Singapore International Commercial Court · Decided 14 May 2019
B2C2 Ltd v Quoine Pte Ltd
Feedback & support[2019] SGHC(I) 06 · Case no. Suit No 7 of 2017 · 14 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
Financial Compensation by way of Equitable Relief (Paragraph 2 of the Plaintiff’s draft)
- [4]
[4] The Plaintiff seeks, in addition to damages at common law for breach of contract, an account of the trust assets held on trust by the Defendant together with equitable compensation for loss suffered as a result of the breach of trust.
- [6]
[6] The second question is whether the Plaintiff is entitled to equitable loss-based financial compensation in addition to damages for breach of contract. The equitable financial relief that is usually sought is an account of the profits made by the Defendant as a result of its breach of trust. Damages at common law compensate the wronged party for the loss it has suffered whereas an account of profits serves to deprive the party in breach of the profits it has made as a result of the wrongful acts. One compensates for loss and the other ensures that the wrongdoer does not profit from its wrongdoing. The English Court of Appeal decision in Ausman Ramzan v Brookwide Ltd [2011] EWCA Civ 985 is illustrative of the point. In that case, there were two causes of action arising out of the same incident, one for trespass and the other for breach of trust. The Court held that the two did not provide cumulative remedies. They were alternative remedies, one of which measured the wrongdoer’s gain and the other, the wronged party’s loss: see also Quality Assurance Management Asia Pte Ltd v Zhang Qing and others [2013] 3 SLR 631.
- [7]
[7] The Plaintiff contends that the same does not apply where the equitable relief sought is compensation for its loss rather than being awarded the Defendant’s profits. I do not agree. As was made clear in the Judgment, the two causes of action were alternative routes to the same conclusion: that the defendant had acted wrongly in reversing the Trades. There was only one incident which gave rise to the two causes of action. In these circumstances it would be wrong to grant the wronged party two aspects of compensation.
- [8]
[8] The third question is whether the Plaintiff is entitled to elect for equitable rather than common law compensation for loss where the loss arises in circumstances where the equitable relief of specific performance has been refused. This is not a matter which has been fully addressed and should be the subject of pleadings and a further hearing in due course.
- [9]
[9] The fourth question is when the Plaintiff should make its election if it is permitted to do so. The Plaintiff has suggested that it should not be forced to make an election before judgment in the Court of Appeal in case one part of the Judgment is overturned. Given my determination at [8] above, the question when the Plaintiff must make its election should also be the subject of pleadings and addressed at a further hearing when the question of whether it has the right to elect has been decided. If the Plaintiff is entitled to make an election, but is required to do so in advance of the appeal, it will be given the option to seek a stay of the election and hence any assessment pending the outcome of the appeal.
- [10]
[10] Paragraph 2 of the Plaintiff’s draft shall therefore be deleted.
The Indemnity (Paragraph 3 of the Plaintiff’s draft)
- [11]
[11] This was originally asserted to be an indemnity for loss suffered by the Plaintiff by reason of the Defendant’s breach of contract. In its written submissions the Plaintiff contended that this was an inadvertent error and should instead have referred to the breach of trust. Regrettably the Plaintiff did not give advance notice to the Defendant of that error such that the Defendant was constrained to put in further written submissions. In these the Defendant objected to the late change of position and sought permission to file yet further submissions if these were required.
- [12]
[12] However, I do not consider that they are. Regardless of whether the indemnity is sought on the basis of breach of contract or breach of trust I do not consider that such a term is appropriate in this case. The Plaintiff has succeeded in the action but the only relief it is entitled to is financial relief in one form or another. It is not entitled to specific performance. It is not entitled to any other substantive relief over and above this. If the proposed indemnity goes beyond this, it is not entitled to it, and if it does not go beyond, it adds nothing.
- [13]
[13] Paragraph 3 of the Plaintiff’s draft shall therefore be deleted.
The Order for an Assessment (Paragraph 4 of the Plaintiff’s draft)
- [14]
[14] In the light of [4]–[9] above, paragraph 4 of that draft, now paragraph 2 of the draft Judgment, should be rewritten as follows:
Interest and Costs (Paragraphs 5 and 6 of the Plaintiff’s draft)
- [15]
[15] These paragraphs, which are not in dispute, will be renumbered 3 and 4 and shall be in the form indicated in the Defendant’s draft, with the addition indicated in [19] below.
Stay of the order for costs
- [19]
[19] The following sentence shall thus be added to the (new) paragraph 4 of the draft:
Stay of the Assessment
- [21]
[21] The second point is of greater substance since an assessment may well involve input from accountants and/or expert witnesses. I would be reluctant to put the parties to this expense if an appeal were to be imminent. The Plaintiff has however indicated that it wishes to seek an interim payment and this is something that it should be possible to assess without undue delay or expense. The objective will be to assess the minimum sum which the Plaintiff would expect to be awarded on the assessment. Any sum which is the subject of reasonable dispute will not be awarded as part of any interim award. Once this is done, the question of a stay of the remainder of the assessment can be considered.
Further Directions
- [22]
[22] Accordingly, the correct way forward is as follows:
(b) It will within the same period plead its case on its right to elect in the circumstances of this case for equitable financial relief in the alternative to common law damages, on the time at which any such right must be exercised and on the alleged limitation of liability issue referred to in [135] of the Judgment.
(c) If the Plaintiff wishes to make an application for interim payment, it will, within the same period, make such an application.
(d) Within 28 days of service of the Points of Claim referred to in (b) above the Defendant will serve Points of Defence together with its pleading in response to the matters set out in (b) above.
(e) The parties will within 28 days confer on the quantum of costs and disbursements up to and including disposal of this action on liability to be paid by the Defendant to the Plaintiff, and shall notify the Court of the extent of the parties’ agreement or disagreement, and, if not agreed, the Court shall fix the said quantum of costs and disbursements.
(f) Thereafter a Case Management Conference will be appointed for further directions.
(g) The Parties have liberty to apply.
Annex A: the Plaintiff’s proposed draft judgment
Annex B: the Defendant’s proposed draft judgment
Annex C: the Plaintiff’s proposed draft Order