Skip to content
Official report

Hansard

Hansard, Tuesday, 3 October 2023

Feedback & support

The text

(1)

Additional Steps to Detect and Prevent Money Laundering Activities 1 Mr Zhulkarnain Abdul Rahim asked the Minister for Home Affairs how is the MAS working with the relevant agencies to prevent movable assets like gemstones, jewellery and luxury watches from being used to launder money in Singapore.

(2)

Additional Steps to Detect and Prevent Money Laundering Activities 2 Mr Zhulkarnain Abdul Rahim asked the Minister for Home Affairs regarding the estimated value of about $1 billion dollars in assets seized in the recent case of money laundering activities (a) what are the measures to ensure that the restrictions under the relevant rules, such as the Precious Stones and Precious Metals (Prevention of Money Laundering and Terrorism Financing) Act 2019, are not circumvented; and (b) whether there will be tighter controls through importers, retailers and our checkpoints over movable assets like gemstones, jewellery and luxury watches into Singapore.

(3)

Additional Steps to Detect and Prevent Money Laundering Activities 3 Mr Murali Pillai asked the Minister for Home Affairs whether the 10 foreigners who have been charged by the Police on 16 August 2023 for money-laundering activities in relation to the $1 billion cash and assets seized are being or will be investigated for running any organised crime syndicate in or from Singapore and, if so, what facts have been established thus far in this regard.

(4)

Additional Steps to Detect and Prevent Money Laundering Activities 4 Mr Murali Pillai asked the Minister for Home Affairs (a) whether there is a reporting requirement on landlords to lodge Suspicious Transaction Reports against their tenants if they have reasonable grounds to suspect that their tenants have access to ill-gotten wealth or gains; and (b) if so, whether the landlords of the private properties where foreign nationals holding passports of convenience were found to be residing when arrested by the Singapore Police on 15 August 2023 for suspected money-laundering related activities will be scrutinised for compliance with this requirement.

(5)

Additional Steps to Detect and Prevent Money Laundering Activities 5 Mr Murali Pillai asked the Minister for Home Affairs (a) whether any additional steps will be taken to protect the real estate market in Singapore from being targeted by money launderers; and (b) if so, what are they.

(6)

Additional Steps to Detect and Prevent Money Laundering Activities 6 Mr Gan Thiam Poh asked the Minister for Home Affairs whether the Police will initiate investigations and arrest any person who is on the wanted list for criminal offences in another country but not listed under the wanted list of the International Criminal Police Organisation (INTERPOL).

(7)

Additional Steps to Detect and Prevent Money Laundering Activities 7 Mr Don Wee asked the Minister for Home Affairs whether MAS shares information obtained from suspicious financial transactions with banks, the Immigration Checkpoint Authority of Singapore and the Ministry of Manpower.

(8)

Additional Steps to Detect and Prevent Money Laundering Activities 8 Mr Don Wee asked the Minister for Home Affairs whether information obtained from Suspicious Transaction Reports is shared with banks, the Immigration Checkpoint Authority of Singapore and the Ministry of Manpower.

(9)

Additional Steps to Detect and Prevent Money Laundering Activities 9 Mr Zhulkarnain Abdul Rahim asked the Minister for Home Affairs in cases where seized assets are ordered by the Court to be forfeited to the state, how are such assets used or liquidated for the benefit of the public or the Consolidated Fund.

(10)

Additional Steps to Detect and Prevent Money Laundering Activities 10 Mr Don Wee asked the Minister for Home Affairs (a) whether ACRA pays attention or conduct surveillance on (i) foreign directors (ii) beneficial owners and (iii) local directors appearing to be nominee directors, where such appointment can be an indication of the misuse of legal entity; and (b) whether there is any public-private partnership between ACRA, CAD or MAS and the banks to share intelligence on emerging risks such as alerts or placement on undesirable lists.

(11)

Additional Steps to Detect and Prevent Money Laundering Activities 11 Mr Saktiandi Supaat asked the Minister for Home Affairs (a) how many business entities are currently registered with ACRA as "dormant" or any other status that indicates that they are not trading; (b) what is the number of such companies for each of the last 10 years; (c) how often does ACRA check on the reason why such companies remain registered despite being inactive; and (d) whether there is a need to step up active enforcement so that Singapore-registered companies are not misused for money laundering or illegal activities.

(12)

Additional Steps to Detect and Prevent Money Laundering Activities 12 Mr Derrick Goh asked the Minister for Home Affairs (a) how Singapore compares to other global financial centres in terms of preventing and detecting anti-money laundering activities; and (b) whether the roll-out of the Collaborative Sharing of Money Laundering/Terrorism Financing (ML/TF) Information and Cases (COSMIC) digital platform will be accelerated and also extended to other industries to detect such illicit transactions across local industries beyond financial institutions.

(13)

Additional Steps to Detect and Prevent Money Laundering Activities Mr Speaker, may I seek your permission to take Question Nos 1 to 12 together?

(14)

Additional Steps to Detect and Prevent Money Laundering Activities Yes, go ahead.

(15)

Additional Steps to Detect and Prevent Money Laundering Activities These queries relate to the recent anti-money laundering operations conducted by the Police and Singapore's anti-money laundering framework. Mr Speaker, with your permission, the Ministry of Home Affairs, together with various other Ministries, will respond to the queries comprehensively in the Ministerial Statement that will be delivered later today.

(16)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments 13 Mr Yip Hon Weng asked the Minister for Transport (a) whether deferring public transport fare increments to future years remains sustainable, given the anticipated continued rise in cost of living in Singapore; (b) whether the Ministry has mandated any measures to be taken by public transport operators to streamline processes and reduce expenses in order to mitigate rising costs; and (c) if so, what are these measures.

(17)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments 14 Mr Chua Kheng Wee Louis asked the Minister for Transport whether the Public Transport Council plans to expunge the 15.6% fare increase deferred for future Fare Review Exercises (FREs) after a 7% increase having been granted in 2023.

(18)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments 15 Ms Mariam Jaafar asked the Minister for Transport (a) what is the mean and median monthly spend on public transport in the past 12 months by (i) persons with disabilities (PwDs) and (ii) seniors who use public transport; and (b) whether the Ministry will consider introducing hybrid monthly concession passes for PwDs and seniors to be made available in different denominations for light, moderate and heavy users.

(19)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments Mr Speaker, may I have your permission to take Question Nos 13 to 15 together?

(20)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments Yes, please proceed.

(21)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments Thank you, Mr Speaker. Sir, my reply will also address written Question No 14 by Mr Louis Chua for today's Sitting and related questions from Mr Gerald Giam1,2, Ms Hazel Poa, Mr Don Wee and Mr Leong Mun Wai for subsequent Sittings.

(22)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments Sir, in setting public transport fares, the Public Transport Council (PTC) is guided by the fare formula and aims to keep fares affordable for commuters, while ensuring that our public transport system remains financially sustainable.

(23)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments The fare formula reflects the general cost drivers of providing public transport services, based on macroeconomic factors such as core inflation, national wage growth and energy prices. It provides for fares to be adjusted in tandem with changes in these cost drivers, rather than changes in operators' actual costs. In this way, the operators cannot assume that their cost increases will be matched by correspondingly higher fares. Hence, they need to be disciplined in managing their costs and improving their productivity over time.

(24)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments This approach also applies to wage costs. In setting fares, the PTC does not focus on the actual salaries paid by the operators. The formula is based on the national wage index. This allows operators to keep public transport sector salaries competitive with the rest of the economy, so that they are able to attract and retain their workers. Wage increases that exceed changes in the national wage index will not be covered by the fare formula. Over the past five years, the wages of public transport workers grew at a similar pace as the national wage index.

(25)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments The fare formula also includes a Productivity Contribution, which reduces the allowable fare adjustment by 0.1 percentage points every year. This further incentivises the operators to look for continuous productivity improvements to reduce their costs. For example, the operators have been using joint tenders to achieve economies of scale, automating their maintenance processes and upskilling their workers to improve productivity.

(26)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments The fare formula therefore avoids operators' costs from being directly passed on to commuters, while allowing commuters to benefit from productivity savings from the operators.

(27)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments Guided by the formula, the PTC exercises judgement on how much of the allowable fare adjustment to implement each year, taking into consideration economic and social factors. For example, the PTC looks at affordability as measured by the estimated proportion of household income spent on public transport. For the lower-income, this proportion has fallen from 3.1% in 2013 to 2.4% in 2022. For average public transport users, the figure has also reduced from 2.2% in 2013 to 1.7% in 2022.

(28)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments The quantum of allowable fare adjustment that is not implemented in a particular year is deferred and carried forward to future years. In the 2022 Fare Review Exercise (FRE), the PTC deferred 10.6% percentage points of the fare increase. In this year's FRE, the fare formula output was 12%, driven by a 62% increase in energy prices, strong national wage growth at about 7%, and core inflation at about 4%. Adding the deferred quantum of 10.6% to the fare formula output, the maximum allowable fare increase for 2023 was 22.6%.

(29)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments To keep public transport fares affordable for commuters and understanding that Singaporean families are currently facing higher costs of living, the PTC again decided not to grant the full quantum this year. Instead, the PTC decided on an overall fare increase of 7% – which is less than a third of the maximum allowable fare increase of 22.6%. The remaining 15.6 percentage points will be deferred to future years.

(30)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments To account for this funding gap, the Government will provide $300 million of additional subsidies in 2023, which is $100 million more than the previous year. This amount is on top of the $2 billion annual subsidies to fund bus and train services. In addition, the cost of public transport infrastructure is also fully funded by the Government.

(31)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments Mr Louis Chua asked whether the PTC plans to "expunge" the 15.6 percentage points. Mr Don Wee asked if the PTC can "impose a moratorium" on future fare increases. Mr Speaker, I am concerned that Mr Chua and Mr Wee are making these suggestions. Please allow me to explain why their proposals are not sound, as these will affect the longer-term reliability and financial sustainability of our public transport system, to the detriment of Singapore and Singaporeans.

(32)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments I had earlier mentioned that the fare formula reflects real cost increases in our economy, such as energy costs and wages. If the deferred fare amount is "expunged" as Mr Louis Chua proposed, or if fares are frozen for future years as Mr Don Wee suggested, it does not mean that these costs of running the public transport system will simply disappear into thin air.

(33)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments Hence, I would like to ask Mr Chua and Mr Wee to clarify whether they are proposing for the operators to absorb this cost, or for taxpayers to bear a larger cost burden to provide higher Government subsidies on a permanent basis? If it is the latter, they should elaborate how such a move will be funded every year and whether they are proposing for Singaporeans to pay additional taxes to do so? I hope that is not what they have in mind.

(34)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments If it is to ask the public transport operators to absorb the costs, we need to consider how this will impact their financial sustainability over time and in turn, affect their ability to provide accessible and reliable public transport services.

(35)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments Mr Louis Chua asked about the profits of the public transport operators and Mr Don Wee suggested that we could freeze fares given that operators have been profitable. Sir, bus and rail services adopt different operating models. For buses, Government collects the fare revenue and pays the operators a service fee that is derived from competitive bids via bus contracting tenders. Overall, bus services are operating at a loss and that is why Government needs to provide about $1 billion in subsidies for buses every year. Expunging the deferred fare or freezing future fare increases will result in larger losses and higher Government subsidies.

(36)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments For rail services, the operators collect the fares to cover their operating costs, so fares do impact the rail operators' profitability directly. In the latest financial year, after accounting for Government grants, SBS Transit reported a loss of several million dollars for their rail operations, while SMRT Corporation (SMRT) Trains reported an operating profit of $6 million, which represents a profit margin of less than 1%.

(37)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments We should not pretend that the deferred fare increases can somehow be expunged and magically disappear, or assume that future fare increases can be frozen without consequences to our public transport system. Making such populist moves will further enlarge the funding gap over time which must be supported by higher Government subsidies funded by taxpayers. It is not the responsible thing to do. We need to be clear that Government subsidies are ultimately borne by current and future generations of taxpayers.

(38)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments The PTC will continue to ensure that fare adjustments each year are affordable. In each future FRE, the PTC will assess the cost increases as reflected by the fare formula, the deferred fare amount from previous years, as well as the impact on affordability for commuters, before deciding on the fare increase to be granted for that year. And when the opportunity arises, the PTC will consider whether it is possible to lower the total deferred fare amount so the gap will gradually reduce over time.

(39)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments The PTC and Government are also mindful that fare increases affect different groups of commuters differently. While it is important that commuters bear their fair share of cost increases, we are committed to ensuring that fares remain affordable, especially for concession groups such as seniors, students, lower-wage workers and Persons with Disabilities. These groups enjoy discounts of up to 70% off adult per-journey fares.

(40)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments Within each concession group, there is a wide range of spending on public transport, depending on different commuting patterns. Among all seniors, persons with disabilities (PwDs) and individuals on the Workfare Transport Concession Scheme (WTCS), the median monthly spending on public transport is about $16, $24 and $35 respectively.

(41)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments As heavy users of public transport will be more affected by the increase in per-journey fares, we will reduce the price of hybrid monthly concession passes by up to 10%, and introduce a new discounted WTCS monthly pass. This is expected to benefit about 60,000 commuters, including about 1,600 WTCS cardholders who currently pay per-journey fares and spend more than the monthly pass price of $96. Concession cardholders who make fewer public transport journeys will continue to enjoy substantial discounts off adult per-journey fares.

(42)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments When fares increase, the PTC requires rail operators to contribute a proportion of their increased fare revenue to the Public Transport Fund. In the coming year, the rail operators will contribute a total of $16 million. Together with Government's contributions to the Fund, these monies are used to provide Public Transport Vouchers (PTVs) to help cushion the impact on lower-income households. The Government will increase the PTV amount from $30 in 2022 to $50 this year.

(43)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments Over the past decade, we have steadily enhanced the quality of our public transport system by expanding the network, and improving accessibility and reliability of services. These outcomes have been achieved through our strong tripartite partnership between the Government, operators and workers, while keeping fares affordable and the public transport system financially sustainable. This will remain our approach going forward.

(44)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments Mr Yip Hon Weng.

(45)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments I thank the Acting Minister for his very comprehensive reply. My supplementary questions pertain to service reliability. Does the PTC take into consideration the recent number of train breakdowns before allowing for the increase in fares? And if so, will maintenance of service reliability be taken into account before we ask commuters to pay more? Also, can the Ministry share and elaborate on some of the initiatives their transport operators are undertaking to reduce expenses that will not affect the reliability of our transport services?

(46)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments Sir, I thank Mr Yip for his two supplementary questions. On reliability, the public transport operators are subject to stringent service standards and we have not relaxed these standards.

(47)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments For rail, the measurement that we use is what they call the "mean kilometres between failures" (MKBF). Since 2019, MKBF has exceeded one million train kilometres.

(48)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments Under the Bus Contracting Model, frequency of all basic bus services, by which I mean trunk services, are 15 minutes or less during peak periods. Feeder services run even more frequently at no more than eight minutes during peak periods. The Land Transport Authority (LTA) will track the commuter demand and ensure that there is sufficient capacity by adjusting the frequencies where needed. And as I explained in this House previously, whenever there are new Build-To-Order developments, new demand, we will also look at whether we need to introduce new feeder services to serve these new estates.

(49)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments Sir, Mr Yip also asked about what are some of the productivity measures that the transport operators would embark on to reduce costs. Sir, this is an ongoing effort. In the fare formula, I explained that we have a productivity contribution component to incentivise them to do so, but on the ground, the operators have been working very closely with their suppliers, and also with the unions, with the help from our unions, together with the workers, to encourage a lot of ground-up initiatives.

(50)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments In SMRT, for example, they focus a lot on "kaizen". They use this as a movement within the organisation to identify areas for improvement, to improve safety, to improve reliability and to also reduce costs. When I visited SMRT, they shared with me that in the latest year, "kaizen" has allowed them to save more than $100 million, in total. And these savings will help not only to keep our public transport system financially sustainable and avoid subsidies going up and up over the years, importantly, I think that it is also in the spirit of continuous improvement and we empower the workers to look for ways in which they can make things better, improve the processes and the ground-up initiatives are then given top-down support by management.

(51)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments Mr Louis Chua.

(52)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments Thank you, Mr Speaker. Two clarifications for the Acting Minister. The first is in relation to the PTC's work, I understand that it is guided by the fare formula. But if you look at the increase that is been granted, 7%, I think that is well above what we are seeing in the overall inflation rates here in Singapore, so far.

(53)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments If you look at the 15.6 percentage-point increase that is going to be deferred to the future, this is going to cause a significant effect, a lasting effect into the increases in public transport fares for Singaporeans, given that this could have a snowballing effect, since there will be the deferred increase and future increases to consider.

(54)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments So, in that sense, would the Minister not consider, even if not expunging, then moderating the level of increase, just as it did in the fare review exercise in 2021, when the PTC did not fully agree with the outputs from the fare formula? So, this is the first clarification.

(55)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments The second is in terms of financial sustainability. In relation to the written answer which Minister has partially responded to, when I look at the public transport operator, should we not look at the public transport system as a whole, and in that sense, would the Minister not agree that if we look at the returns that some of these operators are generating – one of them, for example, is actually generating close to 11% return on equity in the last one year and 13% in the last five years – one would struggle to see how the financial sustainability of the operator, at this point in time, is actually in question?

(56)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments Mr Speaker, I thank Mr Chua for his two supplementary questions. Sir, the fare formula was revised last year and some of the changes that we have made to the fare formula is then reflected in this year's fare review.

(57)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments Sir, the inflation that we look at in a fare formula is captured under the Consumer Price Index (CPI). And yes, that is part of the fare formula. It is 0.5 times the core CPI.

(58)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments However, we also need to look at other components that affect the cost of the operators, but taken, as I explained my main reply, not their actual cost but as a benchmark looking at the national wage index and looking at the energy index, because these are significant cost components that will affect overall public transport operations.

(59)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments So, that is why the fare formula, using these components, we worked it out last year, we carried it forward, 10.6%. And this year, it was 12%. So, if you add that to the 10.6%, the total is 22.6%.

(60)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments But this is where – perhaps Mr Chua and myself, we may not disagree so much – that the PTC does not just go for the formula maximum amount and say, "It is 22.6%, therefore I go for 22.6%". That is not how it is done. As I explained, they will exercise judgement, they will consider the impact on commuters, on affordability and then after that, they will exercise judgement in terms of what is the level to set and how much to defer.

(61)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments This year, for example, the maximum amount that could be set was 22.6%. But the PTC did exactly like what Mr Chua mentioned, they factored in all these different considerations and they decided that we should only increase by less than a third, 7%, and the rest will be deferred.

(62)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments But when we say "deferred", what it actually means is that the Government is then topping up to ensure that this funding gap is provided for. And in this year's fare review, the Government is providing $300 million of subsidies to cater to this gap.

(63)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments That is why I explained earlier that if we do not find ways, in subsequent years when we can, to gradually to reduce this gap, and if we expunge it, what it means is that the $300 million will remain as a permanent subsidy. And it will add on to the existing subsidies that we already provide: $1 billion for rail, $1 billion for bus. This will increase the burden on taxpayers.

(64)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments I appreciate Mr Chua's concern. I think it is a valid point that we do want to look at affordability on commuters, we do want to consider the impact, including on the overall cost of living. And that is why the PTC exercises judgement and it is not just driven by the formula. I hope that addresses Mr Chua's concern.

(65)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments Sir, Mr Chua also had a second point about the profit numbers and the financial sustainability of the public transport operators. I have explained this in my main reply as well. We need to look at bus and rail separately. For buses, the fares that are being collected do not go to the operators. We are discussing fare review here. The fares that are being collected actually do not go to the revenue of the bus operations. The revenue of the bus operations come from LTA, when we tender out bus contracts. And they bid and then, the service fee, based on the bids, that is what we pay them.

(66)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments I would be happy to share with the House that over time, as we do more bus contracting tenders and as of now, there are more operators – there are now four bus operators – the bids are also becoming more competitive and we have also refined the way we do the bus contracting, that the service fees and the margins have been coming down in the more recent contracts. So, hopefully, over time, it will allow us to squeeze out more productivity gains, more savings, that we can then pass on to taxpayers and to commuters.

(67)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments Ms Mariam Jaafar.

(68)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments I thank the Acting Minister for his responses and I also fully agree with the Minister about the need for public transportation to be financially sustainable. I fully empathise with the delicate balance that has to be struck.

(69)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments My supplementary question relates to whether the Minister would consider additional tiers within the hybrid cards and calibrating across these tiers to better reflect the diversity in usage patterns.

(70)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments Even on the concession cards, I believe that the discounts given to seniors also reflects the very different usage patterns, using the buses and off-peak hours, which do not drive as much of the cost of the transportation network. And so, as our seniors become a larger and larger share, and will eventually become 25% of our population, would the Minister agree that there may be room to consider a slightly more differentiated approach to our hybrid cards for seniors, to allow more people to benefit?

(71)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments The figures that the Minister cited $16, $24, are quite far from the hybrid card costs of $58 today. So, could we allow a bigger diversity of seniors to benefit from the subsidies? Not an overall increase, but a better calibration across different tiers, where you have your young seniors who may still be working, you have your Pioneer Generation – these groups have very different usage patterns.

(72)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments Mr Speaker, I understand where Ms Mariam Jaafar is coming from. That is why in this year's FRE, the PTC has looked at how to lower the cost of the concession pass for the different vulnerable groups.

(73)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments Sir, before I respond to her question directly, allow me to briefly recap that we are providing help in a few ways.

(74)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments First, we subsidise public transport services by more than $2 billion every year. If you were to translate it to per journey, it is more than $1 per journey. For the coming year, there will be an additional $300 million subsidy to cover the fare deferment, which I have explained earlier, and these subsidies go towards helping commuters, because they help to cushion the fare increase that is needed.

(75)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments Second, for the concession card holders, they enjoy discounts of up to 70% of the adult per journey fares. So, this is even if you do not buy the concession pass, because we do have a separate rate for the different concession groups. And the benefit applies to all concession users, whether they are light users, moderate users or heavy users.

(76)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments I understand Ms Mariam Jaafar's point, that because today, the concession passes are set to cater to people who are heavy users – if I understood her correctly, I think she is asking whether we can have different tiers of passes. Sir, I think that it is not impossible. We can take a look to see how we can do this. We will ask the PTC to consider different options, whether there are ways in which we can provide more flexibility.

(77)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments But I just want to raise one factual point, that I hope Ms Mariam agrees with me, which is that it is quite difficult to tell ex ante when a person walks in and say, "I want to buy a concession pass", whether this person is a light, moderate or heavy user. We cannot tell – ex post, you can tell, but not ex ante.

(78)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments So, when this person comes in and wants to buy a concession pass, unless we set a limit to how many times this person can use the pass, which then goes against our current concession pass concept – which is once you buy the concession pass, it is unlimited, it is like a buffet, you can use as many times as you like. So, I think we can take a look, but I do not think we can implement the current all-you-can-use approach and have different tiers because it is not possible to tell ex ante whether the person is a light, moderate or heavy user.

(79)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments Mr Gerald Giam.

(80)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments Thank you, Mr Speaker. Sir, the Acting Minister has responded to two of my Parliamentary Questions, so, I have several supplementary questions to ask related to them.

(81)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments Sir, the $50 PTV provides less than two weeks of travel for a family of four, and larger households will deplete it even more quickly. Even for workers and the WTCS, the PTV covers less than half a month's public transport expenses per worker. Given this, what is the rationale for setting the PTV quantum at $50 and can this be increased further?

(82)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments Second, many families have multiple family members working or schooling, and each of them may need help to cover the cost of public transport. Can the PTVs be provided on an individual basis rather than per household to help larger families that are working hard to make ends meet?

(83)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments Next, one of commuters' bugbears is that despite increases in bus fares, bus routes – especially trunk services which are popular among the elderly – continue to be rationalised. While this boosts operator profits and Government savings, it diminishes service quality for the affected commuters. Even to this day, my residents in Bedok Reservoir still complain to me about reduced bus services and request for the return of bus services 66 and 506. Will LTA continue to rationalise bus services despite this increase in bus fares?

(84)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments And lastly, the public transport fare hikes coincide with record-high COE prices and increases in fares and fees for taxis and private hire vehicles in July. Singaporeans cannot help but feel squeezed no matter which mode of transport they take. Did the PTC consider the recent increases in private transport costs when approving the public transport fare hike and its impact on Singapore's plans to become a car-lite city?

(85)

Impact of Deferring Public Transport Fare Increments Mr Speaker, I think the last question that Mr Giam asked, I already explained earlier in my response to Mr Louis Chua that the PTC is mindful of the overall higher costs of living concerns of Singaporeans, and therefore makes a judgement call not to allow the full amount but to allow only less than one third.

This is the start of the text. The rest is on the official site. Open the official text