Family Division of the High Court · Decided 2 October 2024
WYH v WYG
Feedback & support[2024] SGHCF 34 · Case no. District Court Appeal No 45 of 2024 · 6 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
- [3]
[3] It is unfortunate that cases in the Family Courts are often advanced by litigants who have no legal representation. There are rules of evidence and procedure that have an important bearing on the outcome of the case. In the present instance, both parties were represented so there is little excuse for the courses they took.
- [7]
[7] In this case, the court below accepted the Mother’s application for a variation even though the three grounds advanced, ordinarily, would not have been sufficient. The first, as I mentioned, was that her children needed more school fees. The second was that she was earning only $3,600 a month, which was not a change from the time of the consent judgment. The third was that the Father was tardy in making payments. That is a matter for enforcement proceedings, not variation in itself.
- [8]
[8] After the court allowed the Mother’s application, the Father did not appeal. Instead, he waited a year before applying to vary the variation orders obtained by the Mother. When asked why he did not appeal, his counsel stated that, “Bluntly, he did not have the means”. In any case, now that he has applied to vary the new orders of court, he has to satisfy the requirements for a variation.
- [9]
[9] One of the main arguments by Mr Quek, counsel for the Father, was that the court below was wrong in not accepting that the Father’s income had dropped, and wrongly found that he had a dual income from selling cars at a well-known car agency, as well as an income from his job as an insurance salesman. Counsel argued, without proof, that the Father had stopped selling insurance. When asked if the Father still has the licence to sell insurance, counsel replied that he had. The remaining arguments concerned allegations that the court below calculated the overall income and liabilities wrongly. That is clearly a matter for an appeal and not a variation. In any event, the main ground here was that the court did not explain why she found that the Father was earning an average of $7,700.
- [10]
[10] Mr Quek also submitted that the Father had been jailed three times, each time for a day — all for not paying maintenance. This, counsel argued, shows that the Father truly has no money to pay. In my view, it may also show that the Husband is a recalcitrant ex-spouse when it comes to not paying maintenance. The enforcement court may eventually run out of patience and he may find himself imprisoned for a longer term in future.
- [12]
[12] This present application by the Father to vary those orders was filed on 18 October 2023. It is far too late to appeal against the 2022 orders, and this application should not be used as an alternative route to appeal out of time. In any event, it is futile to apply for a variation when the Father has not shown any change of circumstances. He does not even have Inland Revenue Authority of Singapore (“IRAS”) returns as proof because he only started as a car salesman in March this year. Furthermore, all the arguments advanced were arguments that ought to have been made in an appeal.