General Division of the High Court · Decided 6 April 2023
Raffles Education Corp Ltd and others v Shantanu Prakash and another
Feedback & support[2023] SGHC 89 · Case no. Suit No 709 of 2019
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [1]
[1] The first plaintiff, Raffles Education Corporation Limited (“REC”), is a Singapore company in the business of private education. Its Chairman and Chief Executive Officer (“CEO”) is Mr Chew Hua Seng (“Chew”). REC wholly owns the second plaintiff, Raffles Education Investment (India) Pte Ltd (“REI”), a Singapore company, and the third plaintiff, Raffles Design International India Pvt Ltd (“RDI”), a company incorporated in India. REI and RDI are also private education providers. Where appropriate, I refer to REC, REI and RDI as the Raffles Education Group (“REG”).
- [2]
[2] The first defendant, Mr Shantanu Prakash (“Shantanu”), is the founder of the Educomp group of companies (“Educomp”) which includes Educomp Solutions Ltd (“E-Solutions”), a publicly-listed company in India where he is Chairman and Managing Director (“MD”), Educomp Asia Pacific Pte Ltd (“E-AP”) and Educomp Professional Education Limited (“E-Prof”). E-AP and E-Prof are wholly owned by E-Solutions. Shantanu was a director of E-AP until 5 December 2016 and of E-Prof until at least 24 December 2013. The second defendant, Mr Dennis Lui (“Dennis”), is a Singaporean lawyer. He was a director of E-AP from 22 June 2009 to 5 December 2016 and of Edulearn Solutions Limited (“Edulearn”) from October 2013 to 15 October 2019.
- [3]
[3] Essentially the plaintiffs claim in this suit (“the Suit”) that the defendants had conspired and made misrepresentations that caused one or more of the plaintiffs to enter into a Share Purchase Agreement (“SPA”) and a Business Advisory Agreement (“BAA”) with counterparties under the defendants’ control, which they never intended for the counterparties to comply with. This, and the defendants’ other acts, had caused loss and damage to REG.
Background
Joint Venture Agreement and ERHEL
- [4]
[4] In around 2006, Chew and Shantanu discussed the prospect of REG and Educomp entering into a joint venture (“JV”) for the provision of education-related services in India. This resulted in REC and E-Solutions executing a Joint Venture Agreement dated 16 May 2008 (“JVA”), which provided for the parties to procure the incorporation of entities for the establishment of their higher education business in India. Pursuant to the JVA, Educomp-Raffles Higher Education Limited (“ERHEL”) was incorporated on or about 6 June 2008, and which shares were eventually held by REI and RDI (58.18%) and E-AP/E-Prof (41.82%). Chew and Shantanu were appointed directors. ERHEL subsequently set up various education establishments in India.
JRRES and MIDL
- [5]
[5] In around mid-2008, Chew and Shantanu discussed the JV setting up a management college and technical university in India (“College”) via the Jai Radha Raman Education Society (“JRRES”). JRRES is a private not-for-profit society in the business of running educational institutions. It had a lease over a 44-acre site in the Greater Noida Area (“Noida Site”) and intended to build a management and technical university on the Noida Site.
- [6]
[6] JRRES consists of a general body of all its members (“General Body”) and the governing body (“Governing Body”) (collectively the “JRRES Bodies”). At that time, the members of the Governing Body were appointed by the General Body and with the former deciding on key matters in JRRES. Around end 2008 or early 2009, Shantanu became a life member of JRRES.
- [7]
[7] On 1 July 2009, ERHEL and JRRES entered into a loan agreement (“Loan Agreement”) whereby ERHEL loaned JRRES INR500m for the latter to establish the College (or “Noida College”). Subsequently, ERHEL and JRRES executed three addenda to the Loan Agreement, which provided for an increase in the principal loan amount to INR600m. ERHEL disbursed INR513,655,098 to JRRES between 2008 and 2014 which Chew asserts JRRES has to-date failed to repay. Shantanu does not dispute that ERHEL has disbursed around INR 1,100m to JRRES.
- [8]
[8] Construction of Noida College began in 2009 but fell behind schedule. Thus, Millennium Infra Developers Limited (“MIDL”) was incorporated on 21 January 2010 (as a wholly-owned subsidiary of ERHEL) to take over its construction, and entered into a Project Management and Construction Agreement (“PMC”) with JRRES on 17 February 2010 for this purpose.
- [9]
[9] In 2011, construction of Noida College was completed. It obtained approval from the All India Council for Technical Education (“AICTE”) and the Government of Uttar Pradesh to conduct engineering and management courses for the 2011–2012 academic year. It then began to admit students.
- [10]
[10] I will refer to JRRES, ERHEL and MIDL collectively as the “JV Entities”. I note Shantanu’s assertion that JRRES was not part of the JV, an issue which I will return to.
Educomp’s potential exit from the JV and changes to the JRRES Bodies
- [11]
[11] In or around mid-2011, E-Solutions faced cash flow problems and contemplated exiting the JV. Chew and Shantanu discussed several options, but nothing materialised. In the interim, REG continued funding the JV. Subsequently, REC, E-Solutions and ERHEL executed an addendum to the JVA dated 9 May 2012 for REC and E-Solutions to inject funds into ERHEL with equity in ERHEL to be issued proportionate to the funding received.
- [12]
[12] Educomp did not match REG’s injection of capital into ERHEL. In July 2013, E-Solutions embarked on corporate debt restructuring proceedings and filed for insolvency in May 2017. Due to the mismatch in funding, REG’s shareholding in ERHEL increased to 58.18%, with a concomitant fall in Educomp’s shareholding to 41.82%, in around 28 November 2013.
- [13]
[13] On 17 December 2013, REC’s representatives Chew, Mr Mike Yam (“Mike”) and Mr Sunil Peter (“Sunil”), met E-Solutions’ representatives Shantanu and Mr Harpreet Singh (“Harpreet”) and discussed a potential sale of JRRES. They met again on 28 January 2014 and discussed the future funding of the JV. REC was willing to invest up to INR350m in the JV Entities. It was further agreed that the composition of the JRRES Bodies would be aligned with the shareholding in ERHEL, such that each of REG and Educomp would have an equal number of nominees on them (“JRRES Changes”).
- [14]
[14] To effect the JRRES Changes, the JRRES rules were amended to create a position of Chairman (to which Chew was subsequently appointed) with equal standing and powers in the Governing Body as the President (ie, Shantanu), and to increase the size of the General Body from 12 to 16 members.
- [15]
[15] Thereafter: (a) Dr Bindu Rana (“Bindu”), Mr Soumya Kanti (“Soumya”) and Mr Mohan Krishnan Lakhramraju (“Mohan”) resigned from the Governing Body; (b) Ms Priya Prakash (“Priya”), Dr Anjlee Prakash (“Anjlee”) and Mr Mansoor Raza (“Raza”) resigned from the General Body; and (c) new persons were inducted as members of the JRRES Bodies. By April 2014, REG had five nominees (including Chew), while Educomp was represented by Shantanu, Harpreet, Mr Jagdish Prakash (“Jagdish”, Shantanu’s father), Mr Pramod Thatoi (“Pramod”) and Mr Ashok Mehta (“Ashok”), on the Governing Body. As for the General Body, REG had eight nominees and so did Educomp (ie, the five persons on the Governing Body and Bindu, Soumya and Mohan).
JRRES Sale and Purchase Agreement
- [16]
[16] On 5 May 2014, Chew, Mike, Ms Doris Chung (Chew’s wife, a director of REI and RDI) (“Doris”) and Mr Rick John Tham (Director of Legal, REC) (“John”) met Shantanu and Harpreet in Singapore to discuss the potential sale of JRRES’s assets. In the interim, JRRES required funding of INR180m to continue with its near-term operations.
- [17]
[17] RDI and JRRES thus entered into a Sale and Purchase Agreement on 6 May 2014 (“JRRES SPA”), which governed RDI’s purchase of JRRES’s rights and interests to the Noida Site for INR3 billion, to be completed within six months. RDI paid INR40m and INR100m to JRRES (as advanced sale consideration) around 13 May 2014 and 29 May 2015 respectively.
Share Purchase Agreement
- [18]
[18] In January 2015, Shantanu discussed with Doris and/or Chew about REG buying Educomp’s stake in the JV Entities. Ms Jyotsna Sharma (“Jyotsna”), Educomp’s in-house counsel, prepared and forwarded term sheets (“Term Sheets”) to REG. REG’s lawyers then prepared a draft of a share purchase agreement, which John circulated on 21 February 2015 to Mr Ashish Mittal (“Ashish”), E-Solutions’ Chief Financial Officer (“CFO”), and Jyotsna.
- [19]
[19] From around 10 to 13 March 2015, Doris and John (from REG) and Dennis, Ashish and Jyotsna (from Educomp) conducted negotiations on the draft share purchase agreement in Singapore (“Mar 2015 Meetings”). Discussions crystallised in the execution of the SPA dated 12 March 2015. The parties to the SPA comprised E-AP and E-Prof (“Sellers”), and REI and RDI (“Purchasers”). Ashish signed the SPA on the Sellers’ behalf.
- [20]
[20] In particular, the SPA provided as follows:
(a) The Sellers shall sell E-AP’s shares in ERHEL to REI and E-Prof’s shares in ERHEL to RDI for a total of INR986.4m (“SPA Consideration”).
(b) The Purchasers shall deposit INR98.64m (“SPA Deposit”), being 10% of the SPA Consideration, to the escrow agent on execution of the SPA. Thereafter, the Sellers shall allow the Purchasers “to take control of [ERHEL] and JRRES limited to the extent that the Purchasers shall have absolute say on the hiring and dismissal of employees” (cl 3).
(c) The Sellers are to submit the originals of documents set out in cl 4.1 to the escrow agent, by 5 July 2015 (“Cl 4.1 Docs”). Thereafter, the Purchasers shall, by 10 July 2015, inform the escrow agent and Sellers of the availability of funds to discharge the remaining purchase price.
(d) The Sellers are to submit the originals of documents listed in cl 4.4 to the escrow agent by 29 July 2015 (“Cl 4.4 Docs”). These included signed letters from persons listed in Annexure D of the SPA (“Annex D Persons”) resigning from the JRRES Bodies (cl 4.4.5).
(e) Finally, closing is to take place on 31 July 2015 (“Closing Date”) and deemed to have taken place after various steps are completed, including payment of the remaining SPA consideration (ie, 90% of INR986.4m) to the Sellers (cl 5) (“Closing”).
- [21]
[21] The Purchasers then paid the SPA Deposit to the escrow agent. On 12 March 2015, REC announced on the Singapore Exchange (“SGX”) that it had through REI and RDI entered into the SPA to acquire E-Solution’s 41.82% stake in ERHEL for INR986.4m (“12/3/15 SGX Announcement”).
Business Advisory Agreement
- [22]
[22] REI and Edulearn concurrently executed a BAA dated 12 March 2015. The BAA culminated from the time the Term Sheets were negotiated in January 2015. Then, the draft was an “MOU” with the parties being REC and Shantanu as “Advisor”, but which Advisor was then changed to Edulearn in March 2015.
- [23]
[23] In particular, the BAA provided as follows:
(a) Edulearn would provide advisory services to REI on, among other things, the operation and management of higher education business. The services would be provided through Edulearn’s directors “that shall include [Shantanu]”. Should he cease to be a director, Edulearn is to engage Shantanu as a consultant to provide the services.
(b) REI would pay Edulearn INR100m (“BAA Consideration”) comprising INR10m on execution of the BAA (“BAA Initial Payment”) and the balance payable to the escrow agent on the SPA Closing Date.
(c) If Closing did not occur by the Closing Date due to the Sellers’ default, Edulearn was to refund the BAA Initial Payment within five business days of the receipt of notice from REI requesting the same.
- [24]
[24] Also on 12 March 2015, Dennis, in his capacity as Edulearn’s lawyer, provided REI with an undertaking to confirm that Shantanu “has been appointed director of [Edulearn] with effect from 10 February 2015” and to undertake to deliver a Certificate of Incumbency (“COI”) to REI by 31 March 2015 (“12/3/15 Undertaking”). REI also paid Edulearn the BAA Initial Payment.
Failure to complete the SPA and arbitration proceedings
- [25]
[25] The Sellers failed to fully comply with cl 4.1 of the SPA by 5 July 2015. To allow them more time to submit the necessary documents, the Closing Date was extended to 13 and then 19 August 2015 (“New Closing Date”).
- [26]
[26] On 18 August 2015, Dennis informed John that his clients were facing “practical difficulties” in completing the Closing and that Shantanu suggested deferring the New Closing Date or terminating the SPA.
- [27]
[27] John replied to Dennis on 19 August 2015 (“John’s 19/8/15 Email”), conveying REG’s proposal as follows (“Proposal”). The New Closing Date would be extended by 30 days from 19 August 2015 (“Extended Closing Date”). The Sellers were to comply with all the condition precedents of the SPA (save for procuring the resignations of Harpreet and Soumya from JRRES) within seven working days. If the Sellers were unable to procure Harpreet’s and Soumya’s resignations by the Extended Closing Date, they would still have to complete the SPA and deposit 10% of the SPA Consideration into stakeholding. The Sellers were to then obtain the resignations of Harpeet and Soumya within six months from the Extended Closing Date failing which the SPA should still be completed and the Purchasers would forfeit the Sellers’ deposit.
- [28]
[28] On 20 August 2015, Dennis informed John that his clients were unable to close the SPA due to “practical restraints” but wish to close on the basis of satisfying all closing conditions. Dennis proposed adjourning the closing for “4 months hence” (“Counter-Proposal”). John replied that REG was not agreeable to a further unconditional extension of the Extended Closing Date and that the Proposal stood until 20 August 2015. On 21 August 2015, Dennis reiterated the Counter-Proposal, whereupon John sought clarification on the “practical restraints” the Sellers faced. As Dennis did not reply, John placed his non-response on record in a final email of 25 August 2015.
- [29]
[29] On 2 September 2015, the Purchasers sent a letter to the Sellers calling on them to comply with their obligations under, and to close, the SPA. On 15 September 2015, the Purchasers commenced arbitration proceedings against the Sellers (“Arbitration”) in the Singapore International Arbitration Centre (“SIAC”) on the SPA. REC announced the Arbitration on the SGX on 16 September 2015 (“16/9/15 SGX Announcement”).
- [30]
[30] Shortly after, the following letters were exchanged:
(a) On 24 September 2015, the Purchasers’ Indian lawyers, Luthra & Luthra, informed the Sellers to comply with the SPA.
(b) On 25 September 2015, the Sellers issued a notice to terminate the SPA (“Termination Notice”) on the basis that the Purchasers had committed a repudiatory breach of the confidentiality clause of the SPA (cl 11) by REC announcing the Arbitration via the 16/9/15 SGX Announcement. Alternatively, the SPA had been frustrated as the Sellers could not procure the Annex D Persons’ resignations, which they claimed the obligation was only on a “best effort” basis. The Sellers asked the Purchasers to waive the performance of cll 4.4.2, 4.4.3 and 4.4.5 of the SPA or mutually terminate the SPA pursuant to cl 9.1.1.
(c) On 29 September 2015, the Purchasers stated they were not agreeable to waiving the conditions in cl 4.1 or 4.4 of the SPA or terminating the SPA; the 16/9/15 SGX Announcement did not breach cl 11; and there was no frustration of the SPA as the Sellers’ obligation to procure the resignations of the Annex D Persons was mandatory.
- [31]
[31] In the Arbitration, the Purchasers sought specific performance, alternatively damages for the Sellers’ breaches, of the SPA. The SIAC Tribunal (“Tribunal”) issued a final award on 31 March 2017 (“Final Award”) in the Purchasers’ favour, ordering the Sellers to pay INR 163.2m (constituting damages for their breaches of cll 4.1, 4.3 and 4.4 of the SPA) to the Purchasers; the Sellers to introduce an amount equivalent to the total funding contributed by the Purchasers in JRRES for its operations between 12 March 2015 to 31 March 2017; and the SPA Deposit to be released to the Purchasers with interest.
- [32]
[32] Thereafter, REI sought a refund of the BAA Initial Payment via two letters to Edulearn dated 8 May 2017 and 11 February 2019, which Edulearn has not refunded to date.
REG’s claims
- [33]
[33] I briefly set out REG’s claims against the defendants here.
Unlawful means conspiracy and misrepresentation
- [34]
[34] REG pleads that the defendants are liable for unlawful means conspiracy and set out three conspiracies, ie, the “SPA Conspiracy”, “BAA Conspiracy” and “Wrongful Conduct Conspiracy”. Overarching them is a claim that the defendants devised a plan to mislead REG into believing that Educomp would agree to a buy-out of its stake in the JV when it possessed no such intention. This is so REG would continue to fund the JV Entities while Shantanu retained control of JRRES and Noida College (“the Conspiracy”).
- [35]
[35] In respect of the SPA Conspiracy, REG claims that from around late 2014 to 13 March 2015 (when the SPA and BAA were executed), the defendants or their representatives conspired to make the following false representations to REG to induce the Purchasers to enter into the SPA with the Sellers, which they never intended for the Sellers to comply with and subsequently induced the Sellers to breach (“SPA Reps”):
(a) E-Solutions and/or Educomp would give up their stake in and control of the JV Entities (including JRRES).
(b) E-Solutions and/or Educomp could and would ensure that complete control over JRRES would be ceded to REG following their exit from the JV since Shantanu was JRRES President and E-Solutions/Educomp (through E-AP and E-Prof) were in control of their 50% membership in JRRES and thus able to procure the resignations of their nominee members in the JRRES Bodies and to provide for REG’s nominees to take over those positions.
- [36]
[36] The SPA Reps were made via email and phone calls by Shantanu to Doris and/or Chew, and by Ashish to Doris. They were repeated by Ashish and Dennis to Doris and John at the Mar 2015 Meetings. Alternatively, the SPA Reps were implied by words or conduct.
- [37]
[37] As for the BAA Conspiracy, REG pleads that, during negotiations on the BAA, the defendants (or their representatives) conspired to make the following false representations to induce REI to enter into the BAA which they never intended Edulearn to comply with and subsequently induced it to breach (“BAA Reps”):
(a) The defendants/E-AP/E-Prof would take steps to ensure that closing under the SPA would materialise.
(b) Edulearn would abide by the terms of the BAA, including cl 3.2.5.1, which required it to refund the BAA Initial Payment to REI if Closing did not materialise due to the Sellers’ default.
- [38]
[38] Consequently, following non-completion under the SPA, Edulearn retained the BAA Initial Payment for Shantanu’s benefit in breach of the BAA.
- [39]
[39] Finally, REG claims, by the Wrongful Conduct Conspiracy, that the defendants conspired to engage in wrongful conduct vis-à-vis Educomp, JRRES and Noida College by, amongst other acts, inducing Educomp/the Sellers to continue acting in breach of the Final Award and causing JRRES to default on its various obligations. REG claims that this conspiracy was achieved through unlawful means as the defendants breached their director’s duties owed to E-AP/E-Prof/Edulearn by participating in the conspiracy and which was brought about through fraudulent misrepresentations.
- [40]
[40] REG also pleads that the defendants are liable for fraudulent or negligent misrepresentation for making the SPA and BAA Reps.
REG’s other claims
- [41]
[41] Further, and/or in the alternative, REG claims: (a) the defendants are liable to REI and RDI for inducing E-AP, E-Prof and Edulearn to breach the SPA and the BAA; and (b) Shantanu is liable to REG for the tort of causing loss by unlawful means and to REC for inducing E-Solutions to breach the JVA.
Preliminary issues
- [42]
[42] I begin by dealing with some preliminary issues.
Issue estoppel arising from the Arbitration
- [43]
[43] REG’s counsel, Ms Wendy Lin (“Ms Lin”), submits the defendants are bound by the Tribunal’s findings in the Arbitration, in that: (a) REG and Educomp had nominated their affiliates as nominees to be members of JRRES, to control JRRES through the membership; (b) the Sellers breached the SPA by failing to provide the completion documents in accordance with cll 4.1, 4.3 and 4.4 of the SPA, which were mandatory; and (c) the Sellers could not rely on cl 5.9 of the SPA as failure to complete was caused by their default.
- [44]
[44] To raise an issue estoppel, there must be a final and conclusive judgment on the merits from a court of competent jurisdiction and there must be identity of parties and of subject matter in the two actions (Lee Tat Development Pte Ltd v Management Corporation Strata Title Plan No 301 [2005] 3 SLR(R) 157 at [14]–[15]). An arbitral award can constitute a final and conclusive determination for this purpose (AKN and another v ALC and others and other appeals [2016] 1 SLR 966 at [57]–[59]). The required commonality is a direct, parallel or corresponding interest in the subject matter of the litigation, and not simply a financial interest in the result of the action (Ong Han Nam v Borneo Ventures Pte Ltd [2021] 1 SLR 1248 at [59]). The issue here is whether there is identity of parties in that the defendants are privies of E-AP.
- [45]
[45] I find no issue estoppel arises in relation to Dennis. He is not a privy of E-AP and there is no identity of parties. REG seeks to show the connection between them by Dennis’ directorship of E-AP, his involvement in the execution and subsequent non-performance of the SPA, his awareness of the Arbitration, and that he would have been able to enjoy the benefit of an award made in the Sellers’ favour. But these merely show Dennis had a financial interest in the result of the Arbitration. He was not a party to the Arbitration nor could he have been one, and Shantanu’s testimony that Dennis was not involved in the Sellers’ conduct of the Arbitration was unchallenged. As for Dennis’ involvement in the non-performance of the SPA, the Tribunal had merely commented that there were exchanges between lawyers who were seeking to understand each side’s position and attempting to negotiate a resolution.
- [46]
[46] However, I find there was privity of interest between Shantanu and the Sellers, and identity of parties. He was the main director of E-AP. Both defendants attested that Dennis was merely a nominee director appointed by Shantanu, and it was Shantanu who had instructed E-Solutions to appoint Dennis as E-AP’s director. Shantanu was the only person making key decisions and approving the SPA on E-AP’s behalf and, as will be seen later, the key person involved in the subsequent non-performance of the SPA. Ashish also attested that he took instructions from Shantanu on important matters pertaining to the SPA negotiations. On the whole, I find Shantanu was the key person giving instructions (for the Sellers) on the conduct of the Arbitration and he had a direct, parallel or corresponding interest in the subject matter of it.
- [47]
[47] That said, although REG relies on the Final Award to establish that Shantanu controlled the Annex D Persons, at the highest, the Tribunal found REG and Educomp had nominated their affiliates as nominees of JRRES with a view to exercising control over JRRES and made this finding to refute the Sellers’ claim that their obligations under cll 4.3 and 4.4 of the SPA were on a best-effort basis. This is distinct from the question of whether Shantanu had control over the Annex D Persons such that he could compel them to resign from the JRRES Bodies.
- [48]
[48] In any event, even if I disregard the Tribunal’s findings, this would not make a difference to my determination on the material issues in the Suit.
Whether certain claims sufficiently pleaded and abuse of process
- [49]
[49] Next, Ms Lin took issue with Shantanu’s reliance on the doctrines of approbation and reprobation, waiver by election and abuse of process to assert that REG is not permitted to claim misrepresentation (in respect of the SPA Reps) as it had sought specific performance of the SPA in the Arbitration. Mr Poon (Shantanu’s counsel), on the other hand, submits that REG failed to plead its claims that Shantanu (through Dennis) fraudulently represented to REG that he had been appointed Edulearn’s director with effect from 10 February 2015 in the 12/3/15 Undertaking (“Directorship Representation”) (see [24] above) and that Shantanu induced a breach of the JRRES SPA (“JRRES Inducement Claim”). Mr Padman (Dennis’ counsel) contends that REG did not plead the tort of lawful means conspiracy.
- [50]
[50] Before me, Ms Lin stated she was no longer relying on the Directorship Representation as a standalone tortious claim. I thus consider the alleged Directorship Representation only where relevant to REG’s pleaded case.
- [51]
[51] The doctrine of abuse of process must be pleaded (Eng Hui Cheh David v Opera Gallery Pte Ltd [2009] SGHC 121 at [132]), and likewise, the defences of approbation and reprobation and of waiver by election. Waiver by election is fact-dependent and pleading the material facts is an indispensable foundation upon which a plea of waiver rests (Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology v Stansfield College Pte Ltd and another [2018] SGHC 232 at [124]). As for the doctrine of approbation and reprobation, the nature of the inquiry would involve consideration of whether a party has received an actual benefit because of an earlier inconsistent position (BWG v BWF [2020] 1 SLR 1296 (“BWG”) at [118]). This would render it imperative for the opposing party to know the case it has to meet.
- [52]
[52] Mr Poon relies on paragraph 71 of Shantanu’s Defence (as follows) to show that the defences of approbation and reprobation and of waiver by election were sufficiently pleaded:
- [53]
[53] At a general level, the doctrines of approbation and reprobation and of waiver by election prohibit a party from raising a new position inconsistent with a prior position. Inconsistent positions are broadly dealt with under the doctrine of abuse of process, which is ultimately exercised at the court’s discretion (BWG at [53], [100], [101], [121] and [127]). Nevertheless, it is unclear, having regard to the spirit of pleadings, that Shantanu has sufficiently informed REG that he intends to rely on approbation and reprobation and of waiver by election by mere reference to “abuse of process” in his Defence, as it is not necessarily the case that the doctrines are exactly the same. REG’s witnesses have not prepared their affidavits of evidence-in-chief (“AEIC”) to respond to Shantanu relying on approbation and reprobation and waiver by election, and Shantanu has also not attested to state that REG has taken inconsistent positions in the Suit and Arbitration.
- [54]
[54] In any event, these defences would not succeed. REG has not taken inconsistent positions in the Arbitration and Suit. It only sought damages for its claims in misrepresentation and had treated the SPA as valid, even seeking its specific performance in the Arbitration. Misrepresentation does not render a contract void ab initio but merely voidable. There is no inconsistency between specific performance or damages for breach of the SPA being sought on one hand, and damages for misrepresentation on the other. The latter claim is predicated on a party being misled into entering a contract, which wrong may exist independently of a claim for a breach of the contract. Hence, there is no contradiction in the positions adopted by the claimants in the two proceedings, even if the basis for calculating damages may differ for a claim for breach of contract and for misrepresentation.
- [55]
[55] Additionally, REG could not have brought a misrepresentation claim for the SPA Reps against Shantanu in the Arbitration. He was not a party to the SPA and any dispute pertaining to the SPA had to be resolved by arbitration pursuant to cl 15 of the SPA. That said, the Purchasers having succeeded in the Arbitration on the basis that the Sellers breached the terms of the SPA may have a bearing on the issue of double recovery. I address this if and when appropriate.
- [56]
[56] Next, I am of the view that REG pleaded its claim in lawful means conspiracy. It pleaded in the alternative the defendants’ conduct as “evidence of a predominant and/or intention on [the defendants] to induce [E-AP, E-Prof and Edulearn] to breach their respective obligations under the SPA and BAA”, essentially being the element of “predominant purpose” to cause injury, for lawful means conspiracy. Even if I disregard the claim as not being pleaded, this would make no difference to REG’s claims as will be seen later.
- [57]
[57] I find however, that the JRRES Inducement Claim was not pleaded. Ms Lin submits the facts underlying this claim are set out in para 33(c) of the Statement of Claim (“SOC”), which reads “[c]ausing JRRES to default on its contractual obligations under the JRRES SPA”. However, this excerpt must be read in context of the whole SOC. It falls under para 33 which discusses “the Educomp Group’s wrongful conduct vis-à-vis JRRES and Noida College” [emphasis added], the subsection “Educomp’s SPA Breaches and continuing wrongful conduct”, and the header “BACKGROUND”. The focus of the averment is thus Educomp’s conduct in relation to JRRES, even assuming that Shantanu is its directing mind. Pertinently, para 33(c) of the SOC pleads Shantanu’s conduct as limited to failing to cause JRRES to obtain requisite approvals pursuant to JRRES’s obligations under the JRRES SPA, which is not what REG is relying on for the JRRES Inducement Claim; rather REG is relying on Shantanu’s conduct as causing JRRES to refuse to refund the Advance Sale Consideration which is not pleaded (see also [280]–[281] below). Furthermore, the “BACKGROUND” portion of the SOC is ultimately relied upon to ground REG’s claims in sections C, C1, C2, C3 and D of the SOC which claims are specifically set out and do not include the JRRES Inducement Claim.
- [58]
[58] I agree that Shantanu would be prejudiced if REG were allowed to advance the JRRES Inducement Claim, of which he has not been given a proper opportunity to respond to, including whether and to what extent the principle in Said v Butt [1920] 2 KB 497 (“Said v Butt”) applies to JRRES being a society.
Shantanu’s control over the Annex D Persons
- [59]
[59] I proceed, at the outset, to deal with whether Shantanu had control over the Annex D Persons. I find that he wielded control over them even when the parties were negotiating the Term Sheets and when the Annex D Persons’ resignations were purportedly sought in 2015 after the SPA was executed.
- [60]
[60] The evidence from the time JRRES came to be part of the JV between REC and E-Solutions consistently point to the above. I find they had envisaged JRRES to be the vehicle through which they would employ staff and run Noida College and it was commercially absurd for the parties to proceed on this basis if they could not exercise control over JRRES via their nominees therein.
- [61]
[61] In October 2007, Shantanu and Mr Rohit Kumar (“Rohit”) from E-Solutions, met with Chew and Mr Kenneth Ho (“Kenneth”) (CFO of REC). E-Solutions proposed structuring the JV through three entities, one of which would employ staff and run the colleges on a day-to-day basis and may “need to be a non-profit organi[s]ation to comply with [the] [I]ndian regulatory environment”. Significantly, Educomp proposed a “partnership” in respect of the “operating company/Trust”.
- [62]
[62] The three-entity structure envisaged was subsequently reflected in the JVA in May 2008. Clause 3.1 stated that REC and E-Solutions would procure the incorporation of two companies and “such other companies … trusts … or non-profit organisations as may be deemed necessary” (cl 3.1.1.3). Additionally, cl 5.8 provided that if any entity had to be organised “as a trust or foundation”, E-Solutions and REC would be able to nominate an equal number of trustees, with the Chairperson being either an Educomp or Raffles nominee.
- [63]
[63] I reject Shantanu’s claim that cll 3.1.1.3 and 5.8 of the JVA did not give effect to the three-entity structure as initially proposed by E-Solutions’ as the JVA applied to setting up of an entity and not to taking control of a pre-existing one such as JRRES. Shantanu agrees the JVA spoke in “general terms about the incorporation of new entities” as parties had yet to identify any specific or “pre-existing” entities the JV might wish to partner with or “acquire”. Thus, despite the language of cl 3.1.1.3, the JVA parties envisaged leveraging and eventually leveraged on a pre-existing entity, ie, JRRES.
- [64]
[64] Then, on 27 May 2008, shortly after the JVA was executed and when Chew and Shantanu were discussing the potential involvement of JRRES as a JV entity, Rohit emailed Chew (copied to Shantanu) as follows (“Rohit’s Email”):
- [65]
[65] Rohit’s Email supports that REC and E-Solutions believed they could exercise effective control over JRRES via their nominees and brought JRRES into the JV on that basis. I reject Shantanu’s claims that Rohit’s understanding was wrong and that “we” in the email did not refer to REC and E-Solutions. Shantanu never replied to refute what was stated in Rohit’s Email. Further, that E-Solutions had “appointed 8 trustees” is supported by the fact that eight persons were accepted into the General Body in May 2008.
- [66]
[66] In fact, the JVA parties proceeded as per Rohit’s Email. REC contributed about INR 640m in around June 2008, and the JVA parties acquired control of JRRES in broad accordance with the plan in Rohit’s Email:
(a) Between December 2008 and April 2012, persons aligned with Educomp, including Shantanu, his family members (Jagdish, Anjlee and Priya), Bindu (then E-Solutions’ employee), and his personal acquaintances Mohan and Harpreet (who became E-Solutions’ employee), were appointed JRRES members.
(b) On 6 September 2010, 11 persons whom Shantanu confirmed were all E-Solutions’ employees were elected to the Governing Body; and Harpreet agreed that by December 2010, most, if not all, of the “non-Educomp members” on the General Body had resigned.
(c) By June 2012, 14 of the 16 of the General Body members were E-Solutions’ employees; with Mike (from REC) and Mohan being the other two. Mohan was a director of Great Lakes Institute of Management, of which Shantanu was also a director and E-Solutions was associated with. I find Mohan was aligned with Shantanu.
(d) On 8 December 2012, the Governing Body resolved to limit the members in the Governing and General Bodies to ten and 12 respectively. Shantanu admitted this was so that he and Chew could “have complete control” of JRRES as they did not want unknown persons to apply for membership and “scuttle [their] control of JRRES”. At that time, the General Body appointed members to the Governing Body and the latter decided on key matters for JRRES. Hence, around 15 January 2013, the Governing and General Bodies were reconstituted with ten and 12 members respectively.
- [67]
[67] Next, the Supplementary Agreement to the JVA dated 21 September 2008 stated that it was “the intention of [E-Solutions] and REC to … appoint same number of trustees in and jointly man[a]ge [JRRES]”. I reject Shantanu’s assertion that this agreement was “non-binding”. He conceded the agreement reflected the parties’ intentions with respect to JRRES, and the JVA parties took steps to fulfil the objectives therein such as by constructing a university campus for JRRES. The JVA parties also subsequently appointed the “same number of trustees in” JRRES via the JRRES Changes in 2014 (see [13] above), consistent with their respective shareholding in JRRES.
- [68]
[68] The JRRES Changes are significant in two other respects. First, it created the position of Chairman (to be held by Chew) which had equal standing and powers of the JRRES President (Shantanu), “significantly” expanded the powers of the Chairman and President and correspondingly reduced the powers of the JRRES Bodies. All decisions in JRRES were now to be taken jointly by the Chairman and President unless specified otherwise, and they would jointly appoint members of the Governing Body. Shantanu accepts these amendments gave Chew and him “absolute control and say in JRRES”. Apart from General Body meetings held on 26 April 2014 and 19 May 2014 and Governing Body meetings held on 18 July 2014 and 10 July 2015, JRRES did not hold any meetings after these amendments, consistent with Shantanu’s and Chew’s plan to increase the powers of the President and Chairman and reduce the powers of the Governing Body.
- [69]
[69] Second, to effect the changes (in particular, increasing the membership of the General Body to 16 persons to equalise the number of REC nominees vis-à-vis E-Solutions), Shantanu sent an email to Harpreet dated 26 March 2014, which Harpreet forwarded to Mike. The email is titled “List of Society Members from EDUCOMP”, stated “here are the 8 from our side”, and named Soumya, Pramod and Mohan to be removed from the JRRES Bodies. Shantanu agreed these persons were from E-Solutions or his side. This showed Shantanu could unilaterally determine which persons “on [E-Solutions’] side” to retain or should step down to make way for REC’s representatives, and strongly point to the existing nominees on the JRRES Bodies being persons who were aligned with E-Solution’s interests and would comply with his directions.
- [70]
[70] Shantanu claimed the persons who eventually resigned from the General Body, namely, Anjlee, Priya and Raza (see [15] above), differed from those he identified in his email to Harpreet to show that he lacked control over the Annex D Persons. He claims that Soumya, Pramod and Mohan rebuffed his request for them to resign from the General Body because they could still contribute to JRRES and he thus had to ask Anjlee, Priya and Raza to step down (“Mar/Apr 2014 Incident”). I find his explanation untrue and differed from his account in OS 929/2015 (when resisting the Purchasers’ attempt to enforce the Award on Emergency Interim Relief arising from the Arbitration). There, Shantanu claimed Soumya, Pramod and Mohan “originally intended to resign from the [JRRES Bodies]” but were “persuaded to stay on”, and which Shantanu admitted this account to be correct. Furthermore, I disbelieve they refused to resign because they could still contribute to JRRES, when the amendments to JRRES rules significantly reduced the powers of the JRRES Bodies and when Soumya and Mohan had readily resigned from the Governing Body. Indeed, I find Shantanu had control over Soumya, Pramod and Mohan such that they remained in JRRES because he chose to remove Priya, Anjlee and Raza instead.
- [71]
[71] Hence, by around May 2014, Educomp’s nominees on the JRRES Bodies were the ones named in the Term Sheets and the Annex D Persons.
- [72]
[72] The events surrounding Educomp’s exit from the JV and the terms of the SPA further demonstrate that Shantanu exercised control over the Annex D Persons. I disbelieve Shantanu that JRRES was not part of the SPA or the JV between Educomp and REG, as I have found otherwise (see [61]–[67] above). E-Solutions’ Annual Report 2012/2013 also described its JV with REC included JRRES colleges (and Noida College), and Shantanu stated in the Arbitration that REC was buying out E-Solutions’ stake in JRRES. He also agreed that REG’s ability to take over the JRRES membership was part of the SPA transaction; as was subsequently reflected in cl 4.4.5 of the SPA.
- [73]
[73] That Shantanu had control over the Annex D Persons can also be seen from the Term Sheets in January 2015, which attached a list comprising members of the JRRES Bodies and referred to as “Seller’s Representatives in JRRES”. Ashish admitted the term “Seller’s Representatives” came from him. Whilst Annexure D of the SPA describes the persons listed as “List of Representatives to resign from” the JRRES Bodies, the purport was the same, as that “List” pertained to the Sellers’ obligation under cl 4.4.5 of the SPA. I disbelieve Ashish that the term “representatives” meant that Shantanu merely had “influence” over such persons, which was at odds with Jyotsna testimony that in the “ordinary course of business” a “representative” of a party would imply control the party has over the person.
- [74]
[74] Pertinently, the SPA drafts and the SPA provided that the Sellers “shall” procure the resignations of the Annex D Persons. The various iterations of the SPA employed mandatory language that implied the Sellers (through Shantanu) were able to procure the resignations of the Annex D Persons, and not merely as a “best effort” obligation.
- [75]
[75] In the final analysis, the commercial purpose of the JV must be borne in mind. This was a significant project for the provision of higher education services in India jointly undertaken by two sophisticated commercial entities. The JVA parties intended JRRES to step into the role of the operating entity which employed staff and ran the education institutions. As Shantanu agreed, control of JRRES was important given E-Solutions’ and REC’s investments in it. Thus, the JVA parties appointed to the JRRES Bodies persons affiliated with them and who would act in accordance with their directions.
Claim against defendants for fraudulent misrepresentation
- [76]
[76] I turn to deal first with REG’s claim in fraudulent misrepresentation. REG avers the defendants made the SPA and BAA Reps to induce the Purchasers and REI to enter into the SPA and BAA respectively.
Abuse of process
- [77]
[77] Preliminarily, Shantanu contends it is an abuse of process for REG to bring claims in misrepresentations having obtained the Final Award on the basis that the SPA was valid. The Purchasers had been awarded expectation damages in the Arbitration, but now seek damages to restore themselves to the position they were in before entering into the SPA. For completeness, Dennis does not advance a similar claim. I do not find REG to have acted in abuse of process and I reiterate my findings at [53] to [55] above.
Elements of fraudulent misrepresentation
- [78]
[78] The elements of the tort of deceit or fraudulent misrepresentation are set out in Panatron Pte Ltd and another v Lee Cheow Lee and another [2001] 2 SLR(R) 435 (“Panatron”) at [14]. There must be a representation of fact, made with the intent that it should be acted on by the plaintiff. The plaintiff must have acted upon the false statement and suffered damage by so doing. Finally, the representation must be made with the knowledge that it is false; it must be wilfully false, or at least made in the absence of any genuine belief that it is true.
- [79]
[79] At this juncture, I deal with Mr Poon’s submissions that Shantanu cannot be liable for fraudulent misrepresentation in relation to the SPA Reps because they were made on E-Solutions’ behalf. He also submits that the second of the SPA Reps (see [35(b)] above) and the BAA Reps were statements of future intent and hence not actionable. I find these submissions to be without merit.
- [80]
[80] A director is personally liable for his own torts committed in relation to the company’s affairs, whilst acting as a director or employee of the company (Animal Concerns Research & Education Society v Tan Boon Kwee [2011] 2 SLR 146 at [84]). “No one can escape liability for his fraud by saying: ‘I wish to make it clear that I am committing this fraud on behalf of someone else and I am not to be personally liable’” (Standard Chartered Bank v Pakistan National Shipping Corpn and others (Nos 2 and 4) [2003] 1 AC 959 at [22]). Hence, if it can be shown that Shantanu and/or Dennis made the SPA Reps or BAA Reps fraudulently, it is no answer for them to say that they did so on behalf of the relevant companies. Similarly, a statement of future intent is actionable if it is proven that at the time it was made, the person who made it had no intention of doing what he asserted he would do (Yong Khong Yoong Mark and others v Ting Choon Meng and another [2022] SGHC(A) 21 at [17]–[18]).
SPA Reps
- [81]
[81] Starting with the SPA Reps. I find REG has failed to prove its case of fraudulent misrepresentation. I accept that Shantanu and Ashish (acting on Shantanu’s instructions) made the SPA Reps to Doris and Chew. However, I find REG has failed to prove that Shantanu made them knowing they were false or in the absence of any genuine belief that they were true. As for Dennis, there is insufficient evidence to support that he made the SPA Reps. I elaborate below.
Whether SPA Reps made by Shantanu
- [82]
[82] I find Shantanu made the SPA Reps via phone calls with Chew and Doris leading up to the Mar 2015 Meetings. I accept Doris spoke to Shantanu in late 2014 or early 2015, and she recalled the SPA Reps were made because they were important points for the basis of the Purchasers entering into the SPA as they wanted control of JRRES because they would have to fund the JV which E-Solutions was exiting. I likewise accept Shantanu told Chew that Educomp would cede control of the JV Entities and that it was in a position to and would procure the resignation of its nominees from the JRRES Bodies.
- [83]
[83] Shantanu admits he spoke to Chew and Doris on the resignations of persons from the JRRES Bodies. But he claimed to have merely told them he would try his best to procure their resignations as he did not have control over them, which I disbelieve.
- [84]
[84] First, Shantanu’s claim to have merely said that he would try his best is predicated on his lack of control over the Annex D Persons and on the Mar/Apr 2014 Incident. I have however found these to be untrue (see [59]–[75] above).
- [85]
[85] Second, his claim is contradicted by the evidence. Shantanu admitted he never informed REG (prior to the SPA being executed) that he would merely try his best to obtain the resignations. Further, the SPA and final Term Sheet dated 21 January 2015 (“21/1/15 Term Sheet”) were plain and unambiguous in stating the Sellers’ obligation in mandatory terms. Clause 4.4 of the SPA states the Sellers “shall” submit the resignation letters of the Annex D Persons. This is to be contrasted with an earlier draft of the SPA (of 12 March 2015 at 3.39pm), where the term “best efforts” was inserted in cl 4.5, in relation to compliance with the condition precedents in cl 4.1, but was subsequently removed in a later draft (of 12 March 2015 at 8.38pm). In fact, Dennis, who represented Educomp during negotiations of the SPA, understood the Sellers’ obligations under cl 4.4 (and cl 4.1) of the SPA to be mandatory!
- [86]
[86] Similarly, Ashish stated in his emails to Doris of 2 and 3 February 2015 (“Ashish’s 2/2/15 Email” and “Ashish’s 3/2/15 Email”) that “You will deposit the 90% with the escrow, thereafter we will submit the resignation …” and “We will give [the resignation letters] to the escrow agent upon which the escrow will release us the money”. There was no indication that he believed Educomp to be labouring under a best-effort obligation, despite Shantanu’s claim that it was common knowledge amongst Educomp’s representatives that he lacked control over the Annex D Persons.
- [87]
[87] Turning to Ashish, I accept Doris’ evidence that he also made the SPA Reps to her over the phone and repeated them at the Mar 2015 Meetings. Ashish admitted he spoke to Doris on the phone between October 2014 to March 2015. However, I disbelieve he could not recall whether he discussed the resignations of the Annex D Persons with her. That Ashish repeated the SPA Reps at the Mar 2015 Meetings is also attested to by John (who was at the meetings), whom I have no reason to disbelieve. John explained the discussions on E-Solutions exiting the JV proceeded on the common understanding that it would cede complete control of the JV Entities to REG, and he had checked that the Term Sheets and SPA were drafted to impose a mandatory obligation on the Sellers to obtain the Annex D Persons’ resignations. Dennis also confirmed that cl 4.4 of the SPA and the issue of ceding control of JRRES by Educomp were discussed at the Mar 2015 Meetings and this was important to REG.
- [88]
[88] I further find that Ashish acted on Shantanu’s instructions and behalf throughout such that the SPA Reps he made are attributable to Shantanu. Shantanu agreed that during the Mar 2015 Meetings, Ashish and Jyostna would liaise with him on changes to be made to the draft SPA, and Ashish regularly updated Shantanu over the phone on the negotiations at those meetings. This comports with Dennis’ testimony that Ashish attended the Mar 2015 Meetings on Shantanu’s behalf in Shantanu’s capacity as director of E-AP and in whatever role Shantanu had in Edulearn.
- [89]
[89] In the round, I am satisfied the SPA Reps were made by Shantanu and Ashish (acting on Shantanu’s behalf) to REG.
- [90]
[90] Finally, I deal with Shantanu’s claim that REG did not raise the SPA Reps in the Arbitration, which showed they were an afterthought. But this is not entirely accurate as Chew had in his statement for the Arbitration alluded to Shantanu having informed REC that he would cause the resignation of E-Solutions’ nominees from JRRES. In any event, this point is neutral because the Arbitration pertained to the Sellers’ claim against the Purchasers for breach of the SPA, and not for misrepresentation by Shantanu and Dennis.
Whether SPA Reps made by Dennis
- [91]
[91] I turn to Dennis. Doris and John claimed he made the SPA Reps during the Mar 2015 Meetings. I find REG has failed to prove that Dennis did so.
- [92]
[92] REG could not give a convincing account to support its claim against Dennis. Chew admitted that he was not present at the Mar 2015 Meetings and that Dennis did not utter any representations to him. Whilst Doris stated in her AEIC that Dennis first made the SPA Reps at the Mar 2015 Meetings, she conceded in court that she did not have a clear recollection of what was said and admitted that Dennis did not expressly state that Educomp would cede control of the JV Entities by allowing REG to purchase the shareholding in the entities or that Educomp would procure the resignation of its nominees from JRRES and provide for REG’s nominees to take over these positions. Rather, she claimed that Dennis “said something like that to imply all these things” and in particular, “don’t worry, it will be a done deal”. But Doris’ evidence as such was not specifically stated in her AEIC.
- [93]
[93] Similarly, whilst John initially claimed the SPA Reps were made at the Mar 2015 Meetings also by Dennis, he conceded in court that he could not recall what Dennis had said, but he had the impression that Dennis assured REG that Educomp would take steps to ensure Closing would materialise. When re-examined on how he was “given to understand” that Educomp was in control of the nominees (or Annex D Persons) at the Mar 2015 Meetings, John claimed he had that understanding even before the Mar 2015 Meetings and hence there were no further communications to him on this. But it is undisputed that John and Dennis did not communicate on the SPA before the Mar 2015 Meetings.
- [94]
[94] I do not consider my finding that Dennis did not utter the SPA Reps at the Mar 2015 Meetings as inconsistent with Ashish having done so. Unlike Dennis, Ashish engaged in discussions with Doris leading up to those meetings during which he (and Shantanu), as I have found, first made the SPA Reps. Ashish also represented the interests of Shantanu and Educomp at the Mar 2015 Meetings.
- [95]
[95] Next, REG relies on the following to show the SPA Reps were implied by Dennis: (a) the primary purpose of the SPA being to cede control of JRRES by Educomp; (b) the parties to the SPA communicated at all material times on the basis that Educomp was able to and would procure the resignations of the Annex D Persons; (c) the defendants never disabused REG of its belief that the Annex D Persons were Educomp’s nominees over whom Shantanu had control; and (d) the SPA Reps made by Shantanu and Ashish.
- [96]
[96] Even assuming the above matters amount to implied SPA Reps, REG has not shown how they were implied by Dennis. The purpose of the SPA in itself does not assist REG. The documents it relies on such as the 21/1/15 Term Sheet and the initial versions of the SPA which Jyotsna drafted, and Ashish’s 2/2/15 Email, did not involve Dennis. It was Jyotsna who inserted the words “shall” and “representatives” in the Term Sheet, and Ashish who had assured REG that Educomp “will submit” the Annex D Persons’ resignations in his email. As for a revised draft SPA dated 12 March 2015 at 8.38pm sent from Dennis’ law firm (“TKQ Partnership”), Dennis inserted the phrase “[n]ominees of the Sellers” in cll 4.4.2 and 4.4.3, albeit based on a list of completion documents from E-Solutions. But this does not assist REG’s claim against Dennis, as the (final) SPA executed omitted the phrase.
- [97]
[97] Finally, REG claims Dennis impliedly made the SPA Reps because he failed to reply to and contradict John’s 19/8/15 Email wherein John mentioned that REG had been given to understand “that the two recalcitrant members are Harpreet and Soumya … who are the representatives of your client” (see [27] above). But this email superseded the execution of the SPA, and Dennis’ silence in this context cannot be taken as an implied representation.
Whether SPA Reps made to induce REG to enter the SPA
- [98]
[98] Having found that Shantanu and Ashish made the SPA Reps, I find they were made with the intention that they should be acted on by REG, viz, to induce the Purchasers to enter into the SPA. The SPA Reps related to E-Solutions and/or Educomp ceding control of the JV Entities, and especially their ability to cede control of JRRES to REG. This was the raison d’être of the SPA and was also acknowledged by Dennis to be an important issue to REG.
Whether SPA Reps made knowing they were false
- [99]
[99] The SPA Reps must be shown to be made with the knowledge that they were false or in the absence of any genuine belief that they were true. What matters is the state of affairs at the date when the contract is concluded and the representation is acted upon (see Foodco UK LLP v Henry Boot Developments Ltd [2010] EWHC 358 (Ch) at [186]–[192] and Pearlie Koh, “Misrepresentation and Non-disclosure” in The Law of Contract in Singapore (Andrew Phang Boon Leong gen ed) (Academy Publishing, 2nd ed, 2021) at [11.059]).
- [100]
[100] REG submits that Shantanu made the SPA Reps fraudulently because he did not in good faith intend to cede control of the JV Entities. It relies broadly on the following. First, he directed Jyostna not to submit the Cl 4.1 Docs and took steps to frustrate and delay Closing. Second, he chose not to procure the resignations of the Annex D Persons. Third, he authorised Educomp to make repeated non-genuine requests for extension of the Closing Date. Fourth, he unreasonably caused the Sellers to decline the Proposal. Overarching these acts was Shantanu’s desire to obtain personal gratification from the SPA.
- [101]
[101] I accept Shantanu had taken deliberate steps to frustrate Closing. That said, I do not find his actions after the SPA was executed (and which I will elaborate on later) pointed to him having had no intention to comply with the SPA Reps when he first made them until the time the SPA was entered into. The motivation REG imputes to Shantanu for always having harboured an intention to frustrate Closing (even before the SPA was executed) is unconvincing. REG claimed that Shantanu never intended to close the SPA as he wished to retain control of JRRES without the burden of funding it unless REG agreed to pay the SPA Consideration directly to Shantanu.
- [102]
[102] But REG has not adduced evidence to show, prior to the SPA being executed, that Shantanu wanted the Purchasers to pay the SPA Consideration to him instead of to the Sellers. Doris’ testimony pertaining to Shantanu’s desire to receive a sum personally in connection with the sale of Educomp’s stake in the JV, which was a conversation in January 2015 between Ashish and her, pertained to what was eventually the BAA. Doris claimed the first time Ashish called to ask if REG or the Purchasers could pay the SPA Consideration directly to Shantanu, was in April 2015. This was after the SPA was executed. As for Chew, he mentioned he met Shantanu at Pan Pacific Hotel in Singapore (“Pan Pac Meeting”), where Shantanu repeated his proposal for the Purchasers to pay the SPA Consideration to him. But Chew stated this meeting occurred in July 2016 or at the time of the Arbitration hearing.
- [103]
[103] It made no sense for Shantanu to make representations to induce REG to enter the SPA which Educomp/the Sellers did not intend to fulfil. It was unclear how Shantanu or Educomp would benefit from this (ie, execute the SPA with the attendant responsibilities therein only with the intent to later breach it). Under the terms of the SPA, the SPA Deposit would be (and was) paid by the Purchasers to the escrow agent and would only be released to the Sellers on Closing. Further, cl 3.1.2 of the SPA provided that if Closing did not take place and the SPA was terminated, the Sellers would within 30 days have to introduce an amount equivalent to the total funding contributed by the Purchasers in JRRES for its operations. Hence, the Sellers could not be relieved of the burden of funding JRRES indefinitely whilst continuing to retain control of JRRES. Such control was in any event (until the resignations of the Annex D Persons) jointly exercised by Chew as Chairman and Shantanu as President.
- [104]
[104] At the material time, E-Solutions was facing cash flow problems and hence entered into discussions with REG to exit the JV. E-Solutions had started corporate debt restructuring in July 2013. The evidence on whole shows that Educomp entered into the SPA because it wanted to sell its stake in the JV Entities as it was unable to further contribute funds to the JV. Indeed, as will subsequently be seen: (a) Shantanu was keen to execute the SPA because he intended to enrich himself from the SPA Consideration (if and when Closing occurred); and (b) he formed the intention to frustrate Closing only after the SPA was executed because of events that transpired thereafter.
Conclusion
- [105]
[105] In the round, I find REG has not made out its claim for fraudulent misrepresentation against Shantanu. It failed to show that he made the SPA Reps either knowing they were false or in the absence of any genuine belief that they were true. As for Dennis, REG failed to show that he made the SPA Reps.
BAA Reps
- [106]
[106] I now deal with the BAA Reps.
Whether BAA Reps were made
- [107]
[107] I accept Doris’ and John’s evidence that Ashish and Dennis made the BAA Reps to them during the Mar 2015 Meetings. Doris attested that Ashish and Dennis represented that they would fulfil or comply with the BAA and that she recalled Dennis making the BAA Reps and saying that the contract would be performed. Their evidence is supported by the circumstances surrounding how the BAA came to be in its final form.
- [108]
[108] Doris attested that before Jyotsna sent a draft Term Sheet on 21 January 2015 to REG, Ashish informed her that Shantanu wanted some moneys personally in connection with the sale of Educomp’s stake in the JV to REG. REG agreed on condition that Shantanu would continue to assist the JV Entities after REG assumed complete control of them on Closing. In early March 2015, the parties preliminarily agreed that Shantanu and an REG entity would enter into the BAA for Shantanu to provide advisory services to the latter.
- [109]
[109] The MOU from Jyotsna to REG on 21 January 2015 and the first draft of the BAA from Jyotsna to Dennis on 9 March 2015 named Shantanu as the party. The BAA party was changed to Edulearn when Dennis replied to Jyotsna on 9 March 2015 (copied to Shantanu and Ashish) with a revised draft (“Party Amendment”). This change was based on Shantanu’s instructions, and Doris also attested that Ashish told her that Shantanu wanted the BAA Consideration to be made to Edulearn instead. Dennis circulated another draft to Jyotsna and Ashish (copied to Shantanu) on 10 March 2015 where the recipient of the BAA Initial Payment was changed from an escrow agent to Edulearn (“Payee Amendment”). I find Dennis introduced the Party and Payee Amendments following discussions with Shantanu, who attested that he instructed the “Singapore team” and Dennis on the changes.
- [110]
[110] I accept Ms Lin’s submission that it was logical for REG to seek assurances from Ashish and Dennis that the defendants/E-AP/E-Prof would take steps to ensure Closing and Edulearn would abide by the BAA terms, in light of the Party and Payee Amendments. I find that Ashish and Dennis made the BAA Reps in response to the assurances sought by REG. With the Party Amendment, REI would contract with an unfamiliar entity and thus it asked for a COI of Edulearn which was a British Virgin Islands (“BVI”) entity. When Ashish told Doris on 10 March 2015 that a COI could only be provided after five working days, she requested for a solicitor’s undertaking confirming that Shantanu was then a director of Edulearn and that the COI would be delivered shortly after the execution of the BAA. Dennis then provided the 12/3/15 Undertaking (see [24] above). After the signing of the SPA, he provided a COI dated 17 March 2015 (“17/3/15 COI”) that reflected Shantanu as a director of Edulearn from 10 February 2015.
- [111]
[111] That the BAA Reps were made is supported by Ashish’s testimony. He accepted REG wished to be assured the BAA would still be performed according to its terms as the contracting party was no longer Shantanu. Whilst Ashish claimed the assurance was only as to “delivery of services by Shantanu”, this was unbelievable considering the above and as I will explain below.
- [112]
[112] With the Party Amendment, REG was concerned that Shantanu should be a director of Edulearn. Hence the BAA stated that Edulearn would provide its services through its board of directors which “shall” include Shantanu. It is undisputed that REG wanted to retain Shantanu given his knowledge and experience in the Indian education business and his connections in India, as Chew and Ashish attested. In court, John explained that REG was “very concerned” as Shantanu would render the advisory services and yet Shantanu proposed the contracting entity be changed to a company. It was against this backdrop that Dennis provided the 12/3/15 Undertaking. Similarly, the Payee Amendment (which Ashish agreed was discussed at the Mar 2015 Meetings) meant there was a risk that the BAA Initial Payment would not be refunded to REI if Closing did not occur. Dennis did not dispute this or that the Payee Amendment was an important matter discussed at the Mar 2015 Meetings.
- [113]
[113] It is thus unbelievable that REG was only concerned with whether Shantanu would deliver the services under the BAA (without more) and would have accepted assurances limited only to this. The BAA and SPA were intertwined. REG wanted to continue tapping on Shantanu’s expertise and experience in the Indian education business once Educomp exited the JV, for which expertise it would pay. It was thus important for REG to ensure Closing would take place given its already substantial investment in the JV Entities. As Doris attested, the assurance that Edulearn would refund the BAA Initial Payment if Closing did not materialise due to Educomp’s default was important to REG. Otherwise there was no reason to make payment under the BAA if the SPA did not complete, as Educomp would still be part of the JV and Shantanu (being E-Solutions’ Chairman and MD) would have to continue to act in the JV’s interest without REG having to separately pay for his services.
- [114]
[114] Mr Poon submitted there was no need to provide a separate oral assurance by way of the BAA Reps since Edulearn was already obliged under the BAA to refund the BAA Initial Payment in the absence of Closing. But this point does not assist the defendants. REG had sought the assurances precisely because the Party and Payee Amendments would lead to REI making the BAA Initial Payment directly to an entity unknown to it (Edulearn). REG’s conduct is also consistent with it seeking a COI and the 12/3/15 Undertaking.
- [115]
[115] At this juncture I deal with Jyotsna’s claim that she “did not think” Ashish and Dennis had at the Mar 2015 Meetings “expressly” said that the BAA would be performed. I give no weight to her answer, which only came out in court. Despite the defendants knowing REG’s pleaded case that the BAA Reps were made at the Mar 2015 Meetings, Jyostna’s AEIC was bereft of details as to what transpired at the meetings and did not refute REG’s claim. I also reject Mr Padman’s submission that the amendments to the BAA and SPA on 13 March 2015 (after the BAA was signed and dated 12 March 2015) shows that Ashish and Dennis did not make the BAA Reps at the Mar 2015 Meetings. These amendments did not touch on the Party or Payee Amendments.
- [116]
[116] For completeness, I do not consider my finding that Ashish and Dennis made the BAA Reps to be inconsistent with my determination that Dennis did not make the SPA Reps. Doris’ and John’s evidence that Dennis made the BAA Reps is supported by the Party and Payee Amendments, and Ashish’s and Dennis’ concessions that the amendments were the subject of discussion at the Mar 2015 Meetings. As will be seen below, Dennis had an interest in Edulearn.
Dennis’ role in the BAA negotiations
- [117]
[117] Next, I find Dennis had made the BAA Reps as a director of Edulearn.
- [118]
[118] I begin with the 17/3/15 COI that Dennis provided to REG shortly after the SPA and BAA were executed. Whilst this COI reflected Shantanu as director of Edulearn from 10 February 2015, at trial Dennis disclosed COIs dated 3 October 2014, 13 March 2015 and 7 November 2019 (“3/10/14 COI”, “13/3/15 COI” and “7/11/19 COI” respectively). I set out the COIs for reference:
Edulearn’s COI
Directors (Date appointed)
Shareholders(Shares)
3/10/14 COI
Dennis (1 Oct 2013)
Soumya (5 Aug 2014)
Dennis (100,000)
Soumya (6,328)
13/3/15 COI
Dennis (1 Oct 2013)
Soumya (5 Aug 2014)
Dennis (100,000)
Soumya (6,328)
17/3/15 COI
Dennis (1 Oct 2013)
Soumya (5 Aug 2014)
Shantanu (10 Feb 2015)
Dennis (100,000)
Soumya (6,328)
7/11/19 COI
Lise Voisard (15 Oct 2019)
Lise Voisard (106,328)
- [119]
[119] Dennis did not dispute he was a director and 94.05% shareholder of Edulearn between 1 October 2013 and 15 October 2019. He initially gave the impression that he attended to the BAA at the Mar 2015 Meetings solely in his capacity as a lawyer for Edulearn, and that he was merely a nominee director and shareholder of Edulearn (with Shantanu as his principal).
- [120]
[120] However, at trial, Dennis admitted he executed the BAA as Edulearn’s director and represented Edulearn not merely as its lawyer when negotiating the BAA. This was because the 13/3/15 COI revealed Shantanu was never Edulearn’s director before the SPA and BAA were executed but this was not disclosed to REG at the Mar 2015 Meetings. Shantanu had informed Dennis, only at the Mar 2015 Meetings, that he should be made a director and that his appointment should be backdated to 10 February 2015 and reflected as such in the COI. Yet Dennis had at the Mar 2015 Meetings told REG incorrectly that Shantanu was Edulearn’s director and sent REI the 12/3/15 Undertaking, both of which sought to give REG the impression that Shantanu’s appointment was made on or before 10 February 2015. That Dennis also performed the role of a lawyer in relation to the BAA did not make a difference and even if he claimed to be a nominee director he could still be personally liable for any misrepresentations he made.
Shantanu's interest in Edulearn and whether BAA Reps made on his behalf
- [121]
[121] Next, I find the BAA Reps made by Ashish are attributable to Shantanu. Ashish admitted to representing Shantanu at the BAA negotiations and he acted on Shantanu’s instructions. Indeed, I find Shantanu was the beneficial owner of Soumya’s shares in Edulearn. The evidence also shows Shantanu was a key decision-maker in Edulearn and instrumental in shaping the BAA negotiations through Ashish and Dennis, and that Soumya was his nominee director.
- [122]
[122] First, it was Shantanu who wanted to change the BAA party from himself to Edulearn; this was although he was not then reflected as its shareholder or director. Whilst Shantanu claimed to have sought Soumya’s consent to change the BAA party to Edulearn, this is unsubstantiated.
- [123]
[123] Second, Ashish represented Shantanu in the BAA negotiations including at the Mar 2015 Meetings although Shantanu was then not a named party to the BAA. Ashish agreed he could not have done so unless Shantanu had an interest in Edulearn. Tellingly, Ashish described Edulearn as “one of the Educomp companies”. His explanation in court, that this was because Shantanu subsequently became a director in Edulearn when he was also the MD for E-Solutions, was unconvincing. That Shantanu had a real interest in Edulearn is also supported by Sunil’s email to Ashish on 12 March 2015 referring to Edulearn as “Shantanu’s advisory firm”, which Ashish did not correct.
- [124]
[124] Third, Dennis attested that Shantanu had (at the Mar 2015 Meetings) instructed Dennis to appoint him as Edulearn’s director and to backdate the appointment, which Shantanu admitted to so doing. Shantanu could only have decided on his own appointment as a director if he had an interest in Edulearn.
- [125]
[125] Fourth, Shantanu approved the key terms in the BAA for Edulearn. His claim that he obtained instructions from Soumya in this regard is unconvincing. As he later claimed, he could not recall who he took instructions from. He had also directed Ashish to have Dennis sign the BAA on Edulearn’s behalf.
- [126]
[126] Pertinently, after the BAA Initial Payment was made to Edulearn’s bank account in Singapore (“ANZ Account”), Shantanu instructed Dennis to hold part of it personally and purportedly on trust for Edulearn when the ANZ Account was closed in 2017. Again, Shantanu’s claim that this was done on Soumya’s instructions was unbelievable and also unsubstantiated. By this time, Soumya was no longer a shareholder or director of Edulearn.
- [127]
[127] Indeed, Shantanu’s assertion in court that he was essentially acting on Soumya’s instructions on all matters pertaining to the BAA, and that he merely “interfaced” with Dennis on Soumya’s behalf, cannot be believed. Apart from the fact that Shantanu did not plead nor state in his AEIC as such and that Soumya did not testify in Shantanu’s support, Soumya was never involved in the negotiations relating to Educomp’s exit from the JV.
The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.