Skip to content
Official report

Hansard

Hansard, Thursday, 6 March 2025

Feedback & support

The text

(1)

Key Priorities for ASEAN's Relations with US 1 Mr Neil Parekh Nimil Rajnikant asked the Minister for Foreign Affairs (a) what does Singapore consider the key priorities for the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) in its relations with the United States (US) under the new Trump administration, bearing in mind the US President's absence from ASEAN summits during his first term as President; and (b) what messages will Singapore convey to its US counterparts during the ASEAN country dialogues and at the East Asia Summit under the chairmanship of Malaysia.

(2)

Key Priorities for ASEAN's Relations with US Mr Speaker, the short answer to Mr Neil Parekh's question is economics – trade, investment, energy.

(3)

Key Priorities for ASEAN's Relations with US The United States (US) remains a critical partner for Singapore and for the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN). The US' presence in our region has in fact underpinned our peace, stability and prosperity in Southeast Asia for many decades. The US is, by a significant margin, the largest foreign investor in ASEAN. And the US is also ASEAN's second largest trading partner.

(4)

Key Priorities for ASEAN's Relations with US The US has been an active supporter of ASEAN and this includes strengthening collaboration in new growth areas, for instance artificial intelligence (AI), cyber security and energy transition.

(5)

Key Priorities for ASEAN's Relations with US The omni-directional engagement on the part of ASEAN towards the US, to China, to the EU, to India, to Australia and indeed all the middle powers, and our emerging links with Africa and South America, is an essential element of ASEAN's vision for an open, inclusive and rules-based regional architecture in our region. We believe this is the way to secure peace and prosperity, and also based on the appreciation of the fact that in contrast to many parts of the world, Southeast Asia remains at peace and has good prospects for significant growth in the decades to come.

(6)

Key Priorities for ASEAN's Relations with US In this respect, the US' commitment to the ASEAN Outlook on the Indo-Pacific, which they have expressed on previous occasions, is reaffirmation of this point.

(7)

Key Priorities for ASEAN's Relations with US We will keep emphasising the mutually beneficial nature of ASEAN's interactions and engagement with the US. This engagement will continue to contribute in fact for mutual benefit of both ASEAN and America, and create an area in this part of the world which is safer, stronger and more prosperous.

(8)

Key Priorities for ASEAN's Relations with US It is worth reminding this House that in fact if you add, cumulatively, all the economies of the members of ASEAN, we already constitute the world's fifth largest economy and we expect to be on track to become the fourth largest economy by 2030. The trade and investments from the US into our region support hundreds and thousands of jobs in Southeast Asia but similarly, it also supports over 600,000 jobs in America itself. So, the point here is that this is a mutually beneficial relationship.

(9)

Key Priorities for ASEAN's Relations with US ASEAN's rapidly developing economies present significant opportunities for American companies including areas like critical minerals, energy, manufacturing, technology, including digital and AI.

(10)

Key Priorities for ASEAN's Relations with US Another point worth emphasising is that one-third of global trade passes through the critical maritime shipping lanes in Southeast Asia, including the Straits of Malacca and Singapore, and beyond that, into the South China Sea. The US' presence in the region, both economically and therefore also having interests to protect from a defence perspective, has been crucial to maintaining stability and opportunities in our part of the world. From an ASEAN perspective, the primacy of the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Seas (UNCLOS), which sets out maritime entitlements, and avenues for peaceful resolutions of disputes, and sets out as a right freedom of navigation and overflight, is crucial for ASEAN, both from a stability point of view as well as economic prospects for the future.

(11)

Key Priorities for ASEAN's Relations with US So, Mr Speaker, we will continue to work with our partners in ASEAN to seek opportunities for high-level engagement with the new US administration on this basis.

(12)

Key Priorities for ASEAN's Relations with US Mr Neil Parekh.

(13)

Key Priorities for ASEAN's Relations with US I thank the Minister for the comprehensive response as well as the comprehensive discussions during the Committee of Supply with all the other political officeholders.

(14)

Key Priorities for ASEAN's Relations with US My question is related to Ukraine. Does the Minister and envisage a role for ASEAN or Singapore in the peace negotiations that hopefully will get underway very soon, similar, to the way we made an effort to bring the US and North Korea together a few years ago?

(15)

Key Priorities for ASEAN's Relations with US The short answer is no. There are far more proximate partners and stakeholders in the dispute, in the conflict between Ukraine and Russia, than Southeast Asia. So, the short answer is no.

(16)

Key Priorities for ASEAN's Relations with US Having said that, let me give a Southeast Asian perspective. If you look at the votes of the 10 ASEAN member states, you will find that all of us, in our votes and in our explanation of votes at the UN, have emphasised the importance of the UN Charter and the principles of sovereign equality, political independence and territorial integrity.

(17)

Key Priorities for ASEAN's Relations with US ASEAN, perhaps also because of our past experience in the Cold War, has absolutely no intention of allowing ourselves to be a future arena for proxy wars and we will certainly have no intention to allow ourselves to be caught in the strategic contestations between superpowers in the future.

(18)

Key Priorities for ASEAN's Relations with US So, bear in mind ASEAN's history. Bear in mind, ASEAN's prospects for the future. Bear in mind, our adherence to international law in the UN Charter. And just as importantly, bear in mind, our prospects for the future.

(19)

Key Priorities for ASEAN's Relations with US And that is why I began my answer to you just now that the short answer is no. And if I may add, I had I had an introductory telephone conversation with the Secretary of State Mr Marco Rubio last night. Both of us emphasised economics – so trade, investments, energy.

(20)

Cause of Kranji Crescent Warehouse Fire on 19 February and Exposure of Pollutants to Nearby Residents 2 Ms Hazel Poa asked the Minister for Sustainability and the Environment (a) whether NEA has information on what types of waste materials are stored at the warehouse at 11 Kranji Crescent that caught fire on 19 February 2025; (b) whether the four-day fire at the warehouse has exposed residents nearby to toxic pollutants; and (c) if so, what pollutants have residents been exposed to as a result of the fire.

(21)

Cause of Kranji Crescent Warehouse Fire on 19 February and Exposure of Pollutants to Nearby Residents The site that caught fire on 19 February is occupied by a General Waste Disposal Facility. It is licensed to receive industrial and commercial waste for sorting prior to recycling and disposal. The facility contained materials such as paper, plastics, glass, scrap metal, wood waste and e-waste, but it is not licensed to store toxic industrial waste or hazardous substances. Investigations by the National Environment Agency (NEA) and the Singapore Civil Defence Force (SCDF) are ongoing to ascertain whether the facility had adhered to the relevant licensing and fire safety requirements.

(22)

Cause of Kranji Crescent Warehouse Fire on 19 February and Exposure of Pollutants to Nearby Residents The facility is around two kilometres away from the nearest residences. Based on NEA's ambient air quality monitoring network, the air quality in the West region remained within the normal range throughout the four-day duration of the fire.

(23)

Cause of Kranji Crescent Warehouse Fire on 19 February and Exposure of Pollutants to Nearby Residents Ms Poa.

(24)

Cause of Kranji Crescent Warehouse Fire on 19 February and Exposure of Pollutants to Nearby Residents I think the Senior Minister of State for her reply. Does NEA keep track of what materials are stored by recycling companies in their warehouses and whether they rectify any fire safety violations to reduce reoccurrence of such a happening?

(25)

Cause of Kranji Crescent Warehouse Fire on 19 February and Exposure of Pollutants to Nearby Residents Sir, NEA does conduct inspections of these premises from time to time. For this particular premises, they actually did six inspections since 2021. They also regularly send out advisories to these waste recycling facilities to remind them of the need to be cognisant of fire safety risk, to continuously review their fire safety measures to make sure that they are relevant and adequate.

(26)

Cause of Kranji Crescent Warehouse Fire on 19 February and Exposure of Pollutants to Nearby Residents NEA works together with SCDF. SCDF itself also conducts scheduled and regular inspections of these premises. And I understand that SCDF also conducted 10 inspections between 2018 and 2024 for this premises. Where there are non-compliance, these would be issued out. So, for this premises, I think they issued four Fire Hazard Abatement Notices, which is actually a warning to ask them to rectify some non-compliance issues like obstruction of fire exit door or fire extinguisher or faulty fire exit sign. There were three Notices of Offence. Again, this is for non-compliance, for instance, if there is unauthorised fire safety construction. But all these were actually rectified.

(27)

Updates to Pandemic Preparedness Plan for Large-scale Influenza Outbreaks 3 Mr Yip Hon Weng asked the Minister for Health (a) whether he can elaborate on how our pandemic preparedness plan has been updated to include large-scale influenza outbreaks; (b) specifically, what measures are in place to handle a sudden spike in infections; and (c) how does the Ministry ensure sufficient healthcare capacity during such surges.

(28)

Updates to Pandemic Preparedness Plan for Large-scale Influenza Outbreaks Mr Speaker, Sir, large-scale influenza outbreaks are not new and will hit us from time to time. The best way to protect ourselves is for the public, especially those who are medically vulnerable, to take preventive measures. These include having updated vaccinations, practising good personal hygiene and when unwell, wearing face masks, limiting social contacts and seeking medical attention promptly when needed.

(29)

Updates to Pandemic Preparedness Plan for Large-scale Influenza Outbreaks If there is a spike in influenza infections, we may have to release our stockpile of antivirals to reduce the risk of infection and severe outcomes, or to secure more supply of new vaccines.

(30)

Updates to Pandemic Preparedness Plan for Large-scale Influenza Outbreaks Our public hospitals treat high patient volumes on a daily basis. In surges, they have to tap on alternative care models such as Mobile Inpatient Care at Home for suitable patients and Transitional Care Facilities for medically stable patients.

(31)

Updates to Pandemic Preparedness Plan for Large-scale Influenza Outbreaks Mr Yip.

(32)

Updates to Pandemic Preparedness Plan for Large-scale Influenza Outbreaks Thank you, Mr Speaker. I thank the Senior Minister of State for his reply. In light of recent influenza outbreaks in regional countries, such as Thailand, what steps is the Ministry taking to enhance influenza vaccination coverage amongst the high-risk populations in Singapore? For instance, in Yio Chu Kang, we work with donors and clinics to provide free flu vaccinations for seniors. And how are these strategies informed by lessons learnt from COVID-19 vaccination roll-outs?

(33)

Updates to Pandemic Preparedness Plan for Large-scale Influenza Outbreaks Sir, I thank Mr Yip for his question and for the work that he is doing in his constituency to enhance vaccine coverage. Indeed, we have to increase the awareness of the importance of vaccine coverage for high-risk populations. And high-risk populations for influenza are particularly the seniors that he mentioned, anyone over the age of 65, anyone with chronic medical conditions and people who are vulnerable either because of a condition that causes low immunity or increased risk of acquiring an illness such as influenza.

(34)

Updates to Pandemic Preparedness Plan for Large-scale Influenza Outbreaks This is something that we have to think about on an ongoing basis. It is not a illness where it comes once and then it is gone. This is illness that is endemic and it is seasonal – the virus changes, every season. And it is also not an illness where you can be vaccinated once and then are protected for life. You have to update your vaccinations on a regular basis. And so, issues to do with awareness and education, we need to continue on an ongoing basis. And we do so at the medical facilities, or if general practitioners, family physicians are seeing someone over the age of 65 for other routine care, they often do and should ask about when the last influenza vaccination was and offer it, if appropriate.

(35)

Updates to Pandemic Preparedness Plan for Large-scale Influenza Outbreaks Similarly, this is something that anyone who is in regular contact with seniors as a result of the service that they are offering, such as the examples that Mr Yip provided in his constituency, can and should ask seniors. Even on a personal level for family members, children can very often play an important role in reminding their parents. So, for me, for example, for many years, I have had the habit of using my parents' wedding anniversary as a marker in my calendar to nag them, gently nudge them. And then, as they have now become a little bit older, I take on the responsibility of making the appointment for them to then go and receive their influenza vaccinations.

(36)

Updates to Pandemic Preparedness Plan for Large-scale Influenza Outbreaks So, from an organisational, a social and a personal level, we can often find ways to constantly remind the seniors amongst us above the age of 65 that a regular influenza vaccination would be a very important part of protecting themselves. In parallel, the good social habits, the personal hygiene that I mentioned in my original Parliamentary Question answer also need to continue to be reinforced.

(37)

Stopping Illegal Practice of Carpooling Arrangements Set Up via Online Chatgroups 4 Ms Yeo Wan Ling asked the Minister for Transport (a) what measures are taken to stop the illegal practice of carpooling arrangements set up via online chatgroups; and (b) whether the Ministry will embark on a public education campaign on allowable forms of carpooling in Singapore.

(38)

Stopping Illegal Practice of Carpooling Arrangements Set Up via Online Chatgroups The Land Transport Authority (LTA) conducts enforcement actions against drivers who are found to have provided illegal car-pooling services. An individual who provides an illegal car-pooling service may face a fine of up to $3,000, up to six months' imprisonment, or both. Those who provide an illegal car-pool matching service may face a fine of up to $10,000, up to six months' imprisonment, or both. Members of the public who come across individuals providing illegal car-pooling services may write to LTA or notify LTA through the OneMotoring portal.

(39)

Stopping Illegal Practice of Carpooling Arrangements Set Up via Online Chatgroups For safety, we strongly encourage commuters who wish to book point-to-point transport (P2P) services, including commercial car-pooling, to do so via licensed business platforms.

(40)

Stopping Illegal Practice of Carpooling Arrangements Set Up via Online Chatgroups I want to thank the Member for her suggestion for a campaign to improve public awareness of the allowable forms of car-pooling. LTA will work with the taxi and private hire vehicle drivers' associations on this.

(41)

Stopping Illegal Practice of Carpooling Arrangements Set Up via Online Chatgroups Ms Yeo.

(42)

Stopping Illegal Practice of Carpooling Arrangements Set Up via Online Chatgroups Thank you, Speaker. I declare that I am the advisor to the National Private Hire Vehicles Association, an affiliate association to the National Trades Union Congress (NTUC).

(43)

Stopping Illegal Practice of Carpooling Arrangements Set Up via Online Chatgroups The illegal practice of carpooling arrangement set up via online chatgroups continues to be an issue, creating safety concerns for passengers and affecting the professional reputation of licensed P2P drivers. A quick search on Telegram last week using SGHitch already yields five different active chatgroups, the largest, having a member base of 49,115, and the smallest with a base of 3,000. Almost every minute, in these chats, there is an offer to or from a driver to carpool and offer from a passenger to hitch a ride.

(44)

Stopping Illegal Practice of Carpooling Arrangements Set Up via Online Chatgroups In Singapore, it is only legal to carpool for a fee via licensed business platforms. Given that serious safety issues can come with the use of such unlicensed services – from the outrage of modesty to the most recent case of death where the driver did not even have a Class 3 licence – what more can the Ministry do to educate the public on the use of such services? And would the Ministry consider also disallowing paid carpooling amongst strangers, even in matching platforms for the safety of all commuters?

(45)

Stopping Illegal Practice of Carpooling Arrangements Set Up via Online Chatgroups I want to thank the Member for her supplementary questions. As she has noted, currently, we only allow carpooling services if it is through a licensed carpooling operator or through a permitted licence-exempt operator, which is one that has got a fleet of less than 800 cars. These operators are able to record the driver as well as the trip, check on the validity of the driver's licence and also enforce on the maximum two trips per day requirement. This really is to protect the commuters or passengers' safety, provide the commuter with some safeguards.

(46)

Stopping Illegal Practice of Carpooling Arrangements Set Up via Online Chatgroups Carpooling services acquired through informal channels like Telegram, SGHitch that are non-business entities are not allowed. They are banned.

(47)

Stopping Illegal Practice of Carpooling Arrangements Set Up via Online Chatgroups There is some value in providing or allowing some of these carpooling services. Because it optimises vehicle road capacity, the use of the vehicle, as well as, of course, reduce carbon footprint. Totally banning carpooling services will not necessarily remove the problem. In fact, it may exacerbate the problem. If you look at the informal channels, as the Member has rightly pointed out, there is demand. So, when there is demand, there is supply.

(48)

Stopping Illegal Practice of Carpooling Arrangements Set Up via Online Chatgroups And therefore I agree with the Member that besides enforcement actions through enforcement operations that we will continue to do, it is good to intensify our public education efforts to raise awareness among the public that their safety is not protected if they go through these informal channels, and that if they require such carpooling services, they should do it through the licensed or licence-exempt permitted operators. We will work with the associations to look at such a campaign.

(49)

Efforts to Streamline Social Service Offices' Processes to Ensure Timelier Renewals for ComCare Applications 5 Mr Yip Hon Weng asked the Minister for Social and Family Development in view of the challenges faced by some single parents and individuals with disabilities in renewing their financial assistance under ComCare schemes (a) whether the Ministry can provide details on the efforts to streamline the Social Service Offices' processes to ensure timelier responses for such renewal applications; and (b) whether there are plans to implement an automatic renewal system for cases with chronic or permanent medical conditions.

(50)

Efforts to Streamline Social Service Offices' Processes to Ensure Timelier Renewals for ComCare Applications Sir, through digitalisation, we have made ComCare applications simpler and more convenient especially for those who cannot easily leave their homes to apply for help. Applications for ComCare Short-to-Medium-Term Assistance can be made online on the SupportGoWhere portal. Applicants who need help with their online application can call our hotline and our call agents will walk them through the application. Our officers can make home visits to assist those who still cannot apply online despite the guidance and are home-bound, such as the elderly or people with disabilities.

(51)

Efforts to Streamline Social Service Offices' Processes to Ensure Timelier Renewals for ComCare Applications The Social Service Officers would have to speak to applicants to find out more about their financial situations and needs. This can be done through phone calls, video conferencing calls or a home visit, if an applicant is unable to meet face-to-face at our office. For persons who are permanently unable to work and have little or no financial means or family support, we can provide ComCare Long Term Assistance where the period between each renewal is longer. The renewal process is still important as it serves as important touchpoints for our officers to check on our clients' wellbeing and identify any new needs.

(52)

Efforts to Streamline Social Service Offices' Processes to Ensure Timelier Renewals for ComCare Applications Mr Yip.

(53)

Efforts to Streamline Social Service Offices' Processes to Ensure Timelier Renewals for ComCare Applications Thank you, Mr Speaker. I thank the Senior Parliamentary Secretary for his reply. Considering the recurring nature of chronic or permanent medical conditions, what are the Ministry's views on implementing an automatic renewal system for ComCare assistance in such cases? And what potential benefits or challenges have been identified in adopting this approach? And how might it improve the quality of life for some of these affected Singaporeans?

(54)

Efforts to Streamline Social Service Offices' Processes to Ensure Timelier Renewals for ComCare Applications Sir, I thank Mr Yip for his supplementary question. I think there is a need to strike a balance here: a balance between ensuring accountability because it is public money that we are dealing with, but perhaps a more important point is the need for us to check in on a regular basis with these clients. Because we do want to make sure that circumstances within the family have not quite deteriorated and if they have or if they have improved, what are the additional things that we can do to better support these clients.

(55)

Efforts to Streamline Social Service Offices' Processes to Ensure Timelier Renewals for ComCare Applications So, considering the two, I think there is a need for us to still ensure that this renewal process is in place. But for cases where, based on their own merits, we can extend the interval for which each of this renewal is being carried out.

(56)

Dealing with Offenders who Have Been Repeatedly Issued Notices for Severe Breaches of Fire Safety Regulations 6 Ms Hazel Poa asked the Minister for Home Affairs what is the Singapore Civil Defence Force's policy for dealing with offenders who have been repeatedly issued notices of offence for severe breaches of fire safety regulations.

(57)

Dealing with Offenders who Have Been Repeatedly Issued Notices for Severe Breaches of Fire Safety Regulations Sir, the Singapore Civil Defence Force (SCDF) adopts an escalatory approach in enforcing against breaches of fire safety regulations.

(58)

Dealing with Offenders who Have Been Repeatedly Issued Notices for Severe Breaches of Fire Safety Regulations It issues abatement notices or impose composition fines for minor cases of non-compliance. Higher fines are imposed for repeated instances, and prosecution in court may follow if the errant party fails to rectify the non-compliance. An example of a minor non-compliance would be undertaking minor partition works that affect the fire safety design of a space without seeking approval from SCDF.

(59)

Dealing with Offenders who Have Been Repeatedly Issued Notices for Severe Breaches of Fire Safety Regulations For more serious breaches and repeated offences of serious breaches, SCDF will consider prosecution. An example of a serious breach is erection of illegal structures that would seriously compromise escape in the event of a fire.

(60)

Dealing with Offenders who Have Been Repeatedly Issued Notices for Severe Breaches of Fire Safety Regulations Ms Poa.

(61)

Dealing with Offenders who Have Been Repeatedly Issued Notices for Severe Breaches of Fire Safety Regulations I thank the Minister of State for his reply. In view of the recent fire at the Kranji warehouse, does the Ministry feel that there is a need to adopt a tougher position against repeat offenders?

(62)

Dealing with Offenders who Have Been Repeatedly Issued Notices for Severe Breaches of Fire Safety Regulations Sir, we have always taken, like what I shared earlier, an escalatory enforcement approach. In cases like the one that the Member referred to, and also as shared by my colleague Dr Amy Khor, whereby the SCDF went to inspect 10 times during the said period. And all the non-compliance issues were rectified.

(63)

Dealing with Offenders who Have Been Repeatedly Issued Notices for Severe Breaches of Fire Safety Regulations So, we work with with the owners, and like what I shared in my answer, if there are serious breaches, we will take them to task. We will look at the setting, the context and at the same time, we will not hesitate, not only in taking action but will continue to do inspections, making sure that they are safe.

(64)

Dealing with Offenders who Have Been Repeatedly Issued Notices for Severe Breaches of Fire Safety Regulations I think at the end of the day, every case is unique and we not only take an escalatory approach, we are very serious about this, because fires not only cause damages, lives may be lost. We are very serious and we will continue to ensure that fire safety is well adhered to by owners.

(65)

Dealing with Offenders who Have Been Repeatedly Issued Notices for Severe Breaches of Fire Safety Regulations Mr Dennis Tan.

(66)

Dealing with Offenders who Have Been Repeatedly Issued Notices for Severe Breaches of Fire Safety Regulations Thank you, Mr Speaker. Can I ask the Minister of State for serious cases of persistent reoffending, would the Ministry consider, if necessary, working with other agencies or Ministries to consider imposing a business suspension to deter reoffending?

(67)

Dealing with Offenders who Have Been Repeatedly Issued Notices for Severe Breaches of Fire Safety Regulations Sir, we do work with our agencies and partners. What is key, like what I said earlier, is an escalatory approach. While we can use our levers, we also have our other agencies who can use their levers. At the end of the day, fire safety is critical. We do not compromise because what is key is that we want to make sure that while they are able to continue their business, lives are not at risk.

(68)

10.31 am 7 Mr Yip Hon Weng asked the Prime Minister and Minister for Finance (a) whether the Ministry will consider introducing an extension of the GST Voucher scheme to assist more middle-income households in view of rising living costs and household expenses; (b) whether the Ministry will review the assessable income threshold to qualify for GST-related assistance; and (c) whether there are plans to offer additional support for families with children who fall within the qualifying income threshold.

(69)

10.31 am Mr Speaker, the Goods and Services Tax Voucher (GSTV) scheme helps lower- and middle-income households offset their GST expenses. We last updated the Assessable Income threshold for the GSTV scheme in 2022 and will continue to review this to ensure support is targeted at those who need it more.

(70)

10.31 am The Government has also introduced Cost-of-Living (COL) measures to help Singaporean households cope with their living expenses. As announced at Budget 2025, the Government will be providing additional Community Development Council (CDC) Vouchers to all Singaporean households and providing additional U-Save such that eligible HDB households will receive double the regular U-Save, or up to $760, this financial year.

(71)

10.31 am On top of these, the families that meet the eligibility criteria will receive additional support as announced at Budget 2025 in the form of $500 Child LifeSG Credits for each Singaporean child aged 12 and below this year, and $500 top-ups to the Edusave account or Post-Secondary Education Account for Singaporeans aged 13 to 20 years this year.

(72)

10.31 am We have also introduced structural enhancements to better support families. These include a further reduction in the monthly full-day childcare fee caps in Government-supported preschools, and the opening of nearly 40,000 new infant and childcare places by Anchor Operators over the next few years.

(73)

10.31 am We have also rolled out the Large Families Scheme, which includes $1,000 in Large Family LifeSG Credits disbursed annually to families for each of their third and subsequent child during the years that the child turns one to six. These will help to defray a wide range of household expenses for families with children.

(74)

10.31 am Order. End of Question Time.

(75)

10.31 am [Pursuant to Standing Order No 22(3), provided that Members had not asked for questions standing in their names to be postponed to a later Sitting day or withdrawn, written answers to questions not reached by the end of Question Time are reproduced in the Appendix.]

(76)

10.31 am Mr Speaker, I move, "That, notwithstanding Standing Order 91(2), the Ministerial Statement on Review into the Public Disclosure of Full NRIC Numbers on Bizfile People Search be taken before the resumption of proceedings on the Estimates of Expenditure for FY2025/2026 at this day's Sitting".

(77)

10.31 am Supply business ordinarily takes precedence over Ministerial Statements. However, the Ministerial Statement is on a matter of some importance and it would be more efficient for the disposal of Parliamentary Business for the Ministerial Statement to be taken before the resumption of the debate on the Committee of Supply. Members will have sufficient time to seek clarifications from Senior Minister Teo Chee Hean, who will deliver the Ministerial Statement.

(78)

10.31 am [(proc text) Question put, and agreed to. (proc text)]

(79)

10.31 am [(proc text) Resolved, (proc text)]

(80)

10.31 am [(proc text) That, notwithstanding Standing Order 91(2), the Ministerial Statement on "Review into the Public Disclosure of Full NRIC Numbers on Bizfile People Search" be taken before the resumption of proceedings on the Estimates of Expenditure for FY2025/2026 at this day's Sitting. – [Ms Indranee Rajah] (proc text)]

(81)

12.17 pm Ministerial Statement. Senior Minister Teo Chee Hean.

(82)

12.17 pm With your permission, Mr Speaker, may I request the Clerks to distribute a handout to Members, which I will refer to during my Statement? Members may also access the handout through the MP@SGPARL App.

(83)

12.17 pm Please proceed. [A handout was distributed to hon Members. Please refer to Annex 1.]

(84)

12.17 pm Thank you, Mr Speaker. Sir, on 9 December last year, the Accounting and Corporate Regulatory Authority (ACRA) launched its new Bizfile portal to replace its existing system. Like its predecessor, the new portal included a People Search function. This function allowed users to search for and select the individuals associated with registered business entities whose information they wished to access through the purchase of a People Profile. So, there is a People Search function and the People Profile function. The People Search function is generally available to everyone, anyone. The People Profile function sits behind a paywall.

(85)

12.17 pm But unlike the old Bizfile portal, which showed partial National Registration Identity Card (NRIC) numbers in the People Search results, the new Bizfile portal displayed full NRIC numbers. This caused public anxiety about how easily full NRIC numbers could be searched for and accessed. Therefore, the People Search function was disabled on the night of 13 December 2024.

(86)

12.17 pm The Minister for Digital Development and Information, Mrs Josephine Teo, and the Second Minister for Finance, Ms Indranee Rajah, held a media conference on 19 December 2024, during which they apologised for the anxiety caused. They explained what had happened and the Government's intent to change the existing practice of using partial NRIC numbers. Ministers Josephine Teo and Indranee Rajah also made Ministerial Statements to this House on 8 January 2025 and responded to requests for clarifications from Members.

(87)

12.17 pm To thoroughly review the matter, the Prime Minister directed the Head of the Civil Service to set up a Panel to review the Government's policy on the responsible use of NRIC numbers where it pertained to the Bizfile portal; second, to determine what led to the Bizfile incident; and to identify learning points so that similar incidents do not recur.

(88)

12.17 pm The Panel also reviewed the design and implementation of the People Search function and the response to the incident by ACRA and the Ministry of Digital Development and Information (MDDI), from the time public concerns arose on 12 December 2024 until the People Search function was disabled on 13 December 2024.

(89)

12.17 pm The Panel submitted its report to me on 25 February 2025. I reviewed the report and reported to the Prime Minister that I had accepted its findings and recommendations. After studying the report carefully, the Prime Minister agreed with its findings, its assessment of the shortcomings and the learning points identified. He said that the Government would take the lessons to heart to improve its processes and strive to do better. He directed that the report be released to the public and for the matter to be deliberated in Parliament. ACRA and MDDI have also accepted the findings and released separate media statements on their follow-up actions.

(90)

12.17 pm Hon Members would have had the opportunity to study the report, which was made public on 3 March 2025.

(91)

12.17 pm Sir, before we turn to the Panel's findings, I will briefly summarise the issues regarding the use of full and partial NRIC numbers. This is set out on the first page of the handout, which is the Annex to the Panel's report. Minister Josephine Teo had addressed these issues in her Ministerial Statement on 8 January 2025 to this House. So, allow me to recap these issues briefly.

(92)

12.17 pm The NRIC number allows the individual to be referred to uniquely and definitively. It is important to definitively refer to an individual by using the full NRIC number when required by law and for other purposes, such as for medical procedures and business transactions.

(93)

12.17 pm However, the NRIC number had also become used by some organisations, not just to definitively refer to the individual, but also based just on the NRIC number, to carry out important and sensitive actions. The use of the NRIC number in this way is unsafe, because the person's NRIC number is likely to be already known to other persons or organisations.

This is the start of the text. The rest is on the official site. Open the official text