Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 9 Nov 2022

Court of Appeal

How Weng Fan and others v Sengkang Town Council and other appeals

Feedback & support

[2022] SGCA 72Case no. In the matter of Suit Nos 668 and 716 of 2017

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Laws this judgment relies on

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. [1] These appeals raise the important question of whether a public servant exercising statutory duties under public law is also subject to duties under private law (specifically, fiduciary and equitable duties). It is alleged and was found in the court below that fiduciary and equitable duties are owed and were breached by the members (both elected and appointed) and senior employees of Aljunied-Hougang Town Council (“AHTC”) and entities associated with the latter from 2011 to 2015. Within this period, AHTC was reconstituted as Aljunied-Hougang-Punggol East Town Council (“AHPETC”) from 22 February 2013 to 30 September 2015 to include the Single Member Constituency (“SMC”) of Punggol East (“Punggol East SMC”). On 1 October 2015, AHPETC was reconstituted as AHTC while Punggol East SMC was reconstituted to come under Pasir Ris-Punggol Town Council (“PRPTC”). With effect from 1 December 2015, all the properties, assets and liabilities in respect of Punggol East SMC were transferred to PRPTC. On 28 October 2020, all the assets and liabilities of PRPTC were transferred to Sengkang Town Council (“STC”), and it is on this basis that STC replaced PRPTC as a party in these appeals. We will elaborate on these developments later.

  3. [2] Town Councils were established as a feature of local administration and housing estate management in 1989. Since then, they have come to perform an integral and essential public role for their residents. Town Councils are charged with the responsibility to control, manage, maintain and improve the common property of our public housing estates. Town Councils, being creatures of statute, are unique public bodies corporate incorporated pursuant to the Town Councils Act (Cap 329A, 2000 Rev Ed) (the “TCA”). A host of subsidiary legislation has also been enacted under the TCA, chief amongst which and relevant for present purposes is the Town Councils Financial Rules (Cap 329A, R 1, 1998 Rev Ed) (the “TCFR”). The TCA, supplemented by the TCFR, collectively provide the legislative framework for the financial management of Town Councils.

  4. [4] AG v AHPETC thus concerned the question of how a Town Council, as a public body, may be compelled by a statutory mechanism to carry out its statutory duties. However, as a Town Council is a body corporate run by individual persons, the question facing this court is whether the Town Council’s members and senior employees can be made personally liable for the Town Council’s breaches of its statutory duties under the TCA and the TCFR. This was the question that was raised before the High Court judge (the “Judge”). In Aljunied-Hougang Town Council and another v Lim Swee Lian Sylvia and others and another suit [2019] SGHC 241 (the “Judgment”), the Judge found several current and former Town Council members liable for various breaches of fiduciary duties and equitable duties of skill and care owed to AHTC between 2011 and 2015 (including when it was reconstituted as AHPETC from 22 February 2013 to 30 September 2015).

  5. [5] It is undisputed that there were a number of accounting and governance lapses, which were the focus in AG v AHPETC, constituting breaches of the TCA and the TCFR by the relevant Town Council. But the present appeals raise a distinct legal question: are the members and senior employees of a Town Council subject to fiduciary, equitable and/or tortious duties when they act on behalf of a Town Council to carry out the statutory duties that are imposed on it by the TCA and TCFR? A fiduciary obligation is an equitable and exacting duty. As a result, fiduciary duties are not readily imposed. The imposition of fiduciary duties on public officers exercising statutory duties gives rise to a range of interrelated issues, including the question of whether the Town Council’s members and senior employees are subject to any other private legal duties (such as tortious duties), and the proper interpretation and effect of a statutory immunity clause affording public officers protection from personal liability (in this case, s 52 of the TCA). This case thus presents us with the opportunity to clarify the law in this area where public and private law intersect. We will consider these issues in this judgment.

  6. [6] Given the number of issues involved in the present judgment, it is helpful to set out a table of contents for reference:

  7. The parties and persons involved

  8. The plaintiffs

  9. [8] The plaintiffs have evolved in the course of the time covered by the events leading to the Suits. It will therefore be helpful for us to trace their development.

  10. [9] On 7 May 2011, the 2011 General Elections (the “2011 GE”) took place. Prior to the 2011 GE, Aljunied Town Council (“ATC”) and Hougang Town Council (“HTC”) were managed by Town Council members from the People’s Action Party (“PAP”) and the Workers’ Party (“WP”) respectively. In the 2011 GE, candidates from the WP were elected to the electoral division of the Aljunied Group Representation Constituency (“GRC”), as well as to the Hougang SMC as Members of Parliament (“MPs”). This was the first time in Singapore’s history that a political party other than the ruling PAP had been elected as MPs for a GRC. The candidates elected were:

  11. (a) for Aljunied GRC, Mr Low Thia Khiang (“Mr Low”), Ms Sylvia Lim (“Ms Lim”), Mr Chen Show Mao (“Mr Chen”), Mr Pritam Singh (“Mr Singh”) and Mr Muhamad Faisal bin Abdul Manap (“Mr Faisal”); and

  12. (b) for Hougang SMC, Mr Yaw Shin Leong (“Mr Yaw”).

  13. [12] In this judgment, for ease of reference, we shall refer to AHTC, AHPETC, PRPTC and STC from 27 May 2011 simply as “AHTC” unless there is a reason to distinguish between any of these parties. We will refer to AHTC and PRPTC/STC collectively as the “Plaintiffs”.

  14. The defendants

  15. [13] Section 8(1) of the TCA provides that a Town Council shall consist of both elected members and appointed members. An elected member is defined under s 2(1) of the TCA as an MP for any constituency comprised within the town for which the Town Council is established; in other words, an elected MP becomes a member of the Town Council by virtue of his or her election to Parliament. One of these elected members is then appointed and designated as Chairman of the Town Council. By contrast, an appointed member is defined in s 2(1) of the TCA as a person who has been appointed by the Chairman of the Town Council. Section 8(3) of the TCA requires that each Town Council should have a minimum of six appointed members.

  16. [14] The Plaintiffs commenced the Suits against several of AHTC’s former and current Town Council members (both elected and appointed), as well as against some of its senior employees and entities associated with the latter. They were as follows:

  17. Elected members

  18. (a) Ms Lim, the first defendant in the Suits, was an elected member and was appointed Chairman from June 2011 to August 2015, and subsequently continued as Vice-Chairman from October 2015 onwards.

  19. (b) Mr Low, the second defendant in the Suits, was an elected member and was appointed as Vice-Chairman from June 2011 to July 2012.

  20. (c) Mr Singh, the third defendant in the Suits, was an elected member and was appointed as Vice-Chairman from August 2012 to August 2015. The first to third defendants were re-elected in the 2015 GE that was held on 11 September 2015, and Mr Singh subsequently took over as Chairman from October 2015 onwards.

  21. Appointed members

  22. (d) Mr Chua Zhi Hon (“Mr Chua”) and Mr Kenneth Foo Seck Guan (“Mr Foo”), the fourth and fifth defendants in the Suits respectively, were both appointed as Town Council members on 27 May 2011. Mr Chua subsequently stepped down as a Town Council member on 1 December 2016.

  23. Senior employees

  24. (e) Ms How Weng Fan (“Ms How”), the sixth defendant in the Suits, was the Deputy Secretary from 9 June 2011 to 14 July 2015, and also its General Manager from 1 August 2011 to 14 July 2015. In addition, Ms How was previously HTC’s Estate Manager, General Manager, and Secretary from 1991 to 2011. Ms How was married to Mr Danny Loh Chong Meng (“Mr Loh”). Following Mr Loh’s demise on 27 June 2015, Ms How has been the personal representative of his estate.

  25. (f) Mr Loh, the seventh defendant in the Suits, was Secretary from 1 August 2011 to 31 May 2015. Mr Loh was also the sole proprietor of FM Solutions & Integrated Services (“FMSI”), which was registered on 4 August 2004 and subsequently ceased trading on 4 August 2015.

  26. FM Solutions & Services Pte Ltd

  27. (g) FM Solutions & Services Pte Ltd (“FMSS”), the eighth defendant in the Suits, was incorporated on 15 May 2011 with Mr Loh as its sole director and shareholder. Ms How was appointed a director of FMSS on 16 June 2011. After a shareholder restructuring on 17 June 2011, Mr Loh and Ms How held 50% and 20% of the shares in FMSS respectively, while three other shareholders each held 10% of the shares in FMSS. They were Mr Yeo Soon Fei (“Mr Yeo”), Mr Vincent Koh (“Mr Koh”), and Mr Chng Jong Ling (“Mr Chng”). The shareholdings of FMSS changed over time, and by 8 May 2013, one Mr Lieow Chong Sern (“Mr Lieow”) came to hold 10% of the shares in FMSS as well. All these persons were employees in AHTC at the material time, as outlined below along with some of the aforementioned changes in shareholdings:

  28. (i) Mr Yeo was Operations Manager from 1 August 2011 to July 2012 and was Deputy General Manager thereafter until 14 July 2015.

  29. (ii) Mr Koh was Deputy General Manager from 1 August 2011 to 30 June 2012 and served in the same capacity from 4 May 2015 onwards. He also served concurrently as Secretary of AHTC from 1 June 2015 onwards. Mr Koh, however, ceased to be a shareholder of FMSS on 23 July 2012.

  30. (iii) Mr Chng was Finance Manager from 1 August 2011 to 8 December 2011. Mr Chng ceased to be a shareholder of FMSS on 21 February 2013.

  31. (iv) Mr Lieow was Property Manager from 1 August 2011 to July 2012 and thereafter served as AHTC’s Deputy General Manager up until 14 July 2015.

  32. [15] In addition, Ms Lim, Mr Singh, Mr Chua and Mr Foo were also part of the Tenders and Contracts Committee of AHTC (the “Tenders Committee”). The Tenders Committee was responsible for vetting the terms of tenders called by AHTC, evaluating any tenders received and deciding on the award of tenders. Mr Singh was the Chairman of the Tenders Committee.

  33. [16] We use the term “Town Councillors” to refer collectively to the first to fifth defendants in the Suits, meaning both the elected members (Ms Lim, Mr Low and Mr Singh) and appointed members (Mr Chua and Mr Foo) of AHTC. We shall refer to Ms How and Mr Loh collectively as the “Employees”. Where appropriate, we shall refer to the Town Councillors, the Employees and FMSS collectively as the “Defendants”.

  34. Dramatis personae

  35. [17] To summarise, the parties who were involved in this matter are as follows:

  36. (a) The plaintiff in Suit 668 and respondent in CA/CA 197/2019 (“CA 197”) and CA/CA 199/2019 (“CA 199”) is AHTC.

  37. (b) After replacing PRPTC, which was the plaintiff in Suit 716, STC is now the respondent in CA/CA 196/2019 (“CA 196”) and CA/CA 198/2019 (“CA 198”), and the appellant in CA/CA 200/2019 (“CA 200”).

  38. (c) The first to third defendants in the Suits – Ms Lim, Mr Low, and Mr Singh respectively – were the elected members of AHTC. The fourth and fifth defendants in the Suits – Mr Chua and Mr Foo – were appointed members of AHTC. The first to fifth defendants are the appellants in CA 198 and CA 199. Ms Lim and Mr Low are also the first and second respondents in CA 200.

  39. (d) The sixth and seventh defendants in the Suits – Ms How and Mr Loh – were senior employees of AHTC. As Mr Loh was deceased at the time of the commencement of the Suits, he was represented in these proceedings by his wife, Ms How, as the personal representative of his estate. The eighth defendant in the Suits is FMSS. The sixth to eighth defendants are the appellants in CA 196 and CA 197, and the sixth and seventh defendants are also the third and fourth respondents in CA 200.

  40. For ease of reference, we provide a table outlining the parties involved in the Suits below as well as respective appeals in the Annex appended at the end of this judgment.

  41. [18] We will outline the scope of the respective appeals at [109] below.

  42. The claims in the Suits

  43. [19] In this section, we set out a very brief overview of the factual background. We shall set out our detailed analysis of the correspondence and evidence later in the judgment as it becomes relevant.

  44. [20] The Plaintiffs commenced the Suits, which broadly centred on three main areas of contention:

  45. (a) The first set of claims concerns the award of four contracts for Managing Agent (“MA”) and Essential Maintenance Service Unit (“EMSU”) services to FMSS (collectively, the “Contracts”).

  46. (b) The second set of claims concerns the process by which payments were approved and made to FMSS and Mr Loh (trading as FMSI), as well as specific payments made to FMSS under the Contracts.

  47. (c) The third set of claims concerns the award of contracts to various third-party contractors.

  48. Pleadings: Duties owed

  49. [21] The Plaintiffs pleaded that the following duties were owed to AHTC.

  50. (a) The Town Councillors were fiduciaries of AHTC and each of them owed, among others, the following fiduciary duties to AHTC:

  51. (i) a duty of loyalty and fidelity;

  52. (ii) a duty to act honestly and in good faith in the best interests of AHTC and for proper purposes at all material times, and not for any personal, collateral or other improper purpose;

  53. (iii) a duty to avoid placing oneself in a position where there was a conflict, or potential conflict, between one’s loyalty and duty to AHTC, on one hand, and one’s personal interest or the interest of a third party, on the other hand;

  54. (iv) a duty to declare to AHTC if one held any office or possessed any property which placed oneself in a position of actual or potential conflict of interest between one’s duties owed to AHTC and one’s personal interests and/or duties owed to third parties;

  55. (v) a duty not to make a profit from one’s appointment other than through the legitimate emoluments payable to the Town Councillor; and

  56. (vi) the duty to diligently exercise reasonable care and skill in the exercise of their powers and in the discharge of their responsibilities.

  57. (b) AHTC pleaded that Mr Loh and Ms How were fiduciaries of AHTC as they were, respectively, the Secretary and Deputy Secretary of AHTC, and that they each owed the same fiduciary duties to AHTC as the Town Councillors (see [21(a)] above).

  58. (c) AHTC pleaded that the Town Councillors and the Employees “each owed concomitant duties of care to AHTC under the common law tort of negligence”. PRPTC pleaded that they owed “[d]uties of care and skill in tort”.

  59. (d) PRPTC also pleaded that the Town Councillors owed the following statutory duties arising from the TCA and the TCFR:

  60. (i) the duty to do all things necessary to ensure that all payments out of AHTC’s and later AHPETC’s moneys were correctly made and properly authorised and that adequate control was maintained over the assets of, or in custody of, AHTC and later AHPETC and over the expenditure incurred by AHTC and later AHPETC;

  61. (ii) the duty to look into past payments made to third parties to ascertain whether they had been properly made or were duly authorised and, if not, to take steps to recover such payments; and

  62. (iii) the duty to comply with the provisions of the TCA and TCFR.

  63. (e) AHTC pleaded that the following “expressions in the statutes set out duties and obligations consistent with those undertaken by fiduciaries”:

  64. (i) s 15 of the TCA, which obliges a Town Councillor to disclose the nature of his interest at a meeting of the Town Council;

  65. (ii) r 42 of the TCFR, which prohibits lending to “any member, officer or employee of the Town Council”; and

  66. (iii) r 74(19A) of the TCFR, which prohibits the acceptance of the non-lowest priced tender if a Town Councillor has “any interest in the supplier of the stores, services or works in respect of which the acceptance of such tender or the waiver is sought”.

  67. Claims regarding the award of the MA and the EMSU contracts

  68. The Contracts

  69. [22] MA services involve the management of a Town Council and include a wide range of services such as the supervision of contractors, responding and attending to residents’ queries and transactions, and liaising with authorities for renewal of licences. The EMSU is a 24-hour service provided by Town Councils to attend to residents’ maintenance and emergency requests.

  70. [23] The Contracts comprise two contracts for MA services and two contracts for EMSU services:

  71. (a) a contract for the provision of MA and project management services from 15 July 2011 to 14 July 2012 (the “First MA Contract”);

  72. (b) a contract for the provision of MA and project management services from 15 July 2012 to 14 July 2015 (the “Second MA Contract”);

  73. (c) a contract for the provision of EMSU services from 1 October 2011 to 30 June 2012 (the “First EMSU Contract”); and

  74. (d) a contract for the provision of EMSU services from 1 July 2012 to 30 June 2015 (the “Second EMSU Contract”).

  75. [24] In addition to the Contracts, Mr Loh, trading as FMSI, also provided EMSU services to HTC (and subsequently AHTC) under a contract that was in place from 15 October 2007 to 14 October 2014 (the “FMSI EMSU Contract”). The FMSI EMSU Contract was entered into by HTC prior to the 2011 GE, and was subsequently assigned to AHTC following the amalgamation of HTC and ATC (see [10] above). Thereafter, services were rendered pursuant to the FMSI EMSU Contract for residents of the Hougang precinct, which was under the management of AHTC.

  76. [25] Prior to the Contracts, MA and EMSU services for ATC (and briefly for AHTC after the 2011 GE) were provided by CPG Facilities Management Pte Ltd (“CPG”) and EM Services Pte Ltd (“EM Services”). The details of these contracts were as follows:

  77. (a) CPG provided MA services to ATC (or AHTC, as the case may be) under a contract dated 8 June 2010 covering the period that commenced on 1 August 2010 and that was, at the material time, due to expire on 31 July 2013, with an option exercisable at the sole discretion of AHTC to extend the contract for a further period of three years (the “CPG MA Contract”).

  78. (b) CPG also provided EMSU services to ATC (or AHTC, as the case may be), with the exception of the Kaki Bukit precinct and the estates covered by the FMSI EMSU Contract. The EMSU services for the Kaki Bukit precinct were provided by EM Services under a separate contract. Both CPG’s and EM Services’ contracts for the EMSU services were due to expire on 30 September 2011.

  79. [26] These contracts form an important backdrop to AHTC’s subsequent decision to award the contracts for the provision of MA and EMSU services to FMSS. Of particular note here is Mr Jeffrey Chua, who was CPG’s Managing Director and its key representative dealing with AHTC at the material time. Mr Jeffrey Chua had previously served as ATC’s Secretary and General Manager. After the 2011 GE, he served as AHTC’s General Manager from May 2011 to August 2011, and as AHTC’s Secretary from June 2011 to July 2011.

  80. The waiver of tender for the first contract for MA services

  81. [27] The first act sought to be impugned by the Plaintiffs concerns AHTC’s waiver of the requirement to call tenders for the first contracts for the provision of MA and EMSU services to AHTC, resulting in the award of the First MA Contract and the First EMSU Contract to FMSS. The tender for the contract for MA services was waived under the following circumstances.

  82. [28] On 9 May 2011, two days after the 2011 GE, the Ministry of National Development (“MND”) wrote to all newly elected MPs, informing them that the TCA provided that the “reconstituted Town Councils [would] assume responsibility for the new areas under their charge with effect from 1 August 2011”. For present purposes, this meant that the soon-to-be constituted, WP-led AHTC had to be operational by 1 August 2011. On the same day, Mr Low e-mailed Ms Lim, Mr Singh, Mr Faisal and Mr Chen (and copying Mr Yaw and Ms How), following a discussion they had the same morning, setting out their plans to merge HTC with ATC; to “appoint [a] managing agent to manage the town instead of self management”; and noting that Ms Lim had been chosen among the elected members to be Chairman of AHTC (the “9 May 2011 E-mail”).

  83. [29] On 13 May 2011, one “T T Tan”, who claimed to have some access to CPG’s plans with respect to the management of the reconstituted Town Council, wrote to Mr Low, conveying his belief that CPG allegedly intended to cease providing to the reconstituted Town Council the services which it had until then been providing to ATC.

  84. [30] On 15 May 2011, Mr Loh incorporated FMSS. On 27 May 2011, AHTC was gazetted (see [10] above).

  85. [31] On 30 May 2011, an informal meeting took place, at which the elected members of AHTC, Ms How, and representatives from CPG comprising Mr Jeffrey Chua, then-Secretary of ATC, his personal assistant Ms Pan Wanjing, and the Deputy General Manager of ATC, Mr Seng Joo How, were present (the “30 May 2011 Meeting”). This was a critical meeting and it is undisputed that at this meeting, the CPG representatives orally confirmed that CPG did not wish to serve as MA for AHTC and sought to be released from the CPG MA Contract. This was in advance of the contractual expiry date of 31 July 2013 under the CPG MA Contract (see [25(a)] above). The Judge found that the correspondence from 9 May 2011 to 30 May 2011 between the Town Councillors and Ms How showed that the Town Councillors had decided early on to replace CPG with FMSS as the MA for AHTC, even though CPG only formally communicated its withdrawal from the CPG MA Contract at the 30 May 2011 Meeting. We will examine the correspondence in detail below.

  86. [32] On 2 June 2011, Ms Lim, Mr Low and Mr Faisal met Mr Loh. Mr Loh made a presentation, on behalf of FMSS, relating to the provision of MA and EMSU services to AHTC.

  87. [33] The first AHTC meeting was held on 9 June 2011 (the “First Town Council Meeting”). It was attended by all the elected members of AHTC, along with Ms How, Mr Chua, Mr Foo and several representatives from CPG, including Mr Jeffrey Chua. The meeting minutes recorded the following:

  88. (a) In respect of MA services, Mr Jeffrey Chua reported that CPG would facilitate a handover by 1 August 2011 and the parties would sign a deed of mutual release and termination on the same date.

  89. (b) In respect of EMSU services, Mr Jeffrey Chua informed that CPG would provide the services for AHTC up to the end of the contract on 30 September 2011. For the Kaki Bukit precinct, EM Services would continue to provide the services until 30 September 2011.

  90. [34] On 15 June 2011, Mr Loh, in his capacity as Managing Director of FMSS, wrote to Ms Lim attaching a draft letter of intent for the appointment of FMSS as the MA for AHTC (the “LOI”). The LOI stated that:

  91. (a) FMSS would “take-over the management of the former [ATC] on 15 July 2011 at the prevailing [MA’s] fees and fees structure as per the existing [MA] contract between [ATC] and [CPG] made on 8 June 2010”.

  92. (b) FMSS would also “take-over all the existing staff of the former [HTC] at their existing salary and terms of appointment on 15 [July] 2011 for preparation of takeover”.

  93. (c) FMSS’s “scope of work for [AHTC] shall follow the specifications stipulated under the [MA’s] contract of the former [ATC]”.

  94. (d) FMSS’s “appointment shall be for a period of one year with effect from 15 July 2011 to enable the Town Council to call for a tender of the [MA] contract”.

  95. [35] The terms in the LOI broadly tracked the proposed terms that were canvassed in the course of Mr Loh’s presentation on 2 June 2011 (see [32] above). On 6 July 2011, Ms Lim e-mailed the rest of the elected members, attaching a copy of the LOI and intimating her intention to sign the same.

  96. [36] The LOI was signed on behalf of AHTC by Ms Lim on 8 July 2011 and Mr Yaw on 18 July 2011. This was the basis of the First MA Contract. On 3 August 2011, the day before the rescheduled second AHTC meeting (the “Second Town Council Meeting”), Ms Lim forwarded to Mr Low and Mr Yaw a draft report and recommendation to be presented at the meeting (the “MA Appointment Report”). The MA Appointment Report sought AHTC’s approval (a) to waive the calling of a tender for MA services from 15 July 2011 to 14 July 2012 in view of the urgent need to secure the services and the manifest necessity to do so in the public interest, and (b) to appoint FMSS as the MA for AHTC from 15 July 2011 to 14 July 2012. Ms Lim also copied Mr Loh and Ms How in that e-mail and sought their “comments on whether it will pass the auditors’ eyes – esp re waiver of tender”. Both Mr Yaw and Mr Low responded, commenting on the need to disclose the fact that Ms How and Mr Loh were married.

  97. [37] The Second Town Council Meeting was held on 4 August 2011. All the elected members, save for Mr Faisal, were present as were Mr Foo, Ms How and Mr Loh. Ms How and Mr Loh were present as representatives of FMSS. At this meeting, Mr Loh made a presentation on behalf of FMSS, as to its proposal for the provision of MA services to AHTC. After the presentation, Mr Loh and Ms How were excused from the meeting to facilitate a discussion amongst the members of AHTC. The minutes recorded the following:

  98. (a) AHTC’s members noted that CPG “had indicated their desire to be released from the agreement as soon as practicable”. They further noted that, “[g]iven the tight time frame and urgency, there was no time to call any tender for [MA] services which would take several weeks away from critical preparation time”, so that “[i]t was in the public interest that the calling of a tender be waived” [emphasis added].

  99. (b) Ms Lim had consulted the elected members and signed the LOI earlier in June 2011 “to facilitate preparation works”.

  100. (c) The “Council was then requested to waive the calling of a tender for [MA] services and to make the official appointment of [FMSS] for a one year period commencing 15 July 2011, after which a tender would be called”.

  101. (d) Ms Lim informed that she had appointed Mr Loh as Secretary of AHTC with effect from 1 August 2011 and sought AHTC’s ratification of this appointment.

  102. (e) After this discussion, Mr Loh and Ms How were invited back into the meeting and were informed of AHTC’s decision to award the First MA Contract to FMSS as well as to waive the calling of a tender for the MA services for a period of one year.

  103. (f) Mr Loh declared to the meeting that he was the Managing Director of FMSS and that Ms How was a Director/General Manager of FMSS. The meeting “noted the … declaration of interest” and “agreed to ratify the appointment of Mr Danny Loh as the Secretary”. Mr Loh thus took over this position from Mr Jeffrey Chua. Ms How, who had already been appointed as Deputy Secretary of AHTC (with effect from 8 June 2011), remained in the same appointment.

  104. [38] On 5 August 2011, AHTC released a media statement announcing the appointment of FMSS as the MA as well as AHTC’s decision to waive the tender for the initial period (the “Media Statement”). The decision not to call a tender for MA services was explained on the basis of the “urgency of the timelines …, and the overriding concern that Town Council services should not be disrupted to the detriment” of the residents [emphasis added], and that there was “insufficient time” to do so. The Media Statement also stated that “[n]o Workers’ Party member has any interest in FMSS”, and that “AHTC [did] not incur additional MA fees from appointing FMSS as FMSS has agreed to assume the scope of works and pricing of the former MA [for ATC]”.

  105. [39] On 11 August 2011, AHTC and CPG entered into a deed of mutual release with effect from 1 August 2011, which stated that “both parties [were] desirous to be released and discharged from the further performance” of the CPG MA Contract and that “they ha[d] mutually agreed to release and discharge each other” from further performance of the same [emphasis added]. At this point in time, CPG was still the contractor for the provision of EMSU services to AHTC (with the exception of the Kaki Bukit precinct (see [33(b)] above)), as the existing contract was only due to expire on 30 September 2011.

  106. The waiver of tender for the first contract for EMSU services

  107. [40] On 26 August 2011, Ms How, as General Manager of AHTC, wrote to:

  108. (a) Mr Jeffrey Chua to request an extension of CPG’s existing contract to provide EMSU services to AHTC that was set to expire on 30 September 2011 “for another 6 months for the period 1 October 2011 to 31 March 2012 on the same terms and conditions”; and

  109. (b) EM Services, the provider of EMSU services for the Kaki Bukit precinct (see [25(b)] above), seeking an extension of the contract for provision of EMSU services for the same period up to 31 March 2012. On 7 September 2011, EM Services declined the request and indicated that the contract would therefore end on 30 September 2011.

  110. [41] On 8 September 2011, the third AHTC meeting was held (the “Third Town Council Meeting”) with all the Town Councillors, except Mr Singh, present. Mr Loh and Ms How were also in attendance as representatives of FMSS, along with Mr Koh and Mr Chng. At the meeting, FMSS reported that the incumbent EMSU service providers, CPG and EM Services, had contracts that would be expiring on 30 September 2011 (see [25(b)] above). The minutes of the meeting recorded the following:

  111. (a) CPG “had indicated interest to renew for a further period of 6 months” but had yet to confirm officially “in writing on the proposed extension despite several reminders”. EM Services was not agreeable to the proposed extension.

  112. (b) The meeting noted “the lack of EMSU service providers in the market that would be willing to provide their services to [AHTC]” and that they therefore needed to consider FMSS’s proposal to also “provide the EMSU services in case [CPG] decided not to extend” [emphasis added].

  113. (c) In view of the short time frame and anticipating difficulties with securing the continuation of the incumbent EMSU service providers, the meeting thus decided to appoint a committee comprising Ms Lim, Mr Chen, Mr Faisal and Mr Anthony Teo (the “EMSU Committee”) as required under r 76(4) of the TCFR to enable AHTC to consider a proposal from FMSS.

  114. [42] On 14 September 2011, following a telephone conversation on the same morning, Mr Jeffrey Chua, in response to Ms How’s e-mail (see [40(a)] above), confirmed that CPG was not willing to extend the contract beyond its expiry on 30 September 2011. He stated in that correspondence that it would “not be appropriate for [them] to continue providing the EMSU services to your Town Council when the current extended contract ends on 30 Sept 2011” [emphasis added] and informed Ms How that AHTC “may wish to explore other avenues to render these services to [its] residents”.

  115. [43] On 16 September 2011, Ms Lim conveyed these developments to the other elected members of AHTC and stated her belief that CPG “ha[d] been ‘spoken to’ about not helping [them] and ha[d] made a business decision”. Thus, Ms Lim stated that they “must make immediate provision to have continuity of EMSU services beyond 30 Sep for all Divs in Aljunied GRC” [emphasis added].

  116. [44] The first meeting of the EMSU Committee, formed at the Third Town Council Meeting (see [41(c)] above), was held on 18 September 2011 (the “EMSU Meeting”).

  117. (a) At that meeting, the EMSU Committee compared the EMSU contracts of some of the existing providers of EMSU services in the market, which included CPG and EM Services.

  118. (b) The EMSU Committee also considered that there were some advantages in awarding the MA contract and the EMSU contract at the same time and for the same period, such as “having a clean decision and not feeling obliged to award the MA contract to the existing EMSU contractor”.

  119. (c) The EMSU Committee determined that it was necessary to come to an interim solution. It therefore recommended that the EMSU contract be awarded to FMSS for an initial period of nine months from 1 October 2011 to 30 June 2012. In the EMSU Committee’s view, tenders for the subsequent MA and EMSU contracts could then subsequently “be called at about the same time”.

  120. (d) As the existing EMSU contracts were due to expire on 30 September 2011, Ms Lim stated that it would be imperative for AHTC to “make certain decisions by email circulation now, as our next AHTC meeting is only on 13 Oct which is too late”.

  121. [45] Accordingly, Ms Lim e-mailed all the elected and appointed members of AHTC (including the Town Councillors) on the same day stating that both CPG and EM Services had confirmed that they were unwilling to extend their respective contracts for EMSU services beyond 30 September 2011. Ms Lim described CPG’s decision on 14 September 2011 to reject AHTC’s request as a “surprise” and one that was “contrary to the verbal agreement that they were willing to extend for 6 months till March 2012” (see [41(a)] above). She further stated that as EMSU was a critical service for the residents, a waiver of tender for EMSU services was required by reason of the urgency. She sought AHTC’s approval on two matters: (a) first, to waive the tender for EMSU services from 1 October 2011 to 30 June 2012; and (b) second, to award the contract for EMSU services to FMSS for the same period, following which an open tender would be called. This was unanimously approved by the Town Councillors by e-mail circulation. The First EMSU Contract was consequently awarded to FMSS.

  122. Award of the Second MA Contract and the Second EMSU Contract

  123. [46] The Second MA Contract and the Second EMSU Contract were awarded pursuant to open tenders, but the Plaintiffs nevertheless challenge the awards of these contracts arising from tenders for which FMSS was the sole bidder. The circumstances surrounding the award of these contracts were as follows.

  124. [47] Another AHTC meeting was held on 8 March 2012. By this time, FMSS’s provision of services under the First MA Contract and the First EMSU Contract was due to expire within a few months on 14 July 2012 and 30 June 2012 respectively. Open tenders for the provision of these services were to be called soon. The meeting decided to appoint a committee to vet and approve the documents for both the MA and EMSU tenders. This committee comprised the same members making up the Tenders Committee referred to above at [15] and so for ease of reference, we shall also refer to it also as the Tenders Committee.

  125. [48] The next AHTC meeting was held on 12 April 2012. The meeting noted that the Tenders Committee had since met twice and vetted the tender documents and specifications adopted by ATC previously for the appointment of MA and EMSU services. These tender documents would be used for the calling of tenders the next day. The minutes of the meeting also noted that the representatives of FMSS, including Mr Loh and Ms How, had been excused from the meeting during the deliberation on matters pertaining to the tenders. After they were invited back to the meeting, they were informed that AHTC would call for quotations to appoint a firm to audit the process of appointment of the MA.

  126. [49] On 13 April 2012, a tender notice for the provision of MA and EMSU services to AHTC, each for a term of three years, was published in The Straits Times. The notice stated that both tenders would close on 4 May 2012.

  127. [50] By the time the tenders closed on 4 May 2012, FMSS had submitted a bid for both contracts to provide MA services and EMSU services. In respect of the contract for MA services, three sets of tender documents had been collected (by FMSS, EM Services and CBM Pte Ltd) but only FMSS had submitted a tender. In respect of the contract for EMSU services, two sets of tender documents had been collected but only FMSS had submitted a tender.

  128. [51] The next AHTC meeting was held on 10 May 2012. The meeting minutes recorded that by the time of the tender deadline, FMSS had submitted the sole bid for provision of MA and EMSU services to AHTC. In addition, the minutes of the meeting recorded that the Tenders Committee had “appointed M/s RSM Ethos at [a fee of] $6,000 as the firm to audit the process of the appointment of the Managing Agent”.

  129. [52] On 19 June 2012, Ms Lim e-mailed Ms How and Mr Loh, as FMSS’s representatives, asking that they attend a meeting scheduled for 21 June 2012 with the Tenders Committee and be prepared to address questions that the Tenders Committee was likely to raise as to the difference between the pricing under the initial contracts and the pricing proposed in their tender. On the same day, Mr Loh replied to Ms Lim, revising his calculations on FMSS’s rates. The revised calculations showed FMSS’s proposed rates for 2012 to have increased from $5.96 per equivalent dwelling unit (“EDU”) in 2010 to $7.00 per EDU in 2012, representing a 17.28% increase in MA fees.

  130. [53] On 21 June 2012, the Tenders Committee convened a meeting to evaluate FMSS’s tenders for the provision of MA and EMSU services to AHTC. The Tenders Committee noted that FMSS was the sole tenderer for both sets of services:

  131. (a) In respect of the tender for MA services, the Tenders Committee observed that compared with the prices tendered in 2010 by CPG, as the former MA for ATC, the rates tendered by FMSS “represented an increase of 17.3% when averaged out over the respective 3-year contract periods” and “expressed concern about the marked increase and its impact on the AHTC”. The Tenders Committee thus asked FMSS for justification. In response, Mr Loh showed presentation slides to explain FMSS’s pricing strategy and pointed to other costs which FMSS had to bear, including (i) lift testing fees; (ii) additional number of offices requiring more administrative staff; (iii) additional staffing for technicians and the contracts department; and (iv) that as FMSS’s business was focused on town management for AHTC, it did not have the same economies of scale as others who may have several towns to manage or have other business arms. Ms How also added that provision of information technology maintenance services was done by FMSS in-house at no extra cost, which provided savings of more than $30,000 per month. Concerned about the impact of the proposed prices on AHTC’s bottom-line, and in particular whether the residents’ service and conservancy charges would have to be raised, the Tenders Committee asked for a possible three-year projection. Ms How responded that the budget for FY2012 showed a surplus of over $100,000, and that it was “not possible to accurate[ly] project for the next 3 years due to the unpredictable external environment, changing manpower policies and rising costs”. The minutes of meeting also reflected that whereas FMSS’s tender for the Second MA Contract specified project management fees at a rate of 3.5% for the first two years and 4% for the third year, Mr Loh indicated that FMSS was willing to hold the rates at 3.5% for all three years.

  132. (b) In respect of the tender for EMSU services, the Tenders Committee evaluated the price tendered, and noted that compared with the current price being paid by AHTC to FMSS for EMSU services under the First EMSU Contract, there was a proposed increase of 8.5%. The Tenders Committee asked FMSS for its justification. The minutes of meeting recorded that, in response, Mr Loh highlighted that the “price (unit rates) were fixed for the 3 year period (2012 to 2015), with no allowance for annual increases in between” and indicated that “cost and salary increases were expected, especially in the current inflationary environment … and tight manpower situation”.

  133. The Tenders Committee subsequently closed the meeting and deferred deliberations to a later date.

  134. [54] On 21 July 2012, the Tenders Committee reconvened to evaluate FMSS’s tender for the contract to provide MA services. The Tenders Committee asked FMSS to elaborate on why it was not pricing in any reduction in rate for larger projects. In response, Mr Loh stated that different companies had different pricing strategies and since FMSS focused on managing only one town, it did not enjoy the economies of scale in project management enjoyed by other companies.

  135. [55] A further AHTC meeting was held on 2 August 2012. The meeting discussed FMSS’s tenders for the contracts to provide MA and EMSU services to AHTC, at which point FMSS’s representatives left the meeting. The members of the meeting considered tender evaluation reports submitted by the Tenders Committee and accepted the Tenders Committee’s recommendations to award FMSS the Second MA Contract and the Second EMSU Contract at the tendered prices.

  136. [56] On 3 and 7 August 2012 respectively, Ms Lim sent letters of acceptance to FMSS, communicating AHTC’s acceptance of FMSS’s tender for the contract to provide MA services for the period from 15 July 2012 to 14 July 2015, and AHTC’s acceptance of FMSS’s tender for the contract to provide EMSU services for the period from 1 July 2012 to 30 June 2015. The Second MA Contract and the Second EMSU Contract were awarded to FMSS on those respective dates.

  137. The pleaded breaches

  138. [57] The Plaintiffs pleaded that the following breaches of duties occurred arising from the award of the First MA Contract and the First EMSU Contract without tender.

  139. [59] The Plaintiffs pleaded that there was no urgency to waive the tenders for the first contracts to provide MA and EMSU services, and that such waivers were not fully justified in any event. Consequently, PRPTC pleaded that the Town Councillors and Employees acted in breach of their fiduciary duties, duty of care and skill qua fiduciary, and/or their tortious duty of care and skill to AHTC, and also their duties owed under the TCA and the TCFR outlined above at [21]. AHTC made similar claims, except that, regarding the tortious duties, AHTC only made claims against Ms Lim and Mr Low – pleading that Ms Lim and Mr Low breached their duties of care to AHTC by awarding the contracts without tender.

  140. [60] As for the Second MA Contract and Second EMSU Contract, these were awarded to FMSS after a tender that was invited by AHTC on 13 April 2012, which was prior to the expiry of the First MA Contract on 14 July 2012. FMSS was the sole tenderer for both contracts. PRPTC pleaded that the Town Councillors and Employees breached the same duties outlined at [21] above by “causing and/or procuring and/or authorising and/or permitting AHTC to enter into” the Second MA Contract and Second EMSU Contract “in the circumstances set out” above where the waiver of tender for the First MA Contract and First EMSU Contract were not justified, and FMSS was the sole tenderer for both the Second MA Contract and the Second EMSU Contract. The specific reason as to why this constitutes a breach in relation to the Second MA Contract and the Second EMSU Contract is not clearly stated in PRPTC’s pleadings, though PRPTC developed this in its submissions at the trial below by submitting that the breach arose because the reasons and motives which drove the Town Councillors and the Employees to waive tenders and appoint FMSS under the First MA Contract and First EMSU Contract made FMSS’s appointment under the Second MA Contract and Second EMSU Contract a fait accompli. It was contended that because the Town Councillors and the Employees had manipulated events in 2011 to oust CPG and install FMSS, it was a foregone conclusion that no other company would take the tender for the Second MA Contract and Second EMSU Contract seriously. Although PRPTC’s case was run in this way in its closing submissions at trial, however, PRPTC’s case was not explicitly pleaded in these terms.

  141. [61] AHTC was even less precise in its pleadings regarding the breaches flowing from the Second MA Contract and the Second EMSU Contract, as AHTC did not make any distinction between the first and second MA and EMSU Contracts. Rather, AHTC pleaded that Ms Lim and Mr Low’s entry into and/or authorisation and approval of, or acquiescence in, all the MA and EMSU Contracts constituted breaches of their fiduciary duties, without specifying whether there were any differences between the contracts, despite the fact that no tenders were called for the First MA Contract and First EMSU Contract, whereas a tender was held for the Second MA Contract and the Second EMSU Contract. In any event, the Judge held that no breaches arose from the Second MA Contract and the Second EMSU Contract, and AHTC and STC have not appealed against this aspect of the Judge’s decision.

  142. [62] AHTC also pleaded that the Contracts and/or the FMSI EMSU Contract and/or the system set up by the Town Councillors and Employees (the “System”) were so tainted by conflicts of interest and/or so contrary to the best interests of AHTC as to render them incapable of approval by a Town Councillor acting consistently with his or her fiduciary obligations of loyalty and fidelity. Ms Lim’s and Mr Low’s entry into and/or authorisation and approval of, or acquiescence in, the Contracts and/or the FMSI EMSU Contract and/or the System accordingly constituted breaches of their fiduciary duties as set out above at [21].

  143. Pleaded breaches regarding improper payments made to FMSS and FMSI

  144. [63] Next, the Plaintiffs claim that there were various improper payments made to FMSS and FMSI, pursuant to the Contracts as well as the FMSI EMSU Contract. These covered four main areas, namely, (a) the “control failures” in the process that was implemented for AHTC to approve payments to FMSS and FMSI; (b) two particular invoices paid pursuant to the LOI issued to FMSS; (c) the payment of project management fees to FMSS; and (d) a series of other miscellaneous improper payments made to FMSS. Only the first and the last of these are the subject of the present appeals.

  145. [64] Regarding the “control failures” in the payment process, the essence of the Plaintiffs’ claim here concerns the System set up by the Town Councillors and Employees, under which payments to FMSS for the MA or EMSU Contracts and FMSI would be authorised or made by people in positions of conflict of interest, that is to say, persons who had an interest in FMSS but concurrently held positions in AHTC. While there was a standing instruction put in place at the Third Town Council Meeting on 8 September 2011 that required these payments to FMSS to be co-signed by the Chairman (Ms Lim) or Vice-Chairman (Mr Low or Mr Singh) of AHTC (the “Standing Instruction”), this was not a sufficient safeguard, because there was no independent verification as to whether the works had been adequately carried out prior to payment being authorised.

  146. [65] The Plaintiffs’ pleadings are not consistent on this issue, and AHTC’s pleadings at least appear to us to be narrower than PRPTC’s pleadings:

  147. (a) AHTC pleaded that, by awarding the First MA Contract and the Second MA Contract to FMSS and/or by appointing FMSS as the MA of AHTC, Ms Lim and Mr Low had “set up and/or allowed” the System, which was flawed and “which ha[d] effectively enabled [Mr] Loh and [Ms] How to be responsible for certifying work done, approving payments and/or signing cheques to FMSS/FMSI, to benefit themselves from the very same payments”.

  148. (b) AHTC pleaded that “the System is inherently flawed” and that “no Town Councillor could have reasonably approved the System, without being in breach of his or her duties”. This pleading is a general and loose statement that does not plead any specific breaches by the Town Councillors in relation to the alleged “control failures” in the System, particularly when contrasted with the next pleading by AHTC that we come to immediately below at [65(c)].

  149. (c) AHTC pleaded that Ms Lim and Mr Low’s “entry into and/or authorisation and approval of, or acquiescence in, the Contracts and/or the FMSI EMSU Contract and/or the System constituted breaches of their fiduciary duties” [emphasis added]. Ms Lim and Mr Low also breached their fiduciary duties by “[f]ailing to maintain sufficient control over the expenses and payments of AHTC” through the “control failures” in the System.

  150. (d) Critically, regarding the duties of skill and care (whether in equity or in tort), AHTC only pleaded that the Employees “breached their duty of care and skill qua fiduciary and/or duty of care and skill in tort to AHTC” by causing AHTC to make payments to FMSS under the flawed System, in the circumstances set out at [418]–[426416] below; and/or by failing to disclose to AHTC and/or rectify the flaws in the System and/or the aforementioned breaches of duties. This pleading was a new pleading introduced by an amendment application by AHTC post-trial, HC/SUM 2050/2020 (“SUM 2050”), that was allowed by the Judge (see [110104(b)] below). However, AHTC did not explicitly plead that the Town Councillors breached any tortious duties in relation to the “control failures” that allegedly permeated the System. The Judge similarly observed in his oral judgment in SUM 2050 (the “Oral Judgment”) that AHTC did not plead that Mr Singh, Mr Chua and Mr Foo were involved in setting up the System:

  151. [66] We agree with the Judge that AHTC did plead that Ms Lim and Mr Low were involved in setting up the System, as highlighted above at [65(a)]. But, there is also no explicit pleading that Ms Lim and Mr Low committed any breaches of tortious duties by implementing the System. As for the pleading above at [65(b)] that “no Town Councillor could have reasonably approved the System, without being in breach of his or her duties” (which, as we have noted, only makes a loose and general reference to “Town Councillor”), the fact is that AHTC did not even plead that three of the five Town Councillors – Mr Singh, Mr Chua and Mr Foo – were involved in the setting up of the System. This seems to us to bolster the conclusion that this pleading is a general statement, rather than a statement meant to plead that all the Town Councillors breached their duties by instituting the System. On the whole, as it stands, it seems to us that AHTC did not plead that the Town Councillors breached any tortious duties in relation to the “control failures” in the System. We will return to this point below at [455445].

  152. [67] PRPTC pleaded that all the Town Councillors and Employees committed breaches in relation to the “control failures” in the System. Specifically, PRPTC pleaded that the Town Councillors and Employees breached their duties owed to AHTC between 15 July 2011 and 24 January 2013 by causing AHTC to pay a total of $2,689,434.15 to FMSS pursuant to the Contracts “in circumstances where there was no meaningful oversight by AHTC over those payments and/or where AHTC’s funds were exposed to risks of erroneous and/or improper and/or unauthorised payments to FMSS and/or the risk of misappropriation”.

  153. [68] AHTC also pleaded that Ms Lim and Mr Low further breached their fiduciary duties by waiving the need to get quotations for certain transactions without obtaining the necessary authorisation of the AHTC Chairman; approving and/or acquiescing in the award of contracts pursuant to quotations/tenders which were not the lowest quotations/tenders received, without proper justification and/or evaluation; and failing to maintain sufficient control over the expenses and payments of AHTC.

  154. [69] In addition, AHTC pleaded that Ms Lim was an authorised cheque signatory under r 33 of the TCFR for the duration of her appointment as Chairman of AHTC. AHTC pleaded that Ms Lim “breached her duty of care and skill qua fiduciary and/or duty of care and skill in tort to AHTC by failing to conduct proper checks before signing off on cheques in favour of FMSS”.

  155. [70] It is evident that the foregoing alleged breach stems from AHTC’s duty under s 35(c) of the then-TCA (which has since been amended by the Town Councils (Amendment) Act 2017 (Act 17 of 2017) with effect from 1 May 2017 and has become ss 35(2)(c) and 35(2)(d) of the TCA which are in largely similar terms), though the sub-section was neither pleaded nor cited by the Plaintiffs. At the material time, s 35(c) provided:

  156. [71] Furthermore, under the TCFR, Heads of Department are responsible for the accuracy of vouchers rendered by them or under their authority (r 54); they are to certify that the vouchers are accurate (r 56(3)) and that the services specified therein have been duly performed (r 56(4)(a)); and there must also be a certification on the voucher that the payments are in accordance with the terms of the agreement and that the work was properly done (r 61(1)).

  157. Claims regarding the award of miscellaneous contracts to third-party contractors

  158. [72] Through the Tenders Committee, several contracts were awarded to third-party contractors. These acts were challenged by the Plaintiffs on the basis that the contracts were awarded at prices significantly higher than those offered by existing contactors or by other contractors who submitted lower bids. We highlight only the third-party contractors that are relevant to these appeals. These contractors were: (a) LST Architects; (b) Red-Power Electrical Engineering Pte Ltd (“Red-Power”); and (c) Titan Facilities Management Pte Ltd (“Titan”) and J Keart Alliances Pte Ltd (“J Keart”), the last two of which we deal with together. We summarise the circumstances leading up to the appointments of these third-party contractors below. We note, however, that it is not suggested that there was any relationship between any of the Defendants on the one hand, and any of these third-party contractors on the other.

  159. LST Architects

  160. [73] On 31 August 2012, AHTC invited tenders for the appointment of architectural consultants to a panel of consultants (the “Panel of Consultants”). The appointment was to be for a period of three years, for the provision of consultancy services at pre-agreed rates that would be based on the value of the awarded project. AHTC received tenders from LST Architects and Design Metabolists. The tender evaluation report recorded that, for projects valued between $0.5m and $3.66m, LST Architects’ prices were lower, whereas Design Metabolists’ prices were lower for projects under $0.5m or above $3.66m.

  161. [74] On 20 September 2012, a Property Officer of AHTC gave LST Architects and Design Metabolists a performance assessment score of 42 and 41 respectively, suggesting that they were broadly even in terms of performance.

  162. [75] On 7 November 2012, the Tenders Committee decided that both tenderers, LST Architects and Design Metabolists, be appointed to the Panel of Consultants. LST Architects and Design Metabolists subsequently entered into agreements with AHTC for the contract period 1 December 2012 to 30 November 2015.

  163. Red-Power

  164. [76] Sometime in April 2012, AHTC called for a tender for the maintenance of transfer and booster pumps, automatic refuse chute flushing system and roller shutters. At the material time, AHTC had existing contracts with Digo Corporation Pte Ltd (“Digo”) and Terminal 9 Pte Ltd (“Terminal 9”) for the provision of such services. These were due to expire soon, though they were extendable at AHTC’s option for a maximum of one and two years respectively, at the same rates.

  165. [77] On 11 June 2012, AHTC awarded a term contract for the maintenance of transfer and booster pumps, automatic refuse chute flushing system and roller shutters to Red-Power for a period of three years.

  166. [78] In addition, Punggol East SMC had a separate contract with EM Services for the same services, which contract could not be extended after its expiry on 31 March 2015. When this expired, AHTC (by then constituted as AHPETC) had in place the contract with Red-Power mentioned in the preceding paragraph, as well as a separate contract with Tong Lee Engineering Works Pte Ltd (“Tong Lee”) which covered different precincts of AHTC. It would appear that Tong Lee was not obliged to extend their coverage to include Punggol-East.

  167. [79] On 12 December 2014, AHTC sent a letter to Red-Power to confirm that Punggol East would be added to AHTC’s existing term contract with Red-Power at the same rates, terms and conditions, with effect from 1 April 2015.

  168. Titan and J Keart

  169. [80] In addition, AHTC had contracts for conservancy and cleaning works with Titan and for the servicing and maintenance of fire protection systems with J Keart. Both these contracts were scheduled to expire on 31 March 2015, and contained an option, at AHTC’s discretion, to extend them for a further 12 months on the same terms and rates. Instead, AHTC decided to call for fresh tenders for the provision of conservancy and cleaning works, and for the servicing and maintenance of fire protection systems.

  170. [81] AHTC received three bids for the provision of conservancy and cleaning works, and a new contract for these works was awarded to the lowest bidder, Titan, for the period 1 April 2015 to 31 March 2018. Similarly, three bids were received for the maintenance of fire protection systems, and a new contract was awarded to the lowest bidder, J Keart, for a period of three years. In other words, new contracts for the same services were awarded to the existing contractors despite the possibility of the existing contracts being extended. It was not disputed that the new contracts entered into with Titan and J Keart were at higher rates than the existing contracts with the same contractors, which could have been extended for a further year. The Plaintiffs challenge the propriety of awarding these new contracts to Titan and J Keart instead of extending the existing contracts at lower rates for at least a year.

  171. Pleaded breaches

  172. [82] All the foregoing tenders were called pursuant to r 74(1) of the TCFR (see [58] above). PRPTC highlighted in their pleadings that r 74(13) of the TCFR provides that:

  173. [83] PRPTC further pleaded that r 74(15) of the TCFR provides that “[t]he Town Council or the chairman, within the financial limit authorised by the Town Council, may for reasons to be disclosed with the acceptance, accept a tender which is not the lowest tender”, and r 74(16) provides that “[t]he circumstances and reasons for not accepting the lowest tender which meets the specifications fully or very substantially must be fully justified and shall be recorded and open to scrutiny by the auditor”.

  174. [84] AHTC pleaded that it had breached r 74(1)) of the TCFR for ten construction projects by failing to invite a tender in respect of each project and/or by failing to accept the lowest tender for each project. AHTC also pleaded that it had breached rr 74(15) and 74(16) of the TCFR when it appointed LST Architects and Design Metabolists to the Panel of Consultants and by awarding contracts for ten projects to LST Architects without calling for a separate tender for each project; and, in respect of seven out of the ten construction projects, awarding the contracts to LST Architects despite Design Metabolists being the lower-priced contractor. Critically, AHTC pleaded that Ms Lim, Mr Singh, Mr Chua and Mr Foo, who were members of the Tenders Committee, breached their duty of care and skill qua fiduciary and/or duty of care and skill in tort to AHTC by causing AHTC to commit the foregoing acts and breaches.

  175. [85] Separately, on the basis of the duties under the TCFR as just highlighted above at [82]-[83], PRPTC pleaded that the Town Councillors and Employees breached their duties owed to AHTC by:

  176. (a) causing AHTC to award a contract for the provision of various maintenance services to Red-Power for the period from 1 July 2012 to 30 June 2015 (see [477465] below);

  177. (b) causing AHTC to award seven projects to LST Architects instead of Design Metabolists in or around 2012, which caused AHTC to pay $2,794,560 in excess fees, in breach of rr 74(13), 74(15) and 74(16) of the TCFR (see [469458] below); and

  178. (c) causing AHTC to award contracts to LST Architects, Red-Power, Titan and J Keart – after various contracts for maintenance services with EM Services, Clean Solutions Pte Ltd, Titan and J Keart expired on 31 March 2015 – without inviting new tenders or exercising options to extend the existing contracts that would have been cheaper.

  179. Summary of claims

  180. [86] As Town Councils are creatures of statute, it is important to correctly situate the statutory context and powers relevant to the impugned acts. The claims brought against the Town Councillors and the Employees as just outlined, and the respective duties under the TCA and the TCFR which they stem from or concern, can be summarised as follows:

  181. The Auditor-General’s Report

  182. [87] On 10 February 2014, AHPETC submitted to Parliament its audited financial statements for the financial year ending 31 March 2013. On 13 February 2014, the auditing firm engaged by AHPETC, Foo Kon Tan Grant Thornton LLP, submitted an auditor’s report dated 4 February 2014 to the Auditor-General. The report contained a disclaimer of opinion stating that the auditors were “not able to obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence to provide a basis for an audit opinion”, and consequently that they “[did] not express an opinion on the Statement of Financial Position of [AHPETC] as at 31 March 2013 and the income and expenditure statement, statement of comprehensive income, statement of changes in funds and statement of cash flows for the year then ended”. This disclaimer of opinion was based on 13 grounds of concern, which included non-compliance with the TCFR provisions governing the transfer of sinking funds, as well as the lack of details supporting project management service fees paid to a party related to AHTC.

  183. [88] On 19 February 2014, the Deputy Prime Minister, upon the request of the Minister for National Development, exercised his powers under s 4(4) of the Audit Act (Cap 17, 1999 Rev Ed) (the “Audit Act”) and directed the Auditor-General to undertake an audit of AHPETC’s financial statements and to examine, among other things, whether all reasonable steps had been taken by AHPETC to ensure compliance with provisions of written law relating to the collection, custody and payment of AHPETC’s moneys. The Auditor-General in turn appointed PricewaterhouseCoopers Consulting Pte Ltd (“PwC”) to undertake an audit of selected aspects of AHPETC’s financial statements. PwC acted on behalf of and under the authority of the Auditor-General in this regard.

  184. [89] Just under a year later, on 6 February 2015, the Auditor-General’s Office (“AGO”) issued its final report, which incorporated PwC’s findings (the “AGO Report”). The AGO Report found that “AHPETC had several lapses in governance and compliance with the [TCA] and [TCFR]” and that “[u]nless the weaknesses are addressed, there can be no assurance that AHPETC’s financial statements are accurate and reliable and that public funds are properly spent, accounted for and managed”. In all, it identified at least 115 areas of non-compliance and areas in which AHPETC was potentially not compliant with s 35(c) of the then-TCA, which required a Town Council to do all things necessary to ensure that any payment out of its moneys was correctly made and properly authorised and that adequate control was maintained over the assets belonging to, or in the custody of, the Town Council and over the expenditure incurred by the Town Council. In particular, the AGO Report identified the major lapses to include the following:

  185. (a) AHPETC’s failure to make quarterly sinking fund transfers within the specified timeframe in accordance with r 4(2B) of the TCFR;

  186. (b) inadequate oversight of related party transactions involving ownership interests of key officers;

  187. (c) a lack of a system to monitor arrears of conservancy and service charges accurately;

  188. (d) poor internal controls that would risk the loss of valuables, incurring unnecessary expenditure and the making of payments wrongly for goods and services; and

  189. (e) the absence of any proper system to ensure that documents were safeguarded and proper accounts and records were kept as required under the TCA.

  190. AG v AHPETC

  191. [90] On 20 March 2015, the MND commenced HC/OS 250/2015 (“OS 250”) against AHPETC seeking, among other things, declaratory relief and remedies in respect of the accounting and governance lapses in the running of AHPETC, including the appointment of independent accountants to establish the extent of non-compliance and to oversee remedial measures. On 27 May 2015, the High Court dismissed OS 250 and the MND appealed. Before the appeal was heard, the HDB applied to be joined as a party to the proceedings. The question was which, if any, party (whether the HDB or the MND) had standing to make an application under s 21(2) of the TCA seeking to compel AHPETC’s performance of its duties and obligations under the TCA and the TCFR. Such a course was necessitated by the various lapses in its governance and potential breaches under s 35(c) of the TCA that had been uncovered in the AGO Report.

  192. [91] On 27 November 2015, this court delivered its judgment in AG v AHPETC, allowing the appeal in part. This was the precursor to the Suits below. We allowed the HDB’s application to be joined as a party to the proceedings and found that only the HDB had the requisite standing, under s 21(2) of the TCA, to seek relief. On the appropriate remedies to be granted, we held that while the court was empowered to make orders that were effective to compel AHPETC to perform the duties in question that had been breached, it was not for the court to step into the shoes of AHPETC or to substitute its own decisions for those of AHPETC as to how the various requirements and duties were to be carried out. In the circumstances, we made the following orders (AG v AHPETC at [131]):

  193. The KPMG Reports

The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.