General Division of the High Court · Decided 6 December 2021
Wang Xiaopu v Goh Seng Heng and another
Feedback & support[2021] SGHC 282 · Case no. Suit No 686 of 2015 (Summons No 5041 of 2020) · 29 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
Background
(a) RMB ¥39,428,736 paid by the Plaintiff on 24 October 2013 into his HSBC account in Guangzhou, China, bearing the account number 629151309050 (the “HSBC-GZ Account”) (para 2(a) read with paras 3 and 4 of ORC 3129); and
(b) A further ¥46,720,151.01 paid by the Plaintiff on 26 November 2013 into the HSBC-GZ account (para 2(d) read with paras 3 and 4 of ORC 3129).
These are the orders which formed the subject of this contempt action and I shall refer to them as the “HSBC Orders”, and the sums of money to which they relate as the “Funds”.
- [6]
[6] Meanwhile, on 6 March 2020, Dr Goh filed a debtor’s bankruptcy application in HC/B 940/2020 (“B 940”). This application was granted on 19 March 2020 and Dr Goh was declared a bankrupt. The Plaintiff became aware of this on 17 April 2020, and accordingly, applied for court’s leave to proceed against Dr Goh in SUM 1453. She obtained it on 9 June 2020, and ORC 3129 was thereafter served on Dr Goh on 25 June 2020 for his compliance.
- [7]
[7] On 20 July 2020, Dr Goh affirmed an affidavit in response to ORC 3129 (the “July 2020 Affidavit”). He stated the following at paragraph 4: “I make this Affidavit in response the application of the Plaintiff, Wang Xiaopu, in SUM 1453/2020 and ORC 3129/2020 focusing on addressing the orders made by the Court.” By this, Dr Goh put it beyond doubt that this affidavit was specifically made to comply with the orders of Woo J in ORC 3129.
- [8]
[8] Substantively, in response to both HSBC Orders, Dr Goh made the same statements at para 6 of the July 2020 Affidavit:
- [9]
[9] From this, it is clear that on 20 July 2020, Dr Goh’s position was that he was unable to remember what had happened to the Funds. This, however, was discovered to be untrue. On 27 August 2020, the Plaintiff’s counsel, Drew & Napier (“D&N”), learnt from the Official Assignee’s (the “OA”) office that Dr Goh had informed them that he had lost the Funds due to “bad investments” in China. The full statement Dr Goh gave to the OA’s office was as follows:
- [10]
[10] I pause to note that Dr Goh later attempted to clarify in August 2021 (during the contempt proceedings: see [20] to [26] below) that these “business obligations, debts and investment loses” were gambling losses. Specifically, he claimed that the Funds had been paid “to junkets in China who had supplied [him] with gambling and rolling chips”.
- [11]
[11] I interject with his subsequent clarification at this stage because – as will become apparent at [17] below – Dr Goh will come to explain in April 2021 that he was a gambler, and had lost the Funds as a result of his gambling habit. As the phrase, “business obligations, debts and investment losses” is slightly ambiguous, I thought it necessary for it to be seen in that light. That said, I hasten to add that, whether Dr Goh was being truthful as to the fact that all “S$18 million worth of RMB” in the HSBC-GZ Account had been lost to gambling, was not an issue I needed to determine for the purposes of finding him in contempt.
- [12]
[12] I return then to the chronology of events after D&N learnt of Dr Goh’s response to the OA’s office on 27 August 2020. Almost immediately, they wrote to him on 28 August 2020, asking that he clarify what happened to the Funds in the HSBC-GZ Account. In response, Dr Goh affirmed another affidavit on 28 August 2020 (the “August 2020 Affidavit”) and, in answer to that question, stated as follows:
- [13]
[13] By this, Dr Goh solidified the response in his earlier July 2020 Affidavit. Having received Dr Goh’s July 2020 and August 2020 Affidavits, the Plaintiff took the view that he had not, in either of those affidavits, provided a sufficient account of Sales Proceeds nor any useful information. Indeed, the two affidavits filed by Dr Goh spanned less than eight pages in total, and although they contained some exhibits, these were of no real value to the Plaintiff insofar as they were concerned with tracing the Funds.
- [14]
[14] Accordingly, on 18 September 2020, D&N sent another letter to Dr Goh demanding information. It stated that the Plaintiff was “completely unconvinced that [he had] simply forgotten what happened to the Funds [in the HSBC-GZ Account]”, but was prepared to give him “one final opportunity to comply with ORC 3219 fully”. It was only at this point that Dr Goh departed from his earlier position that he could not remember what had happened with the Funds. On 22 September 2020, he responded to D&N – by way of email – that the Funds had been “expended to Chinese businessmen [to] whom [he] owed financial obligations”. However, he provided no details as he claimed that he was unable to recall any, and that he was “still waiting for HSBC China to assist”.
- [15]
[15] It should not be surprising that the Plaintiff was not satisfied with this response. Therefore, on 24 September 2020, D&N sent a further letter to Dr Goh which stated the following. First, that the Plaintiff disagreed that HSBC China would be able to render any assistance as any bank statements it could provide would show no more than the bare account numbers to whom any transfers of the Funds were made. They would not indicate the identities of these “Chinese businessmen”. Second, given the minimal utility of such statements, that Dr Goh was to file a further affidavit – no later than 30 September 2020 – identifying the “Chinese businessmen” and providing documentary proof of the financial obligations owed to them. On 5 October 2020, Dr Goh responded by email stating, essentially, that he was not able to remember, nor did he have any relevant documents.
- [16]
[16] In light of this unhelpful response, on 12 October 2020, the Plaintiff filed an application to commence the present contempt proceedings against Dr Goh. On 13 November 2020, she was granted leave to do so by Woo J, and thereafter, the matter came before me on 30 August 2021.
- [17]
[17] I will turn to the defence Dr Goh put up at the contempt proceedings before me momentarily. Before I do so, however, it is worth nothing that, prior to the hearing, the Plaintiff commenced bankruptcy examination proceedings under s 83 of the Bankruptcy Act (Cap 20, 2009 Rev Ed) against Dr Goh. This took place on 12 and 13 April 2021 before Assistant Registrar Sim Junhui (the “Examination Proceedings”). During these proceedings, Dr Goh said that the “Chinese businessmen” referenced in his earlier 22 September 2020 email were, in fact, casino junkets. He claimed to be a very big gambler, and that he had lost the Funds in the HSBC-GZ Account on gambling in Macau. Specifically, he stated that both amounts of ¥39,428,736 and ¥46,720,151.01 – forming the subject of the HSBC Orders – were completely lost in this way. This was first time Dr Goh raised his gambling habit (cross-reference [11] above), and it was a position he maintained during the contempt proceedings.
- [18]
[18] In summary, in July and August 2020, Dr Goh affirmed two affidavits in which he stated unequivocally that he could not remember what had happened to the Funds in his HSBC-GZ Account. These two affidavits were prepared pursuant to ORC 3219 and served on the Plaintiff. However, in August 2020, Dr Goh informed the OA’s office that the Funds had been used to pay off “business obligations, debts and investment losses incurred in China”. When questioned further by the Plaintiff in September 2020, he then departed from his position that he “could not remember”, and told the Plaintiff that the Funds had been paid to “Chinese businessmen”, though he claimed to be unable to remember who these individuals were. Finally, in April 2021, Dr Goh sought to clarify in the Examination Proceedings that the “Chinese businessmen” he mentioned in September 2020 were, in fact, casino junkets.
- [19]
[19] With this sequence of events in mind, I turn to the contempt proceedings which took place before me on 30 August and 19 October 2021.
The contempt proceedings; Dr Goh’s contempt
- [20]
[20] The Plaintiff ultimately elected to proceed with the present contempt proceedings only on the basis of the HSBC Orders and the Funds. As stated at [5] above, these concerned the ¥39,428,736 and ¥46,720,151.01 transferred by the Plaintiff, on 24 October 2013 and 26 November 2013 respectively, to Dr Goh’s HSBC-GZ Account. I highlight this because the Plaintiff’s application originally referred to another two sums paid into other accounts belonging to Dr Goh, but these were not pursued.
- [22]
[22] The fundamental issue with this claim, however, was that he clearly stated – in his July 2020 and August 2020 Affidavits – that he was unable to recall what had happened to the relevant sums of monies paid by the Plaintiff into his HSBC-GZ Account, when that was not the case. It can therefore hardly be said that Dr Goh complied “at all times”. Indeed, the evidence (set out from [8] to [15] above) shows clearly that Dr Goh knew what had happened to the money, but did not disclose that information to the Plaintiff.
- [23]
[23] In his August 2021 Affidavit, Dr Goh attempted to justify this action – ie, his earlier answers that he could not remember. He explained that he was unable to recall the precise details of how he had dealt with the Funds in the HSBC-GZ Account due to various factors such as the stress from the onslaught of multiple and protracted litigation, his age, and his diabetic condition. More specifically, he claimed that the multiple and protracted law suits he faced had “overwhelmed [him] with information”. He was thus “unable to completely recall whether [he] had received the entirety of the Sale Proceeds and if so where these monies [had been] transferred to, and whether the monies relate[d] to the Sale Proceeds or some other unrelated transaction raised in a separate suit”. He also claimed that he suffered from dyslexia, and always had had a weak ability to retain details. At the age of 66 years, his memory was worsening, and he was increasingly unable to remember details of past events, especially those that had taken place seven years ago.
- [24]
[24] The only meaningful point which arises from this aspect of his August 2021 Affidavit is that he had no recollection of the details of the transfers out of his HSBC-GZ Account, not that he could not recall the general position that the Funds had been gambled away in Macau. This, however, did not aid Dr Goh’s defence. To the contrary, it illustrated why his claims that he “could not recall” in his July 2020 and August 2020 Affidavits were particularly invidious.
- [25]
[25] On 30 August 2021, he elected to give evidence from the witness box before me, and was subject to cross-examination by Ms Morgan. During cross-examination, he accepted without hesitation that he recalled the “general event” of losing the Funds by gambling in Macau. Instead, he sought to explain why he did not disclose this “general event” to the Plaintiff for what appeared to me to be two connected reasons, though he did not explain them in a particularly coherent manner.
(a) First, Dr Goh said that his gambling losses were “huge, very depressing and embarrassing”, and that he was “afraid to tell opposing counsel [ie, D&N], who [he] thought was quite adversarial”. He even went as far as to say that he was “shell-shocked” at the time ORC 3129 had been served on him.
(b) Second, I understood that he did not wish to inform the Plaintiff that he had gambled the Funds away because he had no recollection of the specific payment details, and would not have been able to provide such details until the bank, HSBC China, had supplied him with the relevant bank statements.
- [26]
[26] The essence of Dr Goh’s evidence therefore seemed to be that he did not wish to disclose the fact of his gambling to the Plaintiff because he did not have the details to back up his assertion, which he knew the Plaintiff’s counsel, D&N, would demand, seeing as they were – as he put it – “quite adversarial”. Thus, on this basis, he said that he felt that he could only provide full details when he obtained the bank documents.
- [27]
[27] In my view, this was not a legitimate defence. The inability to provide a full account is not an excuse to provide no account. When the court orders an individual to account for certain funds, he or she is obliged to provide all information relating to those funds, even if such information is incomplete. It is antithetical to the accounting process to allow the obligor to pick and choose how and when he or she wishes to comply.
- [29]
[29] In this regard, I need only refer to the decision of the Court of Appeal in Pertamina Energy Trading Ltd v Karaha Bodas Co LLC and others [2007] 2 SLR(R) 518 (“Pertamina”). Here, the court stated at [51]:
The appropriate punishment
- [35]
[35] Third, in his application in B 940, Dr Goh declared that he had zero assets and total liabilities of $676,350 owing to unsecured creditors. This was despite the fact that he had multiple bank accounts which he used to receive substantial sums of money over the years (as Dr Goh himself later disclosed during the Examination Proceedings), including proceeds from the sale of his house at 36 Cove Way, Singapore 098272, and two motorcars. The house – at the time of his bankruptcy application – had only recently been sold to his wife for S$5.25m in April 2019, and the motorcars to undisclosed persons for a total of $310,000 in November 2019.
- [36]
[36] Though Dr Goh claimed that some of this money had been expended on gambling debts, many of his explanations – given during the Examination Proceedings in April 2021 – were simply that he could not remember. Not only was information about these sums of money not earlier volunteered in his July 2020 and August 2020 Affidavits, but the explanations Dr Goh also ultimately gave during the Examination Proceedings were still not particularly helpful to the Plaintiff, and further, not very reasonable in context.
- [37]
[37] Fourth, for the purposes of his B 940 application, Dr Goh also affirmed an affidavit on 6 March 2020, in which he stated that the cause of his insolvency was “business failure”. If, as he informed the court in the Examination Proceedings, he had lost all the monies in the HSBC-GZ Account to gambling losses, then the cause of his insolvency was certainly not “business failure”. Dr Goh attempted to explain in the Examination Proceedings that he had used the wrong words, but it is somewhat difficult to believe that Dr Goh – an entrepreneurial medical doctor – did not appreciate the differences between legitimate business failure, and failing as a high roller.
- [38]
[38] Finally, as noted above, ORC 3129 was obtained on 22 June 2020 and it was served on Dr Goh by way of personal service on 25 June. Thereafter, he did not act with any degree of urgency, or with any real initiative. This was so much so that the Plaintiff had to send six reminders to Dr Goh, from 16 July to 24 September 2020, demanding full compliance with ORC 3129. However, as can be seen from [13] to [17] above, nothing meaningful was forthcoming from Dr Goh until the Examination Proceedings and the August 2021 Affidavit, after the Plaintiff filed its application for committal. The threat of sanction ought not to have been needed for Dr Goh simply to take more proactive steps towards complying with ORC 3219.
- [41]
[41] In connection, I note that the Plaintiff did not believe that Dr Goh had indeed lost the Funds in the HSBC-GZ Account to gambling, and was of the view that he was actively impeding her efforts to trace the Funds. This was not surprising, though, not a factor I thought appropriate to take into account for the purposes of sentencing given that it was not proven before me, even though the inference was strong.
- [43]
[43] Ms Morgan urged upon me to punish Dr Goh for contempt by ordering him to be imprisoned for no less than seven months, based on a number of precedents. The primary difficulty I had with her submission, however, was that it seemed to require a contempt of greater severity. That is, one which would have required me to find not only that Dr Goh had lied in the July 2020 and August 2020 Affidavits in respect of his claims that he could not remember the “general event” of gambling, but also that he was either: (a) lying entirely about the fact that he had gambled away the Funds; or (b) lying about the fact that he could not recall the precise details of the payments out of the HSBC-GZ Accounts. As stated at [41] above, though the inference in respect of (a) was strong, it was not one I found to have been proven. In relation to (b), it similarly cannot be said to have been proven.
- [44]
[44] Ms Morgan also highlighted the prejudice that the Plaintiff has suffered from Dr Goh’s non-compliance, that is, her inability to recover any of the Funds to-date. I accept this to be the case. However, in my view, a sentence of seven months would cause even further delays to the accounting process. As I observed above, these contempt proceedings appear to have put some pep into Dr Goh’s step. Even if nothing meaningful has yet turned up, I can see that he has now applied effort towards complying with ORC 3219, albeit belatedly.
Conclusion