Court of Appeal · Decided 25 September 2023
Parastate Labs Inc v Wang Li
Feedback & support[2023] SGCA 27 · Case no. Court of Appeal / Civil Appeal No 16 of 2023 · 23 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [3]
[3] The genesis of the requirement for an undertaking as to damages and the purpose it serves was outlined by Lord Diplock in F Hoffmann-La Roche & Co AG v Secretary of State for Trade and Industry [1975] AC 295 as follows (at 360, referred to in CHS CPO GmbH (in bankruptcy) and another v Vikas Goel and others [2005] 3 SLR(R) 202 (“CHS CPO”) at [18]):
- [5]
[5] The present appeal arose from the decision of the judge below (the “Judge”) on an application for a worldwide Mareva injunction, HC/SUM 2564/2022 (“SUM 2564”) made in the main action, HC/OC 130/2022 (“OC 130”). The appellant, Parastate Labs Inc (“Parastate”) had commenced OC 130 against the respondent, Mr Wang Li (“Mr Wang”) and three other defendants. Parastate sought the injunction for the full value of its claim in OC 130, which was US$5 million, as against Mr Wang. The Judge granted the injunction but limited it to a quantum of US$2.5 million and required that Parastate fortify its undertaking as to damages by paying S$50,000 into court. The Judge delivered his grounds of decision in Parastate Labs Inc v Wang Li and others [2023] SGHC 153 (the “GD”).
Background
- [7]
[7] Parastate invested US$5 million worth of the cryptocurrency Tether in the Babel Quant Alpha USDT Fund (the “Fund”), managed by a cryptocurrency financial services provider trading as “Babel Finance”, which refers collectively to the third and fourth defendants in OC 130 – Babel Asia Asset Management Private Limited (“Babel Asia”) and Babel Holding Limited (“Babel Holding”) respectively. Babel Asia was the entity that Parastate contracted with. Babel Holding was the sole shareholder of Babel Asia.
- [8]
[8] The first and second defendants in OC 130, Mr Wang and Mr Yang Zhou (“Mr Yang”), were co-founders of Babel Holding and directors of Babel Asia at certain periods leading up to OC 130. At the time when the key events leading up to OC 130 took place, Mr Wang was the sole director of Babel Asia. Parastate’s case was that Mr Wang was the controlling mind and will of Babel Finance at the material time.
- [9]
[9] Parastate’s investment was made in March 2022. In June 2022, Parastate sought to withdraw its investment but was informed that Babel Finance was experiencing financial difficulties and could not meet the withdrawal request. According to Parastate, it was informed that Deribit, a cryptocurrency exchange platform, had cross-liquidated all of Babel Finance’s sub-accounts maintained with Deribit, including the Fund’s sub-account, as three of Babel Finance’s sub-accounts (excluding the Fund’s sub-account) had exceeded their maintenance margins.
- [10]
[10] On 13 July 2022, Parastate commenced OC 130 seeking, among other reliefs, liquidated damages of US$5 million from Mr Wang and Mr Yang on a joint and several basis. Among other things, Parastate alleged that Babel Asia and Babel Holding breached their fiduciary duties and/or trustee duties owed to Parastate in respect of its investment in the Fund, and Mr Wang and/or Mr Yang dishonestly assisted Babel Asia’s and Babel Holding’s breaches. Parastate initially sought via SUM 2564 the Mareva injunction as against both Mr Wang and Mr Yang but later withdrew the application as against Mr Yang. At the time of the inter partes hearing before the Judge, Parastate’s application for the Mareva injunction was therefore only against Mr Wang.
The decision below
- [11]
[11] The Judge granted the Mareva injunction but limited the quantum to US$2.5 million and required that Parastate fortify its undertaking as to damages by paying S$50,000 into court (GD at [2] and [40]). The Judge found that Parastate had established a good arguable case against Mr Wang and a real risk of dissipation of assets. However, the Judge decided to limit the quantum of the injunction to half the amount claimed, considering it just and convenient to do so having regard to Parastate’s conduct (GD at [44]).
- [12]
[12] The conduct in question referred to two of Parastate’s “material non-disclosures … in relation to its ability to meet its undertaking as to damages, and in deliberately omitting prescribed undertakings …” (GD at [39]). These in essence referred to two irregularities in Parastate’s Mareva injunction application.
- [14]
[14] Second, Parastate failed to include in its application the prescribed undertakings 9 and 10 provided in Form 25 of the SCPD 2021, without explanation and without bringing the omissions to the Judge’s attention. Pursuant to O 13 r 1(7) of the ROC 2021 and paragraph 72(2) of the SCPD 2021, Form 25 of the SCPD 2021 must be used in applications for worldwide Mareva injunctions and any departure from the terms of the prescribed form should be justified by the applicant in its supporting affidavit. At the ex parte hearing, the Judge noted the irregularity and directed Parastate to address the issue at the inter partes hearing. Parastate’s counsel, Mr Foo Maw Shen accepted at the inter partes hearing that the prescribed undertakings 9 and 10 should be included. Accordingly, the Mareva injunction that the Judge granted incorporated those undertakings (GD at [29]–[36]). We refer to this irregularity as the “Failure to Include Prescribed Undertakings”.
- [15]
[15] The Judge considered that the lower quantum injuncted would strike the right balance between the interests of both parties, considering the “likely effects of an injunction on [Mr Wang]” and the “unsatisfactory evidence from Parastate as to whether it was good for its undertaking” (GD at [46]).
Issue to be determined
- [16]
[16] The only issue before us was whether the Judge’s exercise of discretion to reduce the quantum of the Mareva injunction from US$5 million to US$2.5 million was based on principled grounds.
Whether the exercise of discretion was principled
- [17]
[17] At the outset, we noted that in the appeal before us, it was undisputed that Parastate had established (a) a good arguable case; and (b) a real risk of dissipation of assets, as found by the Judge. It was also undisputed that Parastate’s claim was for a single, indivisible sum of US$5 million. In other words, Parastate would either succeed in full or not at all. There was no middle ground.
The applicable law
- [18]
[18] In arriving at his decision, the Judge referred to the legal principles on the failure to make full and frank disclosure in seeking relief ex parte, citing JTrust 2018 at [84] and [89]–[92]. The Judge therefore considered “Parastate’s material non-disclosures” (ie, the Failure to State Available Assets and the Failure to Include Prescribed Undertakings) in deciding to limit the quantum of the Mareva injunction (GD at [26] and [39]).
- [19]
[19] Indeed, as this Court has previously pronounced, a Mareva injunction is a form of equitable relief and any plaintiff seeking such relief is expected to come to court with clean hands (JTrust 2018 at [84]). In the same vein, it is well established that an ex parte injunction obtained may, in the court’s discretion, be discharged if there was a failure to make full and frank disclosure of material facts (JTrust 2018 at [90]).
- [20]
[20] For instance, in Bahtera Offshore (M) Sdn Bhd v Sim Kok Beng and another [2009] 4 SLR(R) 365 (“Bahtera Offshore”), the High Court discharged the ex parte Mareva injunction because of the plaintiff’s failure to make full and frank disclosure. In Bahtera Offshore, the High Court found, among other things, that the plaintiff had “deliberately suppressed and distorted material facts so that the court hearing the ex parte application would believe that the Defendants were dissipating their assets” (Bahtera Offshore at [34]). In the same vein, the High Court in Multi-Code Electronics Industries (M) Bhd and another v Toh Chun Toh Gordon and others [2009] 1 SLR(R) 1000 (“Multi-Code Electronics”), discharged the ex parte Mareva injunction obtained against the third defendant on account of the plaintiffs’ “deliberate suppression and distortion of the material fact concerning the present whereabouts of the third defendant” which “could or would have affected the judge’s impression of the third defendant as someone who was trying to evade the plaintiffs and who had been dissipating his assets …” (Multi-Code Electronics at [136]).
- [21]
[21] A similar approach has been taken in cases where the applicant’s ability to honour its undertaking as to damages had been called into question. In Block and another v Nicholson (trading as Limascue Stud) [1987] CLY 3064 (“Block”), the plaintiffs had obtained an ex parte Mareva injunction while failing to disclose that one of them, Mr Block, had been arrested and charged for fraud about a month before the application. In upholding the decision to discharge the injunction, the English Court of Appeal observed that it was the duty of an applicant seeking an ex parte injunction to make full disclosure of “any facts which could reasonably be regarded as relevant to the exercise of the Court’s discretion to grant such an injunction”. The Court held that Mr Block’s arrest, among other things, should have been disclosed because it would have been a matter of prime importance whether the implied undertaking as to damages given by Mr Block was one that the Court could safely accept.
- [23]
[23] The authorities outlined above illustrate that a Mareva injunction obtained ex parte may be set aside for the applicant’s failure to make full and frank disclosure of any material fact. The underlying rationale for this is that the judge deciding the application may not have been “appropriately sensitised to the real merits of the application” as a result of the material non-disclosure (The “Vasiliy Golovnin” [2008] 4 SLR(R) 994 at [85]).
- [24]
[24] Having examined the authorities outlined above, we made two key observations. First, the material non-disclosures justifying a discharge of the injunctions granted were ones that had a bearing either on (a) the requirements for the grant of a Mareva injunction; or (b) the plaintiff’s ability to honour its undertaking as to damages. In other words, the non-disclosures had a material bearing on the merits of the Mareva injunction application. Further, in those decisions, there were material facts which the claimant sought to suppress. Second, the material non-disclosure typically caused the injunction to be discharged and did not lead merely to a reduction of the quantum of the injunction. In this regard, counsel for Mr Wang, Mr Choo Zheng Xi (“Mr Choo”), candidly acknowledged at the hearing before us that there was no authority for the exercise of discretion to reduce the quantum of an injunction for an indivisible claim notwithstanding the establishment of a good arguable case for the entire claim and a real risk of dissipation of the defendant’s assets.
Whether there was a material non-disclosure in the present case
- [25]
[25] Parastate’s Failure to State Available Assets and Failure to Include Prescribed Undertakings were described by the Judge as material non-disclosures. In our view, there was no material non-disclosure to speak of as neither had an impact on the Judge’s findings of a good arguable case and a real risk of dissipation of assets, or Parastate’s ability to honour its undertaking as to damages. In the cases where the injunctions were discharged on account of material non-disclosure in relation to the applicants’ ability to honour their undertaking as to damages, material facts such as the extent of the applicant’s indebtedness or the applicant’s pending criminal charges were in fact suppressed by the applicants.
- [27]
[27] With respect to the Failure to State Available Assets, we observed that Parastate’s affidavits were unsatisfactory and did not comply with the SCPD 2021, despite the express directions by the Judge. We were not persuaded by Parastate’s attempt to explain the state of the information that it had provided. Parastate contended that owing to the nature of it being a corporate vehicle for its founders’ investment, it did not have financial statements prepared from the time of its incorporation. This, however, did not explain the absence of other relevant documents, such as bank statements.
- [28]
[28] Nonetheless, the Failure to State Available Assets, while unacceptable for its non-compliance with the SCPD 2021 requirements, was not a material non-disclosure relating either to the requirements for the grant of a Mareva injunction or to Parastate’s ability to honour its undertaking as to damages. Indeed, the Judge did not see fit to decline to grant the Mareva injunction on account of the non-compliance, which in our view, was consistent with his finding that there was a good arguable case and a real risk of dissipation of assets. We further observed that the Failure to State Available Assets in the present case was distinguishable from the material non-disclosures in Block and North American Holdings. In the latter two cases, there were undisclosed facts that cast serious doubt on whether the applicants were good for their undertaking as to damages, which should have been disclosed and would have had a material bearing on the Judge’s decision as to whether to grant the Mareva injunction in the circumstances. In the present case, there was no suggestion that Parastate had suppressed or failed to disclose facts which had a material bearing on its ability to honour the undertaking as to damages.
The proper approach to addressing Parastate’s non-compliance with the SCPD 2021
- [29]
[29] That was, however, not to say that any uncertainty as to whether Parastate was good for its undertaking as to damages created by its non-compliance should go unaddressed. In this regard, we referred to the following passage in Steven Gee, Commercial Injunctions (Sweet & Maxwell, 6th Ed, 2016) at para 11-028:
Conclusion
- [34]
[34] As an addendum, we add that it was brought to our attention in the course of the hearing that after the papers for the present appeal were filed, a case management stay of OC 130 as against Mr Wang was granted. The stay is in effect till 15 September 2023, the date on which the moratorium granted in favour of Babel Asia in relation to its proposed restructuring will expire. We were also informed that Babel Holding has sought leave to convene its scheme meeting on or before 21 November 2023. In light of this, we granted the parties liberty to apply in respect of the injunction and the fortification in recognition of a possible change in circumstances due to the scheme proceedings.