Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 15 Oct 2020

Family Division of the High Court

BRZ v BSA

Feedback & support

[2020] SGHCF 17Case no. Divorce (Transferred) No 3317 of 2015 (Summons No 168 of 2019)23 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. Facts

  3. [2] I begin by setting out the facts pertaining to the dispute, starting with the divorce proceedings.

  4. The divorce and AM proceedings

  5. (a) Marina Flat 19;

  6. (b) Keppel Flat 3;

  7. (c) Alexandra Flat 7;

  8. (d) Marina Flat 8;

  9. (e) Keppel Flat 19;

  10. (f) Keppel Flat 127;

  11. (g) Keppel Flat 41; and

  12. (h) Marina Flat 17.

  13. [5] The Wife filed a Notice of Appeal against the whole of the High Court’s decision on 7 June 2018. The parties also entered into discussions and agreed to appoint Colliers International (Singapore) Pte Ltd (“Colliers”) as valuers on 5 July 2018, with a joint letter of instruction sent on 11 July 2018. However, the scope and purpose of Colliers’ appointment are disputed in this case, and I defer discussion of this issue to the appropriate juncture below (see [28] below).

  14. Sale of Alexandra Flat 7 and the stay

  15. The Wife’s appeal to the Court of Appeal

  16. Sale of Keppel Flat 127

  17. Sale of Keppel Flat 19

  18. The application in SUM 168

  19. [14] On 28 June 2019, the Husband filed SUM 168. The Husband sought the following reliefs in the summons:

  20. [15] Three orders that deal with particular aspects of the prayers above have already been granted by consent:

  21. (a) On 15 July 2019, prayer 1(a) above was granted in HCF/ORC 210/2019.

  22. Parties’ positions

  23. Issues

  24. [19] Given the parties’ respective positions, the following issues arise for my determination, dealing first with the most substantial dispute:

  25. (a) With regard to prayer 2,

  26. (ii) How should the net equity of the Flats be calculated, specifically:

  27. (A) what does it mean for the Wife to be “reimbursed” for the Mortgage Payments;

  28. (B) what is the appropriate cut-off date for assessing the Mortgage Payments to be deducted and/or added to the valuation of the Flats; and

  29. (C) should the 3% redemption monies be included in the Mortgage Payments to be accounted for?

  30. (b) With regard to prayer 1(b), what is the correct amount for the Wife to pay to the Husband for his share of the non-real properties in the pool of matrimonial assets?

  31. Decision

  32. Valuation and calculation of shares in the real property

  33. [20] The most substantial dispute in this case concerns the Husband’s share in the Flats and the Wife’s obligation to pay him a sum to represent that share.

  34. The law on interpretation of court orders

  35. [22] These are not controversial principles. Bearing them in mind, I turn to consider the issues raised in this case.

  36. The scope of the application

  37. Should the Colliers Valuation be accepted for the purposes of the AM Order?

  38. [28] In the present case, a valuer had been appointed. By way of a joint letter of instruction, dated 11 July 2018, Colliers was requested to “prepare valuation reports for the [Flats], with all of the reports to be sent together to both Parties’ counsel within 2 months of [their] appointment” [emphasis in original]. Colliers prepared a fee proposal dated 27 July 2018, which the parties accepted. Valuation reports, all dated 3 September 2018, were prepared as follows for each of the Flats:

  39. (1) What did the AM Order require?

  40. (2) Did the parties appoint Colliers under the AM Order and did they agree to a valuation on a date other than the date of the AM Order?

  41. [36] I turn now to consider the circumstances in which Colliers was appointed.

  42. [37] I first deal with the correspondence.

  43. (a) On 23 May 2018, CW had sent a letter to R&T referring to the High Court’s decision on 17 May 2018 and noting that the joint valuer was to be appointed by 17 June 2018. CW proposed two valuers and asked for R&T to communicate the Wife’s proposal by 30 May 2018.

  44. (b) In a letter dated 7 June 2018, CW followed up with the previous proposal, noting that the Wife had not yet given her input as to the appointment of a valuer. CW stated that if no objections were forthcoming by 14 June 2018, they would appoint a valuer.

  45. (c) On 11 June 2018, CW sent another letter, but this appears not to be exhibited in the affidavits.

  46. (d) On 14 June 2018, R&T replied to CW on behalf of the Wife. The letter refers to the appointment of valuers and proposes three valuers for consideration.

  47. (f) On 19 June 2018, R&T wrote to CW stating the Wife’s disagreement with the Husband’s assertion that the valuers she proposed were not renowned, but, in any case, proposed two other valuers, one of which was Colliers. R&T expressly noted that the Husband “had relied on a valuation report by [Colliers] on the properties in [CW’s] letter dated 23 October 2017.” In the event of disagreement, R&T proposed writing a joint letter to court to ask the court to decide on which valuer to appoint.

  48. (g) On 5 July 2018, CW replied to R&T stating the Husband’s agreement to appoint Colliers as the joint valuer. The letter enclosed a draft letter of instruction to Colliers. At para 4, CW sought a reply urgently “since the Court deadline of 17 June 2018 for appointing valuers has already long passed”.

  49. (h) On 10 July 2018, R&T confirmed that the Wife was agreeable to the proposal in the letter dated 5 July 2018 to send the letter of instruction as drafted to Colliers.

  50. (i) On 11 July 2018, CW sent the letter of instruction to Colliers.

  51. [39] In response, Colliers provided a fee proposal dated 27 July 2018. It summarised the work requested as: “the provision of valuation service to advise on the Market Value of the above-captioned properties [ie, the Flats] as at current date, for divorce proceeding purposes” [emphasis added]. The parties agreed to the fee proposal and Colliers commenced their work accordingly.

  52. [40] In her submissions, the Wife made reference to the mediation that was attempted by parties at around the same time. On 18 July 2018, the registry of the Singapore Mediation Centre (“SMC”) had written to the parties to confirm whether they were amenable to attempting mediation. On 25 July 2018, CW confirmed this to be the case. That same day, CW wrote to Colliers stating: “Parties are presently looking at possibly having a Mediation in late August 2018. As such, we would like to ask that the valuations be provided latest by 15 August 2018, in time for parties to consider the same before Mediation.” On 3 August 2018, in its email attaching the signed fee proposal, R&T also noted: “we would be grateful if the valuation can be done as soon as possible as parties are presently looking at having a mediation between mid to end August 2018.”

  53. (3) What is the effect of the difference in dates?

  54. [49] In any case, for completeness and although these principles were not argued before me, I consider it helpful to set out the legal basis for my finding. I take guidance from the Court of Appeal’s discussion of the doctrine of “waiver by estoppel” in Audi Construction Pte Ltd v Kian Hiap Construction Pte Ltd [2018] 1 SLR 317 at [57]:

  55. How should the net equity of the Flats be calculated?

  56. (1) What does it mean for the Wife to be “reimbursed” for the Mortgage Payments?

  57. [54] I begin by considering what the phrase “reimbursed to the [Wife]” means. The parties have put forward two different interpretations of this phrase, which can be expressed in terms of the formula for calculating the respective parties’ shares of the net equity of each flat. As defined at [17] above, I use the term “Mortgage Payments” to refer to “the further mortgage instalments and/or redemption payments including interest payments made by the [Wife]”. Both parties accept that the net equity of each flat is to be calculated as follows:

  58. [55] The disagreement lies in how each party’s share of the net equity should be calculated. The Husband’s position can be summarised as follows:

  59. [56] The Wife’s position can be summarised as follows:

  60. [59] This is confirmed by the overall structure of how the net equity is calculated. The outstanding mortgage amount as of 30 November 2015 is deducted, which gives the equity of the property, ie, the net value of the property as of 30 November 2015. The IJ date was 17 November 2015, so 30 November 2015 was the end of the month closest to the IJ date. Subsequently, since the parties are taken for these purposes to be living separate lives after the IJ date, any payment that the Wife made for the purpose of paying off the loan should be attributed to her alone. As the Wife has the Flats in her name, by deducting these further Mortgage Payments from the net equity, this approach effectively allows the Wife to retain those sums and recoup whatever she had spent on the further Mortgage Payments. That deduction meant that she would not have to transfer that amount to the Husband for his share in the property. In other words, she was being reimbursed for what she paid after 30 November 2015 since she would not have to account for those sums in the calculation of what the Husband’s share of the Flats was. There was no ground for reimbursing the Wife further.

  61. [60] Having regard to the parties’ submissions, I also do not find that anything in the Notes of Evidence for the hearing on 17 March 2018 suggesting that the High Court Family Division intended otherwise. The High Court was consistent throughout and did not mention a further reimbursement of the Mortgage Payments to the Wife beyond what was encapsulated in the formula for net equity.

  62. (2) When is the cut-off date for accounting for the Mortgage Payments?

  63. (3) Should the 3% redemption monies be included in the Mortgage Payments?

  64. What should the Wife pay to the Husband and when?

  65. [77] I summarise the conclusions I have reached above:

  66. (b) The formula for calculating the parties’ respective shares in the net equity is only a halving of the net equity, and does not require further adjustment for the Mortgage Payments made by the Wife.

  67. [78] In that light, I come now to consider the quantification of the sum that the Wife should pay to the Husband. I have already noted the values of the various Flats at [28] above. The mortgage sums outstanding as at 30 November 2015 are stated in the Joint Statement of Information dated 20 March 2018. The remaining question is how much were the Mortgage Payments made by the Wife from 30 November 2015 to 17 May 2018, which I will take to include the month of May 2018.

  68. [80] I summarise these values in the following table:

  69. (a) One-third of the Husband’s share of the net equity within four months of 5 April 2019.

  70. (b) One-third of the Husband’s share of the net equity within six months of 5 April 2019.

  71. (c) One-third of the Husband’s share of the net equity within eight months of 5 April 2019.

  72. What should the Wife pay to the Husband for his share of the non-real property assets?

  73. [84] Having dealt with the substantial part of this application, I turn to prayer 1(b), which sought a payment of a sum of S$3,885.75. As the Wife did not make any specific challenge to the value claimed by the Husband, I only consider if the Husband’s claim is justified by the facts. The Husband’s calculation of S$3,885.75 was arrived at as follows:

  74. (b) The Husband added the following sums to which he claimed that he was entitled to:

  75. (i) the costs due to him for the AM proceedings (S$25,000.00) and for the Appeal (S$40,000.00); and

  76. (ii) half the total of the costs of the valuation undertaken by Colliers of the Flats (S$3,200);

  77. giving a total of S$1,334,292.00.

  78. (c) From this amount, the Husband deducted the monies that had already been transferred to him for this purpose:

  79. (ii) S$20,000.00 in security for costs provided by R&T; and

  80. (iii) S$384,406.25 which had been released from CW as stakeholders under ORC 210/2019;

  81. giving a balance of S$3,885.75.

  82. Caveats and terms on which Husband is to be removed as co-borrower

  83. Costs

  84. Conclusion

  85. [89] I come to the following conclusions in this case:

  86. (b) In terms of prayers 2 and 3,

  87. (i) I conclude that:

  88. (A) the Colliers Valuation should be used for the value of the Flats;

  89. (B) the Husband is entitled to half of the net equity, without further reimbursement for Mortgage Payments made by the Wife;

  90. (C) only the Mortgage Payments from 30 November 2015 to 17 May 2018 (ie, including mortgage payments made for the month of May 2018) should be deducted as part of the calculation of the net equity;

  91. (D) the cost of the valuation is to be the cost of the Colliers Valuation.

  92. (ii) Based on the evidence before me, I conclude that the Husband’s share of the net equity is S$3,468,853.60.

  93. (iii) The Wife was to have paid one-third of the Husband’s share of the net equity four months after 5 April 2019, another one-third six months after 5 April 2019, and the last one-third eight months after 5 April 2019.