High Court · Decided 21 August 2020
Ang Chek Chin v ANS Import & Export Pte Ltd (formerly known as Ang Ngee Seng Import & Export Pte Ltd)
Feedback & support[2020] SGHC 177 · Case no. Companies Winding Up No 285 of 2019 and Summons No 563 of 2020 · 23 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Laws this judgment relies on
Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [1]
[1] ANS Import & Export Pte Ltd (“the Company”) is owned equally by two brothers (“the brothers”), Ang Chek Chin (“Raymond”) and Ang Chek Poh (“Roland”), who are also the two directors of the Company. Raymond commenced winding up proceedings against the Company on the basis that Roland had acted in the Company’s affairs in his own interest and in a manner which appeared to be unfair or unjust to Raymond, and that it would be just and equitable to wind up the Company, pursuant to s 254(1)(f) and (i) of the Companies Act (Cap 50, 2006 Rev Ed) (“the CA”) (based on the provision as it stood at the material time).
- [2]
[2] Roland filed a notice of intention to appear to oppose the winding up and applied by Summons No 563 of 2020 (“SUM 563”) for the court to summon various persons (including Raymond) to be examined and to produce documents, relying on s 285 of the CA. Additionally, two employees and an ex-employee of the Company filed notices of intention to appear and filed affidavits. At the hearing before me, Roland agreed to buy out Raymond’s shares in the Company and thus the winding up application was resolved. This decision deals with two matters in the course of the proceedings, namely whether and when a non-party, particularly one who is not a creditor or contributory of the company, is allowed to appear and intervene in winding up proceedings, and when s 285 of the CA can be invoked.
Background
- [3]
[3] The business was initially set up by Raymond’s and Roland’s father as a sole proprietorship and subsequently incorporated as the Company with the father and sons holding one share each. It was in the business of importing and exporting household products, with its principal business in wholesale trade and the manufacture of chemical products. The father then left his share equally to Raymond and Roland when he passed away.
- [4]
[4] Raymond’s case is as follows. As the father grew older, Roland and Raymond were tasked to grow the business. Although the brothers had their disputes even in 2004, they nevertheless continued to manage the Company together and it became more of a quasi-partnership. Despite their differences, there was a relationship of mutual trust and confidence, with the division of responsibilities between the brothers in the Company. Subsequently, matters took a turn for the worse which led to the breakdown of the relationship and conflict within the Company. This included Roland’s deliberate exclusion or obstruction of Raymond from participating in human resource matters in the Company, Roland’s abuse of his access rights to the computer system to monitor Raymond’s emails, and Roland’s conduct vis-à-vis third parties which affected the Company’s reputation. The Company is dysfunctional and the brothers no longer communicate with each other and can no longer make decisions for the Company. Essentially there is a deadlock and a loss of substratum in the Company which had been formed as a family business and quasi-partnership. Raymond attempted to utilise the buy-out mechanism in the Company’s Constitution, but Roland was not agreeable to any offer that he made.
- [5]
[5] Roland resisted the winding up. He asserted that the Company was never started as a quasi-partnership nor ever ran as such, and that it was not founded on mutual trust or confidence between the brothers. The brothers regarded each other strictly as business colleagues. They had many disagreements over the years and did not see eye to eye on many issues. However, Roland disputed Raymond’s allegations of what Roland had allegedly done to cause the breakdown in trust and confidence between them. In any event, the Company’s Constitution provided for a share buy-out mechanism. The winding up procedure was an abuse of process and Raymond was using it for a collateral purpose to pressure Roland into agreeing to his unreasonable buy-out terms. A winding up was also not appropriate as the Company is a going concern and a viable business.
- [6]
[6] I set out briefly some of the broader areas of dispute, as they formed the backdrop to the applications made in these proceedings.
- [7]
[7] The first concerned the supply of gloves. According to Roland, Raymond had caused the Company to enter into a glove-supply contract with White Glove Co Ltd (“White Glove”) on unconscionable terms and caused the Company to terminate the previous contract with Dupallo Industries Sdn Bhd (“Dupallo”). The gloves supplied by White Glove were consigned to a Singapore company, Motusgen Pte Ltd (“Motusgen”), which belonged to Raymond’s son, Kenneth. The Company was also issued payment invoices from another entity, Century Plastic Manufacturing Company (Private) Limited (“Century Plastic”), for the shipment of the products. Raymond’s friend, one “Kang”, is the owner of Century Plastic. Roland found these arrangements problematic as White Glove only charged about $0.54 per glove, whereas Century Plastic sold the gloves to the Company at $1.07 per glove. Roland hence began investigations into these transactions.
- [8]
[8] The second dispute involved Raymond’s decision to hire one Michael Tan (“Michael”) as the General Manager of the Company, which Roland did not agree with. The third dispute involved NTUC Fairprice Co-operative Ltd’s (“NTUC Fairprice”) decision not to renew a particular contract with the Company, which Roland claimed was Raymond’s fault. He claimed that Raymond had delayed in raising the necessary purchase orders to be issued by the Company to ANS Orient (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd for the latter to supply the product to meet NTUC Fairprice’s requirements.
- [10]
[10] Additionally the following persons (“Non-Parties”) filed notices of intention to appear in the proceedings and filed affidavits, namely: (a) Ang Chek Joo (“Chek Joo”), the sister of Raymond and Roland, who has been employed at the Company for over 30 years and is the present admin manager of the Company; (b) Yuen Chin Ching (“Yuen”), who has been employed at the Company for 20 years and is the present Senior Admin Executive of the Company; and (c) Liew Kit Yee (“Liew”), a former employee of the Company.
Right to appear and be heard at a winding up application
Non-Parties’ and Raymond’s submissions
- [11]
[11] The Non-Parties submitted that they had the right to be heard and relied on Four Pillars Enterprises Co Ltd v Beiersdorf Aktiengesellschaft [1999] 1 SLR(R) 382 (“Four Pillars”). They had served the requisite notice of intention to appear under r 28 of the CWU Rules, and by r 30, were entitled to file an affidavit to oppose the winding up. Further, a non-party is not precluded from intervening merely because is he not a creditor or shareholder of the company. In this regard, the Non-Parties referred to Ambank (M) Bhd v Malaysian Coal & Minerals Corp Sdn Bhd [2016] 11 MLJ 590 (“Ambank”) in relation to rr 28, 29 and 30 of the Companies (Winding-Up) Rules 1972 (M’sia) (“Malaysian CWU Rules 1972”) (which are in pari materia to rr 28, 29 and 30 of the CWU Rules).
- [12]
[12] The Non-Parties argued that it was in the interests of justice for them to be heard. They claimed that they did not side with either Raymond or Roland, but sought only to “factually comment” or “clarify” certain aspects of the Company’s operations. Their evidence was highly probative and would assist the court to make a fair and just decision. There were many inconsistencies between Raymond’s factual claims and the Non-Parties’ evidence, and if their evidence was not admitted, Raymond’s evidence could not be sufficiently scrutinised. Chek Joo and Yuen also attested that if the court were to wind up the Company, it would jeopardise the livelihood of its employees, many of whom have been with the Company for years.
- [13]
[13] Raymond argued that the Non-Parties had no locus standi to participate as they were neither contributories nor creditors of the Company. The purpose of the winding up process and provisions of the CA indicate that persons other than creditors and contributories should have limited involvement. Rule 27 of the CWU Rules allows only a creditor or contributory of the company to be furnished with the winding up application and supporting affidavit, and Form 8 of the First Schedule to the CWU Rules (“Form 8”) suggests that the right to appear and to oppose a winding up is meant to apply only to creditors or contributories of the company. The court in Four Pillars also stated that the party who serves the notice of intention to appear is normally a creditor or contributory.
My decision
- [15]
[15] The question before me is whether a person who is not of an accepted class, ie, the company, a creditor, a contributory, the official receiver or the liquidator of the company (“the class of persons”), has a right to appear and be heard on an application for the winding up of the company. The CA is silent on this. Generally, a person who is not of the class of persons should not be allowed to appear to be heard on the application to wind up the company. However, this is not an immutable rule, as will be seen later.
- [17]
[17] In In re Bradford Navigation Company (1870) LR 5 Ch App 600, the English Court of Appeal held that no person has a right to be heard in a petition for winding up of a company except for creditors and contributories. The court explained (at 602) that, historically, contributories were the only ones who could be heard in a winding up, but as the operation of winding up a company interfered with creditors, Parliament (by legislation) made winding up a matter for both creditors and contributories. Hence, while creditors and contributories could be heard in a winding up application, it was something entirely different to say that “any person who has an interest in, or a right to or in respect of, some of the property of the company, large or small, has a right to appear as a litigant”. Similarly, in In re SBA Properties Ltd [1967] 1 WLR 799 at 802C–D, the court accepted that the only persons entitled to appear at a hearing of a winding up application are the company, its creditors and its contributories. This position was also accepted in Re Mid East Trading Ltd [1997] 3 All ER 481, where the court included an Official Receiver and any liquidator as persons with standing.
- [20]
[20] In the present case, the Non-Parties had no standing to be heard at the application for the winding up, as they did not fall within the class of persons or a person expressly provided for in the CA. Even the very limited exception in PWC v Saad did not apply to them, as they were not the targets of the winding up application. The Non-Parties attested that they merely wished to set some facts straight and claimed to be “neutral” in the proceedings . However, at the same time, Chek Joo and Yuen attempted to argue that if the court were to wind up the Company, this would jeopardise the livelihood of its employees. In my view, it was not appropriate to give any regard to their evidence (see also In re Craven Insurance Co Ltd [1968] 1 WLR 675). By their own evidence, they were not seeking to oppose or challenge the winding up – hence they could not rely on r 30 of the CWU Rules to adduce affidavit evidence since r 30 provides for affidavits to be filed “in opposition” to a winding up application. As for Liew, his position was even more tenuous, given that he was a former employee of the Company and not a person who would have been affected by the Company’s winding up . As such, I did not allow the Non-Parties the right to be heard on the winding up application.
- [21]
[21] The Non-Parties’ reliance on Ambank ([11] supra) was misconceived. The Malaysian High Court in Ambank held (at [13] and [16]) that nothing in the plain reading of the Malaysian CWU Rules 1972 prohibits a non-creditor/contributory from applying to be heard, and that since there was a lacuna in that regard, O 15 r 6(2)(b) of the Rules of Court 2012 (M’sia) (concerning the rule on joinder of parties) could apply to allow such a person to apply to be heard. However, O 1 r 2(2) of the Singapore Rules of Court (Cap 322, R 5, 2014 Rev Ed) (“Rules of Court”) (based on the provision as it stood at the material time) expressly provides that the Rules of Court do not apply to winding up proceedings (save for certain provisions that are irrelevant for the present purposes).
Section 285 of the CA
Roland’s and Raymond’s submissions
- [22]
[22] Next, Roland in SUM 563 applied for Raymond, Kenneth, Kang and Michael (“the Witnesses”) to be orally examined, and for Raymond, Kenneth and Kang to produce documents. His supporting affidavits and written submissions premised his application on s 285 of the CA , although the summons also sought to invoke s 257(2) of the CA.
- [23]
[23] Roland, relying on Liquidator of W&P Piling Pte Ltd v Chew Yin What and others [2004] 3 SLR(R) 164, submitted that s 285 of the CA gives the court a wide discretion to call before it any person it finds relevant to the disposal of the case. In particular, the Witnesses would be relevant to determine, inter alia, whether the factual assertions have been made out for a winding up on just and equitable grounds, whether it was Raymond who had breached his duties to the Company, and whether the winding up application was commenced for a collateral purpose and hence constituted an abuse of the court process. Roland submitted that these were fact-sensitive issues.
My decision
- [25]
[25] I dismissed SUM 563. As Roland and Raymond had subsequently agreed that the former would buy out the latter’s shares in the Company, I no longer had to determine whether the Company should be wound up. The focus here is on when s 285 of the CA can be invoked and by whom.
- [28]
[28] However, the Phrase in s 211(1) of the Companies Ordinance was removed when s 211 was re-enacted as s 249 of the Companies Act (Act 42 of 1967) (“Companies Act 1967”). Instead, s 249 of the Companies Act 1967 was remodelled to be identical to s 249 of the Companies Act 1961 (Aus), which had likewise been derived from s 268 of the 1948 UK Act. Section 249(1) of the Companies Act 1967 read:
- [29]
[29] Whilst the removal of the Phrase may suggest that the powers under s 249 were no longer restricted to situations of winding up or where a provisional liquidator had been appointed, legislative material suggests that there was no intent to make such a substantive change. The Explanatory Statement to the Companies Bill (Bill No 58/1966) stated that the clauses in Part X of the Companies Bill (which included what was eventually s 249 of the Companies Act 1967) “more or less reproduce[d] the provisions of the existing [Companies] Ordinance”. A similar point was made in Re China Underwriters (albeit in the context of whether the court could exercise its jurisdiction in relation to a foreign company not wound up in Singapore) where the court noted (at [42]) that the removal of the Phrase was probably because it was thought to be superfluous.
- [31]
[31] This is further supported by r 49 of the CWU Rules, which provides that if a s 285 application is made by a creditor or contributory, the summons and affidavit in support of the application shall be served on the liquidator – this requirement can only be fulfilled if the company has been wound up or a liquidator appointed. The above interpretation also accords with the purpose of s 285, which is to assist a liquidator in the accumulation of information that would enable or facilitate in the discharge of his duties (Celestial Nutrifoods at [34] and [41]). The procedure in s 285 to summon a person is not meant for the purpose of determining whether a winding up should be granted – in such a case, the proper procedure lies in s 257(2) of the CA, which allows the court on a winding up application to do certain things including directing a trial and directing that oral evidence be taken.
Conclusion
- [33]
[33] To conclude, the Non-Parties had no standing to appear and to be heard in the winding up application. I also dismissed SUM 563. As Roland and Raymond eventually agreed that the former would buy out the latter’s shares in the Company, the question of whether the Company should be wound up was no longer in issue, and I need say no more on this.