between Government Agencies to Verify and Review Fire Risk of Hoarding Cases in HDB Flats That is why on receiving public feedback about in-unit hoarding, Housing and Development Board (HDB) officers visiting the unit concerned need to seek the hoarder and/or his family’s consent to inspect the premises. This often entails repeat engagements, as well as coordination with other frontline agencies who might already be working with the household on other issues, and with whom the hoarder and family have already built up a certain level of trust. All these take time.
Coordination between Government Agencies to Verify and Review Fire Risk of Hoarding Cases in HDB Flats Where there is significant fire risk, HDB coordinates with the Singapore Civil Defence Force (SCDF) to use its regulatory powers where needed. For example, SCDF may order the owner to cease hoarding flammable items, such as fuel.
Coordination between Government Agencies to Verify and Review Fire Risk of Hoarding Cases in HDB Flats Despite these efforts, there are cases where hoarders refuse to grant access for inspections or cooperate in decluttering efforts. The hoarding may also recur, as habits do not change so quickly.
Coordination between Government Agencies to Verify and Review Fire Risk of Hoarding Cases in HDB Flats To address such situations, the Government recently amended the Community Disputes Resolution Act (CDRA) to allow the Director-General of the pilot Community Relations Unit (CRU) to apply to the Community Disputes Resolution Tribunals (CDRT) to declutter the hoarder's unit. This is a measure of last resort, premised on public interest, after existing regulatory levers from frontline agencies have been exhausted and the hoarder has failed to comply with a previous CDRT order to declutter. The CRU aims to begin operations from the second quarter of 2025.
Coordination between Government Agencies to Verify and Review Fire Risk of Hoarding Cases in HDB Flats The underlying motivations and support networks of hoarders and their families vary from case to case. There is no one-size-fits-all solution and enforcement is only one of several measures. A whole-of-society approach is needed to address hoarding in a more holistic and sustainable manner. This is why the public, people and private sector came together over the past year or so, to form an Alliance for Action to manage hoarding, termed the New Environment Action Team (NEAT). Through this platform, members can learn from and tap each other's strengths so that collectively, as an ecosystem, we identify cases early and provide more well-rounded support to hoarders and relief to their neighbours in a sustainable manner.
Coordination between Government Agencies to Verify and Review Fire Risk of Hoarding Cases in HDB Flats Ms Ng.
Coordination between Government Agencies to Verify and Review Fire Risk of Hoarding Cases in HDB Flats Speaker, I thank the Senior Minister of State for the very comprehensive reply. I think fellow Parliamentarians would have read about a very big Hougang fire that happened earlier this year on 9 January 2025 in my Jalan Kayu constituency. In fact, the fire was so fierce that SCDF had to evacuate seven floors of my residents while they were putting out the fire. The fire, unfortunately, took the lives of three of my residents, the youngest, being an 18-year-old girl.
Coordination between Government Agencies to Verify and Review Fire Risk of Hoarding Cases in HDB Flats My first supplementary question is that I am deeply saddened by the tragedy, and so, my grassroots leaders, volunteers and I want to step up to see what we can do as a community to work closer with Government agencies, like HDB and SCDF, to respond to and also to assist when we know of residents who may have suspected hoarding issues in their flats. In this case, several neighbours said that they had given feedback to HDB about this unit. So, my question is, what would the Senior Minister of State advise us to do while waiting for the CRU, which I understand will be piloted first at Tampines, to be rolled out? So, we want to take actions as a community.
Coordination between Government Agencies to Verify and Review Fire Risk of Hoarding Cases in HDB Flats My second supplementary question is that I read from the Institute of Mental Health (IMH) website that hoarding challenges can sometimes be due to mental health conditions, such as Obsessive Compulsive Disorder or even psychosis where a person feels compelled to behave in a certain way. So, my question is, in this regard, how are HDB officers trained to identify potential mental illnesses in checking on hoarding complaints and what is the referral protocol to mental health teams, like Community Outreach Team (CREST), in the community?
Coordination between Government Agencies to Verify and Review Fire Risk of Hoarding Cases in HDB Flats My colleagues and I are saddened by the fire that Ms Ng Ling Ling has mentioned and the fatalities that it has caused. I understand that investigations into the cause of the fire have not yet officially concluded, so while I am not able to comment on the specifics of this case, I understand the gist of what Ms Ng Ling Ling is asking about.
Coordination between Government Agencies to Verify and Review Fire Risk of Hoarding Cases in HDB Flats I would like to say that there is a very positive role for grassroots and community volunteers to play in partnering the agencies in addressing suspected hoarding cases. First of all, in quite a number of the cases that we see, the hoarding behaviour may not be reported by either the hoarder or the family members themselves. Sometimes, they can be quite elusive, and if neighbours observe something and report it, I think this helps to get the information to the agencies.
Coordination between Government Agencies to Verify and Review Fire Risk of Hoarding Cases in HDB Flats I have also mentioned that with the amendments to the CDRA, we now would have an additional pathway to compel decluttering where other regulatory levers are not successful and where other efforts to persuade have failed.
Coordination between Government Agencies to Verify and Review Fire Risk of Hoarding Cases in HDB Flats With the grassroots, we feel that not only are they able to provide some timely information to the agencies, but I think in terms of helping to create a more holistic approach in addressing the underlying needs of the hoarder and the family, they can be very helpful. We see, sometimes, that the underlying cause could be related to social isolation. It could be related to loneliness. It could also be because the person actually does not have any other daily routine. And the kind of befriending and activities that volunteers may be able to come in to help give structure would be helpful. And I think this is one area that NEAT looks forward to working together with grassroots on, especially those who have had some positive experience in helping hoarders, so that we can develop and strengthen future processes in dealing with such cases.
Coordination between Government Agencies to Verify and Review Fire Risk of Hoarding Cases in HDB Flats On mental health, we have a number of organisations with experience in this area, who are also part of NEAT. This includes the Agency for Integrated Care, which oversees CREST. It includes IMH as well as the Ministry of Social and Family Development, and also some of our social service agencies who also have capacities in dealing with mental health-related cases. We look forward to these organisations helping to put together their best practices and also reaching out to grassroots volunteers like those in Ms Ng Ling Ling's constituency.
Coordination between Government Agencies to Verify and Review Fire Risk of Hoarding Cases in HDB Flats In terms of the training, our HDB officers as well as other frontline agencies' officers are given basic training to identify potential mental health cases and to understand how to refer them to specialised assistance as well.
Coordination between Government Agencies to Verify and Review Fire Risk of Hoarding Cases in HDB Flats Mr Dennis Tan.
Coordination between Government Agencies to Verify and Review Fire Risk of Hoarding Cases in HDB Flats Mr Speaker, I thank the Senior Minister of State for her comprehensive answers. I have two supplementary questions.
Coordination between Government Agencies to Verify and Review Fire Risk of Hoarding Cases in HDB Flats As the Senior Minister of State alluded, it may take time to engage a persistent hoarder. How will HDB give assurances to residents who are concerned about their own safety arising from the acts of a neighbour who is a persistent hoarder?
Coordination between Government Agencies to Verify and Review Fire Risk of Hoarding Cases in HDB Flats Second, the CRU is being set up and it will go through a pilot phase in Tampines. Can I ask that the Ministry, and the Government, to try to expedite the application of the CRU to the rest of Singapore to deal with cases like hoarding and also other noise nuisance cases?
Coordination between Government Agencies to Verify and Review Fire Risk of Hoarding Cases in HDB Flats In hoarding cases where residents are worried about potential fire safety and when these cases are alerted to HDB, we will work together with our partner agencies, in this case, SCDF, to make an assessment to see whether, for instance, a Fire Hazard Abatement Notice can be issued. This is one of the regulatory levers that are already at the disposal of the agencies collectively and this is something that can be activated in cases that are warranted. We do not have to wait for the CRU to be set up for this.
Coordination between Government Agencies to Verify and Review Fire Risk of Hoarding Cases in HDB Flats And I also thank Mr Dennis Tan for his support of the CRU and indeed, once it is in operation, we will seek to be as quick as possible in gaining experience from its operation and to scale up, because that is the eventual intention.
Protecting Social Workers against Threats or Harassment On The Job 5 Ms Yeo Wan Ling asked the Minister for Social and Family Development what protections or assistance can the Ministry provide to social workers from social service organisations when they are faced with threats or harassment arising from the cases they handled, besides making reports of the threats and harassment to the Police.
Protecting Social Workers against Threats or Harassment On The Job Sir, the Ministry of Social and Family Development (MSF) takes the safety and well-being of our social service professionals very seriously, and we do not tolerate any forms of abuse. When our professionals face threats or harassment from clients, they should promptly report the matter to the Police, MSF as well as their employers.
Protecting Social Workers against Threats or Harassment On The Job Consistent reporting to the authorities is the most effective way to address such incidents. Following the report, my Ministry will provide guidance and support to the affected social worker while Police investigations are ongoing. If a Police investigation is not initiated, MSF will provide guidance to the affected social worker on lodging a Magistrate's Complaint.
Protecting Social Workers against Threats or Harassment On The Job Our social service professionals play a key role in supporting the vulnerable in society and deserve to be protected from all forms of abuse. This is a shared responsibility, between the Government and social service agencies who also play a crucial role by implementing robust safety policies for their staff.
Protecting Social Workers against Threats or Harassment On The Job Ms Yeo Wan Ling.
Protecting Social Workers against Threats or Harassment On The Job Mr Speaker, our social workers are at the frontline when they deal with the protection and welfare of our vulnerables, from assessing and providing financial support to families in need to being the protector and gatekeeper to women and children who are facing physical and mental abuse at home. In the course of their work, I have seen, personally, our social workers being threatened on emails, stalked at their workplaces and complained against on social media. In a recent case, I have even seen a social worker being named and blamed openly, and her cell phone number being inadvertently released to an alleged abusive spouse and father she was protecting her wards from. While the Police was called in and eventually, the case was transferred to another social agency, the alleged abuser continues to stalk and threaten the case social workers, both past and present.
Protecting Social Workers against Threats or Harassment On The Job I have absolute empathy and respect for the work that our frontline social workers do as they have shown time and time again how they put the safety and dignity of their wards as a priority, sometimes even at the detriment of their own personal safety and reputation.
Protecting Social Workers against Threats or Harassment On The Job More must be done. Will the Ministry consider a public education campaign to let the public know about the work that our social workers do and the enforcement measures that the Ministry and Police will put in to defend our social workers? What can we do to ensure the mental well-being of our social workers and can more support come from the MSF if their social workers and SSA workers are put through a long stretch of abuse from uncooperative stakeholders on cases that they are working on? What intervention can the Ministry take to extract our social workers from such abusive situations?
Protecting Social Workers against Threats or Harassment On The Job Sir, I thank the Member for her supplementary questions and more importantly, for standing with and supporting our social service frontliners.
Protecting Social Workers against Threats or Harassment On The Job As I mentioned, consistent reporting is probably the best response to any social service professional who encounters a threat, verbal or physical abuse, or harassment. So, report it to the Police. And after the report has been lodged, MSF will appoint a dedicated officer to serve as a point of contact on behalf of the social service worker with the Police. And even if the case is assessed to have not crossed the line or threshold for proactive investigation, MSF may guide and advise the social service worker to pursue civil remedies in the form of a Magistrate's Complaint, if it is necessary.
Protecting Social Workers against Threats or Harassment On The Job We will consider the Member's suggestion on public education on measures that MSF can take to protect social service professionals. Like Ms Yeo, MSF does not tolerate any abuse of our social service frontliners and if there are specific cases that the Member has in mind for which MSF can assist with, we would be happy to follow up with her separately.
11.34 am 6 Mr Dennis Tan Lip Fong asked the Minister for Home Affairs (a) what is the cause of the oil leak at the Brani Regional Base of the Police Coast Guard on 5 February 2025 which has resulted in 23 tonnes of diesel being leaked into the waters south of Singapore; (b) whether there will be a formal investigation to ascertain the causes of the oil leak; and (c) if so, whether the full findings can be made known to the public.
11.34 am Mr Speaker, Sir, I will first provide a summary of the chronology of events surrounding the oil leak from the Police Coast Guard’s Brani Regional Base on 5 February 2025, before touching on the cause of the leak.
11.34 am On 5 February 2025, at about 3.25 pm, the Police Coast Guard (PCG) was alerted by the Maritime Port Authority of Singapore (MPA) of a possible oil leak from Brani Base after MPA had detected oil sheens near Sentosa Gateway.
11.34 am While PCG was checking for the oil leak, a contractor who was performing unrelated works in the vicinity saw oil leaking from a fuel hose at one of the pontoons at Brani Base. The contractor isolated the main valve to the leaking hose and the leak was stopped at about 3.40 pm. The contractor was unaware about the report of oil leakage at this point and had acted independently.
11.34 am After carrying out its checks, PCG confirmed that the leak was from this damaged hose and verified that there were no signs of other leaks around Brani Base. PCG updated MPA of the situation at around 5.50 pm. Agencies commenced measures to mitigate the impact, including Sentosa Development Corporation which laid booms to prevent any oil from reaching the beaches.
11.34 am On the morning of 6 February 2025, MPA and PCG flew drones over the waters in the vicinity of Brani Base and the Southern Islands to get a clearer assessment of the impact and also activated an oil cleaning contractor to assist with the clean-up operations.
11.34 am During this period, navigational traffic was not affected, the operations in the Port of Singapore were able to continue unimpacted, and no beaches were closed. On 8 February 2025, MPA and PCG stood down the clean-up operations.
11.34 am After PCG had confirmed the source of the leak on 5 February 2025, it carried out further investigations and CCTV checks, and established that the affected hose had first leaked at about 11.40 am that morning. PCG was unaware of any leaks at that point. That morning, an auxiliary police officer (APO) deployed in PCG had reported at 11.57 am that water was leaking from the affected hose at the pontoon. As there were both fuel and water hoses at the pontoon, and the APO was not trained to identify oil leaks, he had mistakenly reported it to be a water leak. Marine diesel appears as a clear transparent fluid, so he thought it was water.
11.34 am Pursuant to the APO’s report, a PCG officer arrived at about 12.25 pm to do further checks but did not observe any leak. There was no visible oil sheen on the water in the area and no noticeable smell of leaked fuel.
11.34 am The facilities management staff arrived subsequently at 1.38 pm to conduct further checks as part of PCG’s fault reporting protocol for leaks. The staff did not observe any oil sheen on the water, and there was no noticeable smell of fuel.
11.34 am As both the PCG officer and facilities management staff had observed no sign of discharge of oil into the water, it was assessed that the leak reported by the APO was indeed a water leak. A case was lodged for the rectification of a water leak.
11.34 am Minister of State, you might want to wrap up.
11.34 am Yes, Sir. Through PCG’s subsequent investigation and retrospective CCTV checks, PCG discovered that the leak had stopped on its own at about 12.20 pm but restarted at about 2.47 pm. The leak was finally stopped at about 3.40 pm when the contractor spotted the leak and isolated the main valve, as I explained earlier.
11.34 am Based on PCG’s investigations, the leak was caused by a damaged fuel hose connecting the wharf's fuel distribution network to the fuel dispenser on a pontoon. PCG’s preliminary assessment is that the fuel hose developed micro-cracks due to cyclical stresses during routine coiling and uncoiling, which eventually led to a tear that caused the fuel spillage.
11.34 am Sir, just a few minutes. Actually, one minute, Sir.
11.34 am We are actually out of time. A quick one, please.
11.34 am Thank you, Sir. The fuel hoses are checked and maintained every month. The last maintenance check was conducted on 17 January 2025 and the next inspection was scheduled for the week of 10 February 2025.
11.34 am Following the oil leak at Brani Base, PCG promptly inspected all fuel hoses there on 6 February 2025. Similar checks were completed on 8 February 2025 at its three other bases – Loyang, Lim Chu Kang and Gul Regional Bases.
11.34 am While PCG’s maintenance and reporting protocols are generally consistent with industry best practices, PCG is reviewing them nevertheless to further reduce the likelihood of leaks of such magnitude in the future. Thank you very much, Sir.
11.34 am Order. End of Question Time. The Clerk will now proceed to read the Order of the day.
11.34 am [Pursuant to Standing Order No 22(3), provided that Members had not asked for questions standing in their names to be postponed to a later Sitting day or withdrawn, written answers to questions not reached by the end of Question Time are reproduced in the Appendix.]