Family Division of the High Court · Decided 12 May 2026
YAM v YAN
Feedback & support[2026] SGHCF 14 · Case no. Divorce (Transferred) No 3533 of 2023
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Laws this judgment relies on
Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [1]
[1] The parties in this case were married on 13 October 2006 in Singapore. They have four children (collectively, “Children”) who either have turned or will be turning 18, 14, 11 and 9 years old this year. Interim judgment for divorce (“Interim Judgment”) was granted on 15 January 2024 on an uncontested basis, on the basis that the defendant (“Husband”) had behaved in such a way that the plaintiff (“Wife”) could not reasonably be expected to live with the Husband. The marriage therefore lasted for around 17 years and 3 months. Orders were made by consent for joint custody of the Children to be granted to both parties, with care and control to the Husband, and reasonable access for the Wife to the Children.
- [2]
[2] The Wife is presently 42 years old (turning 43 in November) and is a freelance tuition teacher. The Husband is presently 59 years old (turning 60 in October) and is the chef at, and owner of, two restaurants: [Restaurant A] and [Restaurant B] (collectively, “Restaurants”).
- [3]
[3] The three broad issues that arise for determination in the present case are: (a) the division of matrimonial assets; (b) maintenance for the Wife; and (c) maintenance for the Children.
Division of matrimonial assets
Identification and valuation of matrimonial assets
- [4]
[4] Parties agree that the operative date for identifying the matrimonial assets should be the date of Interim Judgment (ie, 15 January 2024), while the operative date for valuing the matrimonial assets should be the date closest to the date of the ancillary matters (“AM”) hearing (ie, 18 March 2026). However, balances in bank accounts and CPF accounts should be valued at the date of Interim Judgment: CVC v CVB [2023] SGHC(A) 28 at [55].
Joint assets
- [5]
[5] There are two assets held in the parties’ joint names. Parties do not dispute the inclusion of either asset in the matrimonial pool.
- [6]
[6] The first joint asset is the sum of S$5,052.63 held in UOB account number 355-XXX-XXX-X.
- [7]
[7] The second joint asset is the parties’ matrimonial home in Singapore. The parties have proposed different net values for this asset, but their counsel agreed at the hearing before me that the difference between their proposed values was minor. The Wife submits that the net value of the property was $1,549,350.12 as of February 2024: this figure is based on the Wife’s estimated value of the property of S$2,296,250.00, less the outstanding mortgage (S$746,899.88 as of 22 February 2024). To arrive at the estimated value of the property, the Wife obtained from the Urban Redevelopment Authority (“URA”) website a list of private residential property transactions at the same condominium in which the matrimonial home is located, and specifically identified the sale of one unit (which had a unit price per square meter of S$18,370) in November 2023. The Wife chose this unit as a point of reference because it was situated between level 1 and level 5 of the condominium, which was similar to the matrimonial home which is located at level 4 of the condominium. The Wife thus applied the same unit price per square metre (S$18,370) to the size of the matrimonial home (125 square meters) to obtain the estimated value of S$2,296,250.
- [8]
[8] The Husband proposes a net value of S$1,590,064.78 as of December 2024, based on the estimated value of the property of S$2,320,000 derived from a “SRX” [Singapore Real Estate Exchange] website, less the outstanding mortgage of S$729,935.22 as of 31 December 2024. The Husband’s SRX search is undated, although he claims in his written submissions that the search was dated December 2024. At the AM hearing before me, the Husband's counsel submitted that the value obtained from the SRX website was “specific to the unit [in question]” (ie, the matrimonial home) and therefore “more reliable”.
- [9]
[9] The Wife did not dispute the authenticity or accuracy of the SRX website screenshot exhibited in the Husband’s affidavit. The valuation obtained from the SRX website is also specific to the matrimonial home, thus distinguishing this case from WXA v WXB [2024] SGHCF 22 (“WXA v WXB”). In WXA v WXB, the court noted that neither party had provided valuations specifically for the matrimonial home, and that since “the disparity in the parties’ valuations [was] not large”, it was “reasonable to split the difference” (see [30] and [31]). Moreover, the Husband’s valuation dates from December 2024, which is closer to the operative date for valuing matrimonial assets (ie, the date of the AM hearing on 18 March 2026) as compared to the Wife’s valuation which dates from February 2024. In the circumstances, I accept the Husband’s proposed net value of S$1,590,064.78 for the matrimonial home.
- [10]
[10] The total value of the two joint assets is thus S$1,595,117.41.
Assets in the Husband’s sole name
- [11]
[11] I turn to consider the assets held in the Husband’s sole name. Based on the joint summary tendered by the parties, as well as the parties’ written submissions, the parties agree on all but one asset in the Husband’s name. I set out the full list of disputed and undisputed assets at [74] below. At [13]–[73], I focus on the sole disputed asset in the Husband’s name; namely, the Restaurants. While parties agree that the Restaurants should be included in the matrimonial pool, they disagree on the valuation.
- [12]
[12] I first set out the background to the restaurant business, before summarising parties’ respective submissions on valuation, and then elaborating on my findings.
(1) The dispute on the valuation of the Restaurants
(A) Background
- [14]
[14] Around mid-2024, with the lease for the Original Premises due to expire in February 2025, the Husband was uncertain about whether the lease would be renewed. This was because of his “declining business” and the possibility of the rent being too high for him to bear. The Husband therefore procured leases of smaller locations at [address redacted] (“Alternative Premises”), which (according to the Husband) he intended to keep if the lease for the Original Premises was not renewed. If, on the other hand, the lease for the Original Premises was renewed, he intended to sell the leases for the Alternative Premises. According to the Husband’s valuation report dated 9 July 2025 (“Husband’s Final Valuation Report”), the Alternative Premises comprise two separate units for which two tenancy agreements were entered into; the leases will expire in May 2026 and August 2027. I will refer to the units as the “First AP Unit” and the “Second AP Unit” respectively.
- [15]
[15] The Husband eventually obtained a two-year renewal of the lease for the Original Premises for the period from 1 March 2025 to 28 February 2027. According to the Husband, a condition for the renewal of this lease was that he renovate the Original Premises “to as good as new conditions”. This condition was not expressly included in the supplemental agreement for the lease renewal. The Husband alleged that it was a verbal agreement between him and the landlord, with whom he had a “very long-standing commercial relationship”.
- [16]
[16] The Husband’s position is that having secured the renewal of the lease for the Original Premises, he has no intention to continue renting the Alternative Premises. This is disputed by the Wife, who claims that the expansion into the Alternative Premises reflects “a long-term business strategy”.
- [17]
[17] Parties produced separate valuations of the Restaurants, which I deal with in the next section of this judgment.
(B) Parties’ valuations and submissions on the valuation of the Restaurants
- [19]
[19] The Wife eventually obtained four independent valuations of the Restaurants, but she only relies on the figures in the latest valuation, ie, the fourth valuation dated 19 September 2025 (“Wife’s Final Valuation Report”). The Husband similarly relies on the later of two valuations which he obtained.
- [20]
[20] I summarise below the latest valuations obtained by both parties, with the specific figures used by each party for their calculations underlined and in bold:
- [21]
[21] Before dealing with the valuation figures, I first address the issue of whether the Restaurants should be valued on the basis that the leases for the Alternative Premises will be renewed, or on the basis of non-renewal of these leases.
(C) Whether to value the Restaurants on the basis that the leases for the Alternative Premises will be renewed
(I) Parties’ submissions
(II) My decision
- [23]
[23] In my view, there are two reasons to value the Restaurants on the basis that the leases for the Alternative Premises will not be renewed.
- [24]
[24] At the outset, I note that pursuant to s 108 of the Evidence Act 1893 (2020 Rev Ed) (“EA”), when any fact is “especially within the knowledge of any person”, the “burden of proving that fact is upon that person”. Illustration (a) to this provision provides that “[w]hen a person does an act with some intention other than that which the character and circumstances of the act suggest, the burden of proving that intention is upon that person”. In this case, the taking of the leases for the Alternative Premises is an act which (at least at first blush) suggests that the Husband intended to continue his restaurant business at those premises. As such, the Husband bears the burden of proving that his intention was actually not to renew the leases for the Alternative Premises. In my view, the Husband has discharged this burden of proof.
- [25]
[25] First, the Husband’s evidence as to his intention not to renew the leases for the Alternative Premises has been consistent. In his second Affidavit of Assets and Means (“AOM”) dated 10 January 2025, at which point it was still unclear if the lease for the Original Premises would be renewed, the Husband stated his intention to sell the leases for the Alternative Premises if the lease for the Original Premises was renewed. The Husband also stated that he had taken on the leases for the Alternative Premises “in anticipation of not being able to renew the tenancy of [the Original Premises]”. After the renewal of the lease for the Original Premises, the Husband wrote to the Wife on 3 March 2025 to provide an update, and reiterated his intention to sell the leases for the Alternative Premises. He indicated that such a sale would “take a considerable period”, pending which his business would “incur losses because of the additional rental expenses”. The Husband’s written submissions dated 16 January 2026 confirm the absence of any intention on his part to renew the leases of the Alternative Premises.
- [26]
[26] Second, I note that in an affidavit which she filed on 19 September 2025 in support of her application for leave to file an updated valuation report on the Restaurants, the Wife claimed (at paras 10–12) that she was “surprised” and “shocked” at the Husband’s position, because – according to her – he had “consistently expressed to [her]”, throughout their marriage, that “he was waiting to acquire the tenancies for [the Alternative Premises] in order to expand his business and had been patiently waiting for the units to become available”. The Wife claimed that the Husband had mentioned expanding his business “into new types of food offerings, such as finger foods and beverages, to attract a different clientele”, and that this expansion would be bolstered by the fact that the Second AP Unit was “immediately adjacent” to the Original Premises, while the First AP Unit was situated so as to “provide better visibility and help attract more customers”. However, these were bare assertions by the Wife. Her apparent inability to produce any evidence of the representations previously made by the Husband was striking, considering her assertion that these representations had been made “consistently” throughout the 17-odd years of their marriage.
- [27]
[27] Further, the Wife would have become aware by 10 January 2025 of the Husband’s intention not to renew the leases for the Alternative Premises in the event that the lease for the Original Premises was renewed, because it was in his second AOM of 10 January 2025 that the Husband mentioned such an intention. In other words, if the Husband had indeed previously told the Wife of his wish to expand his business by taking on the Alternative Premises, the Wife would have become aware by 10 January 2025 that the Husband appeared to be changing his tune. Strangely, however, the Wife made no attempt to challenge the Husband’s apparent change of position in the affidavits that she filed between 10 January 2025 and 19 September 2025. In particular, in between those two dates, the Wife filed the following documents:
(a) An affidavit affirmed on 6 March 2025 in support of her summons for leave to file a third AOM;
(b) An affidavit affirmed on 17 March 2025 in reply to the Husband’s affidavit filed in response to her summons for leave to file a third AOM;
(c) An affidavit affirmed on 21 May 2025 in support of her application to file (inter alia) an affidavit by her valuer with updated figures and commentary;
(d) Her third AOM affirmed on 5 June 2025; and
(e) Her fourth AOM affirmed on 16 September 2025.
- [28]
[28] Tellingly, in none of these affidavits did the Wife bring up her claim about the Husband’s long-standing wish to expand his business using the Alternative Premises. In fact, the Wife’s third AOM did not even address the issue of the valuation of the Restaurants, even though she sought in this AOM to rebut some of the other claims in the Husband’s second AOM of 10 January 2025. In my view, her allegations about the Husband having “consistently” informed her of his intention to expand the restaurant business using the Alternative Premises were simply an afterthought for which no supporting evidence can be found and to which no weight should be given.
- [29]
[29] In sum, I accept the Husband’s argument that the Restaurants should be valued on the basis that the leases for the Alternative Premises will not be renewed. It is on this basis that I consider the valuations put forward by the parties.
(D) Which Final Valuation Report is to be preferred
(I) Wife’s Final Valuation Report
- [30]
[30] I first summarise the key contents of the Wife’s Final Valuation Report. It is expressly stated in this report that the financial projections for FY2025 to FY2029 were calculated based on the valuer’s “own [judgment] and analysis”, because “management did not provide input on the business outlook”. Focusing on the financial projections for the scenario where the leases for the Alternative Premises are not renewed, I outline below the Wife’s figures for earnings before interest and taxes (“EBIT”), free cash flow (“FCF”), and enterprise value.
- [31]
[31] In arriving at the EBIT figure, an important constituent figure is the estimated revenue of the Restaurants. The estimated revenue in 2025 (S$4,043,636) is based on the average monthly revenue from the first four months of 2025 (for which revenue data is available) multiplied by 12. As for the expected revenue from 2026 to 2029, the Wife’s Final Valuation Report estimates that the revenue will increase to S$4,508,333 in 2026, before dropping to S$3,940,361 in 2027 after the non-renewal of the leases for the Alternative Premises. The estimated revenue is then projected to drop further to S$3,338,565 in 2028 before undergoing a slight uptick to S$3,626,513 in 2029.
- [33]
[33] As for the depreciation and capital expenditure figures in the Wife’s Final Valuation Report, the Husband’s figure for expected renovation expenses (S$443,469) is taken as capital expenditure for 2025, with this expenditure being depreciated over 5 years. This results in an annual depreciation expense of S$88,694. I note that the Husband has adduced a quotation for renovation works of S$443,468.68. In addition, the Wife’s valuer states that “based on our calculations, depreciation excluding rights-of-use assets stood at SGD 51,592 in 2024”; this is the figure reflected as annual “capital expenditure” in the Wife’s Final Valuation Report for 2026, 2027 and 2028. Adding the figures of S$88,694 and S$51,592 results in total annual depreciation of S$140,286 for the periods from 2026 to 2028. For 2029, the total annual depreciation and the capital expenditure are both stated as S$140,286, because for that year, the Wife’s valuer “assume[d] that [capital expenditure] and depreciation [would] remain equal, which implies a steady-state position”.
- [34]
[34] The figures for working capital in the Wife’s Final Valuation Report are negative for 2025 and 2026, before turning positive for 2027 and 2028. The Wife’s valuer has not explained these figures.
- [35]
[35] Finally, the annual FCF of the Restaurants is derived by taking the EBIT value, adding depreciation, and subtracting working capital and capital expenditure. Under the “discounted cash flow” method, a discount is applied to the FCF figure to derive the present value of the future cash streams in order to reflect the risk and uncertainty inherent in forecasted FCF. The enterprise value of the Restaurants is the sum of the annual discounted FCF figures (which translates to the “present value of cash flow”) for the period from 2025 to 2029, on top of the “terminal value” of the Restaurants. The “terminal value” refers to the “value of the business beyond the forecasted period when future cash flows can be estimated”, and it is calculated on the assumption that the Restaurants “will grow at a set growth rate forever after the forecast period”.
- [36]
[36] According to the Wife’s valuer, the equity value of the Restaurants (ie, S$2,530,275) is obtained by adding cash (of S$345,368) to and deducting debt (of S$132,177) from the enterprise value.
(II) Husband’s Final Valuation Report
- [37]
[37] Turning to the Husband’s Final Valuation Report, the figures for forecasted revenue are based on the calculations of the daily revenue per seat (“DRPS”) in the Restaurants. In gist, DRPS is obtained by taking the forecasted daily revenue of the Restaurants divided by the number of seats, but with factors applied to the figure based on table size and seasonal adjustments. The DRPS at the Original Premises is assumed to grow in line with the tourism growth rate of 4.6% per annum, but with a slight discount applied to this growth after FY2026 because of the Husband’s representation that he would “not be involved in the operation of [the Restaurants] in full capacity due to personal commitments going forward”. The Husband’s Final Valuation Report notes that the DRPS at the Alternative Premises is S$7 (ie, lower than that at the Original Premises) – which is consistent with representations made by management (ie, the Husband). The DRPS for the Original Premises and the Alternative Premises is then adjusted to take into account table size adjustments (given that “different size table[s] will generate different revenue per [seat]”) and seasonal adjustments (eg, to take into account public holidays and varying revenue in different months). The adjusted DRPS is then multiplied by the number of seats per table to obtain the daily revenue per table, which is multiplied by the probability of the table being filled (since “there may not always be full capacity at each table when walk-in customers are dining in”). The weighted daily revenue for the Restaurants is then added to obtain the total forecasted revenue of the Restaurants.
- [39]
[39] The estimated renovation expenses of S$420,000 is taken to be capital expenditure for 8M2025. This is depreciated over four years, which the Husband’s valuer assumes to be the useful life of new property, plant and equipment (“PPE”); this is based on the valuer’s assessment of the unaudited report for FY2024 as being indicative of an estimated useful life of three to five years for PPE. This results in annual depreciation for “[n]ew PPE” of S$105,000 for FY2026 to FY2029. This is in addition to annual depreciation for “[e]xisting PPE” (which the Husband’s valuer estimates “based on the balance sheet as at 31 December 2024”), as well as depreciation of S$8,000 for the “terminal year” (ie, the year corresponding to the “terminal value”, which is defined as “the sum of all subsequent cash flows after the final year of forecast”, on the assumption of “the perpetuity of the subject business”).
- [40]
[40] The discounted cash flow method is also used in the Husband’s Final Valuation Report. Thus, the after-tax FCF figure is first obtained by taking the EBIT value, deducting tax expenses, adding depreciation, and subtracting working capital and capital expenditure. A “time factor” and a “discount factor” are taken into account in the derivation of the present value of FCF. The enterprise value of the Restaurants is the sum of two figures: (a) the sum of the present value of FCF (ie, the annual discounted FCF figures for the period from 8M2025 to FY2030); and (b) the present value of terminal value (ie, the future value of terminal value, multiplied by the appropriate discount factor).
- [41]
[41] The equity value of the Restaurants (ie, S$404,640) is obtained by adding surplus assets (of S$455,483) and deducting debt (of S$573,951) from the enterprise value.
Description
WACC of 9.80%
WACC of 9.30%
WACC of 8.80%
Low
Medium
High
Enterprise value
S$402,485
S$523,108
S$685,614
Add: Surplus assets
S$455,483
Less: Debts
(S$573,951)
Equity value
S$284,017
S$404,640
S$567,146
- [43]
[43] The “low” and “high” equity values of the Restaurants approximate to the equity values of S$284,000 and S$567,000 that are presented as the final figures in the Husband’s Final Valuation Report.
(III) Parties’ submissions on which report is to be preferred
- [44]
[44] The Wife argues that the Husband’s Final Valuation Report should be rejected because according to her:
(a) This report is premised on the Husband incurring renovation expenditure of around S$420,000 for the Original Premises, yet there is no evidence that this expenditure is a condition precedent for the renewal of the lease for those premises.
(b) This report provides a low total value of the Restaurants (see [20] above) that is inconsistent with the Husband’s intention to spend around S$420,000 on renovations. The Wife argues that this is “commercially irrational”, that “no prudent businessperson” would commit large sums of capital expenditure as the Husband has done, and that this behaviour suggests that the Husband “anticipates continuity and profitability” in the Restaurants. The Wife’s case is that the Husband has “artificially suppress[ed] the Restaurants’ valuation”.
(c) This report was based on information “provided solely by the [Husband]”, who “may have selectively disclosed information to his advantage”.
(d) This report reflects low valuations that are “inconsistent” with the historical figures for the Restaurants. The Wife asserts that historically, the Restaurants have run at high gross profit margins (eg, [Restaurant A] had gross profit margins of 65.8% in FY2024 and 62.5% in FY2023).
- [45]
[45] On the other hand, the Husband submits that the Wife’s Final Valuation Report is flawed because:
(a) This report purports to be based on a valuation date of 31 August 2025, when it, in fact, is based on data up till April 2025 – which is also the date up to which data is available for use in the Husband’s Final Valuation Report.
(b) This report is based on information regarding the “financial projections, history and business profile” of the Restaurants as provided by the Wife to the valuer, with no input from the management of the Restaurants, even though the Wife is “not familiar with the business”.
(c) This report does not provide adequate explanation as to how the figures used in the financial analysis were derived. The Husband contrasts this with his own Final Valuation Report, which provided “detailed financial analysis and projections of the restaurant business over 16 pages”. The Husband also submits that it is unclear where the Wife’s valuer obtained the figure of S$132,177 in respect of the debts to be deducted from the enterprise value of the business: according to the Husband, the actual amount of debts owed by the Restaurants is S$573,951.
(d) This report is unrealistic, because the Restaurants have been “loss-making in recent years” and thus cannot possibly be valued at around S$2.5 million as the Wife’s Final Valuation Report suggests.
(e) This report valued the Restaurants based on their “equitable value”, which was defined as the “estimated price for the transfer of an asset or liability between identified knowledgeable and willing parties that reflects the respective interests of those parties”. At the AM hearing before me, the Husband’s counsel argued that this was an inaccurate basis on which to value the Restaurants since “there is no such identified buyer” in this case. The Husband’s Final Valuation Report, which is based on “market value” without considering “any potential specific buyer”, is thus preferable.
- [46]
[46] From the above, it can be seen that parties’ valuations are vastly different (see [20] above), despite the discounted cash flow valuation method being used in both valuation reports (see [35] and [40] above). In the next section at [47]–[72], I set out my decision on which valuation report is to be preferred.
(IV) My decision
(a) The different estimated revenue in parties’ Final Valuation Reports
- [48]
[48] First, in respect of the forecasted revenue of the Restaurants, the Wife’s Final Valuation Report lacks any explanation of the calculations used to derive the expected revenue from 2026 to 2029. The Wife’s Final Valuation Report estimates that the revenue per seat per month is S$1,745 (assuming that revenue per seat is constant at the Original and Alternative Premises), and states that this figure “serves as a baseline metric for [the] revenue forecast assumptions in the subsequent years”. However, there is simply no explanation of how this figure was used to obtain the expected revenue ranging from around S$4.5 million in 2026 to around S$3.6 million in 2029.
- [49]
[49] The Wife’s Final Valuation Report also states that projections are based on “the industry growth rate as a logical benchmark”, before “consider[ing] conservative incremental growth”. The report notes that the food service industry growth rate is expected to be 4.2% a year from 2025 to 2028. Yet this is based on data of all food and beverage sales, including sales from “Full-Service Restaurants, Limited-Service Restaurants, Cafes, Street Stalls, and other related establishments”. Whether this growth rate is specifically applicable to eateries such as the Restaurants is therefore unclear, but in any case, how this growth rate was used to calculate the forecasted revenue for the Restaurants is not explained. The changes in revenue from 2026 to 2029 (as noted at [31] above) do not match a 4.2% increase per annum.
- [51]
[51] On the other hand, the Husband’s Final Valuation Report provides a detailed breakdown of the calculations used to obtain the forecasted revenue for the Restaurants from the final eight months of 2025 to 2030, based on the DRPS projections: see [37] above. The DRPS of S$7 for the seats at the Alternative Premises appears to have been obtained by the Husband’s valuer taking the difference between the total revenue from the Restaurants from January to December 2023 (ie, S$3,529,306 for a total of 76 seats) and the total revenue from May 2024 to April 2025 (ie, S$3,725,646 for a total of 158 seats), and then using the difference to obtain the DRPS. This therefore assumes that the increase in revenue between the two periods is solely attributable to the revenue earned at the Additional Premises. However, the Husband’s Final Valuation Report also notes that based on representations by the management of the Restaurants, the increase in revenue of the Restaurants from FY2023 to FY2024 was partly due to a “gradual reopening of [the] borders” after the Covid-19 pandemic (thus allowing more tourists to contribute to the dine-in spending), and also partly due to the additional seats at the Alternative Premises. This suggests that the increase in revenue from 2023 to 2024/2025 might be due to various factors, not necessarily due solely to the business at the Alternative Premises. Yet this only means that by attributing any increase in revenue to the Alternative Premises, the Husband’s Final Valuation Report is more generous as to the estimated DRPS from those premises, and therefore is more generous as to the forecasted revenue that may be derived from the Alternative Premises.
- [52]
[52] To sum up, I prefer the forecasted revenue figures in the Husband’s Final Valuation Report, as this report provides a much clearer and more detailed explanation as to how the forecasted revenue was calculated. Although the estimated DRPS at the Alternative Premises is only based on a comparison of the increase in revenue from 2023 to 2024/2025, I accept these calculations for the reasons set out at [51] above.
(b) The different estimated operating expenses and depreciation figures in parties’ Final Valuation Reports
- [55]
[55] In respect of depreciation, both reports appear to make certain unexplained assumptions. For example, the Wife’s Final Valuation Report does not explain how the figure of S$51,592 for “depreciation excluding rights-of-use assets” was obtained: see [33] above. While this sum corresponds to the sum of the depreciation of office equipment and motor vehicles in FY2024 (S$25,098 and S$26,494 respectively), the Wife’s Final Valuation Report does not elaborate on why this figure is assumed to remain constant even after the non-renewal of the leases for the Alternative Premises.
- [56]
[56] The Husband’s Final Valuation Report states that the depreciation for existing PPE is estimated “based on the balance sheet as at 31 December 2024”. The basis for this statement is unclear. I note, however, that the estimated depreciation is S$24,454 for FY2026 and FY2027 each, before dropping to S$19,207 in FY2028 and decreasing further in FY2029 and FY2030. This correctly reflects reduced depreciation of existing PPE on the assumption that the leases for the Alternative Premises will not be renewed. This, in my view, is more credible than the Wife’s Final Valuation Report, which assumes that depreciation remains constant from 2025 to 2029, and thus omits to factor in the likely reduction in depreciation of PPE after the non-renewal of the leases for the Alternative Premises.
(c) The different cost of sales figures in the parties’ Final Valuation Reports
(d) The “sanity checks” in the Husband’s Final Valuation Report
- [59]
[59] Fourth, unlike the Wife’s Final Valuation Report, the Husband’s report contains a section in which a “sanity check” was conducted to test the figures derived. Using (a) the enterprise value (“EV”); and (b) the average forecast value of earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortisation (“EBITDA”) for FY2028, FY2029 and FY2030, the Husband’s valuer obtained a ratio of “implied forward EV/EBITDA”. To elaborate, the average EBITDA value appears to have been derived by adding the pre-tax EBIT values and the depreciation of PPE for FY2028, FY2029 and FY2030, and then calculating the average figure over that period. The EV/EBITA ratio is then compared to the ratios for comparable companies to “cross-check the valuation results”. The six comparable companies are all food and beverage-related investment holding companies. The Husband’s valuer candidly acknowledges that the EV/EBITDA ratio for the Restaurants is lower than the median of the comparable companies’ ratios, but provides three reasons for this. First, the six comparable companies are “large corporation[s] with main chain outlets, [and] multiple food & beverage brands in multiple countries”. Second, the “key person” of the Restaurants is the Husband, “who intends to gradually reduce his working hours while the comparable companies [have] 1 main chef per restaurant outlet”. Third, the Restaurants are “obligated to incur at least SGD 420,000 to renovate the [Original Premises]”.
- [60]
[60] In my view, the reasons provided for the EV/EBITDA ratio for the Restaurants being lower than other food and beverage companies are sound, and reinforce the conclusion that the Husband’s valuation should be preferred.
- [61]
[61] In this connection, I note that the Wife has submitted that the Husband’s evidence about his obligation to renovate the Original Premises (see [44(a)] above) is unsubstantiated. However, this submission is undercut by the fact that the Wife’s Final Valuation Report is also based on a similar assumption that renovation expenses will need to be incurred.
- [62]
[62] I find no merit either in the Wife’s argument that the renovation expenses are high relative to the low value of the Restaurants and therefore “commercially irrational” (see [44(b)] above). The Husband explained in his third AOM that he was caught between a rock and a hard place when negotiating the renewal of the lease for the Original Premises: either his monthly rent would increase substantially to S$60,000 (in line with the market rate) or his rent would increase to S$35,000 (which was lower than the market rate, but in return for which he would need to renovate the Original Premises). In his third AOM, the Husband gave evidence that the landlord “made it very clear to [him] that if [he] [did] not carry out the renovations as required, they [would] not renew the lease after this term”. I accept that it is entirely possible that given the “very long-standing commercial relationship” between the Husband and the landlord (which the Wife has not refuted with evidence to the contrary), the renovation requirement may have been agreed verbally between them. Further, the Wife’s Final Valuation Report acknowledges that “publicly available industry data” indicates that restaurant renovations can increase sales (see [50] above). There is thus a plausible commercial reason for the Husband to have committed to renovating the Original Premises; this is no basis on which to reject the Husband’s Final Valuation Report.
- [63]
[63] As an added “sanity check”, I should highlight that the Wife’s valuations are extremely high, considering the fact that the Restaurants have been loss-making in recent years: see [45(d)] above. This is supported by the figures for FY2024 and 4M2025 that were referenced in the Husband’s Final Valuation Report: the EBIT values for FY2024 and 4M2025 were both negative (-S$424,743 and -S$136,347 respectively).
(e) The different rental figures used in the parties’ Final Valuation Reports
- [64]
[64] In respect of the estimated rental figures used in the calculations in both valuation reports, these were as follows:
FY2026
FY2027
FY2028
FY2029
Rental per Wife’s Final Valuation Report (SGD)
990,416
784,947
583,420
583,420
Rental per Husband’s Final Valuation Report (SGD)
850,200
832,760
706,320
706,320
- [65]
[65] I make two preliminary observations about the estimated rental figures. First, the rental in FY2028 and FY2029 is assumed to be the same in both reports because at that point, the Alternative Premises will no longer be rented. Both reports calculate rental on the basis that one of the leases for the Alternative Premises will expire in May 2026, while the other will expire in August 2027.
- [66]
[66] Second, the total estimated rent from FY2026 to FY2029 (see [64] above) is S$2,942,203 according to the Wife’s valuer, and S$3,095,600 according to the Husband’s valuer. The differences in parties’ rental figures is thus relatively minor and certainly not so stark as to explain the significant difference in their respective EBIT values: instead, that difference can be attributed to the differences in forecasted revenue and EBIT calculations (which I deal with below at [70]–[72]). In the circumstances, I do not consider the differences in parties’ estimated rental figures to be a factor in my decision as to which valuation report to prefer.
(f) The Wife’s remaining arguments about the Final Valuation Reports.
- [67]
[67] As to the Wife’s remaining arguments about the Husband’s Final Valuation Report, I do not find any merit in these arguments. The Wife purports to take issue with the fact that the Husband’s Final Valuation Report was based on information provided by the Husband, who (according to her) may not have fully disclosed information (see [44(c)] above). This is a bare assertion: the Wife has produced no evidence of the Husband having allegedly concealed information. In any case, the Wife has acknowledged in her written submissions that her Final Valuation Report was “prepared using the same documents that the [Husband’s] valuer relied on in preparing [the Husband’s Final Valuation Report]”.
- [69]
[69] For completeness, in oral submissions, the Wife’s counsel sought to point to Appendix IX to the Husband’s Final Valuation Report, where the forecasted rental for the First AP Unit was estimated to fall in FY2026 (and so too for the Second AP Unit in FY2027). I surmise that counsel’s argument is that this decrease in forecasted rental is inconsistent with the increase in tourism which the Husband’s own valuer assumed to be expected in the coming years. I find no merit in this argument. While the expected uptrend in tourism may be relevant to expected earnings (assuming tourists account for a sizable part of the Restaurants’ business), the link between the tourism growth rate and expected rental incurred at the Original and Alternative Premises is unclear and has not in any event been explained by the Wife’s counsel.
(g) The different EBIT values in the parties’ Final Valuation Reports
Description (all figures in SGD)
8M2025
FY2026
FY2027
FY2028
FY2029
FY2030
Revenue (A)
2,389,189
3,657,704
3,834,003
3,905,179
4,028,701
4,159,883
Staff costs (B)
919,691
1,311,701
1,337,502
1,301,745
1,337,198
1,373,714
Depreciation (C)
16,302
129,454
129,454
124,207
121,583
5,528
Other operating expenses (D)
344,630
478,329
461,770
401,579
411,231
421,173
Rental (E)
706,320
850,200
832,760
706,320
706,320
706,320
Cost of sales (F)
845,773
1,298,485
1,361,071
1,386,339
1,430,189
1,476,758
My calculations of EBIT: (A) – (B) – (C) – (D) – (E) – (F)
(443,527)
(410,465)
(288,554)
(15,011)
22,180
176,390
EBIT in Husband’s Final Valuation Report
(443,528)
(410,464)
(288,554)
(15,011)
22,180
176,390
(E) My decision on the value of the Restaurants
(2) Summary of assets held in the Husband’s name
- [74]
[74] Taking into account the value of the Restaurants (S/N 6 below) along with the Husband’s other undisputed assets (S/N 1–5 below), the following assets in the Husband’s name are to be added to the matrimonial pool:
- [75]
[75] I note that although parties agreed on the amount owed to the Husband by the Restaurants in the Joint Summary (see S/N 5 in the table above), the Wife initially tried to resile from this agreement at the hearing before me. The arguments put forward by her counsel in this respect were somewhat incoherent. In any event, counsel eventually confirmed that the Wife accepted that the total amount owed by the Restaurants to the Husband was S$572,104 (as set out in the Joint Summary). Counsel then sought to argue that the Husband was obliged to show what repayments the Restaurants had made to him, how the repayments were made, and how the Husband had dealt with the repaid monies, pursuant to a discovery order that had been made, and that his (alleged) failure to provide such information should result in an adverse inference being drawn against him.
- [76]
[76] There being no dispute as to the identification and valuation of the amount owed by the Restaurants to the Husband, I include the agreed amount of S$572,104 in the table at S/N 5 above. The issue of whether an adverse inference should be drawn against the Husband is a separate issue which I address below.
- [77]
[77] To sum up, I find that the total value of the assets in the Husband’s sole name is S$1,654,913.88. I next consider the assets in the Wife’s sole name.
Assets in the Wife’s sole name
- [78]
[78] Parties agree that two of the Wife’s pre-marital assets which she holds in her sole name are to be excluded from the matrimonial pool: (a) S$105.38 held in a China bank account; and (b) “China shares” valued at S$112,605.54. Parties also agree on the inclusion of two Australian properties in the Wife’s name, but disagree on the valuation of those assets. Further, parties disagree on whether a property in China (“China Property”) and the Wife’s diamond ring should be included in the matrimonial pool. I address these issues seriatim.
(1) China Property
- [79]
[79] The Wife argues that the China Property was bought by the Husband and presented to her and her parents as a “belated betrothal gift”, and that this is reinforced by the fact that the property was “purchased solely in the [Wife’s] name”. The Wife also points out that the China Property has not been “substantially improved” or “ordinarily used” by the family during the marriage. The Husband agrees that he did buy the China Property “for the Wife in her sole name” but contends that since this property was bought during the marriage, it constitutes a matrimonial asset.
- [80]
[80] The valuation of the property is also in dispute, with the Wife suggesting a value of RMB 300,000 as at 20 February 2024, which works out to S$56,794 based on the Wife’s proposed exchange rate of S$1 to RMB 5.2821 (as at 4 March 2024, ie, the date of the Wife’s first AOM). This exchange rate was obtained from an online search on Yahoo! Finance that was conducted on 29 February 2024. The Husband argues that the China Property is worth RMB 900,000, which works out to S$166,051.66 based on the Husband’s proposed exchange rate of S$1 to RMB 5.42 (as at 14 January 2026). The figure of RMB 900,000 was obtained from a screenshot of results from the Wife’s desktop search for valuations of comparable properties, which she exhibited in her response (dated 23 May 2024) to the Husband’s request for discovery. Although the screenshot contained various prices for different apartment types, the Husband’s counsel highlighted at the hearing before me that the valuations ranged from RMB 900,000 to RMB 980,000, and the Husband took the lowest figure of RMB 900,000 as the value of the China Property so as to give the Wife “the benefit of the doubt”. The Husband’s counsel also confirmed that she adopted the exchange rate of S$1 to RMB 5.42 based on an internet search dated 14 January 2026.
- [81]
[81] In my view, the China Property constitutes a matrimonial asset. The China property was purchased on 9 June 2013, ie, during the marriage. Pursuant to s 112(10)(b) of the Women’s Charter 1961 (2020 Rev Ed) (“WC”), assets acquired “during the marriage by one party or both parties to the marriage” will constitute matrimonial assets, unless one of the exceptions in that provision is established. This is consistent with the trite principle that a party’s assets will be included in the matrimonial pool unless that party proves that an asset was not acquired during the marriage or was acquired through gift or inheritance: USB v USA [2020] 2 SLR 588 at [31]. The Wife has produced no evidence to substantiate her claim that the purchase of this property was a gift. The mere fact that the Husband purchased the property in her sole name is not enough to establish that it was a gift. In short, therefore, I find that the Wife has failed to persuade me that the China Property should be excluded from the matrimonial pool.
- [82]
[82] As for the valuation of the China Property, I note that the documentary evidence of sale prices of similar properties that the Husband had relied on (see [80] above) is undated. However, as that evidence was adduced in the Wife’s response on 23 May 2024 to a discovery request, I adopt that date (23 May 2024) as the date of the Husband’s valuation. This means that the Husband’s proposed valuation of RMB 900,000 was obtained on a date closer to the date of the AM hearing (ie, 18 March 2026), as compared to the Wife’s proposed valuation of RMB 300,000 which was dated 20 February 2024. Since the operative date for valuing matrimonial assets is the date closer to the date of the AM hearing (see [4] above), I accept the Husband’s valuation of the China Property. Since the Husband’s proposed exchange rate dated 14 January 2026 is also closer to the date of the AM hearing than the Wife’s proposed exchange rate dated 4 March 2024 (see [80] above), I accept the former exchange rate. I thus accept the Husband’s proposed value of S$166,051.66 for the China Property.
(2) Wife’s diamond ring
- [83]
[83] As for the Wife’s diamond ring, she claims that she purchased this ring using part of a cash gift of S$300,000 that she received from the Husband in 2015. According to the Wife, this cash gift was given by the Husband to “salvage [their] marriage” at a time when she had discussed seeking a divorce with him. Per the Wife’s case, the ring – being traceable to the cash gift – should be regarded as a gift from the Husband and should thereby be excluded from the matrimonial pool. The Husband’s position, conversely, is that the cash gift was a “pure inter-spousal gift” which constitutes a matrimonial asset under s 112(10)(b) of the WC; and that the ring – having been purchased with part of that cash gift – should be included in the matrimonial pool.
- [84]
[84] Parties also disagree on the valuation of the ring. The Husband submits that the value of the ring is S$250,000, while the Wife referred – in the Joint Summary – to the purchase price of S$68,000 and the current valuation of the ring of S$18,000. This is based on the Wife’s argument that she spent S$68,000 on the ring initially, but that its value has since depreciated, and that if sold, it would fetch a price of about S$18,000.
- [85]
[85] As to whether the ring should be included in the matrimonial pool, I find that this question should be answered in the affirmative. I agree with the Husband that his cash gift of S$300,000 to the Wife constituted a “pure inter-spousal gift”. Pure inter-spousal gifts are defined as gifts that are not acquired by way of a third-party gift or inheritance, and that are instead acquired through the efforts of the donor spouse: Wan Lai Cheng v Quek Seow Kee [2012] 4 SLR 405 (“Wan Lai Cheng”) at [40]–[41]. The court in Wan Lai Cheng explained that all pure inter-spousal gifts fall under s 112(10)(b) of the WC – which provides that assets acquired by one party during the marriage is a matrimonial asset – and thus “are matrimonial assets without the need to satisfy any further conditions”. The court in Wan Lai Cheng also noted that this approach of taking pure inter-spousal gifts to be matrimonial assets recognises the initial effort of the donor spouse in the acquisition of the gift (see [40]). This is consistent with the fact that a pure inter-spousal gift is in effect nothing more than the “mere circulation of an asset within and from the same [matrimonial] pool” between the spouses, and such circulation should not – without more – be considered as “manifesting an intent to remove that asset permanently from that pool”: Wan Lai Cheng at [116].
- [86]
[86] Indeed, the court in Wan Lai Cheng noted at [115] that even though pure inter-spousal gifts are generally taken to be matrimonial assets, where the donor spouse “clearly intends to permanently renounce his or her beneficial interest in the asset transferred”, the donor spouse “may be estopped from claiming any share in that asset when the court exercises its discretion in equitably distributing the pool of matrimonial assets”. This was recently reiterated in CLC v CLB [2023] 1 SLR 1260 (“CLC v CLB”) at [52] and [64], in which it was stated that the courts will give effect to a donor spouse’s manifestation of an “unequivocal intention” to divest his asset in favour of the other spouse. The court in CLC v CLB explained that “it is ultimately a question of fact as to what a donee spouse intended to do with their asset that was originally acquired by gift or inheritance” (see [56]).
- [87]
[87] Section 105 of the EA provides that the burden of proof as to any particular fact lies on that person who wishes the court to believe in its existence (unless any law provides to the contrary); in this case, the burden of proving an unequivocal intention on the Husband’s part to divest the ring in favour of the Wife thus lies on the Wife. In my view, she has failed to discharge this burden of proof.
- [88]
[88] In the present case, apart from the Wife’s bare assertions about the Husband’s cash gift of S$300,000 having been motivated by his desire to salvage their marriage, there is no evidence of an unequivocal intention on the Husband’s part to divest his interest in the cash gift. At the hearing, the Wife’s counsel confirmed that she was relying on paras 168–170 of the Wife’s first AOM for the evidence of such intention on the Husband’s part. However, these paragraphs in the Wife’s affidavit merely set out the Wife’s claim that the Husband provided the cash gift as part of his “reconciliation efforts”, and that she used “part of the sum to purchase a diamond ring” (with the rest used to buy a property in Australia): there is no evidence in the affidavit – or indeed, anywhere else – to support the Wife’s claim.
- [89]
[89] Having found that the cash gift constitutes a matrimonial asset, I find that the ring – which (on the Wife’s own case) is traceable to that cash gift – must be included in the matrimonial pool.
- [90]
[90] As to the valuation of the ring, the Husband’s counsel submitted at the hearing that there was no evidence of the values of S$68,000 and S$18,000 put forth by the Wife (see [84] above). I agree. Conversely, the Husband refers to the Wife’s first AOM (at para 169) in which she states that she used “part of” the S$300,000 gift to purchase the ring, with the “remaining amount” used to cover her downpayment for an Australian property “in the sum of 47,900 AUD (approximately S$41,943.70)”. The Wife’s own evidence thus suggests that approximately S$250,000 was expended on the ring in 2015; and this is the figure that the Husband takes to be the value of the ring. If the Wife’s figures were to be used instead (ie, S$68,000 on the ring and S$41,943.70 on the Australian property), it would leave the remaining balance of the cash gift (ie, S$190,056.30) unaccounted for; and the Wife has certainly not attempted to account for it.
- [91]
[91] There being no evidence to substantiate the Wife’s case, I accept the Husband’s calculation of the value of the ring.
(3) Australian properties
- [92]
[92] The Wife holds two Australian properties in her sole name. Both were purchased during the marriage, in 2015 and 2016. Although the Wife argued in her first AOM that the Australian properties should be excluded from the pool of matrimonial assets, she has not made this argument in her written submissions. In fact, the Australian properties are included in her list of assets, which she eventually uses to calculate the total matrimonial pool. In the circumstances, I include both Australian properties in the matrimonial pool.
- [93]
[93] The dispute over the valuation of the Australian properties is solely a result of the different exchange rates used by parties. This is because parties agree that one property is valued at A$194,654.84 while the other is valued at A$522,500. However, the Wife applies an exchange rate of S$1 = A$1.1418 (as at 4 March 2024); the Husband’s exchange rate is S$1 = A$1.16 (as at 14 January 2026). Since the Husband’s exchange rate is closer to the date of the AM hearing on 18 March 2026 (see also [82] above), I adopt the Husband’s exchange rate and correspondingly, the Husband’s valuation of the two Australian properties.
(4) Summary of assets held in the Wife’s name
- [94]
[94] Taking into account the above-mentioned assets along with the Wife’s other undisputed assets, the following assets in the Wife’s name are to be added to the matrimonial pool:
- [95]
[95] For completeness, there appears to be a typographical error in the Joint Summary at p 10 (regarding the Wife’s Singlife Insurance Policy). The Husband’s position in the Joint Summary is that the policy is valued at S$42,390.83 – but in his own written submissions, the value is stated to be S$42,380.83 (which is also the value proposed by the Wife). I have taken the latter value to be the agreed value of the Singlife Insurance Policy.
Summary
- [96]
[96] Following from the above, I find that the matrimonial pool comprises the following:
(a) Joint assets (see [10] above): S$1,595,117.41
(b) Assets in the Husband’s name (see [74] above): S$1,654,913.88
(c) Assets in the Wife’s name (see [94] above): S$1,541,794.65
- [97]
[97] This amounts to a total matrimonial pool of S$4,791,825.94.
Division and apportionment of matrimonial assets
- [98]
[98] It is well-established that the “structured approach” is more appropriate for dual-income marriages; with the “broad-brush approach” being better suited for long, single-income marriages: TNL v TNK [2017] 1 SLR 609 (“TNL v TNK”) at [42] and [46]. Under the structured approach, the court first ascribes ratios that represent the parties’ direct and indirect contributions to the marriage before calculating the average of these ratios to determine each party’s average percentage contribution: ANJ v ANK [2015] 4 SLR 1043 (“ANJ v ANK”) at [22]. Both parties applied the structured approach in their written submissions.
- [99]
[99] This case involves a moderately lengthy marriage of around 17 years. Both parties worked during the marriage: the Husband as a restaurant owner; the Wife as a tuition teacher who, at one point, also managed a cosmetics business. While the Wife’s monthly income was stated to be variable, a large disparity in income between spouses does not, in itself, render the marriage a single-income one – the primary roles played by each spouse is more important: DBA v DBB [2024] 1 SLR 459 at [13]. In this case, as I explain later, the evidence suggests that the Husband was more engaged with running the restaurant business, with the Wife likely taking on a greater caregiving role. The Wife’s tuition business was dependent on student-demand, while her cosmetic business appeared to be a small business which, in any event, she intended to close due to her health issues. In my view, there are arguments to be made for characterising this marriage as a single-income marriage. However, since this marriage is not as long as that in TNL v TNK (which involved a 35-year-long marriage), and parties agree on the application of the structured approach, I adopt this approach while bearing in mind the need to still take a broad-brush view where appropriate.
Direct contributions
- [100]
[100] I begin with parties’ direct contribution to the joint assets. In this regard, the Wife submits that she made CPF contributions of S$74,400 to the matrimonial home. She acknowledges that she did not contribute to the parties’ UOB joint account. The Husband submits that he was the sole contributor to the joint UOB account, and further, that he contributed the lion’s share of the direct contributions to the matrimonial home (S$885,664.78).
The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.