General Division of the High Court · Decided 20 June 2023
Haw Wan Sin David and another v Kwek Siang Ling Wendy and others
Feedback & support[2023] SGHC 171 · Case no. Suit No 867 of 2018
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Laws this judgment relies on
Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [1]
[1] The Plaintiffs in this suit are property investors who signed two sale and purchase agreements (the “two SPAs”) with Eco House Brazil Construcoes Ltda (“Ecohouse Brazil”), a company incorporated in Brazil. The Plaintiffs made two separate payments totalling S$598,000 under the terms of the two SPAs. The two SPAs stated that, upon completion, Ecohouse Brazil would sell and the Plaintiffs would buy various residential freehold units in two different residential developments in Brazil. The two SPAs also stated that Ecohouse Brazil would undertake to procure buyers for the Plaintiffs’ residential freehold units within 12 months from the date of the signing of the two SPAs. Further, the Plaintiffs would earn a 20% return of the purchase price within 14 days of the 12-month anniversary of the date of the two SPAs. The two payments totalling S$598,000 were made by the Plaintiffs in Singapore into an escrow account of a law firm in the United Kingdom (“UK”) following the signing of the two SPAs.
- [2]
[2] Towards the 12-month anniversary of the date of the two SPAs, it became apparent that Ecohouse Brazil was unable to meet its contractual obligations under the two SPAs. Ecohouse Brazil persuaded the Plaintiffs to sign two deeds of modification granting a 12-month extension to Ecohouse Brazil upon which an additional payment of 20% of the capital investment would be made to the Plaintiffs, ie, a sum totalling S$119,600. However, Ecohouse Brazil ultimately failed to deliver the residential freehold units as contracted in the two SPAs. Ecohouse Brazil also failed to deliver the 20% return of the purchase price to the Plaintiffs as contracted in the two SPAs. The Plaintiffs claim that the investments were fraudulent and Ecohouse Brazil did not, at any time, intend to honour its obligations under the two SPAs.
- [3]
[3] The Plaintiffs now seek to claim from the First to Sixth Defendants (collectively referred to as the “Defendants”) for the losses which they had incurred. The thrust of the Plaintiffs’ claim against the Defendants lies against the First Defendant who had introduced the Ecohouse Brazil developments to the Plaintiffs at two separate presentations conducted by the First Defendant and a Brazilian director of Ecohouse Brazil. Subsequently, the First Defendant sent emails to the Second Plaintiff and the other investors on the Ecohouse Brazil developments. The Plaintiffs claim that various representations were made by the First and Second Defendants, namely that the Ecohouse Brazil developments were backed and supported by the Brazilian government, that extensive and comprehensive due diligence had been done by the First and Second Defendants, that the moneys of the Plaintiffs would be kept safe in an escrow account and that the Plaintiffs would earn the promised 20% return. The Plaintiffs allege that these representations made by the First and Second Defendants were false at the time they were made. Accordingly, the Plaintiffs pursue various heads of claims against the Defendants, namely fraudulent misrepresentation, misrepresentation under the Misrepresentation Act (Cap 390, 1994 Rev Ed) (the “MRA”), negligent misrepresentation, breaches of collateral contracts, loss of opportunity, constructive trusts and losses arising from the breach of duties under the Estate Agents Act (Cap 95A, 2011 Rev Ed) (the “Estate Agents Act”).
- [4]
[4] In defence, the Defendants deny making such representations to the Plaintiffs. Further, the Defendants allege that the representations were not false. They claim that they had paid a six-figure sum to engage a Singapore lawyer to conduct due diligence on the Ecohouse Brazil developments. The First and Second Defendants also state that they had bought nine residential freehold units in the Casa Nova Project, which was one of the Ecohouse Brazil developments. Similarly, they had signed a sale and purchase agreement with Ecohouse Brazil and had also suffered losses as a result. Therefore, they deny that they should be held liable for the losses suffered by the Plaintiffs.
Background facts
The parties
- [5]
[5] The First Plaintiff is Haw Wan Sin David (“David”). The Second Plaintiff is David’s wife, Yee Ai Moi Cindy (“Cindy”).
- [6]
[6] The First Defendant is Kwek Siang Ling Wendy (“Wendy”). The Second Defendant is Poh Wei Leong (“Joey”). At the material time, Wendy and Joey were married to each other. They were, however, divorced on 24 August 2018.
- [7]
[7] The Third Defendant is WK Events Pte Ltd (“WK Events”), an exempt private company which was incorporated in Singapore on 1 June 2012. At the material time, Wendy was a director and shareholder of WK Events, and Joey was a shareholder of WK Events. Joey was also a director of WK Events until around 2016. WK Events was struck off the Register of Companies (the “Register”) on 4 May 2020.
- [8]
[8] The Fourth Defendant is WK Investment Network Pte Ltd (“WKIN”), an exempt private company which was incorporated in Singapore on 27 February 2012. At the material time, Wendy was a director and shareholder of WKIN, and Joey was a shareholder of WKIN. Joey was also a director of WKIN until around 2016.
- [9]
[9] The Fifth Defendant is Ecohouse Developments Asia Pacific Pte Ltd (“Ecohouse Asia Pacific”), a private company which was incorporated in Singapore on 27 July 2012. Ecohouse Asia Pacific was a joint venture (“JV”) set up by Ecohouse Singapore Pte Ltd (“Ecohouse Singapore”), which was incorporated for the purpose of the JV, and Ecohouse Brazil. At the material time, Joey was the managing director of Ecohouse Asia Pacific. The other director of Ecohouse Asia Pacific was Charles Valentine Fraser-Macnamara (“Charles”). Charles was the nominee of Anthony Jon Domingo Armstrong-Emery (“Anthony”). Anthony was a director of Ecohouse Brazil.
- [10]
[10] Charles was a solicitor in the UK at the material time. He was subsequently struck off the roll in the UK following a disciplinary tribunal’s decision on his conduct in relation to the Ecohouse Brazil developments. The shareholders of Ecohouse Asia Pacific were Charles and Ecohouse Singapore. Ecohouse Asia Pacific was struck off the Register on 23 September 2020.
- [11]
[11] The Sixth Defendant is Ecohouse Singapore, an exempt private company which was incorporated in Singapore on 26 July 2012 (see [9] above). At the material time, Joey was the sole director and shareholder of Ecohouse Singapore. Ecohouse Singapore was struck off the Register on 23 September 2020.
- [12]
[12] For completeness, there was a Seventh Defendant, Ecohouse Developments Ltd (“Ecohouse UK”), a private limited company which was incorporated on 28 May 2010 in the UK. Ecohouse UK went into liquidation on 15 January 2015 and was dissolved on or about 14 February 2018. The Plaintiffs did not serve the writ on Ecohouse UK. The Plaintiffs wholly discontinued the action against Ecohouse UK on 8 May 2019. This judgment, therefore, only focuses on the Plaintiffs’ case against the Defendants.
Wendy’s property investment programmes and the incorporation of WKIN and WK Events
- [13]
[13] Wendy was a property investor and she organised seminars where speakers would give talks on property investment. From 2009, Wendy conducted property investment seminars under the auspices of a company called Executive Directions Pte Ltd (“Executive Directions”). Wendy was a director of Executive Directions together with one Jerome Tan (“Jerome”).
- [14]
[14] Later, the relationship between Wendy and Jerome soured. Wendy left Executive Directions and incorporated WKIN with Joey in February 2012. Wendy then purportedly received advice from a mentor that she should not use the words “Investment Network” in her company name because it would attract unnecessary scrutiny from government agencies since the intention for the company was to organise talks and events. Therefore, she incorporated WK Events in June 2012.
- [15]
[15] WK Events was, thereafter, used to organise seminars conducted by Wendy. At these seminars, Wendy would share her experiences on investing in properties, including properties outside of Singapore.
The WK Investment Network Yahoo Group
- [16]
[16] When Wendy left Executive Directions and started her own companies, namely WK Events and WKIN, Wendy also created a WK Investment Network group which was hosted on the Yahoo platform (the “WK Investment Network Yahoo Group”). The participants of Wendy’s property investment seminars, including past participants of seminars conducted under the auspices of Executive Directions, were invited to the WK Investment Network Yahoo Group.
- [17]
[17] According to Wendy, the WK Investment Network Yahoo Group was set up for sharing information and networking purposes. Further, according to Wendy, anyone in the WK Investment Network Yahoo Group could share property investment opportunities and could also invite members of the group to events or provide market updates.
How the Plaintiffs became acquainted with Wendy
- [18]
[18] Sometime in October 2011, Cindy came across an advertisement offering a free one-hour seminar on property investment conducted by Wendy under the auspices of Executive Directions. Cindy subsequently attended the seminar in or around October 2011.
- [19]
[19] Thereafter, Cindy signed up for a paid two-day training event conducted by Wendy under the auspices of Executive Directions. Cindy paid S$2,995 to Executive Directions and attended the two-day training event sometime in November 2011.
- [20]
[20] Subsequently, from June 2012 onwards, after Wendy left Executive Directions, she conducted seminars organised by WKIN or WK Events. It is undisputed that Cindy was also a member of the WK Investment Network Yahoo Group.
The Plaintiffs’ investment in a property venture in Berlin, Germany which was introduced by Wendy in April 2012
- [21]
[21] On 10 April 2012, Wendy extended an invitation to various individuals, including Cindy, to attend a presentation on an investment opportunity for a project to refurbish and convert historical buildings in Berlin, Germany into residential properties (the “Berlin Project”).
- [22]
[22] Subsequently, Cindy attended a presentation on the Berlin Project conducted by Wendy. At the presentation, Wendy stated that she had secured an opportunity and structured the investment so that investors could invest a minimum of S$10,000 with a 12% return to be earned within 12 months.
- [23]
[23] Following Wendy’s presentation, the Plaintiffs invested a sum of S$300,000. The Plaintiffs received their principal sum and the 12% return when the amounts were due.
The Plaintiffs’ investment in the Casa Nova property development project in Brazil
- [24]
[24] On 12 July 2012, Wendy extended an invitation to various individuals, including Cindy, to attend a presentation on an investment opportunity for a purported social housing project called “Casa Nova Residencial” in Brazil (the “Casa Nova Project”). The developer of the Casa Nova Project was Ecohouse Brazil.
- [25]
[25] On or about 30 July 2012, the Plaintiffs attended a presentation of the Casa Nova Project (the “30 July 2012 Presentation”) conducted by Wendy. The Casa Nova Project was marketed as a project by Ecohouse Brazil under the Brazilian government’s social housing programme, “Minha Casa, Minha Vida” (“MCMV”), which means “my house, my life”.
- [26]
[26] Following the 30 July 2012 Presentation, Wendy sent an email on 7 August 2012 to the investors, including Cindy (the “7 August 2012 email”). The heading of the email was “IMPORTANT INFO: - CasaNova Residencial – Presentation slides attached”. PowerPoint presentation slides on the Casa Nova Project (the “Casa Nova Presentation Slides”) were attached to the 7 August 2012 email.
- [27]
[27] On 13 August 2012, Wendy sent another email to the investors, including Cindy (the “13 August 2012 email”). The heading of the email was “FW: Pls read – Clarification on ‘investing in far away places’”.
- [28]
[28] On 1 September 2012, the Plaintiffs entered into a sale and purchase agreement with Ecohouse Brazil in respect of the Casa Nova Project (the “Casa Nova SPA”) for the purchase of five residential units. Under the terms of the Casa Nova SPA, the purchase price was to be paid to Sanders & Co, a law firm in the UK which was the appointed escrow agent. The Plaintiffs paid a sum of S$230,000 by way of a cheque for the purchase of five residential units. The Plaintiffs also signed an escrow agreement with Sanders & Co and Ecohouse Brazil dated 1 September 2012 (the “Casa Nova Escrow Agreement”).
- [29]
[29] Under the terms of the Casa Nova SPA, Ecohouse Brazil agreed to sell and the Plaintiffs agreed to buy five residential freehold units in the Casa Nova Project in Brazil. The Casa Nova SPA also stated that Ecohouse Brazil undertook to procure buyers for the Plaintiffs’ units within 12 months from the signing of the Casa Nova SPA. The Plaintiffs would receive a 20% return of the purchase price within 14 days of the 12-month anniversary of the date of the Casa Nova SPA, ie, S$46,000.
- [30]
[30] The Plaintiffs subsequently received a document titled “Declaracao” dated 18 September 2012 setting out the lot numbers of the residential units in the Casa Nova Project which were purchased by the Plaintiffs.
The Plaintiffs’ investment in the Bosque property development project in Brazil
- [31]
[31] On 3 October 2012, Wendy sent an email to the investors, including Cindy (the “3 October 2012 email”). The heading of the email was “Wendy Kwek - 20percent Assured Returns plus PROFIT BONUS! - Ecohouse Developments”. In the email, Wendy extended an invitation to various individuals, including Cindy, to attend a presentation on an investment opportunity for a second purported social housing project called “Residencial Bosque” in Brazil (the “Bosque Project”). The developer of the Bosque Project was also Ecohouse Brazil.
- [32]
[32] On or about 6 October 2012, Cindy attended a presentation of the Bosque Project (the “6 October 2012 Presentation”) conducted by Wendy. The Bosque Project was another residential project carried out by Ecohouse Brazil under the Brazilian government’s social housing programme, MCMV.
- [33]
[33] On 3 December 2012, the Plaintiffs entered into a sale and purchase agreement with Ecohouse Brazil in respect of the Bosque Project (the “Bosque SPA”) for the purchase of eight residential units. Under the terms of the Bosque SPA, the purchase price was paid to Sanders & Co, the appointed escrow agent. The Plaintiffs paid a sum of S$368,000 by way of a cheque for the eight residential units. Similarly, the Plaintiffs also signed an escrow agreement with Sanders & Co and Ecohouse Brazil dated 3 December 2012 (the “Bosque Escrow Agreement”).
- [34]
[34] Under the terms of the Bosque SPA, Ecohouse Brazil agreed to sell and the Plaintiffs agreed to buy eight residential freehold units in the Bosque Project in Brazil. The Bosque SPA also stated that Ecohouse Brazil undertook to procure buyers for the Plaintiffs’ units within 12 months from the signing of the Bosque SPA. The Plaintiffs would receive a 20% return of the purchase price within 14 days of the 12-month anniversary of the date of the Bosque SPA, ie, S$73,600.
- [35]
[35] The Plaintiffs subsequently received a document titled “Declaracao” simply dated 2012 setting out the lot numbers of the residential units in the Bosque Project which were purchased by the Plaintiffs.
The deeds of modification signed by the Plaintiffs
- [36]
[36] Sometime from 16 August 2013 onwards, the Plaintiffs received various emails informing them of delays in the construction of the two developments, namely the Casa Nova Project and the Bosque Project. The Plaintiffs were thereafter offered various options, including an option to sign the deeds of modification granting Ecohouse Brazil a 12-month extension to fulfil its contractual obligations under the Casa Nova SPA and the Bosque SPA. In consideration for granting Ecohouse Brazil a 12-month extension, the Plaintiffs were offered an additional interest amounting to 20% of the purchase price which was paid by the Plaintiffs when they signed the Casa Nova SPA and the Bosque SPA. This additional interest was to be paid within 14 days of the execution of the deeds.
- [37]
[37] On or around 6 November 2013, the Plaintiffs signed two deeds of modification (the “Deeds of Modification”) with Ecohouse Brazil for the Casa Nova Project and the Bosque Project. Under the terms of the Deeds of Modification, the Plaintiffs agreed to extend the agreement period of the Casa Nova SPA and the Bosque SPA by 12 months. The Plaintiffs received the additional interest amounting to 20% of the purchase price, ie, a sum totalling S$119,600 comprising S$46,000 (for the Casa Nova Project) and S$73,600 (for the Bosque Project), after signing the Deeds of Modification.
Ecohouse Brazil ultimately failed to fulfil its contractual obligations
- [38]
[38] Ecohouse Brazil ultimately failed to fulfil its contractual obligations under the Casa Nova SPA and the Bosque SPA despite the 12-month extension granted to Ecohouse Brazil under the Deeds of Modification.
- [39]
[39] Thereafter, the Plaintiffs and the other investors who had purchased units in the Casa Nova Project and the Bosque Project from Ecohouse Brazil engaged lawyers in Singapore to consider pursuing a claim against Sanders & Co in the UK. However, this was abandoned as the Plaintiffs and the other investors were unable to secure third-party financing for the purposes of a claim against Sanders & Co.
- [40]
[40] The Plaintiffs, thereafter, engaged a property lawyer in Brazil, one Fernando Guo Tao (“Fernando”), to purportedly review the Casa Nova SPA and the Bosque SPA and to provide his legal opinion. A legal opinion was rendered by Fernando dated 12 December 2015 (“Fernando’s 12 December 2015 Legal Opinion”), with a translation of this opinion thereafter obtained.
The relationship between Ecohouse Asia Pacific, Ecohouse Singapore, Ecohouse UK and Ecohouse Brazil
- [41]
[41] I pause here to explain the relationship between the various entities bearing the name “Ecohouse”. Ecohouse Brazil and Ecohouse UK were both entities under the larger Ecohouse Group controlled by Anthony. Ecohouse Brazil was responsible for the construction of the Casa Nova Project and the Bosque Project. Ecohouse UK was responsible for the marketing of the Casa Nova Project and the Bosque Project. As will be seen from the documentary evidence raised during the trial, however, the various entities bearing the name “Ecohouse” were often simply referred to as “Ecohouse Developments”. In much of the documentary evidence, the term “Ecohouse Developments” was used when referring to the developer of the Casa Nova Project and the Bosque Project, ie, Ecohouse Brazil.
(a) Charles, who was Anthony’s appointed nominee; and
(b) Ecohouse Singapore, which was an exempt private company incorporated by Joey to participate in the JV, ie, Ecohouse Asia Pacific.
- [43]
[43] Under the terms of the JV marketing and sales agreement for Ecohouse Asia Pacific dated 1 August 2012 (the “JV Agreement”), Wendy was listed as a trainer for Ecohouse Asia Pacific.
- [44]
[44] A diagram summarising the relationship between the various entities bearing the “Ecohouse” name and the key persons involved in each entity was prepared jointly by the parties and is annexed to this judgment.
The parties’ cases
The Plaintiffs’ case
- [45]
[45] The Plaintiffs claim against the Defendants for the amounts of S$598,000 and S$119,600, being the respective amounts paid under the Casa Nova SPA and the Bosque SPA for the purchase of residential units in the Casa Nova Project and the Bosque Project as well as the 20% return of the investments they were meant to receive under the Casa Nova SPA and the Bosque SPA. The Plaintiffs also claim interest at the rate of 10% per annum. Further, the Plaintiffs seek damages as well as orders in relation to their various claims.
- [46]
[46] The Plaintiffs make various heads of claims against the Defendants. I shall briefly summarise each of these in turn.
Misrepresentation
- [47]
[47] The Plaintiffs claim that Wendy made four representations (collectively referred to as the “Four Representations”) in relation to the Casa Nova Project which were untrue:
(a) The first representation was that the Casa Nova Project was a safe investment as it was approved and supported by the Brazilian government as a social housing development (the “Brazilian Government Representation”).
(b) The second representation was that the moneys invested by the Plaintiffs in the Casa Nova Project would be deposited into an escrow account maintained by Sanders & Co, and the moneys would only be disbursed for the building of the invested units (the “Escrow Representation”).
(d) The fourth representation was that investors in the Casa Nova Project would earn a 20% return of their investment within one year (the “Investment Return Representation”).
- [48]
[48] The Plaintiffs allege that the Four Representations in relation to the Casa Nova Project were made by Wendy at the 30 July 2012 Presentation. These representations were then repeated by Wendy in the 7 August 2012 email and 13 August 2012 email which were sent to Cindy and the other investors.
- [49]
[49] The Plaintiffs state that Joey had endorsed the Due Diligence Representation at the 30 July 2012 Presentation. In particular, the Plaintiffs allege that, at the 30 July 2012 Presentation, Joey had smiled and nodded his head in acknowledgment when Wendy mentioned that Joey had gone to Brazil to carry out due diligence for the Casa Nova Project. This, according to the Plaintiffs, amounted to Joey affirming the truth of the Due Diligence Representation.
- [50]
[50] The Plaintiffs also allege that, at the 6 October 2012 Presentation, Wendy repeated the Brazilian Government Representation, the Escrow Representation, the Due Diligence Representation and the Investment Return Representation, though in the context of the Bosque Project.
- [51]
[51] The Plaintiffs allege that the Four Representations were false and that Wendy and Joey had knowledge of the falsehood of the Four Representations or, alternatively, had no belief in the truth of the Four Representations or were reckless as to the truth of the Four Representations. The Plaintiffs assert as follows:
(a) In relation to the Brazilian Government Representation, the Plaintiffs state that the Casa Nova Project and the Bosque Project were not approved and supported by the Brazilian government as social housing projects. The Plaintiffs allege that Wendy had relied simply on the assertion of Anthony, who had a vested interest since he stood to gain from the investors’ purchase of residential units in the Casa Nova Project and the Bosque Project. Further, Wendy and Joey had failed to carry out independent due diligence but had merely relied on the due diligence reports commissioned by Ecohouse Brazil, the developer. The Plaintiffs state that Wendy was reckless as to the truth of the Brazilian Government Representation.
(b) In relation to the Escrow Representation, the Plaintiffs state that the moneys in the escrow account maintained by Sanders & Co were disbursed even though there was little or no progress in the construction of the Casa Nova Project and the Bosque Project. The Plaintiffs state that Wendy knew that the Escrow Representation was false.
(c) In relation to the Due Diligence Representation, the Plaintiffs state that no proper due diligence was done by Wendy and Joey on the Casa Nova Project, the Bosque Project and the Ecohouse Group. Rather, the Plaintiffs state that the due diligence reports obtained by Wendy and Joey were commissioned by Ecohouse Brazil, and that they had not conducted their own due diligence at the time of the Due Diligence Representation. Therefore, the Plaintiffs state that Wendy and Joey had knowledge that the Due Diligence Representation was false.
(d) In relation to the Investment Return Representation, the Plaintiffs state that the representation was false as the investors in the Casa Nova Project and the Bosque Project, including the Plaintiffs, did not receive a 20% return of their investments within one year. The Plaintiffs assert that Wendy was reckless as to the truth of the Investment Return Representation, as she failed to do any due diligence on the Casa Nova Project and the Bosque Project which would have otherwise revealed that Ecohouse Brazil “did not own any of the land in Brazil that was mooted for development”.
- [52]
[52] The Plaintiffs submit that Wendy and Joey intended for the Plaintiffs to rely on the Four Representations which were false when investing in the Casa Nova Project and the Bosque Project. In relation to the Casa Nova Project, they allege that the Four Representations were first made at the 30 July 2012 Presentation to convince the investors and the Plaintiffs to invest in the Casa Nova Project. Thereafter, the Four Representations were repeated in the 13 August 2012 email sent by Wendy to allay the worries of the investors in investing in overseas projects such as the Casa Nova Project. In relation to the Bosque Project, the Plaintiffs allege that the Four Representations were made at the 6 October 2012 Presentation to convince the investors and the Plaintiffs to invest in the Bosque Project.
- [53]
[53] The Plaintiffs state that they relied on the Four Representations when they signed the Casa Nova SPA and the Bosque SPA. Consequently, the Plaintiffs suffered losses when they failed to get back their invested amount and receive the 20% return they were entitled to under the Casa Nova SPA and the Bosque SPA.
- [54]
[54] The Plaintiffs also rely on s 2 of the MRA against the Defendants for the misrepresentations.
Negligent misrepresentation
- [55]
[55] The Plaintiffs claim that Wendy and Joey owed them a duty of care. Applying the test in Spandeck Engineering (S) Pte Ltd v Defence Science & Technology Agency [2007] 4 SLR(R) 100 (“Spandeck”), the Plaintiffs state that it was evidently foreseeable that the Plaintiffs would suffer losses if they invested moneys into a scheme based on the Four Representations made by Wendy and Joey which turned out to be false.
- [56]
[56] The Plaintiffs state that there was sufficient legal proximity between the Plaintiffs and the Defendants. First, there was physical and circumstantial proximity, given the nature in which the Four Representations were made at the 30 July 2012 Presentation and the 6 October 2012 Presentation, as well as in the 7 August 2012 email and the 13 August 2012 email. Second, there was causal proximity given the direct causal link between the making of the Four Representations and the Plaintiffs’ decision to sign the Casa Nova SPA and the Bosque SPA. Third, there was a voluntary assumption of responsibility by Wendy who accepted moneys from Cindy as payment for entry to Wendy’s investment network. Wendy and Joey also held themselves out as investment experts.
- [57]
[57] The Plaintiffs state that there are no public policy considerations militating against the imposition of a duty of care upon Wendy and Joey.
- [58]
[58] The proper standard of care, according to the Plaintiffs, is that of a reasonably competent and prudent investment expert, which was what Wendy and Joey held themselves out to be. A reasonably competent and prudent investment expert would have ensured that he had obtained accurate facts about investments before advertising the investments and he also had to take care not to make false statements about the investments. The Plaintiffs state that, in making the Four Representations, Wendy and Joey breached their duty of care by failing to obtain independent due diligence on the Casa Nova Project and the Bosque Project. Therefore, Wendy and Joey had no proper way of knowing whether the Four Representations were true.
- [59]
[59] The Plaintiffs state that, but for the Four Representations, the Plaintiffs would not have signed the Casa Nova SPA and the Bosque SPA.
- [60]
[60] The Plaintiffs state that the losses they have suffered were foreseeable and cannot be said to be remote.
- [61]
[61] In the alternative, the Plaintiffs submit that WKIN owed them a duty of care and that WKIN had breached its duty of care which led to the Plaintiffs suffering losses.
Breaches of collateral contracts
- [62]
[62] The Plaintiffs further state that there were two collateral contracts (hereinafter referred to as the “First Collateral Contract” and the “Second Collateral Contract”) between the Plaintiffs and Wendy. Wendy had breached the two collateral contracts. This is even though Wendy was not a party to the Casa Nova SPA and the Bosque SPA signed by the Plaintiffs.
- [63]
[63] The Plaintiffs submit that the First Collateral Contract arose between Wendy and the Plaintiffs as a result of the promise made by Wendy in the 13 August 2012 email that she had done detailed due diligence on the Casa Nova Project. It was this promise that led the Plaintiffs to enter into the Casa Nova SPA with Ecohouse Brazil. The Plaintiffs allege that Wendy breached the First Collateral Contract by wilfully and recklessly failing to do proper due diligence on the Casa Nova Project. The Plaintiffs allege that as a result of signing the Casa Nova SPA, the Plaintiffs were deprived of the opportunity to make profits from alternative projects which they could have invested in.
- [64]
[64] Further, the Plaintiffs submit that the Second Collateral Contract arose between Wendy and the Plaintiffs following a meeting between Wendy, Cindy and about 50 other investors of the Casa Nova Project and the Bosque Project on 8 November 2013 (the “8 November 2013 Meeting”). I note that while the Plaintiffs’ Statement of Claim states that the meeting took place on 2 December 2013, Cindy’s affidavit refers to a meeting which took place on 8 November 2013. At the 8 November 2013 Meeting, Wendy had purportedly assured the investors present that, if they did not demand for the return of their investments, Wendy would “fight for the investors” and “stand with the investors to see that they get back their investments and promised returns”. The Plaintiffs’ case is that they relied on Wendy’s promise at the 8 November 2013 Meeting and did not demand for the return of the amounts they invested in the Casa Nova Project and the Bosque Project. The Plaintiffs state that Wendy breached the Second Collateral Contract by failing to fulfil her promise.
Knowing receipt and dishonest assistance
- [65]
[65] The Plaintiffs also submit that the Defendants are liable to the Plaintiffs on the grounds of knowing receipt and dishonest assistance.
- [66]
[66] In relation to the claim of knowing receipt, the Plaintiffs argue that the Casa Nova Project and the Bosque Project were fraudulent schemes since Ecohouse Brazil did not, at any time, intend to complete the projects or, in the alternative, fulfil its promises to complete the development of the Casa Nova Project and the Bosque Project within one year. The Plaintiffs contend that Ecohouse Brazil and Sanders & Co misapplied the moneys invested by the Plaintiffs, thereby breaching the fiduciary duties which they owed to the Plaintiffs. The Plaintiffs state that the Defendants received monetary gains which were traceable to the fraudulent schemes of Ecohouse Brazil. Further, according to the Plaintiffs, Wendy and Joey had knowledge, whether actual, constructive or implied, that the projects were fraudulent. As a result, they had knowingly received moneys which are traceable to the Plaintiffs’ moneys.
- [67]
[67] In relation to the claim of dishonest assistance, the Plaintiffs state that the Defendants, and in particular Wendy, assisted in the promotion of the Casa Nova Project and the Bosque Project which turned out to be fraudulent. Further, the Plaintiffs allege that Wendy and Joey had wilfully and recklessly failed to make all necessary inquiries that an honest and reasonable person would have made before marketing the Casa Nova Project and the Bosque Project. Therefore, the Plaintiffs claim that the Defendants had dishonestly assisted Ecohouse Brazil in its fraudulent schemes.
Breach of statutory duty under the Estate Agents Act
- [68]
[68] The Plaintiffs also seek to hold the Defendants liable for breach of statutory duty. According to the Plaintiffs, ss 28 and 29 of the Estate Agents Act require anyone marketing foreign or local properties to be licensed as real estate agents or real estate salespersons. The Defendants, by marketing the Casa Nova Project and the Bosque Project whilst not being licensed, had breached the requirements under the Estate Agents Act.
- [69]
[69] Whilst breaches of ss 28 and 29 of the Estate Agents Act constitute criminal offences punishable by fines, imprisonment or both under the Estate Agents Act, the Plaintiffs submit that there ought to be a private right of action available to them arising from the Defendants’ breach of the Estate Agents Act. The Plaintiffs argue that the statutory duty was imposed to protect a limited class of the public, namely purchasers in Singapore who buy foreign properties, by putting in place a licensing regime. Therefore, the Plaintiffs argue that Parliament intended to confer on members of that class a private right of action for breach of that duty.
The Defendants’ case
The First, Third and Fourth Defendants’ case
- [70]
[70] According to Wendy, she had been asked by Joey in early 2012 to market the Casa Nova Project on behalf of Ecohouse Asia Pacific to members of the WK Investment Network Yahoo Group. She agreed to help market the Casa Nova Project through WK Events. Under the auspices of WK Events, she organised the 30 July 2012 Presentation.
- [71]
[71] Wendy claims that her role at the 30 July 2012 Presentation was primarily to address members of the WK Investment Network Yahoo Group and introduce them to Anthony. Wendy states that she spoke generally about investing in overseas projects. She also spoke on the topic of risks and returns. However, Wendy denies making the Four Representations at the 30 July 2012 Presentation. She states that it was Anthony who spoke about the Casa Nova Project.
- [72]
[72] In relation to the 7 August 2012 email and the 13 August 2012 email which the Plaintiffs rely on to support their allegations that Wendy had made the Four Representations, Wendy’s defence is as follows:
(a) Wendy alleges that she did not make the Brazilian Government Representation in the 7 August 2012 email. She states that the main text of the 7 August 2012 email does not contain the Brazilian Government Representation. In relation to the Casa Nova Presentation Slides which were attached to the 7 August 2012 email, Wendy explains that the Casa Nova Presentation Slides were prepared by Ecohouse UK and were used only by Anthony during the 30 July 2012 Presentation. Wendy had simply forwarded the Casa Nova Presentation Slides in the 7 August 2012 email.
(b) In relation to the 13 August 2012 email, Wendy admits that there were representations made in the 13 August 2012 email. However, Wendy submits that steps were taken as she had stated in the 13 August 2012 email:
(i) In relation to the Due Diligence Representation, Wendy states that Joey did visit Brazil in early 2012 to see the site of the Casa Nova Project as well as the site of a previous Ecohouse Brazil project called Arco Iris (the “Arco Iris Project”). Wendy states that Joey also met with one of the heads of Caixa Bank, a bank owned by the Brazilian government. Further, a due diligence report from a Brazilian lawyer, Andre Elali (“Elali”), dated 5 September 2012 (“Elali’s Casa Nova Due Diligence Report”) was obtained as part of the due diligence exercise. Wendy also submits that a Singapore lawyer, ie, Fong, was engaged to do due diligence. Fong was paid a six-figure fee of over S$100,000 to review the documents for the purchase and stakeholding of funds for the Casa Nova Project.
(ii) In relation to the Escrow Representation, Wendy states that there was, in fact, an escrow agent, Sanders & Co. Further, the Plaintiffs did sign the Casa Nova Escrow Agreement. Wendy also refers to a document obtained by Fong confirming that Sanders & Co was covered by professional indemnity insurance of £2,000,000.
- [73]
[73] Wendy states that it is unclear what representations are alleged by the Plaintiffs in relation to the Bosque Project.
- [74]
[74] Wendy further mentions that she and Joey had also bought nine residential units in the Casa Nova Project and signed a sale and purchase agreement with Ecohouse Brazil. Their total investment was a sum of S$414,000 which they were also unable to recover.
- [75]
[75] Wendy alleges that the Plaintiffs were not novice investors. Prior to investing in the Casa Nova Project and the Bosque Project, the Plaintiffs had invested in the Berlin Project as well as invested in another project in New Zealand through a different marketing agent (the “Plaintiffs’ New Zealand Investment”). Wendy also highlights that the Plaintiffs themselves are registered property agents. Therefore, the Plaintiffs should have known of the potential risks and pitfalls of investments with high returns.
- [76]
[76] Wendy also denies that the First Collateral Contract and the Second Collateral Contract existed. In particular, Wendy denies making any promises at the 8 November 2013 Meeting.
- [77]
[77] Finally, Wendy denies that she had knowingly assisted or participated in any fraud. She also denies holding any moneys on trust for the Plaintiffs. She states that she did not receive any part of the purchase price paid by the Plaintiffs for the Casa Nova Project and the Bosque Project.
- [78]
[78] In respect of WK Events and WKIN, Wendy submits that the role of WK Events and WKIN was limited to providing administrative support, on behalf of Ecohouse Asia Pacific and Ecohouse UK. In this regard, WK Events and WKIN helped to arrange the paperwork and passed these documents to Ecohouse Asia Pacific. Wendy acknowledges that WKIN was paid by Ecohouse Asia Pacific for organising the events at which the Casa Nova Project and the Bosque Project were marketed, ie, the 30 July 2012 Presentation and the 6 October 2012 Presentation. However, Wendy claims that WK Events and WKIN did not receive any commission for the sale of the residential units in either the Casa Nova Project or the Bosque Project.
The Second, Fifth and Sixth Defendants’ case
- [79]
[79] Joey states that one Winstorn Ee (“Winstorn”) introduced Anthony and the Casa Nova Project to him in early 2012. Thereafter, in June 2012, Joey visited Brazil to meet Anthony. In Brazil, Joey states that he did the following:
(a) He visited the Ecohouse Brazil office.
(b) He visited the site of the Arco Iris Project.
(c) He visited the site of the Casa Nova Project.
(d) He was introduced by Anthony to one of the heads of Caixa Bank. Joey states that Caixa Bank was the entity in charge of funding end-buyers in Brazil for the Casa Nova Project.
(e) He was also introduced by Anthony to Elali, a Brazilian lawyer. Joey states that Elali told him that the land on which the Casa Nova Project was going to be built was owned by Ecohouse Brazil. Joey states that Elali also told him that he would be able to render a due diligence report on the Casa Nova Project.
- [80]
[80] Thereafter, Joey agreed with Anthony to set up a JV company which led to the incorporation of Ecohouse Asia Pacific. Joey states that Ecohouse Asia Pacific was interested in marketing the Casa Nova Project to members of the WK Investment Network Yahoo Group. He, therefore, asked Wendy to reach out to people in her network.
- [81]
[81] Joey denies that he made any representation, or affirmed the Due Diligence Representation, at the 30 July 2012 Presentation. Joey states that his role at the 30 July 2012 Presentation was to ensure the event ran smoothly.
- [82]
[82] However, Joey states that he did carry out due diligence as described above (see [72(b)(i)]) during his trip to Brazil in June 2012. He also engaged Fong to advise and deal with the legal aspects of the Casa Nova Project. Joey, therefore, submits that he had taken steps which were more than adequate.
- [83]
[83] Joey denies holding moneys on trust for the Plaintiffs. In fact, Joey states that he did not receive moneys from Ecohouse UK. Further, Joey states that Ecohouse Singapore did not receive the commissions owed under the terms of the JV Agreement from Ecohouse UK.
Issues to be determined
- [84]
[84] There are numerous issues which are as follows:
(a) First, there is the preliminary issue of whether the claims against WK Events, Ecohouse Asia Pacific and Ecohouse Singapore can be sustained as these entities have been struck off the Register.
(b) Second, whether Wendy and/or Joey had made fraudulent misrepresentations to the Plaintiffs. As I shall explain below at [98], this would depend on the following:
(c) Third, whether the Plaintiffs have made out a case against Wendy and/or Joey under s 2 of the MRA.
(d) Fourth, whether Wendy and/or Joey are liable for negligent misrepresentation. As I shall explain below at [217], this would depend on the following:
(e) Fifth, whether the Plaintiffs and Wendy entered into the First Collateral Contract and the Second Collateral Contract and, if so, whether there were breaches of the First Collateral Contract and the Second Collateral Contract by Wendy.
(f) Sixth, whether the Defendants are liable as constructive trustees for knowing receipt.
(g) Seventh, whether the Defendants dishonestly assisted in any fraud by Ecohouse Brazil when they marketed the Casa Nova Project and the Bosque Project to the Plaintiffs.
(h) Eighth, whether the Defendants breached their statutory duty under the Estate Agents Act and, if so, whether a private right of action arises from such a breach.
(i) Ninth, if Wendy and/or Joey are found to be liable under any of the Plaintiffs’ heads of claims above, there is the issue of whether WKIN is liable in any way.
(j) Tenth, there is the issue of damages, should any of the Defendants be found liable.
My decision
Whether the claims against WK Events, Ecohouse Asia Pacific and Ecohouse Singapore can be sustained
- [85]
[85] At the outset, there is the issue of whether the Plaintiffs can pursue their claims against WK Events, Ecohouse Asia Pacific and Ecohouse Singapore when these entities had already been struck off the Register. As highlighted above at [7], [9] and [11]:
(a) WK Events is an exempt private company which was struck off the Register on 4 May 2020.
(b) Ecohouse Asia Pacific is a private company which was struck off the Register on 23 September 2020.
(c) Ecohouse Singapore is an exempt private company which was struck off the Register on 23 September 2020.
- [86]
[86] The implication of WK Events, Ecohouse Asia Pacific and Ecohouse Singapore being struck off the Register is that the companies are no longer in existence today. In Re Asia Petan Organisation Pte Ltd [2018] 3 SLR 435 (“Re Asia Petan”), Audrey Lim JC (as she then was) had to consider the issue of whether to allow an application by a former director of a company, Song, to restore a company which had been struck off the Register so as to commence a derivative action in the company’s name against the other director of the company, Tan, who had purportedly breached his fiduciary duties. In this context, Lim JC stated (at [13]) as follows:
- [87]
[87] It is clear from the above that once a company is struck off the Register, it would be unable to act as it is no longer in existence unless the company is first restored to the Register. In the context of Re Asia Petan, this meant that the company was unable to bring a claim against a director for breach of fiduciary duties until it was restored to the Register. In the present case, as WK Events, Ecohouse Asia Pacific and Ecohouse Singapore were struck off the Register, this means that they are no longer in existence and cannot, therefore, be included as defendants to the present suit.
- [88]
[88] This, however, does not preclude the Plaintiffs from pursuing claims against the officers or members of the three entities. Under s 344A(7)(a) of the Companies Act 1967 (2020 Rev Ed) (“Companies Act 1967”), the liability of officers and members of the company continue even after a company has been struck off and dissolved and may be enforced as if the company had not been dissolved. Section 344A(7)(a) of the Companies Act 1967 provides as follows:
- [89]
[89] This means that when WK Events, Ecohouse Asia Pacific and Ecohouse Singapore were struck off the Register, the Plaintiffs could still have recourse against Wendy and Joey who were directors and shareholders of WK Events. However, Wendy was not the director or shareholder of Ecohouse Asia Pacific or Ecohouse Singapore.
- [90]
[90] Under s 344(5) of the Companies Act 1967 and as was alluded to above at [87], a company struck off the Register may be restored on an application by any aggrieved party within six years after the company has been struck off the Register:
- [91]
[91] In Re Asia Petan, Lim JC reviewed the law in relation to the question of restoration under s 344(5) of the Companies Act (Cap 50, 2006 Rev Ed) which is in para materia with s 344(5) of the Companies Act 1967 (at [31]):
- [92]
[92] In the present case, there was no application by the Plaintiffs to restore WK Events, Ecohouse Asia Pacific and Ecohouse Singapore to the Register. Hence, the Plaintiffs’ claims against the three companies simply cannot be sustained since the companies legally are no longer in existence.
- [93]
[93] The counsel for the Plaintiffs, Mr Goh Kim Thong Andrew (“Mr Goh”), conceded during the oral closing submissions that the Plaintiffs had not applied to restore the three companies to the Register despite this being an option which was available to them. In fact, he stated that the Plaintiffs had no intention to undergo the process of seeking to restore the three companies to the Register. Mr Goh also accepted that the effect of the three companies being struck off the Register was that they were legally no longer in existence.
- [94]
[94] For the above reasons, the Plaintiffs’ claims against WK Events, Ecohouse Asia Pacific and Ecohouse Singapore must, therefore, fail.
- [95]
[95] In any case, I shall nevertheless consider the substratum of the Plaintiffs’ claims against WK Events, Ecohouse Asia Pacific and Ecohouse Singapore. The Plaintiffs’ primary case is undeniably against Wendy and Joey in relation to the Four Representations purportedly made by them. The Plaintiffs intend to hold Wendy and Joey responsible. The Plaintiffs do not want them to hide behind the companies to evade liability. Cindy stated this in Court:
- [96]
[96] There is no evidence against WK Events and Ecohouse Singapore for the following reasons:
(a) First, WK Events only played an administrative role, ie, the organisation of the 30 July 2012 Presentation for the Casa Nova Project and the 6 October 2012 Presentation for the Bosque Project. Thus, WK Events could not be held liable for any misrepresentation made by Wendy and Joey.
(b) Second, Ecohouse Singapore had little involvement in the 30 July 2012 Presentation for the Casa Nova Project and the 6 October 2012 Presentation for the Bosque Project. As I had explained above at [9] and [42], Ecohouse Singapore was an entity which was incorporated for the purpose of the JV entity, Ecohouse Asia Pacific. Thereafter, Ecohouse Asia Pacific became the entity responsible for marketing the Casa Nova Project and the Bosque Project in Singapore. Hence, there is nothing to connect Ecohouse Singapore to any misrepresentation made by Wendy and Joey.
- [97]
[97] As for Ecohouse Asia Pacific, under the terms of the JV Agreement, it was an entity set up for the specific purpose of marketing Ecohouse Brazil’s property developments in the Asia Pacific region. Wendy was the trainer under the terms of the JV Agreement. Thus, Ecohouse Asia Pacific was also responsible for the content of the presentations made at the 30 July 2012 Presentation for the Casa Nova Project and the 6 October 2012 Presentation for the Bosque Project. Therefore, Ecohouse Asia Pacific may potentially be held liable if any misrepresentation was made by Wendy or Joey at the presentations which were organised on behalf of Ecohouse Asia Pacific. However, as the Plaintiffs have failed to make an application to restore Ecohouse Asia Pacific to the Register, the Plaintiffs’ claims against Ecohouse Asia Pacific must fail.
The Plaintiffs’ case of fraudulent misrepresentation against Wendy and Joey
The applicable law
- [98]
[98] The essential elements which need to be established to support a claim of fraudulent misrepresentation were set out in Bradford Third Equitable Benefit Building Society v Borders [1941] 2 All ER 205 and endorsed by the Court of Appeal in Panatron Pte Ltd and another v Lee Cheow Lee and another [2001] 2 SLR(R) 435 (“Panatron”) (at [14]). The elements are as follows:
(a) First, there must be a false representation of fact made by words or conduct.
(b) Second, the representation must be made with the intention that it would be acted upon by the plaintiff, or by a class of persons which includes the plaintiff.
(c) Third, it must be proved that the plaintiff had acted upon the false statement.
(d) Fourth, it must be proved that the plaintiff suffered damage by so doing.
(e) Fifth, the representation must be made with knowledge that it is false; it must be wilfully false, or at least made in the absence of any genuine belief that it is true.
- [100]
[100] Further, in Panatron, the Court of Appeal clarified that the misrepresentation need not be the sole inducement to the plaintiff. In Panatron, the two individuals to whom the misrepresentation was made were experienced businessmen. In this context, the Court of Appeal found that even where the plaintiff relies partly on his own knowledge and expertise and partly on the misrepresentations, this would not be a bar to establishing a case of fraudulent misrepresentation (see [20]–[23] of Panatron):
- [101]
[101] However, as was stated in Panatron (at [13]), the plaintiff must show that the false representation was made: (a) knowingly; (b) without belief in its truth; or (c) recklessly, without caring whether it be true or false.
Preliminary issue on the Plaintiffs’ pleadings
(1) The Plaintiffs’ failure to specifically plead a case of fraudulent misrepresentation in their Statement of Claim
- [102]
[102] I pause here to briefly mention that the Plaintiffs have not, in their Statement of Claim, specifically pleaded a case of fraudulent misrepresentation. Instead, the Plaintiffs have merely referred to their claim under the heading of “Misrepresentation”.
- [103]
[103] However, while the Plaintiffs may have omitted to make specific reference to fraudulent misrepresentation in their Statement of Claim, it is abundantly clear that the Plaintiffs, in substance, intended to pursue a claim of fraudulent misrepresentation. This is evident from the fact that they have alleged in their Statement of Claim that Wendy and Joey “had knowledge of the falsity” of the Four Representations, ie, the key element which distinguishes a case of fraudulent misrepresentation from a case of negligent misrepresentation.
- [104]
[104] In any case, it is quite evident from the Defendants’ case at the trial as well as their opening statements that the Defendants were aware that one of the Plaintiffs’ claims related to fraudulent misrepresentation by Wendy and Joey. Therefore, the Defendants cannot be said to have been taken by surprise or have suffered any prejudice, even if the Statement of Claim did not specifically refer to fraudulent misrepresentation (see Song Jianbo v Sunmax Global Capital Fund 1 Pte Ltd and another [2021] SGHC 217 at [69], cited recently in Bay Lim Piang v Lye Cher Kang [2023] SGHC 13 at [93]).
(2) The First, Third and Fourth Defendants’ claim that the Plaintiffs’ case at the trial on the purported Four Representations differ from the Plaintiffs’ pleaded case
- [105]
[105] I shall now consider the issue raised by the First, Third and Fourth Defendants in their submission at the close of trial relating to the Plaintiffs’ pleadings. They allege that there are differences in the Plaintiffs’ case in relation to the Four Representations. They make this allegation by comparing the case presented by the Plaintiffs in Cindy’s affidavit and at the trial with the Plaintiffs’ Statement of Claim.
- [106]
[106] The First, Third and Fourth Defendants have focused, in particular, on the Due Diligence Representation. According to them, the Plaintiffs’ case as pleaded in the Statement of Claim was limited to a representation made by Wendy that she and/or her companies had spent large sums of money to carry out detailed due diligence to ensure the Casa Nova Project and the Bosque Project were government-approved. Based on the Plaintiffs’ pleaded case, Wendy never did any detailed due diligence in the Casa Nova Project and the Bosque Project. However, the First, Third and Fourth Defendants state that the Plaintiffs had deviated from their pleaded case on the Due Diligence Representation by introducing the element of a “safe investment” in Cindy’s affidavit.
- [107]
[107] Before considering the contention above, I highlight the salient principles on the adequacy of pleadings. It is trite that, where there are allegations of misrepresentation or fraud, these allegations must be pleaded with sufficient particularity. This principle is set out in O 18 r 12(1)(a) of the Rules of Court (Cap 332, R 5, 2014 Rev Ed):
- [108]
[108] The reason for this principle is clear. It is to ensure that the Defendants know the case they have to meet: BOM v BOK and another appeal [2019] 1 SLR 349 (“BOM”) at [39], citing Singapore Civil Procedure vol I (Foo Chee Hock JC, gen ed) (Sweet & Maxwell, 2018) at para 18/12/2.
- [109]
[109] However, in BOM, the Court of Appeal also emphasised that when assessing the adequacy of pleadings, one must not simply focus on the technicalities. Rather, the focus must remain on whether the scope of issues has been adequately defined in the pleadings so as not to take the parties by surprise or deprive the parties of the opportunity to adduce relevant evidence (see BOM at [40]):
- [110]
[110] In the same vein, the Court of Appeal explained in OMG Holdings Pte Ltd v Pos Ad Sdn Bhd [2012] 4 SLR 231 (“OMG Holdings”) that the aim of pleadings is to narrow the parties to definite issues (see OMG Holdings at [18]):
- [111]
[111] The question, therefore, is whether the Plaintiffs’ pleadings adequately set out the Four Representations which the Plaintiffs claim were made by Wendy. I set out in the table below (the “Table”) the Plaintiffs’ pleaded case on the Four Representations for the Casa Nova Project in their Statement of Claim, the Plaintiffs’ case as stated in Cindy’s affidavit and the Plaintiffs’ case at the trial:
- [112]
[112] It is clear from the Table above that there has been no substantive change in the Plaintiffs’ pleadings with respect to the Brazilian Government Representation, the Escrow Representation and the Investment Return Representation. As set out in the Table, the Plaintiffs’ case as detailed in the Statement of Claim for these three Representations is largely replicated in Cindy’s affidavit and at the trial by the Plaintiffs.
- [113]
[113] As for the Due Diligence Representation, there seems to be a slight but immaterial variation between the Plaintiffs’ case as set out in the Statement of Claim and the Plaintiffs’ case as set out in Cindy’s affidavit. In the Statement of Claim, the Plaintiffs have only stated that Wendy and/or her companies (a) had spent large sums of money; and (b) carried out detailed due diligence to ensure the “Brazilian Investments”, ie, the Casa Nova Project and the Bosque Project, “were made into government approved project”. In Cindy’s affidavit, however, the Plaintiffs had gone further to claim that Wendy had stated that:
(a) she had done all that was possible and had invested a six-figure sum on due diligence checks to ensure the Casa Nova Project was government-approved and the investment was safe;
(c) Fong had been engaged to review and vet the sale and purchase agreements and escrow agreements and to tighten the terms in the investors’ favour.
- [114]
[114] These are minor differences in the framing of the Due Diligence Representation and the Plaintiffs’ case is consistent with what they have pleaded in their Statement of Claim. In the Statement of Claim, the Plaintiffs have alleged that Wendy had stated, in the 13 August 2012 email, that large sums of money had been paid to carry out detailed due diligence. This representation was also made at the 30 July 2012 Presentation. Significantly, in the Statement of Claim, the Plaintiffs have made reference to the 13 August 2012 email. Therefore, the First, Third and Fourth Defendants’ submission ignores the fact that the Plaintiffs’ case was premised on what Wendy had said in the 13 August 2012 email.
- [115]
[115] The Plaintiffs’ case on the Due Diligence Representation as stated in Cindy’s affidavit is not inconsistent with the 13 August 2012 email which was sent by Wendy. I reproduce below the relevant parts of the 13 August 2012 email where Wendy had clearly stated what forms the Plaintiffs’ case:
- [116]
[116] Thus, Cindy’s affidavit regarding the Due Diligence Representation was an elaboration of the Plaintiffs’ Statement of Claim on Wendy’s due diligence work as stated in the 13 August 2012 email. The Plaintiffs are not required to reproduce the entire contents of the 13 August 2012 email in the Statement of Claim. Hence, there is no deviation from the Plaintiffs’ pleaded case on the Due Diligence Representation in the Statement of Claim.
- [117]
[117] The Court of Appeal in BOM (at [40]) and OMG Holdings (at [18]), stated that the key issue is whether any deficiency in the pleadings has the effect of causing the other party to be taken by surprise or causing the other party to be irreparably prejudiced. In the present case, the Defendants are not taken by surprise and are not irreparably prejudiced by the Plaintiffs’ allegation of the Due Diligence Representation. It would have been abundantly clear to the Defendants that the Plaintiffs were relying on the 13 August 2012 email sent by Wendy to investors including Cindy. This would have been clear to the Defendants from the Plaintiffs’ Statement of Claim. Given that the 13 August 2012 email was sent by Wendy, she would have been undeniably familiar with the contents of her own email. Further, the Defendants’ opening statements and affidavits show that the Defendants were, in fact, fully aware that the Plaintiffs’ case hinged, in part, on the statements made by Wendy in the 13 August 2012 email. Hence, the contention of the First, Third and Fourth Defendants that the Plaintiffs’ case at trial on the purported Due Diligence Representation differs from the Plaintiffs’ pleaded case has no merits.
- [118]
[118] I shall now consider whether the Plaintiffs have established a case of fraudulent misrepresentation against Wendy and Joey on a balance of probabilities. It is important to consider whether Wendy made the Four Representations.
Whether the Four Representations were made by Wendy
(1) The Casa Nova Project
- [119]
[119] According to the Plaintiffs, Wendy made the Four Representations, ie, the Brazilian Government Representation, the Escrow Representation, the Due Diligence Representation and the Investment Return Representation, at the 30 July 2012 Presentation where the Casa Nova Project was introduced to investors, including the Plaintiffs. Thereafter, Wendy sent two emails, the 7 August 2012 email and the 13 August 2012 email, where the Four Representations were repeated.
- [120]
[120] In defence, Wendy denies making the Four Representations at the 30 July 2012 Presentation. According to Wendy, Anthony was invited to speak to the investors and Anthony was the one who spoke about the Casa Nova Project at the 30 July 2012 Presentation. Wendy alleges that she introduced Anthony to the audience. Further, based on Wendy’s affidavit, she only spoke generally about investing in overseas projects as well as about “risks versus returns”. Anthony then presented material facts relating to the “property development and opportunity”, ie, the Casa Nova Project. Wendy stated in her affidavit that Anthony used the Casa Nova Presentation Slides at the presentation and that she did not prepare the slides. She also did not use the slides in her introduction at the presentation.
- [121]
[121] Before considering the 7 August 2012 email and the 13 August 2012 email, I shall deal first with Wendy’s role at the 30 July 2012 Presentation. Wendy admitted during the cross-examination by Mr Goh that her involvement at the 30 July 2012 Presentation went further than what she had stated in her affidavit:
(a) First, Wendy clarified that she had spoken beyond investing in overseas projects and the “risks versus returns”. She also spoke about investing in Brazil and the economic climate in Brazil. Wendy’s evidence in Court during the cross-examination by Mr Goh is as follows:
(b) Second, Wendy also admitted that it was not just Anthony who used the Casa Nova Presentation Slides at the 30 July 2012 Presentation. Wendy had also referred to a few slides from the Casa Nova Presentation Slides when she was addressing the audience. This is Wendy’s evidence in Court during the cross-examination by Mr Goh:
(c) Third, Wendy also said during the cross-examination by Mr Goh that she had, in fact, told the audience during the 30 July 2012 Presentation that she represented Ecohouse Asia Pacific. Wendy conceded that this claim was not found in her affidavit. This is Wendy’s evidence in Court:
- [122]
[122] These discrepancies raised during the cross-examination are serious material inconsistencies in Wendy’s account of her role at the 30 July 2012 Presentation. She has not provided any explanation to account for these inconsistencies. This, however, means that Wendy’s account in her affidavit that she only introduced Anthony and spoke generally about investing overseas and on risks and returns at the 30 July 2012 Presentation is self-serving and clearly false. Rather, based on Wendy’s own account in Court, she went into some details about investing in Brazil specifically, she and Anthony used the Casa Nova Presentation Slides and spoke about the Casa Nova Project in Brazil.
- [123]
[123] In contrast, the Plaintiffs, who were both present at the 30 July 2012 Presentation, have been consistent in their evidence that Wendy had made the Four Representations at the 30 July 2012 Presentation. The Defendants have contended that the Plaintiffs’ evidence is not entirely credible in view of David merely adopting Cindy’s affidavit without reservation. I accept that there is a need to carefully scrutinise the evidence of the Plaintiffs, in view of the fact that David has, in essence, adopted Cindy’s position as his own. However, in light of the contents of the 7 August 2012 email and the 13 August 2012 email sent by Wendy which I shall come to shortly, it is more probable that the Plaintiffs’ version of the events, ie, that Wendy had made the Four Representations at the 30 July 2012 Presentation, is true.
- [124]
[124] The Plaintiffs called Chang Tuck Yuen (“Chang”), another investor, as a witness. Chang attended the 30 July 2012 Presentation. Later, Chang also signed a sale and purchase agreement with Ecohouse Brazil for the purchase of some residential units in the Casa Nova Project. Chang’s evidence is consistent with the Plaintiffs’ evidence that Wendy had made the Four Representations at the 30 July 2012 Presentation. I am, however, mindful that Chang stated during the cross-examination by the counsel for the First, Third and Fourth Defendants, Ms Oei Ai Hoea Anna (“Ms Oei”), that he had discussed with Cindy the contents of his affidavit before the trial. This is Chang’s evidence in Court:
- [125]
[125] The Defendants have argued that Chang is not a credible witness as he had worked on his affidavit together with Cindy and they had agreed on the information that went into the affidavit. They had freely discussed matters relating to the present case during the meetings with the lawyers before the commencement of the trial. The Defendants have also focused on Chang’s admission at the trial that he stands to gain financially if the Plaintiffs succeed in their claim against the Defendants. This is Chang’s evidence in Court during the cross-examination by Ms Oei:
- [126]
[126] It is clear from the exchange above that Chang’s and Cindy’s testimonies need to be treated with extreme caution. Thus, prudence requires the Court to exercise extreme care when evaluating the evidence of the Plaintiffs and Chang. Notwithstanding this, it is undisputed that Wendy sent to Cindy and the other investors the 7 August 2012 email and 13 August 2012 email. The contents of these emails indicate that Wendy did, in fact, make the Four Representations as the Plaintiffs allege.
- [127]
[127] In the 7 August 2012 email, Wendy forwarded the Casa Nova Presentation Slides which were used at the 30 July 2012 Presentation. This email was sent to Cindy and the other investors in the Casa Nova Project following the 30 July 2012 Presentation. In this email, Wendy provided a set of instructions to the investors on the next steps that they would need to take following their reservation of the residential units in the Casa Nova Project.
- [128]
[128] The following representations can be gleaned from a review of the Casa Nova Presentation Slides forwarded in the 7 August 2012 email:
(a) First, the Casa Nova Presentation Slides reveal that the Brazilian Government Representation was made to the investors, including the Plaintiffs, at the 30 July 2012 Presentation and in the 7 August 2012 email. The evidence of the Brazilian Government Representation is listed below:
(i) The slides found at Bundle of Affidavits of Evidence-in-Chief Volume 1 (“1BAEIC”), pages 120 to 123, show that various representations were made about the Brazilian government’s MCMV programme. Representations were made that the government launched the MCMV programme in 2009 to provide significant funding for Brazilians to purchase their own homes.
(ii) The slide found at 1BAEIC, page 124, shows that representations were clearly made that Ecohouse Brazil was a government-backed developer which was certified by the state-owned Caixa Bank:
(b) Second, the Casa Nova Presentation Slides reveal that the investors’ moneys for the Casa Nova Project would be deposited into an escrow account, ie, the Escrow Representation. This was mentioned at the 30 July 2012 Presentation and in the 7 August 2012 email:
(i) The slide found at 1BAEIC, page 124, shows that a representation was clearly made that investors’ moneys for Ecohouse Brazil were fully secured and protected by way of an escrow account in the UK:
(ii) A similar representation was again made at the slide found at 1BAEIC, page 130:
(iii) This representation was again made at the slide found at 1BAEIC, page 133, where it was stated:
(c) Third, the Casa Nova Presentation Slides reveal that the Investment Return Representation was made to the investors and the Plaintiffs at the 30 July 2012 Presentation and in the 7 August 2012 email:
(i) The slide at 1BAEIC, page 133, shows that a representation was clearly made that investors would earn a 20% return of their investment within one year:
(ii) This representation was again made in the slide at 1BAEIC, page 135:
- [129]
[129] From the above, it is clear that the Brazilian Government Representation and the Investment Return Representation were made in the Casa Nova Presentation Slides which were used at the 30 July 2012 Presentation and were attached in the 7 August 2012 email sent by Wendy. In relation to the Escrow Representation, the Casa Nova Presentation Slides only refer to investors’ moneys being deposited into an escrow account, though they do not state the conditions under which investors’ moneys in the escrow account would be released.
- [130]
[130] Wendy has tried to distance herself from the Casa Nova Presentation Slides. In her affidavit, she stated that the 7 August 2012 email “was merely forwarding the slides that were presented”. During the cross-examination by Mr Goh, Wendy stated that the slides attached to the 7 August 2012 email were prepared by Anthony and that her involvement with respect to the contents of the Casa Nova Presentation Slides was merely to include the contact information of the parties as well as to convert the monetary figures stated in the Casa Nova Presentation Slides to Singapore Dollars:
- [131]
[131] Regarding the instructions to the investors on the next steps that they would need to take following the reservation contained in the 7 August 2012 email, Wendy stated in Court that she was merely forwarding instructions from Ecohouse Asia Pacific:
The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.