Family Division of the High Court · Decided 7 March 2025
UBQ v UBR
Feedback & support[2025] SGHCF 20 · Case no. Divorce (Transferred) No 1861 of 2015 · 10 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
- [2]
[2] The parties married in May 2006 in America. The applicant is a 53-year-old American, and presently unemployed although she had worked in the career services centre of an established university in New York until 2008. The respondent is a 56-year-old Canadian who works at a sovereign wealth fund in Singapore. Their sons are 15 and 17 years old, respectively. Both are schooling in Singapore.
- [3]
[3] Theirs was a long and acrimonious divorce. Married for nine years, they spent the next ten in and out of the Family Courts. They filed numerous applications and cross-applications before, during, and after the ancillary proceedings. Tan Puay Boon JC delivered a 112-page judgment determining the ancillary matters on 21 September 2020. The parties had also appeared in the Appellate Division of the High Court as well as the Court of Appeal. All those matters have ended. The application before me is a fresh application, and so is the respondent’s reactive application in HCF/SUM 22/2025 which is to strike out large portions of the applicant’s affidavit. From the history of this case, it appears that no tit goes without a tat. The parties are, as always, each determined to have the last word.
The applicant requested for further arguments on 5 October 2020 in relation to Tan JC’s judgment, but the request was rejected by the court three days later. The parties also brought an appeal and cross-appeal regarding Tan JC’s orders, but both parties eventually withdrew their respective appeals.
- [9]
[9] Another difference is that an appellant is entitled to appeal against any or all the orders below. In an application to vary, a party is generally not allowed to vary by asking for a fresh relief that was not argued previously. In this regard, the applicant’s application for the respondent to contribute to the children’s share of rent is more properly the subject of an appeal and not one for a variation of the original orders. That application will not be allowed.
- [11]
[11] The applicant claims that she has no breaks from parenting and that limits her ability to find employment. The applicant claims to “have no competitive edge over Singaporeans” and has difficulty securing high-paying employment. At the same time, she claims that the conditions of her employment pass do not permit her to engage in low-paying jobs. These are not new matters, of course, and ought to have been the subject of appeal of Tan JC’s 2020 orders.
- [12]
[12] The applicant says that she has nonetheless been active in the professional community, “taking on leadership roles that would enhance [her] visibility and demonstrate current capabilities”. She serves on multiple committees and volunteers with community organisations. These roles, she says, have allowed her to “work alongside and develop relationships with high-level executives and decision-makers in the Singapore expat business community”. She claims that her “networking efforts have been comprehensive and strategic”, and she has “connected with CEOs, senior executives, and business leaders”. It is through these that she “learned that for professional roles matching [her] current qualifications, the market salary would not meet the Employment Pass requirements for foreign workers”.
- [13]
[13] The applicant also claims to have made hundreds of applications in search of employment. Despite her networking, and her qualification as a Chartered Professional Accountant (“CPA”), the applicant has not shown evidence of actual job applications. Furthermore, networking takes time, but she was obliged to find work when the divorce was made absolute, not after years of networking. The respondent says that part of the reason that the applicant has not found a job may be because she had let her CPA qualification lapse and did nothing to renew her CPA licence until she filed HCF/SUM 300/2024. The applicant admits in her submissions that she is trying to bring this “up to speed”. She claims that she has never been a chartered accountant because public accounting was not a career she enjoyed or excelled at. Nevertheless, she now thinks that any job that may employ her is worth pursuing. More importantly, the respondent points out that all the applicant’s efforts to find a job were made after the 48 months or were feeble efforts in sending her out-of-date resume to her friends overseas. There is no evidence of a formal job application and its rejection.
- [14]
[14] The respondent claims that the applicant was not seriously setting herself to be financially independent after the expiry of 48 months. He says that she spends too much time socialising at the XXX Club and playing tennis. He says she paid for 89 tennis sessions in nine months in 2024, and when she had used up the maximum allocated sessions, she booked sessions under their sons’ names — neither of them plays tennis. The applicant retorts that her socialising at the XXX Club was a form of looking for work. The respondent also says that the applicant cannot find a job in Singapore because she spends two to three months a year back in America for holiday. But the applicant says that the travels were necessary “to preserve [their] children’s mental well-being”.
- [15]
[15] In my view, the burden is on the applicant to show that she had taken reasonable steps to find gainful employment. I am not satisfied that there has been a material change to justify any variation of the maintenance orders for herself. Running out of money can be said to be a change in circumstances, but it is not a material change so far as the law is concerned. If a spouse is given a million dollars in maintenance and she spends it all in the casino within a month, that is no less a material change of circumstances — going from being solvent to broke. But I cannot see any court giving her more maintenance on that account.
- [16]
[16] Much of the rest of the applicant’s submission concerns matters which she claims were not considered by Tan JC (such as adjustments for inflation or growth) or matters that she ascribed to assumptions made by Tan JC, such as her finding a job in America after four years.
- [18]
[18] The remaining issue concerns the increase sought for the sons’ maintenance. They were about 10 and 12 years old in 2020. The maintenance of S$2,500 to each of them is, in my view, generous, especially when the expenses for education, enrichment and health are borne separately by the father. They are also given S$10,000 travel expenses each year. I think that the award is generous then because even today, at 15 and 17 years of age, I do not think that these amounts are inadequate.