Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 29 May 2019
Contents

Singapore International Commercial Court

DyStar Global Holdings (Singapore) Pte Ltd v Kiri Industries Ltd and others

Feedback & support

[2019] SGHC(I) 09Case no. Singapore International Commercial Court — Suit No 3 of 2017 (Summons No 26 of 2019) Anselmo Reyes IJ 29 May 20198 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. [1] The facts have previously been set out by this court in its Judgment of 3 July 2018 (DyStar Global Holdings (Singapore) Pte Ltd v Kiri Industries Ltd and others and another suit [2018] SGHC(I) 06). The abbreviations defined in that Judgment will also be used here.

  3. [4] The grounds for Kiri’s stay application are as follows:

  4. (a) In its Oral Judgment dated 8 January 2019 (“the Oral Judgment”) dealing with directions for the valuation of Kiri’s shares in DyStar, this court stated at [10]: “[A]ny sum that Kiri will have to pay DyStar will be factored in the ultimate valuation of Kiri’s shareholding.” In light of that statement, Kiri suggests that this court must have envisaged that Kiri would not be required to pay the relevant amounts now, but that instead those sums are to be “factored in the ultimate valuation of Kiri’s shareholding”.

  5. Discussion

  6. [5] I am not persuaded that the grounds relied on by Kiri justify the grant of a stay.

  7. [6] First, Kiri’s abortive striking-out application before Coomaraswamy J also relied on this court’s statement at [10] of the Oral Judgment. In his decision rejecting the striking-out, Coomaraswamy J stated:

  8. [11] Coomaraswamy J observed when hearing Kiri’s application to strike out the winding-up proceedings that Kiri’s shares (which as a whole are worth significantly more than the amount due to DyStar) could be sold in part to meet the debt due to DyStar. He said:

  9. [13] Third, the mere fact that Kiri is willing for the amounts now due from Kiri to DyStar to be set-off against amounts payable in the future by Senda for Kiri’s shares has no logical bearing on whether payment of the relevant amounts by Kiri should be stayed to some future date. The amounts owed by Kiri to DyStar have been outstanding for some time, since October 2011 and May 2012 respectively. Kiri is in practical terms saying that, so much time having already elapsed, there is no prejudice to DyStar in waiting for a few more months before it receives its monies following a valuation in August 2019. Kiri argues that DyStar can show no real prejudice arising from the prospect of having to wait for a little longer.

  10. [17] In my view, there is no good reason justifying the grant of a stay in the present circumstances.

  11. Conclusion and Costs

  12. [18] For the foregoing reasons, a stay of execution is refused. Kiri’s application is dismissed.