General Division of the High Court · Decided 13 March 2025
The court sided with the plaintiffs on disputed timesheets and administrative charges
Shipworks Engineering Pte Ltd and another v Sembcorp Marine Integrated Yard Pte Ltd and another and other suits
Feedback & support[2025] SGHC 40 · Case no. Suit No 1040 of 2020(consolidated with HC/Suits Nos 1042, 1051 and 1052 of 2020) · 11 paragraphs
✱ The decision, in one line
Not legal advice
The court sided with the plaintiffs on disputed timesheets and administrative charges
Summary by laws.sg·Paragraphs [3], [4]
There is no fuller plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
- [1]
[1] In Shipworks Engineering Pte Ltd and another v Sembcorp Marine Integrated Yard Pte Ltd and another and other suits [2024] SGHC 325 (the “Main Judgment”), I directed the parties to calculate the quantum of damages that each party owes to the other. Counsel for the plaintiffs and defendants have indicated what they had agreed and what they had not. The quantum of the Work Orders on which the parties have a common position stands at $6,959,144.76 in the plaintiffs’ favour.
- [2]
[2] As to the parts that they disagree with each other, I find as follows. I adopt the same terminology here as in the Main Judgment. First, the defendants contend that payment should be excluded for works pursuant to the Plaintiffs’ Timesheets which either do not bear signatures, or bear signatures or contents which are too faint to be legible. I will call these timesheets the “Plaintiffs’ Faint Timesheets”. The plaintiffs contend that payment should be excluded only pursuant to the Plaintiffs’ Timesheets which the defendants’ experts, Ms Lee, found had signatures too faint to be examined.
- [3]
[3] I agree with the plaintiffs. The defendants had not pleaded the timesheets which they say are Plaintiffs’ Faint Timesheets, nor that the plaintiffs are not entitled to claim for work done in relation to those timesheets. Had the defendants done so, the plaintiffs might have produced clearer copies or scans of the timesheets. But the defendants did not do so. This can be distinguished from the timesheets which Ms Lee found to have signatures too faint to be examined — the plaintiffs were put on notice regarding those signatures but did not produce clearer copies or scans of those timesheets. I thus accept the plaintiffs’ figures in respect of the timesheets which the defendants allege to be Plaintiffs’ Faint Timesheets.
- [4]
[4] The next dispute centres on the administrative charges payable on the partial payments made by the defendants to the plaintiffs. The defendants contend that they are entitled to charge an administrative charge of 1% based on the aggregate quantum of partial payments for Work Orders under which a partial payment was made after 27 July 2018. This means that the defendants would charge 1% for some partial payments made before 27 July 2018. The plaintiffs argue that the defendants are only entitled to the 1% charge for partial payments made after 27 July 2018. I agree with the plaintiffs. The text of the Main Judgment (at [80]) states clearly that the defendants are not entitled to administrative charges on partial payments made before 27 July 2018 because they have not satisfactorily proven any agreement which entitles them to such administrative charges. I agree with the plaintiffs that in determining whether partial payments were made on or after 27 July 2018 with administrative charges applying, the relevant date is the date of the partial payment invoices or Request for Partial Payment forms (whichever later), not the date of payment as the defendants claim.
- [5]
[5] There are other miscellaneous disputes in relation to the number of payment hours claimable in other Work Orders. My decision on them is as follows:
- [8]
[8] Finally, I turn to the parties’ arguments on the defendants’ counterclaim in HC/S 1042/2020 (“S 1042”). The defendants want to recover payments already made to the plaintiffs in relation to supporting documents which Ms Lee had found contained forged and/or fabricated signatures. These supporting documents are part of the Defendants’ Set of Documents, and include Plaintiffs’ Timesheets, Daily Timesheets, Weekly Timesheets and Timesheet Summaries.
- [9]
[9] The plaintiffs first submission in respect of the S 1042 counterclaim is that the defendants have not adduced the evidence proving their counterclaim for S 1042. This is because the court found that “it is unlikely that the Defendants’ Set of Documents is exactly what the plaintiffs had submitted to the defendants” and that the Plaintiffs’ Timesheets disclosed in the Plaintiffs’ Set of Documents should be preferred (see the Main Judgment at [28] and [31]). The Plaintiffs’ counsel argues that the timesheets in the Defendants’ Set of Documents therefore cannot be relied upon to prove the S 1042 counterclaim. Also, the plaintiffs seem to think that based on the Main Judgment at [38], the defendants could only be able to impugn the Plaintiffs’ Timesheets in the Plaintiffs’ Set of Documents where they have done so on a matching Plaintiffs’ Timesheet in the Defendants’ Set of Documents. Since the supporting documents on which the defendants now rely do not correspond with the Plaintiffs’ Set of Documents, the defendants cannot impugn the former.
- [10]
[10] The defendants’ response is that the documents produced by the defendants are the only documents before the court in respect of the counterclaim — the plaintiffs have confirmed that they have not produced any documents in respect of the counterclaim. Hence, the Defendants’ Set of Documents in relation to the Work Orders pertaining to the S 1042 counterclaim must be accepted.
- [12]
[12] The plaintiff’s second and alternative submission in respect of the S 1042 counterclaim is that the defendants’ calculations for some of the Work Orders are inaccurate. One, the plaintiffs allege that for 14 Work Orders in S 1042, the defendants have included timesheets “which are clearly wrong on the face of the documents”. These errors include:
But the plaintiffs do not appear to have identified such timesheets. The plaintiffs’ allegation is thus not proved.
- [14]
[14] These discrepancies, relating to mere ascertainment of hours and rates (similar to what the parties had done for the other Work Orders) could clearly have been resolved by the parties but were not. This is probably because the plaintiffs had simultaneously argued that the defendants should not be entitled to any sums in relation to the S 1042 counterclaim, and so the defendants did not engage the plaintiffs on their alternative arguments on quantum.
- [16]
[16] The sum payable to the plaintiffs, including the agreed Work Orders but excluding the 13 Work Orders under the S 1042 counterclaim, is as follows: